Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 12th JULY, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RSA No.02 of 2016
Appellant
:
Shri K. B. Bhandari,
S/o Late Amber Singh Bhandari,
Aged about 53 years,
R/o Malbasey,
Soreng,
West Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Pro-forma Respondent :
Shri Laxuman Limboo,
S/o Late Til Bahadur Limboo,
R/o Tharpu,
West Sikkim.
Shri Naval Kishore (Das) Chettri,
S/o Late Bhuwan Singh Chettri,
R/o Tharpu,
West Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 100 read with Section
151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Udai P. Sharma, Advocate with Mr. Anup Gurung, Advocate
for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and
Mr. Suraj Chhetri, Advocates for the Respondent No.1.
None for Respondent No.2.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Appeal arises out of the impugned Judgment of the
learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok, in Title Appeal No. 2
of 2015, dated 9.6.2016, which in turn arose out of the impugned
Judgment and Decree of the learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim at
Gangtok, in Title Suit No. 9 of 2014 dated 30.4.2015.
2.
The
learned
Appellate
Court,
vide
its
impugned
Judgment confirmed the findings of the learned Civil Judge, East
Sikkim, hence this Second Appeal which was admitted on the
following substantial question of Law.
“Whether in arriving in its findings, the Judgment of the
First Appellate Court has ignored the material evidence
on record?”
3.
In order to understand the matter in its correct
perspective, it is essential to briefly advert to the facts of the case.
The appearance of the parties before the learned Trial Court was as
follows;
The Appellant before the First Appellate Court and herein, was
the Defendant No.1. The Respondent No.1 was the Plaintiff, while
the Pro-forma Respondent herein was the Defendant No.2. The
parties shall be addressed herein in terms of their appearance
before this Court. As the Defendant No.3 before the learned Trial
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
Court is not a party to this Appeal, he shall be referred to as
Defendant No.3.
4.
It was averred by the Respondent No.1 before the
learned Trial Court that he is the son of Til Bahadur Limboo, who
owned landed property, which included Plot No. 250 and 251 under
Khatiyan No. 25, having an area of 1.20 acres and 0.38 acres
respectively at Tharpu Block, Soreng, West Sikkim. In the year
1979, Til Bahadur Limboo sold out a portion of land from Plot No.
250, measuring an area of 0.15 acres equivalent to 0.0600 hectare
to late Phip Raj Limboo. Phip Raj Limboo in turn, in 1983, sold the
aforesaid land measuring 0.15 acres to the Appellant, by which time
the Plot Number was renumbered as 329 and the area measured in
hectares. The sold land did not share any boundary with the Naya
Bazaar Sombaria road. After a few years of such purchase, the
Appellant started encroaching on another plot of land belonging to
Til Bahadur Limboo, being Plot No. 324 and into the unsold portion
of Plot No.329. The Appellant, after purchasing the land from Phip
Raj Limboo, interpolated the Sale Deed document, Exhibit D-1-1,
executed between him and late Phip Raj Limboo, thereby increasing
the area of land purchased by him to 0.19 acres equivalent to
0.0780 hectare, instead of 0.15 acres equivalent to 0.0600 hectare,
actually purchased by him. He then sold a portion of the land from
Plot No. 329 to the Pro-forma Respondent in the year 1999, who
also started encroaching upon Plot No. 324 of the
land of the
Respondent No.1 and the unsold portion of Plot No.329, hence the
Respondent No.1, inter alia, sought the following reliefs;
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
5.
“a)
a decree declaring that the suit land is the
integral part of plot No. 324 and unsold
portion of plot No. 329 belonging to the
plaintiff and the plaintiff has right, title and
interest over the suit land.
b)
a decree directing the defendant No.1 and 2
for vacating the Schedule land and to hand
over the same to the plaintiff.
c)
a decree for removal/demolition of the
structure put up by the defendant No.1 and 2
upon the suit land.
d)
a decree for nullifying and canceling the
interpolation made in the sale deed of the
Defendant No.1 and/or 2 and resultant
direction to the defendant No.3 to make
correction of the said documents along with
the mutated records of right of defendant No.1
and/or 2, if any.
e)
a decree directing the defendant No.1 and 2 to
pay a compensation of Rs.50,000/- to the
plaintiff for the damages caused to the suit
land.
f)
the cost of this title suit may be awarded to
the plaintiff.
g)
any other relief or relieves as the plaintiff may
be found entitled to under the law."
