Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
TUESDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF JANUARY 2024 / 19TH POUSHA, 1945
RFA NO.42 OF 2018
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DT. 31.10.2017 IN OS 246/2011 OF
PRINCIPAL SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM
----APPELLANTS/PLAINTIFFS:
K.V.XAVIER,
AGED 68 YEARS,
S/O.LATE VARGHESE,KIZHAVANA HOUSE, VYTTILA
P.O,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT.
K.V.ANTONY, AGED 68 YEARS,
S/O.LATE VARGHESE, KIZHAVANA HOUSE,VYTTILA P.O,
THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT.
KARMALI JOSEPH, AGED 72 YEARS,
D/O LATE VARGHESE, KIZHAVANA HOUSE,NOW RESIDING AT
VATTAPPILLY, MANJUMMEL P.O., UDYOGAMANDAL,ERNAKULAM
DISTRICT.
KATHREENA VINCENT, AGED 65 YEARS,
D/O.LATE VARGHESE, KIZHAVANA HOUSE,NOW RESIDING AT
KUNNATH, CHOTTANIKKARA P.O., ERNAKULAM DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.ABRAHAM K.JOHN
SMT.C.G.ARUNDHATHI
RFA NO.42 OF 2018
-2-
RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
PETER AUGUSTINE,
S/O.KUNGUSTINE (@)DEVASSY, PARAVARA HOUSE,VYTTILA P.O,
THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SALIMKUMAR, S/O LATE BHASKARAN,
MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM
DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SUKUMARI THILAKAN,
D/O LATE BHARATHY, MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA
P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SANTHOSH KUMAR,
S/O.LATE BHARATHY, MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA
P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SARASA,
MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM
DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SURYA SOUMYA,
D/O LATE K.B.SURESH KUMAR,MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA
P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SARIKA SOUMYA,
D/O.LATE K.B.SURESH KUMAR,MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA
P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
SAYUJ.S.KUMAR,
S/O LATE K.B.SURESH KUMAR,MAMBRAYIL HOUSE, VYTTILA
P.O.,THYKOODAM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-682019.
RFA NO.42 OF 2018
BY ADVS.
SMT.N.DEEPA
T.SETHUMADHAVAN (SR.)
DEEPA NARAYANAN
PRADEEP P B
TOMY CHACKO
VISHNU PRADEEP
KODOTH PUSHPARAJAN
VANDANA MENON
PREETHI. P.V.
K.JAYESH MOHANKUMAR
-3-
- R5 TO R8
- R5 TO R8
- R2
- R1
- R1
- R1
- R2
- R2
- R2
- R2
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
09.01.2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
SATHISH NINAN, J.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
R. F. A. No.42 of 2018
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 9th day of January, 2024
J U D G M E N T
The suit for declaration of title, fixation of
boundary and prohibitory injunction was dismissed by the
trial court. The plaintiffs are in appeal.
2. The plaint schedule property is described as, 9
cents
in
Survey
plaintiffs
are
No.1250
the
of
children
Poonithura
village.
The
of
Varghese.
The
late
plaintiffs claim title over the plaint schedule property
as per Exts.A8 and A1 Sale Deeds dated 08.02.1955 and
13.02.1964 respectively, executed by late Devassy alias
Kunjagasthy, the father of the first defendant in favour
of the plaintiffs' father Varghese. The suit has been
filed alleging that on the strength of Ext.B7 Partition
Deed of the year 1993 executed between the 1 st defendant
and
others,
by
including
a
portion
of
the
plaint
schedule property, attempts are being made to trespass
into the plaint schedule property. Defendants 2 to 7 are
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 2 :-
the owners of the property on the southern side of the
plaint schedule property. The plaint schedule is bounded
on all the other three sides by the properties of the
first defendant.
3. The defendants denied the claim of title and
possession of the plaintiffs over the plaint schedule
property.
