The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. A Full Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court in Sushila Bhadoriya v. M.P. SRTC has also laid down that in case of composite negligence, the liability is joint and several and it is open to implead the driver, owner and the insurer one of the vehicles to recover the whole amount from one of the joint tort feasors. As to apportionment also, it has been observed that both the vehicles will be jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation. Once the negligence and compensation is determined, it is not permissible to apportion the compensation between the two as it is difficult to determine the apportionment in the absence of the drivers of both the vehicles appearing in the witness box. Therefore, there cannot be apportionment of the claim between the joint tort feasors.” It is also submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court that in case of all joint tortfeasors have been impleaded and evidence is sufficient, it is open to the Court/tribunal composite to determine negligence of the inter se drivers. extent of However, determination of the extent of negligence between the joint tortfeasors is only for the purpose of their inter se liability so that one may recover the sum from the other after making while of the payment to the plaintiff/claimant to the extent it is satisfied the liability of the other. In case of both of them have been impleaded and the apportionment/extent of thei…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item
No.
4, 5
and 6
Ct
rup
13.01.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
FMA 304 of 2025
The New India Assurance Company Limited
Vs
Jaly Singha & Ors.
WITH
COT 115 of 2025
Jaly Singha & Anr.
Vs.
United India General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
WITH
FMA 1211 of 2025
JLY Singha & Anr.
Vs.
United India General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
Mr. Rajesh Singh.
… for the appellant in FMA 304 of 2025,
respondent No.2 in COT 115 of 2025
and respondent no.2 in FMA 1211 of
2025.
Mr. Subir Banerjee,
Mr. Sandip Bandyopadhyay,
Mrs. Ruxmin Basu Roy.
… for the respondents/claimants in
FMA 304 of 2025, appellant in COT
115 of 2025 and appellants in FMA
1211 of 2025.
Mr. M. P. Chakraborty,
Ms. Ratnadipa Karmakar.
… for the respondent no.5 in FMA 304
of 2025, respondent No. 1 in COT
115 of 2025 and respondent no.1 in
FMA 1211 of 2025.
Learned advocates for the appellant /New India
Assurance Company Limited in FMA 304 of 2025 and
learned advocates for the respondent nos. 1 and
2/claimants and learned advocate for the respondent
no.5/United India Assurance Company Limited are
present.
Heard learned advocates for the parties.
The appellant before this Court was an opposite
party in claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act 1988 and is aggrieved by the judgement and
award dated 11.09.2024 passed by the Learned
Additional District Judge, Fast Track, 2 nd Court,
Raiganj, Uttar Dinajpur in MAC Case 2 of 2020. The
respondent
nos.
and
2/claimants
being
also
aggrieved by the said judgment and order has filed
cross-objection being COT 115 of 2025 as well as a
separate appeal being FMA 1211 of 2025 The case of
the respondent No.1/claimant before the learned Trial
Court may be summed up thus:On 29.11.2019 at night Palash Kumar Singha
since deceased boarded on the bus being No. WB
73A/3697 at Siliguri for going to Berhampur and the
bus was proceeding in high speed in negligent manner
and when the bus reached at Khairakandi at about
5:15 hours at that time another truck being No. BR01GH/5651 was proceeding from Berhampur side to
Malda Side from a opposite side at a high speed in a
rash and negligent manner and due to high speed and
rash driving both the drivers of the bus and the truck
lost control over the bus and the truck and made a
head to head collusion and as result most of the
passengers of the bus received injuries and the driver
of the bus and the truck also received injuries and at
first they were taken to Tarapur and Beniagram
Hospital and out of them the drivers of the two
vehicles and two passengers of the bus i.e. Palash
Kumar Singha and one girl Dipika Modak succumbed
to their injuries. The drivers of the bus and the truck
were driving their vehicle in a rash and negligent
manner and the accident took place.
The deceased
Palash Kumar Singha was a man of active habits and
he was the only earning source of his family and the
applicants were the dependent in his income.
