Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
IN THE HIGH COURT 0F RERALA AT E
AKuliAM
PRESENT
THE HONOuRABI]E MR. ]usTlcE EAsvmRAN s.
THtJRSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MZRCH 2025 / 6TH CHAITHRA,
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
AGAINST THE ruDGMENT DATED 19.12.2oo2 IN os No.79 oF
1989 OF pRINclpAL SUB cOuRT, KOLLm¢
APPEliLENTS/ADDITIONAI-D72 TO D74 :
K.SAVITHRI, W/O.
AKARZEN
{D33) ,
AENINNAVILA VEEDU,KOTIAPPURAM, , PARAV'OOR P. 0. ,
KOLIAM DISTRICT.
pAmmKumR, s/O.
AKARZEN
ARANINNAVIIiA VEEDU,KOTTAPPURAM, , PARAVOOR P. O. ,
KOLLzn¢ DlsTRlcT .
pADMAKunmRI , D/o.
AKARAN
ARZININNAVIIA VEEDU, ROTTAPPURAM, , PARAVOOR P.O. ,
KOI.IchM DISTRICT.
8¥ anvs .
N . v . sanll¥A
emNu V¥ASAN PETER
P.B.KRISHNEN(K/1193/1994)
S.V.BALAKRISHNA IYER (SR. ) (B-75)
p.B.suBRzanmN¥AN(K/1145/2oog)
SABU GEORGE (K/000711/1998)
B.AIIUSREE(K/000951/2016)
AIS"ARYA MOHAN (K/274/2020)
RESPONDENTS/PIAINTIFFS 1 TO 10
DI TO D71
D75 TO D87 AND
ADDITIONAL PIAINTIFFS 13 AND 14:
ENrmA BHAI
D/0. um4INI, (DIED 18.o8.2oo6) , LRs -AI]I>ITIONAI[
D78 T0 D85, VIDE IA 3482/06, DATED 04.08.2007) .
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
SUBHADRA "/0. VIDYADHARAN
(s/o.urmlNI) , AGED 6o ¥EARs, ARANINNAvlLA vEEDu, ,
PAMPURAM CHERRY, KAlilluvATHUKKAI. P. 0. , KOLLZD4
DISTRICT .
SULOCHANA D/O. VIDYADHARZEN
AGED 40 YEARS, ARANINNAVILA VEEDU, PAMPURAM
CIIERRY, KAliliuvATHUKKAli P.O. , KOIiLAM DISTRICT.
SATHEESAN S/O. VIDYADHARAN
AGED 34 YEARS, ARANINNAVILA VEEDU, PAMPURAM
CHEREY, KAIILUVATHUKKAII P. O,. , KOLIIAM I)ISTRICT.
dAGADAmm, D/o. vlD¥ADHARAN
AGEI) 29 YEARS , ARZININNAVIIiA VEEDU, PAMPURAI4
CHERRY, KAIILUVATHUKKAII P.O. , KOLILAM DISTRICT.
SOBEIZENA, D/O. VIDYAI)IIARAN
AGED 24 YEARS, ARANINNAVILA VEEDU, PAMPURAI4
cHERRy, KALLuvATHUKKAI] p.o. , KOLLan4 I>ISTRlcT.
V.VIJAYANANI)AN, S/O. VIDYADHARAN
AGED 23 YEARS, ARZENINNAVILA VEEDU, PAB@URZD4
CHERRY, KALLUVATHUKKAL P.O. , KOLILZ\M DISTRICT.
v. sATHyASRELmT D/o. vlDyADIIARA?a
AGED 20 YEARS, AENINNAVIIiA VEEDU, PAMPURAM
cHERR¥, KAI,I,UVATHUKKAL p.o. , Kol.Lzn¢ DlsTRlcT.
KUNCHUKALI SARADA (P9) (DIED 08.02.2003
I-RS ADDITIONAL P 13 & P 14 VIDE IA 2760/06, DATED
04 . 08 .2007) .
V. SUDEVAN,
S/O. VIDYADHARZEN.
(D36 wllo eras TRANspOsED) , ARZENIENAvlLA vEEDu,
PAMPURAM CHERRY, PARIPPAliLY P.0. , KOIiliAM
DISTRICT.
RAI4AN,
(D1)
S/O.
GOPAliAN
(DIED) , IIRS D61 TO D63.
VASUDECZEN
(D2)
S/0. RESAVAN
(DIED) , I.RS D64 TO D67.
2 0 2 5 : KE.R : 2 61 0 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
SADANANDAN
(D3^)
S/O.
RESAV:ZEN
(DIED)
I.RS D68 TO D71.
BHASURANGI , D/0. BEIZIVANI
AGED 45 ¥EARs, sAsl MZENDIRzn4, VAIATHUNGZEL,
AKKOLIII CHERRY, RAYYANAD VIIillAGE.
HARIDASAN,
S/O.
GOPALZIN
AGED 35 ¥EARs, sAsl imNI>IRZM, vALATHtINGAL,
AKKOLIII CHERRY, MAYYENAD VILIIAGE.
SASIDHARAN, S/O. GOPALAN, AGED 32 YEARS
SASI MZENDIRZM, VALATIIUNGAli, AKKOLIII CHERRY, ,
m¥¥ANAD vll[IAGE.
RADHAMONY, D/0. BHAV:ANI
AGED 30 YEARS, SASI MANDIRAM, VALATHtJNGAli,
AKKOLIIi CHERRY, RAYYANAD VILIAGE.
COPALEN,
(DIED)
s/o. vELu, AGED 6o ¥EARs, suKtr nmNDIRZM,
CHOZHIYAKKODU CHERRY , KUIATHUPPUZHA VIIiIAGE.
(R18 DIED ISSUEliESS AND THAT HE HAS NO IiEGAli
HEIRS AS PER ORDER DATED 18/12/2009 IN IA
4508/09)
THANKAIn4A D/o. vELu
AGED 5o yEARs, dAyANTHI BHzlvENAI, suKtr imNDIRAM, ,
CHOZHIYAKKODU CHERRY , KULATHUPPUZHA VII.LACE.
*
BHARGZIVI (DIED) D/O. VEI-U
(HAD ASSIGNED RIGHTS TO D37) .
ANANDAN, S/O. VEIIU AGED 55 YEARS
KODUMOOTTIIi VEEDU , KOTTAKKARUM CHERRY ,i PARIPALLY.
BIIARAIH¥, D/O. VELU
(HAD ASSICRED RIGHTS TO D37) .
J
A104AKUNOu (DIED)
D/O. KOCHUPENNU, LRS
KOCHUNARAYANAN,
(D20) .
(STRUCK OFF)
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
S/O. REELAKANDAN, AGED 65 YEARS, ARANINNAVIIA
VEEDU, KOTTAPPURAM, PARAVO0R P.O. , KOI]IiAM
DISTRICT .
(THE NAME OF THE 24`H RESPONDENT IS STRUCK OFF
FROM THE PARTY ARRAY AS PER ORDER DATED
16/03/2010 IN IA 1077/2010)
SAKTHIDARAN, S/0. REELAKZENDAN
AGED 55 YEARS, ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU, KOTTAPPURZM,
PARZIVOOR P.O. , KOLIAM DISTRICT.
GOPINAI)AN,
S/0. NEELAKZENDAN
AGED 52 YEARS, ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU, KOTTAPPURZM,
pARAvOoR p.O. , KOI.Lzn¢ DlsTRlcT.
CIIANDRZIN S/O. NEELAICANDAN
AGED 47 YEARS, ARANINNAVILA VEEDU, KOTTAPPURAM,
PARAVOOR P.O. , K0I.IAM DISTRICT.
SASIDHABAN S/O. REELAKZENDAN
AGED 45 YEARS (COVT. SERVANT) , ARANIENAVIIA VEEDU,
KOTTAPPUR", PARE:VOOR P.O. , KOLLAM DISTRICT.
SANTHA, D/O. NRElnKANDAN
AGED 43 YEARS, ARANINNAVIIA VIEDU, KOTTAPptJRE,
PARZIVOOR P.O. , KOI.IiAM DISTRICT.
SATHYAN, S/O. NANU
AGED 52 YEARS, ARANINNAVILA CHAlilli VEEDU,
OZHUKUPARA, REDUNG0ILAM P.0. , PARAV00R, , KOIiliAM
DISTRICT .
