Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 5th June, 2024
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
:
Appellants
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
versus
:
Respondent
SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Umesh Ranpal, Ms. Rubusha Gurung and Ms. Laxmi Khawas,
Advocates for the Appellants.
Mr. Pawan Gurung, Advocate for the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
The
1.
Claimants/Appellants
were
denied
the
compensation amounting to ₹ 99,21,020/-(Rupees ninety nine
lakhs, twenty one thousand and twenty) only, claimed by them on
account of the death of the son of Claimant No.1, the husband of
the Claimant No.2 and the father of the Claimants No.3, 4 and 5.
The Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gangtok, Sikkim,
(hereinafter, the “MACT”) vide its assailed Judgment, dated 17-072023, in MACT Case No.14 of 2022, Jai Bahadur Subba and Others vs.
SBI General Insurance Company Limited, inter alia observed that the
insurance policy of the vehicle in accident was an “Act Policy” and
not
a
“Comprehensive
Claimants/Appellants
would
Package
be
entitled
Policy”.
to
the
That,
extent
the
of
compensation in terms of the insurance coverage i.e., “personal
accident cover for unnamed passenger” as stipulated in the policy,
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
Exhibit 16 and accordingly granted compensation of ₹ 50,000/(Rupees fifty thousand) only, augmenting the
amount with
litigation costs of ₹ 1,00,000/-(Rupees one lakh) only.
2.
Before this Court, Learned Counsel for the Appellants
contended that, the deceased was travelling in the Alto vehicle,
bearing registration No.SK-02-P-2766, of the deceased driver, late
Jai Man Limboo.
That, the vehicle was duly insured with the
Respondent-Insurance Company.
He was a third party as the
occupant of the vehicle in accident and therefore fully covered by
the insurance policy and not a gratuitous passenger as stated by
the Respondent.
The Respondent was liable to pay the entire
compensation claimed which was erroneously denied by the
Learned MACT. Referring to Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (hereinafter, the “MV Act‟), it was contended that the said
section does not distinguish between an “Act Policy” and a
“Comprehensive Policy” and the liability to pay compensation is
based on the statutory provision. That, the question of third party
rights have been considered by the Supreme Court in Guru Govekar
vs. Miss Filomena F. Lobo and Others ,
wherein it was inter alia
observed that if a policy is taken in respect of motor vehicle from
an insurer in compliance with the requirement of Chapter VIII of
the Act, the insurer is under an obligation to pay the compensation
payable to third party on account of any injury to his/her person or
property or payable to the legal representative of third party in
case of death of the third party caused by or arising out of the use
of the vehicle at a public place. Reference was also made to the
decision of the Supreme Court in Jameskutty Jacob vs. United India
AIR 1988 SC 1332
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
Insurance Co. Ltd. and Others .
It was urged by Learned Counsel
that it has been observed therein that even in respect of an „Act
only‟ policy the insurance company would be liable for the statutory
amount as payable under Section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1939. That, accordingly the compensation ought to be computed
in terms of the law laid down by the Supreme Court, towards this
reliance was placed on National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay
Sethi and Others
and United India Insurance Company Limited vs.
Satinder Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur and Others .
That, this Court in
Passi Lamu Sherpa and Another vs. Branch Manager, New India
Assurance Co. Ltd.
had observed that the facts and circumstances
of every motor accident cases is different and an umbrella view
cannot be applied to all the matters, hence the Award of the
Learned MACT be set aside and compensation be enhanced as
prayed.
3.
Per contra the arguments raised by Learned Counsel
for the Respondent was that in the first instance the policy was an
“Act Policy” and the premium towards personal accident cover of
unnamed passenger was paid amounting to ₹ 25/-(Rupees twenty
five) only. The insurance cover thereby was limited to ₹ 50,000/(Rupees fifty thousand) only, as reflected in Exhibit 16.
As the
deceased passenger was a gratuitous passenger in a private
vehicle, he would be covered under the personal accident cover
and no other claims made by the Appellants were maintainable.
