Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on 20.05.2026
Pronounced on. 03.06.2026
Uploaded on 03.06.2026
RP No. 79/2024
CM No. 6700/2024
Jindal Photo Ltd.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. P. N. Goja, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Abhinav Jamwal, Adv.
Q
Vs
U. T. of J&K and others
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Raman Sharma, (AAG) Sr. Adv. with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Adv.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Through the medium of present order, application bearing CM No.
6700/2024 filed by the petitioner, seeking condonation of 907 days’ delay in
filing the review petition as also the review petition filed in respect of order
dated 19.04.2022 passed in OWP No. 1057/2013, are proposed to be
disposed of.
2.
Heard and considered.
3.
It appears that the petitioner had filed a writ petition bearing OWP No.
1057/2013 before this Court seeking a direction upon the respondents for
release of outstanding payment on account of supply of Radiology items
along with interest at the rate of 18% per annum. In the writ petition, it was
alleged by the petitioner that pursuant to supply orders issued by the
respondents, the petitioner made supplies of various items to the respondents
from its factory at Samba on door delivery basis. However, amount on
account of cost of the supplied items was not released by the respondents in
favour of the petitioner despite repeated requests. According to the
petitioner, respondent No. 5 vide inter-departmental communication dated
27.09.2011 admitted its liability towards the petitioner to the tune of ₹30.32
lacs.
4.
The writ petition was contested by the respondents by filing its reply. In the
reply the respondents did not specifically deny the entitlement of the
petitioner to the outstanding amount and in fact, an affidavit came to be filed
by the respondents in which authenticity of communication dated
27.09.2011, (Annexure-K to the writ petition), was confirmed in terms of
communication dated 21.10.2021 issued by Medical Superintendent,
Government Bone and Joint Hospital, Barzulla, Srinagar.
5.
The learned Writ Court vide its order 19.04.2022, allowed the writ petition
and directed the respondents to release the admitted liability in terms of
Annexure-K amounting to ₹30.32 lacs in favour of the petitioner provided
the said amount has not been released in favour of the petitioner. The Writ
Court further directed that the admitted liability along with interest at the rate
of 6% be released within a period of six weeks from the date a certified copy
of the order is made available to them by the petitioner. It was also provided
that in case, the respondents fail to release the said amount within the
aforesaid period, the petitioner shall be held entitled to further interest at the
rate of 12% on the actual amount of liability.
RP No. 79/2024
6.
It seems that when the respondents did not release the amount in favour of
the petitioner in terms of order of the learned Writ Court passed on
19.04.2022, the petitioner filed a contempt petition, which was registered as
CCP(S) No. 297/2023. During the pendency of the contempt petition, the
respondents released an amount of ₹30.32 lacs along with interest at the rate
of 12% per annum on the aforesaid amount, which came to ₹3,63,840/-.
Thus, total amount of ₹34,06,302/- was released by the respondents in favour
of the petitioner. In terms of order dated 25.09.2024 passed by the Contempt
Court, the contempt proceedings were closed giving liberty to the petitioner
to seek appropriate remedy under law, as the petitioner had contended before
the Contempt Court that whole of the interest amount has not been released
by the respondents in his favour.
7.
It is in the above circumstances that the petitioner has filed the present
review petition seeking clarification of order dated 19.04.2022 passed by the
learned Writ Court. Along with the review petition, the petitioner has also
moved an application seeking condonation of delay of 904 days in filing the
review petition. The condonation of delay in filing the review petition has
been sought on the ground that the petitioner was pursuing the contempt
proceedings, which were filed on 10.10.2023 and were disposed of on
25.09.2024, whereafter, the present review petition came to be filed by the
petitioner on 19.11.2024. It has been submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioner that it is only when the respondents released the amount in favour
of the petitioner during the contempt proceedings and when the Contempt
Court refused to go into the issue as to from which date the respondents were
obliged to pay interest on the admitted amount that the petitioner had to file
RP No. 79/2024
the accompanying review petition. On this ground, condonation of delay that
has occasioned in filing the accompanying review petition is being sought.
8.
The aforesaid reasons assigned by the petitioner, for not filing the review
petition within the prescribed time of limitation, are clearly borne out from
the record of contempt petition. Having regard to the fact that the petitioner
was pursuing the contempt petition under a bona fide impression that the
ambiguity in the order of the writ court would be clarified in the contempt
proceedings, therefore, the reason assigned forms a sufficient cause for
preventing the petitioner from filing the review petition within the stipulated
period of limitation. Accordingly, the delay in filing the review petition is
condoned.
9.
