The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. Shri K. Vijay Kumar, IG, J&K, Zone HQR, C.R.P.F., Bantalab Road, Barnai, Dina Nagar, NardaniBajwan, Jammu and Kashmir – 181206. ...Respondents HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH For the Petitioner :: Anjan Prasad Sahu, Advocate, For the Respondents:: Mr. S. Samarjeet, Sr.PCCG Dates of hearing :: 05-04-2023 Date of Order 25-04-2023 :: WP(C)No. 134 of 2020 Page 1 Heard Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr.PCCG appearing for the respondents. [2] The present writ petition has been filed with a prayer for quashing and setting aside the order dated 3rd June, 2018 issued by the Director General, CRPF rejecting the representations submitted by the petitioner for upgradation of the gradings in his Annual Performance Appraisal Report (APAR) from ‘good’ to ‘very good’ as well as for quashing the grading recorded in his APAR for the period from 15-05-2016 to 25-11-2016 coupled with a prayer for directing the respondents to treat the gradings recorded in the petitioner’s APAR for the period from 13-12-2016 – 31-03-2017 as the grading for the whole year, i.e., 2016-2017. [3] According Commandant, to the petitioner, he was posted as 86th of Manipur during the CRPF, assessment period of his Annual Performance Appraisal Report (APAR), i.e. from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016. Subsequently, the petitioner’s APAR for the period from 1…
6. 3.1 of Swami’s Establishment and Administration is applicable and followed in the CRPF organization. In para No. 6.3.1(b) of the said Swami’s Establishment and Administration, it is provided that the DPC shall determine the merit of those being assessed for promotion with reference to the prescribed benchmark and accordingly, graded the officers as ‘fit’ or ‘unfit’ and only those who are graded ‘fit’ by the DPC shall be included and arranged in the selected panel in order of their inter se seniority in the feeder grade and that there shall be no supersession in promotion among those who are graded ‘fit’ by the DPC. [11] After perusal of the additional affidavit filed by the respondents No. 1 & 2 and on careful examination of the guidelines dated 31-03-2010 issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs regarding benchmark for promotion as well as provisions under para No. 6.3.1 (b) of the Swami’s Establishment And Administration regarding principles to be observed and preparation of panel, which is applicable and followed in the CRPF organization, this Court is of the considered view that if the case of the petitioner is considered by the authorities for his promotion to the rank of DIG by taking into consideration his last five years APARs starting from 2012-2013 to 2016-2017, he will be deemed fit for promotion to the rank of DIG under the CRPF since the petitioner got three ‘very go…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
LAISHRAM Digitally
LAISHRAM
DHAKESH DHAKESHORI DEVI
Date: 2023.04.26
ORI DEVI 12:07:09 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.134 of 2020
Shri Jayant Kumar, aged about 51 years, S/o Dr. Birendra
Prasad Pandey, permanent resident of Mahabir Colony,
TetritoliNamkum and District Ranchi, Jharkhand – Pin –
834010. Presently residing at 73 BN. S.S.B, Shergaon,
District West Kameng, Arunachal Pradesh – 790002.
....Petitioner
-Versus1. The Union of India, through the Secretary (Home),
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, North
Block, New Delhi – 110001.
2. The Director General of Central Reserve Police Force,
Govt. of India, Block No.-1, C.G. O. Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi – 110003.
3. Dr. SubhashDamle, Dy. I.G.P., Central Reserve Police
Force, GC, C.R.P.F. Langjing, Imphal West, Manipur –
795113.
4. Shri K. Vijay Kumar, IG, J&K, Zone HQR, C.R.P.F.,
Bantalab Road, Barnai, Dina Nagar, NardaniBajwan,
Jammu and Kashmir – 181206.
...Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner ::
Anjan Prasad Sahu, Advocate,
For the Respondents::
Mr. S. Samarjeet, Sr.PCCG
Dates of hearing ::
05-04-2023
Date of Order
25-04-2023
::
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 1
ORDER
Heard Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner and Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned
Sr.PCCG appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed with a
prayer for quashing and setting aside the order dated 3rd June,
2018 issued by the Director General, CRPF rejecting the
representations submitted by the petitioner for upgradation of
the gradings in his Annual Performance Appraisal Report
(APAR) from ‘good’ to ‘very good’ as well as for quashing the
grading recorded in his APAR for the period from 15-05-2016 to
25-11-2016 coupled with a prayer for directing the respondents
to treat the gradings recorded in the petitioner’s APAR for the
period from 13-12-2016 – 31-03-2017 as the grading for the
whole year, i.e., 2016-2017.
