Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
FAO No. 03 of 2018
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia,
Son of Late Sonam Topden Bhutia
R/o Children’s park, Tibet Road,
Gangtok, East Sikkim
APPELLANT (S)
VERSUS
1. Aishwarya Rai
D/o of Late Gyanson Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia
R/o Dokan Dara, Kurseong
Dist-Darjeeling, W.B
Also residing at
Lower Sichey, Gangtok, East Sikkim
2. General Public
RESPONDENT (S)
For appellant
:
Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharya, Advocate.
Mr. Souri Ghosal, Advocate.
For respondent no.1
:
Mr. N.B. Khatiwada, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. Navtara Sarda, Legal Aid Counsel.
For respondent no.2
:
None.
Date: 06-03-2021
CORAM :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JITENDRA KUMAR MAHESHWARI, CJ.
…
1.
This Appeal is filed by the defendant no.2/appellant questioning
the
legality
and
propriety
of
the
Judgment
of
remand
dated
25.09.2017 passed in Title Appeal Case No.04/2015 by the learned
District Judge, Special Division–I, East Sikkim at Gangtok arising out
of
the
Judgment
dated
24.07.2015
passed
against
the
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
plaintiff/respondent in Title Suit No.39/2014 by the Court of Civil
Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok dismissing the suit.
2.
The plaintiff filed the suit seeking declaration that she is the
daughter of Late Gyanson Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia inter alia
pleading that her father joined British army in the year 1966. The
people from Bhutia community were not recruited in British Army,
therefore, he changed his name as Gyanson Rai in place of Sonam
Topden Bhutia and joined the British Army. The said change of name
was only to secure job in British army. Later he married with Ms. Rupa
Rai nee Thakuri in 1976-77. Out of the said wedlock plaintiff was borne
at Hongkong in the year 1977.
3.
The plaintiff’s father, after spending almost 20 years in service at
Hongkong came to Kurseong on retirement and started living there.
Again after sometime he could get the job at Bahrain. Later he came
to Gangtok and stayed at Zigmee Building, old children Park, Gangtok.
The real identity of Gyanson Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia came to the
knowledge of the plaintiff after coming back of him from Bahrain. In
2014 plaintiff’s father died and his last rituals were performed as per
the traditions of the Bhutia community.
4.
In the said backdrop and pleading, the suit has been filed
seeking declaration that the plaintiff is the daughter of Gyanson Rai @
Sonam Topden Bhutia. In the suit no one appears as defendantdespite publication of notice. The said suit was dismissed by Learned
Trial Court. On filing an appeal the lower appellate Court by the
impugned judgment remitted the matter back to the Trial Court
because Jigmee P. Bhutia (defendant no.2/appellant) and the daughter
of plaintiff’s father were found necessary party to the suit. The
Appellate court observed their presence is necessary for effective and
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
complete adjudication and to settle the issue involved in the suit.
However, with the help of proviso of Section 99 and under Order 41
Rule 23A of the CPC by setting aside the impugned judgment and
decree of the Trial Court remitted the matter back restoring the suit to
its original number. The plaintiff is also allowed to amend the
pleadings to the extent required and to decide the suit in accordance
with law.
5.
Learned Counsel for the appellant has argued with vehemence
and submitted that the judgment of remand passed by learned Lower
Appellate Court is contrary to the spirit of the provisions of Order 41
Rule 23 A of the CPC, without reversing the findings recorded by the
Trial Court. It is argued as per Section 99 of CPC, on account of
misjoinder or non-joinder of the parties reversing or modifying the
decree for error or illegality not affecting the merit and jurisdiction is
not permissible. It is further argued the lower Appellate Court while
pronouncing the judgment granted liberty to the plaintiff to amend the
pleadings without affording opportunity of rebuttal. However, after
remand such an observation prejudices the defendant/appellant,
therefore, the judgment of remand passed by the learned Lower
Appellate Court is illegal and contrary to the settled law, which, may
be set aside. In support of his contention reliance has been placed on
the judgment of P. Purushottam Reddy and Ors vs. Pratap Steel
Ltd., reported in AIR 2002 SC 771. The reliance has further been
placed on the judgment of Ashwinkumar K. Patel vs. Upendra J.
Patel & Ors., reported in AIR 1999 SC 1125. In addition further
reliance has been placed on Promotha
Nagendra
Nath
Nath
Mazumdar
vs.