KOCHUPENNU BHARGZIVI , (DEI.ETED)
AGED 78 YEARS
ARZENINNAVILA CHALIIi VEEDU, OZHUKUPARA, ,
REDUNGOLzn4 p.o. , pARAvooR, Kol,ILAM DlsTRlcT.
IAKSHMI ,
(DELEIED)
D/0. KOCHUPENNU, AGED 66 YEARS
ARZENINNAVILA CHAIIIIi VEEDU, OZIIUKUPARA, NEDUNGOIiAM
P.O. , PARAVOOR, KOI.IAM DISTRICT.
COPALAN,
(DEIIETED)
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
S/o. NEELznBI & KoCHupENNu
AGED 72 YEARS, ARENINNAVIIA CHAIIIII VEEDU, ,
OZHUKUPARA, NEDUNGOILAM P.O. ,
PARE:VOOR, ,
KOIiLZu}4
DISTRICT .
RZIVINDEN, S/0. NABAYANAN
AGED 36 YEARS, AENINNAVIIiA CHAlilL VEEDU,
OZHUKUPARA, REDUNcoliAI4 P.O. , PARAV00R, KOI.RAM
DISTRICT.
SURENDRAN,
S/O. NARAYANAN
AGED 34 YEARS, ARANINNAVILA CHAlill. VEEDU,
ozHUKUpARA, NEDUNcol]AM p. o. , pARAvooR, Kol[Lzan4
DISTRICT .
GOURI D/O. KUCHUKAI.I
LRS D52 TO D60,.
SAR6TINI (DIED - IIRS ADDlhR96 TO 99 IMPLEADED)
D/O. KUNJUKAlil KALYENI
(TEACHER) , AGED 54 YEARS, KAI.LIL VEEDU,
NEDUNcOLAM,
P.O. ,
(DIED)
PARZIVOOR, KOIiLAM DISTRICT.
sARAsmaTHy (DELETED)
D/O. KUNJUKAlil KAliYANI
AGED 45 YEARS, (GOVT. SERVENT) , I.C.29/727,
puNNApuRZD4 ROAD , KAITIIAMUKKu , THIRuvENENTHApuRzn4.
SULOCHAllA (DIED -IIRS, ADI)ILR100 TO R102
IMPIIEZDED)
D/O. KUNtJtJKALI KAliYANI
AGEI] 47 ¥EARs, KAI]I,II, vEEDu, REDUNGolnM p.o. ,
PABA:VOOR, KOLLAM DISTRICT.
RzivEEmRZEN (DIED - I[Rs IMPLEADED)
S/O. KtJNTUKALI KALYANI.
AGED 53 YEARS, KAliLIL VEEDU, NEDUNcOIIAM P.0. ,
PARAVOOR, KOLIAM DISTRICT.
SOMZEN, s/O. KUNruKAI]I KALyANI
AGED 48 YEARS, KAIILII. VEEDut, NEDUNcOLAI4 P.0. ,
PARAVOOR, KOI.LAM DISTRICT.
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
RZDmcHANDRAN, s/o. COPAI.AN
AGED 38 YEARS, (GOVT. SERVANT) , I.C.29.727,
KAliLIIi VEEI)U, NEDUNGOIiAM P.O. ,
PARZIVOOR, ,
KOLLZD4
DISTRICT .
ZuKAEN, S/O.
LRS D72 TO D77) .
V. CHANDRASENAN, S/O. VII)YADHARAN
ARZENINNAVILA VEEDU, PAMPURAI4 CHEREY , ,
KALI]UVATHUKKAI-P. 0. , HOLlfiM DISTRICT.
V. TAXADEVAN, S/O. VIDYADIIARZIN
ARANIENAVIIA VEEDU, PAMPURAM CHERRY , ,
KAI.LtJVATHUKKAI-P.O. , KOLLAM DISTRICT.
BHZISI, S/O. BASKABAll, AGED 32 ¥EARS
RETHI imNDIRZD4, MUNDAylL cHERRy, VARICAIA vlLIAGE.
SURENDRAN, AGED 35 YEARS
PADMENABHAIl
(DIED)
(TENANT)
AENIENAVILA VEEDU , KOTTAPURZD4 CHEREY , PARAVOOR
P.O. , KOI.IAM DISTRICT.
SREEKUMAR (DEliETED )
AGED 30 YEARS (TENANT)
ARAN.INNAvlLA vEEDu, KOTTApuRm4 cHERRy , PARZIVOOR
P.O. , KOI.IiAM DISTRICT.
SASIDHARAN (DELETED)
AGED 35 YEARS (TENANT)
ARANINNAVILA VIEDU, KOTTAPURAM CHERRY , PARZIVOOR
P.0. , ROI]LAM DISTRICT.
SUGATHAN (DEI-ETED)
AGED 28 YEARS (TENANT)
ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU , KOTTAPURAM CHERRY , PARAVO0R
P.O. , KOI.IAM DISTRICT.
SUGUNAN (DELETED)
AGED 39 YEARS (TENANT)
ARANINNAVILA VEEDU , KOTTAPURAM CHERRY , PARAVOOR
P.O. , KOI]IIAM DISTRICT.
2025 : KER: 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
NAZEEM AGED 36 YEARS (TENANT)
ARZININNAVIIiA VEEDU, KOTTAPURAM CHERRY , PARAV00R
p.o. , Kol.Lm¢ DlsTRlcT.
GOPAliAN AGED 38 YEARS (TENANT)
ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU, KOTTAPURAM CHERRY , PARAVOOR
P.0. , KOLliAM DISTRICT.
SIIAMSUDEEN (DEIIETED)
AGED 47 YEARS (TENANT)
ARZINIENAVIIA VEEDU , KOTTAPURZD4 CHERRY , PARAVOOR
P.O. , KOLIAM DISTRICT.
BAHUDEEN (DEliETED)I
AGED 50 YEARS (TENANT)
AENIENAVILA VEEDU , KOTTAPURAM CHERRY , PARE:VOOR
p.O. , KOI]Lzan¢ DlsTRlcT.
MOHANAN (DELETED)
AGED 37 YEARS (TENANT)
ARANINNZIVILA VEEDU, KOTTAPURAM CHERRY ,I PARZIVOOR
P.O. , KOLIAM DISTRICT.
GOVINDHANKUTTY AGED 49 YEARS (TENANT)
ARZENINNAVIIA VEEDU , KOTTAPURZD4 CHERRY ,
PARZIVO0R
p.O. , KOI.Lzn¢ DlsTRlcT.
I)R. S.RAJU (DELETED)
AGED 38 YEARS (TENANT)
ARANINNAVILA VEEDU, KOTTAPURZD4 CHERRY , PARAVOOR
P.O. , KOLliAM DISTRICT.
P.GZENGADHARAN PIIilAI (DIED -ADDL.R92 TO R95
IRELEADED)
SAKTHI VIHAR, KALAKKODE CHERRY, POOTHAKKUILAM
p.o. , KOLLzan¢ DlsTRlcT.
sARAswATH¥ Aiom
W/O. GENGADHARZEN PILIAI, SAKTHI VIHAR, KAliAKKODE
CHEBR¥, PO0THAKKuld\M P.O. , KOLIAM DISTRICT.
RAdArmm, (DIED - I,Rs IMpl[EADED)
D/o. GOuRI , NATARAr BIIZIVAN
KALI-UVATHUKKAI] P. O. , KOI-LAM DISTRICT.
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
M.S.ANAND (DIED -IiRS IMpliEADED)
S/O. COURI, SANTHI BHA:VAN
KOoNAyll], pARAvOOR p.O. , KOI,Lzan4 DlsTRlcT.
SARASArm4A D/o. GouRI SANTHI BIIZIVAN
KooNA¥II., pARAVooR P.o. , KOLLzn¢ DlsTRICT.
MADHAV:AN CHZENDRA MOHAN
(DELETEI))
s|o. cgr5f rITi
SENTHI BHAVEN, KOONAYIL,
PARAVOOR P.O. , KOIilLAM
DISTRICT .
38, 48 TO 51, 54 TO 56, 58 AND R64
ARE DEI.ETED FROM THE PARTY AREAY AT TIIE RISK OF
(R31 T0 R33
THE APPELIENTS AS PER ORDER DATED 18/12/2009 IN
IA 4508/2009)
nmDHAVAN coplNATHAN, (DIED - I[RS IMpl[EADED)
S/O. COURI
SANTIII BHAVEN, K00NAYIL, PARAVOOR P.O. , KOI]IAM
DISTRICT .
