Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
THURSDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 29TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP(C) NO. 224 OF 2025
CMA NO.37 OF 2022 OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT & MOTOR ACCIDENT
CLAIMS TRIBUNAL , NORTH PARAVUR ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER IN OS NO.253 OF
2022 OF MUNSIFF COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
PETITIONER/S:
JOSE ANTONY, AGED 57 YEARS
S/O.ANTONY, MUKKATH HOUSE, MADAPLATHURUTHKARA, MOOTHAKUNNAM
P.O, MOOTHAKUNNAM VILLAGE, PARAVUR TALUK., PIN - 683516
BY ADVS.M.G.JEEVAN
SANIYA JOSE MAMPILLY
RESPONDENT/S:
JOB ANTONY, AGED 54 YEARS, S/O.ANTONY, MUKKATH HOUSE,
MADAPLATHURUTH KARA, MOOTHAKUNNAM P.O, MOOTHAKUNNAM VILLAGE,
PARAVUR TALUK., PIN - 683516
BY ADVS.
PHILIP T.VARGHESE
THOMAS T.VARGHESE(K/000516/1995)
ACHU SUBHA ABRAHAM(K/001758/1999)
V.T.LITHA(K/278/2006)
K.R.MONISHA(K/915/2013)
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV. ANJALY JAYAKRISHNAN
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 17.3.2025, THE COURT
ON 20.3.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 20th day of March 2025)
The petitioner filed O.S. No.253 of 2022 before the
Munsiff's Court, North Paravur,
for a decree of permanent
prohibitory injunction against the respondent, preventing trespass
into the petitioner's property, destruction of buildings, waste, and
any obstruction to the petitioner's rights. The respondent is the sole
defendant therein.
2. The petitioner claims ownership and possession of 27.375
cents of property in Moothakunnam Village, comprised in Sy.No.
305/15, 303/12A, and 313/1/51 by virtue of Settlement Deed No.
7432/1995 and Sale Deed No. 731/2002, both from the Paravur
Sub-Registrar's Office (SRO).
3. The property is divided by a Panchayat road: 4 cents lie
north, and 23.375 cents lie south. Two buildings, numbered 272/8
and 295/8, are located on the southern portion. A partial demolition
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
of the ancestral house has resulted in the construction of two new
rooms and a kitchen, designated as Building No. 8/273A. The entire
23.375 cent portion south of the road is enclosed by a compound
wall with a gate installed by the petitioner, and is the plaint schedule
property.
4. The petitioner and respondent are brothers. The petitioner
allowed the respondent to reside in the ancestral house situated in
10 cents of property covered by the above-said settlement deed. The
respondent, unmarried, resided there with their mother. With the
petitioner's consent, the respondent renovated the Tharavad House
using government financial assistance.
5. Subsequently, a dispute arose when the respondent made
false claims to the said 10 cents of property and he began
threatening the petitioner and his family, with demolition of
buildings on the property.
6.
This constrained the petitioner to file O.S. 253/2022
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
before the
Munsiff's Court, North Paravur, along with I.A.
No.3/2022, for temporary injunction to which the respondent filed
a counter-affidavit.
7.
In his counter-affidavit, the respondent claimed
ownership of the 10 cents of property comprised in Sy.No. 305/15,
Settlement Deed No. 7432/95, based on a Will No. 171/2008,
executed by their mother and he asserted possession of the same.
An Advocate Commission was deputed, he inspected the property
and submitted a report and sketch as Exhibits C1 and C1(a).
8.
The counter filed by the respondent, to the injunction
application, specifically contends the petitioner's ownership and
possession of the 10 cents of property. The respondent claimed
ownership of Building No. 8/273A, located near the Tharavad
House. He acknowledged Building No. 8/272 as being on the
property covered by Sale Deed No. 731/2002. He denied ownership
of Building No. 295/8 by either party.
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
9.
