Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF JULY 2024 / 1ST SRAVANA, 1946
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 22.07.2023 IN AS NO.34 OF 2017 OF
ASSISTANT
SESSIONS
COURT/SUB
COURT/COMMERCIAL
COURT,
CHAVAKKAD
ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 21.07.2017 IN OS NO.50 OF
2008 OF MUNSIFF COURT,CHAVAKKAD
APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS 7, 8 & 10:
JAYASREE
AGED 51 YEARS
D/O. KAMALAKSHI AMMA,
NJARENGATTU HOUSE,
CHOWANNUR VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR,
PIN - 680517
JAYAPRAKASH
AGED 49 YEARS
S/O. KAMALAKSHI AMMA
NJARENGATTU HOUSE,
CHOWANNUR VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR - .,
PIN - 680517
RATHEESH
AGED 40 YEARS
S/O. KAMALAKSHI AMMA
NJARENGATTU HOUSE,
CHOWANNUR VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN – 680517
BY ADVS.
K.B.GANGESH
SMITHA CHATHANARAMBATH
ATHIRA A.MENON
HARISANKAR.K.V.
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF 2 TO 12,14 TO 20 AND DEFENDANTS 1 TO
6,9 AND 11 TO 14 & SUPPLEMENTARY RESPONDENTS:
RADHA
AGED 69 YEARS
D/O. PARUKKUTTYAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
SASIDARAN
AGED 55 YEARS
S/O. RADHA
MANGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR, PIN - 680516
SUDHAKARAN
AGED 50 YEARS
S/O. RADHA
MANGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
SUNILKUMAR
AGED 46 YEARS
S/O. RADHA
MANGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
DAKSHYANIAMMA
AGED 55 YEARS
D/O. PARUKKUTTYAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
SARALA
AGED 60 YEARS
D/O. DAKSHAYANIAMMA
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
SUMATHI
AGED 56 YEARS
D/O. DAKSHAYANIAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
SADANATHAN
AGED 60 YEARS
S/O. DAKSHAYANIAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
SUKUMARAN
AGED 63 YEARS
S/O. DAKSHAYANIAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
GOPALAKRISHNAN
AGED 65 YEARS
S/O. PARUKKUTTYAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
RAJAN
AGED 64 YEARS
S/O. PARUKKUTTYAMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
BALAKRISHANAN NAIR
AGED 75 YEARS
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
S/O. KRISHNANKUTTY NAIR
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
RAVEENDRAN NAIR
S/O. NARAYANAN NAIR
PADINJAROTT HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
DAKSHAYANI AMMA
AGED 75 YEARS
W/O. MAGALATH VALAPPIL NARAYANAN NAIR,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR - 680516
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT NO. J78
ANJANEYA BLOCK SESHARIPURAM,
BANGALORE -,
PIN - 560020
SARALA
AGED 60 YEARS
D/O. NARAYANAN PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
SUMATHI
AGED 58 YEARS
D/O. MAGALATH VALAPPIL NARAYANAN NAIR,
NO. J78 ANJANEYA BLOCK
SESHARIPURAM,
BANGALORE -,
PIN - 560020
SADANANDHAN M,
AGED 54 YEARS
S/O. MAGALATH VALAPPIL NARAYANAN NAIR,
NO. J78 ANJANEYA BLOCK
SESHARIPURAM,
BANGALORE -,
PIN - 560020
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
SUKUMARAN M
AGED 52 YEARS
S/O. MAGALATH VALAPPIL NARAYANAN NAIR,
NO. J78 ANJANEYA BLOCK
SESHARIPURAM,
BANGALORE -,
PIN - 560020
PADMAVATHI AMMA
AGED 87 YEARS
D/O. MAGALATH VALAPPIL LAKSHIMIKUTTY AMMA,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
VALSALA
AGED 55 YEARS
D/O. PADMAVADI AMMA
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
SAVITHRI(DIED)
AGED 54 YEARS
W/O. GOPALAKRISHNAN
ARAYAMPARAMBATH HOUSE,
PARAPPUR P.O
MULLOOR,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680552
GEETHA
W/O. PULITHAILAYIL MURALI
MARATHOMKODU P.O,
VELLITHIRUTHI
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 676616
SOBHA
AGED 47 YEARS
W/O KUNNATHEL SURESH KUMAR @ BABU
PUNNAYURKKULAM P.O,
THRISSUR -,
PIN – 676616
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
NJARENGATT KAMALAKSHIAMMA
AGED 75 YEARS
W/O. MAGALATH VALAPPIL RAMAN NAIR,
CHOWANNUR VILLAGE, DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680617
RAJALEKSHMI
AGED 47 YEARS
D/O. KAMALAKSHIAMMA
NJARENGATT HOUSE,
CHOWANNUR VILLAGE,
DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680617
LATHA
AGED 47 YEARS
W/O. NARAYANAN MADAMBATH HOUSE,
CHALISSERY TALUK,
VILLAGE PATTISSERY DESOM,
OTTAPPALAM TALUK
PALAKKAD -,
PIN - 679536
SREEDEVI AMMA
AGED 83 YEARS
W/O. KRISHNAN NAIR
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -, PIN - 680516
VIDHU BALA
D/O. KRISHNAN NAIR,
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE,
DESOM,
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
VINOD
S/O. KRISHNAN NAIR,
MAGALATH VALAPPIL HOUSE,
PERUMBILAVE VILLAGE,
DESOM,
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
THIS
ADMISSION
TALAPPILLY TALUK,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680516
GOPIKA
AGED 29 YEARS
D/O. ARAYAMPARAMBATH GOPALAKRISHNAN & SAVITHRY,
PARAPPUR P.O
MULLOOR,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680551
SREEJITH
AGED 25 YEARS
S/O. ARAYAMPARAMBATH GOPALAKRISHNAN & SAVITHRY,
PARAPPUR P.O
MULLOOR,
THRISSUR -,
PIN - 680551
REGULAR
ON
SECOND
23.07.2024,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
APPEAL
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
JUDGMENT
1. The defendants 7, 8 and 10 in a suit for partition have
filed this Regular Second Appeal. The parties are
referred according to their status before the Trial Court.
