Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.940 of 2022
Jayanti Bhattacharjee,
Wife of Sri Suman Bhattacharjee, resident of Village-Joynagar,
Lane-4, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, Sub-division-Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799001, aged about 40 years.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The Tripura University, represented by its Registrar, Tripura University,
Suryamaninagar, Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799022.
2. The Vice-Chancellor, Tripura University, Suryamaninagar, Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799022.
3. The Registrar, Tripura University, Suryamaninagar, Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799022.
….Respondent(s)
[[
[[
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mrs. R. Chakraborty, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. T. Debbarma, Advocate
Date of hearing
and delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
09/01/2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
[
By means of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for regularization with regular scales of pay under the respondents. The
petitioner has further prayed for revoking/rescinding the impugned order dated
30.09.2022(Annexure-17 to the writ petition) wherein it was notified that the
wages of the petitioner would be regulated @ Rs.1200/- per day for office
working days w.e.f. 03.01.2022.
2.
Facts:
The seminal facts relevant to decide the controversy raised in this
writ petition may be reproduced hereunder:
2.1.
Pursuant to an advertisement dated 04.06.2008, issued by
Registrar, Tripura University(Central), the petitioner, through a regular
selection process was selected and accordingly appointed as Lecturer under
BBA programme on contractual basis in the School of Management, Tripura
University under memorandum dated 20.01.2009(Annexure-2 to the writ
petition). The contractual period of the service of the petitioner was extended
time to time. During such renewal of the contractual period, the post held by
the petitioner was re-designated as Assistant Placement Officer(Contractual)
vide memorandum dated 02.02.2016(Annexure-5 to the writ petition). The last
extension of the service of the petitioner as Assistant Placement
Officer(Contractual) was extended under memorandum dated 28.12.2020
issued by the Registrar(I/c), Tripura University for a period of one year w.e.f.
02.01.2021 to 01.01.2022 with one day break on 01.01.2021(Annexure-15 to
the writ petition) and it came to an end w.e.f. 02.01.2022. Thereafter, no
extension was made. The petitioner submitted representations to consider the
extension of her contractual service as she was facing serious financial crisis.
2.2.
It is the case of the petitioner that she was performing her duties
under the respondents-Tripura University even after the expiry of the
contractual period and for that reason, she claimed monthly salaries with
arrears of pay. On consideration of repeated representations submitted by the
petitioner, the respondents-Tripura University had issued a fresh office order
dated 30.09.2022 notifying her engagement as daily wage basis and it was
stipulated that the wages of the petitioner as Assistant Placement
Officer(Contractual), Tripura University would be regulated @Rs.1200/- per
day for office working days w.e.f. 03.01.2022 and the total wages payable for
her working days w.e.f. 03.01.2022 to 20.08.2022 is Rs.1,82,400/- only.
2.3.
Feeling shocked, the petitioner submitted a representation to the
Vice-Chancellor, Tripura University on 17.10.2022 inter alia urging to recall
the order dated 30.09.2022 and further praying for issuance of a formal order
of regularization of her service. Having found no response, the petitioner has
challenged the action of the respondents-Tripura University by presenting the
instant writ petition before this Court.
3.
On the aforesaid background facts, I have heard Mr. Somik Deb,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mrs. R. Chakraborty, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. T. Debbarma, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents-Tripura University.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner:
4.1.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the action of the respondents-Tripura University is pre-judicial to the
interest of the petitioner and the office order regulating her service on daily
basis @ Rs.1200/- per working day is unwarranted and arbitrary and therefore,
the said order dated 30.09.2022(Annexure-17 to the writ petition) is liable to
be quashed. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has strongly contended that the
petitioner was appointed through a regular selection process and served the
respondent-Tripura University for more than 14 years which entails her to
claim regularization of her service as Assistant Professor/Associate Professor
in the post of BBA programme. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has further
contended that re-designation of the post of the petitioner as Assistant
Placement Officer(Contractual) was illegal and arbitrary vis-à-vis pre-judicial
to the interest of the petitioner since she was appointed as Lecturer against the
post of BBA programme. Learned senior counsel has persistently tried to
persuade this Court that since 2008 the petitioner has been serving under the
respondents-Tripura University, firstly, as Lecturer under BBA programme
and thereafter, since 2016 as Assistant Placement Officer and refusing to
extend the contractual period of the service of the petitioner the respondentsTripura University has put her in acute hardship.
