Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 638 of 2017
WithMC(WP(C)) No. 131 of 2023
WithMC(WP(C)) No. 164 of 2018
WithMC(WP(C)) No. 291 of 2017
WithMC(WP(C)) No. 311 of 2021
Dr. Ningombam Minita Devi, aged about 46 years, w/o. Ch. Jayanta
Singh presently working and functioning as Statistician-cum- Assistant
Professor, Dept. of Community Medicine, JNIMS, Porompat and resident
of Soibam Leikai, Ayangpalli Road, P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East –
795005, Manipur.
… Petitioner
Versus
1. The Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences (JNIMS) represented by
its Director at JNIMS Porompat, Imphal East, Manipur.
2. Dr. Haobijam Nirendra Kumar Singh, aged about 48 years, s/o. Late H.
Angousana Singh, a resident of Thangmeiband Lairenhanjaba Leikai, P.O.
Lamphel and P.S. Imphal, District Imphal West, Manipur.
… Respondents
With
WP(C) No. 231 of 2020
Dr. Haobijam Nirendra Kumar Singh, aged about 51 years, s/o. Late H.
Angousana Singh, a resident of Thangmeiband Lairenhanjaba Leikai, P.O.
Lamphel and P.S. Imphal, District Imphal West, Manipur.
… Petitioner
Versus
1. The Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences (JNIMS) represented by
its Director at JNIMS Porompat, Imphal East, Manipur.
2. Dr. Urmila Thiyam, aged about 62 years, w/o. Dr. Salam Nongthon Singh,
a resident of Singjamei Mayengbam Leikai Lairembi Lampak, P.O. Imphal,
P.S. Singjamei, District Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
3. Dr. Keisham Sarojini Devi, aged about 63 years, w/o. Dr. L. Deben Singh, a
resident of Nagamapal Kangjabi Leikai, District Imphal West, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners
:: Mr. N. Umakanta, Adv. for WP(C)
No. 638 of 2017,
Mr. H.S. Paonam, Sr. Adv.,assisted
by Ms. Lekhakumari, Adv. in WP(C)
No. 231 of 2020.
For the respondents
:: Mr. S. Nepolean, G.A. assisted
by Mrs. R.K. Emily, Dy. G.A. for
R1 (JNIMS); None for R-2&3.
Date of hearing
:: 24.04.2023 & 25.04.2023
Date of Judgment and Order
:: 22.12.2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
The present writ petitions have been filed by the petitioners under Article
226 of the Constitution of India qua seeking reliefs with respect to filling up of
the newly upgraded and created post of Associate Professor in the Department
of Community Medicine, JNIMS by way of promotion. Since the issues involved
in both the writ petitions relate to the same factual matrix, they are heard
together and disposed of by this common judgment.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
It may be noted that writ appeals being WA Nos. 22 of 2023 and 23 of
2023 against the interim orders dated 01.02.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022
and dated 20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)] No.315 of 2021 are pending before
Division Bench. Vide orders dated 16.03.2023 in these writ appeals, Registry
was directed to post WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 and WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 on
21.03.2023 along with the writ appeals. However, vide common order dated
21.03.2023 passed by the Division Bench in these batch of appeals and writ
petitions, Registry was further directed to place writ appeals, ie, WA Nos. 22 of
2023 & 23 of 2023 along with misc. applications before another Division Bench
and to de-tag WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 and WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 and misc.
applications and post before this Court on 29.03.2023. In the circumstances,
the writ petitions and the pending applications were listed before this Court for
consideration. In may also be pointed out that writ appeals being WA Nos. 5 of
2023 and 6 of 2023 are pending before Division Bench of this Court in respect
of matters connected with WP(C) No. 231 of 2020.
WP(C) No. 638 of 2017
[2]
The brief facts of the case in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 is that pursuant to
notice/advertisement dt. 25.01.2011 of the Director, Jawaharlal Nehru Institute
of Medical Sciences (in short ‘JNIMS’), and upon recommendation of the
Selection Board, the petitioner namely, Dr. Ningombam Minita Devi was
appointed as Statistician-cum-Asst. Professor in the Department of Community
Medicine, JNIMS vide order No. JNIMS/TS-1/4/08 (iv) dt. 17.05.2011. By the
year 2015, the petitioner had completed 4 years of minimum service in the
grade of Asst. Professor, besides fulfilling other criteria as laid down by the
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Minimum Qualification for Teachers Regulations, 1998 framed by the Medical
Council of India, and as such became qualified and eligible for promotion to the
next higher post of Associate Professor.
Vide letters dated 07.01.2016 and 20.10.2016, the petitioner requested
the
JNIMS
Authority
for
upgradation
of
her
post
of
Assistant
Professor/promotion to Associate Professor. In the meantime, the Governing
Council of JNIMS in its meeting held on 15.10.2016 proposed for upgrading
certain post of Asst. Professor to the next higher post of Associate Professor.
