Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:1:
2025:KER:29912
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JOHNSON JOHN
MONDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 17TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO. 2925 OF 2019
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 20.12.2018 IN O.P(MV) NO.146 OF 2017 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, MUVATTUPUZHA
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
JUDITH, AGED 30 YEARS,
W/O LATE GEO, PARAKKATTU HOUSE, KADAVOOR VILLAGE,
KOTHAMANGALAM TALUK, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT,PIN-686 671.
IVAN, AGED 3 ½ YEARS,
S/O LATE GEO, PARAKKATT HOUSE, KADAVOOR VILLAGE,
KOTHAMANGALAM TALUK, MINOR,REPRESENTED BY MOTHER JUDITH,
AGED 30 YEARS, W/O LATE GEO PARAKKATT HOUSE, KADAVOOR
VILLAGE, KOTHAMANGALAM TALUK,ERNAKULAM DISTRICT,
PIN 686 671.
SUSI SEBASTIAN, AGED 67 YEARS,
W/O LATE SEBASTIAN, PARAKKATT HOUSE, KADAVOOR VILLAGE,
KOTHAMANGALAM TALUK, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN-686 671.
BY ADVS.
ANU S NAIR
SRI.SAIGI JACOB PALATTY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
MUHAMMED SHAREEF
S/O PAREED, 10/520A, PULLOLIL HOUSE, PEZHAKKAPPILLY
MUVATTUPUZHA, ERNAKULAM,PIN -686 673.
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
T H TOWER, STADIUM ROAD, MARKET P.O.MUVATTUPUZHA,
PIN: 686 673.
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:2:
2025:KER:29912
BALAKRISHNA TARU,
S/O DATTA TRAY ALIAS DATTA TARU, PANCHWATI BANGLAW S NO
33/27, KATRAJ KONDUWA ROAD, KATRAJ, PUNE, PIN 411 046.
RAJU PAIKRA,
S/O RAM, 33/27,PANCHWATI, SHIV SAMBHO NAGAR, KATRAJ
KONDUWA ROAD, KATRAJ, PUNE, MAHARASHTRA, PIN-411 046.
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD.,
LEELA CHAMBERS, PUNE SATARA ROAD, ARANYESHWAR CORNER,
PUNE, MAHARASHTRA, PIN-411037
BY ADV PANICKER V.P.K.
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
03.04.2025, THE COURT ON 07.04.2025, DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:3:
2025:KER:29912
JOHNSON JOHN, J.
--------------------------------------------------------M.A.C.A No. 2925 of 2019
-------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 7th day of April, 2025.
JUDGMENT
The petitioners in O.P.(MV) No. 146 of 2017 on the file of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Muvattupuzha filed this appeal seeking
enhancement of compensation.
2.
The petitioners are the legal representatives of the deceased
Geo, who died in a motor vehicle accident. According to the petitioners,
on 28.10.2016, while the deceased was riding a motorcycle, auto
rickshaw driven by the 1st respondent was parked on the eastern side of
the road and when the 1st respondent suddenly opened the right side
door of the autorickshaw, it caused to hit the motorcycle and thereby,
the deceased was thrown to the road and then, lorry driven by the 4 th
respondent caused to run over the body of the deceased and as a result
of the serious injuries sustained, he died on the same day.
3. The 2nd respondent is the insurer of the auto rickshaw and the
5th respondent is the insurer of the lorry. The 3 rd respondent is the owner
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:4:
2025:KER:29912
of the lorry. The petitioners alleged negligence against respondents 1
and 4.
4.
Before the Tribunal, PW1 examined and Exhibits A1 to A14
were marked from the side of the petitioners and no evidence adduced
from the side of the respondents.
5. The Tribunal recorded a finding that the accident occurred only
because of the negligence on the part of the 1 st
respondent and that
respondents 1 and 2 are liable to pay compensation to the petitioners.
The Tribunal awarded a total compensation of Rs.36,58,000/- to the
petitioners. The Tribunal exonerated respondents 3 to 5 from liability.
The findings of the Tribunal regarding negligence and liability are not
under challenge.
6. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants and the learned
counsel for the respondent insurance company.
7.
The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the
deceased was a businessman earning Rs.30,000/- per month and the
Tribunal fixed only a notional income of Rs.20,000/- for the reason that
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:5:
2025:KER:29912
the petitioners failed to adduce any evidence to prove the income of the
deceased.
8.
The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the
deceased was running a business concern by name ‘Trinity Sales
Corporation’ and that Exhibit A11 statement of account of Trinity Sales
Corporation
in
State
Bank
of
Travancore
bearing
account
No.
67329083625 is produced and the financial transactions reflected in the
account will indicate the income of the deceased.
9.
The learned counsel for the respondent insurance company
argued that Exhibit A11 account is in the name of ‘Trinity Sales
Corporation’ and it is not forthcoming as to whether the deceased was
authorized to make transactions in the account. The appellants have not
produced the bank passbook relating to Exhibit A11, statement of
account. There is also no material to indicate as to whether the business
concern by name ‘Trinity Sales Corporation’ is a proprietary concern or
partnership.
10.