It
was
contended
that
the
plaintiffs
predecessor late Varghese had not obtained title over
the property under Exts.A8 and A1. The plaintiffs’ claim
of possession over the plaint schedule property was also
denied.
4.
The
trial
court
relied
Exts.B3
and
B4
Settlement
Deeds
executed
by
the
father
the
of
on
of
the
recitals
in
the
year
plaintiffs
in
their
favour, wherein the property obtained under Exts.A8 and
A1
are
stated
to
be
situated
in
Survey
No.1236.
Accordingly, the claim of the plaintiffs over the plaint
schedule
property
situated
in
Survey
No.1250
was
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 3 :-
negatived.
5. This appeal was earlier disposed of by this
Court as per judgment dated 05.07.2021, remanding the
suit to the trial court for disposal denovo. The same
was challenged by the first defendant before the Apex
Court in Civil Appeal No.2595/2023. The Apex Court as
per judgment dated 10.04.2023 interfered with the order
of remand and directed the appeal to be disposed of
afresh.
6. I have heard the learned counsel on either side.
7. The points that arise for determination in the
appeal are :(i) Was the trial court right in having held against the
claim of title of the plaintiffs over the plaint schedule property
as the legal heirs of their late father Varghese, by relying on
the recitals in Exts.B3 and B4 Settlement Deeds executed in
their favour by their father ?
(ii) Has the plaint schedule property been correctly
identified in Ext.C1(a) Commissioner's Plan ?
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 4 :-
8. It is the case of the plaintiffs that, Ext.A8
Sale Deed was executed by the father of the first
defendant in favour of their father conveying two items
of properties which are situated in Survey Nos.1236 and
1250 respectively. However, due to an oversight, the
property in Survey No.1250 was omitted to be scheduled
to Ext.A8. It is on realising the same that subsequently
Ext.A1 Sale Deed was executed scheduling the property in
Survey No.1250 which is the plaint schedule property.
9. Presently we are not concerned with the question
as to whether under Ext.A8 Sale Deed two items of
properties were conveyed or intended to be conveyed. All
that this Court is to consider is as to whether the
plaintiffs have established their title over the plaint
scheduled property viz. 9 cents in Survey No.1250.
10. A reading of Ext.A8 Sale Deed indicates that,
it related to 9 cents of property in Survey No.1236.
Subsequently Ext.A1 Sale Deed was executed between the
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 5 :-
parties reciting that there had been a mis-description
of the property in Ext.A8 Sale Deed with regard to the
survey number, and that the correct survey number is Sy.
1250 and not in Sy.1236. It is important to notice that,
the boundary description on all the four sides in both
Exts.A1 and A8 are, one and the same.
11. Therefore, from Ext.A1 it is evident that the
father of the first defendant asserted that the property
conveyed by him to the father of the plaintiffs under
Ext.A8 was 9 cents in Sy. 1250.
12. Ext.A8 authorised the vendee therein viz. The
father of the plaintiffs, to get return from the Sub
Registrar's Office a release deed in respect of the
property,
which
was
executed
on
the
very
same
day
releasing a liability over the plaint schedule property.
Ext.A9 is the Release Deed. The boundary description of
the property in Ext.A9 on all the four sides are also
the very same description as in Exts.A1 and A8. Therein
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 6 :-
also the survey number of the property is stated as Sy.
1250.
13. Ext.B6 is a Sale Deed executed by the Jenmi of
the property in favour of the plaintiffs' father. Item
No.4 therein is the 9 cents in Survey No.1250. The
boundary description of the properties on all the four
sides are the same as described in Exts.A1, A8 and A9.
14. The description of the boundaries in Exts.A1,
A8, A9 and B6 which are identical, indicates that the
property dealt with in all those documents were one and
the same. As noticed earlier, though Ext.A8 mentions the
property dealt with therein to be situated in Survey
No.1236, in the subsequent document Ext.A1 it has been
recited
that
in
Ext.A8
the
survey
number
has
been
mistakenly stated and that the correct survey number is
Sy.1250. This suggests that the father of the plaintiffs
have obtained title over the 9 cents of property in
Survey
No.1250
which
is
described
in
the
plaint
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 7 :-
schedule.