MADHAV:AN RZIVEENDRZEN,
S/O.
(DIED -LRS IMPI.EAI)ED) ,
GOURI
SANTHI BHA:V:ZEN, K00NAYIIi, PARAVO0R P.O. , KOLLZD4
DISTRICT .
GOURI OMENA, (DIED - IiRS IMpliEADED)
D/O. GOURI, SANTHI BHAVEN, KOONAYIL,
P.O. , KOI.LAM DISTRICT.
PARZIVOOR
bnDHAV:AN sormN, s/o. couRI
SANTIII BHAVEN, KOONAYII., PARAVO0R P.O. , KOI.IAM
DISTRICT .
nnDHZIVAN HARIDASAN, s/o. GouRI
SANTHI BHAVEN, KOONAylL, PARZIVOOR p.O. , , KOLlnM
DISTRICT .
sAvlTHIRI , w/o.RAimN copAIAN
AGED 71 ¥EARs, SATHEESH imNDIRzn4, VARINBZLM
cHERE¥, RAI.I.uVATHUKKAI] p.o. , Kol.Lzn¢ DlsTRlcT.
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
THtJIASI AIIIAS THULASEEDHABAN
AGED 50 ¥EARs, s/O.RznnN copAlnN, SATHEESH
MANI)IRZM, VARINdAM CHERRY, KAI.I.UVATHUKKAL P. O. ,
KOLLzn¢ DISTRlcT.
YAMUNA,
D/O.
RZD4AN COPAILEN,
AGED 40 YEARS, SATHEESH MANDIRZM, VARINdAM
CHERRY, KAI-LUVATHUKKAL P.O. , K0I.IiAM DISTRICT.
KunmRI, AGED 5o ¥EARs
D/O. VASUDEVAN, (D2) , ARANINNZIVILA VEEDU,
KOTTAPPURAM, PARAVOOR P.O. , KOI.IiAM DISTRICT.
SURESH KUMAR, AGED 45 YEARS
S/O. VASUDEVAN, ARZENINNAVILA VEEDU, KOTTAPPURZD4, ,
pARAvOOR p.O. , KOLLzan¢ DlsTRlcT.
StJNII., AGED 40 YEARS
S/O. VASUDEVAN, ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU, KOTTAPPURAM, ,
PARZIV00R P.O. , KOI-IEM DISTRICT.
SIIivI, AGED 38 YEARS
D/O. vAsuDEVAN, plAVILA vEEDu, pOOTHAKKulm¢ p.0. ,
PARAVOOR, KOI.LAI}¢ DISTRICT.
LALITHA, AGED 55 YEARS
W/0. SADANANI)AN (D3) , ECHAVIItA VEEDU,
P.O. , KOIilAM DISTRICT.
CHATHANNOOR
VldAYAN, AGED 35 YEARS
S/O.
SADANANDAN, ECHAVIIA VEEDU,
CEIATHANNOOR
P.0. , K0IiliAM DISTRICT.
IiATHA, AGED 32 YEARS, D/O. SADANANDAN
ECHAV.ILA VEEDU, CHATHANNOOR P.O. , KOIiLZD4
DISTRICT .
LATHIKA, AGED 30 YEARS, D/O. SADANANDAN
ECHAvr[LA VEEDU, CHATHANNooR P.o. , Ko[]LAI4
DISTRICT .
pADemRAOAN AGED 29 ¥EARs
S/O.
AKARAN (D33) , ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU, ,
KOTTAppuRAM, PARZIVOOR p.o. , KOI.Lzan4 DlsTRlcT.
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
SREEDEVI, AGED 26 YEARS
D/O.
ARARZIN , ARANINNAVIIA VEEDU ,
KOTTAPPURAM, , PARAVOOR P.O. , KOI.IiAM DISTRICT.
PADMINI, AGED 23 YEARS
D/O.
AKARZIN , ARANINNAVILA VEEDU,
KOTTAPPURAM, , PARZIVOOR P.O. , KOI.IAM DISTRICT.
SAROJINI, D/O. ANANDA BHAI
(P1)
ENAppURATHu vEEDu, PERIGABmLA, KAI[LI¥ooR, ,
TRlvrmRUM.
RAJENDRZEN,
S/O. ANANI)A BHAI
HousE No. 24 , AlsDmR¥A NAGAR, KESAVADASApuRAM. ,
PATTOM, TRIVANDRUM.
DR. REim CHANDRASENAN ,
D/0. ANANDA BHAI, HOUSE NO. 24, A'ISWARYA NAGAR, ,
RESAVADASAPURAM, PATTOM, TRIVANDRUM.
SARADA (WIRE OF DECEASED SON 0F ANANDA
BHAI) , SARADA NlvAs, KOODATHINKtr Roam, ,
KULASEKHARAPURAM, KEN AKUMARI DISTRICT, TAMIL
NZDU
SHYLAJA, ``RESHMI'' , KOTTAPPURAM
PARAVOOR P.O. , K0I.IiAM DISTRICT.
(IMPLEADED VIDE IA 2760/2006 DATED 4.8.20)
THE SECRETARY,
SNVRC BANK
pARAvooR p.o. , Kol.Lzn¢ DISTRICT.
(IREIEADED VIDE IA 2760/2006 DATED 4.8.20)
CHANDRIRA, D/O. KtJNCHUKALI SARAI)A (P9)
THEKRE PliAVIIA VEEDU, KOONAYIIi CHERRY, PARZIVOOR
P.O. , KOI-IiAM DISTRICT.
(IMPLEADED AS ADDI..P13 AND P14 VIDE IA 2760/2006
DATED 4.8.20)
SURESEN,
S/O. KUNCHUKALI SARAI)A, THEKKE PLZIVILA VEEDU,
KooNA¥IL cHERR¥, pARAvooR p.o. , KOLLzan¢ DlsTRlcT.
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
BEA NO. 52 0F 2009
ADDII.R92. G. SURENDRAN PIIIIiAI ,,
S/O. GZENGADHARAN PILLAI, AGED 53, RESIDING AT
NIDHI , KooNArll], PARA:vooR posT, KOLLm¢ DlsTRlcT.
ADDli.R93 G.
dzLYAPRASAD,
S/0. GENGADHARAN PII.IAI, AGED 48, RESIDING AT
SAKTHI vlEIAR, KALAKKODE, pOOTHAKULzn4 p.o. ,
PARAVOOR, KOI.IiAM DISTRICT.
ADDL. R94 G.BHADRAKUMAR,
S/O. GZINGADHARAN PIIIIAI, AGED 46, RESII)ING AT
SAKTHI vlHAR, KAILAKKODE,
poOTHAKULzan4 p.O. ,
PARAVOOR, KOI.LZ" DISTRICT.
ZDDII.R95 S. GEETHAKUMARI,
D/0. GZENGADIIARAN PILIAI, AGED 43, RESIDING AT
ASHOK BHAVENAI, Kul[ArmA, KlzHAKKENADA p.o. ,
pARlppAI.Ly, KOLLm¢ DlsTRlcT.
(LRS 0F DECEASED D59 ARE IMpliEADED AS ADDITI0NAli R92 T0
R95 AS PER OREER DATED 17/02/2014 IN IA 174/14)
ADDI].R96 suDHARImNI ,
D/o. sARorlNI, AGED 54 yEARs, REslDING AT RAI]I-IL
VEEDU, NEDUNcoliAM P.O. ,
PARAVOOR, KOLLZD4
DISTRICT .
ADDL. R97 SATHI ,
D/O. SAROTINI, AGED 48 YEARS, RESIDING AT KAliLIL
VEEDU, NEDUNcOILAM P.O. ,
PARAVOOR, KOIILAI4
DISTRICT .
ADI)I. R98 SHEELA,
D/O. SARodlNI, AGED 43 YEARS, RESIDING AT KAI.IilL
vEEDu, REDUNcoLZD4 p.O. , pARzlvooR, KOLlnM
DISTRICT .
(ADDITIONAI, R96 TO R98 ARE IMPLEADED As LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED R37 AS PER ORDER DATED
11/06/2015 IN IA 2178/2014)
ADDli. R99 SUSEELA,
D/O. SULOCHENA, AGED 48 YEARS, RESIDING AT
2'02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
VIIiAYIII VEEDU, NEDUNcOLAM P.O. ,
PARZIVOOR, KOIiLAI¢
DISTRICT .
ADDI| .