The proposal was approved by the State Cabinet and accordingly, 16 (sixteen)
posts of Associate Professor were created by upgrading 13(thirteen) post of
Assistant Professor and creating 3 more additional posts. The same was notified
vide Office Order dt. 23.02.2017 being No. 1/7/ESTT/JNIMS/08/12766 issued
by the Director, JNIMS.
[3]
Further, on 03.04.2017, communication bearing no. 1/366/Appointment
Faculty/2016(pt) was issued by the Director, JNIMS regarding holding of DPC
on 04.04.2017 for selection of Associate Professors in different departments of
JNIMS. The DPC proceedings for 15 posts of the newly created posts of
Associate Professors was completed on 04.04.2017 itself. However, in respect
of the Associate Professor post in Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS,
DPC proceeding was deferred and re-fixed on 05.04.2017 due to objection from
one of the DPC members regarding flouting of norms. On 05.04.2017 itself, the
petitioner served legal notice on the concerned authorities to hold and conduct
the DPC as per MCI regulations and DPC norms such as preparation of eligible
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
candidates in feeder grade as per seniority etc. The authority concerned again
tried to deviate from the norms inviting objection from one of the DPC
members, thereby leading to deferment and postponement of the DPC without
fixing dates. On 07.04.2017, the petitioner filed an application/representation
to the concerned authority of JNIMS requesting for re-convening the
deferred/postposed DPC for promotion to the post of Associate Prof., Dept. of
Community Medicine, JNIMS and to give primacy/preference to the senior-most
eligible candidate in the feeder grade of Assistant Professor, Dept. of
Community Medicine, JNIMS. As her application dt. 07.04.2017 was not acted
upon, the petitioner filed WP(C) No. 246/2017 before this Court for directing
the JNIMS authority to re-convene the deferred DPC at the earliest while giving
primacy to the petitioner on account of being the senior-most Assistant
Professor. The said WP(C) No. 246/2017 was disposed of on 12.04.2017 with
directions, relevant portion thereof is being reproduced as hereunder:
“
Accordingly, the present writ petition is disposed of with the direction
to the respondent authorities to consider filling up the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Community Medicine by considering the claim
of all the eligible candidates including the petitioner by acting upon the relevant
seniority list in accordance with the relevant rules including the MCI norms in
this regard. It is expected that the authority will undertake the aforesaid
exercise preferably within a period of one month from today.
Petition stands disposed of accordingly.”
[4]
Thereafter, vide letter dated 07.07.2017 of the Director, JNIMS, it was
informed to the petitioner that the available promotional post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS is to be from
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
amongst Associate Professors with medical background only, and that she
being from a non-medical background is not eligible for the said promotional
post.
[5]
Aggrieved by the said decision of JNIMS authority, the petitioner filed
the present WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 seeking inter-alia for quashing and setting
aside the decision of JNIMS authority declaring the newly created post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS to be
the promotional post of Assistant Professor with medical background only, and
further to declare that the said newly created post of Associate Professor, Dept.
of Community Medicine, JNIMS to be the promotional post of Statistician-cumAssistant Professor, JNIMS. The writ petitioner further prays for an alternative
relief to the effect that the respondent/JNIMS authority be directed to create
promotional post of Associate Professor, Dept. of Community Medicine to be
filled up from amongst non-medical background Assistant Professors/faculty,
for their career advancement.
[6]
The case of the respondent JNIMS and private respondent namely, Dr.
H. Nirendra Kumar Singh in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 is that the vacant post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS should
be filled up from amongst Associate Professors with medical background, and
as such the writ petitioner therein, belonging to a non-medical background is
not eligible for promotion to the vacant post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS in terms of the minimum
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
qualification for teachers in Medical Institutions Regulations, 1998. Accordingly,
both respondents pray for dismissing the writ petition as being devoid of merit.
WP(C) No. 231 of 2020
[7]
The case of the writ petitioner in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 (also
subsequently impleaded as private respondent in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 vide
order dated 09.10.2017 in MC[WP(C)] No.241 of 2017) is that pursuant to the
recommendation of the Selection Board vide order dated 17.05.2011, writ
petitioner namely, Dr. Haobijam Nirendra Kumar Singh was appointed as
Medical Officer of Health cum Assistant Professor in the Department of
Community Medicine, JNIMS. The petitioner claims that in the final seniority list
of Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS published
vide notification dt. 03.08.2015, his name was reflected at Sl. No. 3 and since
the persons at Sl. Nos. 1 and 2 are now promoted to the post of Associate
Professors, he has now become the senior-most in the grade of Assistant
Professor in the Department. Vide order dated 28.01.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No.
18 of 2021: Ref- WP(C) No. 231 of 231 of 2020, the private respondent Nos. 2
& 3 were impleaded as respondents as their rights for promotion would
allegedly be affected by the interim order dated 18.05.2020. It may be noted
that the respondent Nos. 2 & 3 are not from the same Department of
Community Medicine to which the petitioner herein belongs to.
