Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad
And
The Hon’ble Justice Prasenjit Biswas
M.A.T.577 of 2020
Jayanta Sarkar
-VersusNational Jute Board
: Mr. Victor Chatterjee,
For the Appellant
Ms.Shreya Bhattacharjee.
: Mr. Surya Prasad Chattopadhyay,
Mr.Samudraneel Nandi.
For the Respondent
Judgment on
:
15.06.2026
Prasenjit Biswas, J:1.
The writ petitioner/appellant, while serving as an Accounts Officer
under the National Jute Board, was proceeded against on the basis of a
charge memorandum dated 28th April, 2015 containing two articles of
charge. Those two articles of charge which were required to be
established in the departmental proceeding were stated in the charge
memo in the following terms:
“Article I
That the said Sri Jayanta Sarkar while functioning as
Accounts Officer during the period June’2010 to December’2010
defrauded the Government of India/National Jute Board by Rs.
57,56,400/- by wrongfully releasing subsidy to M/s Nilkanth
Jute Processing Private Ltd located at Muragacha, Jugberia,
North 24 Parganas which was not due and acted in a manner
which is unbecoming of a Government Servant and thereby
violated Rules 3 (1)(i),3(1)(ii),3(1)(iii),3(1)(vi),3(1)(ix),3(1)(xii)and
3(1)(xxi)ofCCS(Conduct)Rules1964.
Article II
That the said Sri Jayanta Sarkar while functioning as Accounts
Officer during the period 31stMarch 2014 to 5thDecember 2014
was about to defraud the Government of India/National Jute
Board by Rs. 93,79,200/- by wrongfully recommending release of
subsidytoM/sMahabirJutexlocatedatPiaraBagan, Bolkanda Gram
Panchayat II, Jugberia, North 24 Parganas which was not due
and acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a Government
Servant
and
therebyviolatedRules3(1)(i),3(1)(ii),3(1)(iii),3(1)(vi),3(1)(ix),3(1)(xii)
and 3(1)(xxi)of CCS(Conduct) Rules 1964.”
2.
The Enquiry Officer, by his report dated 7th October, 2015, held the
charges to be proved. The findings were accepted by the Disciplinary
Authority, culminating in the imposition of the extreme penalty of
dismissal from service.
3.
It is submitted by the learned advocate appearing for the writ
petitioner/appellant that the Enquiry Officer, by his report dated
07.10.2015, held both the articles of charge to have been proved against
the petitioner. The findings recorded in the enquiry report were thereafter
accepted in toto by the Disciplinary Authority, culminating in the
imposition of the severest penalty known to service jurisprudence,
namely dismissal from service. According to the learned advocate, the
enquiry proceeding which formed the foundation of such drastic
punishment suffers from grave procedural irregularities and fundamental
infirmities, rendering the entire disciplinary process unsustainable in
law.
4.
The learned advocate contends that the enquiry was conducted in a
manner wholly inconsistent with the settled principles of natural justice
and fair play. It is submitted that a careful examination of the enquiry
proceedings would reveal that the procedure adopted by the Enquiry
Officer was not merely irregular but fundamentally unfair, thereby
causing serious prejudice to the petitioner in defending himself against
the allegations leveled in the charge memorandum.
5.
Drawing attention to the records of the enquiry, the learned advocate
submits that on the dates when evidence was purportedly considered in
the proceeding, namely on 17.11.2015, 24.11.2015 and 22.01.2016,
there was no reference whatsoever to the documents enumerated in
Annexure-III to the articles of charge. The said documents constituted
the documentary foundation of the allegations and were relied upon by
the disciplinary authority while framing the charges against the
petitioner. However, despite their obvious relevance and significance, the
documents were never produced before the Enquiry Officer, nor were
they exhibited or proved through any witness during the course of the
enquiry.
6.
According to the learned advocate, in a departmental proceeding where
the charges are founded substantially upon documentary materials,
production and proof of such documents constitute the minimum
procedural safeguards required for a fair adjudication. In the absence of
such production, the delinquent employee is deprived of an effective
opportunity to challenge the authenticity, relevance and evidentiary value
of the materials relied upon against him. It is contended that findings
recorded without formally bringing the foundational documents on
record cannot be said to be based upon legally admissible evidence even
on a preponderance of probability, applicable to disciplinary proceedings.
7.
The learned advocate further submits that the proceedings disclose
another
serious
irregularity.
