The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. The applicant was already named in the original complaint. The record contains summons issued in January 2024 and postal material recording locked premises and an unclaimed return. These circumstances answer the assertion that no summons was issued, but do not conclusively establish actual receipt or deliberate evasion. His interception during proposed overseas travel is not proof of guilt, and the police-clearance certificate relied upon by counsel does not adjudicate this prosecution. The earlier Rajasthan charge was set aside by the order dated 26th September 2024 and is not treated as a conviction or proof of present involvement. Nor are the respondent's apprehensions of revival of a narcotic network accepted as established merely because they are asserted in the reply. -1238-BA-2077-2025
15. I have considered the applicant's age, medical complaints and custody since 12th March, 2025, extending to approximately nineteen months. I have also noted that the trial is not yet started and matter is pending for framing of charge. This delay is a matter of concern and requires a definite direction for expedition. The right to a reasonably prompt trial cannot be disregarded merely because Section 37 applies. On the material presently placed, however, the custody undergone and the anticipated duration of proceedings do not yet furnish an independent ground for release after having regard to the circumstances supporting the alleged role of the applicant. This assessment must remain open to reconsideration if the trial do not advance with reasonable expedition. Completion of investigation, by itself, does not resolve the statutory conditions. Medical necessity must be considered on current specialist evidence; the outpatient urology opinion cannot be treated as resolving every renal concern. On the independent circumstances cumulatively assessed, I am unable to record reasonable grounds for believing that the applicant is not guilty of the alleged offences involving commercial quantity. Since the first statutory condition is not satisfied and both conditions are cumulative, regular bail cannot be granted to the applicant. It is unnecessary to make a speculative -1338-BA-2077-20…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:49097
-138-BA-2077-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 2077 OF 2025
WITH
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 1129 OF 2026
IN BA/2077/2025
JITENDRA MANEKLAL PANCHAL
VERSUS
THE INTELLIGENCE OFFICER, DIRECTORATE OF REVENUE
INTELLIGENCE (DRI)
......
Advocate for Applicant : Mr. Taraq Sayyed a/w Mr. Prashant M.
Nagargoje and Ms. Priya Dagade
Advocate for Respondent : Mr. Parikshit Dawalkar
......
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 12th OCTOBER, 2026
PER COURT :
1.
The applicant seeks regular bail in connection with
F.No.DRI/MZU/PuRU/ENQ-46/2023, pending as Special NDPS Case
No.77 of 2024 before the Special Court at Aurangabad. He is
accused no.4 and faces prosecution for offences punishable under
Sections 22, 27-A, 28 and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. He was arrested on 12 th
March, 2025.
2.
The respondent states that the investigation concerns
illicit manufacture and interstate distribution of drug mephedrone.
Searches at premises associated with accused no.1, Jiteshkumar
-238-BA-2077-2025
Premjibhai Hinhoriya, resulted in recovery of a packet recorded as
containing 2,960 grams of mephedrone from his residence and,
subsequently, a drum containing 107 litres of liquid from the
company Apex Medichem. The applicant is alleged to have financed
the activity and procured and distributed the manufactured
substance through consignments sent from Aurangabad by
courier. The original complaint was filed on 15 th February, 2024
and the supplementary complaint on 9th May, 2025.
3.
Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that the
case rests principally upon inadmissible statements under Section
67 of Accused No.1. He argues that Accused no.1 initially referred
to
Jitendra
Thakur
as
a
supplier
from
Ahmedabad,
but
subsequently named the applicant and alleged supplies in the
opposite direction. He submits that nothing was recovered from
the applicant during the entire investigation. The payments made
through Angadia Firms, even if accepted as alleged against the
applicant, are not connected with manufacture of the seized
contraband. The Learned Advocate also questions the procedure
adopted
by
the
Investigating
agency
about
photograph
identification which according to him is not recognised under the
law. He further submits that investigation has completely failed to
verify the sender's identity who allegedly send the consignment
-338-BA-2077-2025
and further more the non-recovery of the mobile handset allegedly
used for communication also serious dent in the investigation case
as it does not complete the evidential chain in a present case so as
to involve the present applicant as financier of the manufacture of
illicit drug. He relies upon the negative report concerning other
chemical samples, the orders of bail granted to other persons, the
applicant's age and medical ailments, completion of investigation
and charge-sheet filed, and the police-clearance certificate obtained
before his proposed holiday in Costa Rica as other grounds for his
release on bail.
