Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP. NO. 263 OF 2019
AGAINST THE
NO.174 OF 2012 OF
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 12.11.2018 IN LAR
ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY
APPELLANTS/CLAIMANTS 6 & 7 :
P.V.RAZAK,
AGED 69 YEARS
S/O.AHAMMED, RESIDNG AT ’SAHIL’
OPP. PHC KURUCHIYIL, NEW MAHE,
PIN-673311
THAHIRA BEEGUM RAZIYA BANU
AGED 61 YEARS
W/O.ABDUL RAZAK, RESIDING AT 'SAHIL',
OPP. PHC KURUCHIYIL, NEW MAHE,
PIN-673311
BY ADV SERGI JOSEPH THOMAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS 4 & 5 :
THE SPECIAL TAHASILDAR, L.A,
THALASSERY, PIN-670101
THE SECRETARY,
ZILLA PANCHAYATH, KANNUR, PIN-670002
THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
KANNUR-670002
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
CHAPPAVALAPPIL BEEVI,
THYKANDI HOUSE, PERINGADI,
NEW MAHE.P.O, KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN-673311
K.CHANDRAN,
KANOTH KUNIYIL, AZHIYOOR.P.O,
NEW MAHE, PIN-673309
2025:KER:29565
BY ADVS. SRI. TK SHAJAHAN, SR. GP, FOR R1 & R3
SMT.C.LEENA, FOR R2
SMT.G.CHITRA, FOR R4
THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
03.04.2025, ALONG WITH LA.App.NO.286/2017 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP. NO. 286 OF 2017
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 24.10.2016 IN LAR NO.147
OF 2012 OF
ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY
APPELLANTS/CLAIMANTS :
C.P. SUHARA
AMEENA BAUGH, A.K.G. ROAD,
POOZHITHALA P.O., AZHIYOOR,
VATAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 309.
SHERBEENA
D/O. LATE T.P. NASEEHU, RESIDING AT AMEENA BAUGH,
A.K.G. ROAD, POOZHITHALA P.O., AZHIYOOR,
VATAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 309.
MUHAMMED NASEEHU
S/O. LATE T.P. NASEEHU,
RESIDING AT AMEENA BAUGH, A.K.G. ROAD,
POOZHITHALA P.O., AZHIYOOR, VATAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 309.
RASHA NASEEHU
S/O. LATE T.P. NASEEHU, RESIDING AT AMEENA BAUGH,
A.K.G. ROAD, POOZHITHALA P.O., AZHIYOOR,
VATAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 309.
APPELLANTS 2 TO 4 REPRESENTED BY THEIR POWER OF
ATTORNEY HOLDER C.P. SUHARA, AMEENA BAUGH, AKG ROAD,
POOZHITHALA PO, AZHIYOOR, VATAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE
DISTRICT 673309
BY ADV SRI.SERGI JOSEPH THOMAS
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS :
THE SPECIAL TAHASILDAR (L.A)
THALASSERY - 670 101.
THE SECRETARY
ZILLA PANCHAYATH, KANNUR - 670 002.
THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
KANNUR - 670 002.
BY SRI. T.K.SHAJAHAN, SR.GP, FOR R1 AND R3
THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
03.04.2025, ALONG WITH LA.App.NO.263/2019 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP. NO. 226 OF 2019
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 12.11.2018 IN LAR NO.174
OF 2012 OF
ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY
APPELLANT/CLAIMANT NO.1 :
KADAKKAYATH CHANDI BABU,
AGED 68 YEARS
S/O.K.G.CHANDI, RESIDING AT KALLUVILA HOUSE,
PUTHIYANGADI, WEST HILL P.O.,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT, PIN - 673 005.
BY ADV SERGI JOSEPH THOMAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS :
THE SPECIAL TAHASILDAR L.A.,
THALASSERY, PIN - 670 101.
THE SECRETARY, ZILLA PANCHAYATH,
KANNUR, PIN - 670 002.
THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
KANNUR -670 002.
BY ADV SRI. T.K. SHAJAHAN, SR.GP. FOR R1 AND R3
SMT.C.LEENA, R2
THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
03.04.2025, ALONG WITH LA.App.NO.263/2019 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP. NO. 212 OF 2019
AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 12.11.2018 IN LAR
NO.174 OF 2012 OF ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY
APPELLANTS/CLAIAMNTS 2 & 3 :
THAYYIL KAKKAT ABDUL ASALI
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O. V. ABDULLA KOYA, RESIDING AT ‘PRATHIBHA’,
RAILWAY STATION ROAD, MAHE, PIN - 673310
THAYYIL KAKKAT ZAHIRA
AGED 65 YEARS
D/O. MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT 'PRATHIBHA',
RAILWAY STATION ROAD, MAHE, PIN - 673310
BY ADV SERGI JOSEPH THOMAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDNETS/CLAIMANTS 4 & 5 :
THE SPECIAL TAHASILDAR L.A
THALASSERY, PIN - 670101.