R100
SUI.EKHA,
D/0. SUI-OCHANA, AGED 42 YEARS, RESIDING AT
vllA¥II[ vEEDu, NEE)UNcoLzm p.o. , pARZIVooR, KOLLzn4
DISTRICT .
ADDL .
SUJA'
R101
D/O.
SULOCHENA, AGED 38 YEARS, RESIDING AT
vlLAyll[ vEEDu, REDUNcOLzn4 p.o. , pARAvooR, KOLlnM
DISTRICT .
ADDli.
SUMZITHI ,
R102
D/0. SULOCHENA, AGED 33 YEARS, RESIDING AT
VIIAYIL VEEDU, NEDUNcOILAM P.O. , PARAVOOR, KOLLZD4
DISTRICT .
(anDITloNAI, R99 To Rlo2 ARE IMpl[EAI>EI) As LEGAI.
REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED R39 AS PER ORDER DATED
11/06/2015 IN IA NO.2202/2014)
ADDL.
R103
T. RAJENDREN PIIiIAI ,
S/O. dANARDHANAN PIIIIiAI, AGED 56 YEARS,
SANGEETHA, FROM RAJEslmRI MANDIRZD4, pooTHAKKulnM
P.O. , K0IILZD4 DISTRICT-691302.
(ADDITIONAL R103 IS I'MPREED AS PER ORE)ER DATED 05/11/2020
IN IA 2702/2016)
ADDL.
K.
R104
AGED 66 YEARS, S/O. RESAVAN, RESIDING AT OMAli
KOTTAPPURAM, PARE:VOOR, KOLliAM DISTRICT-691301.
SADANANDAN,
(ADZ)ITIONAli R104 IS IMpliEADED AS PER OREER DATEI)
05/11/2020 IN IA NO.876/2018)
ADDI..
SolnRAJAli
R105
AGED 70 YEARS
H/O SARASVATHI, I.C. 28/876, RAITIIAMUKKU, PETTAH
P.O. , THIRUVENENTHAPURAM TAliuK.
ADDli.
R106
M.S. MINI
AGED 48 YEARS
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
D/0 SARASVATHI, I.C. 28/876, KAITHAMUKKU, PETTAH
P. O. , THIRUVENENTHAPURAM TAIUK.
ADDli.
M.S. ANI
Rlo7
AGED 46 rEARs
s/o sARAsimTHI, I.c. 28/876, KAITIIAMUKKu, PETTAII
P.O. ,
THIRUVANANTHAPURZD4 TAIIUK.
ADDL.
M.S.
SHENI
R108
AGED 44 YEARS
D/o SARASRATHI, I.c. 28/876, KAITHArm]KKtr, PETTAII
P. O. , THIRUVENENTHAPURAM TAIUK.
THE IHGAL HEIRS OF THE DECEASED R38 ARE IMpliEADED AS
ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 105 TO 108 VIDE OREER DATED
rl2 / T2 / 2:2; Tr] TA 1 / 2:2 .
ADDli.
RATAMONY
R109
D/O. RAVEENDRAN, AGED 35, ANEVIKA, NEAR KALlilli
VEEDU, NEDUNcOILAM P.0. , KOIIIIAM DISTRICT -691
334.
ADDI..
R110
MINI
"/0. SATU, ANEVIKA, NEAR KAliLIL VEEDU, REDUNcOLZD4
P.O. , KOIILAM DISTRICT.
(THE LEGAL HEIRS OF THE DECEASED 40TII RESPOREENT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 109 AND 110 VIDE ORDER
DATED 27/3/25 IN IA 1/24) .
ADDL .
Rill
NATARAJAN , AGED 76,
s/O. RArAm4zi, CHANDRAV.ILASAM, VENGOD , pALAyAMKUNNu
P.O., TRIVANDRUM -695146.
AI)DI, .
StRENDEN, AGED 64,
R112
s/O. RAdAm4A, NATARAOA BHAVEN, pzLMpuRAM,
KAI]LUVATHUKKAli P. 0. , KOLILAM DISTRICT.
ADDIJ ,
SURESH, AGED 53
R113
S/o. RABiAmm, NATARA4A BHzlvEN, pAMpuRAM,
KALLUVATHUKKAL P.O,. , KOIiLZD4 DISTRICT -691578.
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
THE IiEGAL HEIRS OF THE DECEASED 61ST RESPONDENT ARE
IMPI.EADED AS ADDITIONAli RESPONDENTS 111 TO 113 VIDE ORDER
DATED 27/3/25 IN IA 3/24
ADDL .
R114
PREM ANAND, AGED 45,
S/O'. M.S. ANAND, ATHORIA BHAV:AN, KOONAYIIi,
PARAVO0R P.0. , KOLIIAM DISTRICT -691301.
ADDII .
R115
PREM PRAKASH, AGED 40,
S/0. M.S. ANAND, SANTHI BHZIVEN, KO0NAYIIi,
pARZIVooR p.o. , KOLLznd DISTRlcT -691301.
THE LEGAli HEIRS OF DECEASED 62ND RESPONDENT ARE IRELEADED
AS ADDITIONAI. RESPONDENTS 114 AND Ills VIDE OREER DATED
2:I / 3 / 2:i I:" I:A 5 / 24
ADDII.
R116
KANTHAIENI, AGED 64,
w/O. imDHAVAN coplNATHAN, coKulLAM, Nt]EKKUNILAM,
vALI]IKKODE p.O. , pATHANAnflHITTA p.O.
PIN -695 653.
ADDli.
R117
VIPIN, AGED 40,
s/O. imDHAVAN coplNATHEN, GOKULAM, NBEKRI7NIILz`M,
VAI]LIKKODE P.0. , PATHENJREHITTA P.O.
PIN -695 653.
ADDII.
R118
REKHA COPINATH, AGED 37,
D/O. imDIIzlv:ZEN coplNATHAN, cOKulLAM, NeEKKUNII[AM,
vAI]I,IKKODE p.O. , pATHENrmHITTA p.0. ,
PIH-695 653.
THE IiEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED 65TH RESPONDENT ARE IMpliEADED
AS ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 116 T0 118 VIDE 0REER DATED
2:I / 3 / 2:5 ". TA r| / 24
'
ADDII.
LALITHA, AGED 65
R119
W/O. RZIVEENDEN, SREETYOTHI, CHIRAKKABA THAZAM,
CHIRAKKARA P.O. , KOIiLZD4 DISTRICT -I 691578.
ADDli.
R120
YAMUNA, AGED 40
D/O. RZIVEENDRAN,
SABHALYAM, CIIEERA VIIA, THAZIIAM,
cHATHENooR p.o. , KOLlnM -691572.
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
anDL .
R121
SINDU, AGED 37
D/O. RA:VEENDRZIN,
CHARUVIIiA VEEDU, KOONYIL,
pARAvooR p.o. , Kol.Lzn¢ -691301.
ADDL .
R122
-, AGED 35
S/O.
SREETYOTHI ,
P.O. ,
CHERAKKARA, THAZHAM,
CHURAKKABA
KOLIAM -691578.
THE LEGAI] HEIRS 0F DECEASED 66TH RESPONDENT ARE IMPLEADED
AS ADDITIONAli RESPONDENIS 119 AND 122 VIDE ORE)ER DATED
2:I I 3 I 2:5 TIN I:A 9 I 2A
ADDIJ ,
]A¥AKunmR, AGED 55,
R123
S/O. GOURI OENA, SANTHI BHAVEN, KOONYIII,
PARAVOOR P.O. , KOLliAM -691301.
ADDIJ ,
R124
JAYASANTHI, AGED 52 ,
D/O. COURI OMENA, SANTHI BHAVEN, KOONYII.,
PARZIVOOR P.0. , KOLILAM - 691301
ADDII .
BALAMUELI, AGED 49
R125
S/O.
COURI OMENA,
SANTHI BHAVEN, KOONYIII,
pARAvooR p.O. , KOI.Lzn4 -691301.
ADDL .
SUIAdA, AGED 45,
R126
D/O.GOURI OMAHA, SENTHI BHAVEN, KOONYIIi, PABA:V00R
P.0. , KOI.IiAM 691301.
THE LEGAL HEIRS 0F DECEASED 67TH RESPONDENT ARE IMPLEADED
AS ADDITIONAli RESPONDENTS 123 AND 126 VIDE 0REER DATED
2] / 3 / 2:5 T" TA T| / 24 .
By anvs.