The respondent further asserted that the 10 cents of
property was bequeathed to him via the aforementioned Will of the
year 2008. He stated that he constructed a house using funds from
the Indira Vikas Yojana. He alleged that the petitioner filed O.S.
253/2022, when he attempted to demarcate the property with a
Taluk Surveyor. The respondent also claims to have effected
mutation in the property in his name in the revenue records and pays
taxes on it.
10.
The Munsiff Court dismissed I.A. 3/2022 (Ext.P23)
holding that the respondent is in possession of the disputed property
as the respondent's evidence indicated prima facie possession of
4.05 ares of property comprised in Sy. No. 303/2015 and Building
No. 273-A/8. The court also noted that the respondent treated the
property as his own and the adjudication in respect of the
conflicting title claims required further inquiry and evidence, and
that the petitioner had admitted the respondent’s possession. The
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
court also reasoned that it was unlikely for the mother to have
mortgaged the property in 2000, if she had already executed a
Settlement Deed in favour of the Petitioner. The petitioner filed an
appeal before the Additional District Court, N.Paravur againt the
order in I.A.No.3 of 2022, as CMA No.37/2022.
11. As per Ext.P24, the Additional District Court dismissed
CMA No.37/2022 with costs, concurring with the Munsiff's
finding. The appellate court emphasized the petitioner's burden of
proof regarding the Settlement Deed and found the petitioner's
failure to mutate the property.
The appellate court found the
balance of convenience in favour of the respondent, and that the
Petitioner had not proven his legal possession.
Hence, aggrieved
by Exhibit P23 and Exhibit P24, the petitioner has filed this OP(C).
12. According to the petitioner, he obtained 4.5 Ares of land
in Sy.No.303/2015 and the building by virtue of Ext.A1. He has
purchased 17 cents 385 sq. links of property adjacent to Ext.A1
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
property by sale deed No.731/2002. Petitioner is residing in the
building No.272/8 and the respondent is residing in the building
No.295/8. The petitioner has a case that the respondent is residing
in the building in the plaint schedule property
with his
permission. Ext.A1 is a settlement deed No.7432/1995 executed
by the mother of the petitioner in respect of 4.05 Ares of land.
The respondent bases his title on Ext.B1 registered
Will
No.17/2008 of Paravur SRO dated 3.6.2008 executed by the
mother of the petitioner as well as the respondent. Ext.B2 is the
patta in favour of the predecessor of the respondent and Ext.B3 is
the possession certificate in favour of the mother. The mother
passed away on 19.3.2013. Thereafter, Ext.B1 document came
into force and the respondent became the absolute owner in
possession of the property covered by Ext.B1. Ext.B5 is the land
tax receipt in the name of the respondent dated 11.07.2013 and
Ext.B4 is the land tax receipt dated 08.06.2022.
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
13. The respondent had executed an agreement in favour of
the Secretary of Paravur Block Panchayath as Ext.B9 to get
financial assistance for renovation of the building under the Indira
Avas Yojana scheme. Ext.B11 is the certificate issued by the Branch
Manager of the Kerala Bank, Moothakkunnam, stating that the
document in respect of 10 cents of land was deposited in bank for
taking loan.
14. It is to be noted that the petitioner places his title on
Ext.A1, settlement deed in the year 1995 and the respondent places
his title on the will executed by the mother. It is a fact that the
petitioner has not effected mutation of the property till date,
whereas the respondent, after the death of the mother and after
coming into force of the will, has mutated 4.05 ares of land in his
name. Ext.B11 certificate would show that even after execution of
settlement deed in the name of the petitioner, the mother had
mortgaged the property in favour of the bank for getting loan.
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
15. The Commissioner, who visited the property, filed Ext.P4
report and plan, which shows that the entire property is bounded by
wall and there is a gate on the northern side. The house of the
petitioner as well as that of the respondent is inside this property.
There is no demarcation separating Ext.A1 and A2 property.
Though the petitioner admits that the respondent is residing in a
small house inside the property, the same is with his permission.