Mazumdar, reported in MANU/WB/0472/1929;
Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu vs. The Motor & General Traders,
reported AIR 1975 SC 1409, R.K Tombi vs. R.K Maipaksana Singh
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
& ors., reported in MANU/GH/0134/2002; Municipal Corporation,
Hyderabad vs. Sunder Singh, reported in AIR 2008 SC 2579;
Mukund Ramchandra Kolapkar vs. Kisan Tryambak Gaikwad &
ors., reported
in MANU/MH/1366/2008; Rajinder
Sharma
vs.
Arpana Sharma, reported in AIR 2011 SC 3161. In view of the said
submissions, prayer is made to set aside the judgment of remand
directing the Lower Appellate Court to decide the appeal on merit as
per law.
6.
Per
contra,
learned
Senior
Counsel
representing
plaintiff/respondent contends that certainly as per Section 99 of CPC
Judgment and decree cannot be reversed or modified by way of
remand in an appeal on account of misjoinder or non-joinder or some
other defects or irregularity in any proceedings not affecting the merits
of the case and also the jurisdiction; but the proviso makes it clear
that the substantive provision of Section 99 CPC would not attract in a
case of non-joinder of “necessary” party. He placed reliance on the
judgments
of
Remco
Industrial
Workers
House
Building
Cooperative Society vs. Lakshmeesha M. & Ors., reported in AIR
2003 SC 3167; Jaibunnisha Bibi vs. Sk. Jalaluddin & Ors.,
reported in MANU/OR/0735/2008; J. Balaji Singh vs. Diwakar Cole
& Ors., reported in AIR 2017 SC 2402; Radhakrishnan P.S vs. A.
Indu, reported in ILR 2018 (3) Kerala 820; Jose vs. Johnson,
reported in 2020 (3) SCC 780. It is said Lower Appellate Court has not
committed any error of law while exercising the jurisdiction and
directing remand. It is urged the impugned Order passed by the
learned Lower Appellate Court is in conformity to law, which do not
warrant any interference.
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
7.
In the present case looking to the findings recorded by the
Appellate Court, the appellant as well another sister of the plaintiff
were found “necessary” party, looking to the nature of the declaration
prayed in the suit. Therefore, by the aid of proviso to Section 99 and
as per the procedure prescribed under Order 41 Rule 23 A of CPC
reversing the decree of the Trial Court and by recording finding that
re-trial considered necessary in the facts of the case remand has been
directed.
8.
After having heard learned Counsel representing the parties in
the facts of the case, it is required to be seen whether the Order
passed by the learned Lower Appellate Court directing remand is
within the purview of Proviso to Section 99 and the procedure
prescribed under Rule 23A of Order 41 of CPC or the Lower Appellate
Court acceded from its power while passing the impugned Judgment.
9.
On perusal of the relevant provisions, as per Section 99, the
decree, if any, passed by the trial Court shall not be reversed or
substantially varied nor the case shall be remanded in appeal merely
due to misjoinder or non-joinder of the parties or causes of action or
any error, defect or irregularity in any proceedings in the suit not
effecting the merit of the case or jurisdiction of the court. But the
proviso puts an embargo to the applicability of the provisions of
Section 99, in case of non-joinder of “necessary” party found by the
Court. Thus it is clear, due to non-joinder of “necessary” party, in view
of proviso, aid of Section 99 CPC would not available to the appellant.
The lower Appellate Court recorded the findings that appellant and
another sister of plaintiff are “necessary party” to the suit, in the
context of the relief as prayed therein.
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
10.
As per Order 41 Rule 23 of the CPC remand by the Appellate
Court, may be directed when the suit is decided on any primary point
reversing the decree. The Appellate Court can further direct to decide
the issue or issues by re-admitting the suit on its original number, as
per law after recording the evidence. Rule 23 A of Order 41 CPC was
inserted by Act of 104 of 1976 w.e.f. 01.02.1977 by which as specified
if the suit has been decided otherwise then on preliminary point and if
re-trial is considered necessary by Appellate Court reversing the
decree under appeal, the remand can be directed. As per Rule 25
which as exist was prior to the said amendment makes it clear that in
case the Trial Court omitted to frame or try any issue or to determine
any question of facts which the Appellate Court deems it essential for
decision of the suit on merit, after framing the issue and referring the
same for trial to the Court who passed the decree, may direct to take
such evidence as required while remanding. Similarly, on bringing the
additional evidences on record under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC, the
Appellate Court may either directly take the evidence or direct the Trial
Court to take such evidence and send back to the Appellate Court.