Relying on the Judgment of this Court in Branch Manager, New India
(2003) 7 SCC 131
(2017) 16 SCC 680
(2021) 11 SCC 780
2024 SCC OnLine Sikk 24
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. Geeta Khatiwada and Others , it was contended
that there is a difference between a “Comprehensive Policy” and an
“Act Policy” and the insurer will not be liable to pay compensation
when a private vehicle meets with an accident and a gratuitous
passenger dies as a consequence of the accident. That, the limits
of liability is the maximum amount that the insurance company
would be liable to pay for each individual claim made during the
policy period and the Respondent cannot be made liable to pay any
compensation exceeding the coverage under the limits of the
liability as reflected in the insurance policy for which an additional
premium is required to be deposited, hence the Appeal be
dismissed.
4.
The facts in brief are that, the deceased an Assistant
Sub-Inspector of Police (ASI) (Sikkim Armed Police), aged about
fifty-two years, earning a monthly salary of ₹ 91,611/- (Rupees
ninety one thousand, six hundred and eleven) only, was travelling
from Hee Pechrek, West Sikkim to Pangthang, Gangtok, in the
aforementioned vehicle, on 18-10-2021.
At around 08.30 a.m.,
the vehicle met with an accident near “Akkar Bridge”, Naya Bazar,
Soreng District, resulting in the death of the deceased, the
owner/driver and injuries to other occupants.
5.
The Learned MACT on being seized of the facts and
circumstances settled one issue for determination i.e., (1) Whether
the claimants are entitled to the compensation claimed? If so, who
is liable to pay the same? Having considered the evidence in its
entirety and the submissions canvassed, the Learned MACT as
2021 SCC OnLine Sikk 196
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
aforestated, declined to grant compensation to the Claimants save
as covered by the policy.
The same question as settled for determination by the
6.
Learned MACT arises for determination by this Court.
In Geeta Khatiwada (supra) this Court had delved into
7.
various pronouncements of the Supreme Court on payment of
compensation to Claimants of gratuitous passengers where motor
vehicle accident resulted in their fatalities viz., United India
Insurance Co. Ltd., Shimla vs. Tilak Singh and Others , New India
Assurance Company vs. Satpal Singh and Others
and New India
Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. Asha Rani and Others .
The Supreme Court in National Insurance Company
8.
Limited
vs.
Balakrishnan
and
Another
distinguished
between
“Comprehensive/Package Policy” and “Act Policy” and inter alia
observed that;
“26. In view of the aforesaid factual position, there
is no scintilla of doubt that a “comprehensive/package
policy” would cover the liability of the insurer for payment
of compensation for the occupant in a car. There is no cavil
that an “Act policy” stands on a different footing from a
“comprehensive/package policy”. As the circulars have
made the position very clear and IRDA, which is presently
the statutory authority, has commanded the insurance
companies stating that a “comprehensive/package policy”
covers the liability, there cannot be any dispute in that
regard. We may hasten to clarify that the earlier
pronouncements were rendered in respect of the “Act
policy” which admittedly cannot cover a third-party risk of
an occupant in a car. But, if the policy is a
“comprehensive/package policy”, the liability would be
covered……………………………………..”
It
therefore
concludes
that
a
“Comprehensive/Package
Policy” would cover the liability of the insurer to indemnify the
occupant of a vehicle. Contrarily in an “Act Policy” the liability is
confined to the limits set out in the Policy.
(2006) 4 SCC 404
(2000) 1 SCC 237
(2003) 2 SCC 223
(2013) 1 SCC 731
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
In Satpal Singh (supra), the Supreme Court held that
9.
the provision to Section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, when
compared to Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, reveals
as follows;
“7. In fact the said ratio has been approved by the
three-Judge Bench in Mallawwa v. Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. [(1999) 1 SCC 403 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 58]. At the same time
learned Judges pointed out that the old Act is now repealed
by the new Act and Section 147 of the new Act
corresponding to Section 95 of the old Act has been
substantially altered and hence the above interpretation of
Section 95 of the old Act will govern the cases which have
arisen under the old Act.”