MINI GANGADHARAN FOR R90 & R91
SRI.AliEXANDER GEORGE FOR R82
SRI.ABRAHAM GEORGE JACOB FOR R46
SRI . s .BIru KlzHAKKANELA
SRI.M.RAdENI>Rzn¢ NAIR FOR Rlo3 & 1o4
SRI.B.SURESH KumR FOR R89
SRI.StJENY ZACHARIA FOR R2, R3, R5, R6, R8, R10
SMT . M . SANTHY
SRI.SUNII-N.SHEN0I FOR R99, R100, R101 & R102
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
SRI.K.`v.vlNOD Foe R99, Rloo, Rlol & Rlo2
IHIS
RE GUIAR
HEARING/ORDERS
ON
F I RS I
APPEAII
14.02.2025,
DEI.IVERED TIIE FOI.LOWING :
THE
HAV.ING
COURT
COIE
UP
FOR
ON
27.03.2025
2 025 : KER : 2 610 6
BEA NO. 52 0F 2009
JUDGMENT
Defendants 72 to 74 in O.S.No.79/1989 on the files of Principal
Sub Court, Kollam have come up in the present appeal. Suit is for
partition, in].unction and consequenti.al reliefs.
2.
Thebrieffacts necessaryforthe disposal of the appeal, ,are
as follows:
The plaint A schedule property having an extent of 12 cents and
8 schedule property having an extent of lo cents originally belonged
to Paranthiyil Veylu Mangattu Family. The properties were given to
Anandan Raman as ottikuzhikanam- for a consideration of 14oo
pa7iam as per ottikuzhikanam document dated 3.12.1o78 M.E. The
properties were thus remaining in thei possession of Anandan Raman.
Anandan Raman died leaving behind his wife Kurumba and nine
children,
Kesavan,
Velu,
Neelakandan,
Krishnan,
Kochuupennu, Kunjamma, Ummini, Kun].ukali.
Gopalan,
The appellants
traced their title to the predecessor-in-interest, Karunakaran, who is
the son of Kunjukali.
'The plaintiffs are the legal heirs of ummini,
the 8th child of Anandan Raman and Kurumba. The .9th plaintiff is the
daughter of Kunjukali.
The 5th and 6th children, REshnan and
2025 : KER: 26106
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
Kunjamma, died issueless.
Kunjukali had four children, the 9th
plaintiff, the 26th defendant, Kalyani and Karunakaran. Karunakaran
is the 33rd defendant in the suit. The appellants, are the legal heirs of
Karunakaran, the 33rd defendant.
For a better appreciation of the
flow of title, the genealogy chart of the family is appended in this
judgment at page No.45.
3.
While so, the members ofthejoint family of the original
jenmi filed O.S No.134/1966 before the Munsiffs Court, Kollam
against plaintiffs 1 to 9 and defendants 1 to 36 in this .case for
redemption of the mortgage. In the said suit, the lst defendant and
the other children and grandchildren of Anandan Raman, who were
alive at the time of the institution of the suit, raised a plea that the
plaintiffs therein are not entitled to redeem and recover the plaint
schedule property thereunder. During the pendency of the suit, the
Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1964 was amended by Act 35 of 1969 and
by operation of Section 4A of the provisions of the said Act, which
came into force on 1.1.197o, the plaintiffs and defendants .1 to 36
obtained fixity of tenure over the plaint A and 8 Schedule properties.
Accordingly, O.S No.134/1966 was dismissed by the Munsiffs Court,
finding that the landlords are not entitled for redemption of the
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
property, since the defendants are entitled to fixity of tenure under
the provisions of the Kerala Land Reforms Act. Aggrieved by the
judgment and decree in O.S.No.134/1966, an appeal was preferred by
the jenmi family before the District Court, Kollam as A.S No.46/1972.
The appeal was also dismissed affirming the findings of the trial court.
Thus, the plaintiffs 1 to 9 and defendants 1 to 36, who are the legal
heirs of deceased Anandan Raman, were stated to have become
absolute owners of plaint A and 8 schedule properties and are being
continued as such.
4.
Going by the plaint averments, the children ofAnandan
Raman by name Kesavan, Velu, Neelakandan, Kochupennu, Ummini,
Kunjukali, Gopalan and Krishnan are entitled to 1/8 share each over
the plaint schedule properties.
The three shares entitled to,
Neelakandan, Krishnan and Gopalan and 1/8 share to Kochupennu
had been released by their legal heirs and, hence, defendants 2 to 7,
who are the children of Kesavan, have got 1/8 share in the plaint A
and 8 schedule properties. It is further contended that the lst plaintiff
and late Vidyadharan jointly got 1/8 share. The 1/8 share entitled to
Kunjukali devolved upon Nanu, Sarada (9th plaintifD, Gor^ri (26th
defendant), Kalyani and Karunakaran (33rd defendant). According to
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RNA NO. 52 0F 2009
the plaintiffs, defendants 8 to 12, who are children of Velu, had got
1/8 share and they had alienated their 1/8 share in the plaint 8
schedule property in favour of the 37th defendant in the case. Nanu,
S/o. Kunjukali died after his marriage and predeceased his wife.
Nanu, Sarada (9th plaintifD, Gowri and defendants 27 to 32, who are
the children of Kalyani, and the 33rd defendant had got 1/5 share in
the 1/8 share since Nanu died issueless. Thus, each of them have got
1/4 share in the 1/8 share. The lst plaintiff and the legal heirs of late
Vidyadharan, who are plaintiffs 2 to 8 and lo to 12, had got 1/8 share
jointly. It is further averred that Sarada, the 9th plaintiff, had got 1/4
share in 1/7 share, that is 1/28 share. It is further conten.ded that the
ist plaintiff had got 1/2 share in the 1/4 share and the plaintiffs 2 to 8
and lo to 12 got 1/2 share in 1/7 share, that is 1/14 share. Though the
plaintiffs had demanded the defendants 1 to 33 to join with them for
partition of the plaint schedule property, they did not accept it.
According to the plaintiffs, the 33rd defendant had constructed certain
shop rooms on the western side of the plaint schedule property
without the consent and knowledge of the plaintiffs and others. The
•defendants 38 to 49 are the tenants in the shop room and the 2nd
defendant is using the shop room in the plaint A schedule property
2 025 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
and making preparations ,for new constmctions in it disregarding the
residence of other co-owners. Therefore, according to the plaintiffs,
defendants 2 and 33 have no right to make any construction in the
plaint schedule properties since they are only co-owners of the same
along with the plaintiffs and other defendants`. Defendants 2 and 33
had filed separate whtten statements. The 37th defendant supported
the plea of the plaintiffs. The 33rd defendant contended that the plaint
schedule property does not belong to the plaintiffs. 'The suit was
instituted by the plaintiffs in collusion with the 37h defendant and his
brother, Saji, just to harass the defendants. The deceased Anandan
Raman had not obtained possession over the plaint 8 schedule
property by virtue of the ottikuzhikanam document.
ottikuzhikanam document is only `a purakkczdczm,
plaint 8 schedule property is concerned.
The
insofar as the
The plaint 8 schedule
property came into the possession of Anandan Raman only after lo81
M.E. In lo88 M.E Anandan Raman partitioned his property among
his children and shifted his residence to Parippally. Thereafter, it was
the mother and brothers Of the 33rd defendant, who were in
possession and enjoyment of the plaint 8 schedule property by
residing in the building in it. While so, the sister(s) of the 33.rd
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
defendant was/were married off by making use of his own funds. The
mother of the 33rd defendant died in the year 1943 and the marriages
of the younger sisters, including the 9th plaintiff, were conducted in
the year 1945. From 1945 onwards, the 33rd defendant is in absolute
possession and enjoyment of the plaint 8 schedule property by
residing in it along with his family and making improvements. The
brother of the 33rd defendant, Padmanabhan Nanu continued to
reside along with him and his family in the building in the plaint 8
schedule property and by 196o, he shifted his residence to Pulickal
veedu. After 1945, none of the sisters of the 33rd defendant have
resided in the house along with the 33rd defendant in the plaint 8
schedule property. Thus, plaint 8 schedule property remained in the
exclusive and absolute possession and enjoyment of the 33rd
defendant and his family ever since 1945. The 33rd defendant further
raised a plea that in the year 1974, he filed O.A.No.74/1974 before the
Ithikkara Land Tribunal, in which Raman Neelakantan, Raman
Krishnan, Raman Gopalan, Padmanabhan Nanu, Narayanan
Vidyadharan, Vasu, Raveendran, Velu Raghavan, K,unchali Gouri,
Kunchali Kallyani and Kunchali Sarada, who are the children and
grandchildren of deceased Anandan Raman, were impleaded as
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
respondents/ intermediari,es along with the members of the jenmi
family. Subsequendy, the said O.A was amended on knowing that the
right available to the 33rd defendant under the Ke`rala Land Reforms
Act is as a deemed tenant. Meanwhile, the Ithikkara Land Tribunal
was abolished, and the said O.A was transferred to the Kollam Land
Tribunal and renumbered as O.A No.5oo/1975, and by order in the
said O.A, the 33rd defendant obtained purchase certificate in respect
of the plaint 8 schedule property having an extent of 18 cents.
