The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. Considering the entire facts as noticed supra, we are of the opinion that the appeal is liable to be restored and disposed of on the merits. The inconvenience caused to the first respondent, consequent on the delay in seeking for restoration of the appeal and also in seeking to set aside the ex parte decree, can be compensated by way of costs. We are of the opinion that, costs of ₹ 30,000/- could be awarded.
20. In the result, the Appeal is disposed of as hereunder: The appeal will stand allowed and the exparte decree set aside on condition that the appellant pays an amount of ₹ 30,000/- as costs to the counsel appearing for the 1st respondent-wife, on or before 21.05.2025. The Family Court shall try and dispose of the Original Petition afresh, parties to after adduce affording evidence. The opportunity written to the statement/ Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017 2025:KER:31347 -: 12 :- objections if any, of the appellant, shall be filed by him within 60 days from today. On the failure of the appellant to pay the costs as ordered, the appeal will stand dismissed, affirming the impugned order. Sd/SATHISH NINAN Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN kns///True Copy// P.S. To Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31347
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 960 OF 2017
AGAINST THE ORDER IN IA925/2015 & IA 924/2015 IN OP 1453/2011
DATED 11.05.2017 IN OP NO.1453 OF 2011 OF FAMILY COURT, KOTTAYAM
----APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
JOHNY JOHN
S/O JOHN,
VALYAKAPPIL VEETTIL, KADANADU VILLAGE,MEENACHIL TALUK,
KOTTAYAM DISTRICT.
BY ADV SRI.DOMSON J.VATTAKUZHY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
JAINYMOL SASANKAN @ JAINYMOL K.JOSEPH,
D/O. JOSEPH ANTONY, KIZHAKKEL VEETTIL, POONJAR
NADUBHAGOM VILLAGE, MEENACHIL TALUK, KOTTAYAM
DISTRICT,NOW RESIDING AT 7334,ELIZABETH WAY, SAN
ANTINIO TEXAS 78240, REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY
HOLDER SONY JOSEPH,S/O. JOSEPH ANTONY,KIZHAKKEL
VEETTIL, POONJAR NADUBHAGOM VILLAGE,MEENACHIL TALUK,
KOTTAYAM DISTRICT.
SASANKAN @ SASANKAN J. VALIYAPARAMBIL
S/O. JAYACHANDRAN, VALIYAPARAMBIL HOUSE, VADAKKEKARA
KARA,POONJAR NADUBHAGOM VILLAGE, MEENACHIL
TALUK,KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, NOW RESIDING AT 5055,VAN
APARTMENT, 114,SEHEELA DR SAN ANTANIO,TEXAS.
THIS
MATRIMONIAL
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
10.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:31347
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 10th day of April, 2025
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
The appeal is filed by the second respondent in OP
1453 of 2011 of the Family Court. He challenges the
order
refusing
to
set
aside
of
the
exparte
decree
on
condoning the delay.
2.
O.P.
was
filed
by
the
first
respondent in the appeal, against the second respondent
and the appellant herein as respondents 1 and 2. The
respondents in the appeal are husband and wife. For the
sake of convenience the parties are hereinafter referred
to as “the appellant”, “the husband” and “the wife”.
3. The wife filed the Original Petition seeking a
declaration
property
that
she
scheduled
is
to
the
the
absolute
owner
of
the
Original
Petition.
The
appellant was set exparte on 24.09.2012. The husband
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 2 :-
also did not appear. The Family Court passed an exparte
decree declaring the exclusive title of the wife over
the property.
4. The appellant filed an application to set aside
the exparte decree and to condone the delay of 946 days
in seeking to set aside the exparte decree. It was
contended that he was not served with any notice or
summons in the case. He contended that he had obtained a
decree against the husband in OS 94/2005, for return of
the advance sale consideration based on an agreement for
sale entered into with him in respect of the property.
He holds a charged decree over one-half of the property
in
question.
decree,
the
In
wife
the
execution
filed
a
proceedings
claim
petition,
of
that
it
was
dismissed by the execution court. Challenging the same
the wife filed an appeal before this Court as Ex.F.A.