Exhibits A12, A13 and A14 are the licences issued by the
panchayat in the name of the deceased for stocking and conducting sale
of sanitary items. The claim petitioners have not produced the copies of
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:6:
2025:KER:29912
the income tax return or the copies of the relevant registers in the
business concern, Trinity Sales Corporation, to prove the income of the
deceased and therefore, I find no reason to interfere with the finding of
the Tribunal that in the absence of any satisfactory evidence regarding
the actual income, only a notional income can be fixed for the purpose of
calculating the compensation.
11.
The
Tribunal
fixed
a
notional
income
of
Rs.20,000/-.
Considering the facts and circumstances and the standard of living of the
deceased, I find that the monthly notional income fixed by the Tribunal
is reasonable and requires no interference.
12. The Tribunal applied the multiplier of ‘16’ and deducted onethird of the income towards personal and living expenses of the
deceased by following the decision of the Honourable Supreme Court in
Sarla Varma v. Delhi Transport Corporation [2010 (2) KLT 802
(SC)] and the said findings of the Tribunal are not under challenge.
13.
The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the
Tribunal has not granted any compensation towards pain and sufferings
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:7:
2025:KER:29912
of the deceased. Section 2 of the Kerala Torts (Miscellaneous Provisions)
Act, 1976 shows that the right to sue for compensation for pain and
suffering would survive upon the legal heirs, if the injured died at a later
point of time.
14. In Jyni and Others v. Raphel P. T. and Others [2016 (2)
KHC 870], a Division Bench of this Court held as follows:
36. Death in an accident is generally the result of violent impact
on the body resulting in serious injuries causing severe pain. The
magnitude of the ordeal may vary from case to case depending
upon the nature of injuries sustained. In cases of instantaneous
deaths also pain and suffering is invariably present, as in the case
of survival for hours or days. In cases of instantaneous death as
well as cases where the deceased was unconscious between the
time of accident and the time of his death, some notional amount
is payable under the head pain and suffering. A slightly higher
amount can be awarded under this head, if the death is not
instantaneous. Therefore, a conventional amount in the range of
Rs.5,000/- to Rs.15,000/- could be awarded under the head pain
and suffering in such cases. In the instant case, the deceased
succumbed to injuries on the date of accident itself. In such
circumstances, Rs.10,000/- awarded by the Tribunal under the head
pain and suffering represents just and reasonable compensation,
which requires no enhancement in this appeal.”
In this case, the deceased died on the same day and therefore,
considering the facts and circumstances, I find that Rs.5,000/- can be
allowed as compensation towards ‘pain and sufferings’ of the deceased.
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:8:
2025:KER:29912
15. The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] would
show that the reasonable amount payable on conventional heads namely
loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be
Rs.15,000/-, Rs.40,000/- and Rs.15,000/- respectively and that the
aforesaid amount should be enhanced by 10% in every three years. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rojalini Nayak & Ors v. Ajit Sahoo (2024
KHC
Online
8300)
compensation
of
Rs.18,150/-
each
by
adopting
Rs.48,400/towards
the
towards
funeral
above
metric
awarded
loss
of
consortium
expenses
and
loss
of
a
and
estate.
Therefore, the amount awarded by the Tribunal towards funeral
expenses and loss of estate will be modified to Rs.18,150/- each.
16.
In Sunita v. Vinod Singh [2025 KHC Online 6249], the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held thus:
“...With regard to the loss of love and affection, Pranay Sethi
(supra) grants Rs.40,000/- (Rupees Forty Thousand) per head with
escalation of 10% every three years for loss of consortium which has
been interpreted in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v Nanu Ram,
(2018) 18 SCC 130 to include spousal, parental, and filial consortium.
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
:9:
2025:KER:29912
Thus, there being five claimants the amount shall be (Rs.48,000/- x 5)
which comes to Rs.2,40,000/- (Rupees Two Lakhs and Forty
Thousand) payable under the head of loss of love and affection.”
The claimants are the wife, son and mother of the deceased. Thus, there
being 3 claimants, the amount of consortium shall be (48,400 x 3),
which comes to Rs.1,45,200/-.
17. In conclusion, the enhanced amount of compensation, as
modified as a result of the above discussion is encapsulated, in a tabular
format herein below:
Sl.
No
Compensation
Particulars
awarded by the
Loss of dependency
Loss of estate
Funeral expenses
Loss of consortium
Pain and sufferings
Transportation to hospital
Damage to cloth and articles
Total amount Payable
Tribunal (Rs.)
35,84,000/15,000/15,000/40,000/NIL
3,000/1,000/36,58,000/-
Final Amount
Payable
35,84,000/18,150/18,150/1,45,200/5,000/3,000/1,000/37,74,500/-
18. Accordingly, the total amount of compensation payable to the
petitioners is determined as Rs.37,74,500/-.
In the result, this appeal is allowed, and the appellants/petitioners
are allowed to recover the compensation amount of Rs.37,74,500/-
M.A.C.A. No. 2925/2019
: 10 :
2025:KER:29912
(Rupees Thirty Seven Lakhs Seventy Four Thousand Five Hundred only)
with interest at the rate of 7% per annum from the date of the claim
petition till the date of realization (excluding the period of delay of 103
days
in
filing
the
respondents. The 2nd
appeal)
with
proportionate
costs
from
the
respondent insurance company shall deposit the
said amount together with interest and costs before the Tribunal within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment.
sd/JOHNSON JOHN,
JUDGE.
Rv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review