Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
JAMMU
Reserved on: 16.07.2026
Pronounced on: 23.07.2026
Uploaded on: 23.07.2025
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
HCP No. 140/2025
Arjun Kumar, through his father
Sham Lal.
...Petitioner(s)
Through: -
Mr. Nikhil Choudhary, Advocate
Vs.
...Respondent(s)
UT OF J&K & ORS
Through: -
Mr. P. D. Singh, Dy. AG.
CORAM:HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Through the medium of the present petition, the petitioner has challenged the
order No. PSA 14 of 2025 dated 12.09.2025 (for short, "the detention order")
passed by the District Magistrate, Jammu (hereinafter referred to as "the
detaining authority"), whereby the petitioner has been detained under
Section 8(1)(a) of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978, with a
view to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order.
2.
The detention order has been assailed primarily on the grounds that the
constitutional and statutory safeguards governing preventive detention have
not been complied with. It is contended that the grounds of detention were
neither furnished nor explained to the detenue in a language understood by
HCP No.140/2025
him, thereby depriving him of his valuable constitutional right to make an
effective representation against the order of detention. It is further pleaded
that the material relied upon by the detaining authority, including copies of
the FIRs, seizure memos, FSL reports, site plans, bail orders and other
relevant documents, was not supplied to the detenue. According to the
petitioner, the grounds of detention are vague, stale and founded upon
irrelevant material, which vitiates the subjective satisfaction recorded by the
detaining authority. It is also urged that the petitioner was not informed of
his right to make a representation before the Advisory Board. It is further
contended that the dossier and the detention order bear the same date, i.e.,
12.09.2025, which, according to the petitioner, clearly reflects a mechanical
exercise of power and complete non-application of mind by the detaining
authority.
3.
Respondent No. 2 has filed the counter affidavit, wherein it is stated that the
detention order has been passed after due application of mind and on the
basis of the subjective satisfaction arrived at by the detaining authority upon
consideration of the dossier submitted by the Senior Superintendent of
Police, Jammu. It is further stated that the detenue is a habitual and notorious
criminal involved in serious offences, including attempt to murder, assault
and use of illegal firearms and sharp-edged weapons. It is pleaded that six
FIRs and six Daily Diary Reports (DDRs) have been registered against him
and that his criminal activities have created fear and insecurity amongst the
public, thereby adversely affecting public order. It is further stated that all
the constitutional and statutory safeguards were duly complied with, the
HCP No.140/2025
grounds of detention along with the material relied upon, were supplied to
the detenue, and the contents thereof were explained to the petitioner in the
language understood by him.
4.
Mr. Nikhil Choudhary, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
reiterated the grounds urged in the petition and submitted that the detenue
was deprived of his valuable constitutional right to make an effective
representation as neither the grounds of detention nor the material relied
upon by the detaining authority were supplied to the detenue. Learned
counsel further submitted that the allegations against the detenue, even if
accepted in their entirety, constitute a breach of “law and order” and do not
affect „public order‟ at all. He has also submitted that the mere fact that the
order of detention and dossier bear the same date, is sufficient in itself to
vitiate the order of detention. In support of his submissions, reliance has
been placed upon the judgments of the Supreme Court in Ameena Begum v.
State of Telangana and others, 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 873, and of this Court
in Hilal Ahmad Laway v. State of J&K and others, HCP No. 112/2019,
decided on 07.06.2019.
5.
Per contra, Mr. P. D. Singh, learned Dy.AG, submitted that the antecedents
of the detenue clearly establish that he is a habitual offender, whose
activities have consistently disturbed public order. It was submitted that
adequate material existed before the detaining authority to conclude that
preemptive detention was necessary to prevent the detenu from repeating
similar acts. He further submitted that the detention order, grounds of
HCP No.140/2025
detention and whole material relied upon were duly furnished to the detenue
and explained to him in a language understood by him.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the pleadings and
carefully examined the detention record produced by the learned Dy. AG
7.
The primary contention of the petitioner is that the detenue was not
furnished with the material relied upon by the detaining authority, thereby
depriving him of the opportunity to make an effective representation against
the detention order. A perusal of the detention record, however, belies the
said contention. The receipt forming part of the detention record clearly
shows that the detenue received 155 leaves, including the detention warrant,
notice of detention, grounds of detention, police dossier and all other
relevant documents. The receipt further indicates that the contents of the
grounds of detention were read over to the detenue in English language and
explained in Hindi/Dogri language, which he fully understood. The
petitioner has not produced any material to rebut the official record.
Consequently, this ground fails.
8.