4.2.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has strongly placed reliance
upon a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Somesh Thapliyal and Anr.
v. Vice Chancellor, H.N.B. Garhwal University and Anr., reported in (2021)
10 SCC 116 to substantiate the claim of the petitioner that though she was
appointed on contractual basis, but, by elapse of over 14 years, her service
should not be treated as contractual but regular service since she was
appointed through a regular selection process by the competent authority.
5.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents-Tripura University:
5.1.
Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel for the respondents-Tripura
University has vehemently opposed the submissions of the petitioner. To
counter the submissions of learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner,
Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel for the respondents-Tripura University has
submitted that the very appointment of the petitioner was on contractual basis.
Reliance being placed on the decision of the Constitution Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka and Ors. v.
Umadevi (3) and Ors., reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1, Mr. Debbarma, learned
counsel for the respondents-Tripura University has submitted that the
Constitution Bench has categorically held that “if it is a contractual
appointment, the appointment comes to an end at the end of the contract”. At
para 45 of Umadevi(3)(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has further
observed that “While directing that appointments, temporary or casual, be
regularized or made permanent, the courts are swayed by the fact that the
person concerned has worked for some time and in some cases for a
considerable length of time. It is not as if the person who accepts an
engagement either temporary or casual in nature, is not aware of the nature of
his employment. He accepts the employment with open eyes. It may be true
that he is not in a position to bargain – not at arm’s length – since he might
have been searching for some employment so as to eke out his livelihood and
accepts whatever he gets. But on that ground alone, it would not be
appropriate to jettison the constitutional scheme of appointment and to take
the view that a person who has temporarily or casually got employed should
be directed to be continued permanently.”
5.2.
Drawing my attention to the counter affidavit filed by the
respondents-Tripura University, Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel has submitted
that the petitioner has not requisite qualification since she is not NET/
SLET/SET qualified which is an essential condition to get appointed as
Assistant Professor/Associate Professor under the UGC regulations. Mr.
Debbarma, learned counsel has further urged this Court to reject the claims of
the petitioner and to vacate the interim order under which the respondentsTripura University is paying her last pay.
6.
Analysis:
I have given my conscious thought to the submissions advanced
by learned counsel appearing for the parties.
6.1.
At the very outset, I have taken note of the advertisement dated
04.06.2008 issued by the respondents and the advertisement clearly manifests
that it invited applications for the post of Lecturer under BBA programme on
contractual basis for one year which might be extended on annual basis. The
petitioner had fulfilled the requisite qualifications as mentioned in the said
advertisement. Thereafter, I have taken note of the memo. dated 20.01.2009
whereunder the petitioner was appointed as Lecturer under BBA programme
on contract basis in the School of Management, Tripura University on a
consolidated pay of Rs.15,000/- per month for a period of 1(one) year from
the date of joining. Undisputedly, the contractual period of service of the
petitioner was extended from time to time till the year 2016 when the post of
Lecturer under BBA programme was re-designated under memorandum dated
02.02.2016 issued by the Registrar, Tripura University(A Central University).
The petitioner though filed representations raising her grievance against redesignation of her post, but, ultimately accepted such re-designation and
continued to work till last extension order expired on 02.01.2022.
6.2.
It is settled proposition of law that contractual service, however
long it is will not confer any right upon the employee to claim
absorption/regularization. There is no quarrel at the bar as regards to the
proposition that if the appointment is purely on contractual basis, such
appointment would come to an end at the end of the contract period and the
Court has no right to extend the period of the contract. The aforesaid view of
mine
is
reinforced
by
the
decision
of
the
Supreme
Court
in
Umadevi(3)(supra).
6.3.
At this juncture, I have considered the case of Somesh
Thapliyal(supra) as referred to by learned senior counsel for the petitioner.
Having gone through the facts of the case of Somesh Thapliyal(supra), it is
evinced that Somesh Thapliyal was appointed as a Teacher in the Department
of Pharmaceutical Sciences which was a constituent teaching department
under H.N.B. Garhwal University, a State University governed by Uttar
Pradesh State Universities Act, 1973(for short, 1973 Act). The teaching
posts(Lecturer/Reader),
later
on
re-designated
as
Associate
Professor/Assistant Professor were created by the Executive Council which is
the Statutory Authority of the University as per Section 19(a) of the 1973 Act
from the year 1997 to 2006. In the year 2004, the University had issued an
advertisement No.34 dated 04.02.2004 to hold regular selection of teaching
posts of the Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences including teaching posts
of various departments. Somesh Thapliyal was selected along with other
candidates considering his academic qualifications. In the appointment order
issued in favour of Somesh Thapliyal it was incorporated that appointment of
Somesh was on contract basis initially for 3(three) years which was extended.