[8]
The petitioner had earlier moved this Court by filing WP(C) No. 266 of
2017 for considering his case of promotion to the post of Associate Professor,
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS, and on 24.04.2017, the same was
disposed of, relevant operative portion of which is reproduced as under:
“
In view of the above, the present writ petition is disposed of with a
similar direction to the respondent authorities to consider filling up the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Community Medicine, NJIMS by
considering the claim of all eligible candidates including the petitioner if eligible,
by acting upon the relevant seniority list in accordance with the relevant rules
including the MCI norms in this regard. It is expected that the authority will
undertake the aforesaid exercise preferable within a period of one month from
today.
Petition stands disposed of accordingly.”
[9]
Accordingly, DPC for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS was held on 15.09.2017. However,
the result could not be declared owing to an interim order dt. 11.09.2017
passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 which reads as under:“
Heard Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner;
heard also Mr. A. Bimol, learned senior counsel for the JNIMS.
It has been submitted by Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel for the
petitioner that the DPC is going to be held for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Community Medicine, JNIMS without
considering the case of the petitioner, and if the DPC is allowed to be held, the
petitioner’s interest would be adversely affected, even though this Court had
directed consideration of the petitioner also.
This is objected to by Mr. A. Bimol, learned senior counsel for the JNIMS
contending that the petitioner is not eligible. This aspect will be considered
after filing of the affidavit-in-opposition.
It is however, directed that, in the interim and until further
order, if the DPC is held, the result of the same may not be declared
without leave of this Court.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
List the matter on 09.10.2017.”
[10]
When the authority of JNIMS began the process of filling up vacant posts
of Associate Professors, the present writ petitioner had also filed WP(C) No.
604 of 2019 before this Court to restrain filling up of the said posts of Associate
Professors pending disposal of WP(C) No. 638 of 2017. However, the same was
disposed on 25.09.2019 taking into record the submission of learned senior
counsel of JNIMS that the DPC for the remaining 1(one) vacant post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Community Medicine will not be held
till the disposal of WP(C) No. 638 of 2017, as under:
[25.09.2019
Heard Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel for the petitioner.
The present writ petition has been filed with the following prayers:
“In view of the above, it is, therefore, prayed that this Hon’ble Court
may graciously be pleased to:
i)
Issue rule nisi and call for the records;
ii)
Issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ or
direction of the like nature restraining the respondents from
giving further promotion to the post of Associate Professor in
JNIMS pending disposal of the WP(C) No. 638 of 2017.”
Mr. A. Bimol, learned senior counsel appearing for the JNIMS, on
instructions, submits that there are 4 (four) posts of Associate Professor in the
Department of Community Science. Out of 4 (four) posts, 2 (two) posts are
occupied by Dr. Rk. Bishwalata & Dr. H. Kulabudhi Singh and the remaining
2(two) posts of Associate Professor is vacant till date. He also submits that the
DPC for 1(one) post out of 2(two) vacant posts for Associate Professor was
held on 15.09.2017 and the result is kept in a sealed cover in terms of the
interim order dated 11.09.2017 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
It is also submitted that the DPC for the remaining 1(one) vacant post
of Associate Professor in the Department of Community Medicine will not be
held till the disposal of WP(C) No. 638 of 2017.
Considering the submissions made by the learned senior counsel
appearing for the JNIMS, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
apprehension of the writ petitioner stands addressed.
Accordingly, recording the submissions of the learned senior counsel
appearing for the JNIMS, writ petition is closed.]
[11]
In the meanwhile, on 12.03.2020 the State Government have requested
the JNIMS authority to submit draft rules/scheme to give effect to Time Scale
Promotion Scheme for teachers (Assistant Professors and Associate Professor)
of JNIMS. The present writ petitioner thereafter moved this Court in WP(C) No.
231 of 2020 to restrain the JNIMS authority from giving promotion under the
Time Scale Promotion Scheme coupled with an interim prayer to restrain the
JNIMS authority from filling up the post of Associate Professor and Professor in
JNIMS under the proposed Time Scale Promotion Scheme.
[12]
On the other hand, respondent JNIMS in its affidavit-in-opposition filed
by the Director, JNIMS took the stand that the proposed time scale promotion
rule is in the process of implementation, and thus, the question of restraining
further promotion under the said rule does not arise. It is further clarified that
the Time Scale Promotion Rule, 2018 are only for the 77 regular appointed
(Senior Residents, Demonstrators, Tutors, Lady Medical officer) and not
applicable otherwise. Prayer is thus made to reject the relief sought for in the
present WP(C) No. 231 of 2020.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
[13]
During the pendency of the present writ petitions, vide order dated
18.05.2020 passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020, this Court passed an interim
order restraining the respondent JNIMS authority from filling up the post of
Associate Professor and Professor in JNIMS under the proposed Time Scale
Promotion Scheme, which is reproduced as under:
[18.05.2020
Heard Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned senior counsel for the petitioner.