Next, it was contended that the petitioner was not informed of his right to
make a representation to the detaining authority. Learned counsel placed
heavy reliance upon the receipt of the grounds of detention, which merely
records that the petitioner was informed of his right to represent to the
Government alone. However, the notice of the detention order reveals a
contrary position, clearly demonstrating that the petitioner was apprised of
his right to make a representation not only to the Government but also to the
HCP No.140/2025
District Magistrate. Consequently, this contention, being belied by the
record, is rejected.
9.
It was further submitted by the learned counsel that the identity of dates on
the police dossier and the detention order demonstrates a rubber-stamping
exercise, devoid of independent application of mind. This argument is
wholly untenable. The mere fact that the dossier and the detention order
share the same date cannot lead to an automatic presumption of arbitrariness.
What is paramount is whether the detaining authority subjected the material
to independent scrutiny before recording its subjective satisfaction. A
reading of the grounds of detention reveals a conscious and independent
assessment of the detenu's continuous course of conduct, rather than a mere
copy-paste of the police report. Consequently, this submission, being
without force, is rejected.
10. Another submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the
allegations against the detenu, at best, constitute a breach of law and order
and do not impinge upon public order. This submission does not merit
acceptance. The allegations against the petitioner as that he is member of
organized criminal “Khauf Gang”. Although reference has been made to six
FIRs in the grounds of detention, FIR No. 17/2025 assumes particular
significance. The allegations contained therein disclose that on 31.01.2025,
while a police party was on routine patrolling duty near Tube Well, Alawal
Chak, two persons riding a motorcycle allegedly opened indiscriminate fire
upon the police party with the intention of killing the police personnel. The
police retaliated in self-defence, resulting in one of the accused sustaining a
HCP No.140/2025
bullet injury, whereafter both the accused, including the petitioner herein,
were apprehended. During investigation, illegal firearms and live cartridges
were recovered from their possession. In the grounds of detention, it is
recorded by the detaining authority that the petitioner was granted bail by the
Court of learned 2nd Additional District, Judge Jammu in FIR (supra) vide
order dated 15.07.2025 and the SHO concerned has applied for cancellation
of bail.
11. The record discloses that the detenu is actively associated with an organized
criminal gang and was involved in firing indiscriminately upon police
personnel on duty. Such gravamen cannot be viewed through the narrow
prism of an ordinary crime against individual victims. On the contrary, such
overt acts send shockwaves of terror through the community and disrupt the
peaceful flow of societal life, squarely impacting public order. It is an
established principle that while every disturbance of public order involves a
breach of law and order, every crime affecting law and order does not
inherently disturb public order. Here, the detenu's violent conduct transcends
ordinary law enforcement issues and falls squarely within the ambit of
public order. The act of opening fire upon law enforcement agencies is, in
itself, sufficient to instill a sense of fear and insecurity in the citizenry, and
inherently possesses the propensity to disturb public order. If these
individuals are permitted to remain at large, total breakdown of public order
would follow. A perusal of the detention record reveals that the detaining
authority subjected the detenu's past conduct, criminal record, and recent
activities to independent scrutiny before forming its subjective satisfaction
HCP No.140/2025
that his remaining at large posed a real threat of recurrent prejudicial
behavior. The petitioner's contention, therefore, stands rejected.
12. In “Arjun S/o Ratan Gaikwad vs. the State of Maharastra and others”,
2024 INSC 968, the Hon‟ble Apex Court has held as under:
“15. As to whether a case would amount to threat to the public
order or as to whether it would be such which can be dealt with
by the ordinary machinery in exercise of its powers of
maintaining law and order would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. For example, if somebody
commits a brutal murder within the four corners of a house,
it will not be amounting to a threat to the public order. As
against this, if a person in a public space where a number of
people are present creates a ruckus by his behaviour and
continues with such activities, in a manner to create a terror
in the minds of the public at large, it would amount to a
threat to public order. Though, in a given case there may
not be even a physical attack.”
(emphasis added)
13. It is well settled that the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226, when
reviewing orders of preventive detention, is inherently circumscribed. This
Court does not sit in appeal over the material on record to supplant the
subjective satisfaction reached by the detaining authority. The judicial
inquiry is strictly confined to verifying adherence to constitutional and
statutory guarantees, and ensuring that the order is free from fatal legal
infirmities such as mala fides or a total non-application of mind. In the
instant case, the statutory procedural safeguards having been fully complied
with and the impugned order being founded on cogent and reliable material,
this Court finds no justification for interfering with the same.The precedents
relied upon by the petitioner are wholly inapposite to the facts at hand.
14. For the foregoing reasons, this Court finds no merit in the present petition.
The impugned detention order does not suffer from any legal or procedural
HCP No.140/2025
infirmity warranting interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of this
Court. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.
15. The detention record be returned to learned counsel for the respondents.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
23.07.2026
Karam Chand”
Whether the judgment is reportable:
KARAM CHAND
2026.07.23 13:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
HCP No.140/2025
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review