The
deceased had a chance to get promotion very soon and
due to his pathetic and early death the claimants have
sustained great financial loss and mental pain and
agony and we have to suffer through out of their lives.
Pursuant to the filing of the case notice was
issued upon the New India Assurance Company
Ltd./appellant
herein,
United
India
Assurance
Company Ltd. and the vehicle owners.
The appellant/New India Assurance Company
Ltd. and the respondent no.5/ United India Assurance
Company Ltd. contested the claim by filing the written
statement.
Evidence was adduced and the Learned
Trial Judge upon considering the evidence and upon
hearing the learned advocates was pleased to dispose
of the claim case by the judgement and award dated
11.09.2024 by observing and directing as follows:“ ORDERED
87. 1) that, the M.A.C. Case No. 02 of 2020
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act is allowed
on contest against the O.P. No.3/Insurance Company
namely United India Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. and O.P.
No. 4 New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and exparte
against the O.P. No.1 and O.P. No.2 but without any
order of Cost.
87. 2) The Claimants do get an award of compensation
of Rs.42,70,000/- ( Rupees Forty Two Lakhs Seventy
Thousand
only)
from
the
O.P.
No.3/Insurance
Company namely United India Gen. Insurance Co.
Ltd. and O.P. no.4 New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Along
with interest at the rate of 6% per annum since filing
of the case i.e. since 02.01.2020.
87.3) The O.P. No.3/Insurance Company namely
United India Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. and O.P. no.4
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. are directed to pay the
said amount of compensation in equal share i.e. 50%
each of it to the claimants.
87. 4) Both the petitioners being the wife and
daughter of the deceased are entitled to get equal
share on the amount of compensation awarded.
87. 5) The O.P. No.3/Insurance Company namely
United India Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. is directed to pay
Rs.21,35,000/-
(50%
of
the
total
amount
of
compensation) and the said interest by way of
issuance of one Account Payee Cheque in favour of the
petitioner/claimants no.1 Jaly Singha within two
months from the date of passing of this Judgment
through
this
Tribunal,
failing
which
the
petitioner/Claimant will be at liberty to realize the
awarded sum of compensation along with said interest
in accordance with the provisions of law.
87.6) The O.P. no.4 New India Assurance Co. Ltd. is
directed to pay Rs.21,35,000/- (remaining 50% of the
total amount of compensation) and the said interest
by way of issuance of one Account Payee Cheque in
favour of the petitioner/Claimants no.2 Paramita
Singha within two months from the date of passing of
this Judgement through this Tribunal, failing which
the petitioner/Claimant will be at liberty to realize the
awarded sum of compensation along with said interest
in accordance with the provisions of law.
87. 7) The petitioners/Claimants are directed to pay
the requisite Court-Fee at the earliest.
87.8) The O.P. No.3/Insurance Company namely
United India Gen. Insurance Co. Ltd. and O.P. No.4
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. are directed to get copy
of the judgment from the official portal of the e-Courts
services for information an compliance.
87.9) The case is thus disposed of. Note accordingly.”
The appellant/New India Assurance Company
Limited being aggrieved by the judgment and award
passed by the learned Trial Judge, has come up with
the instant appeal.
The claimants/respondent No 1 and 2 also being
aggrieved by the said judgment and award has also
preferred a separate appeal and cross-objection to the
appeal filed by the appellant/New India Assurance
Company Limited.
Heard
learned
advocates
for
the
parties.
Perused the petition filed and the material on record.
Mr. Rajesh Singh, learned advocate for the
appellant/New India Assurance Company Limited
submits that the learned Judge failed to appreciate
the evidence adduced both oral and documentary and
imposed the liability on his client to pay 50% of the
awarded sum. Mr. Singh draws attention to the copy
of the complaint made before the police authority on
01.12.2019, wherein the allegation against the BR01GH/563K is made for causing the accident due to
rash and negligent driving. Mr. Singh further draws
attention to the copy of the charge-sheet wherein it is
stated that driver of the oil tanker namely Sonu
Kumar Roy was driving with excessive speed that he
could not move for the left way and was moving
through wrong lane and it is further stated in the said
charge-sheet that the accident took place due to rash
driving of the driver of the oil tanker who had died on
that day.