On request made by Mr. Nepolean, learned counsel appearing for the
JNIMS, list the matter on 26.05.2020.
In the interim, the respondents are directed not to fill up the
post of Associate Professor & Professor in the JNIMS under the
proposed Timescale Promotion Scheme, till the next returnable date.]
[14]
The respondent JNIMS moved a miscellaneous case in WP(C) No. 231 of
2020 being MC(WP(C))No. 7 of 2021, seeking to modify the interim order dt.
18.05.2020 whereby direction was given restraining the respondents from
filling up the post of Associate Professor and Professor in JNIMS under the
proposed Time Scale Promotion Scheme. Vide order dated 22.04.2021,
reproduced hereunder, the same was allowed:
[22.04.2021
Heard Mr. S. Nepolean, learned G.A. for the applicant. Also heard Mr.
HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent/writ
petitioner.
By
this
application,
the
application
is
praying
for
vacation/modification/alteration of the interim order dated 18.05.2020 and
subsequent extension orders passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Mr. S. Nepolean, learned G.A. appearing on behalf of the applicant,
submits that though the applicant has filed the present misc. application
praying for vacation/modification/alteration of the interim order dated
18.05.2020 passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020, the applicants, at this stage,
would be satisfied if the interim order dated 11.09.2017 passed in WP(C) No.
638 of 2017 is modified by permitting the applicants to declare the results of
the DPC meeting held on 15.09.2017 for promotion to the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Community Medicine which shall, however, be
subject to the outcome fo the writ petition.
Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent/writ petition, has no objections in allowing the applicants to declare
the results of the DPC held on 15.09.2017.
In that view of the matter, the interim order dated 11.09.2017 passed
in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 is modified by allowing the applicants to declare the
results of the DPC held on 15.09.2017 for promotion to the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Community Medicine, which shall, however, be
subject to the outcome of WP(C) No. 638 of 2017.
It is also directed that after the declaration of the results of the DPC
held on 15.09.2017 for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Community Medicine, both the recommended and nonrecommended person shall be considered under the time scale promotion for
teachers of J.N. Institute of Medical Sciences.
Accordingly, the interim order dated 18.05.2020 passed in WP(C) No.
231 of 2020 shall also stand modified to that extend.
Misc. Case stands disposed of.]
[15]
Pursuant thereto, writ petitioner in WP(C) 638 of 2017 challenged the
order dated 22.04.2021 passed in MC(WP(C)) No. 7 of 2021 of WP(C) No. 231
of 2020, by filing WA No. 31 of 2021. Vide order dated 13.05.2021 passed in
WA No. 31 of 2021, the said order dated 22.04.2021 under appeal was set
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
aside and MC(WP(C)) No. 7 of 2021 was restored on file to be decided on merits
afresh, on the short ground that the writ appellant was not given an opportunity
of being heard in the said order under appeal.
[16]
Thereafter, the respondent JNIMS authority preferred MC(WP(C)) No.
315 of 2021 in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 seeking to vacate the interim order dated
18.05.2020 passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 whereby the respondent JNIMS
was restrained from filling up the post of Associate Professor and Professor in
JNIMS under Time Scale Promotion Scheme. Vide order dated 20.12.2021
passed in MC(WP(C)) No. 315 of 2021, the said interim order dated 18.05.2020
was vacated with a direction to accommodate the writ petitioners in WP(C) No.
638 of 2017 and WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 within a period of 3(three) weeks from
the date of receipt of copy of the order, the relevant portion being reproduced
as hereunder:
[
After hearing learned counsel for the parties and on consideration of
the materials available on record, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the interim order dated 18-05-2020 passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 is a
blanket order not to fill up the post of Associate Professor & Professor in the
JNIMS under the proposed Timescale Promotion Scheme. On consideration of
the Timescale Promotion Scheme for Teachers of JNIMS Rules, 2020 which was
notified on 18th December, 2020, this Court is of the considered opinion that
upgradation under this scheme is purely personal and the promotion effected
will be non-functional. The submission of the learned Addl. AG that any
upgradation in any posts under the Timescale Promotion scheme is purely
personal and the incumbents would continue to receive the pay scale of the
post held prior to their upgradation unless they are accommodated in a
substantive vacancy in the upgraded post has also been considered.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Accordingly, interim order dated 18-05-2020 passed in WP(C)
No. 231 of 2020 is vacated. The applicants are permitted to make
upgradation of the incumbents eligible under the Timescale
Promotion Scheme for Teachers of JNIMS Rules, 2020. The applicants
are also directed to accommodate both the writ petitioners in WP(C)
No. 638 of 2017 and WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 in the post of Associate
Professor, Community Medicine as proposed by the applicants within
three weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. However,
accommodation/promotion of the two writ petitioners shall be
subject to the outcome of the results in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 and
WP(C) No. 231 of 2020. The prayer for vacation of the interim order
dated 15-09-2017 passed in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 is rejected.
