The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Having considered thus, we come to this conclusion that the injuries disclosed by post-mortem notes and the inquest report are clearly consistent with the deposition of PW-1 and PW-16. Having carefully considered the said evidence, we find no reason to differ from the conclusion arrived at by the learned trial Judge that the incident took place as has been deposed by the prosecution witnesses and that establishes that the appellant used a knife (one side sharp and other side blunt) aggressively and thus committed the offence of murder of the victim. Accordingly, this court is of the view that the trial court has rightly convicted the appellant based on material evidence produced by the prosecution and there is no infirmity in the impugned findings regarding conviction.
14. In view of foregoing analysis, in our view, the learned trial court has appreciated the evidence on permissible legal parameters and reached to a plausible conclusion. The prosecution could establish its case beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, we find no reason to interfere in the Page 15 impugned judgment as passed by the learned trial court convicting the appellant to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life.
15. Accordingly, the appeal fails and the same is hereby dismissed. Send down the LCRs. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed. Saikat CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A (J) 18/2021
Jashim Ahmed
son of late Manjir Ali, resident of West Irani, Ward No. 2,
P.S. Irani, District- Unakoti, Tripura
----Appellant
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. PK Biswas, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Majumder, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, PP
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. PP
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
09.03.2023
Whether fit for reporting
Yes / No
:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
(Amarnath Goud, ACJ)
Heard Mr. PK Biswas, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P.
Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr. Ratan
Datta, learned PP assisted by Mr. S. Debnath, learned Additional PP
appearing on behalf of the respondent.
2.
This appeal arises out of the judgment and order of conviction and
sentence dated 02.09.2021 passed in connection with case No. S.T. 17 (UK)
of 2019 by the learned Sessions Judge, Unakoti District, Kailasahar, whereby
and whereunder the learned Sessions Judge had convicted the appellant for the
offence punishable under Section 302 IPC, and sentenced him to suffer R.I.
for life with default stipulation.
Page 2
3.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that, on 15.07.18 at about 10-30
AM the informant and his brother Jashim Ahmed, the appellant herein had
gathered in the house of their uncle Jahur Ali and therein the appellant
demanded their uncle to amicably partition their ancestral property. Jahur Ali
told the appellant that it will be done later on. In the mean time tea was served
to all the parties. Suddenly the appellant brought out a knife from his waist
and started hitting the informant with it. The informant jumped over to the
road to save himself and the appellant chasing him started hitting him again
with the knife. The informant was saved at the intervention of their uncle
Jahur Ali. The appellant then escaped from the spot towards the house of the
informant following him. At that point of time, wife of the informant, namely,
Jyotsna Begum was standing in the verendah of the house. The appellant
started to hit Jyotsna Begum with the knife and when she tried to flee, she was
held back by Halima Bibi, wife of the appellant. Jyotsna Begum fell down and
the appellant ran away towards the jungle. Local people shifted the informant
and his wife to the hospital where the Doctors declared that Jyotsna Begum
was brought dead. The informant was also admitted to the hospital where
police came and recorded his complaint. He was referred to GBP hospital,
Agartala for better treatment but on his own accord, he went to Silchar.
4.
The said complaint was registered as Irani PS case no. 45 of 2018 under
Sections 120(B)/448/326/302/34 of the IPC. The matter was investigated by
the investigating officer, and after completion of investigation submitted
Page 3
charge-sheet against the convict appellant under Sections 447/326/307/506 of
the IPC. At the commencement of trial, the learned Sessions Judge had framed
charges against the convict appellant and his wife, Halima Bibi under Section
120(B) IPC and again framed charges against the convict appellant under
Sections 448/326/302 of the IPC to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed
to be tried.
5.
During trial, the prosecution to establish the charges had adduced 19
(nineteen) witnesses and exhibited some documents. After closure of
recording evidences, the convict appellant and his wife were examined under
Section 313 Cr.P.C. wherein they denied all the allegations levelled against
them by the prosecution witnesses and also denied to adduce any evidence on
their behalf. After hearing arguments and on examining the evidences and
materials on record, the learned Sessions Judge had acquitted Halima Bibi
from the charges levelled against her, but convicted and sentenced the
appellant for committing offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. Hence,
this appeal before this court.
6.
Mr. PK Biswas, learned senior counsel for the appellant has submitted
that the prosecution has miserably failed to establish the charges levelled
against the convict-appellant. Mr. Biswas, learned counsel has further argued
that according to the complainant, Jahur Ali had saved him from the hand of
the appellant, but said Jahur Ali was not cited as a witness. Further, Mr.