The documents produced from the side of the defendant/respondent
shows that after the will came into effect, he had mutated the
property in his name and had obtained loan under Indira Avas
Yojana treating the same as his own property.
16. The question to be decided in this suit is that who has got
title over the 4.05 ares of land. The said question can be decided
only after evidence. But for granting an injunction restraining the
respondent from trespassing into the plaint schedule property or
from demolishing any building situated in the plaint schedule
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
property and from doing any act which will affect the ownership
and possession of the property, the petitioner has to show the court
that (i) he has a prima facie case in his favour, (ii) that there is
balance of convenience and (iii) irreparable injury will be caused,
if the same is granted. All these 3 conditions are to be satisfied for
granting of temporary injunction. The trial court as well as the
lower appellate court has come into a definite conclusion that prima
facie it shows that 4.05 ares of property is in the possession of the
respondent, as he is residing in the building bearing No.273-A/8.
17.
If an order of injunction is granted against the
respondent, that would be as ousting him from his own house,
which is situated in the plaint schedule property. However, there is
only one gate for ingress and egress to the property and there is no
demarcation of plaint A and B properties. Both the courts found that
there is a prima facie case in favour of the respondent and balance
of convenience also is in his favour. It is also found that no
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
irreparable injury will be caused to the petitioner, if injunction is
not granted.
18.
The
counsel
for
the
petitioner
relied
on
Ambujakshyamma v. Kesavan Kamalasanan [2010 (3) KLT SN
10], wherein this court held that when a gift is not onerous, only
slight evidence is sufficient for its acceptance. Reliance was also
placed on Joosa v. Simon [2024 (6) KLT SN 7] to contend that
mutation in favour of the donee is not essential to prove that the
donee has accepted the gift.
The decision in Balakrishnan
Nambeesan v. Meenakshyamma [2014 (2) KLT Suppl. 1996
(Ker.), was cited as the authority to contend that when title has
passed on to the donee “on acceptance of the gift, it has to be
presumed that possession over the property also passed with such
title and the person challenging the title must establish his
antecedent title to such property.
19. These authorities relied on by the counsel for the petitioner
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
cannot be taken into account as it deals with the question as to when
does a gift is said to be accepted. That is a different aspect to be
considered after taking the evidence in the suit. Hence, have no
application in the case at hand.
20. The counsel for the respondent relied on a decision by the
Apex court in Ramakant Ambalal Choksi v. Harish Ambalal
Choksi (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3538), wherein the court has held
in paragraph Nos.33 and 34 as follows:
“33. In the case of Anand Prasad Agarwal v. Tarkeshwar
Prasad [(2001) 5 SCC 568, it was held by this Court that it would not
be appropriate for any court to hold a mini-trial at the stage of grant of
temporary injunction.
34. The burden is on the plaintiff, by evidence aliunde by
affidavit or otherwise, to prove that there is "a prima facie case" in his
favour which needs adjudication at the trial. The existence of the prima
facie right and infraction of the enjoyment of his property or the right
is a condition precedent for the grant of temporary injunction.
Satisfaction that there is a prima facie case by itself is not sufficient to
grant injunction. The Court further has to satisfy that noninterference
by the court would result in "irreparable injury" to the party seeking
relief and that there is no other remedy available to the party except one
to grant injunction and he needs protection from the consequences of
apprehended injury or dispossession. Irreparable injury, however, does
not mean that there must be no physical possibility of repairing the
injury, but means only that the injury must be a material one, namely
one that cannot be adequately compensated by way of damages. The
third condition also is that "the balance of convenience" must be in
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
favour of granting injunction. The Court while granting or refusing to
grant injunction should exercise sound judicial discretion to find the
amount of substantial mischief or injury which is likely to be caused to
the parties, if the injunction is refused and compare it with that which
is likely to be caused to the other side if the injunction is granted. If on
weighing competing possibilities or probabilities of likelihood of injury
and if the Court considers that pending the suit, the subject matter
should be maintained in status quo, an injunction would be issued. The
Court has to exercise its sound judicial discretion in granting or refusing
the relief of ad interim injunction pending the suit. (See: Dalpat Kumar
v. Prahlad Singh, (1992) 1 SCC 719.)”