6.4.
In the context of the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that the appointment of the petitioner was indeed on substantive basis. It was
further observed that H.N.B. Garhwal University was converted to a Central
University under the Central Universities Act, 2009 and it took over the assets
and liabilities of University created under the 1973 Act, protecting rights and
interests of the persons employed in the University before the creation of the
Central University in terms of Section 4(d) of the said Act.
6.5.
Moreso, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Somesh Thapliyal(supra)
had noticed that the communication dated 14.08.2020 was made by the
respondents-University wherein the UGC had been informed that the faculty
members of the Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences were working against
the sanctioned posts from time to time in compliance with the norms of
AICTE/PCI and they were appointed as per the required qualification and
procedure of selection as provided under the 1973 Act. In that context, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Somesh Thapliyal(supra) held that:[SCC p 135
para 50,51]
“50. In the instant case, after the teaching posts in the Department of
Pharmaceutical Sciences have been duly sanctioned and approved by the University
Grants Commission of which a detailed reference has been made, supported by the
letter sent to the University Grants Commission dated 14-8-2020 indicating the fact
that the present appellants are working against the teaching posts of Associate
Professor/Assistant Professor sanctioned in compliance of the norms of the
AICTE/PCI and are appointed as per the requirements, qualifications and selection
procedure in accordance with the 1973 Act and proposed by the University, such
incumbents shall be treated to be appointed against the sanctioned posts for all
practical purposes.
51. Thus, it can safely be held that the appellants became entitled to claim their
appointment to be in substantive capacity against the permanent sanctioned post
and become a member of the teaching faculty of the Central University under the
2009 Act.”
7.
In the context of the present case, the petitioner was not
appointed against a substantive post. The appointment of the petitioner was
made on contract basis in terms of the advertisement dated 04.06.2008. The
petitioner has no requisite qualification to get her service regularized in the
regular scale of pay as that of Assistant Professor/Associate Professor
appointed under the UGC Regulations. Being a contractual appointee, no right
is conferred upon the petitioner to claim regularization. In the counter affidavit
filed by the respondents-Tripura University, it is clearly stated that at the time
of advertisement there was no sanctioned post of Lecturer under BBA
programme. Furthermore, initiation of regular selection process is the mandate
of the Constitutional scheme as enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India for appointment or filling up of the posts irrespective of
the nature of the posts, but mere selection through a regular selection process
to any posts which is to be filled up on contractual basis will not confer any
right upon such successful candidate to claim regularization subsequently.
Another distinguishing feature, in the instant case, is that in the advertisement
it was clearly mentioned that the appointment was made on contractual basis,
but in Somesh Thapliyal(supra) it was against the regular posts approved by
the State Government and under a specific Act. However, at the time of
issuance of the appointment letter it was a paradigm shift from the terms and
conditions mentioned in the advertisement issued by the respondentUniversity and in the appointment letter, for the first time, arbitrarily
conditions were incorporated making the appointment of Somesh Thapliyal to
be contractual for a period of 3(three) years.
8.
In view of this, I find clear distinction between the terms of the
appointment of the petitioner of the present case and the appointment made in
the case of Somesh Thapliyal(supra), which in no way relatable to decide the
controversy raised in the present writ petition. It is reiterated that the
appointment of the petitioner was made purely on contract basis as per the
terms of the advertisement made by the respondents-Tripura University. The
petitioner has no right to claim regularization or to renew her contract period
after it has ended on 02.01.2022.
9.
Accordingly, the claim of the petitioner for regularization of her
service as Assistant Professor/Associate Professor deserves no consideration
and thus, rejected. Again, the office order dated 30.09.2022 issued by the
Registrar, Tripura University is a fresh order of engagement and the said order
is not in anyway connected to the appointment of the petitioner made under
the advertisement dated 04.06.2008 qua her appointment as Lecturer under
BBA programme.
10.
with.
In view of this, the office order dated 30.09.2022 is not interfered
11.
Resultantly, the instant writ petition filed by the petitioner being
devoid of merit is dismissed. Interim order, if any stands vacated.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.01.19
GHOSH 16:45:48 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review