While taking such additional evidence on record as allowed by the
Appellate Court he shall specify the points on which the evidence
ought to be taken. Therefore, looking to the aforesaid it is apparent
that remand is permissible if a suit is decided on preliminary issue as
per Rule 23 and if re-trial considered necessary as per Rule 23A and
on any issue which in the opinion of the Court is required to be
decided essentially as per Rule 25 and for taking the additional
evidence as per Rule 28 and 29 of Order 41 of CPC.
11.
On perusal of the impugned judgment and facts of the case, it is
not in dispute that the Judgment of remand passed by the learned
Lower Appellate Court is in exercise of the power under Rule 23 A of
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
the Order 41 of the CPC with the aid of Proviso to Section 99 of CPC,
therefore, to the said extent it may be seen such remand is in
conformity to law, or not permissible.
12.
As referred above, by way of Act No.104 w.e.f 01.02.1977 Rule
23A is inserted in Order 41 of CPC. As per proviso to Section 99 it is
apparent that the provisions of the Section 99 would not be attracted if
a defect of non-joinder of “necessary” party is there. The legislative
intent is clear that remand of any judgment by Appellate Court is not
permissible for a formal defect but cannot be denied if defect of nonjoinder of “necessary” party is there, in particular when re-trial
considered necessary. The wholesale remand can be ordered, if the
Court opined that re-trial is considered necessary, reversing the
decree, under Rule 23A, akin to the power of Rule 23.
13.
The reliance placed by learned Counsel for the appellant on a
judgment of P. Purushottam Reddy (supra) throw light to the
powers of the Appellate Court, how the power ought to be exercised
under Rule 23 A of Order 41 of CPC. The relevant of paragraph 9 is
reproduced as thus:“ In 1976, Rule 23-A has been inserted in Order 41 which provides for
a remand by an appellate court hearing an appeal against a decree if
(i) the trial court disposed of the case otherwise than on a preliminary
point, and (ii) the decree is reversed in appeal and a retrial is
considered necessary. On twin conditions being satisfied, the appellate
court can exercise the same power of remand under Rule 23-A as it is
under Rule 23. After the amendment, all the cases of wholesale
remand are covered by Rules 23 and 23-A. In view of the express
provisions of these Rules, the High Court cannot have recourse to its
inherent powers to make a remand because, as held in Mahendra
Manilal Nanavati v. Sushila Mahendra Nanavati [AIR 1965 SC 364 : 66
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
Bom LR 681] (AIR at p. 399), it is well settled that inherent powers
can be availed of ex debito justitiae only in the absence of express
provisions in the Code. It is only in exceptional cases where the court
may now exercise the power of remand dehors Rules 23 and 23-A. To
wit, the superior court, if it finds that the judgment under appeal has
not disposed of the case satisfactorily in the manner required by Order
20 Rule 3 or Order 41 Rule 31 CPC and hence it is no judgment in the
eye of law, it may set aside the same and send the matter back for
rewriting the judgment so as to protect valuable rights of the parties.
An appellate court should be circumspect in Ordering a remand when
the case is not covered either by Rule 23 or Rule 23-A or Rule 25 CPC.
An unwarranted Order of remand gives the litigation an undeserved
lease of life and, therefore, must be avoided.”
14.
On perusal of above, it is clear that inherent powers at the
appellate Court can be availed ex debito justitiae only in the absence
of express provisions in the Code. In the exceptional cases the Court
can exercise the power of remand dehors the Rule 23 and 23 A of the
Order 41 CPC. As per the ratio of the said judgment in exceptional
cases the Court may exercise the power of remand even dehors the
Rule 23 and 23 A of the Order 41 of the CPC. Thus, after the
amendment Act No.104, dated 01.02.1977, as per proviso to Section
99 if there is a defect of non-joinder of “necessary” party and the
Lower Appellate Court if records a finding that re-trial is necessary, by
setting aside the decree of Trial Court, the Appellate Court may direct
remand in exercise of the powers of Rule 23 or 23A of CPC or even
dehors the rule in exceptional cases, in view of ratio of the above
judgment.
15.
