Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 202
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on :
07.02.2026.
Pronounced on :
31.03.2026.
HCP No. 140/2025
Junaid Ahmad Sheikh, Aged 17 years
S/o Gh. Mohd. Sheih
R/o Chandigam, Anantnag
Presently at Chitgram Shopian
& District Shopian, Jammu & Kashmir
Through his Mother namely Shafeeqa Akhter
Aged 67 years
D/o Ali Mohd Ganie
R/o Chitgram, Shopian
& District Shopian, Jammu and Kashmir
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Tariq M. Shah, Advocate
Vs
1. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir through
Commissioner/Secretary to Government, Home Department,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/ Jammu.
2. District Magistrate/ Deputy Commissioner, Shopian.
3. Senior Superintendent of Police, District Shopian.
4. Jail Superintendent, District Jail, Jammu.
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. Bikramdeep Singh, Dy. AG
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
01.
Heard learned counsel for both sides.
HCP No. 140/2025
Perused the writ petition and the annexures
02.
therewith and also the counter affidavit filed in response.
The
03.
detention
record
produced
also
scanned
thoroughly.
The petitioner-Junaid Ahmad Sheikh, who is said
04.
to be a 17 years old at the time of institution of this writ
petition on 26.05.2025, filed through his mother – Shafeeqa
Akhter, has come forward pleading quashment of preventive
detention imposed upon him under the Jammu & Kashmir
Public
Safety
Act,
by
virtue
of
an
order
No.
06/DMS/PSA of 2025 dated 01.05.2025 passed by the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Shopian in terms
whereof the petitioner was order to be detained in order to
prevent him from acting in a manner prejudicial to security of
the State.
05.
It is the Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Shopian
who had reckoned the alleged state of activities of the
petitioner to be falling within the scope of mischief to be
curbed under the Jammu & Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978
and,
therefore,
by
virtue
of
a
dossier
No.
PSA-
Cell/SPN/19967-69 dated 29.04.2026 submitted the case
HCP No. 140/2025
before the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Shopian for
ordering the preventive detention of the petitioner which
came to be so ordered in response by virtue of the
aforementioned detention order passed on the basis of
purported grounds of detention.
06.
The stated backdrop in which the petitioner was
reckoned to be a case for being subjected under the Jammu
& Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978 is that the petitioner
having got his initial schooling in Shimla upto 6th class had
then joined Public High School Chitragam, district Shopian
upto 7th class. The petitioner is said to be son of a
surrendered militant but residing with his maternal uncle at
Chitragam, district Shopian and right from his school days
got
influenced
by
harmful
narratives
to
undergo
radicalization and adopting extremist ideology and, therefore,
acting as an information provider about the movements of
the security forces which resulted in failure of many cordons
and search operations of the terrorists who later on were
found to be involved in killing of innocent people and many
attacks on security forces.
HCP No. 140/2025
07.
The petitioner is said to have been one of co-
conspirators by reference to FIR No. 47/2018 registered by
the Police Station Zainpora for alleged commission of offences
under sections 13, 16, 38 Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1967 in which the petitioner being a juvenile was
detained on 12.02.2019 at Juvenile Home, Srinagar to be
later on released by Juvenile Justice Board, Shopian before
which the case stands challaned on 24.11.2023.
08.
The petitioner upon attaining age of majority is said
to be still active in spreading the agenda of LeT/HM outfits
and motivating the youth towards joining militancy on the
directions
of
terrorist
handlers
which
constrained
proceedings under sections 126/170 Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 by the Executive Magistrate,
Zainpora but despite that the petitioner is said to have not
checked himself from acting in a prejudicial manner with
respect to the security of the State.
09.
The petitioner came to be arrested pursuant to the
detention warrant which came to be executed by Inspector
Showkat Ahmed, No. EXK-022645 of DPL, Shopian who took
the petitioner into custody on 06.05.2025 and handed over
HCP No. 140/2025
him to the Superintendent District Jail, Jammu by first
delivering to the petitioner notice of the order and the
grounds of detention and taking a receipt for the said
compliance from the petitioner. The petitioner is said to have
acknowledged the receipt of copy of notice, order of detention
and grounds of detention alongwith dossier consisting of total
24 leaves and also acknowledging of the fact that he was
apprised of his right to make a representation to the
Government as well as to the detention order making
authority.
10.
It is from his said state of custody that the
petitioner has come up with the present petition filed on
26.05.2025 assailing detention on the grounds as set out in
para 4 in the writ petition by citing that the petitioner is still
under 18 years of age and being subjected to preventive
detention custody. The petitioner refers to the fact that the
grounds of detention are vague and baseless besides being
stale.
11.
The petitioner has referred to the fact that his
representation has not been decided by the respondents
made against his detention and which detention is assailed
HCP No. 140/2025
to be based upon no subjective satisfaction from the end of
the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Shopian.
12.
The approval of the petitioner’s preventive detention
came to be accorded in terms of Govt. Order No. Home/PBV/831
of
06.05.2025
dated
with
the
case
recommended to the Advisory Board for its opinion.
13.
Before coming forward with the institution of the
present writ petition on 26.05.2025, the petitioner being in
the state of preventive detention custody had addressed a
representation to the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Shopian which came to be acknowledged as received vide
receipt
No.
137/DCS
dated
15.05.2025
wherein
the
petitioner acting through his mother solicited revocation of
his preventive detention.
14.
Upon
approval
of
the
petitioner’s
preventive
detention, the Govt. Submitted file to the Advisory Board, by
virtue of communication No. Home/PB-V/253/2025 dated
06.05.2025, whereupon the Advisory Board came up with its
opinion report dated 02.06.2025 with the opinion that the
petitioner’s
detention
was
justifiable
and
that
the
representation submitted by him and also upon hearing the
HCP No. 140/2025
petitioner in person on 02.06.2025 there was no good
ground for holding that the petitioner’s detention was
unjustified.