2. The plaintiffs filed the suit for partition of plaint schedule
properties claiming that the plaint schedule properties
are set apart to the Thavazhi (Branch) of the plaintiffs
and the defendants as per Ext.A1 Partition Deed of
3003/1088 M.E of Kunnamkulam SRO and are liable to
be partitioned among the plaintiffs and the defendants
who are co-owners of the said properties.
3. The defendants 6 to 10 contested the suit raising an
independent right over two items of properties having
extent of 25 Cents and 45 cents covered by Ext.B2
Purchase Certificate No.1430/1977 from Mullassery
Land Tribunal which is obtained by the Raman Nair, who
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
is their predecessor .
4. The Trial Court rejected the independent right claimed by
the defendants 6 to 10 and passed Preliminary decree
for partition of the plaint schedule properties among the
plaintiffs and the defendants. Though the defendants 7, 8
and 10 filed appeal before the First Appellate Court, the
same was also dismissed confirming the judgment and
decree of the First Appellate Court.
5. This Regular Second Appeal is filed against the
concurrent findings of the Trial Court as well as the First
Appellate Court.
6. I heard the learned counsel for the appellant Sri.
Gangesh P.B.
7. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the
plaintiffs have not challenged Ext.B2 purchase certificate.
Ext.B2 Purchase Certificate is of the year 1977.
According to him, if the plaintiffs had any grievance
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
against Ext.B2 Purchase Certificate, they ought to have
challenged
the
same
in
appropriate
proceedings.
According to him so long as Ext. B2 Purchase Certificate
subsists, the Trial Court as well as the Appellate Court
ought to have excluded the property covered by the said
Purchase Certificate from the properties found to be
partible.
8. From the impugned judgments, it is clear that the Raman
Nair who is the predecessor of defendants 6 to 10 is one
of the members of the same Thavazhy. He is claiming
right through one Govindan Nair and on the basis of the
such claim he obtained Ext.B2 Purchase Certificate. No
documents were produced by the defendants 6 to 10 to
prove that how the said property belonged to Govindan
Nair. The Trial Court found that the property covered by
Ext.B2 Purchase Certificate is part of the property
covered by Ext.A1 Partition Deed. On the other hand, the
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
First Appellate Court found that it is not clear whether
Ext.B2 property is included in Ext. A1 Partition Deed.
Whatever that may be, when the defendants 6 to 10
claims independent right through one Govindan Nair the
defendants 6 to 10 should have adduced evidence to
show that Govindan Nair had title over the property.
9. It is seen from Ext. A1 document of the year 1088 M.E
that Thrippalassery Devaswom is the jenmy(landlord) of
the property. If Thrippalassery Devaswom is the jenmy,
Thrippalassery Devaswom and Taravadu of the plaintiffs
and the defendants should have been impleaded as
landlord and intermediary in Ext.B2 proceedings. There
is specific findings entered into by the Trial Court that
there is no evidence that the title holder or intermediary
was impleaded in the Land Tribunal proceedings. Hence
the Trial Court as well as the
Appellate Court rightly
discarded the claim on the basis of Ext.B2 purchase
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
certificate.
10.
The learned counsel for the appellant cited the
decision of this Court in Thayukutty v. Manikandan
[2023 KHC 886]
and contented that remedy of the
person aggrieved by a purchase certificate is to file an
appeal before the Appellate Tribunal as provided under
the Kerala Land Reforms Act. But in Paragraph 21 of the
very same decision it is held that when the purchase
certificate is inaccurate on its face, or obtained by fraud,
the evidentiary value of the Purchase certificate could not
be disregarded and that doubtlessly, a purchase
certificate shall not bind a party, who is not a party to the
proceedings before the Land Tribunal having better title
of the property covered by the purchase certificate. In
view of the aforesaid findings in the said decision, the
said decision is not applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the case as neither the Thrippalassery
RSA NO. 378 OF 2024
Devaswam nor Tharavadu of the
plaintiffs and the
defendants were impleaded in the Land Tribunal
proceedings. I do not find any illegality in the judgments
passed by the Trial Court as well as the Appellate Court.
11.
Accordingly the Regular Second Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/-
sms
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review