The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Accordingly, order dated 26.09.2023 passed by First Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Indore in Miscellaneous Case No.84/2019 is hereby affirmed. The appeal being devoid of merit is hereby dismissed.
17. The appellant shall bear the cost of the respondent. 4:24:08 PM
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
FIRST APPEAL No. 2214 of 2023
BETWEEN:JAYA @
ANISHA SHARMA D/O
LT.
SHRI
JAGATNARAYAN SHARMA W/O MANOJ RATNAKAR,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, OCCUPATION: GOV. OFFICER
FLAT NO. 201, SUKOON VILLA, 3/2 NEW PALASIA,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI A. S. RATHORE - ADVOCATE)
AND
ANKURSINGH S/O SHRI SATISH KUMAR, AGED ABOUT
40 YEARS, OCCUPATION: ARMY CAPTAIN 37, VIKAS
ENCLAVE, RANJI PART-2, DELHI (DELHI)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI RAGHVENDRA SINGH RAGHUVANSHI - ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENT/CAVEATOR)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, Justice Devnarayan
Mishra passed the following:
ORDER
This first appeal has been filed by the appellant/wife - Jaya @ Anisha
Sharma being aggrieved with the order passed by First Additional Principal
Judge, Family Court, Indore in Civil MJC No.84/2019 on 26.09.2023 by which
the application of the appellant/wife under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil
Procedure has been dismissed.
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
02. The facts giving rise to this appeal in short are that as per the
appellant/wife the marriage of the appellant/wife and respondent/husband was
solemnized on 02.07.2017 as per Hindu Rites and Customs and both were
living as a married couple. After sometime of the marriage, husband Ankur
Singh filed the petition under Section 11 r/w Section 5(1) r/w Section 27 of
Hindu Marriage Act before the Principal Judge, Family Court Indore to annul
the marriage solemnized on 02.07.2017 and for delivery of ornaments and
expenditure incurred in marriage. The petition was allowed by the ex parte
order.
03. The appellant/wife - Jaya filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13
of the CPC before the First Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Indore
that was registered as Civil Case/MJC No.84/2019 on 15.04.2019 on the ground
that she came into the knowledge of ex parte order on 30.03.2019 and she
received the copy of the judgment on 11.03.2019. On 11.03.2019, she got
injury and due to that injury, she has not appeared before the Court on
11.03.2019 and her advocate was out of station. On that date, the Court has
recorded the ex parte evidence of the respondent and on 14.03.2019 by passing
ex parte decree has allowed the petition. Her counsel has clearly stated before
the Court that she is suffering from medical ligament injury on her foot and
ankle, so she cannot appear before the Court but the Court has not considered
the above facts. She has requested that the ex parte decree be quashed and
after giving an opportunity to file the reply and adduced the evidence, the matter
be re-adjudicated.
04. The respondent/husband filed the reply before the Court.
05. The trial Court after recording the evidence of the parties has passed
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
the impugned order by which the petition of the appellant has been dismissed.
06. Shri A.S. Rathore, learned counsel appearing on behalf of appellant
has argued that before the Family Court appellant appeared through her counsel
Shri Vijay Singh Rathore and Shri Rathore has filed a memo of appearance and
prayed that the appellant is having an injury in her leg. She is not able to be
present before the Court as a consequence of which time was sought by the
counsel for the appellant and on that basis the case was adjourned and date was
fixed for 17.01.2019 for conciliation proceedings. On 17.01.2019, the appellant
could not appear personally before the Court as a consequence of which an ex
parte order was passed against the appellant herein fixing the case on
07.03.2019 for recording of ex parte evidence.
On 25.02.2019, the
appellant/wife herein filed an application under Order 9 Rule 7 r/w 151 of the
CPC for setting aside ex parte order passed against the appellant and the case
was fixed on 07.03.2019 for hearing on application under Order 9 Rule 7 of the
CPC on the condition that the appellant shall remain present before the Court at
the time of hearing of the said application. Meanwhile, on 27.02.2019, the
respondent filed an application for urgent hearing which was allowed and
application under Section 9 Rule 7 of the CPC filed by the appellant was also
allowed on the basis of oral submission of respondent. The learned Family
Court directed not to adjourned the case as per the provisions of Section 32 of
Army Act, 1950 and the case was again fixed for conciliation proceedings on
07.03.2019 at 03:30 PM.
07. On 05.03.2019, an application under Section 32 of Army Act, 1950
r/w Section 151 of the CPC was presented by the respondent and on that the
case was transferred in the court of First Additional Principal Judge, Family
Court, Indore. On 07.03.2023, the case was fixed on 11.03.2023 despite the
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
objection by the appellant's counsel that he will not be available on 11.03.2023
and the appellant will not appear due to medical reasons.
