Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 53
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No.756/2023
CrlM No. 1631/2023
CrlM No. 1462/2023
Reserved on: 18.08.2026
Pronounced on: 20.08.2026
Uploaded on: 20.08.2026
Operative part or
full judgment: Full
1.
2.
Jaswant Singh
S/O Bichater Singh
R/O Village Salehar,
Tehsil Bishnah, District Jammu.
Abhishek Singh
S/O Jaswant Singh
R/O village Salehar,
Tehsil Bishnah, District Jammu.
…....Petitioners
Through: Mr. R S Kotwal, Advocate.
Vs.
1. Anita Devi
W/O Surjeet Singh
R/O Village Salehar
Tehsil Bishnah
District Jammu
2. UT of J&K through
Principal Secretary, Home Deptt.,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu
3. Station House Officer,
Police Station Arnia,
District Jammu.
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. Vishal Sadotra, Advocate for R-1.
Mr. P. D. Singh, Dy. AG for R-2&3.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Petitioners, through the medium of this petition, seek quashing/setting aside
of the order dated 13.04.2023, passed under Section 156(3) of CrPC by learned
Judicial
Magistrate
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
(Munsiff)
Bishnah,
directing
SHO,
P/S
Arnia
to
register an FIR against the petitioners on the basis of a complaint/application dated
20.01.2023, filed by respondent No.1-Anita Devi.
2.
Petitioners have pleaded, in their petition, that the complainant-Anita Devi
along with her husband Surjeet Singh committed criminal trespass into land
measuring 4 kanals comprising of Survey No.636 situated in Revenue Village
Salehar, Bishnah, owned by the petitioners on the basis of a Sale Deed registered
on 22.12.2021 by Sub Registrar Jammu South, which was also mutated in favour
of petitioner No.1 on 15.02.2022 and, on their complaint, FIR No. 7/2023 was
registered against the complainant and her husband on 18.01.2023 at P/S Arnia for
the commission of offences punishable U/Ss 447/427/504/506 IPC; that as a
counterblast to the FIR registered against them, respondent No.1, moved an
application on 27.01.2023, seeking direction to SHO, P/S Arnia, to register an FIR
against the petitioners.
3.
The learned Magistrate called for a report from the police, who submitted the
same on 27.02.2023, which revealed that a report was recorded on the complaint
of complainant-Anita Devi on 09.12.2022, however, no cognizable offence was
made out as she on examination by the doctor was found to have received minor
injuries, as such, offence under Section 323 IPC only was constituted, which was
not cognizable by the police; that on 13.04.2023, the learned Magistrate passed the
impugned order directing registration of an FIR against the petitioners. Aggrieved
of the impugned order, the same was challenged through a Revision Petition
before Principal Sessions Court Jammu, however, it is claimed that same was
withdrawn by the petitioners, in view of judgment delivered by this court on
17.12.2020 in case titled ‘Sat Pal Sharma V. Pawan Singh Rathore’.
4.
The impugned order has been assailed on the grounds that the same has been
erroneously passed against the petitioners on the same facts when already
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
complaint/report of the respondent-complainant had been recorded on 09.12.2022
by the police for taking action under law; that the learned Magistrate had exceeded
jurisdiction vested in him under Section 156(3) CrPC, as the offence reported by
the police was non cognizable, for which, process of law has been initiated by the
police concerned; that dispute between the petitioners and respondents was of civil
nature for which civil litigation was also pending in two civil courts, however, the
respondent-complainant wants to harass the petitioners by filing false criminal
cases and that the impugned order requires to be quashed to prevent the abuse of
the process of court and to secure the ends of justice.
5.
Pursuant
to
notice,
respondent
No.1-complainant
filed
objections,
controverting the assertions made in the petition, asserting that the complaint filed
before the learned Magistrate clearly revealed the cognizable offence and the
police being hand in glove with the petitioners have reported about non cognizable
offence under Section 323 IPC only; that the learned Magistrate has rightly
directed for registration of the FIR under the ambit of law and has not exceeded
jurisdiction in any manner. Admitting the pendency of civil litigation before the
courts of learned Munsiff Bishnah, and learned City Judge Jammu, it was pleaded
that it is well settled law that on the basis of civil litigation, criminal proceedings
cannot be quashed and finally, it was prayed to reject this petition.
6.
The official respondent No.2, in its reply/status report, has pleaded that the
inherent powers of this court can be exercised sparingly, carefully and with
caution and should not be resorted to as remedies of appeals and revision.
7.
Mr. Kotwal, learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the
complainant/respondent No.1 had moved an application on 27.01.2023, against the
petitioners and the police, after conducting an enquiry, submitted a report dated
27.02.2023 that an offence under Section 323 IPC was made out on the basis of
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
the complaint, which is a non cognizable offence; that, thereafter, the learned
Magistrate on a complaint lodged by the respondent-complainant vide impugned
order dated 13.04.2023 directed SHO of the jurisdictional police station to register
a case, whereas, the fact of the matter is that the police had already enquired into
the matter and submitted a status report to the learned Magistrate that only a non
cognizable offence under Section 323 IPC was made out, on the basis of the
complaint lodged by the complainant and her medical examination report and that
a permission shall be sought to file a complaint.
8.
