The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. There is no whisper of any settlement between the parties at 20% share in favour of the applicant. The order passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court does not grant any liberty to the applicant to seek restoration of the First Appeal which has been dismissed as withdrawn voluntarily. The observation of the Hon'ble Apex Court while setting aside the order of the High Court allowing restoration of First Appeal, cannot be read that a liberty is granted to the applicant to seek restoration of appeal.
7. In view of the aforesaid, we do not find any merit to seek restoration of First Appeal under section 151 CPC which was voluntarily withdrawn by the applicant. Apart from that the petition for restoration has been filed after delay of four and a half years without ascribing any sufficient cause for condoning the delay.
8. The petition is dismissed.
9. No order as to costs. (RAVI MALIMATH) s
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE RAVI MALIMATH,
CHIEF JUSTICE
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA
ON THE 29th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISCELLANEOUS CIVIL CASE No. 417 of 2011
BETWEEN:JAGDEEPENDRA
SINGH
HOLKAR
S/O
SHRI
MALHARRAO HOLKAR, AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 18, MALVIYA COMPLEX,
MALVIYA NAGAR, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPLICANT
(BY SHRI ARJUN PATHAK - ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 01-02-2024
20:42:40
1.
PRINCESS USHA DEVI W/O SHRI SATISH
CHANDRA MALHOTRA, AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: LANDLADY 414, SENAPATI BAPAT
MARG,
LOWER
PAREL,
MUMBAI,
MAHARASHTRA
2.
SATISH CHANDRA MALHOTRA S/O SHRI
PANNALAL MALHOTRA, AGED ABOUT 82 YEARS,
OCC.: BUSINESS, R/O: 414, SENAPATI BAPAT
MARG,
LOWER
PAREL
MUMBAI
(MAHARASHTRA)
3.
THE PRINCESS USHA TRUST THROUGH ITS
CHAIRMAN, MANIK BAGH ANNEXE, 38/2, MANIK
BAGH ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
KHASGI DEVI AHILYABAI HOLKAR CHARITIES
TRUST, THROUGH THE CHAIRMAN MANIBAGH
ANNEXE 38/2, MANIK BAGH ROAD, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
ALAMPUR CHARITIES TRUST THROUGH ITS
C H A I R M A N , ALAMPUR CHARITIES TRUST,
MANIK BAGH ANNEXE, 38/2 MANIK BAGH ROAD,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, GOVT. OF INDIA,
SOUTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI
7.
THE HOME MINISTER, GOVT. OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, GOVT. OF INDIA
SOUTH BLOCK NEW DELHI
8.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
CHIEF SECRETARY, VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
9.
THE COMMISSIONER INDORE DIVISION, MOTI
BUNGALOW, MG. ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
10.
THE COLLECTOR, DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
11.
THE SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER PUBLIC
WORKS
DEPARTMENT (ICHARGE BUILDINGS
AND ROADS), PALASIA INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
12.
SHRIMANT ANSHUVANTRAO HOLKAR S/O LATE
SHRIMANT MALHARRAO HOLKAR, AGED ABOUT
55 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS, R/O: 39, VISHNUPURI
MAIN COLONY INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
13.
SHRIMANT GAUTAMRAO HOLKAR S/O LATE
SHRIMANT MALHARRAO HOLKAR, AGED ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: 39,
VISHNUPURI MAIN COLONY INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI ABHINAV MALHOTRA - ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT NO.1
A N D SHRI
ANIKET NAIK - DEPUTY ADVOCATE GENERAL FOR
RESPONDENTS NO.8 TO 11)
This application coming on for orders this day, Hon'ble Shri Justice
Vijay Kumar Shukla passed the following:
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 01-02-2024
20:42:40
ORDER
The present Miscellaneous Civil Case is filed for restoration of First
Appeal No.264 of 2003 under section 151 CPC.
2.
Facts of the case are that one Shrimant Malharrao Holkar - father of the
applicant and respondents No.12 & 13 herein filed a suit being Civil Suit
No.38A of 2002 (old No.15A of 1973) in the Court of District Judge, Indore for
a declaration that the suit property as described in Schedules A,B,C,D & E of
the plaint was the ancestral Joint Hindu Family Property in which he had a right
by birth and that he was entitled to succeed to the same being the sole surviving
co-parcener member thereof. The relief of possession of the entire property
held by late Maharaja Yashwant Rao Holkar in his capacity as Ruler of Indore
State was also sought after annulling the creation of various Trusts and transfer
of properties made to the said trusts. A further declaration was also sought that
declaration of Princess Usha Raje as successor Ruler of Indore State by the
Government of India on 3rd May, 1962 and giving her the power to transfer the
properties, are illegal and not binding on him. During the pendency of the said
suit, the plaintiff Shrimant Malharrao Holkar expired leaving behind his widow
Smt. Mrinalini Raje Holkar, applicant and respondents No.12 & 13 being the
sons as his legal heirs and representatives. The trial Court allowed the said
application being IA No.82 and rejected the plaint of the Civil Suit No.38A of
2000 (Old No.15A of 1973) on the ground that the right to sue did not survive.