Biswas, learned senior counsel has argued that the mother-in-law of the victim
Page 4
i.e. PW-16 is a chance witness whose deposition has not been supported by
any of the prosecution witnesses. Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel has also
argued that since there is no eye witness to the alleged incident, the order of
conviction of the appellant cannot sustain. Further, Mr. Biswas has submitted
that PW 10 had deposed that the miscreants were wearing masks around their
face. Learned senior counsel also has submitted that there are many
contradictions between the deposition of the witnesses. Lastly, learned senior
counsel has urged this court to set aside the judgment and order as passed by
the learned trial court and release the appellant.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. Ratan Datta, learned PP has supported the
findings of the learned trial court while convicting the accused. Mr. Datta,
learned PP has also submitted that if the evidences of prosecution witnesses
are read conjointly, it could safely be presumed that the convict appellant had
committed the alleged offence. Hence, learned PP has submitted to maintain
the findings of the learned trial court.
8.
We have considered the submissions for learned counsel appearing for
the parties. We have also perused the evidences and materials on record and
the judgment passed by the learned Sessions Judge. For purpose of
appreciating the submissions of learned counsel, it would be pertinent for us
to revisit the evidences let in by the prosecution witnesses.
PW 1 Sri Abdul Mukim, the complainant-cum-victim of this case
deposed that on 15-07-18 at about 10.30 am he was in the house of his
Page 5
uncle Jahur Ali. His younger brother Jasim also went to that house and
asked his uncle for amicable partition of their ancestral property and then
his uncle told him that he will do that at later stage and in the mean time
tea was offered to all of them. All of a sudden his brother took out knife
from his waist and started hitting him and then he in order to save himself
jumped over the road and his brother Jasim also chased him and again
started hitting him with knife and then their uncle Jahur Ali saved him
from his hand. Then, his brother escaped from the spot towards his house
and the appellant also followed him towards their house. He found that his
wife at the relevant time came out from home and was standing in the
veranda and in the meantime his brother Jasim started hitting his wife
Jyotsna Begam with knife and when his wife tried to escape from the
place, the wife of his brother, Halima Bibi detained his wife and then
again his brother Jasim started hitting his wife with the knife. In the result,
his wife fell down and his brother Jasim ran away from that place towards
the jungle. Local people rushed to the spot and shifted his wife to
Bhagabannagar hospital but doctor declared her brought dead. He was also
admitted in the hospital and during his admission police went to the
hospital and recorded his complaint.
PW 2, Prasenjit Paul, deposed that on 16-07-2018 police seized one
DVD cassette being handed over by him and prepared seizure list which
Page 6
was marked as Ext 2. Nothing material has been elicited from his crossexamination.
PW 3, Surman Ali, deposed that on 15-7-18 he went to Bhagabannagar
hospital, Kailashahar and there Darogababu prepared inquest report over
the dead body of one Jyotsna Begam in presence of him and others.
Witness identified his signature in the inquest report and the same was
marked as Ext 3. Nothing material has been elicited from his crossexamination.
PW 4, Rajan Malakar, deposed that on 17-7-18 he was in Maa studio,
Kailashahar town and in his presence police seized one DVD cassette
preparing seizure list which was marked as Ext. 2/1. Nothing material has
been elicited from his cross-examination.
PW 5, Tamjid Ali deposed that on 18-07-2018 being asked by police
personnel of Irani PS he escorted them at the place in the bank of Irani
stream and there Jashim Ahmed went down the stream and recovered one
knife and then the same was seized by police taking his signature in the
seizure list which was marked as Ext. 4. The witness identified a knife
produced in the court as being the one which had been seized in his
presence and the same was marked as Ext M.O.1. In cross examination he
stated that he saw one side of knife was blunt and another side was sharp.
Jashim Ahmed went to the stream along with police personnel.
Page 7
PW 6, Abdul Basid was tendered by the prosecution. In cross
examination he deposed that he knew Jashim Ahmed as well Tamjid Ali.
Once in the last year Jashim Ahmed went along with police and thereafter
he found one knife in the hand of Jashim but he cannot say from where he
got that knife.
PW 7, Iqbal Ahmed, deposed that on 18-7-18 being asked by police of
Irani PS he went to the PS and thereafter police, himself, Jashim Ahmed
and others went to Irani stream and thereafter Jashim recovered one knife
from the stream and the said process was video graphed by him and then
he made CD from said videography and the same was handed over to
police. Witness identified one CD and claimed the same was made by him
and handed over to police. Nothing material has been elicited from his
cross-examination.
PW 8, Musaraf Ali, deposed that on 15-07-18 at noon time all on a
sudden he received one phone call with an information that Jashim
Ahmed stabbed his sister Jyotsna and her husband Abdul Mukim with a
knife and having heard the same, he went to the house of his sister and
found that local people were shifting his sister and her husband towards
hospital by an auto rickshaw and then he also accompanied them to
Bhagabannagar hospital but on the very night doctor declared his sister as
dead and his brother-in-law Abdul Mukim remained under treatment at
hospital. After the death of his sister Darogababu prepared inquest report
Page 8
over the dead body in his presence and others and during examination of
dead body he found stab injury over the stomach/belly and back side of
her body. Nothing material has been elicited from his cross-examination.