A
perusal
of
the
enquiry
records
demonstrates that the Enquiry Officer himself undertook the task of
examining the management witnesses, namely Sri Susanta Pal, Sri M.
Dutta and Sri S. Dutta. The records do not reveal any examination-inchief conducted by the Presenting Officer. Instead, the Enquiry Officer
appears to have directly questioned the witnesses and recorded their
responses.
8.
It is argued that such a course of action is wholly incompatible with the
role assigned to an Enquiry Officer in a departmental proceeding. The
Enquiry Officer is required to function as an impartial adjudicator who
evaluates the evidence adduced by the parties. He cannot assume the
role of a prosecutor or investigator. By undertaking the examination of
witnesses himself and eliciting evidence in support of the charges, the
Enquiry Officer effectively stepped into the shoes of the Presenting
Officer. Such conduct, according to the learned advocate, destroys the
neutrality expected of a quasi-judicial authority and creates a reasonable
apprehension that the Enquiry Officer had abandoned his role as an
unbiased adjudicator.
9.
It is further submitted that the manner in which the evidence of the said
witnesses was recorded itself demonstrates the infirmity in the enquiry
process. The statements attributed to the witnesses consist of brief and
telegraphic answers bereft of any meaningful discussion regarding the
documents relied upon in support of the charges. The witnesses were not
confronted with the documentary records, nor were they asked to explain
the manner in which the petitioner allegedly committed the acts
attributed to him. The learned advocate submits that such cryptic
recording of evidence cannot be treated as substantive material capable
of sustaining findings of serious misconduct carrying the consequence of
dismissal from service.
10.
The learned advocate next contends that the enquiry was prematurely
and arbitrarily closed on 27.01.2016 without granting the petitioner an
adequate opportunity to present his defence. Despite the petitioner's
desire to adduce evidence and examine defence witnesses, no effective
opportunity was afforded to him by the Enquiry Officer. The right to lead
defence evidence, it is argued, constitutes an integral component of a fair
disciplinary proceeding and forms part of the reasonable opportunity
guaranteed to a delinquent employee.
11.
Particular emphasis has been laid upon the fact that immediately after
closure of the enquiry, the petitioner addressed a written communication
dated 29.01.2016 objecting to the procedure adopted by the Enquiry
Officer and protesting against the denial of an opportunity to examine
defence witnesses. The said objection specifically highlighted the
prejudice caused to the petitioner by the abrupt closure of the enquiry.
However, no response was ever furnished to the petitioner, nor was any
attempt made to consider the objections raised therein. Instead, the
Enquiry Officer proceeded with the matter and ultimately submitted his
report. According to the learned advocate, such conduct clearly
demonstrates that the petitioner's legitimate grievance regarding denial of
opportunity was completely ignored.
12.
The learned advocate further submits that an even more serious violation
of natural justice became apparent only upon the petitioner receiving a
copy of the enquiry report. From the report it transpired that the Enquiry
Officer had relied upon a written brief purportedly submitted by the
Presenting Officer together with certain documents annexed thereto.
However, at no stage of the enquiry was any copy of such written brief
supplied to the petitioner. Nor was the petitioner informed that any such
written submissions had been placed before the Enquiry Officer.
13.
According to the learned advocate, if such written brief was indeed
submitted by the Presenting Officer, elementary fairness required that a
copy thereof be served upon the charge-sheeted employee so as to enable
him to respond to the submissions made therein. The petitioner was
completely denied such opportunity. Consequently, the written brief
appears to have been furnished directly to the Enquiry Officer behind the
back of the petitioner. Any material, submission or document placed
before the Enquiry Officer without notice to the delinquent employee and
subsequently relied upon for recording findings of guilt, constitutes ex
parte material and cannot legally form the basis of a disciplinary finding.
14.
Apart from these procedural infirmities, the learned advocate submits
that the enquiry report suffers from a fundamental defect on merits.
According to him, the Enquiry Officer failed to examine the very charges
framed against the petitioner. A reading of both Articles of Charge would
reveal that the gravamen of the allegations was that the petitioner had
either wrongfully released subsidy or wrongfully recommended release of
subsidy with the object of “defrauding” the Government of India and the
National Jute Board. The allegation of fraud constituted the essence of
the misconduct alleged against the petitioner.However, a careful reading
of the enquiry report reveals that the Enquiry Officer has not returned
any finding whatsoever regarding the alleged fraudulent intention on the
part of the petitioner. There is no discussion in the report as to whether
the petitioner acted dishonestly, whether he had any ulterior motive,
whether he stood to derive any personal benefit, whether there existed
any collusion with the beneficiary entities, or whether there was any
deliberate intention to deceive the Board. The report is conspicuously
silent on the most essential ingredient of the charge.