That takes us to the merits of the review petition. It has been contended by
the petitioner that there has been an inadvertent mistake on the part of the
learned Writ Court in not mentioning the date from which the petitioner has
been held entitled to interest on the admitted liability and having regard to
the tone and tenor of the operative portion of the order passed by the learned
Writ Court, it can safely be inferred that the petitioner is entitled to interest
on the admitted liability from the date the said amount had become due to the
petitioner.
10.
Mr. Raman Sharma, learned AAG appearing on behalf of the respondents
has submitted that it is clear from the order of the learned Writ Court passed
on 19.04.2022, which is sought to be reviewed, that the interest was made
payable from the date of said order and because the respondents failed to
release the amount of admitted liability in favour of the petitioner within the
period as depicted in the said order, as such, the respondents have paid
RP No. 79/2024
interest on the admitted liability at the rate of 12% from the date of passing
of the order. Thus, no further amount is payable by the respondents to the
petitioner.
11.
In order to understand the controversy involved in the case, it would be apt
to notice the operative portion of order dated 19.04.2022, which is sought to
be reviewed. It reads as under:
“6. As the respondents are admitting their responsibility, therefore,
instead of keeping it as pending consideration, I propose to dispose of
this writ petition and as such the same is, disposed of, with a direction
to the respondents to release the admitted liability in terms of
Annexure-K i.e., a communication dated 27.09.2021 amounting to
Rs. 30.32 lakhs, provided the said balance amount has not already
been released. Let the respondents release the admitted liability along
with @6% within a period of six weeks from the date a certified copy
of this order is made available to them by the petitioner. In case, the
respondents fail to release the said amount within the aforesaid
period, the petitioner shall be held entitled further interest @12% on
the actual amount of liability.”
12.
From a perusal of the aforesaid order, it is clear that the same is silent as
regards the date from which the petitioner has been held entitled to interest
on the admitted amount. However, from a close analysis of the order sought
to be reviewed, particularly the sentence relating to payment of interest, it
appears that the petitioner has been held entitled to interest on the admitted
liability at the rate of 6%, if the amount is paid within six weeks of service of
said order upon the respondents and at the rate of 12%, if the respondents fail
to release the said amount within the period of six weeks.
13.
The phrase “let the respondents release the admitted liability along with
interest @ 6% within a period of six weeks from the date a certified copy of
the order is made available to them by the petitioner” would mean that the
time of compliance is fixed as six weeks. However, the said phrase does not
RP No. 79/2024
expressly specify, the date from which the interest is to run. In such a
situation, the judgment has to be construed reasonably and harmoniously. In
order to clear the ambiguity regarding date from which the interest on
outstanding liability is to be payable, the Court will have to look to the
pleadings, relief claim, nature of liability and context of the judgment.
14.
If we have a look at the relief claimed in the writ petition, it is clear that the
petitioner has sought release of admitted liability along with interest at the
rate of 18% per annum. The transaction between the petitioner and the
respondents is commercial in nature, inasmuch as, the petitioner, who is
operating the business of supply of radiology and allied items, has supplied
these implements/items to the respondents. So, it is not a case of
advancement of a friendly loan but it is a case of pure and simple
commercial transaction between the parties. Therefore, it has to be inferred
that the petitioner is entitled to interest on outstanding liability. In the
absence of date of commencement of interest in the judgment under review,
the petitioner is, at least, entitled to interest on the said amount from the date
of filing of the writ petition, otherwise, the award of interest on admitted
liability at the rate of 6%/12% by the Writ court would lose its significance.
If the learned Writ Court intended to decline pendente lite interest to the
petitioner, then it would have been specifically mentioned in the judgment by
providing that if the respondents fail to clear the liability within a particular
period only then the petitioner would be entitled to interest. However, in the
instant case, the learned Writ Court has specifically stated that the
respondents shall release the admitted liability along with interest at the rate
of 6%. This clearly indicates that the petitioner has been held entitled to
RP No. 79/2024
pendente lite interest at the rate of 6% per annum and he has also been held
entitled to future interest at the rate of 12% per annum for the period beyond
six weeks from the date copy of the judgement is received by the
respondents up to the date of realisation of full amount.
15.
For all what has been said, analysed and discussed hereinabove, present
review petition filed by the petitioner is allowed and order dated 19.04.2022
passed in OWP No. 1057/2013 is clarified by providing that the petitioner
shall be entitled to interest on the amount of ₹30.32 lacs from the date of
filing of the writ petition at rate of 6% per annum up to six weeks from the
date a certified copy of the judgment was made available by the petitioner to
the respondents and beyond this date, the petitioner shall be entitled to
interest at the rate of 12% per annum on the aforesaid amount of ₹30.32 lacs
till the date of payment by the respondents.
16.
The petition stands disposed of.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
Jammu
03.06.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
RP No. 79/2024
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review