Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.REV. P NO.55 OF 2021
Sanjoy Debnath,
S/o- Sri Ranjan Debnath,
Narayan Sarani, Kanchanpur,
P.S.- Kanchanpur, North Tripura.
……… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Ld. Public Prosecutor,
Hon’ble High Court of Tripura, Agartala.
……. Respondent(s).
CRL.REV. P NO.58 OF 2021
Jahar Debbarma,
S/o- Sri Priti Ranjan Debbarma,
Bischitra Daspara,
P.S.- Manu, District- Dhalai Tripura
……… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Ld. Public Prosecutor,
Hon’ble High Court of Tripura, Agartala.
……. Respondent(s).
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 17.03.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
Both these Criminal Revision Petitions are heard
and taken up together for disposal since they arise out of a
common Judgment and Order involving common questions of
law and facts.
2.
The Criminal Revision Petition No.55 of 2021 is
filed under Section 397(1) read with Section 401 of Cr.P.C.
against the Judgment dated 28.09.2021 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmangar in Case No. Crl.
Appeal
No.07
of
2020,
affirming
the
Judgment
dated
03.03.2020, passed by the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate,
Kanchanpur, North Tripura in PRC(WP)02/2019, whereby and
where under convicting the petitioner for committing offence
punishable under Section 409 of IPC and sentencing him to
suffer simple imprisonment for 3 years and to pay a fine of
Rs.10,000/- with default stipulation.
2.1.
The Criminal Revision Petition No.58 of 2021 is
filed under Section 397(1) read with Section 401 of Cr.P.C.
against the Judgment dated 28.09.2021 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmangar in Case No. Crl.
Appeal
No.06
of
2020,
affirming
the
Judgment
dated
03.03.2020, passed by the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate,
Kanchanpur, North Tripura in PRC(WP)02/2019, whereby and
where under convicting the petitioner for committing offence
punishable under Section 409 of IPC and sentencing him to
suffer simple imprisonment for 3 years and to pay a fine of
Rs.10,000/- with default stipulation.
The brief fact of the prosecution case is that Sri
3.
Arabinda Sarkar, in the capacity of ATM Executive of SIS Cash
Services Private Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as SIS), lodged
one ‘Ejhar’ with the Officer-in-charge, Kanchanpur P.S. stating
inter alia that Sri Sanjoy Debnath and Sri Jahar Debbarma i.e.
the petitioner herein were appointed as joint custodians of ATM
vide
I.D.
no.
TR13002U,
under
United
Bank
of
India,
Kanchanpur Branch, State Bank of India, Anandabazar Branch,
and United Bank of India, Vanghmun Branch from 2013 onwards
with proper KYC. On 08.06.2015 as per requisition, both the
accused persons' collected cash of Rs.12,00,000/- (Rupees
Twelve Lakhs only) from UBI of Kanchanpur Branch for loading
cash in the above said ATM. After loading said cash in the ATM,
both the accused persons confirmed the cash balance of
Rs.25,27,300/- (Rupees Twenty Five Lakhs Twenty Seven
Thousand and Three Hundred only) with the previous cash
balance in the said ATM. From 17.06.2015 the dispensing of
cash by the said ATM was stopped for unknown reasons and
after communication with the accused persons they reported
that there was link issue (V. Set problem) and as a result, ATM
was not working. According to the informant, both the accused
persons were reporting the above issue falsely. But as per the
machine-generated report, it was found that both the accused
persons went to the ATM on 13.06.2015 and confirmed the
balance with E.O.D report which was not reported by them to
UBI Kanchanpur Branch. Since the ATM vide no. TR 13002U was
closed for link issue for consecutive seven days, there was
suspicion from the side of the complainant. So, they made a call
to Senior Manager of UBI Kanchanpur Branch on 24.06.2015 at
12.00 noon for physical inquiry of the cash. But when the
Manager of the bank along with bank officials went for inquiry, it
was found that one of the joint custodians namely accused Sri
Jahar Debbarma was working at the machine. When the UBI
bank personnel asked the accused Sri Jahar Debbarma for
physical cash verification then he refused due to the absence of
another custodian i.e. accused Sri Sanjoy Debnath. This incident
was reported by UBI Branch personnel to the complainant who
advised the Bank Officials to close the shutter of the said ATM
and the informant traveled from Agartala to Kanchanpur for a
joint-inquiry of ATM cash.
