Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.71 of 2025
Jamal Uddin (Aged 50 years),
son of Asaddar Ali,
resident of Ranigram,
Jalalnagar, P.S. Karimganj,
State-Assam, Pin No.-788712
---- Petitioner on behalf of Custody Accused Person(s)
Md. Abdul Pata (Aged 37 years),
son of Amad Uddin,
resident of Nilambazar, Ranigram,
P.S. Nilambazar, Sreebhumi, Assam
---- Custody Accused Person(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
(represented by the Secretary,
Home Department), Government of Tripura,
Agartala
----Respondent(s)
______________________________________________________
For Applicant(s)
: Mr. Janardhan Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Mr. Subhradip Sharma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
________________________________________________________
[---
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
08/09/2025
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023
corresponding to Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is filed for granting bail to
the accused in custody namely Md. Abdul Pata in connection with
Bagbassa P.S. Case No.12/2025 under Section 8(C)/22(C)/29 of
NDPS Act, 1985.
[02]
Heard Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel assisted
by Mr. S. Sharma appearing for the accused in custody. Also
heard Learned P.P., Mr. R. Datta appearing on behalf of the Staterespondent. At the time of hearing, Learned P.P. produced the CD
and also received the record from the Learned Trial Court.
(2)
[03]
Taking part in the hearing, Learned counsel for the
accused in custody first of all drawn the attention of the Court
referring the contents of the FIR and submitted that from the sua
moto complaint it is clear that nothing was mentioned as to the
date, time and place of detention of the accused in custody which
was mandatory. Furthermore, in the FIR the informant has
enclosed some of the documents but nowhere it was mentioned
that the ground of arrest as required under Article 22 of the
Constitution of India was communicated to the accused custody.
Furthermore, the accused was produced before the Court of
Learned CJM in absence of Learned Special Judge on 03.07.2025
and from the order passed by Learned CJM, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar dated 03.07.2025 (Annexure-3) it appears that in
the order sheet also nothing was reflected by Learned CJM that
the ‘grounds of arrest’ was duly communicated to the accused.
Learned counsel further drawn the attention of the Court referring
the order dated 04.07.2025 passed by Learned Special Judge,
North Tripura, Dharmanagar (Annexure-4) wherein from the order
sheet it will further transpire that ‘no grounds of arrest’ was duly
communicated either orally or in writing to the accused in custody.
Learned counsel again drawn the attention of the Court referring
arrest memo i.e. Annexure-2 of the bail application and referring
the said document he submitted that in column No.5 nothing was
mentioned
by
IO
that
the
‘grounds
of
arrest’
was
duly
communicated in writing to the accused which violates Article 21
and 22 of the Constitution of India and the same also violates
Section 47 and 48 of BNSS, 2023. In this regard, Learned counsel
(3)
referring the case of Vihaan Kumar, Prabir Purkayastha and
Pankaj Bansal of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India drawn the
attention of the Court that he has referred the citations of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India of the aforesaid cases in different
bail applications and in the present case, the directions referred by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforenoted cases have not been
complied with by the police authority. Furthermore, Learned
counsel also referred the order dated 11.08.2025 passed by
Learned Special Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar wherein the
judgment of this High Court in W.P.(Crl.)04 of 2025 was reflected,
but the principle of the said judgment has not been considered by
the Learned Trial Court. So, in summing up, Learned counsel for
the accused in custody submitted that since the prosecution has
failed to comply with the mandatory provisions of law by not
supplying/informing the ‘grounds of arrest’ in writing to the
accused in custody and as such, the present accused in custody
deserves to be released on bail in any condition henceforth. He
further submitted that prosecution may take the plea that the
contraband item was recovered from his possession and he had
knowledge of the same is not a sufficient ground to overlook the
principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in series of
judgments. He also submitted that Learned P.P. may refer the
case of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India but the said citation
was relating to a case of murder, not relating to a case under
NDPS Act and as such, the said principle cannot be applied in this
case and urged for releasing the accused on bail in any condition.