Therefore, it was specifically contended that once the purchase
certificate was issued, the 33rd defendant has absolute right, title, and
interest over the property. It was also contended that the right, if any,
of the plaintiffs had lost by adverse possession and ouster and,
therefore, the suit be dismissed.
5.
Onbehalfofthe plaintiffs, Exts.Al to A43 documents were
produced and marked. Exts.Bl to 814 were marked on the side of the
defendants. The report of the Advocate Commissioner was marked
as Ext.C1. PWs Jl to .3 were examined on behalf of the plaintiffs,
whereas DW.1 was examined on behalf of the defendants. On the basis
of the evidence and pleadings on record, the trial court framed the
following issues : -
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RNA NO. 52 0F 2009
"1)
Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of
necessaryparties?
Whether the plaint schedule properties are
available for partition?
3)
Whether the right if any of the plaintiffs and
othersoverplaintAschedulepropertyislostby
ouster and adverse possession of 2nd
defendant?
4)
Whether plaintiffs are taking any share in the
plaint schedule items?
l^7hether and defendant has made
substantial improvements in plaint A
schedule item No.1 as contained? If so,
whether he is entitled to any value of
improvements?
6)
Whether plaint B schedule property belongs to
33rd defendant alone?
Whether the 33rd defendant made valuable
improvements in plaint 8 schedule property, if
so whether 33rd defendant is entitled to get
value of improvements?
8)
Whether the suit is not maintainable?
9)
Whether 37th defendant entitled to get
partition and separate possession of his
share? If so what is his share'?
1o)
Whether injunction prayed for is allowable?
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
11)
6.
Reliefs and costs?"
On appreciation of evidence, the trial court came to the
conclusion that the 33rd defendant is not entitled to any absolute right
over the plaint schedule property, inasmuch as the possession of the
33rd defendant was only as that of the other co-owners. Therefore, the
court came to the conclusion that merely by obtaining purchase
certificate, the 33rd defendant will not get any absolute right, title and
interest over the property. The trial court further held that the
possession, if any, of the 33rd defendant is deemed to be as that of
other co-owners and, therefore, the 33rd defendant did not have any
absolute right over the property and hence, decreed the suit.
Aggrieved by the judgment and decree in O.S.No.79/1989, the
defendants 72 to 74 have preferred the present appeal.
7.
Heard Sri.S.V.Balakrishna Iyer, the learned Senior
Counsel, assisted by Smt.Aiswarya Mohan, appearing on behalf of the
appellants and Sri.Abraham George Jacob, the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the 46th respondent/37h defendant and
Sri.M.Rajendran Nair, the learned counsel appearing for respondents
lo3 and 104.
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
8.
Before proceeding to consider the rival submissions
raised across the bar, this Court finds that except the 37th defendant,
none of the legal heirs of the plaintiffs have contested the present
appeal. In the backdrop of the above facts, this Court proceeds to
analyse the rival submissions raised on behalf of the parties.
Sri.S.V.Balakrishna Iyer, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the appellants, submitted that as early as in the year 1966,
when the suit was instituted by the members of the jenmi family, the
33rd defendant and his parents were in exclusive possession. The
Munsiffs Court in O.S No.134/1966 had taken notice of the exclusive
claimofthe2nddefendantovertheplaintAschedulepropertyandthe
33rd defendant over the plaint 8 schedule property. After filing of O.A
No.33/1974 and after disposal of A.S No.46/1972, the 33rd defendant
obtained 4/8 share under Exts.A13 and A14 release deeds.
The
purchasecertificatehavingbeenissuedonl8.6.1976(Ext.82),thesuit
was instituted only on 14.3.1989, i.e. beyond 12 years of the issue of
the final order (Ext.A18) and the purchase certificate. In the light of
Exts.A13 and A14, even if it is assumed that the plaintiffs are entitled
to maintain the suit, they are not entitled for share to the extent as
ordered by the trial court. Out of the 8 sharers, four sharers have no
2.0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
claim because of Exts.A13 and A14. Out of the remaining, the legal
heirs of Kesavan do not have any claim or right in the plaint 8
schedule property.
As far as plaintiffs 2 to 8 and lo to 12 are
concerned, they are bound by Ext.A18 order because of their
predecessor, Vidyadharan, was a party to the proceedings, and he did
not file any appeal against the said order. None of the children of the
33rd defendant had raised any challenge to Ext.A18 since they did not
file any appeal against the same. Therefore, the 9th plaintiff is also
bound by the order passed by the land tribunal. He further pointed
out that plaintiff No.1 having been represented by her brother
Vidyadharan, shares of defendants 3 to 7 and 8 to 12 and plaintiff No.1
are also not allottable to them. Thus, th.e purchase certificate gives
absolute right and title over the plaint 8 schedule property to the
appellants.
It is further pointed out that in respect of plaint A
schedule item, the right of Kesavan had been recognised as early as in
the year 1944 in Ext.A4 partition deed of 1119 M.E by stating that the
property will be allotted to him without any improvements.
Concluding his submissions, the learned Senior Counsel also raised
the question of ouster, especially in the light of unimpeachable
evidence produced by the. appellants before the trial court. According
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
to the learned Senior Counsel, the findings rendered by the trial court
on the plea of ouster are erroneous and therefore, liable to be
interfered with by this Court.
9.
On the other hand, Sri.Abraham George Jacob, the
learned counsel appearing for the 46th respondent, contented that the
plaint schedule properties though originally belonged to Paranthiyil
Veylu, Mangattu family, the properties were mortgaged to Anandan
Raman as ottikuzhikanam. He reiterated the submissions on the
basis of the averments in the plaint. It is further contended by the
learned counsel that the 33rd defendant cannot claim exclusive right
over the property by virtue of the proceedings in O.A Nos.5oo/1975
and 733/1975.
According to him, Exts.82 and 84 purchase
certificates had been obtained by fraud and ignored as invalid and
inoperative.
Ext.82, according to the learned counsel, had been
obtained on the basis of Ext.A21 application filed by the 33rd
defendant and Ext.84 was issued on the basis of Ext.A23 application.
In Ext.A21, the landlord's name is given as Parameswaran Pillai and
the basis of the claim is Ext.A3 judgment and the ottikuzhikanam and
the other claimants mentioned are Raman, Neelakandan, Krishnan,
Gopalan, Ayyappan and Narayanan. The names\ and addresses of
2025 : KER: 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
defendants 1 to 36 had not been mentioned in either Exts.A2 or A3.
It is further pointed out that the persons who are entitled to the share
on the basis of Exts.A2 and A3 are not made parties in the O.A
proceedings and, therefore, the 33rd defendant is not entitled to claim
any absolute right. It is lastly submitted that, at any rate, Exts.82 and
84 will not affect the rights of the plaintiffs and the defendants. In
Exts.A4, A13 and A14, the 33rd defendant admitted the oodrkoor
rights of the others in the ottikuzhikanam and therefore, the
possession of the 33rd defendant is that of a co-owner and therefore,
the rights of other parties cannot be excluded. Insofar as the plea of
ouster is concerned, according to the learned counsel, though the plea
of ouster is tenable, it ought to have been supported by concrete
evidence. The trial court after appreciation of the evidence had found
that the plea of ouster cannot be sustained and therefore, had rightly
decreed the suit and thus he prayed that the appeal be dismissed by
confirming the judgment and decree of the trial court.
1o.
Shri M.Rajendran Nair, learned Counsel appearing for
respondents lo3 and 1o4 contended that they purchased the property
in the year 2oo6 from the predecessors of the appellants and that the
rights of co defendant was not decided ,in OS No.134 of 1966 and
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
REA NO. 52 0F 2009
hence the contention of the plaintiffs that they took the properties as
co tenant cannot be accepted. In fact, the learned counsel went to the
extent of stating that Late Anandan Raman did not get the property
by virtue of ottikuzhikanam and therefore question of application of
Section 2(39) of the Kerala Land Reforms Act 1964 does not arise. The
subsequent purchase being bona fide in nature, they are entitled to
equity.