The applicant herein alone being aggrieved, filed Civil First Appeal No.264 of
2003 in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Indore Bench. The applicant filed
an application being No.1193 of 2008 under Order XXIII, Rule 1 of the CPC
for withdrawal of the Civil First Appeal No.264 of 2003. The High Court
allowed the same. The High Court held that the appeal stood dismissed as
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 01-02-2024
20:42:40
withdrawn. "As a necessary consequence, all interim orders passed in the
appeal are vacated." The respondents No.12 & 13 herein being the sons of the
original plaintiff and younger brothers of the applicant herein being aggrieved,
filed an application being MCC No.131 of 2008 under Order XLI, Rule 21 r/w
Rules 4, 8, 33 & Section 151 of the CPC for recalling the order dated
30.01.2008 permitting withdrawal of the appeal and to restore the appeal to its
original file and be decided after hearing the applicants. The High Court by its
impugned judgment & order allowed the same and recalled the order dated
30.01.2008 passed in C.F.A. No.264 of 2003 and restored the same to its
original file for its disposal in accordance with law. I.A. No.11680 of 2008 was
filed by the applicant for withdrawing IA No.1193 of 2008 dated 29.01.2008. IA
No.11499 of 2008 was filed by the respondent No.12 & 13 for withdrawal of
FA No.264 of 2003. SLP No.205 of 2009 was filed by Princess Usha Raje in
the Hon'ble Supreme Court. An order was passed in SLP (C) No.205 of 2009
setting aside impugned order dated 09.09.2008.
3.
Counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant filed the present
petition for restoration of First Appeal No.264 of 2003 as respondents No.1 to
5 have practiced fraud on the applicant by making him believe that he would be
paid his share once the cases filed by him against respondent No.1 to 5 are
withdrawn only to resile from their promise and the applicant has been cheated.
It is argued that though the order of restoring the first appeal at the instance of
respondents was set aside by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Special Leave to
Appeal (Civil) No.205 of 2009 by the order dated 16.04.2010, but the present
application is maintainable in view of the observation made by the Apex Court.
He has emphatically relied on the following observation of the order of the
Apex Court which is extracted as under:Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 01-02-2024
20:42:40
"Needless to say that disposal of special leave petition in the
manner indicated above shall not prejudicially affect the rights of
either parties."
4.
Per contra counsel for the respondent/non-applicant No.1 & non-
applicants No.8 to 11 opposed the prayer and submitted that the present
application is not maintainable under section 151 CPC. Under the garb of an
application under section 151 CPC, he cannot seek restoration of an appeal
which has been voluntarily withdrawn. It is argued that law does not
contemplate that a party, who has voluntarily withdrawn an appeal can file an
application for its restoration. The allegations of fraud and cheating are an after
thought and the same were not pleaded in the application (IA No.1193 of 2008)
for withdrawal of First Appeal.
5.
After hearing learned counsels for the parties and to appreciate the rival
submissions of the parties, it is apposite to reproduce the contents of the
application filed by the applicant under Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC in First
Appeal No.2604 of 2003.
"The appellant submits that the original suit was filed by his
father inter alia seeking declaration in respect of ancestral joint
family properties of Royal Holkar Dynasty as well as possession
thereof. It is submitted that during the pendency of the suit the
appellant's father died on 18.05.2001. Needless to mention that
the original suit was dismissed on 21.04.2003. Being aggrieved by
the judgment and decree dated 21.04.2003, only the present
appellant chose to file this appeal.
The appellant further submits that during the pendency of the
present appeal, considering the object of the respondent Trusts,
has settled the matter outside the court and does not wish to
press the present appeal."
6.
There is no whisper of any settlement between the parties at 20% share
in favour of the applicant. The order passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court does
not grant any liberty to the applicant to seek restoration of the First Appeal
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 01-02-2024
20:42:40
which has been dismissed as withdrawn voluntarily. The observation of the
Hon'ble Apex Court while setting aside the order of the High Court allowing
restoration of First Appeal, cannot be read that a liberty is granted to the
applicant to seek restoration of appeal.
7.
In view of the aforesaid, we do not find any merit to seek restoration of
First Appeal under section 151 CPC which was voluntarily withdrawn by the
applicant. Apart from that the petition for restoration has been filed after delay
of four and a half years without ascribing any sufficient cause for condoning the
delay.
8.
The petition is dismissed.
9.
No order as to costs.
(RAVI MALIMATH)
CHIEF JUSTICE
s
Signed by: SOUMYA
RANJAN DALAI
Signing time: 01-02-2024
20:42:40
(VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review