(4)
[04]
On the other hand, Learned P.P. taking part in the
hearing strongly countered the submission made by Learned
counsel for the accused in custody and submitted that on the day
of production of accused before the Court, the ‘grounds of arrest’
in
writing
was
duly
communicated
to
the
accused
and
furthermore, the contraband item was directly recovered from his
possession and more so, on the day, when the accused was
produced under arrest before the Court of Learned CJM, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar that day he was duly represented by
Learned Defence Counsel. Situated thus, at this stage, there is no
scope to consider bail to the accused since the ‘grounds of arrest’
has been duly communicated to the accused in writing and also
the ground of arrest was duly communicated to the near relative
of the accused with the consent of the accused on 03.07.2025. So,
according to Learned P.P. the plea taken by Learned defence
counsel cannot be accepted and furthermore, referring the order
dated 28.08.2025 passed by this Court in B.A.No.70 of 2025 and
also referring the case of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in State
of Karnataka vs. Sri Darshan Etc. reported in 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1702 in para Nos.20.1.6 and 20.1.7 he further
submitted that in view of the principle of law laid down in the
aforesaid case there is no scope to release the accused on bail.
Further, he referred another case of the Hon’ble High Court of
Calcutta in CRM(NDPS)No.169 of 2025 along with others
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Cal 4502 wherein in para Nos.37 to
40 Hon’ble High Court of Kolkata made certain observations.
Finally, Learned P.P. submitted that the defence in this case could
(5)
not place any strong materials before the Court to consider
release of the accused on bail and as such, Learned P.P. urged for
dismissal of the bail application.
[05]
In this case, the prosecution was set into motion on the
basis of a sua moto complaint laid by SI Shibu Ranjan Debnath of
Bagbassa Police Station on 03.07.2025 with the allegation that on
02.07.2025 at about 2100 hrs., he received on telephonic
information from Asi Naichung Thang Tripura of BGB PS who was
discharging vehicle checking duty on NH-48 near Bagbassa Petrol
Pump from 1400 to 2200 hrs., that time he found that one person
is walking suspiciously from the Naka while carrying white colour
bag, when the staff asked him to stop. Seeing the police personnel
the person started to flee away. But the Ps staff chased him and
somehow managed to detain him. In course of detention they
found one brown colour packet under the possession of said
person and accordingly, they detained that person on that basis of
suspicion and that person was brought back to naka point and the
police party informed the matter to the informant for taking
necessary action. After receipt of the telephonic information, he
reduced the matter in writing and informed O/C PS vide GDE
number 22 dated 02.07.2025. After that, the informant went to
naka point for checking of the detained person along with other
necessary equipment, weighing machine etc. in reference to
Bagbassa P.S. G.D. Entry No.23 dated 02.07.2025. After that the
OC PS appraised the information to the higher authority over
phone and also through letter and also sent requisition to SDM,
Dharmanagar to depute one executive Magistrate for conducting
(6)
search and seizure as per guide line of NDPS Act. At about 2155
hrs SDPO Dharmanagar and Sandeep Debbarma DCM of SDM,
Dharmanagar arrived to the PO near Bagbassa Petrol Pump. At
about 2210 hrs. the informant obtained authorization from SDPO,
Dharmanagar and notice was served under Section 50 of the
NDPS Act to the said detained person namely Abdul Pata.
Thereafter, he prepared pre-search memo and in presence of
police personnel he conducted search of the bag belonging to the
said detained person and also in presence of executive Magistrate
and after opening the bundle the informant found that 2000
numbers of suspected Yaba tablets, in 5 numbers of white colour
bundles total 10000 nos. of suspected Yaba tablets. Lateron,
forensic expert collected 5 numbers tablets from 5 numbers
bundle of suspected Yaba tablets for preliminary examination.
Thereafter, at about 2250 hrs. he seized the said five numbers of
bundles containing 10,000 nos. of suspected Yaba tablets, having
total 50 nos. of small plastic packets, and one OPPO mobile phone
from the possession of detained person and after completion of all
the formalities the detained person namely Abdul Pata along with
the contraband items were brought to the police station and
thereafter, the suo moto complaint was laid by the informant to
O/C, Bagbassa Police Station for registration of the case.
Accordingly, the case was registered.
[06]
In course of investigation, by a forwarding report along
with GD extract, copy of notice, seizure list, arrest memo, presearch memo and other papers, the accused was produced before
the Court of Learned CJM on 03.07.2025 as regular special Judge
(7)
was absent, and on that day the accused was defended by his
engaged Learned defence counsel by filing a bail application.
[07]
I have also gone through the record of the Learned
Trial Court including the documents forwarded at the time of
production of accused before the Court. Also I have gone through
the order dated 03.07.2025 passed by Learned CJM, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar. From the documents produced before the
Learned Trial Court on 03.07.2025 which were duly counter signed
by Learned CJM it appears that separate ‘grounds of arrest’ memo
was furnished to the accused by O/C, Bagbassa Police Station
which contained the seal and signature of O/C, Bagbassa Police
Station. In the order Learned CJM reflected that the IO produced
the report along with arrest memo, forwarding report and medical
examination report. But for any reason that the ‘grounds of arrest’
was communicated to the accused was not specifically mentioned
in the order sheet. But from the record it is clear that separate
‘grounds of arrest’ in writing was also communicated to the
accused in writing which also contained the signature of Learned
CJM,
North
Tripura,
Dharmanagar
on
03.07.2025.