[3]
According
Commandant,
to
the
petitioner,
he
was
posted
as
86th
BN
of
Manipur
during
the
CRPF,
assessment period of his Annual Performance Appraisal Report
(APAR), i.e. from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016. Subsequently, the
petitioner’s APAR for the period from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016
was communicated to him by the competent authorities of the
CRPF under cover of a letter dated 15-09-2017. In the said part
APAR of the petitioner for the period from 15-05-2016 to 25-112016 his grading was recorded as ‘good’. Feeling aggrieved, the
petitioner submitted two representations dated 06-10-2017 and
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 2
01-12-2017 to the Special Director General of Police, North
Eastern Zone, CRPF, Guwahati and the Director General,
Directorate, CRPF, New Delhi respectively, requesting for
quashing the grading recorded in his APAR for the period from
15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016 and for treating the grading recorded
in his APAR for the period from 13-12-2016 – 31-03-2017 as
the grading of his APAR for the complete year i.e., 2016-2017.
[4]
After considering the representation submitted by
the petitioner, the Director General, CRPF, issued an order
dated 3rd June, 2018 rejecting the said representation as being
devoid of merit. Having been aggrieved, the petitioner
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition for
redressing his grievances.
[5]
According to the petitioner, the grading recorded in
his APAR in the last four years i.e., 2012-2013, 2013-2014,
2014 – 2015 and 2015 – 2016 are ‘very good’, very good’,
‘outstanding’ and very good’ respectively and that only for the
period from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016, the grading recorded in
his APAR is only ‘good’. However, for the period from 13-122016 – 31-03-2017, the grading recorded in his APAR is ‘very
good’. According to the petitioner, the authorities have
consistently given either the grading of ‘very good’ or
‘outstanding’ in his APAR in the last many years and that it is
highly improbable that there would be a sudden downfall in his
performance. It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioner
that the grading of ‘good’ recorded in his APAR has an adverse
effect on the petitioner’s chance for the next promotion,
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 3
inasmuch as, there is a possibility of being superseded by his
juniors because of the grading of ‘good’ recorded in his APAR
and accordingly, such grading of ‘good’ is a below benchmark
grading and accordingly, it amounts to adverse grading.
[6]
In the additional affidavit filed by the respondents, it
has been categorically stated that the benchmark for promotion
to DIG rank from Commandant in CPMFs as contained in the
UO No. I-45024/1/2010-Pers – II dated 31-03-2010 of the
Ministry of Home Affairs are as under:“Para 3 (b) : “Very Good”
An officer may be graded as “Very Good‟ if in the opinion of
the Selection Committee his overall service record reflects
that the officer has done highly meritorious work and
possesses positive attributes and these characteristics are
reflected in at least 4 of the last 5 ACRs. Further, in the
opinion of the Selection Committee, the remaining ACR
under consideration of the Committee should reflect that the
officer‟s performance is generally good, during the period of
report. There should be no adverse entry in any of the ACRs
under consideration of the Selection Committee.”
[7]
In a subsequent additional affidavit filed by the
respondents No. 1 & 2, it has been stated that the benchmark
for promotion from Commandant to DIG as contained in
Swami’s Establishment and Administration at para No. 6.3.1 is
applicable and followed by the CRPF organization. The relevant
portion of the said Para 6.3.1 is as under:“6.3.1 Principles to be observed and preparation of panel. –
The list of candidates considered by the DPC and the overall
grading assigned to each candidate, would form the basis for
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 4
preparation of the panel for promotion by the DPC. The
following principles should be observed in the preparation of
the panel:(a) Mode of Promotion. – In the case of „selection‟ (merit)
promotion, the hitherto existing distinction in the
nomenclature („selection by merit‟ and „selection-cumseniority‟) is dispensed with and the mode of promotion
in all such cases is rechristened as „selection‟ only. The
element of selectivity (higher or lower) shall be
determined with reference to the relevant benchmark
(“Very Good” or “Good”) prescribed for promotion.