15.
The
defendants
bank
upon
Exts.B3
and
B4
Settlement Deeds which are executed in favour of the
plaintiffs by their father. The said settlement deeds
are stated to be in respect of the property obtained by
their father under Exts.A8 and A1. In the scheduled
description to the said document it has been stated
that, though in Ext.A1 the property is described as
situated in Survey No.1250, going by Ext.A8 and village
survey, the property is in Survey No.1236. Relying upon
the same, the defendants contend that the plaintiffs'
father had obtained title under Exts.A1 and A8 only over
the
property
situated
in
Survey
No.1236
and
the
plaintiffs cannot lay claim over the property in Survey
No.1250.
16. From the above it is evident that, there are
two sets of documents - one set in which the first
defendant's
father
(the
vendor)
asserts
that
the
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 8 :-
property conveyed by him to the plaintiffs' father under
Exts.A8 and A1 is situated in Survey No.1250 and not in
Survey No.1236; the other set of documents being the
ones executed in favour of the plaintiffs by their
father reciting that the property obtained under Exts.A8
and A1 is situated in Survey No.1236 and not in Survey
No.1250. In the light of the conflicting recitals, a
finding on identity cannot be entered into either way
based on such recitals regarding survey number. The
finding of the trial court solely relying on Exts.B3 and
B4 documents executed by the father of the plaintiffs in
favour of the plaintiffs cannot be sustained. Point No.1
is answered accordingly. The judgment of the trial court
is based on such finding and it is liable to be set
aside.
17. Admittedly, the property in Survey No.1236 and
Survey No.1250 do not lie adjacent; but they lie far
apart. The plaintiffs have filed the suit claiming title
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 9 :-
over the property not based on Exts.B3 and B4 Settlement
Deeds executed by their father but as the legal heirs of
their
father
and
tracing
title
to
Exts.A1
and
A8.
Therefore, the claim is independent of Exts.B3 and B4.
It would appear that the plaintiffs attempt is to claim
title over the property in Sy. 1236 under Exts.B3 and
B4, and over Sy.1250 under Exts.A8 and A1 as the legal
heirs of their father. As has been noticed supra, the
question that arises for determination in this suit is
as to whether the plaintiffs have established title over
the plaint schedule property and not whether they have
title over the properties in both survey numbers.
18. As noticed earlier, the boundary description on
all the four sides of the property included in Exts.A1,
A8, A9 and B6 are one and the same. Since there is
discrepancy
in
the
survey
number,
and
the
boundary
description on all the four sides in Exts.A1, A8, A9 and
B6 being one and the same, an identification based on
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 10 :-
boundaries would clinch the issue. Admittedly there has
been no identification by the commissioner. Unless such
identification is made, it cannot be said that the
plaint schedule property has been properly identified.
Point No.2 is answered as above.
19. I have already found that the judgment of the
trial court cannot be sustained. The suit being one on
title, it is only in the interests of both sides that
they
be
identified
given
opportunity
afresh,
especially
to
have
with
the
reference
property
to
the
boundary description in the documents referred to above.
The rival claim of possession over the property, and the
contentions based on the same with regard to limitation
etc. are all to be left open to be agitated before the
trial court.
In the result, the appeal is allowed. The decree
and judgment of the trial court are set aside. The suit
is remanded back to the trial court for disposal denovo.
RFA No.42 of 2018
-: 11 :-
Parties shall be afforded opportunity to adduce further
evidence. Considering the fact that the suit is of the
year 2011, I am sure that every endeavour will be made
by the trial court for an expeditious disposal of the
suit.
Parties
to
appear
before
the
trial
court
on
30.01.2024.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
kns/-
//True Copy//
P.S. to Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review