Mr. Kotwal further, vehemently, argued that the learned Magistrate directed
the registration of the case under Section 156(3) CrPC, which is a provision to be
invoked for registration of the case in cognizable offences, in a case, wherein the
police had already after conducting an enquiry, reported that offence constituted
was non cognizable under Section 323 IPC; that the learned Magistrate, on the
basis of the police report, should have passed orders, if any, in terms of Section
155 CrPC, dealing with non cognizable offences; that the learned Magistrate has
committed grave illegality and the impugned order is, thus, liable to be set aside.
9.
Learned counsel for the respondents, initially, making submissions that the
police should have registered the case as the complainant had alleged the
commission of offences under Section 325 IPC, which was cognizable and if at all
after the investigation, the police could reach to this conclusion that the offence
constituted was non cognizable as in case of offence under Section 323 IPC, the
case could have been filed, for the commission of this offence and that there was
no illegality committed by learned Magistrate while passing the impugned order,
however, they reconciled to the scheme of the CrPC as contained under two
different provisions of Sections 155 and 156 CrPC, dealing with non cognizable
and cognizable offences, respectively.
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
10.
Chapter XII of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, deals with
information to the police and their powers to investigate. Section 154 CrPC deals
with information in cognizable cases, whereas Section 155 CrPC deals with non
cognizable cases and investigation of such cases. Section 156 CrPC deals with
police officers’ powers to investigate cognizable cases.
11.
The admitted facts, in the present case, are that the complainant/respondent
No.1 had moved a complaint before the learned Magistrate Bishnah on
27.01.2023, against the petitioners alleging that on 09.12.2022 at about 1.45 PM,
the petitioners, herein, deliberately and intentionally trespassed into her land and,
on being objected, started to beat the complainant mercilessly with fists and blows
and also used unparliamentary language; that she was examined at PHC Arnia, on
09.12.2022; that the complainant, on being assaulted, had suffered miscarriage of
her unborn child and, as such, it was prayed that the police concerned be directed
to register a case for investigation.
12.
It appears that the police as directed had filed a report on 27.02.2023 before
the learned Magistrate stating that on examination of the complainant by a doctor,
she was found to have received minor injuries, as such, an offence under Section
323 IPC only was made out, regarding which, a complaint shall be lodged before
the court after seeking permission.
13.
The learned Magistrate vide impugned order dated 13.04.2023, observing
that ‘prima facie’ the contents of the application do disclose commission of
cognizable offences, directed, the jurisdictional police, to register an FIR in the
case under the relevant provisions of law and report compliance forthwith. The
learned Magistrate, in such a situation, was under an obligation before passing
directions for registration of the case to take a view as to what was the offences
constituted and as to what was the reason not to agree with the police report with
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
regard to the commission of a non cognizable offence. The complainant, had
alleged that she suffered miscarriage, on being assaulted by the petitioners, and the
Magistrate should have enquired into this aspect of the matter before directing the
police concerned to register a case in a routine manner, that too, after a period of
more than two months from the date of receipt of application.
14.
The police is under an obligation to register a case for investigation in all
those cases, which are cognizable, in terms of Section 154 CrPC, however, in the
case of non cognizable cases, the police has to record the information and
thereafter refer the informant to the Magistrate having jurisdiction. Sub Section (2)
of Section 155 CrPC provides that the police officer is debarred from investigating
a non cognizable offence without the orders of the Magistrate concerned. Once
such an order is received by the police officer, he can exercise the same powers as
he may exercise in a cognizable offence, except he cannot exercise the power of
arrest without warrant. The learned Magistrate, on the basis of the complaint filed
before him and the report filed by the police thereon, should have discussed in
detail as to what could be the offence committed against the person of the
complainant before a direction to the police concerned for investigation of the
matter. The learned Magistrate had the option to ask for a report from the police
concerned with regard to the non cognizable offence, whereupon, the investigation
could have been ordered in terms of Section 155(2) CrPC, instead of Section
156(3) CrPC.
15.
It is settled law that police officer cannot investigate non cognizable case
without the permission of the Magistrate. At the cost of repetition, it is made clear
that investigation into a non cognizable case cannot be undertaken without orders
of a Magistrate, whereas, there is no such requirement in case of cognizable cases.
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
16.
Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and the legal
position discussed hereinabove, this court is of the considered opinion that the
impugned order passed by the learned Magistrate is not sustainable for the limited
reason that the learned Magistrate has passed the direction for registration and
investigation of the case, invoking the provisions of Section 156(3) CrPC, which is
available in the cognizable cases, instead of the relevant provisions of law, under
Section 155(2) CrPC to order investigation in a non cognizable case, or in the
alternative not satisfied with the inquiry of the police, the learned Magistrate could
have proceeded in the complaint itself and tried the same as a private complaint.
17.
Viewed thus, the instant petition is allowed and the impugned order, being
unsustainable, is set-aside and the matter is remanded back to the Trial Court for
passing fresh orders, on receipt of the police report by taking a cumulative view of
complaint and police report, of course, after affording an opportunity of being
heard to both the sides. A copy of this order shall be forwarded to the learned
Judicial Magistrate Bishnah, for compliance.
18.
The petition is, accordingly, disposed of as allowed along with connected
application(s).
) (M.A Chowdhary)
Judge
(
Jammu:
20.08.2026
Raj kumar
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
Yes
Yes
Raj Kumar
2026.08.20 16:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM(M) No. 756/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review