Looking to the position of law as discussed above, the finding
recorded by the Lower Appellate Court is required to be looked into. As
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
per the said finding it is clear that defendant no.2/appellant and
daughter of Late Gyanson Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia were found to
be the “necessary party” being legal heir, to pass a declaratory decree
sought by the plaintiff. The nature of the declaration in the present
case sought by the plaintiff is that she be declared the daughter of
Late Gyanson Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia, however, in the said
circumstances, joining appellant (son) and daughter of the Late
Gyanson Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia was rightly found “necessary
party” by the Lower Appellate Court. It is to observe that appellant has
not said that they are not the necessary party and not assailed such
findings. Once the Court found the son and daughter of Late Gyanson
Rai @ Sonam Topden Bhutia are the “necessary party” in a suit filed
for declaration by the plaintiff who is his other daughter, there is no
impediment in remanding the case after following the procedure as
contemplated under Rule 23 and 23A of Order 41 of CPC.
16.
Now reverting to the arguments advanced that finding of the
Trial Court has not been reversed and in absence thereto mere finding
that re-trial considered necessary is not sufficient to remand the case.
As per the language of Order 41 Rule 23A of CPC the remand may be
directed otherwise then on a preliminary point on satisfying twin
conditions; (i) reversing the decree passed by the Trial Court (ii) if the
Court for the reasons so stated considered re-trial necessary. In the
present case on account of non-joinder of “necessary party”, the Lower
Appellate Court
formed
the opinion
that
re-trial
is
considered
necessary, however, reversing the decree the remand has been
directed. It is to observe that as per the requirement of law finding,
recorded by the Trial Court is not required to be reversed infact the
decree is required to be reversed. Therefore, arguments advanced by
the Counsel for the appellant regarding non reversal of the finding of
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
the Trial Court by the Lower Appellate Court is misplaced and cannot
be countenanced. In addition as per the ratio of the case of P.
Purushottam Reddy (supra) after amendment in CPC, the remand
even dehors to the Rule 23 and 23A is permissible in exceptional
cases. But in the present case, as discussed above, the Order
impugned is within the purview of Rule 23 and 23A of the Order 41
CPC. Therefore, the said judgment is of no help to appellant.
17.
On perusal of the facts, it is apparent that the case at hand is a
case wherein the remand has been directed otherwise then only on a
preliminary point, recording the finding that in the facts the re-trial is
considered necessary. In the said context the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jegannathan vs. Raju Sigamani reported in
(2012) 5 SCC 540 can be profitably referred by which Apex Court has
reiterated the scope of Order 41 Rule 23 A of the CPC specifying the
power of the Appellate Court directing remand. Therefore, relying upon
the said judgment and looking at the nature of the finding recorded by
the Lower Appellate Court, in the opinion of this Court, the case at
hand is a case in which the power under Order 41 Rule 23 and 23 A
read with Proviso to Section 99 of the CPC has rightly been exercised
by Lower Appellate Court, having no scope of interference in this
appeal.
18.
It is made it clear here, that this Court has not dealt with the
provision of remand, as specified in Rule 23, Rule 25, Rule 28, and 29
of Order 41 of CPC, in extentio therefore, ratio of this judgment is
confined to the scope of the Order 41 Rule 23A read with proviso of
Section 99 of the CPC. Those questions of law and its interpretation
are left open, for decision in appropriate cases.
FAO No.03 of 2018
(Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.)
19.
On perusal of the records and the Order sheets of the Lower
Appellate Court of the present case, it appears that after joining
appellant herein as a party, he appeared in the Court and permitted to
cross-examine the witnesses of the plaintiff without filing any written
statement. As per interim Order dated 06.06.2017 passed in first
appeal, while
rejecting
the
objection
filed
by
plaintiff
on
the
Commissioner’s report, the Court observed on account of affording due
opportunity to plaintiff application for adjournment was rightly rejected
by the Commissioner. On perusal of the provisions of Order 18 Rule 4
and Order 26 of CPC in the opinion of this Court no power are vested
to the Commissioner to decide any application filed by any of the
parties until directed by the Court. In the Order of appointment of the
Commissioner also no such power is given to the Commissioner by the
Court, therefore, Commissioner cannot decide any such application
and such Order cannot be acknowledged by Court while rejecting the
objection of the plaintiff. In the opinion of this Court such Order is
prejudicial to the parties, therefore, it be not given affect to.
20.
It is to observe here, the other judgments cited by the Counsel
for the appellant or the respondents are not required to be adverted to
in detail as it is not dealing the issues similar to this case and that too
on the cost of making the judgment lengthy for no justifiable reason,
therefore, those cases are not referred here.
21.
Accordingly, in view of the above discussion, this appeal fails and
is hereby dismissed. The Order passed by learned Lower Appellate
Court is hereby upheld with an observation that the parties are at
liberty to take recourse of law as permissible while deciding the suit
afresh on its restoration.
Avi/ Approved for reporting: yes
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review