11.
I have considered the rival submissions raised across the
bar and have perused. the records.
12.
On the basis of the rival pleadings raised across the bar, it
is imperative for this Court to decide, primarily, two issues;
(a)
Whether the 33rd defendanthad any absolute right or title
over plaint B schedule property by virtue of Ext.82 purchase
certificate?
(b)
If not, is the plea of the 33rd defendant on ouster
sustainable?
13. Before delving into the rival contentions, this Court is
reminded of the fact that respondents lo3 and lo4 being the
subsequent purchasers of the property after passing of the decree
cannot raise any contention other than one available to the
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
appellants. Of course, it is open for them to point out that the
plaintiffs are not entitled to any relief in the suit. In the above back
drop, this Court proceeds to consider the issues presented before it.
Decision of this Coulf on the first issue will determine the fate of this
appeal to a greater extent and if the decision is in favour of the
appellants, then the plea of ouster is mere academic,. However, if the
finding in the first issue is negative, still, the appellants ,could
successfully maintain ,a plea of ouster.
14. The appellants trace the devolution of their title towards 33rd
defendant in the suit. To apprecia.te the contention of the 33rd
defendant, it is important that an extensive consideration be
bestowed upon Ext.A2, the judgment and decree in O.S No.134/1966.
It must be borne in mind that the suit was initially instituted by the
members of the jenmi family for redemption of the mortgage. In the
aforesaid suit, it was specifically noticed by the Munsiff s Court,
Kollam that the defendants are entitled to fixity of tenure. Though
the said judgment was questioned before the appellate court in A.S
No.46/1972, the abpeal was also dismissed.
Therefore, it is an
indicative factor to prove that late Anandan Raman had obtained
possession of the property on the basis of the ottikuzhikanam.
2 025 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
15.,` Now, coming to the plea of the 33rd defendant that he has
absolute right over the property by virtue of the purchase certificate
issued by the land tribunal, certain unassailable facts must be
discussed by this Court. Ext.A4 is a partition deed between Kurumba,
W/o.deceased Anandan Raman, and eight children. As per Ext.A4
partition deed, the mortgage righ`t under Ext.Al was divided equally
among the eight children of Anandan .Raman with a specific right to
Kesavan, the father of the deceased 2nd defendant. Be that as it may,
when Ext.A4 partition deed was executed, Kunjukali was no more and
- the 33rd defendant did notjoin the partition deed and that other legal
heirs of deceased Kunjukali refused to join as parties to the partition
deed. It is pertinent to mention that the partition deed was executed
in the year 1119 ME. It is worthwhile to mention that the specific case
set up by the 33rd defendant is that he is in possession of the plaint 8
Schedule property from lo88 M.E. It is indisputable that the mo.ther
of Kamnakaran died in the year 1943 and in the same year the
partition deed Ext.A4 was executed.
So long as the legal heirs of
deceased Kunjukali did notjoin in execution of Ext.A4, the plaintiffs
cannot successfully maintain the plea that all the defendants in OS
No.134/1966 are tenants in common and Ext.A4 is binding on
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
defendant no.33. The contents of Ext.A4 will go a long way in
establishing the fact that the 33rd defendant was in exclusive
possession of the property. It is in this context, the findings of the
lower appellate court in A.S No.46 of 1972 has to be construed. The
33rddefendanthadaspecificpleathathehasgotfixityoftenurebased
on his possession as per Section 4A of the Kerala Land Reforms Act,
1964. This plea was accepted by the appellate court. The finding has
since become final. So, when the 33rd defendant set up a plea of
exclusive title over the property, the plaintiffs attempted to get over
the plea by raising a contention that going by Ext.A4, .all the
defendants in O.S No.134/1966 are tenants in common. The said plea
found favour with the trial court while decreeing the suit. In view of
the indisputable fact that neither late Kunjukali or her legal heirs
being parties to the partition deed, the contents of the same cannot
bind on them. Even assuming that Ext.A4 is binding on the 33rd
defendant owing to its peculiar nature of being a family arrangement,
this Court cannot bu.I notice the compelling facts that the plaintiffs 1
to 8 were allotted the 8th schedule whereas Late Kunjukali and her
legal heirs were set apart with the 9th item. The description of the 8
Schedule matches with that of the 9th Schedule of Ext.A4. It is beyond
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RNA NO. 52 0F 2009
one's comprehension as to how the plaintiffs could stake their claim
to 8 Schedule property, especially since they were allotted a share
under Ext A4. It must be borne in mind that the suit for partition is
not based on Ext.A4, but on the assertion that the plaintiffs are
tenants in common with that of the defendants. When a further
scrutiny of Ext.A4 is made, it becomes evident that Late Kurumba, the
predecessor in interest of Ummini under whom the plaintiffs 1 to 8
traced their title, reserved life interest only on items 1 to 8 in Ext.A4.
This leads a strong credence to the case set up by the 33rd defendant
that he is in exclusive possession of plaint 8 Schedule property. Still
further, the application before the land tribunal is on the basis of the
finding of the lower appellate court that he is a deemed mortgagee
under Section 4A of the Kerala Land Reforms Act.
If that be so,
inevitably, the finding of the trial court that all the defendants took
the plaint schedule properties as tenants-in-common cannot be
sustained. The fact that none of the heirs of Kunjukali was party to
the partition deed is a strong indication that the deceased Kunjukali
held the properties in exclusion to the others. The staunch silence on
the part of the plaintiffs from lo88 M.E (1943) till 1989 is also a strong
indication that the 33rd defendant was in exclusive possession of the
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
35'
plaint 8 Schedule property and, therefore, the finding to the contrary.
by the trial court is palpably wrong.
16.
As regards the application before the land tribunal is
concerned, the specific case set up by the 33rd defendant, Sri
Karunakaran, is that the lower appellate court had accepted his plea
that he had got a fixity of tenure under Section 4A of the Kerala Land
Reforms Act, 1964 and hence the application was maintainable. On
perusal of the Ext.A21 application in OA No.5oo of 1975 on the files
of Ithikkara Land Tribunal, it is evident that the 33rd defendant set up
his title based on the findings of the lower appellate court in A.S No.
46, of 1972. Still further, the devolution of title is sought to be traced
to his mother, Late Kunjukali, who came into possession of the
property from her father Late Anandan Raman by virtue of the
ottikuzhikanam in the year lo78 M.E„ When one analyses the finding
of the lower appellate court in A.S No.46 of 1972, the irresistible
conclusion is that the 33rd defendant is a mortgagee under the
ottikuzhikanam and is entitled to fixity of tenure under Section 4A of
the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1964 and thus the application was
perfectly maintainable. It must be borne in mind that in the light of
the recitals in Ext.A4, the property covered in items 1 to 9 allotted to
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
the parties is in the nature of "oodrkoor". Exts.A13 andA14 release
deeds were executed in favour of the 33rd defendant. It is in this
context that this Court finds considerable force in the submissions of
the learned Senior Counsel, Shri S.V.Balakrishna Iyer, that the 33rd
defendant had impleaded the heads of the 7 branches and his own
brother in OA No.5oo/1975, which led to an order in his favour and
theconsequentpurchasecertificate.Itispertinenttomentionthatthe
father of the 3rd plaintiff, Sri.Vidhyadaran, was a party to O.A No.5oo
of 1975 and that the order passed by the tribunal is thus binding on
the legal heirs. No case of fraud or collision is urged before this Court.
Furthermore, none of the plaintiffs have chosen to appear before this
Court and contest the appeal on merits.
17.
Although
the
learned
Counsel
for
the
46th
respondent/defendant no.37 vehemently pointed out that a reading
of Exts.A13 and A14 will disprove the plea of exclusive possession set
up by defendant no.33 and that the contents of Exts.A13 and A14 will
gotoshowthattheexecutants,thereinhadtherightofinheritanceand
hence the cla.im of exclusive possession is disproved. However, this
Court is not in a position to accept the argument. The necessity to
execute Exts.A13 and A14 documents itself is beyond one's
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
comprehension, especially when parties were allotted respective
shares in Ext.A4 partition deed. But even if it is assumed that the
parties therein wanted to reduce their bargain into whting, they were
perfectly entitled to do so. Still further a close reading of Ext.A13
document shows that the exclusive possession of the 33rd defendant `
and his mother over the plaint 8 Schedule property is accepted by the
vendors therein. The plaintiffs or as a matter of fact the 37th defendant
cannot eschew a .portion of Exts.A13 and A14 and project only those
parts which are in their favour. When Exts.A13 and A14 are read as a
whole, the irresistible conclusion is that the 33rd defendant has
successfully proved his possession over the plaint 8 Schedule
property in exclusion to others.