The Appellant for this part averred that his land is
covered by Khasra No. 329/684 and he had originally purchased
0.0780 hectare of land from Plot No.329. That, the boundaries
mentioned by the Respondent No.1 in the Plaint are incorrect, as the
Northern boundary extended up to the Naya Bazaar Sombaria road.
According to him, he retained 0.0080 hectare from Plot No. 329 for
his own use, after selling the larger portion to Pro-forma Respondent
and therefore, has been in possession since the year 1983 i.e. more
than 12 years and has perfected his right, title and interest over the
Suit property by way of adverse possession.
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
6.
The Pro-forma Respondent denied and disputed the
claims of the Respondent No.1 and claimed to have purchased
0.0700 hectare from the Appellant in the year 1999 vide a
registered Sale Deed, duly registered in the office of the SubRegistrar, Soreng, West Sikkim. Hence, the question of encroaching
upon the land of the Respondent No.1, does not arise.
7.
The Defendant No.3, the Sub-Registrar/Sub-Divisional
Officer (not a party in this Appeal) for his part, averred that he had
no role to play in the interpolation of documents as alleged.
8.
The learned Trial Court on the basis of the pleadings of
the parties settled the following Issues for determination.
“a)
Whether the suit land/schedule land belongs to the
Plaintiff and the Plaintiff has right, title and interest
over it?
b)
Whether Defendants no.1 and 2 are liable to vacate
the suit land and to hand over the possession of the
same to the Plaintiff? And if so, whether the
Defendants no. 1 and 2 are liable to remove/demolish
the structure upon the suit land?
c)
Whether the sale deed of Defendants no. 1 and 2
have been interpolated rendering the same null and
void. If so, whether Defendant No.3 is required to
make correction of records of right (Sale deed and
mutation records) of the Defendants no.1 and 2 visa-vis the Plaintiff?
d)
Whether the suit has been under valued or not?
e)
Whether the Defendants No.1 and 2 are liable to pay
compensation to the Plaintiff for the damage of the
suit land?
f)
Whether the Defendant No.1 has acquired right, title
and interest over the suit property measuring 0.0780
hectares by virtue of the Principles of Adverse
Possession?
g)
Any other reliefs, as the Plaintiff is entitled to?”
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
9.
The Respondent No.1 examined himself as P.W.1 and
two other witnesses i.e. P.W.4 and P.W.5 in support of his case but
dropped his witnesses, P.W.2 and P.W.3, before the learned Trial
Court. The Appellant examined himself as D.W.1 and three others
i.e. D.W.2, D.W.3 and D.W.4 in support of his case. Pro-forma
Respondent examined himself as D.W.1 and two other witnesses.
10.
The learned Trial Court took up Issues (a) and (f)
together and considered Exhibit 1 to Exhibit 6, Exhibit 14, Exhibit
15, Exhibit D-1-1 and the evidence of the witnesses and concluded
that the evidence and documents on record establishes that the
Appellant and the Pro-forma Respondent, herein, had encroached
upon the land of the Respondent No.1, being 0.08 acres in Plot Nos.
324 and 329. It was also found that the Appellant could not show
that he had perfected his title by way of adverse possession. For
Issue (b), it was found that the Appellant and the Pro-forma
Respondent are liable to remove/demolish any existing structure
over the encroached portion of the Suit land. In Issue (c), the Court
concluded that there appeared to be corrections made in Exhibit D1-1, without following the mandate of the Registration Rules and
there
is
encroachment
by
the
Appellant
and
the
Pro-forma
Respondent upon the land of the Respondent No.1. Thus, the
records of right maintained in respect of Plot Nos. 324 and 329 be
corrected accordingly. The Suit was not undervalued as per the
finding in Issue (d). While discussing Issue (e), the learned Trial
Court did not deem it appropriate to impose compensation on the
Appellant and the Pro-forma Respondent, as the demolition, removal
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
of the structure and restoration of the Suit property to its original
form would suffice as compensation. Hence, the Suit of the
Respondent No.1 was decreed accordingly.
11.
The Appellant being aggrieved by the said Judgment was
in Appeal before the Court of the learned District Judge, East Sikkim
at Gangtok. The learned Appellate Court taking into consideration
the entire evidence and documents relied on by the parties,
concluded that the actual area of land sold by the Respondent
No.1‟s father to Phip Raj Limboo was 0.15 acres, equivalent to
0.0600 hectare. When this was the factual position, the question of
Phip Raj Limboo selling 0.0780 hectare did not arise. The learned
Appellate Court took into consideration Exhibits C-1 to C-5 and
concluded that the veracity of the documents were not free from
uncertainty and thereafter confirmed the findings of the learned
Trial Court.