Misc case stands disposed of.]
[17]
Unable to comply with the directions abovementioned, respondent
JNIMS authority filed MC(WP(C)) No. 22 of 2022 seeking extension of time to
implement the directions contained in the order dated 20.12.2021. The same
was allowed vide order dated 01.02.2022 which is reproduced as under:
[01.02.2022
Heard Mr.Lenin Hijam, learned Addl. Advocate General, Manipur
appearing on behalf of the applicants. Also heard Mr.H.S.Paonam,
learned senior counsel for the respondent/writ petitioner in WP(C)
No.231 of 2020 and Mr.N.Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner in WP(C) No.638 of 2017 as well as Mr.N.Jotendro, learned
senior counsel for the applicants in MC (WP(C)) No.35 of 2022.
By these application, the applicants are praying for extension of
time for implementing the order dated 20.12.2021 which was passed in
MC (WP(C)) No.315 of 2021, on the ground that the exercise for
complying the order is taking some time as the first part of the order
dated 20.12.2021 regarding upgradation of eligible incumbents under
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
the Time Scale Promotion for 2 Teachers of JNIMS Rules, 2020, the
JNIMS Rules, 2015 do not have provision for fixation of inter-se seniority
and the process for fixing the said inter-se seniority is under process. It
is further submitted that the Model Code of Conduct has come into
effect from 8.1.2022 and the process is underway to seek exemption
from the Election Commission through the Screening Committee
constituted vide order dated 9.1.2022.
MC (WP(C)) No.315 of 2021 was disposed of by an order dated
20.12.2021 and the relevant portions are extracted hereinbelow:
“After hearing learned counsel for the parties and on
consideration of the materials available on record, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the interim order dated 18-052020 passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 is a blanket order not to
fill up the post of Associate Professor & Professor in the JNIMS
under the proposed Timescale Promotion Scheme. On
consideration of the Timescale Promotion Scheme for Teachers
of JNIMS Rules, 2020 which was notified on 18th December,
2020, this Court is of the considered opinion that upgradation
under this scheme is purely personal and the promotion effected
will be non-functional. The submission of the learned Addl. AG
that any upgradation in any posts under the Timescale
Promotion scheme is purely personal and the incumbents would
continue to receive the pay scale of the post held prior to their
upgradation unless they are accommodated in a substantive
vacancy in the upgraded post has also been considered.
Accordingly, interim order dated 18-05-2020 passed in WP(C)
No. 231 of 2020 is vacated. The applicants are permitted to
make upgradation of the incumbents eligible under the
Timescale Promotion Scheme for Teachers of JNIMS Rules,
2020. The applicants are also directed to accommodate both the
writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 and WP(C) No. 231 of
2020 in the post of Associate Professor, Community Medicine as
proposed by the applicants within three weeks from the date of
receipt
of
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
a
copy
of
this
order.
However,
accommodation/promotion of 3 the two writ petitioners shall be
subject to the outcome of the results in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017
and WP(C) No. 231 of 2020. The prayer for vacation of the
interim order dated 15-09-2017 passed in WP(C) No. 638 of
2017 is rejected. Misc case stands disposed of.”
Mr.Lenin Hijam, learned Addl. A.G, Manipur submits that the
National Medical Commission Rules, would be coming into effect by
17.2.2022 and, therefore, an order is also required to exempt the
incumbents who are eligible for upgradation in the Time Scale
Promotion Scheme for Teachers of JNIMS Rules, 2020 and also for
accommodation of both the petitioners in WP(C) No.638 of 2017 and
WP(C) No.231 of 2020 in the post of Associate Professor, Community
Medicine. He further submits that the Inter-se seniority is being finalized
and, therefore, once the exemption from the Election Commission is
obtained, the applicants would have no difficulty in complying with the
order dated 20.12.2021 passed in MC (WP(C)) No.315 of 2021.
At this stage, Mr.H.S.Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
respondents/writ petitioner in WP(C) No.231 of 2020 draws attention
of this Court to Annexure M/2 (Colly), particularly to the “Self-contained
Note for placing before the Screening Committee to be chaired by the
Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur”, issued by the Director JNIMS
on 13.1.2022 wherein at Sl.No.4 it is proposed to hold fresh DPC as per
the JNIMS Service Rules – 10(b) for accommodating the two writ
petitioners in WP(C) No.638 of 2017 and WP(C) No.231 of 2020. He
submits that both the writ petitioners were already screened in the DPC
held in the year 2017 as per the Rules of the JNIMS and, therefore, a
fresh DPC as proposed would be subjecting both the petitioners to
another DPC, which is not required. He also submits that at present,
considering the length of service, the petitioner would not be eligible
for Time Scale Promotion to the post of Professor, Community Medicine
and, therefore, a direction may also be issued to keep one post of
Professor, Community Medicine vacant.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Mr.N.Umakanta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
WP(C) No.638 of 2017 endorses the submission made by Mr.Paonam,
learned senior counsel for the respondent.