15.
The learned advocate submits that fraud is not a matter of presumption.
It is a serious allegation carrying severe civil consequences and must be
established by cogent material demonstrating a conscious and deliberate
intent to deceive. Mere procedural irregularity, negligence or incorrect
recommendation cannot automatically be elevated to an act of fraud.
Unless the element of fraudulent intent is specifically established, the
charge as framed remains unproved.
16.
It is accordingly argued that the Enquiry Officer completely misdirected
himself by proceeding to examine matters divorced from the actual
charges contained in the charge memorandum. The enquiry report
merely refers to the release or recommendation of subsidy allegedly not
due, but does not address the crucial question whether such acts were
undertaken with the intention of defrauding the Board. Consequently,
the Enquiry Officer failed to adjudicate upon the charge actually framed
against the petitioner.
17.
The learned advocate therefore submits that the findings recorded in the
enquiry report are fundamentally flawed, inasmuch as they do not
correspond to the allegations contained in the charge memorandum.
Since the charge of fraud was never examined or established, the
conclusion that the charges stood proved is wholly unsustainable. The
disciplinary authority, while accepting such findings and imposing the
punishment of dismissal, failed to notice these glaring defects. The entire
disciplinary proceeding, therefore, stands vitiated both on account of
procedural unfairness and on account of failure to establish the essential
ingredients of the charges leveled against the petitioner.
18.
Reliance has been placed by the learned Advocate of the petitioner upon
the following decisions rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court.
i)
Jai
Prakash
Saini-vs.-Managing
Director,
U.P.
Cooperative Federation Ltd. & Ors.reported in 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 505 (Para 17).
ii)
Sur Enamel & Stamping Works Ltd.-vs- Workmen reported
in 1963 SCC OnLine SC 97 (para 4).
iii)
Narinder Mohan Arya -vs- United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
& Ors.reported in (2006) 4 SCC 713 (para 26).
iv)
Roop
Singh
Negi
–vs-
Punjab
National
Bank
&
Ors.reported in (2009) 2 SCC 570 (paras 14, 17 and 23).
19.
Per contra, the learned Advocate appearing for the respondent Board
emphatically refuted and denied each and every contention advanced on
behalf of the writ petitioner/appellant. It was submitted that the
disciplinary proceeding had been initiated and concluded strictly in
accordance with the applicable rules and procedures and that the
findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer, as well as the consequential
decision of the Disciplinary Authority, were fully justified on the basis of
the materials available on record.
20.
The learned Advocate for the respondent Board contended that the
charges levelled against the petitioner were grave and serious in nature.
The petitioner, while discharging his duties as an Accounts Officer, was
found to have wrongfully released funds in one instance and to have
recommended and facilitated the release of funds in another case without
proper verification and in violation of the established norms and
procedures governing financial disbursements. Such acts, according to
the respondent Board, constituted gross misconduct and reflected a
complete disregard of the responsibilities attached to the office held by
the petitioner.
21.
It was further argued that the departmental enquiry was conducted in a
fair, transparent and impartial manner, ensuring complete adherence to
the principles of natural justice. The allegation of denial of reasonable
opportunity, as sought to be projected by the petitioner, was categorically
denied. The learned Advocate submitted that the petitioner was afforded
every opportunity to defend himself during the course of the enquiry. In
fact, the request made by the petitioner for engagement of a Defence
Assistant was duly considered and allowed by the Enquiry Officer,
thereby enabling the petitioner to effectively participate in the proceeding
and present his defence.
22.
The learned Advocate further submitted that, in order to verify the
factual position relating to the allegations levelled against the petitioner,
a Joint Inspection Team was constituted by the competent authority.
Pursuant thereto, a detailed field investigation was conducted at the
relevant sites in the presence of the petitioner himself. During such
inspection, the physical status of the machinery, the existence and
condition of the assets purportedly financed, and the land and premises
of the concerned mill were examined and verified. The findings of such
field inspection were duly confronted to the petitioner and incorporated
in a detailed inspection report prepared by the authorities. According to
the respondent Board, the field verification unequivocally established the
irregularities
and
illegalities
committed
by
the
petitioner
substantially corroborated the charges framed against him.
and
23.