12.
Before this Court, it is urged by learned Counsel for the
Appellant, that, the Appellant on 22.11.1983, purchased the Suit
land measuring 0.0780 hectare, as per the new survey operations
enforced from 17.1.1984, belonging to and recorded in the name of
the vendor, one Phip Raj Limboo. However, the learned District
Judge ignored the documents marked as Exhibits C-1, C-2, C-3, C-4
and C-5, produced by the P.W.4 Shri I.B. Limboo, which clearly
establishes that Plot No. 329, measuring 0.0780 hectare, was
recorded in the name of late Phip Raj Limboo. The Appellant after
purchasing it, mutated the land in his name vide Mutation Order
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
dated 19.04.1991, as borne out by Exhibit D-1-1, the Sale Deed
document executed between the two persons.
13.
It was expostulated by learned Counsel for the Appellant
that the learned District Judge erred in considering the statements
allegedly given by witnesses before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Soreng, when the statements had not been proved in accordance
with law. The cross-examination of P.W.-4 was also ignored, as
according to the witness, the Appellant was absent at the time of
spot verification and the report was prepared without consulting the
Sale Deed document of Phip Raj Limboo but was allegedly based on
the Survey Map and Khatiyan Register. That, this evidence is
falsified, as the Khatiyan Register reflects that the vendor‟s land
covers an area of .0780 hectare. That, the First Appellate Court
erred in holding that the Appellant had encroached an area
measuring 0.08 acres in Plot No. 324 and 329, as Plot No. 324 did
not exist after 17.1.1984 and Plot No. 329 was already converted to
hectares. That, the findings of the learned District Judge are
perverse, as the Land Records of 1951 ceased to be in operation
since 17.1.1984, when the new Land Records were enforced. To
substantiate this argument reliance was placed on S. R. Tewari vs.
Union of India , where while dealing with “perverse findings” it was
held that findings of fact are perverse if arrived at by ignoring or
excluding relevant material. That, the observation of the District
Judge that the Trial Court had rightly relied on Section 10 of the
Sikkim State Rules, Registration of Document, 1930, is erroneous,
(2013) 6 SCC 602
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
as the said Rule does not apply to documents which have already
been accepted for registration. Besides, the learned Court also erred
in holding that the Appellant being unsuccessful in establishing his
case on title, would not be permitted to raise a contradictory claim
on adverse possession. That, the findings of the learned District
Judge, that the possession of the Appellant over the Suit property
was not uninterrupted is perverse as the averments of the
Respondent No.1 and his evidence indicate that shortly after the
registration and mutation, the Appellant fenced the entire land with
wires and constructed an Ekra house, hence it is prayed that the
impugned Judgment and Decree dated 9.6.2016, be set aside.
14.
To substantiate his submissions, learned Counsel for the
Appellant placed reliance on Sashidhar and Others vs. Ashwini Uma
Mathad and Another . Reliance was also placed on S. R. Tewari vs.
Union of India
with Contempt Petition (C): S. R. Tewari vs. R. K. Singh
and Another. While
forwarding the contention that Exhibits „C1‟ to
„C5‟ were totally ignored by the Learned Trial Court while reaching
its findings, thereby leading to a decision which is perverse, which
therefore, can be set aside, support was taken from the decisions of
Damodar Lal
Another
vs. Sohan Devi and Others3, Krishnan vs. Backiam and
and Easwari vs. Parvathi and Others5. Reliance was also
placed on Vinod Kumar vs. Gangadhar6.
(2015) 11 SCC 269
(2016) 3 SCC 78
(2007) 12 SCC 190
(2014) 15 SCC 255
(2015) 1 SCC 391
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
15.
Per contra, it was the contention of learned Senior
Counsel for the Respondent that, in the first instance, the learned
Trial Court has not ignored any substantial evidence placed before it
and in Second Appeal, facts cannot be taken into consideration.