Mr.N.Jotendro, learned senior counsel appearing for the
applicants in MC (WP(C)) No.35 of 2022 submits that the applicants are
entitled to be promoted as Professor under the JNIMS Rules of 2020 as
mandated under Rule 4, which provides that Time Scale Promotion shall
be implemented every year by drawing up vacancy on the 1st February
of every year starting from 1.2.2021 by calculating 22% of the total
post of Associate Professors and also Assistant Professors. However, as
the same was not done in the year 2021, when the applicants takes up
the matter with regard to giving promotion, calculation for the year
from 1.2.2021 should be a total of 44% (i.e. 22% for the year 2021 and
22% for the year 2022).
Mr.Lenin, learned Addl. A.G, appearing on behalf of the
applicants submits that there would be no impediment on the part of
the applicants to consider the case of eligible incumbents for Time Scale
Promotion to the post of Professor from Associate Professor by
calculating 44% of the total regular posts (i.e. from 1st February 2021).
He also submits that as and when the exemption is granted by the
Election Commission, the case of the petitioners in WP(C) No.638 of
2017 and WP(C) No.231 of 2020 can be considered separately for
accommodation in the post of Associate Professor, Community
Medicine.
After hearing the parties, MC (WP(C)) No.22 of 2022 is
accordingly allowed by granting extension of time of 4 (four)
weeks for implementing the order dated 22.10.2021 passed in
MC (WP(C)) No.315 of 2021 within four weeks’ time from
today. The extension is also granted for accommodating both
the petitioners in WP(C) No.638 of 2017 and WP(C) No.231 of
2020 in the post of Associate Professor in Community Medicine
without holding a fresh DPC. However, for the substantive post
of Associate Professor, Community Medicine which arose in the
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
year 2019 the same shall be subject to the outcome of the
decision in WP(C) No.638 of 2017.
The applicants are also directed to make upgradation of the
eligible incumbents including the applicants in MC (WP(C)) No.35 of
2022 under the Time Scale Promotion Scheme for Teachers of JNIMS
Rules, 2022 within the extended period. It is also made clear that
the National Medical Commission Rules, which is to come into
effect from 17.2.2022 would have no bearing on the
accommodation of the petitioners in WP(C) No.638 of 2017
and WP(C) No.231 of 2020 for the post of Associate Professor,
Community Medicine as well as those incumbents who are
eligible under the Time Scale Promotion by calculating 44% of
the total regular post (i.e. 22% for the year 2021 and 22% for
the year 2022). The parties are also directed that one post of
Professor in Community Medicine shall not be filled up which
shall, however, be subject to the outcome of the WP(C) No.638
of 2017. Accordingly, these misc. applications are disposed of. Furnish
copy of this order to learned counsel for the parties through their
respective emails/WhatsApp.]
[18]
Thereafter, respondent JNIMS authority filed Review Petition Nos. 7 and
8 of 2022 seeking review of the order dt. 01.02.2022 passed in MC(WP(C)) No.
22 of 2022 and order dt. 20.12.2021 passed in MC(WP(C)) No. 315 of 2021 in
WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 respectively. The said review petitions are dismissed on
19.12.2022 by a common order on the ground that there is no error apparent
on the face of the record and no case for interference is made out in the matter.
It is also stated that the orders sought to be reviewed have been passed on
the proposal of the learned Additional Advocate General representing the
review applicant and therefore, there is no apparent error on the face of record
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
or discovery of new facts for making the present review applications
maintainable.
[19]
It may be noted that writ appeals being WA Nos. 22 of 2023, 23 of 2023,
5 of 2023 and 6 of 2023 are pending before the Division Bench arising out of
the interim orders dated 01.02.2022, 20.12.2021 and common order in review
petitions dated 19.12.2022. The WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 and 231 of 2020 along
with the connected applications are listed before this Court in view of the order
dated 21.03.2023 passed by the Division Bench in WA Nos. 22 of 2023 & 23 of
2023 by de-tagging the writ petitions from the writ appeals of the same cases.
[20]
This Court has heard Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel for the petitioner
in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017, Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel for petitioner
in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 & who is also respondent No.2 in WP(C) No. 638 of
2017 assisted by Ms. Lekhakumari, Advocate and Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA
assisted by Mrs. RK Emily, learned Deputy GA on behalf of JNIMS authority in
both cases.
[21]
Vide order dated 29.03.2023, this Court permitted the petitioner in
WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 to file an application to bring on record subsequent
events and accordingly an additional affidavit dated 21.04.2023 was filed and
taken record. On 24.04.2023 when the cases were taken up for hearing, it was
recorded that both Mr. N. Umakanta and Mr. S. Nepolean would seek
instructions as to whether the petitioner in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 could be
considered for accommodation in time scale promotion in the scale of Associate
Professor. On 25.04.2023, Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA placed before this Court
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
a letter dated 25.04.2023 addressed to him from the Director, JNIMS inter alia
stating that the case of Dr. N. Minita (petitioner in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017)
could be considered along with others, subject to fulfilling the eligibility criteria.