So,
the
submission made by Learned Defence counsel that no ‘grounds of
arrest’ was separately communicated to the accused in writing
cannot be legally accepted at this stage. On 04.07.2025 the said
accused was again produced before the Court of Learned Special
Judge. I have also seen the order dated 04.07.2025 and
subsequent orders dated 07.07.2025, 21.07.2025 04.08.2025,
11.08.2025 and 25.08.2025. In all the aforesaid dates the
accused was duly represented by his engaged Learned defence
(8)
counsel. From the relevant prosecution papers it is crystal clear
that on the date of production before the Learned Trial Court the
accused was duly informed the ‘grounds of his arrest’ in writing.
Initially, on the ground of non furnishing of ‘grounds of arrest’ in
another case this Court granted interim bail to an accused but the
fact of that case and the present case are totally different. In this
regard reference is made by Learned P.P. to a judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in State of Karnataka vs. Sri
Darshan Etc. reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1702 wherein in
para Nos.20.1.6 and 20.1.7 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“20.1.6. The High Court, however, relied heavily on the
alleged procedural lapse as a determinative factor while
overlooking the gravity of the offence under Section 302 IPC
and the existence of a prima facie case. It noted, inter alia,
that there was no mention in the remand orders about service
of memo of grounds of arrest (para 45); the arrest memos
were allegedly template-based and not personalised (para
50); and eyewitnesses had not stated that they were present
at the time of arrest or had signed the memos (para 48).
Relying on Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, (2024) 7 SCC 576
and Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) (supra), it
concluded (paras 43, 49 - 50) that from 03.10.2023 onwards,
failure to serve detailed, written, and individualised grounds
of arrest immediately after arrest was a violation entitling the
accused to bail.
20.1.7. In the present case, the arrest memos and remand
records clearly reflect that the respondents were aware of the
reasons for their arrest. They were legally represented from
the outset and applied for bail shortly after arrest, evidencing
an immediate and informed understanding of the accusations.
No material has been placed on record to establish that any
prejudice was caused due to the alleged procedural lapse. In
the absence of demonstrable prejudice, such as irregularity is,
at best, a curable defect and cannot, by itself, warrant release
on bail. As reiterated above, the High Court treated it as a
determinative factor while overlooking the gravity of the
charge under Section 302 IPC and the existence of a prima
facie case. Its reliance on Pankaj Bansal and Prabir
Purkayastha is misplaced, as those decisions turned on
materially different facts and statutory contexts. The approach
adopted here is inconsistent with the settled principle that
procedural lapses in furnishing grounds of arrest, absent
prejudice, do not ipso facto render custody illegal or entitle
the accused to bail.”
Referring the same, Learned P.P. drawn the attention
of the Court that even if it is found that no ‘grounds of arrest’ is
(9)
communicated to the accused, still it is a curable defect and
cannot by itself warrant release of the accused on bail and also
cannot be said that the arrest was illegal and the accused be
entitled to be released on bail.
Reference was made by Learned P.P. in another citation
of the Hon’ble High Court of Kolkata in CRM(NDPS)No.169 of
2025 along with others reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Cal
4502 wherein in para Nos.37 to 40 Hon’ble High Court of Kolkata
further observed as under :
“37. In most of the instant bail applications as stated above
the recovery was made from the possession of the petitioners
who according to prosecution case knew about the
transportation or carrying narcotic substance and each of
them had alleged role in the transportation and/or possession
with conscious knowledge of what they are doing.
38. Even on perusal of Vihaan Kumar Case (supra) in
paragraph 17, it appears that the argument canvassed on
behalf of the respondents is that even if the appellant is
released on the grounds of violating Article 22, the arresting
officer can arrest him again or not and the Hon'ble Supreme
court held “at this stage it is not necessary to decide the
issue.” Accordingly Supreme Court has not yet completely
negated said issue and has kept it open for future
consideration.