08. The appellant filed an application under Section 13 r/w Rule 14 of
Family Court Act and Rules and also an application under Order 17 Rule 1 of
the CPC alongwith the medical documents seeking the adjournment but the
family Court dismissed the applications filed by the appellant and proceeded ex
parte against the appellant and the case was fixed for ex parte evidence on
13.03.2023. On 13.03.2023, an ex parte evidence was recorded though the
appellant filed an application for seeking the adjournment alongwith medical
report. On 14.03.2019, appellant filed an application under Section 151 of the
CPC and an application under Order 9 Rule 7 of the CPC but the same was
dismissed and arguments were heard and judgment and decree was passed.
9. Shri Rathore has further argued that the Family Court without going
through the record and evidence of the appellant and medical evidence
dismissed the application that is against the established principles of law and
submitted that the appeal be allowed. The order of the trial Court be cancelled,
an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC be allowed, the judgment and
decree passed in HMA No.1474/2018 be quashed, the appellant be give an
opportunity to file the written statement and adduced her evidence then matter
be decided afresh.
10. Learned counsel for the respondent has argued that in this case the
appellant/wife was constantly watching the proceedings and on notice she did
not turn up but when the learned trial Court ordered to issue notice through
paper publication then she appeared through her counsel Shri Rathore on the
same date i.e. 10.12.2018 at later stage and on that date it was stated by the
learned counsel that she has injury in her foot, so she cannot personally appear.
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
On 17.01.2019 for which the case was fixed, she did not turn up and the ex
parte order was passed against her and after that she filed an application under
Order 9 Rule 7 of the CPC on 25.02.2019 which were allowed and she was
given the opportunity to appear in person but she never appeared before the
Court. She wanted to prolong the litigation and that is why the trial has passed
the ex parte decree in the light of Section 32 of Army Act, 1950.
11. The Family Court in MJC Case No.84/2019 under Order 9 Rule 13
of the CPC has give an opportunity to adduce the evidence. No documents of
government hospital has been produced by which it can be assessed that the
injury was of such a nature that the appellant could not appear before the Court.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
12. In the original case, an application for annulment of the marriage was
filed on 24.08.2018 by the husband. The order to issue the notice to opposite
party was ordered on 27.08.2018. On 26.10.2018, it was also ordered that the
notice be served by the RAD and the notice was un-served. On 10.12.2018, the
Court has ordered that the notice be served through paper publication on the
same date, the learned counsel for the appellant appeared before the Court and
requested that the appellant got injury in her leg, so she cannot appear before
the Court and on that basis the Court granted time but since 10.12.2018 till
14.03.2019. The appellant/wife not appeared personally before the Court. If the
statement of the counsel Shri Vijay Rathore as recorded by the trial Court in the
order sheet dated 10.12.2018 taken true, the appellant was unable to move due
to injury in her leg. From the statement and medical record, no bone fracture
was found on her foot, only ligament injury was found and before the Family
Court, the report dated 25.02.2019 of Dr. Rajeev Hingorani of Shalby Hospital
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
has been produced prior to that no prescription or medical document has been
produced by the appellant before the Family Court, though she was suffering
from leg injury on 10.12.2018.
13. It is further observed that till 25.10.2019, she has not consulted any
doctor or hospital nor have taken any treatment and for non-appearance on
17.01.2019, she has not produced any document. For the first time she
consulted the doctor on 25.02.2019 and on that date she got a medical unfitness
of 10 days and after that she has regularly filed the prescription and sick
certificate.
14. The family Court has discussed all the above facts in its impugned
order and elaborately dealt with the documents and after due-appreciation of
evidence has passed the impugned order. Nothing has been brought that on the
appellant Jaya summon was not duly served or she was prevented by sufficient
cause for not appearing before the family Court on the date of hearing instead
from the overall proceeding, conduct and the documents produced by the
appellant, it appears that her sole motive was to prolong the litigation and the
trial Court in its order in MJC No.84/2019 dated 26.09.2023 has considered all
the facts and situations.
15. The learned Counsel for the appellant has failed to indicate that the
trial Court has ignored the fact brought on the record and has committed any
mistake while deciding an application filed by the appellant. Thus, no perversity
is found in the order passed by the Family Court.
16. Accordingly, order dated 26.09.2023 passed by First Additional
Principal Judge, Family Court, Indore in Miscellaneous Case No.84/2019 is
hereby affirmed. The appeal being devoid of merit is hereby dismissed.
17. The appellant shall bear the cost of the respondent.
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
18. With the copy of this order, the record of the trial Court be returned
back.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
VS
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 12/01/2024
4:24:08 PM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review