(b) „Benchmark‟ for promotion. – The DPC shall determine
the merit of those being assessed for promotion with
reference to the prescribed benchmark and accordingly
grade the officers as „fit‟ or „unfit‟ only. Only those who
are graded „fit‟ (i.e., who meet the prescribed benchmark)
by the DPC shall be included and arranged in the select
panel in order of their inter se seniority in the feeder
grade. Those officers who are graded „unfit‟ (in terms of
the prescribed benchmark) by the DPC shall not be
included in the select panel. Thus, there shall be no
supersession in promotion among those who are graded
„fit‟ (in terms of the prescribed benchmark) by the DPC.”
[8]
Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr.PCCG appearing for
the respondents submitted that in view of the benchmark for
promotion to DIG rank from Commandant as quoted herein
above, the petitioner will be graded as ‘fit’ for promotion
since in the last five years the petitioner got four ‘very
good’/’outstanding’ grading in his APARs and one ‘good’ APAR
and there is no possibility of the petitioner being superseded by
his juniors in the matter of promotion to the rank of DIG. The
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 5
learned counsel also submitted that the authorities after
assessing and evaluating the performance of the petitioner
during the period from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016 gave the
grading of ‘good’ in the petitioner’s APAR and that the Director
General,
CRPF
after
due
consideration
rejected
the
representation submitted by the petitioner for upgradation of the
gradings recorded in his APAR during the said period as being
devoid of merit and accordingly, there is no ground or reason for
allowing the prayer made by the petitioner.
[9]
Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr. PCCG further
submitted that the petitioner’s contention that the grading of
‘good’ recorded in his APAR during the period from 15-05-2016
– 25-11-2016 is a below benchmark/adverse grading and that
such grading will have an adverse affect on his chance of
promotion to the post of DIG is unfounded and misconceived.
The learned counsel accordingly submitted that the present writ
petition is liable to be dismissed as being devoid of merit.
[10]
In the guidelines dated 31-03-2010 issued by the
Ministry of Home Affairs regarding benchmark for promotion
especially from Commandant in CPMFs to DIG rank, which is
enclosed as Annexure/C-13 in the additional affidavit dated 3105-2022 filed by the respondents No. 1 & 2, it is provided, inter
alia, that an Officer may be graded as ‘very good’ if he possess
at least four ‘very good’ gradings out of five ACRs/APARs and
the remaining ACRs/APARs under consideration is graded as
‘good’. In the affidavit dated 14-03-2023 filed by the
respondents No. 1 & 2, it has been stated that the principles to
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 6
be observed in preparation of panel as contained in para No.
6.3.1 of Swami’s Establishment and Administration is applicable
and followed in the CRPF organization. In para No. 6.3.1(b) of
the said Swami’s Establishment and Administration, it is
provided that the DPC shall determine the merit of those being
assessed for promotion with reference to the prescribed
benchmark and accordingly, graded the officers as ‘fit’ or ‘unfit’
and only those who are graded ‘fit’ by the DPC shall be included
and arranged in the selected panel in order of their inter se
seniority in the feeder grade and that there shall be no
supersession in promotion among those who are graded ‘fit’ by
the DPC.
[11]
After perusal of the additional affidavit filed by the
respondents No. 1 & 2 and on careful examination of the
guidelines dated 31-03-2010 issued by the Ministry of Home
Affairs regarding benchmark for promotion as well as provisions
under para No. 6.3.1 (b) of the Swami’s Establishment And
Administration regarding principles to be observed and
preparation of panel, which is applicable and followed in the
CRPF organization, this Court is of the considered view that if
the case of the petitioner is considered by the authorities for his
promotion to the rank of DIG by taking into consideration his last
five years APARs starting from 2012-2013 to 2016-2017, he will
be deemed fit for promotion to the rank of DIG under the CRPF
since the petitioner got three ‘very good’ and one ‘outstanding’
grading out of five APARs and the remaining one APAR being
graded as ‘good’.
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 7
[12]
In view of the above, this Court cannot agree with
the submission advanced by the learned counsel for the
petitioner that the grading of ‘good’ recorded in the petitioner’s
APAR during the period from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016is a
below benchmark grading and such grading will have adverse
effect on the petitioner’s chance for promotion to the rank of
DIG. Since this Court is of the considered view that the grading
of ‘good’ recorded in the petitioner’s APAR during the period
from 15-05-2016 – 25-11-2016 is not an adverse entry and
since such grading will not adversely affect the petitioner’s
chance of promotion to the rank of DIG, this Court is not inclined
to entertain the present writ petition and accordingly, the same
is hereby dismissed as being devoid of merit.
[13]
In the facts and circumstances of the present case,
there will be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Kim
WP(C)No. 134 of 2020
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review