39. Petitioner heavily relied upon a co-ordinate Bench
judgment of this court in CRM (NDPS) 144 of 2025,
(Ramkrishna v. State of West Bengal), where in an offence
under NDPS Act, bail prayer of petitioner was allowed only on
the ground of non-compliance of section 52(1) of the NDPS
Act, without going into merit of the case. But it appears that
the above-mentioned judgments of Supreme Court passed in
connection with stringent provisions under the NDPS case
were neither referred non discussed in the said judgment,
while dealt with bail prayer of the accused, and as such it is
not binding upon me.
40. Considering observations made in above mentioned cases
viz.
Superintendent,
NCB
Chennai
(Supra)
and
Narayanaswamy Rabi Shankar (supra), it appears to me that
the offence under NDPS Act containing stringent provisions
are not to be equated with general offences. Needless to say
that the NDPS Act has been enacted by the legislature to
achieve specific purpose and objectives as stated in preamble
and in the object and reasons of the Act. Fundamental rights
usually strikes a balance between individual liberty with the
interest of justice and social control. Offences under NDPS Act
are very serious in nature and any sort of indulgence against
combatting such menace may have a detrimental effect in the
society, more specifically it's adverse impact may destroy
specially the young generation of the country. It is quite
expected that the stringent provisions of the Act which
includes section 37 of the Act must be construed in the
manner which would enhance the objectives of the special Act
and not to frustrate the very purpose and objective of the Act.
While dealing with such issue, court must be cautious in
exercise of the power, so that it must not create any undue
advantage or benefit to the persons accused of serious
(10)
offences under the NDPS Act or to demoralise the officers who
have been specially conferred with the powers to combat the
serious crime and/or encourage the unscrupulous element to
commit crime. An offence under the NDPS Act cannot be
compared with the ordinary offences committed against an
individual or with the accused of ordinary crime. It is a crime
against society at large and the nation itself. I am afraid that
any other interpretation of stringent provisions including
section 37 of NDPS Act may frustrate the very purpose and
objectives of the Act.”
Referring the same, Learned P.P. further drawn the
attention of the Court that considering the facts and circumstances
of the present case there is no scope to release the accused on
bail at this stage and urged for dismissal of the bail application.
[08]
I have given anxious hearing of both the sides and
after going through the relevant prosecution papers and also after
perusal of the citations as referred above by Learned P.P. in
course of hearing it appears that on the day of production of the
accused before the Learned CJM the ‘grounds of arrest’ was duly
communicated in writing to the accused and the same fact was
also informed to his near relative with the consent of the accused
in custody. Furthermore, in this case, contraband item of
commercial quantity was recovered/found under the possession of
the accused in custody regarding possession of which the accused
in custody could not give any specific account to the investigating
police officer. Furthermore, it is also the settled position of law
that the stringent positions under the NDPS Act cannot be
compared with other general offences. In a case under NDPS Act
the twin conditions as provided under Section 37 of NDPS Act are
to be strictly followed.
[09]
Here in the case at hand save and except the ‘grounds
of arrest’, no other satisfactory arguments were placed by Learned
defence Counsel representing the accused in custody to consider
(11)
bail of the accused in connection with this case. More so, the
accused in custody at the time of hearing also failed to satisfy the
Court that the twin conditions of Section 37 of NDPS Act cannot be
applied in this case. So, considering the materials on record and
also the fact that the contraband items of commercial quantity
was directly seized from his possession and the said fact also
reveals from the seizure memo. Furthermore, the grounds of
arrest have been duly communicated in writing to the accused at
the time of arrest and his production before the Court .
Situated thus, considering the materials on record at
this stage I do not find any scope to consider release of the
accused on bail. Accordingly, the bail application filed on behalf of
the accused stands rejected. The accused is to remain in JC as
before.
However, from the record it appears that in the arrest
memo the IO did not reflect that separate ‘grounds of arrest’ was
communicated in writing to the accused and in this regard, this
Court in another order directed the DGP of Police to inform all the
investigating officers who are dealing with cases under the NDPS
Act to specifically mention with the arrest memo as ‘enclosure’ to
avoid any legal confusion. Here in this case also nothing is found
from the arrest memo that the ‘grounds of arrest’ was enclosed
with the arrest memo to ensure that the same was duly
communicated in writing to the accused at the time of production
under the arrest before the Learned Trial Court which needs to be
taken care of. Learned P.P. be asked to take up the matter again
(12)
with the appropriate authority so that the same thing may not
occur in near future to avoid any legal confusion.
With this observation, the present bail application
stands disposed of. Send down the record to the Learned Trial
Couret along with a copy of this order. Return back the CD to IO
through Learned P.P. along with a copy of this order.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.09.10
A DATTA Date:
01:44:45 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review