THE SECRETARY
ZILLA PANCHAYATH, KANNUR,
PIN - 670 002.
THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
KANNUR – 670002
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
CHAPPAVALAPPIL BEEVI
THYKANDI HOUSE, PERINGADI,
NEW MAHE P. O., KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 673311.
K. CHANDRAN
KANOTH KUNIYIL, AZHIYOOL P. O.,
NEW MAHE, PIN - 673309.
2025:KER:29565
SRI.T.K. SHAJAHAN, SR.GP, FOR R1 AND R3
SRI.P.U. SHAILAJAN, FOR R2
THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
03.04.2025, ALONG WITH LA.App.NO.263/2019 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP. NO. 318 OF 2019
AGAINST THE
NO.145 OF 2012 OF
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 12.11.2018 IN LAR
ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY
APPELLANT/CLAIMANT NO.1 :
KADAKKAYATH CHANDI BABU,
AGED 68 YEARS
S/O.K.G.CHANDI, RESIDING AT KALLUVILA HOUSE,
PUTHIYANGADI, WEST HILL.P.O.,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT, PIN-673005
BY ADV SERGI JOSEPH THOMAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS 4 & 5 :
THE SPECIAL THAHASILDAR, L.A.
THALASSERY, PIN-670101
THE SECRETARY
ZILLA PANCHAYATH, KANNUR, PIN-670002
THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
KANNUR-670002
BY ADV SRI. T.K. SHAJAHAN, SR.GP, FOR R1 AND R3
SMT.C.LEENA, FOR R2
THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
03.04.2025, ALONG WITH LA.App.NO.263/2019 AND CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
DR. A.K. JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR &
EASWARAN S., JJ.
-----------------------------------------------L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
LAA Nos. 212, 226, 263, 318 of 2019
-----------------------------------------Dated this the 3rd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
Easwaran S., J.
These appeals are preferred by the claimants aggrieved by
the judgment and decree of the Additional Sub Court, Thalassery.
LAA Nos.212, 226 and 263 of 2019 are preferred against in LAR
No.174 of 2012, LAA No.286 of 2017 is preferred against LAR
No.147 of 2012 and LAA No.318 of 2019 is preferred against LAR
No.145 of 2012.
2. Since the facts in all these appeals are common, for the
sake of brevity, we deem it appropriate to refer the facts in L.A.A.
No.263 of 2019. An extent of 0.4308 hectares of land comprised in
Re-survey No.24/4 (New 24/11) of Chokli Amsom of Peringadi
Desom of Thalassery Taluk was acquired for the purpose of
construction of a park for children and aged people at New Mahe.
The notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act,
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
1894 was issued on 23.5.2008 and the award was passed on
21.5.2011. Pertinently all other properties involved in these cases
are also in the same Taluk and lying contiguously together. The
land acquisition officer relying upon document No.2154 of 2006
fixed the land value at Rs.17,930/- per cent. Dissatisfied with the
award, the claimants sought reference under Section 18 of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 . In support of their claim, Exts.A1 to
A3 were produced and AW1 to AW3 were examined. The
respondents/State
produced
the
report
of
the
Advocate
Commissioner and also the basic documents, which were marked
as Exts.R1 to R2.
The Advocate Commissioner’s report was
marked as Ext.X1. The respondents/State examined the author of
Ext.R1 report as RW1. The primary contention raised by the
claimants before the reference court was based on Exts.A1 and A2
deeds. The reference court discarded Ext.A2 since it was a postnotification document and, proceeded to fix the land value relying
on the judgment in L.A.R. No.147 of 2012 out of which LAA No.286
of 2017 arises. We referred to the facts in the present case since
the best exemplar that is available is in L.A.R. No.174 of 2012.
Thus, relying on the judgment in L.A.R. No.147 of 2012, the
reference court fixed the land value at Rs.25,000/-. Being
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
aggrieved by that the present appeals are preferred.
3.
Heard Sri. Serji Joseph Thomas, the learned counsel
appearing for the appellants/claimants and Sri. T.K. Shajahan, the
learned Senior Government Pleader.
4.