It was next contended that all documents sought for and relied upon by
the petitioner for the purpose of his defence were supplied to him. The
respondent Board denied any allegation regarding non-supply of
documents or withholding of materials. The learned Advocate submitted
that adequate and sufficient opportunity was granted not only to the
petitioner but also to his Defence Assistant to scrutinize the records,
participate in the enquiry proceedings and put forward the defence case.
Despite such opportunities, the petitioner failed to produce any cogent
material capable of disproving the allegations or discrediting the evidence
adduced by the management.
24.
The learned Advocate for the respondent Board further submitted that
the management witnesses were examined in the presence of the
petitioner and that full opportunity was afforded to him to cross-examine
each of the witnesses. The petitioner availed himself of such opportunity
and actively participated in the proceedings. After completion of the
examination
and
cross-examination
of
the
witnesses
and
after
considering the documentary evidence brought on record, the enquiry
proceedings were concluded in accordance with law. It was, therefore,
contended that there was no procedural irregularity whatsoever which
could vitiate the enquiry.
25.
It was also argued that the disciplinary proceeding had been conducted
strictly in conformity with the principles analogous to those embodied in
the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules,
1965. The safeguards ordinarily available to a delinquent employee in a
departmental enquiry were fully extended to the petitioner. The enquiry
was conducted by a competent Enquiry Officer, the evidence was
properly recorded, opportunities of hearing were granted at every stage,
and the findings were ultimately arrived at on the basis of evidence
adduced during the proceeding.
26.
In such circumstances, it was argued that there exists no legal or factual
infirmity either in the conduct of the disciplinary proceeding or in the
decision-making process adopted by the disciplinary authorities. The
respondent Board, therefore, contended that no ground has been made
out warranting interference by this Hon’ble Court with the findings
recorded in the departmental proceeding or with the punishment
imposed upon the petitioner. The writ petition, according to the
respondent Board, is devoid of merit and the findings of the learned
Single Judge may not be interfered with..
27.
In support of his submission learned Advocate placed reliance upon the
following decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court.
i)
State
of
Meghalaya
&Ors.-vs-
Meckensingh
N.
Marakreported in (2008) 7 SCC 580 (para 15 and 16).
ii)
R.S. Saini –vs- State of Punjab & Ors.reported in (1999)8
SCC 90.
28.
We have considered the rival submissions advanced by both the parties.
29.
The records indicate that on the dates fixed for enquiry, namely 17th
November, 2015, 24th November, 2015 and 22ndJanuary, 2016, the
documents listed in Annexure-III to the charge memorandum were
neither formally produced nor proved before the Enquiry Officer. The
documentary materials which constituted the very foundation of the
charges were thus not brought on record in accordance with any
recognised procedure. In a disciplinary proceeding where the allegations
related to release and recommendation of subsidy, the relevant files,
inspection reports, subsidy claims, processing notes and connected
records constituted the primary evidence. In the absence of their formal
production and proof, the enquiry stood deprived of the evidentiary basis
necessary for arriving at a finding of guilt.
30.
It is trite law that a departmental proceeding, though not governed by the
strict rules of evidence applicable to judicial proceedings, must
nevertheless conform to the fundamental principles of natural justice
and fair play. The enquiry must be conducted in a manner which
inspires confidence and ensures that the delinquent employee is afforded
a reasonable opportunity to defend himself against the charges levelled.
Any procedure which compromises fairness or creates a reasonable
apprehension of bias strikes at the very root of the disciplinary process.A
scrutiny of the enquiry proceedings reveals that the procedure adopted
by the
Enquiry
requirements.
Officer
fell
substantially
short
of
these
settled
31.
More importantly, the proceedings disclose that the Enquiry Officer
himself assumed the task of questioning and examining the witnesses.
The statements of the witnesses, namely Susanta Pal, M. Dutta and S.
Dutta, were recorded in a telegraphic manner, and even on the standard
of preponderance of probability, such statements must be considered as
supporting the charge. The statements are devoid of any substance and
meaningless. The Presenting Officer did not undertake any substantive
examination-in-chief of the witnesses. Nor does the record disclose that
the witnesses were confronted with the relevant documents on the basis
whereof the charges had been framed.Such a procedure cannot be
countenanced in law.