18. The learned counsel, Sri Abraham George Jacob, further
asserted before this Court that there can be no adverse possession
against a co owner. In support of his contention, he relied on the
decisions of this Court in Joy Kuriakose Vs Kulakose [2ol5
KHC 2o] and John.P (dead) Vs P.J.George (dead) [2o24
KHC 7176]. This Court has no doubt regarding the proposition
canvassed by the leamed Counsel for the 37th defendant. But the
pertinentquestioninthiscaseisnotregardingadversepossessionbut
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
ouster. Have the appellants succeeded in proving the same? The
following discussion will ultimately take this Court to the conclusion.
19. The rule regarding what constitutes an ouster of a co-sharer
from the joint property is well settled by the decision of Their
Lordships of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in a case
which went from Ceylone. In Thomas v. Thomas [1855 (2) K&J
79], it was held that possession is never considered adverse if it can
be referred to as a lawful title. To succeed on the ground of ouster,
the person setting up ouster is bound to show that he did set up
adverse or independent title during the period, which was beyond the
statutory period of 12 years.
2o.
The uninterrupted sole possession of such property,
without more, must be referred to the lawhl title possession by the
joint holder to use the joint estate, and cannot adversely claim against
other interested members. The possession may be either lawful or
unlawful, in the absence of evidence, it must be assumed to be the
former. While deciding the question of ouster or exclusion from the
joint property in true route what is deducible is that there can be no
adverse possession by one co-sharer as against others until there is an
ouster or exclusion and that the possession of the co-sharers becomes
2 025 : KER: 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
adverse to another co-sharer from the moment when there is ouster.
That is after the assertion of an ouster title by one co-sharer against
the other and to the knowledge of the latter.
21..
In Govindammal v. R.Perumal chettiyar.& Others
I(2oo6) 11 SCC 6oo], the Supreme Court held that a co-sharer
becomes constructive trustees of the other co-sharers and the right of
a person or its predecessor in interest is deemed to have been
protected by the trustees.
In order to prove ouster and adverse
possession against the co-sharer, the following relevant factors have
to be taken into consideration:
(i)Exclusive possession and perception of profits for well
over the period prescribed by the law of limitation;
(ii)
Dealings by the party in possession treating the
properties as exclusively belonging to him;
(iii)
The means of excluded co-sharer of knowing that
his title has been denied by the co-owner in possession.
22.
Again, in Des Raj & Ors vs Bhagat Ram (Dead) By
Lrs. & Ors I(2oo7) 9 SCC.'641], the Supreme Court considered the
issue of adverse 'possession and ouster in suits relating to partition. It
was held that a plea of adverse possession or a plea of ouster would
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RNA NO. 52 0F 2009
indisputably be governed by Articles 64 and 65 of the Limitation Act.
Mere assertion of the title by itself may not be sufficient unless the
pardes prorve cminis possidend±.
23.
In B.R.Patflv. TulsaYsawkar &Others [2o22 SCC
OnLine SC 24o], the Supreme Court had occasion to consider the
plea of ouster in a wider perspective and it was held that the very
essence of adverse possession and therefore ouster lies in a party
setting up a hostile title in himself. The possession of a co-owner is
ordinarily on his behalf and also on behalf of the entire body of the
co-owners. In the case of an ouster, the co-owner must indeed have
the hostile animus. He must assert a title which is not referable to a
lawhl title.
24.
Based on the principles expoundedby the supreme court
in the aforesaid decisions, it becomes imperative for this Court to
deduce the evidence that is adduced in the present case to consider
the plea of ouster in a deeper perspective. Apart from the evidence in
the present case, the pleadings of the 33rd defendant in the written
statement show that 12 shop rooms were coristructed by the 33rd
defendant after issuance of the purchase certificate and the same were
let out. The plaintiffs have no case that at any point of time prior to
2 02 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO.. 52 0F 2009
the institution of the suit, they had demanded any share of the rent
that was derived from the shop rooms. A reading of Ext.A2 judgment
shows that the averment of the 33rd defendant herein who was a party
to the suit, that he is in .exclusive possession of the plaint 8 schedule
property and the house constructed therein is not seen disputed
seriously by either Vidyadharan, the predecessor in interest of the
plaintiffs or any other person. The house, which was the subject
matter of the proceedings in O.S No.134/1966, was demolished and
re-constructed in 1977, and thereafter, fou`r` shop rooms were built in
the year 1978. Either immediately after the ].udgment was rendered
in O.S No.134/1966 or within the statutory period of limitation of 12
years before the date of filing of the suit in the year 1989, it appears
that none of the parties had come forward with any claim for share in
the plaint schedule properties. It was only when the legal heirs of the
33rd defendant started construction of the building in the year 1988,
the suit was filed.
25.
One additional fact which would prompt this Court to
hold in favour of the appellants on the plea of ouster is Exts.Cl and
C1(a) reports. The report of the advocate tcommissioner shows that
the building was constructed earlier and it is pretty old at the time of
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RNA NO. 52 0F 2009
his visit. Therefore, there is a clear indication that the building was in
existence immediately after the Ext.82 purchase certificate was
obtained.
26.
Before concluding finally on the issue ofouster, this court
needs to take note of the contention raised on behalf of the 37th
defendant. No doubt, the learned counsel is right in contending that
mere nonparticipation in the rent and in profits of the land of a Cosharer does not amount to ouster and give. title by adverse possession
to the other co-sharers. But, this Court cannot ignore the fact that
none of the plaintiffs have come forward to contest the appeal on
merits and it is only the 37th defendant is contesting the case. This,
gives a strong indication that the plaintiffs have instituted the suit
solely at the instance of the 37h defendant for the purpose of
harassing the appellants.
27. With 'these impelling facts, when this Court proceeds to test
the findings of the trial court,` the inescapable conclusion is that the
trial court misdirected itself to, the entire issues ''by pining down the
appellants to the findings of the trial court in OS No.134/1966. In the
considered view of this Court, the findings in OS No.134/1966 having
merged into the findings in A.S No.46 of 1972, the trial court went
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
wrong in holding that since defendants were tenants in common, the
application filed by the 33rd defendant was for the benefit' of all
tenants in common and the purchase certificate issued in his favour
will inure to the benefit of all others. The primary concern of this
Court was to see whether the appellants have discharged the burden
and proved that they were in exclusive possession of the property to
the knowledge of others. The contents of Exts.A4, A13 and A14 and
other evidence show that the appellants have discharged the burden.
Therefore, this Court finds that the plea of ouster insofar as the plaint
8 schedule property in which the appellants are in possession must
be sustained. This is more so when as regards plaint A schedule
property, there is no challenge by the aggrieved party against the
judgment and decree of the trial court.
As an upshot of these discussions, this Court is of the considered
view that the trial court erred egregiously in decreeing the suit insofar
as the plaint 8 schedule property is concerned. Therefore, this Court
isleftwithnootheralternative,buttointerferewiththejudgmentand
decree of the trial court. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The
judgmentanddecreeofthetrialcourI,insofarastheplaint8schedule
property is concerned, in O.S No.79/1989 is set aside and the suit will
2 0 2 5 : KER : 2 610 6
RFA NO. 52 0F 2009
stand dismissed as against the plaint 8 schedule property. No order
as to costs.
Sd/-
EaswA~s.
JUDGE
-,
¢FA ulo. 5c2
B`
`r.fa`t=..a`,
•L
aa
\i
t+
EBE=
5dr
g
5dr£.a
Bc}
8€
9.g.S! a.
®`\-E'-
5`.E.=.
:*
}
8=t}--fLI,rE;`-tJ
b,.roeB
i+af=
®=tJ
GELt=..--a.
t=
*.
•8+
gi-.
B?B.. 9.J
•-
B
tr¥
Ei,
E+
g',iE`-`P
rB.'-
§.
a
!i: §s
ga
•apgtB
I,
E'!
E+
-tra 9.i.
E:
ii
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review