The letter was taken on record. The matter was reserved for judgment on
25.04.2023 and parties were permitted to submit short written submissions
giving chronology of the events. Accordingly, written submissions of the parties
have been taken on record.
[22]
From the pleadings of the petitions, it is seen that the main prayers in
WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 are for setting aside the decision of JNIMS authority
declaring the newly upgraded and created post of Associate Professor,
Department of Community Medicine to be the promotional post of Assistant
Professor with medical background only; to declare the newly created post as
promotional post of Statistical-cum-Professor, JNIMS; or in alternate, to direct
JNIMS authority to create promotional post of Associate Professor, Department
of Community Medicine to be filled from faculty members/Assistant Professor
with non-medical background, ie, Statistician-cum-Assistant Professor for
career advancement of non-medical background. Vide order dated 11.09.2017
in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017, this Court passed an interim order directing that
DPC result, if held, should not be declared without leave of the Court. DPC for
the post of Associate Professor, Community Medicine, JNIMS was held on
15.09.2017 and the proceedings was kept under sealed cover in pursuance to
the interim order dated 11.09.2017.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
[23]
The main prayer in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 is for direction restraining
from giving promotion to the post of Associate Professor and Professor in JNIMS
under the proposed Time Scale Rules pending disposal of WP(C) No. 638 of
2017. Vide an interim order dated 18.05.2020, this Court directed JNIMS not to
fill up the post of Associate Professor & Professor in the JNIMS under the
proposed Time Scale Promotion Scheme till next returnable date and the same
was extended from time to time. The interim order dated 18.05.2020 was
vacated vide order dated 20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)] No. 351 of 2021 and
directed JNIMS to accommodate both the writ petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 638 of
2017 & 231 of 2020 in the post of Associate Professor, Community Medicine as
proposed by JNIMS. It may be noted that private respondent Nos. 2 & 3
(belonging to other departments) were impleaded in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020
on their applications, as their career would be affected the interim order dated
18.05.2020 which prevented Time Scale Promotion for the whole institute. It
may be pointed out that WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 was filed after reserving of
WP(C) No. 638 of 2017 for judgment.
[24]
It is seen from the case record that JNIMS filed an application being
MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021 for modification of the interim order dated
18.05.2020 in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020 and to permit it to conduct DPC for about
100 faculty members including the writ petitioners namely, Dr. H.
Nirendrakumar Singh and Dr. N. Nimita Devi for promotion to the next higher
post as per law, subject to the outcome of WP(C) Nos. 231 of 2020 & 638 of
2017. It is specifically stated in the application that there were 2 (two)
vacancies for the post of Associate Professor of Community Medicine in JNIMS
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
and both the petitioners could be accommodated against the existing vacancies
in addition to the promotion to be given to 100 faculty members proposed for
promotion.
[25]
After hearing the parties at length and on perusal of the undertakings
made in the application and during the hearing, vide order dated 20.12.2021
in MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021, this Court vacated the interim order dated
18.05.2020 passed in WP(C) No. 231 of 2020, as the same was a blanket order
not to fill up the post of Associate Professor and Professor in JNIMS under the
proposed Timescale Promotion Scheme. It was further directed to JNIMS to
accommodate the writ petitioners in both cases in the post of Associate
Professor, Community Medicine as proposed by JNIMS within a period of three
weeks, subject to the outcome of WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of 2020.
However, the prayer for vacation of interim order dated 11.09.2017 in WP(C)
No. 638 of 2017 was rejected.
[26]
Later on, JNIMS filed an application being MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022 for
extension of 2 (two) months’ time to comply the directions in order dated
20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021. Vide order dated 01.02.2022 in
MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022, this Court granted extension of 4 (four) weeks for
implementation of the order dated 20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021.
It was further clarified that the time extension was granted for accommodating
both the writ petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of 2020 in the post
of Associate Professor in Community Medicine without holding a fresh DPC.
However, for the substantive post of Associate Professor in Community
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Medicine which arose in the year 2019, the same would be the outcome of the
decision in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017. It was further directed that the upgradation
of the eligible incumbents including the applicants in MC[WP(C)] No. 35 of 2022
under Time Scale Promotion Scheme for Teachers in JNMIS Rules, 2022 be also
made within the extended period. It was also made clear that the National
Medical Commission Rules to be effective from 17.02.2022 would not have any
bearing on the accommodation of the petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 &
231 of 2020 for the post of Associate Professor, Community Medicine as well
as those incumbents eligible under the Time Scale Promotion by calculating
44% of the total regular posts (ie. 22% for the year 2021 and 22% for the year
2022). It was further directed to that one post of Professor in Community
Medicine should not be filled up, subject to the outcome of WP(C) No. 638 of
2017.