32.
The Enquiry Officer, while performing a quasi-judicial function, is
expected to maintain neutrality and detachment. His role is to adjudicate
upon the evidence adduced before him and not to collect evidence or
present the case against the delinquent employee. By virtually stepping
into the shoes of the Presenting Officer and assuming the responsibility
of eliciting evidence in support of the charges, the Enquiry Officer
abandoned the role of an impartial adjudicator and assumed the position
of a prosecutor. Such conduct gives rise to a reasonable apprehension of
bias and renders the enquiry vulnerable to challenge on the touchstone
of fairness.
33.
The records further reveal that the enquiry was abruptly closed on 27th
January, 2016. The appellant was not afforded an effective opportunity
to adduce defence evidence or to examine witnesses in support of his
case. The denial of such opportunity assumes significance in view of the
fact that the appellant specifically protested against the procedure
adopted by the Enquiry Officer through a written communication dated
29th January, 2016. The said objection highlighted the procedural
irregularities and sought an opportunity to present the defence case. The
record does not disclose any consideration of the said objection nor any
reasoned response thereto.
34.
The right to lead defence evidence is not an empty formality. It
constitutes an integral component of the reasonable opportunity
contemplated under the principles of natural justice. Once a delinquent
employee expresses his intention to produce defence witnesses, the
Enquiry Officer is duty bound to consider such request fairly and permit
the defence to be presented unless justifiable reasons exist to the
contrary. The denial of such opportunity, particularly without assigning
any reason, results in serious prejudice to the delinquent employee and
vitiates the enquiry.
35.
Another grave infirmity emerges from the manner in which the Enquiry
Officer relied upon the written brief allegedly submitted by the Presenting
Officer. From the enquiry report it appears that the Enquiry Officer took
into consideration a written brief accompanied by documents purportedly
filed on behalf of the management. However, the appellant consistently
maintained that no copy of such written brief was ever supplied to him.
There is nothing on record to demonstrate that the written brief was
served upon the appellant or that he was afforded an opportunity to
submit his response thereto.
36.
The consequence is obvious. Any material submitted behind the back of
the delinquent employee and relied upon by the Enquiry Officer for
arriving at a finding of guilt constitutes an ex parte material. Reliance
upon such material is antithetical to the principles of natural justice. A
delinquent employee cannot be condemned on the basis of submissions
or documents to which he had no access and regarding which he had no
opportunity of rebuttal. The consideration of such undisclosed material
by the Enquiry Officer therefore causes serious prejudice and renders the
findings unsustainable.
37.
In the case of Jai Prakash Saini (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reiterated the settled principles governing the conduct of departmental
enquiries and the observance of the principles of natural justice therein.
The Apex Court held that the burden initially lies upon the employer or
the disciplinary authority to adduce evidence in support of the charges
framed against the delinquent employee. The management is required to
examine its witnesses in the first instance and afford the charged
employee a reasonable opportunity to cross-examine such witnesses.
Only upon completion of the employer's evidence and the crossexamination thereof can the delinquent employee be called upon to enter
upon his defence, either by leading evidence in rebuttal or by furnishing
an explanation with regard to the materials brought on record against
him.
38.
The Hon'ble Court further observed that this requirement is not
dispensed with merely because the case is founded predominantly or
exclusively on documentary evidence. Unless the authenticity and
contents of the documents relied upon are expressly admitted by the
delinquent employee, the employer is under an obligation to prove such
documents through competent witnesses. Such witnesses, after proving
the documents, must be made available for cross-examination by the
charged employee. The right of cross-examination constitutes an integral
facet of a fair enquiry and cannot be denied on the ground that the
charges are sought to be established through documentary materials
alone. The judgment thus underscores that proof of documents through
witnesses
and
the
corresponding
right
of
cross-examination
are
indispensable safeguards to ensure fairness and compliance with the
principles of natural justice in disciplinary proceedings.
39.
In the case of Narinder Mohan Arya (supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court held
at paragraph 26 as follows:
“26.
In our opinion the learned Single Judge and consequently the
Division Bench of the High Court did not pose unto themselves the
correct question. The matter can be viewed from two angles. Despite
limited jurisdiction a civil court, it was entitled to interfere in a case
where the report of the enquiry officer is based on no evidence. In a
suit filed by a delinquent employee in a civil court as also a writ
court, in the event the findings arrived at in the departmental
proceedings ae questioned before it, it should keep in mind the
following: (1) the enquiry officer is not permitted to collect any
material from outside sources during the conduct of the enquiry.
