Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
…
SWP No. 2189/2010
Reserved on: 06.07.2026
Pronounced on: 10.07.2026
Uploaded on: 10.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Jyoti Devi, w/o Kewal Krishan
R/o anandpur, P.O. Utterbeni,
Tehsil and District Samba, Age
26 years.
…….Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Ankesh Chandel, Advocate
Versus
1. State of J&K through
Secretary to Govt. Education
Deptt. Civil Sectt. Srinagar.
2. Director School Education,
Jammu.
3. Chief Education
Samba.
Officer,
4. Zonal Educational Officer,
Purmandal.
5. Poonam Sharma, W/o Sh.
Prakash Sharma R/o Ward
No. 4, Anandpur (Utterbeni)
Tehsil and District Samba.
…..Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
Mr. Rakesh Sharma, Adv. for R-5
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner has filed the instant writ petition seeking quashing of the
panel prepared by the Zonal Education Officer, Purmandal, wherein
SWP No. 2189/2010
the name of respondent No. 5 has been included for engagement as
Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT) Teacher for Village Anandpur, as well as
setting aside the engagement order dated 30.08.2010, whereby
respondent No. 5 came to be engaged as a ReT Teacher. The petitioner
has further seeks a direction to the official respondents to reframe the
panel for Village Anandpur by including the name of the petitioner
therein, by giving preference in terms of Government Order No. 288Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009, on the ground that she resides within the
distance of 100 meters from the school. A further direction has also
been sought for commanding the official respondents to issue the order
of engagement in favour of the petitioner after considering the
objections submitted by her within the prescribed time. The petitioner
has also prayed for restraining the official respondents from giving
effect to the engagement order issued in favour of respondent No. 5.
2.
The petitioner primarily assails the selection panel and the subsequent
engagement of respondent No. 5 as a ReT Teacher in New Primary
School, Anandpur, on the ground of residential proximity. The
petitioner resides within a distance of 100 meters from the subject
school, thereby claiming a preferential right to engagement vis-à-vis
respondent No. 5, who allegedly resides more than two kilometers
away. In support of this claim for preferential consideration, the
petitioner has relied upon Government Order No. 288-Edu of 2009
dated 08.04.2009.
3.
It is further contended that the petitioner submitted timely
objections/representations before the official respondents, explicitly
SWP No. 2189/2010
asserting that the panel was prepared in flagrant violation of the
mandate, spirit, and guidelines of the ReT Scheme. However, without
considering these objections, the official respondents arbitrarily
engaged respondent No. 5. Furthermore, relying on the report of the
concerned Naib Tehsildar, the petitioner contends that the population of
Village Anandpur exceeds 300 souls, thereby squarely bringing her case
within the ambit of the aforementioned Government Order dated
08.04.2009.
4.
The official respondents, in their objections, have stated that the
petitioner possesses a Bachelor of Arts (B.A.) degree, whereas
respondent No. 5 holds both B.A. and Bachelor of Education (B.Ed.)
qualifications. It is contended that respondent No. 5, being superior in
academic merit, was selected and engaged as a ReT Teacher vide order
dated 30.08.2010. Furthermore, upon the successful completion of five
years satisfactory tenure under the ReT Scheme, respondent No. 5 was
regularized as a General Line Teacher with effect from 30.09.2015.
They further averred that other candidates in the panel also possessed
the requisite eligibility; thus, the petitioner cannot claim engagement by
ignoring the comparative merit of higher ranked candidates. It is further
submitted that both the petitioner and respondent No. 5 reside within
the same revenue village where the school is situated. Since both
candidates belong to the same village unit and their names were duly
recommended by the Village Education Committee, the official
respondents
evaluated
their
comparative
merit.
Consequently,
SWP No. 2189/2010
respondent No. 5, being better qualified and more meritorious, was
rightly selected for engagement.
5.
Respondent No. 5, in her objections, has submitted that both she and the
petitioner reside within Ward No. 4 of Village Anandpur in House
Numbers 28 and 49 respectively. It is stated that as per the 2011
Census, the total population of Village Anandpur stands at 268 souls.
The contesting respondent further averred that the Zonal Education
Officer, Purmandal, prepared the panel of eligible candidates in May
2010 based on the lawful recommendations of the Village Education
Committee. In the said panel, respondent No. 5 placed Serial No. 1 with
a merit percentage of 55.33%, whereas the petitioner was placed at
Serial No. 4 with a merit percentage of 48%. Respondent No. 5
specifically denies that the petitioner holds any preferential claim to the
post, given that both candidates reside within the same ward and
habitation in which the school is situated. It is further contended that the
representations submitted and certificates subsequently procured by the
petitioner are legally inconsequential, as the selection and engagement
of respondent No. 5 were conducted strictly on the basis of comparative
merit and in conformity with the rules governing the ReT Scheme.
6.
Mr. Ankesh Chandel, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that
Village Anandpur holds the status of a distinct habitation with a
population exceeding 300 souls, as evidenced by the report of the
concerned Naib Tehsildar. He contended that in terms of Government
Order No. 288-Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009, the petitioner possesses a
preferential claim for engagement as a ReT Teacher because she resides
SWP No. 2189/2010
within 100 meters from the school, whereas respondent No. 5 resides
more than two kilometres away. Learned counsel, however, fairly
conceded that there is no official habitation certificate on record to
establish that Village Anandpur holds the legal status of an independent
habitation.