[27]
The crux of order dated 01.02.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022 is that
the writ petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of 2020 are to be
accommodated without facing fresh DPC as they had already been subjected
to the DPC held in the year 2017. The accommodation of the writ petitioners
and other eligible incumbents shall not be affected by the new NMC Rules. The
protection is given not only to the writ petitioners, but also to all eligible
incumbents of JNIMS from other Departments.
[28]
JNIMS filed two review petitions being RP No. 7 of 2022 against order
dated 01.02.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022 and RP No. 8 of 2022 against
order dated 20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021 inter-alia on the grounds
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
that- (i) there were only one clear vacancy in Community Medicine as the other
vacancy was reserved for the DPC held in 2017, and (ii) the direction for
accommodation in Time Scale Promotion could be implemented only after
disposal of WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of 2020 or on modification of the
interim orders passed in these petitions. Vide common order dated 19.12.2022,
this Court dismissed the review petitions being, RP Nos. 7 of 2022 and 8 of
2022, as the orders dated 01.02.2022 and 20.12.2021 under review were
passed on the proposal of learned Addl AG representing JNIMS and also there
was no apparent error on the face of record nor discovery of new facts.
[29]
When the matter is taken up for hearing, the writ petitioners in both
cases, ie, WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of 2020 do not press on the merit of
the case. Since the rights of both of them and other eligible incumbents have
been protected by the interim orders dated 01.02.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No. 22
of 2022 and dated 20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021, it has been urged
by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the writ petitions may be
disposed of by directing JNIMS to declare the result of the DPC held on
15.09.2017 [which has been kept in sealed cover in pursuance to interim order
dated 11.09.2017 in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017] and accommodate the nonrecommended candidate by DPC of 2017 in the subsequent vacancy or under
Time Scale Promotion Scheme in pursuance to the afore-said orders dated
20.12.2021 and 01.02.2022.
[30]
Due to the various interim orders, the process for promotion to the post
of Associate Professor, Community Medicine in JNIMS and Time Scale
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
Promotion could not be completed, thereby causing stagnation in the promotion
and other related matters concerning the service conditions of the incumbents.
The review petitions have been filed on the limited grounds that there was only
one clear vacancy in the Associate Professor in Community Medicine and the
second vacancy (as submitted by JNIMS in MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021) arose
only in the years 2019 and hence could not be adjusted in the DPC of 2017 and
the directions for accommodation of the both the writ petitioners and other
eligible incumbents of JNIMS could be considered only after the disposal of
WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of 2020 or upon modification of the interim
orders.
[31]
This Court is of the considered opinion that the interest of the writ
petitioners and other incumbents whose interests have been affected by the
pending petitions as well as the concern of JNIMS, can be safeguarded by
introducing a via media. The same can be achieved by directing the JNIMS
authority to declare the result of the DPC held on 15.09.2017 for the post of
Associate Professor, Community Medicine [kept in sealed cover in pursuance to
interim order dated 11.09.2017 in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017]. The nonrecommended incumbent/petitioner may be considered against the vacancy
arose in the year 2019 or may be considered for accommodation in Time Scale
Promotion along with other eligible incumbents in terms of orders dated
01.02.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022 and dated 20.12.2021 in MC[WP(C)]
No. 315 of 2021.
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
[32]
In the facts and circumstances of the cases and in order to do complete
justice, the writ petitions are disposed with a direction to JNIMS that the result
of the DPC held on 15.09.2017 for promotion to the post of Associate Professor
in JNIMS in respect of Community Medicine [which is kept in sealed cover in
pursuance to interim order dated 11.09.2017 in WP(C) No. 638 of 2017] be
declared within a period of 1(one) month from the date of receipt of this order,
by giving effect from the date of DPC, ie, 15.09.2017 or from the date on which
similarly situated incumbents have been given promotion in pursuance to the
DPC conducted in the year 2017 in JNMIS. It is clarified that the JNIMS may
consider the case of the incumbent/petitioner who is not recommended by the
DPC, in the vacant post of Associate Professor of Community Medicine arose in
the year 2019 or under the Time Scale Promotion Scheme as directed in orders
dated 01.02.2022 in MC[WP(C)] No. 22 of 2022 and dated 20.12.2021 in
MC[WP(C)] No. 315 of 2021. It is further clarified that other eligible incumbents
of JNIMS are also to be considered in terms of the afore-said orders.
[33]
In view of the directions in para 32, WP(C) Nos. 638 of 2017 & 231 of
2020 are disposed of. Interim orders, if any, are merged with the final order.
Misc. applications, if any, are disposed of in terms of these directions. No cost.
[34]
Send a copy of this order to the Director, JNIMS for information.
JUDGE
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2024.01.11
10:10:08 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 638 OF 2017 & WP(C) NO. 231 OF 2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review