4.
Learned Advocate for the respondent relying upon the
written reply, submits that the applicant's role is supported by
courier records, repeated cash remittances, identification by
Angadia personnel and mobile-location data corresponding with
parcel collection points. The respondent alleges use of the name
Raju bhai by the applicant to conceal his identity and use of mobile
numbers registered to other persons as one of the circumstance
supporting the prosecution case of involvement of the present
applicant in alleged crime. It further relies upon the applicant's
alleged admissions and his signatures acknowledging earlier
statements and Panchanama’s. According to the respondent, the
statements are corroborated admissions and can be considered
-438-BA-2077-2025
with the other evidence. The respondent also alleges noncooperation, flight risk and possible interference with witnesses,
and submits that the requirements of Section 37 of NDPS act are
not satisfied.
5.
Since the prosecution concerns commercial quantity
and includes offence under Section 27-A of the Act, the rigors of
Section 37 applies. According to section 37 of the Act, where the
prosecution opposes release, the Court must be satisfied that there
are reasonable grounds for believing that the applicant is not guilty
of the alleged offence and that he is not likely to commit any
similar offence while on bail. These conditions are cumulative. The
statutory belief must arise from the facts and circumstances of the
case and neither the gravity of the accusation nor the mere
assertion of a defence answers that requirement. The assessment
is provisional and does not demand a final finding of innocence. In
Narcotics Control Bureau v. Mohit Aggarwal , (2022) 18 SCC 374,
the Supreme Court emphasized consideration of independent
circumstances notwithstanding the inadmissibility of confessional
statements. In case of Union of India v. Vigin K. Varghese, 2025
SCC OnLine SC 2440, likewise requires appraisal of the prosecution
material and the rival contentions before recording satisfaction
under Section 37 of the Act; it does not dispense with the rules
-538-BA-2077-2025
governing admissibility.
6.
The respondent's submission that the applicant's self-
inculpatory statement becomes admissible merely by describing it
as an admission cannot be accepted. The alleged statement of
knowingly financing, receiving and distributing mephedrone is
confessional in substance. In the case of Tofan Singh v. State of
Tamil Nadu, (2021) 4 SCC 1, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that,
the voluntary character of the statement does not remove the bar
against its use as a confession. Nor can that bar be avoided by
relying upon signatures obtained while confronting the applicant
with earlier statements and Panchanama’s. Corroboration by other
piece of evidence also does not, by itself, make the confession
admissible. Permission to question accused no.1 in judicial custody
also does not convert the statement recorded by a DRI officer into a
confession recorded by a Magistrate. Accordingly, the alleged
confessional admissions of both accused persons needs to be kept
aside. The assessment that follows concerns independently
collected documents and the statements of persons describing
transactions they handled are subject to proof at trial. One accused
confession cannot be treated as independent corroboration of
another’s statement.
-638-BA-2077-2025
7.
The scientific evidence in the nature of chemical
analysers report does not support the submission of the Accused
that every factory recovery of contraband has tested negative.
Findings 21 and 36 of the CFSL report dated 18 th January, 2024
record positive finding of drug mephedrone in U-Original and AIOriginal, respectively. The inventory connects AI-Original with the
liquid drum recovered from Apex Medichem. The negative results
concerning other exhibits narrow the initial allegations, but do not
eliminate this positive recovery from the premises connected with
Accused no.1. It establishes the presence of mephedrone at the
premises concerned, although the applicant's connection with that
activity must be examined separately.
8.