Mr. Singh also draws attention to the
evidence of the witness of the claimants wherein in
cross-examination PW-3 stated that he boarded on the
concerned bus in the night of 29/30.11.2019 at
Durgapur for going to Baharampur and he is driver by
profession. He further stated in his cross-examination
that one and half hours has been taken on that day to
reach Malda by the concerned bus and the bus took
stoppage at Rathbari More, Malda at about 1:00 at
night. Few passengers boarded there. The bus started
running thereafter and reached Farakka about 02:15
A.M. The accident was caused half and hour after
leaving Farakka. He was in the bus at the time of
accident and was sitting rearest seat of it.
He also
stated bus was running in normal speed and offending
truck dashed the bus from its front in high speed by
coming from the opposite side.
It is stated the
accident might not be happended if the driver of the
truck drove the truck cautiously in normal speed.
The
opposite
party/United
India
Assurance
Company Limited being respondent no.5 herein did
not put anything else in the cross examination but
simply adopted the cross-examination of New India
Assurance Company Limited.
Learned advocate for the United India Assurance
Insurance Company Limited submits that as the case
involves composite negligence of both bus and the oil
tanker, the learned Trial Judge has rightly directed
both the parties to pay equal compensation.
Mr. M. P. Chakraborty, learned advocate for the
United India General Insurance Company Limited
relies upon the decision of Khenyei vs. New India
Assurance Company Limited and Others reported in
(2015) 9SCC 273, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
said judgment and decision while dealing with the
issue of composite negligence was pleased to observed
as follows:“11. A Full Bench in Karnataka SRTC v. Arun
while answering aforesaid questions has observed
that it was a case of composite negligence and the
liability of tort feasors was joint and several. Hence,
even if there is non-impleadment of one of tort
feasors,
the
claimant
was
entitled
to
full
compensation quantified by the Tribunal. The Full
Bench referred to the decision of a Division Bench of
the Gujarat High Court in Hiraben Bhaga & Ors. v.
Gujarat SRTC in which it has been laid down that it
is entirely the choice of the claimant whether to
implead both the joint tort feasors or either of them.
On failure of the claimant to implead one of the joint
tort feasors, contributory liability cannot be fastened
upon the claimant to the extent of the negligence of
non-impleaded joint tort feasors. It is for the joint
tort feasors made liable to pay compensation to take
proceedings to settle the equities as against other
joint tort feasors who had not been impleaded. It is
open to the impleaded joint tort feasor to sue the
other wrong doer after the decree or award is given
to realize to the extent of others’ liability. It has been
laid down that the law in Ganesh’s case has been
rightly laid down and it is not necessary to implead
all
joint
tort
feasors
and
due
to
failure
of
impleadment of all joint tort feasors, compensation
cannot be reduced to the extent of negligence of
non- impleaded tort feasors. Non-impleadment of
one of the joint tort feasors is not a defence to
reduce the compensation payable to the claimant. In
our opinion, the law appears to have been correctly
stated in Karnataka SRTC v. Arun.
12. A Full Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court in
Sushila Bhadoriya v. M.P. SRTC has also laid down
that in case of composite negligence, the liability is
joint and several and it is open to implead the driver,
owner and the insurer one of the vehicles to recover
the whole amount from one of the joint tort feasors. As
to apportionment also, it has been observed that both
the vehicles will be jointly and severally liable to pay
the
compensation.
Once
the
negligence
and
compensation is determined, it is not permissible to
apportion the compensation between the two as it is
difficult
to determine the apportionment in the
absence of the drivers of both the vehicles appearing
in the witness box. Therefore, there cannot be
apportionment of the claim between the joint tort
feasors.”