On
that
date
of
24.06.2015
at
6.30
pm
complainant along with the Bank Officials of UBI Kanchanpur
Branch went to the said ATM and asked the accused persons to
open the vault of the said ATM being the custodians. But
intentionally accused persons gave wrong password so that it
will hang the machine and the vault does not open. But after
several times of counseling, the accused persons opened the
ATM vault and it was found from the machine-generated report
which displayed cash of Rs.30,700/- (Rupees thirty thousand
seven hundred only) which meant that there was a shortage of
Rs.9,77,100/-(Rupees nine lakh seventy-seven thousand one
hundred only). It is also stated in the 'Ejahar' that on
24.06.2015 at about 1.00 pm it was confirmed by the Manager
of SBI, Anandabazar Branch that accused Sri Sanjoy Debnath
visited the ATM of SBI, Anandabazar for unknown reason, as
according to operational report there was no schedule loading
in the said ATM on that date. Accordingly, this 'Ejhar’ was
lodged alleging that the accused persons were entrusted for
cash loading in the ATM vide no. TR13002U of UBI, Kanchanpur
branch by collecting cash from the bank with their secret
password which were created by them and they misutilized the
public money of Rs.9,77,100/-(Rupees Nine Lakhs Seventy
Seven Thousand One Hundred only) by cheating SIS.
4.
After receipt of the "Ejhar", the Officer-in-charge,
Kanchanpur PS registered Kanchanpur PS case no. 2015 KCP
048,
dated
25.06.2015
for
the
commission
of
offence
punishable under Section 409/420 of the Indian Penal Code
against the accused persons and endorsed the case to Sri
Shakti
Sadhan
Jamatia,
Sub-Inspector
of
Police
for
investigation and on completion of the investigation, the
Investigating Officer finding prima-facie case submitted charge
sheet against the accused persons for the commission of
offence punishable under section 409/420 of IPC.
5.
The accused persons faced trial in the Court of
Learned SDJM, Kanchanpur North Tripura in PRC(WP) No.02 of
2019, and following charges were framed against the accused
persons:“i) Whether accused persons being entrusted by
SIS Cash Services Private Litd, as cash custodian committed
criminal breach of trust of an amount of Rs.9,77,100/-(Rupees
Nine Lakh Seventy Seven Thousand and One Hundred only) at
any time on and from 08.06.2015 to 17.06.2015 form United
Bank of India ATM I.D. No.TR 133002U situated at Kanchanpur
market?
ii) Whether both the accused person on an form
08.06.2015 to 17.06.2015 at any time cheated the UBI,
Kanchanpur Branch and thereby dishonestly induced the said
bank officials to deliver Rs.9,77,100(Rupees Nine lakh Seventy
Seven Thousand and One Hundred Only)?”’
6.
Prosecution, to prove their case, examined as
many as 10 (ten) witnesses i.e., P.W.-1, Sri Jadab Debnath,
P.W.-2 Sri Sujit Nath, P.W.-3 Sri Madan Mohan Chakma, P.W.-
4 , Sri Arabinda Sarkar, P.W.-5 Sri Shakti Sadhan Jamatia,
P.W.-6, Sri Bhabatosh Talukdar, P.W.-7, Sri Sougat Chakma,
P.W.-8, Sri Subhasish Sengupta, P.W.-9, Inspector Ratan Mani
Debbarma and P.W.-10 Inspector Swapan Debbarma. The
prosecution side also proved some documents(Exbt-1 to Exbt49). The exhibited documents include Exbt-13 which is a Memo
regarding CCTV footage, Exbt-14,14(1) to 14(30) which is a
Certificate Under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act with
regard to Electronic Files in enclosed pen drive along with
printed out format of images. After the closure of the
prosecution evidence, the accused persons were examined
under section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. to which they denied the truth
of all the prosecution evidence and declined to adduce any
evidence on their behalf.
7.
The learned Trial Court relying on the evidence of
P.W.1, P.W.-3, P.W.4, P.W.8 and some exhibits i.e. Exbt-3 and
Exbt-4 which shows the names of the accused persons as
custodians of SIS, authorizing them to sign, withdrawal of slips
and cash, withdrawal from UBI Kanchanpur and carrying out
day to day ATM replenishment & FLM related activities, Exbt3(i), Exbt.4(i) which shows the photographs and specimen
signatures of the accused persons, and Exbt-5
which is a
bonafide letter of SIS providing the names and designation of
their employees found the first point of determination as
affirmative. The allegation under Section 420 of IPC was not
proved against the accused persons.