That connection is not sought to be established by the
prosecution only through an accused statement as suggested by
the learned counsel for the Applicant. The statement of witnesses
Hasmukh Kumar Shankar Bhai Patel and Dignesh Kumar Mukund
Bhai Patel describe repeated dealings with a person known as Raju
bhai who deposited cash for remittance to Jitesh bhai (Accused
no.1) at Aurangabad. They identify the applicant through the
photograph shown to them by the investigating officer and refer to
the sender's contact number. Their statements are supported by
transaction details such as courier receipts and challans. No doubt,
-738-BA-2077-2025
photograph identification of the applicant is not conclusive, and the
admitted absence of formal identity verification and another
witness's inability to identify the applicant are relevant limitations
to such identification. Nevertheless, witnesses describing prior
dealings are not identifying a wholly unfamiliar person seen on a
single occasion. Their evidence and the accompanying records
cannot presently be discarded in their entirety. The allegedly
unlawful manner of conducting the cash-transfer business does not
itself prove the applicant's narcotic activity but equally does not
make the records of the transactions worthless.
9.
The courier and telecom evidence provides a further
circumstance against the present applicant. Consignments booked
by accused no.1 for delivery to Ahmedabad bear the receiver's
name as Raju bhai. Paragraph 29.2 of the complaint identifies two
numbers registered to the applicant and compares their locations
with the other numbers appearing in the courier and Angadia
records. It also sets out the location of mobile
number
9714753388, registered to the applicant, in the Ramol area on
eleven - twelve occasions when consignments arrived there.
Telecom records and certification accompany the material relied
upon. The relevance of this material lies in the repeated movement
of the applicant's registered number towards the collection area on
-838-BA-2077-2025
the recorded arrival dates. When this is considered with the
numbers and identity described in the financial and courier
records and the statements of witness from the Angadia office, the
chain of present applicant gets completed in the present offence.
This connection does not depend solely upon the untraced handset
or the confessions of the accused persons.
10.
The limits of that correlation are important. Tower
location does not precisely establish collection of a parcel or
conclusively prove use of every number by the applicant. The
courier
witnesses
did
not
open
the
parcels
and
cannot
independently establish their contents. Cash remittances, standing
alone, also do not establish a narcotic purpose. However, these
circumstances must be considered together with the scientifically
confirmed
factory
recovery,
the
independently
recorded
dispatches by accused no.1, the repeated location correspondence
and the witnesses' identification arising from earlier financial
dealings. The consignments were declared by the sender as food
items and were dispatched without commercial invoices. The
combined material prima facie indicates a continuing supply-andpayment arrangement between the applicant and accused no.1,
whose
associated
mephedrone.
The
premises
applicant's
yielded
alleged
manufacturing
of
drug
participation
is
thus
-938-BA-2077-2025
supported by circumstances beyond mere acquaintance or
occasional
telephone
contact.
The
possibility
of
lawful
pharmaceutical dealings has been considered, but the repeated
collection-location
pattern,
identification
arising
from
prior
dealings, cash remittances and manner of dispatch, taken together,
prevent the statutory belief that he was not involved. This
inference is confined to bail and does not establish that every
historical parcel contained mephedrone or that every remittance
financed its manufacture.
11.
Counsel rightly submits that every payment to a person
dealing in narcotics does not amount to financing under Section 27A. The prosecution must establish its connection with illicit
activity. Nevertheless, participation in a continuing conspiracy
need not be established only by tracing a particular remittance to
manufacture of the very packet seized from the residence. The
exact nature and purpose of the payments require evidence. The
precise aggregate also requires reconciliation; overlapping branch
figures and amounts concerning other senders cannot be added
indiscriminately. The present conclusion rests upon the course of
transactions and the accompanying circumstances, not an
assumed correctness of every figure. No final finding on the distinct
ingredients of Section 27-A is necessary at this stage. The
-1038-BA-2077-2025
independent
circumstances
also
support,
the
allegation
of
participation in the course of dealing concerning commercial
quantity under Section 29 read with Section 22. Section 37
therefore does not depend solely upon the prosecution's use of the
expression financing.