That, the new records which are in hectares ought to have reflected
the equivalent of 0.15 acres i.e. 0.0600 hectare but the land
recorded in the name of the Appellant is in excess of his purchase
and reflected as 0.0780 hectare. A perusal of the impugned
Judgment would indicate that the Trial Court as well the First
Appellate Court have considered all necessary evidence and the
submission of the Appellant that there was no cross-examination
conducted on the Sub-Divisional Magistrate‟s report is clearly
misplaced and erroneous. Exhibit C1, Exhibit C-2 and Exhibit C-3
have been prepared on the basis of the Sale Deed, Exhibit D-1-1,
which is incorrect, as a consequence, the other documents are
incorrect as well. That, Exhibit D-1-1, the Sale Deed executed
between Phip Raj Limboo and the Appellant, has been considered by
the Trial Court which reveals that in the line “Khatiyan Plot
No./Nos.”, the numerical „329‟ in English has been inserted after
scoring out the numerical „250‟, written in Nepali. The area i.e. .15
decimal Sukhabari which had been written in Nepali, has also been
scored out and “.0780 hac” inserted, but there is no revelation as to
who was responsible for the corrections. Exhibit 6 reveals that the
Office is unaware of the interpolation on Exhibit D-1-1. Hence, the
concurrent findings of the learned Courts below ought not to be
disturbed.
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
16.
I have heard learned Counsel at length and given due
consideration to their submissions. I have also perused the entire
records of the case including the evidence, documents and the
impugned Judgment.
17.
The argument that, the District Judge ignored the fact
that the Plot No.329 bearing .0780 hectare, as per the new survey
operation which came into force from 17.1.1984, and was mutated
in the name of the Appellant vide Mutation Order dated 19.4.1991,
is incorrect, as the Appellate Court has considered the evidence and
documents on record and elaborately discussed it from Paragraph
28 to Paragraph 36 of the impugned Judgment.
18.
The contention that the Appellate Court ignored Exhibits
C-1 to C-5, meets the same fate as above, since Paragraph 41 of
the impugned Judgment discusses these documents.
19.
Exhibit C-3, which is a „Khatiyan‟, reveals that an area
measuring .0780 hectare in Plot No. 329 is recorded in the name of
the Appellant, it may be pointed out that undeniably the transaction
between Phip Raj Limboo and the
Appellant took place on
22.11.1983. If this be so then the endorsements on the document
Exhibit C-3, which reads variously as, “Tailed (sic, Tallied)”,
“Retelied (sic, Retallied)” and “Copied by” different officials, i.e.,
Surveyors, purportedly of the office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Soreng on 18.6.1981, defies logic. It is indeed baffling as to how the
property came to be recorded in the name of the Appellant in 1981,
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
as reflected in Exhibit C-3, when the sale transaction took place two
years later in 1983. I cannot help but remark that the situation in
Exhibit C-3 is identifiable to the limerick of a “Young lady named
Bright”. I refrain from reproducing the same herein but it is evident
that Exhibit C-3 reflects registration of the land in the Appellant‟s
name, prior to him having purchased it, which goes without saying
is an incongruous situation. In this context, we may also peruse
Exhibit D-1-1, the Sale Deed executed between Phip Raj Limboo and
the Appellant, which fortifies the position that the sale transaction
actually took place on 22.11.1983, which is also the date of cash
payment.
The
document
was
presented
for
registration
on
28.1.1985 and registered compulsorily on 20.12.1986. It is indeed
unfathomable as to how Exhibit C-3 could indicate the Appellant‟s
ownership in 1981, two years before the purchase of the land by
him, from Phip Raj Limboo. Besides, both Courts below have
reached a concurrent finding that the plot number on Exhibit D-1-1
has been altered from Plot No. 250 to Plot No. 329 and the area
from 0.15 decimals to 0.0780 hectare, but no one has been able to
enlighten the Courts as to on whose behest the alterations were
inserted or who scribed the alterations and why no witness was
examined in this regard to clarify the matter. Further, I do not find
any error in the conclusion of both Courts below that the mandate of
the Sikkim State Rules, Registration of Document, 1930 have not
been complied with. The Sikkim State Rules, Registration of
Document, 1930 at Rule 10 lays down that;
“10. All interlineations, erasures or alterations
appearing in the document must be attested by the
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
parties to it with their signatures before the said
documents could be accepted for registration.”
Clearly, this has not been complied with in Exhibit D-1-1 and
there are no signatures of the parties after the alterations were
made, raising a doubt about the motive of such alterations, the
records being devoid of any details in this context. The Appellant, in
his evidence, has admitted that he is unaware as to who made the
fresh insertions pertaining to the Plot Number and area of the Suit
land after deleting the original insertions. The argument of the
Appellant that the said Rules would not apply to cases which have
already been accepted for registration is not tenable, nor backed by
any legislation.
20.