8.
Thereafter, learned Trial Court vide Judgment
dated
03.03.2020
convicted
the
petitioners
herein
for
committing offence punishable under Section 409 of IPC and
sentenced them to suffer simple imprisonment for 3(three)
years and to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- in default of suffer
simple imprisonment for 1(one) year.
9.
The petitioner-Jahar Debbarma preferred Criminal
Appeal No.6 of 2020 and the petitioner-Sanjoy Debnath
preferred Criminal Appeal No.7 of 2020 before the learned
Sessions Judge, North Tripura Dharmanagar.
10.
The
learned
First
Appellate
Court
after
perusing the Judgment passed by the Trial Court, vide a
common Judgment and order dated 29.09.2021 dismissed the
said
appeals
confirming
the
judgment
and
order
dated
03.03.2020 passed by the Trial Court in the following terms:“10. From the evidence on record, it is clear that
the accused persons were the joint custodian of ATM vide I.D. no
TR 13002U under United Bank Of India, Kanchanpur Branch and
State Bank of India, Vaughmun Branch from 2013 onwards with
proper KYC and they were entrusted with the property on the
date of alleged offence i.e. on and from 08-06-2015 to 17-062015 and the accused persons dishonestly misappropriated
Rs.9,77,100/- (Rupees Nine Lakhs Seventy Seven Thousand One
Hundred only) and both the accused persons acted in furtherance
of their common intention.
11. Considering the materials available before this court and on
scrutiny of the judgment and evidence recorded by Ld. Court
below, this court finds that in the instant appeals there is no
scope to interfere with the judgment passed by the Ld. Trial
court. Hence, the order of Conviction and Sentence passed by the
Ld. Trial court is hereby upheld in toto.
12. In the light of the aforesaid order and observation, both the
appeals are hereby dismissed and disposed of on contest. The
convicts are directed to surrender before the Ld. Trial Court within
a month from date to serve out the sentence.
11.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have filed
these instant appeals and prayed to set aside both the
judgment and orders dated 03.03.2020 and 28.09.2021 passed
by the learned Trial Court and First Appellate Court.
12.
Heard
Mr.S.
Bhattacharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing for the petitioners as well as Mr. S. Debnath, learned
Addl. P.P. appearing for the respondent.
13.
Mr.
S.
Bhattacharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing for the petitioners submits that the findings of the
Courts below are perverse since the same were relied on
documents that were not admissible. The learned Courts below
failed to consider that acquittal of the petitioners from the
charge framed under Section 420 of the IPC has bearing upon
allegation made under Section 409 of the IPC. Further learned
counsel submits that there is a lacuna on the part of the
prosecution since CCTV footage was not examined. Stating
thus learned counsel prayed to allow this instant appeal.
14.
Mr. S. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents submits that the judgment and order as passed by
the Court below is just and proper and needs no interference.
15.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
16.
Though the argument of the petitioner-counsel on
the point of Sections 409 & 420 of IPC is convincing to say that
they have not committed any breach of trust, but this Court
has not made up its mind on merits. This Court finds that when
Public Money is involved and the same is loaded in the ATM
Machines and the role of the petitioners herein are suspected,
the crucial evidence of CCTV footage where not dealt with,
either in the evidence nor in the Judgment and Order passed
by the Court below, this Court expresses its concern for public
money in the ATM machines.
17.
It is seen from the record that the CCTV footages
and the pen drives have been collected and the same are
shown as exhibits [Exbt-13, 14(1) to 14(30)] but there is no
discussion by the Court below on the said evidence and the
investigation appears to be silent on the same. This ignorance
of such crucial piece of evidence by the investigating officers as
well as the Courts below needs to be considered more
diligently. CCTV footages forms the crucial evidence for coming
to the conclusion to decide whether the accused persons were
present in the ATM rooms on the alleged day, and if so,
whether their presence is authorized or unauthorized.
18.
Accordingly, both the Judgment and Order dated
03.03.2020
and
28.09.2021
is
set
aside
and
without
expressing any opinion on the merits the matter is remanded
back to the Trial Court for re-appreciating the evidence in the
light of the CCTV footages and any other material and pass
appropriate order as per the procedure. The Trial Court shall
decide the matter on a priority basis on or before 1st August
2023.
19.
With the above observation and direction, these
instant petitions stand disposed of. Hence stay if any stands
vacated and pending application, if any, also stands closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review