21. In Naramadaben Maganlal Thakker v. Pranjivandas
Maganlal Thakker [(1997) 2 SCC 255], the apex court held that
acceptance by or on behalf of the donee must be made during the
lifetime of the donor and while he is still capable of giving. It would
thus be clear that the execution of a registered gift deed, acceptance
of the gift and delivery of the property, together make the gift
complete. Thereafter, the donor is divested of his title and the donee
becomes the absolute owner of the property.
22. The counsel also relied on the decision of the apex court
in Tehsildar, Urban Improvement Trust and another v. Ganga
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
Bai Menariya (dead) through Lrs. [(2024 SCC Online SC 169]
in which in paragraph No.23 it was held as follows:
“A suit simplicitor for injunction may not be maintainable
as the title of the property of the plaintiff/respondent was disputed
by the appellants/defendants. In such a situation it was required for
the respondent/plaintiff to prove the title of the property while
praying for injunction. xxx xxx xxxx”
23. As mentioned earlier, when the petitioner admits that
the respondent is residing in a house inside the plaint schedule
property, an injunction cannot be granted against the respondent.
Both the courts have concurrently found on facts, that the petitioner
is not entitled to an injunction order.
24.
Moreover, the Apex Court in Estralla Rubber v.
Dass Estate (P) Ltd. [(2001) 8 SCC 97], has observed thus:
“6. The scope and ambit of exercise of power and jurisdiction by a
High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is examined and
explained in a number of decisions of this Court. The exercise of power
under this article involves a duty on the High Court to keep inferior courts
and tribunals within the bounds of their authority and to see that they do
the duty expected or required of them in a legal manner. The High Court
is not vested with any unlimited prerogative to correct all kinds of hardship
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
or wrong decisions made within the limits of the jurisdiction of the
subordinate courts or tribunals. Exercise of this power and interfering with
the orders of the courts or tribunals is restricted to cases of serious
dereliction of duty and flagrant violation of fundamental principles of law
or justice, where if the High Court does not interfere, a grave injustice
remains uncorrected. It is also well settled that the High Court while acting
under this Article cannot exercise its power as an appellate court or
substitute its own judgment in place of that of the subordinate court to
correct an error, which is not apparent on the face of the record. The High
Court can set aside or ignore the findings of facts of an inferior court or
tribunal, if there is no evidence at all to justify or the finding is so perverse,
that no reasonable person can possibly come to such a conclusion, which
the court or tribunal has come to."
Therefore, I am of the considered view that Ext.P23 order in
I.A.No.3 of 2022 and Ext.P24 judgment in C.M.A. No.37 of 2022
do not suffer from any perversity or illegality and hence, no
interference is warranted with the same.
Accordingly, this O.P.(C) is dismissed.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl/
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 224/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF PLAINT IN O.S.253/2022 ON THE FILE OF
MUNSIFF’S COURT, NORTH PARAVUR.
Exhibit P2
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF I.A.3/2022 IN O.S.253/2022 ON THE FILE
OF MUNSIFF’S COURT, NORTH PARAVUR.
Exhibit P3
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF COUNTER AFFIDAVIT DT.29.6.2022 FILED
BY RESPONDENT IN O.S.253/2022 ON THE FILE OF MUNSIFF’S
COURT, NORTH PARAVUR.
Exhibit P4
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF COMMISSIONER’S REPORT AND ROUGH SKETCH
DT.25.6.2022 FILED IN O.S.253/2022 OF MUNSIFF’S COURT,
NORTH PARAVUR.
Exhibit P5
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF REGD. SETTLEMENT DEED NO:7432/1995
DT.18.11.1995 OF PARAVUR SRO.