12.
The change between accused no.1's first and subsequent
statement is a legitimate defence argument. This Court does not
resolve it by preferring one confession over the other. The present
assessment rests on
the
independently collected
material.
Similarly, counsel's reliance upon the alleged use of part of the
money to repay a debt does not establish the lawful character of
the whole course of transactions. Absence of recovery from the
applicant and his non-ownership of the premises are relevant but
are not decisive where his alleged role concerns procurement,
distribution and conspiracy. The respondent's assertion that all
such considerations are irrelevant is therefore too broad; they
have been considered with the other circumstances.
13.
The earlier bail orders concern different positions.
Accused Saurabh Gondhalekar's order dated 9th September, 2024
considered the anti-cancer correspondence and his absence of
knowledge of accused no.1's activity; it did not proceed upon a
negative result for the Apex liquid sample. Accused Shekhar
-1138-BA-2077-2025
Pagar's order dated 25th October, 2024 considered his position as
an employee and the issue of direct control over the affairs of the
company. Accused Sandeep Kumawat's position was affected by
negative scientific findings concerning the recovery from Shri
Mahalaxmi Chemical Works and absence of other incriminating
material. The distinct financial, courier and telecom circumstances
concerning this applicant do not permit those reasons to be
transferred to him merely because the investigation is common.
Thus law of parity does not apply to the present applicant.
14.
The applicant was already named in the original
complaint. The record contains summons issued in January 2024
and postal material recording locked premises and an unclaimed
return. These circumstances answer the assertion that no
summons was issued, but do not conclusively establish actual
receipt or deliberate evasion. His interception during proposed
overseas travel is not proof of guilt, and the police-clearance
certificate relied upon by counsel does not adjudicate this
prosecution. The earlier Rajasthan charge was set aside by the
order dated 26th September 2024 and is not treated as a conviction
or proof of present involvement. Nor are the respondent's
apprehensions of revival of a narcotic network accepted as
established merely because they are asserted in the reply.
-1238-BA-2077-2025
15.
I
have
considered
the
applicant's
age,
medical
complaints and custody since 12th March, 2025, extending to
approximately nineteen months. I have also noted that the trial is
not yet started and matter is pending for framing of charge. This
delay is a matter of concern and requires a definite direction for
expedition. The right to a reasonably prompt trial cannot be
disregarded merely because Section 37 applies. On the material
presently placed, however, the custody undergone and the
anticipated duration of proceedings do not yet furnish an
independent ground for release after having regard to the
circumstances supporting the alleged role of the applicant. This
assessment must remain open to reconsideration if the trial do not
advance with reasonable expedition. Completion of investigation,
by itself, does not resolve the statutory conditions. Medical
necessity must be considered on current specialist evidence; the
outpatient urology opinion cannot be treated as resolving every
renal concern. On the independent circumstances cumulatively
assessed, I am unable to record reasonable grounds for believing
that the applicant is not guilty of the alleged offences involving
commercial quantity. Since the first statutory condition is not
satisfied and both conditions are cumulative, regular bail cannot be
granted to the applicant. It is unnecessary to make a speculative
-1338-BA-2077-2025
adverse finding on the likelihood of commission of another offence.
In the result, Application for bail of the applicant is rejected.
ORDER
a)
Bail Application No.2077 of 2025 is rejected.
b)
All observations are confined to bail, and the prosecution
shall be decided independently on the evidence.
c)
The applicant may seek appropriate relief upon a material
change in circumstance.
d)
The separate application on medical ground is disposed
of by this order, with direction that Superintendent of the
Prison
shall
ensure
timely
specialist
assessment,
treatment and any referral advised by the treating
doctors to the applicant pertaining to his medical ailment
without any delay.
e)
Criminal Application No.1129 of 2026 is also disposed of.
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
Tandale
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review