P.W. 9, Majmun Islam, P.W.10, Hasirun Nessa and P.W.11, Abdul
Sukur were tendered by prosecution.
PW 12, Dr. Sekhar Sarkar is the Doctor who conducted the postmortem
of the victim. On 15-7-18 he was posted as Medical Officer at Bhagaban
Nagar hospital, Kailashahar. On that day IO of the case placed dead body
of one Jyotsna Begam along with dead body challan and inquest report of
the deceased for the purpose of P.M. examination and then being endorsed
by MS of the hospital he conducted P.M examination over the dead body
of the deceased observing proper formalities. After examination he
prepared report in details and opined that the cause of death is shock and
hemorrhage resulting from injury caused by impact of double edged long
bladed sharp cutting weapon. He collected and preserved viscera. As per
his opinion the injury sustained with double edged long bladed sharp
cutting weapon.
PW 13, Swapan kumar Dhar, is a seizure witness.
PW 14, Bishnu Suklabaidya deposed that on 15-7-2018 at about 11-30
at noon being asked by people of locality he went to the house of Abdul
Mukim and then shifted Abdul Mukim and his wife being injured to
Page 9
Bhagabannagar hospital for treatment. Cross examination of this witness
was declined by the defence.
PW 15, Saktisadhan Jamatia, is the investigating officer who on
completion of the investigation and having found prima facie case
furnished charge sheet.
PW 16, Nabija Bibi deposed that victim Jyotsna was her daughter and
she was married to Abdul Mukim of Irani. About one year prior to the
date of deposition she went to her daughter’s matrimonial home because
she was pregnant at that time. During that time she found Jasim, Abdul
Mukim and Halima Bibi were quarreling among them, and thereafter,
Jasim went to the house of Jahur Ali and thereafter she heard hue and cry
in the house of Jahur Ali and she came out at the court yard and found that
Jasim came to the court yard with knife in hand and stabbed her daughter
Jyotsna with knife and then Halima Bibi caught hold Jyotsna and again
Jasim gave second stab on the back side of Jyotsna and then she fell down
and thereafter she tried to save her daughter Jyotsna, but by that time she
already lost her sense and witness also fainted. Thereafter she could not
see anything but later on she found that she was already shifted to
hospital. She also found her daughter Jyotsna already dead in the hospital.
She identified Accused Jasim and Halima Bibi in the court. During crossexamination she told that her daughter Jyotsna was married about 3 years
back. Jasim had four brothers and they live in the same complex. Abdul
Page 10
Mukim is brother of Jasim and he also lives in the same house. Nothing
material has been elucidated from her cross-examination.
PW 17, Md. Abdullah, deposed that on 15-7-18 he was posted at Irani
PS, Kailashahar as SI of police. On that day he visited Kailashahar
District hospital and there he found Abdul Mukim was admitted and he
gave oral complaint to him and the same was recorded by him as per his
version and thereafter the said complaint was forwarded to OC PS for
necessary action.
PW-18, S.I Jatish chandra Das, deposed that in course of his
investigation he collected PM report of the deceased and arrested accused
Jashim Uddin and also recorded his discloser statement in presence of
Executive Magistrate and other witnesses. Thereafter as per his discloser
and being indicated by Jashim Uddin, witness recovered one sharp knife
in a stream and then seized the same in presence of the witnesses. He also
examined available witnesses and recorded their statements and arranged
examination of blood collected from the P.O by forensic teams and it was
found that the blood was of deceased Rushna Begam. He also collected
blood sample of injured Abdul Mukim through doctor. He seized one Tshirt of accused Jashim Ahmed. He sent the blood sample collected from
PO from injured Abdul Mukim and the recovered and seized knife to
SFSL for examination. Witness also seized one DVD playing cassette.
During cross-examination witness deposed that at the time of recording
Page 11
discloser statement of the accused, one Ikbal Ahmed, the videographer
was present and no other local witnesses were there.
PW 19, S.I. Sanesh Debbarma deposed that on 01-09-2018 he was
endorsed with a case for completion of the investigation and also handed
over the case record. After receiving the case docket and on perusal of the
same he found that the previous I.O Jatish Chandra Das had almost
completed the investigation. During investigation he re-examined all the
witnesses previously examined by his predecessor, but did not record their
statement having found corroborative in nature. He collected injury report
of Abdul Mukim from hospital, also collected SFSL report of exhibit
already sent by previous I.O. At last on 30-12-2018 on completion of the
investigation and having found prima facie case he furnished charge-sheet
against accused Jashim Ahmed and absconding accused Halima Bibi.