The learned counsel appearing for the appellants
submitted that the reference court discarded Exts.A1 and A2
produced in L.A.R. No.174 of 2012. According to the learned
counsel, the property covered by Ext.A2 lies 800 metres away from
the land acquired and, therefore, even if it is a post notification
document, there is no impediment for the reference court to rely
on the said document. Just because it is a post notification
document, there is no disqualification for accepting the same as an
exemplar. The learned counsel further took this Court to the report
of the Advocate Commissioner and pointed out that the land
acquisition officer misdirected himself by relying on to the basic
document which has no similarity with that of the land acquired.
5. On the other hand, the learned Senior Government Pleader
would submit that, in the absence of any exemplar, the reference
court was justified in placing reliance on its own decision in L.A.R.
No.147 of 2012. The reference court fixed the land value at
Rs.25,000/- per cent in order to bring parity in compensation to all
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
the landowners and, therefore, the judgment of the reference court
does not call for any interference.
6. We have considered the submissions raised across the bar
and are of the view that the appellants are entitled to succeed. It is
true that the reference court was guided by its own decision in
L.A.R. No.147 of 2012, we hasten to note that the quality of
evidence produced in all these reference cases substantially
differs. Therefore, though prima facie, we feel that, to some extent,
the reference court was justified in fixing the land value in terms
of its own decision in LAR No.147 of 2012, we cannot remain
oblivious to the fact that all the claimants are before us in appeals
and therefore once we examine the quality of evidence produced
in each case and come to a conclusion that the claimants are
entitled for a higher value, then necessary consequences will have
to follow.
7. In this backdrop, we proceed to consider the evidence
produced in L.A.R. No.174 of 2012. The documents produced are
Exts.A1 and A2. The commercial importance of the property is
beyond any doubt in view of the specific findings recorded by the
Advocate Commissioner in Ext.X1 report. However, the question to
be considered is whether Ext.A1 document which was executed on
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
15.1.2007 for a sum of Rs.1 lakh per cent or Ext.A2 document
executed in the year 2010 with an amount of Rs.65,000/- per cent
has to be taken into consideration.
8. No doubt Ext.A2 is a post-notification document. However,
there is no absolute rule that the post-notification document cannot
be relied on as an exemplar. The only caution to be exercised in
such cases is to apply a suitable deduction from the value in order
to arrive at a just and fair compensation.
9.
We find that the reference court has analysed the
applicability of Exts.A1 and A2 documents qua the land acquired
and found that Ext.A1 is three kilometers away from the acquired
property, whereas, Ext.A2 is just 500 meters away from the
acquired land. The only disqualification attributed by the reference
court towards Ext.A2 is that it is a post-notification document. As
a matter of fact, if this is the only disqualification attributed
towards Ext.A2 and once the aforesaid disqualification can be got
over by applying the suitable deduction, then we are of the view
that Ext.A2 is the best exemplar that was available before the
reference court.
10. When we further read the judgment of the reference court
we find that perhaps it is because of the lack of suitable evidence
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
that the reference court proceeded to consider LAR No.147 of 2012
and fixed the land value at Rs.25,000/- per cent. Having fixed the
land value at Rs.25,000/- per cent, the reference court though was
satisfied with regard to the proximity of the land acquired and also
the land covered by Ext.A2 document, it found itself difficult to get
over its own judgment in LAR No.147 of 2012 and accordingly
followed the same principle and fixed the land value at
Rs.25,000/-. As aforesaid, when all the claimants are before us, we
need not confine ourselves to the evidence produced by the parties
before the reference court in LAR No.147 of 2012.
11. On a consideration of the entire facts and circumstances,
we are of the considered view that the claimants in LAR No.174 of
2012 were successful in establishing the proximity of the land with
that of the land acquired. However, we are of the view that merely
because Ext.A2 document was a post-notification document, the
evidentiary value of the same does not get eroded. Therefore, the
appellants are entitled to succeed.
12. In the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the
view that the interest of justice would be served if we apply a 10%
deduction for each year and arrive at a market value. We find that
the notification under Section 4(1) was issued in the year 2008
L.A.A. No.286 of 2017 and
connected cases
2025:KER:29565
whereas Ext.A2 was executed in the year 2010. Therefore, when
we apply 10% deduction, we arrive at the following figure:
65000x10%=6500
6500x2years =13000
65000-13000=52,000/13.
Accordingly, these appeals are allowed modifying the
judgment and decree of the reference court in LAR Nos.174 of
2012, 145 of 2012 & 147 of 2012 by refixing the land value at
Rs.52,000/- (Rupees Fifty Two Thousand only) per cent. The
appellants are entitled to all statutory benefits flowing out of the
aforesaid refixation together with proportionate costs.
Sd/-
DR. A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
JUDGE
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
NS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review