This observation was disagreed to in Asha Rani (supra),
where the Supreme Court observed after discussing the provisions
Section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, Section 147 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, prior to its amendment in 1994 and after
being amended, it was concluded that the Judgment of the
Supreme Court in Satpal Singh (supra) must be held to have been
incorrectly decided and the impugned Judgment of the Tribunal as
well as that of the High Court were set aside. It was held that the
insurer will not be liable to pay compensation to the owner of the
goods or his authorized representatives on being carried in a
vehicle that meets with an accident and the owner of the goods or
his representative dies or suffers any bodily injuries.
In M/s. National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Baljit Kaur and
(i)
Others
the Supreme Court in a batch of appeals was considering
whether an insurance policy in respect of goods vehicle would also
cover gratuitous passenger in view of the legislative amendment in
1994 to Section 147 of the MV Act. It was concluded as follows;
“20. It is, therefore, manifest that in spite of the
amendment of 1994, the effect of the provision contained
in Section 147 with respect to persons other than the
AIR 2004 SC 1340
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
owner of the goods or his authorised representative
remains the same. Although the owner of the goods or his
authorised representative would now be covered by the
policy of insurance in respect of a goods vehicle, it was not
the intention of the Legislature to provide for the liability of
the insurer with respect to passengers, especially
gratuitous passengers, who were neither contemplated at
the time the contract of insurance was entered into, nor
any premium was paid to the extent of the benefit of
insurance to such category of people.”
(ii)
In Tilak Singh (supra) the pivotal issue was whether a
statutory insurance policy under the MV Act, 1988 intended to
cover risk to life or damage to properties of third parties would
cover the risk of death or injury to a gratuitous passenger carried
in a private vehicle. It was held as hereunder;
“21. In our view, although the observations made
in Asha Rani case [(2003) 2 SCC 223 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 493] were in
connection with carrying passengers in a goods vehicle, the
same would apply with equal force to gratuitous
passengers in any other vehicle also. Thus, we must uphold
the contention of the appellant Insurance Company that it
owed no liability towards the injuries suffered by the
deceased Rajinder Singh who was a pillion rider, as the
insurance policy was a statutory policy, and hence it did
not cover the risk of death of or bodily injury to a
gratuitous passenger.”
10.
Having carefully examined the facts and circumstances
of the instant case although the Appellants sought to take shelter
under the decision of this Court in Passi Lamu Sherpa (supra) the
facts as emerge therein are different as the deceased wife was
travelling in the private vehicle of her husband and could not be
termed as a gratuitous passenger being the wife of the owner of
the vehicle, in addition a third party premium had been paid for
covering any liability that would accrue to the owner/driver on
account of the involvement of a third party in an accident involving
his vehicle. These circumstances were clarified by this Court in the
Judgment (supra).
In the instant case, it is seen that the vehicle
in which the deceased was travelling was a private vehicle.
The
insurance policy is a “Motor Act Only—Private Car” Policy and not a
MAC App. No.08 of 2023
Jai Bahadur Subba and Others
vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd.
Comprehensive Policy. A meticulous perusal of Exhibit 16 reveals
that “PA Cover (Personal Accident Cover)—Unnamed Passengers”,
a sum insured was of ₹ 50,000/-(Rupees fifty thousand) only, for
which a premium of ₹ 25/-(Rupees twenty five) only, had been
deposited. No premium was paid to cover a gratuitous passenger
which the deceased ASI indubitably was.
11.
In light of the above findings, there is no reason
whatsoever to interfere with the findings of the Learned MACT
which is accordingly upheld.
12.
It is admitted before this Court by the parties that a
sum of ₹ 1,50,000/-(Rupees one lakh and fifty thousand) only,
along with interest calculated at ₹ 18,123/-(Rupees eighteen
thousand, one hundred and twenty three) only, amounting to ₹
1,68,123/-(Rupees one lakh, sixty eight thousand, one hundred
and twenty three) only, was deposited by the RespondentInsurance Company and has been made over to and received by
the Appellant/Claimants.
13.
In the obtaining circumstances, nothing further thereby
remains for adjudication in the matter.
14.
Appeal dismissed and disposed of.
15.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
16.
No order as to costs.
17.
Copy of this Judgment be forwarded forthwith to the
Learned MACT for information, along with its records.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
05-06-2024
Approved for reporting : Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review