(See State of Assam v. Mahendra Kumar Das.) (2)In a domestic
enquiry fairness in the procedure is a part of the principles of
natural justice. (See Khem Chand v. Union of India and State of U.P.
v. Om Prakash Gupta.) (3) Exercise of discretionary power involves
two elements-(i) objective, and (ii) subjective and existence of the
exercise of an objective element is a condition precedent for exercise
of the subjective element. (See K.L. Tripathi v. State Bank of India.)
(4) It is not possible to lay down any rigid rules of the principles of
natural justice which depend on the facts and circumstances of
each case but the concept of fair play in action is the basis. (See
Sawai Singh v. State of Rajasthan.) (5) The enquiry officer is not
permitted to travel beyond the charges and any punishment
imposed on the basis of a finding which was not the subject-matter
of the charges is wholly illegal. [See Director (Inspection & Quality
Control) Export Inspection Council of India v. Kalyan Kumar Mitra.]
(6) Suspicion or presumption cannot take the place of proof even in a
domestic enquiry. The writ court is entitled to interfere with the
findings of the fact of any tribunal or authority in certain
circumstances. (See Central Bank of India Ltd. V. Prakash Chand
Jain, Kuldeep Singh v. Commr. Of Police.)
40.
The principles and safeguards enunciated by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
the aforesaid decision were not duly taken into consideration while
examining whether the disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner had
been conducted in conformity with the requirements of fairness and the
principles of natural justice. The fundamental tests laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court for ensuring a fair enquiry appear to have been
overlooked, resulting in serious prejudice to the petitioner in defending
himself against the charges levelled against him.
41.
A
careful
scrutiny
of
the
enquiry proceedings reveals
that
the
management witnesses were neither confronted with the documentary
records relied upon by the disciplinary authority nor were they called
upon to explain the contents, relevance and evidentiary value of such
documents. The witnesses merely made telegraphic statements without
establishing the nexus between the documentary materials and the
allegations leveled against the petitioner. Consequently, the documents
relied upon by the management remained formally unproved in
accordance with the requirements of a fair departmental enquiry.
Therefore, the findings of the Enquiry Officer and the Disciplinary
Authority are based on no material.
42.
It further appears that the witnesses were not asked to depose as to the
specific role allegedly played by the petitioner in the commission of the
acts constituting misconduct. No attempt was made to elicit from the
witnesses the manner in which the petitioner was responsible for the
alleged irregularities or the precise circumstances under which the
purported acts of omission or commission were committed by him. In the
absence of such evidence, the charges against the petitioner were left
unsupported by any substantive oral testimony explaining how the
petitioner could be connected with the alleged misconduct.
43.
The failure to confront the witnesses with the relevant documents and
the omission to obtain evidence explaining the petitioner's alleged
involvement in the transactions in question deprived the petitioner of an
effective opportunity to challenge the case sought to be made out against
him through cross-examination. Such a course of action strikes at the
very root of a fair enquiry and renders the findings vulnerable to
challenge on the ground of violation of the principles of natural justice.
44.
In the case of Roop Singh Negi (supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court held at
paragraph 14, inter alia that:
“14. Indisputably, a departmental proceeding is a quasi-juricial
proceeding. The enquiry officer performs a quasi-judicial function.
The charges leveled against the delinquent officer must be found to
have been proved. The enquiry officer has a duty to arrive at a
finding upon taking into consideration the materials brought on
record by the parties. The purported evidence collected during
investigation by the investigating officer against all the accused by
itself could not be treated to be evidence in the disciplinary
proceeding. No witness was examined to prove the said documents.
The management witnesses merely tendered the documents and did
not prove the contents thereof. Reliance, inter alia, was placed by
the enquiry officer on the FIR which could not have been treated as
evidence.”
45.
In the aforesaid decision, the Hon'ble Apex Court unequivocally held that
the mere production or marking of documents does not, by itself, amount
to proof of the contents thereof. The Court emphasized that documents
relied upon in a disciplinary proceeding must be duly proved through
competent witnesses who can speak to their authenticity, contents and
relevance. Such witnesses are also required to be made available for
cross-examination so as to afford the delinquent employee a fair
opportunity to challenge the evidence sought to be relied upon against
him. The underlying principle is that documentary evidence cannot be
treated as substantive proof unless its contents are established in
accordance with the requirements of a fair enquiry.