24/2012. It was only when the wife produced a copy of
the exparte judgment in the present Original Petition,
in the Execution First Appeal on 13.02.2015 that he came
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 3 :-
to know about the present exparte decree. Thereupon
these applications were filed.
5. The wife filed a counter affidavit contending
that, though the appellant was served with notice in the
Original Petition he choose to remain exparte resulting
in the exparte decree. It was contended that there are
no sufficient reasons to condone the delay and to set
aside the exparte decree.
6. The Family Court held that the appellant was
served with notice and that he has failed to give
satisfactory explanation for the delay in seeking to set
aside the exparte decree. Accordingly the applications
were dismissed.
7. We have heard the learned counsel on either
side.
8. On hearing the learned counsel on either side
and
on
emerge:-
perusing
the
records,
the
following
facts
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 4 :-
9. In the year 2003 there was an agreement for sale
in respect of the property in question between the
appellant and the husband. Allegedly the agreement was
entered into by the husband on behalf of the wife also
since the property belonged jointly to them. In the year
2005, the appellant filed OS 94/2005 against the husband
as
defendant
for
return
of
the
advance
sale
consideration of ₹ 3 lakhs paid under the agreement. On
24.03.2006, the suit was decreed ex parte allowing the
appellant to realise ₹ 3 lakhs with interest thereon,
charged over the share of the husband over the property.
The appellant proceeded for execution of the decree by
filing EP 129/2006. The property was sold in execution
in the year 2011. The appellant/decree holder was the
auction purchaser. He took symbolic delivery of the
property.
10. The wife filed OS 10/2011 against the appellant
as the first defendant and her husband as the second
defendant
seeking
a
declaration
that
she
is
the
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 5 :-
exclusive title holder of the entire property. The suit
was rejected for non-payment of the balance court fee.
11. It appears that there was a divorce proceeding
in between the husband and the wife at a District Court
in
Texas,
USA,
resulting
in
a
divorce
decree
on
12.11.2010.
12. In the execution proceedings in EP 129/2006,
the wife had filed a claim petition as EA 24/2011 under
Order XXI Rule 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The
claim
petition
was
dismissed
after
taking
evidence.
Challenging the same the wife filed Execution First
Appeal
as
Ex.FA
24/2012,
before
this
Court.
On
20.11.2017, based on a memo filed by the wife that the
disputes have been settled, the appeal was dismissed as,
not pressed.
13.
In
the
meanwhile,
the
wife
had
filed
the
present Original Petition as OP 1453/2011 before the
Family Court seeking a declaration that she is the
absolute owner of the property in question. The husband
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 6 :-
was the first respondent and the appellant herein is the
second respondent. Both the husband and the appellant
were set exparte, and an exparte decree was passed on
24.09.2012.
The
present
applications
were
filed
on
27.05.2015 seeking to set aside the exparte decree, on
condoning the delay of 946 days. The reason for the
delay is stated to be that he was unaware of the decree
and that he came to know about it only when the judgment
was produced before this Court in Execution First Appeal
and the appeal was got dismissed as not pressed.
14. The wife alleges collusion between the husband
and the appellant, while the appellant alleges collusion
between the husband and wife.
15. The alleged agreement for sale, upon which the
appellant filed OS 94/2005, was in the year 2003. Under
the decree, charge is created over one-half share over
the property. The EP of the year 2006 culminated in a
sale only in the year 2011. The claim petition filed by
the wife in the year 2011, was dismissed after taking
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 7 :-
evidence. The suit filed by the wife as OS 10/2011
seeking
declaration
of
her
title
over
the
entire
property, was rejected for non-payment of the balance
court fee. The exparte decree in the present Original
Petition was produced by the wife in her appeal, Ex.FA
24/2012, before this Court, in the year 2015.
16. On 03.07.2012 ie. pending the present Original
Petition, the husband executed a document styled as
“Power of Attorney” in favour of the wife. Copy of such
power of attorney is produced and marked in the Original
Petition as Ext.A19. In the said power of attorney,
referring to the property in question the husband has
stated thus :“.....Myself is the Respondent and Jainymole Sasnkan is the petitioner in
the said case in the District Court 407th Judicial District, Bexar County,
Texas USA, 78240 are joint owners of properties mentioned by Document
No.234/1998 in Book No.I Volume No.614 pages 29-32 of Sub Registrar
Office, Erattupetta, Kottayam, Kerala, India and properties mentioned in
Document No.3896/1995 in Book No.1 Volume No.452 pages 389 to 391
Sub Registrar of Poonjar, Kottayam, Kerala, India.