During cross examination witness deposed that he collected injury report
of Abdul Mukim from Silchar Medical Collage & Hospital. As per injury
report of Abdul Mukim, the injury sustained by him was simple and was
caused by blunt object.
9.
On scrutiny and scanning of prosecution evidence and other materials
as well as the defence evidences and facts and circumstances on record
keeping them in juxtaposition, it transpires clearly that initially there was an
altercation between the accused-appellant and the victim and the appellant had
stabbed the victim and his wife with a knife. PW-1, the complainant in his
Page 12
complaint had stated that all of a sudden his brother took out knife from his
waist and started hitting him and then he to save himself jumped over the road
and his brother Jasim also chased him and again started hitting him with
knife and then their uncle Jahur Ali saved him from his hand. He in his
complaint has also stated that he found that his wife at the relevant time came
out from home and was standing in the veranda and in the mean time his
brother Jasim started hitting his wife Jyotsna Begam with knife and when his
wife tried to escape from the place the wife of his brother Halima Bibi
detained his wife and then again his brother Jasim started hitting his wife with
the knife. In course of his cross-examination, the complainant did not turn
down from his previous statement and reiterated that he stated to police officer
who recorded his complaint that immediate after being separated by his uncle
his brother Jasim ran towards his house and he also followed and thereafter
he started hitting his wife with knife and while his wife tried to escape from
the spot the wife of Jasim obstructed her. PW-16, also in her evidence had
deposed that after the first stab by the appellant when victim tried to flee the
wife of the appellant caught of the victim and prevented her from escaping
allowing the appellant to stab her the second time. Thus, the deposition of the
complainant and PW-16 does corroborate to each other and there is no
discrepancies in their statement to hold that the appellant had caused the
murder of the wife of the victim.
Page 13
10.
From the inquest report (Exhibit 3) it transpires that there is one deep
injury mark measuring around 2 ½ x 1 ½ inch on the chest of the deceased
which seems like an injury by sharp knife. It also transpires from Exhibit-3
that one deep injury is there on the back of the deceased measuring 2 ½ x 1 ½
inch which seems like an injury by a sharp knife. From the post mortem report
(Exhibit-5) it would transpire that there is injury on the chest and back of the
victim which would be the impact of double edged long sharp cutting weapon.
Thus, the inquest report evidently supports the post mortem report and also
the statement of the complainant made in the FIR that the appellant had
stabbed his wife with a double sided knife.
11.
From the disclosure statement (Exhibit 10) of the accused-appellant, it
becomes apparent that the appellant first went to the house of Johur Ali and
dealt blows on hand and shoulder of the complainant, Abdul makim with one
knife and thereafter came running to his own house and dealt blows with the
knife on the chest and back of wife of the complainant, who had sustained
fatal injuries. Further, the appellant had led to the spot for discovery of the
weapon of offence i.e. Irani stream, from where the weapon of offence i.e. the
knife which is sharp at one end and blunt at other end, was recovered by the
investigating officer in presence of local witnesses.
12.
The nature of the complaint is supported by the evidence of PW-1 and
PW-16 and also by the medical reports i.e. the inquest report and the post
mortem report. PW-1 sustained injury inflicted by the appellant by a knife
Page 14
(sharp at one end and blunt at other end) and also that the victim i.e. wife of
PW-1 also sustained fatal injury and the same is established from the postmortem report and the inquest report. As per the complainant and PW-16, the
victim was stabbed with a knife which was recovered at the instance of the
appellant himself. The forensic report also indicates that the blood stains on
the knife are of human origin.
13.
Having considered thus, we come to this conclusion that the injuries
disclosed by post-mortem notes and the inquest report are clearly consistent
with the deposition of PW-1 and PW-16. Having carefully considered the said
evidence, we find no reason to differ from the conclusion arrived at by the
learned trial Judge that the incident took place as has been deposed by the
prosecution witnesses and that establishes that the appellant used a knife (one
side sharp and other side blunt) aggressively and thus committed the offence
of murder of the victim. Accordingly, this court is of the view that the trial
court has rightly convicted the appellant based on material evidence produced
by the prosecution and there is no infirmity in the impugned findings
regarding conviction.
14.
In view of foregoing analysis, in our view, the learned trial court has
appreciated the evidence on permissible legal parameters and reached to a
plausible
conclusion.
The
prosecution
could
establish
its
case
beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, we find no reason to interfere in the
Page 15
impugned judgment as passed by the learned trial court convicting the
appellant to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life.
15.
Accordingly, the appeal fails and the same is hereby dismissed.
Send down the LCRs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Saikat
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review