15.
On the basis of the Advisory Board’s opinion, the
preventive detention order of the respondent No. 2 - District
Magistrate, Shopian came to be confirmed about which there
is no recital made in the counter affidavit submitted on
09.07.2025 but from the detention record said Govt. Order
No.
Home/PB-V/1237
of
dated
13.06.2025
is
available in terms whereof the petitioner has been directed to
be detained at first instance for a period of six months with
effect from 06.05.2025 till 05.11.2025 to be confined in
District Jail, Jammu and said detention period is now surely
in its extended spell.
16.
From the end of the respondents, counter affidavit
came to be submitted on 09.07.2025 stating therein that the
petitioner’s
preventive
detention
was
an
unavoidable
situation in hand of the District Police as well as District
Magistrate, Shopian because of the alleged reported state of
activities of the petitioner which if left unattended would have
undermined security of the State.
HCP No. 140/2025
17.
Through the medium of counter affidavit, the
learned counsel for the respondents argues vehemently that
preventive detention of the petitioner is an effort to nip the
evil in the bud.
18.
When
this
Court
examines
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case then what comes out in bold print
is that per se impugned detention order is not accompanied
with formal grounds of detention for enabling the petitioner
to understand what was being delivered to him along with
the detention order are the grounds of detention without any
express reference made in that regard anywhere, whereas in
the present case there is a long drawn narrative from the end
of the District Magistrate, Shopian which is meant to be
assumed to be the grounds of detention, without being stated
to be so, wherein the District Magistrate, Shopian is going at
length to quote the very purpose of the Public Safety Act,
1978, the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of “Subharta Vs State of West Bengal, (1973) 3 SCC
250, article 22 of the Constitution of India, legal position with
respect to preventive detention, settled position of law with
respect to democracy governed by the rules of law, judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of “Naresh
HCP No. 140/2025
Kumar Goyal Vs Union of India and others” (2005) 8 SCC
276, judgment in the case of “Hardhan Saha Vs State of West
Bengal” (1975)3 SCC 198 and lastly judgment of this Court
in the case of “Mian Abdul Qayoom Vs State of J&K and
others” decided on 07.02.2020 and drawing excerpts from
the aforesaid judgments to inflate the document so as to give
it a semblance of grounds of detention without even naming
it so.
19.
This exercise at the end of the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Shopian obviously is with a latent
acknowledgment that otherwise but for the petitioner’s
involvement in FIR No. 47/2018 there is nothing fresh
factual input to portray that the petitioner’s state of activities
being in a state of personal liberty as prejudicial to the
security of State.
20.
In the dossier, the petitioner is said to be a class 7 th
drop out but in the so called assumed to be Grounds of
Detention accompanying the impugned detention order, the
petitioner is being referred to be an educated person to the
extent of even knowing that routine laws of the land are not
easily enforceable upon him due to various tangible reasons
HCP No. 140/2025
and under the exploit of the same the petitioner turning
himself into a notorious terrorist and managing Over Ground
activities.
21.
It did not occur to the respondent No. 2-District
Magistrate, Shopian to first confirm the fact from the District
Police, Shopian as to whether the proceedings under sections
126/170 Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023
initiated
against
the
petitioner
before
the
Executive
Magistrate, Zainpora were ever taken to logical end with any
final order passed so as to bind the petitioner with a personal
as well as surety bond or was it only that proceedings were
initiated and thus abandoned without being taken to logical
end except to use as a pretext for preparing a case for
seeking his preventive detention.
22.
Thus, this Court finds that not only a stale ground
by reference to FIR No. 47/2018 was pressed into service
but even vague ground has also been pressed against the
petitioner to somehow subject him to preventive detention
custody.
23.
There is hardly any factual input worth name in the
dossier as well as in the so called grounds of detention as to
HCP No. 140/2025
when the petitioner came to be released from the juvenile
confinement so as to attain his state of personal liberty in the
course of which it was being reckoned by the District Police
that the petitioner was indulging in activities prejudicial to
the security of State. Without even knowing that period of
personal liberty, the petitioner has been so painted as if his
state of activities is so live and visible that it took no time for
the District Police to take notice of the same and book the
petitioner for preventive detention custody but still nothing in
the dossier is in the name of factual content and context.
24.
The Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in an
identically placed case of “Tahir Riyaz Dar Vs UT of J&K
and others” in LPA No. 121/2025 in terms of its judgment
dated 06.11.2025 came to set aside the preventive detention
of a person who was also a juvenile, first booked in FIR No.
46/2022 and upon his release by the order of the Juvenile
Justice Board, Pulwama getting booked for preventive
detention custody. The Hon’ble Division Bench by referring to
the tests prescribed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of “Ameena Begum Vs State of Telangana”
(2023)9 SCC 587 came to quash the detention of said
person.
HCP No. 140/2025
25.
The end situation of this Case cannot be, thus,
different and the preventive detention of the petitioner also
warrants to be set aside, which is, accordingly, set aside. The
detention
order
No.
06/DMS/PSA
of
dated
01.05.2025 passed by the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate,
Shopian
read
with
approval/confirmation/
extension order if any passed from the end of the Govt., are
hereby quashed. The petitioner is directed to be restored to
his personal liberty forthwith by his release from the jail
concerned and to this effect the Superintendent of the
concerned jail to ensure the release of the petitioner to his
personal liberty.
26.
Detention record to be returned back to the learned
counsel for the respondents.
27.
Disposed of.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
31.03.2026
Opinder
HCP No. 140/2025
Whether the judgment is speaking :
Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable :
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review