I am hereby authorizing and transferring all my rights to the
above mentioned properties to Jainymole Sasankan 7334 Elizabeth Way,
San Antonio. Texas, USA, 78240 without any considerations.”
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 8 :-
It is relevant to notice that, though the divorce decree
is stated to be on 12.11.2010, the said “power of
attorney” is dated 03.07.2012. Therein it is affirmed
that the husband and wife are the joint owners of the
property. Under the document, the husband purports to
convey all his rights in the property to the wife,
without any consideration. The learned counsel for the
wife
would
submit
that
such
document
was
only
in
pursuance of the terms of the divorce decree.
17. Considering the entire facts as above, we are
of the view that an opportunity is to be granted to the
appellant to agitate his contentions in the Original
Petition and to invite a judgment on the merits. The
Family Court, while refusing to set aside the exparte
decree has observed that the service of notice on the
appellant
is
evidenced
by
his
signature
in
the
acknowledgment card and the appellant does not have a
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 9 :-
case that the signature in the acknowledgment card is
not that of his. The Court omitted to note that the very
contention of the appellant was that he was not served
with any notice in the Original Petition. A reading of
the deposition of the appellant as PW1 reveals that the
signature in the acknowledgment card was not put by him.
The appellant would not stand to gain by remaining
exparte
in
the
claimed
absolute
Original
Petition
title
the
over
wherein
the
wife
property,
when
the
appellant had already purchased one-half right over the
property
in
a
decree
and
the
execution
proceedings
against the husband. Incidentally it is to be noticed
that
the
husband
remained
ex
parte
Original
Petition.
Suffice
to
notice
in
the
that
present
we
find
sufficient reasons to grant the appellant an opportunity
to contest the Original Petition and seek for a judgment
on the merits.
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 10 :-
18. The present appeal was dismissed by this Court
on 26.08.2019, for failure on the part of the appellant
to take steps within the prescribed time. The appellant
has sought for restoration of the appeal with a delay of
1790 days. MJC 135/2024 was filed on 19.08.2024 seeking
restoration
of
the
appeal.
In
the
meanwhile,
the
appellant had filed OS 6/2021 for partition and separate
possession of his one half share over the property, he
being the owner of the one-half share under execution
sale in E.P. 129/2006 in OS 94/2005. Therein, though an
ex parte decree was passed subsequently the wife sought
to set aside the ex parte decree. Thereupon on enquiries
he realised that the appeal was dismissed for default.
From out of the extent of delay from 15.02.2020 to
28.02.2022 is liable to be excluded due to the Covid-19
pandemic and hence the actual delay involved is (1790715=1075) 1075 days.
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 11 :-
19. Considering the entire facts as noticed supra,
we are of the opinion that the appeal is liable to be
restored
and
disposed
of
on
the
merits.
The
inconvenience caused to the first respondent, consequent
on the delay in seeking for restoration of the appeal
and also in seeking to set aside the ex parte decree,
can be compensated by way of costs. We are of the
opinion that, costs of ₹ 30,000/- could be awarded.
20. In the result, the Appeal is disposed of as
hereunder:
The
appeal
will
stand
allowed
and
the
exparte
decree set aside on condition that the appellant pays an
amount of ₹ 30,000/- as costs to the counsel appearing
for the 1st respondent-wife, on or before 21.05.2025.
The Family Court shall try and dispose of the Original
Petition
afresh,
parties
to
after
adduce
affording
evidence.
The
opportunity
written
to
the
statement/
Mat. Appeal No.960 of 2017
2025:KER:31347
-: 12 :-
objections if any, of the appellant, shall be filed by
him within 60 days from today. On the failure of the
appellant to pay the costs as ordered, the appeal will
stand dismissed, affirming the impugned order.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review