Exhibit P6
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF REGD.SALE DEED NO:731/2002 DT.5.2.2002
OF PARAVUR SRO.
Exhibit P7
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF ENCUMBRANCE CERTIFICATE DT.14.3.2022
ISSUED FROM PARAVUR SRO.
Exhibit P8
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF WILL DEED NO:17/2008 DT. 3.6.2008 OF
PARAVUR SRO.
Exhibit P9
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF PURCHASE CERTIFICATE NO:5000
DT.4.3.1970 ISSUED BY TAHASILDAR, NORTH PARAVUR,
ALONGWITH TYPED COPY OF THE SAME.
Exhibit P10
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF DEATH CERTIFICATE SOOSA ANTONY
DT.3.4.2013 ISSUED FROM NORTH PARAVUR MUNICIPALITY
Exhibit P11
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF TAX RECEIPT DT.11.7.2013 ISSUED FROM
MOOTHAKUNNAM VILLAGE OFFICE ISSUED FROM NORTH PARAVUR
MUNICIPALITY
Exhibit P12
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF TAX RECEIPT DT.8.6.2022 ISSUED FROM
MOOTHAKUNNAM VILLAGE OFFICE
Exhibit P13
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF CERTIFICATE DT.7.6.2022 ISSUED FROM
VADAKKEKARA GRAMA PANCHAYATH
Exhibit P14
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF DEMAND NOTICE DT.10.2.2021 ISSUED FROM
VADAKKEKARA GRAMA PANCHAYATH.
Exhibit P15
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF BUILDING TAX RECEIPT NO:10439 ISSUED
FROM VADAKKEKARA GRAMA PANCHAYATH
Exhibit P16
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF REGD.AGREEMENT NO:2050/2017
OPC 224/2025
2025:KER:26847
DT.21.7.2017 EXECUTED BY RESPONDENT IN FAVOUR OF
SECRETARY, BLOCK PANCHAYATH.
Exhibit P17
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF NOTICE DT.28.5.2022 ISSUED BY TALUK
SURVEYOR, NORTH PARAVUR TO THE RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P18
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF CERTIFICATE DT.18.6.2022 ISSUED FROM
KERALA BANK, MOOTHAKUNNAM BRANCH
Exhibit P19
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF MORTGAGE DEED NO: 2596/2000
DT.8.5.2000 OF PARAVUR SRO WITH TYPED COPY OF THE SAME.
Exhibit P20
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF REGD.RELEASE DEED NO:2642/13
DT.30.5.2013 OF PARAVUR SRO.
Exhibit P21
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THANDAPER NO:18211 OF MOOTHAKUNNAM
VILLAGE.
Exhibit P22
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY KERALA BANK,
MOOTHAKUNNAM BRANCH, DT.30.6.2022.
Exhibit P23
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DT.29.7.2022 IN I.A. 3/2022 IN O.S.
253/2022 ON THE FILE OF MUNSIFF COURT, N.PARAVUR
Exhibit P24
TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT DT.9.9.2024 IN CMA 37/2022 ON THE
FILE OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE, N.PARAVUR.
Exhibit P25
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF ACKNOWLEDGMENT DT.21.7.2022 SIGNED BY
THREE SISTERS OF PETITIONER, ACKNOWLEDGING THE EXECUTION
OF REGD.SETTLEMENT DEED NO:7432/1995
Exhibit P26
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF FORM NO:1 FOR MUTATION SIGNED BY
MOTHER IN CONNECTION WITH REGD.SETTLEMENT DEED
NO:7432/95, WITH TYPED COPY OF THE SAME.
Exhibit P27
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THANDAPER LEDGER OF MOOTHAKUNNAM
VILLAGE REGARDING PAYMENT OF TAX OF 4.05 ARES IN
SY.NO:303/15
Exhibit P28
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF REPORT DT. DT.15.7.2022 PREPARED BY
VILLAGE OFFICER, MOOTHAKUNNAM.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review