46.
Applying the aforesaid principle to the facts of the present case, it
becomes evident that the procedure adopted by the management suffers
from a far more fundamental defect. In the instant proceeding, the
management did not even formally tender the documents upon which
reliance was purportedly placed for establishing the charges against the
petitioner. Consequently, there was no occasion for any witness to prove
the said documents, explain their contents, or establish their nexus with
the allegations levelled against the petitioner.
47.
The omission on the part of the management to bring the relevant
documents on record in accordance with law constitutes a serious
procedural infirmity and goes to the very root of the enquiry. When the
documents forming the foundation of the charges were neither tendered
nor proved through witnesses, the petitioner was effectively deprived of
his valuable right to challenge the authenticity, correctness and
evidentiary value of those materials through cross-examination. Such a
course of action is wholly inconsistent with the principles of natural
justice and the settled legal position governing disciplinary proceedings.
48.
We also find that a plain reading of both articles of charge demonstrates
that the central allegation was not merely the release or recommendation
of subsidy. The essence of the accusation was that the appellant had
acted
with
the
intention
of
“defrauding”
the
Government
of
India/National Jute Board. The allegation of fraud constituted the
foundational ingredient of both charges. It was the alleged fraudulent
conduct
which
elevated
the
matter
from
a
mere
administrative
irregularity to an act of grave misconduct warranting major penalty
proceedings.
49.
However, a careful reading of the enquiry report reveals that the Enquiry
Officer did not undertake any analysis whatsoever regarding the
existence of fraudulent intent. There is no discussion concerning any
dishonest motive, ulterior purpose, personal gain, collusion, mala fide
conduct or conscious design on the part of the appellant to deceive the
Board. The report is conspicuously silent regarding the essential
ingredient of fraud.
50.
In the present case, while the charge alleged fraudulent release or
recommendation of subsidy, the Enquiry Officer appears to have shifted
focus and examined only whether subsidy had been released or
recommended in circumstances where it was allegedly not due. Such an
approach effectively substitutes the original charge with a different and
diluted allegation. The appellant was never called upon to defend himself
against a charge of mere erroneous recommendation or administrative
lapse divorced from the allegation of fraud. Findings recorded on a
charge not framed are legally unsustainable.
51.
The Court is therefore confronted with a twofold infirmity. First, the
charge as framed was never properly examined and established with
reference to any material. The findings therefore are not based on any
material and therefore liable to inference by the writ court.
Secondly,
there is no finding whatsoever regarding the charge of fraudulent
intention. Therefore, the findings ultimately returned relate to matters
which do not constitute the charge contained in the memorandum. Such
findings cannot legally form the foundation of a punishment order.
52.
The matter may also be viewed from another perspective. Even assuming
that
subsidy
was
released
or
recommended
in
circumstances
subsequently found to be erroneous, the question would still remain
whether such conduct, in the absence of any finding regarding fraud,
dishonesty, mala fide intention or extraneous consideration, could justify
the imposition of the severest penalty of dismissal from service. The
answer undoubtedly would be in the negative.
53.
Viewed cumulatively, the procedural violations, the denial of reasonable
opportunity to defend, the reliance upon materials not disclosed to the
appellant, findings without any basis, the assumption by the Enquiry
Officer of the role of the Presenting Officer, and the complete failure to
record any finding on the essential ingredient of fraud, strike at the very
foundation of the disciplinary proceeding. The enquiry cannot therefore
be regarded as fair, impartial or legally sustainable.
54.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the enquiry report,
the consequential findings recorded therein and the punishment imposed
on the basis thereof stand vitiated in law. The learned Single Judge failed
to adequately appreciate these fundamental infirmities.
55.
The appeal therefore deserves to be allowed, the impugned judgment is
set aside and the disciplinary action founded upon the vitiated enquiry is
quashed. The order of dismissal dated 25.05.2016 and the order passed
by the appellate authority dated 27th February, 2017, being the direct
consequence of such defective proceeding, cannot be sustained, is liable
to be interfered with, and is hereby quashed. As a result of quashing of
the punishment, the petitioner is entitled to all consequential benefits.
56.
There will be no order as to costs.
57.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.
I agree.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review