We may pertinently refer to Exhibit 5, which is a Notice
dated 19.12.1978, issued by the Registrar, West District, Gyalshing,
giving Notice to all concerned that Til Bahadur Limboo of Tharpu
Block was selling his land bearing Plot No.250 measuring 0.15
decimals situated at Tharpu Block to Phip Raj Limboo of the same
place for Rs.2600/- (Rupees twenty-six hundred) only. This Notice
dispels all doubts with regard to the measurement of the land in
dispute, since Phip Raj Limboo evidently purchased 0.15 decimals
from Til Bahadur Limboo and obviously he could not have sold an
area more than what he had purchased. Besides, Exhibit 6, which is
a Note-Sheet of the Sub Divisional Officer, Soreng Sub-Division,
West Sikkim, is clear that the land sold out by Til Bahadur Limboo to
Phip Raj Limboo was 0.15 decimals vide copy of Registration No. 84
dated 03.03.1979 in the old Land Records, before the general
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
survey operation of 1981 commenced. The disputed land was resold
to the Appellant by Phip Raj Limboo, vide copy of Registration Book
No. A, Vol. No. II and Item No. 164 dated 19.12.1986, wherein an
area of 0.15 decimals, dry land has been mentioned on the Sale
Deed document, from the newly recorded Plot No. 329 pertaining to
the disputed plot of land.
21.
As Exhibit C-3 cannot be relied on, as a corollary the
question of Exhibit C-4, vide which an area of 0.0700 hectares is
purported to be mutated in the name of the Pro-forma Respondent
from the Appellant is an unbelievable document. Although, it is
submitted that Exhibits C-1 to C-2 are true copies of the „Khatiyan‟
but in the absence of explanation to the entries in Exhibit C-3, the
two documents have to be taken with a pinch of salt. It was alleged
that the Appellant was not at the spot during verification, a careful
perusal of the evidence on record more especially of P.W.4, would
reveal that no question was put to the witness on this count.
Contrary to the allegation of the Appellant, it is also relevant to
point out that the learned District Judge has in fact not considered
the statement of the witnesses before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Paragraph 36 of his Judgment would stand testimony to this. The
said Paragraph reads as;
“36. However, I agree with Learned Counsel for the
appellant that it was not proper for the Learned trial
Court to rely in the statement of PW-2 (Dhan Maya
Subba) and 3 (Bhim Bahadur Nimbang), reportedly
made before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Soreng.
As the statement of PW-2 and PW-3 were not tested
under cross-examination and as the plaintiff had
dropped the said witnesses (vide Order dated
17.05.2012), Learned trial Court should not have
relied in their statement (marked Exhibit-14 and
Exhibit-15) respectively. Nevertheless, as it is clear
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
that the area of land sold by the plaintiff’s father to
Phip Raj Limboo was 0.15 acre or 0.060 hectare, I do
not find that dropping PW-2 and PW-3 by the plaintiff
would cause any impact in the merits of the case.”
22.
The findings of the learned Appellate Court that the
Appellant has not been able to make out a case for adverse
possession, suffers from no infirmity. The Appellant‟s claim on the
Suit property is based on title, on the basis of documents as already
discussed. The concept of adverse possession is in opposition to a
claim under title, the two claims cannot either be parallel or
simultaneous.
23.
With regard to the records of 1951 not being valid, we
may peruse Notification No. 991/D.D.L.R. dated 17th January, 1984,
which reads as follows;
“………………………………………………………………………………………
…………….It is hereby notified for the information of
general public that the old Land Records of 1951
which was in existence in the state of Sikkim shall
cease to be in operation and new Land Record shall
come into force with immediate effect.
………………………………………………………………………………………”
The
Land
Records
prior
to
1984,
was
in
acres
and
subsequently on converting the measurements to hectares, this
Notification fell in place. However, it does not mean that the Land
Records
of
corroborating
the
have
been
possession
shut
of
out
for
property
the
held
purposes
by
of
different
individuals, the subsequent records can be verified from the 1951
Land Records.
RSA No.02 of 2016
Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman Limboo and Another
24.
Keeping in view the aforesaid facts and discussions, no
other conclusion emerges, save that, the Judgment of the First
Appellate Court has not ignored the material evidence on record. I,
therefore, find no reason to hold differently from the findings of the
learned Trial Court and the First Appellate Court, finding no infirmity
therein.
25.
Appeal dismissed.
26.
No order as to costs.
27.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Court of the
learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok.
28.
Records be remitted forthwith.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
12.07.2017
Approved for reporting :Yes
Internet :Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review