7.
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, learned Government Advocate, submitted that
respondent No. 5 was engaged as ReT Teacher in New Primary School,
Anandpur strictly on the basis of merit. He contended that since both
the petitioner and respondent No. 5 were residents of Village Anandpur,
their names, along with those of the other eligible candidates, were
included in the prospective panel. However, respondent No. 5, being
more meritorious than the petitioner and the other candidates, was
selected and engaged as ReT Teacher in accordance with the applicable
rules and guidelines.
8.
Mr. Rakesh Sharma, learned counsel for respondent No. 5, submitted
that both the petitioner and respondent No. 5 are residents of Ward No.
4 of Village Anandpur and, consequently, stand on the same footing
regarding their residential status. He contended that Government Order
No. 288-Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009, relied upon by the petitioner,
does not contemplate or provide for an intra-village proximity
preference where the competing candidates reside within the same
village unit. Learned counsel further submitted that the Naib Tehsildar's
report dated 17.07.2010 cannot be considered to establish that Village
Anandpur had acquired the legal status of an independent habitation. He
argued that because the report was procured subsequent to the
SWP No. 2189/2010
compilation and issuance of the tentative panel, it cannot be relied upon
to challenge the validity of the selection panel or the consequential
engagement of respondent No. 5.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10.
It is an admitted position that respondent No. 5 possesses superior
academic merit as compared to the petitioner. Consequently, the
petitioner rests her claim exclusively on Government Order No. 288Edu. of 2009 dated 08.04.2009, contending that she holds a preferential
right to engagement as a ReT Teacher by virtue of the mandates
contained in the said Government Order. The Government Order dated
08.04.2009 is extracted as under:
“Government of Jammu and Kashmir
Civil Secretariat, Education Department
……
Subject:Rehbar-e-Taleem Scheme to ensure people's
participation in the management of Education at grass roots
level.
Government Order No.: 288-Edu of 2009
Dated: 08-04-2009
The following explanation is added below the Eligibility
condition No. 1 laid down in Government Order No. 396 of Edu
2000 dated 28-04-2000 (Rehbar-e-Taleem Scheme):
Explanation:
Village means a Revenue Village. However, where
habitations in a Revenue Village are scattered, a candidate
belonging to a habitation, popularly known as a village, at
least one kilometer away from other habitations and
having a population of more than 300 persons, shall be
entitled to seek engagement as Rehbar-e-Taleem in a local
school."
The above explanation shall have prospective effect.
By order of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir.
SWP No. 2189/2010
Sd/Secretary to Government
Education Department”
11.
The Explanation appended to Eligibility Condition No. 1 defines
"village" as a Revenue Village. However, where habitations within a
Revenue Village are scattered, a candidate belonging to a habitation,
popularly known as a village, situated at least one kilometer away from
the other habitations and having a population of more than 300 persons,
shall be entitled to seek engagement as a ReT Teacher in a local school.
To qualify as an independent habitation under the scheme, an area must
be situated at least one kilometer away from any other existing
habitation and possess a population exceeding 300 persons. Notably,
the petitioner does not contend that respondent No. 5 belongs to a
different habitation. On the contrary, the Naib Tehsildar's report
substantiates that the subject school is located within Ward No. 4, and
that both the petitioner and respondent No. 5 reside within the same
ward.
12.
Thus, while respondent No. 5 resides approximately 1.5 kilometres
away from the school and the petitioner resides within 100 meters of it,
Government Order No. 288-Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009 does not
mandate micro-distance or immediate proximity as the sole or
overriding criterion for engagement as a ReT Teacher within a common
Village. It would be apt to observe that no habitation certificate is on
record, as admitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner. On the
contrary, where a school is situated within a distinct habitation as
SWP No. 2189/2010
defined under the aforementioned Explanation, only a candidate
residing within that specific habitation can claim a preferential right to
engagement.
13.
In the present case, as already noticed hereinabove, both the petitioner
and respondent No. 5 are residents of Ward No. 4 of Village Anandpur,
and the subject school is situated within the same ward. Under such
circumstances, the petitioner cannot claim any preferential right to
engagement over respondent No. 5 merely on the ground of closer
proximity to the school. This is particularly true given that no habitation
certificate has been placed on record to establish that the school is
located within a separate, independent habitation within the meaning of
Government Order No. 288-Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009. The report
submitted by the Naib-Tehsildar cannot help the petitioner's case in any
manner, as it relies on the vague, hearsay assertions of local residents to
claim that the population exceeds 300, rather than referencing verified
official records.
14.
For the reasons stated hereinabove, this Court is of the considered view
that the petitioner has failed to make out any case warranting
interference with the panel prepared by the official respondents or the
engagement of respondent No. 5 as a ReT Teacher. The writ petition,
being devoid of merit, is accordingly dismissed.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
10.07.2026
Karam Chand
Whether approved for reporting:
KARAM CHAND
2026.07.10 14:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review