It is also submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme
Court that in case of all joint tortfeasors have been
impleaded and evidence is sufficient, it is open to the
Court/tribunal
composite
to
determine
negligence
of
the
inter
se
drivers.
extent
of
However,
determination of the extent of negligence between the
joint tortfeasors is only for the purpose of their inter
se liability so that one may recover the sum from the
other after making while of the payment to the
plaintiff/claimant to the extent it is satisfied the
liability of the other. In case of both of them have been
impleaded and the apportionment/extent of their
negligence
has
been
determined
by
the
Court/Tribunal, in the main case one joint tortfeasor
can recover the amount from the other in the
execution proceeding.
Mr. Chakraborty further submits that both the
insurance companies namely New India Assurance
Company Limited and United India General Insurance
Company being government companies can share the
liabilities equally.
Learned advocate for the claimants/respondents
no. 1 and 2 submits that the decision Khenyei should
be followed in this case and the liability should be
distributed among both the insurance companies.
Learned advocate further submits that in another case
arising out of the accident where both the insurance
companies were directed to pay equally to satisfy the
awarded sum, no appeal is preferred by New India
Assurance Company Limited.
Learned advocate also relies an unreported
decision of the learned Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court
passed
in
F.M.A.
of
2023.
Upon
considering the decision relied upon and the facts of
the case at the very outset the cases relied upon does
not appear to be similar to the facts of this case.
Moreover the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Khenyei (Supra) has observed that the direction to
recover from one of the joint tortfeasor can be issued
when both of them have been impleaded and the
apportionment/extent of their negligence has been
determined by the Court/Tribunal.
Further there
should be a determination of negligence of the
tortfeasor. Thus, one of the primary consideration in
this aspect is at the very outset there should be
determination of the negligence of both the tortfeasors
and without determination of the negligence the
liability of paying compensation cannot be imposed.
Where the evidence is not sufficient to determine the
negligence of either of the joint tortfeasor liability upon
the said tortfeasors cannot be fastened.
Upon considering the materials on record, the
evidence of PW-3 in cross-examination the First
Information Report and the Charge-sheet submitted
by the police authority there is a clear involvement of
the oil tanker with regard to the rash and negligent
driving being vehicle No. BR- 01GH/5651.
The
evidence on record does not satisfy the conscience of
the Court to hold the driver of the bus being No. WB
73A/3697 to be negligent and to impose the liability
upon the said vehicle owner.
In the facts and circumstances, this Court is of
the view that the liability to pay equally by both the
insurance companies namely the New India Assurance
Company
Limited
and
United
India
Assurance
Company Limited should be modified.
With regard to the cross objection about the
quantum of compensation and from the separate
appeal filed by the claimants being FMA 1211 of 2025
this Court is of the view that as the compensation
awarded is just and reasonable there is no scope to
interfere in the compensation awarded.
Thus, FMA 304 of 2025 along with COT 115 of
2025 and FMA 1211 of 2025 stands disposed of. The
judgement and award of the Learned Additional
District Judge, Fast Track 2nd Court, Raijanj, Uttar
Dinajpur in M.A.C. Case No. 02 of 2020 stands
affirmed so far as the compensation is concerned.
However, the direction upon both the insurance
companies stands modified to the extent that United
Assurance
Company
Ltd.
shall
deposit
balance
amount of the awarded sum along with interest as
directed by the Learned Trial Judge from the date of
filing of the claim case till today. Such deposit shall
be made within period of eight (08) weeks before
Registrar General, High Court, Calcutta from date of
communication of this order.
Upon
deposit
being
made
the
claimants/respondents no.1 and 2 will be entitled to
withdraw the sum upon compliance of all formalities
and the appellant/New India Assurance Company
Limited will be entitled to withdraw the sum deposited
by them along with accrued interest.
With the aforesaid observation, all the appeals
and corss objection stands disposed of.
Urgent photostat certified copy of the order, if
applied
for,
be
given
to
the
parties
on
usual
undertakings.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review