Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 23RD DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 20628 OF 2013 (MV)
BETWEEN:
SRI. JAGANNATH MANGALESHAPPA ALVANDI,
AGE: 43 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. MANGLORE, TQ: YALABURGA,
DIST: KOPPAL.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. G.N. RAICHUR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
BHARATHI
HM
BHARATHI H M
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
SRI. AJAY ROHIDAS ANVEKAR,
AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC: NIL,
R/O. BASWESHWAR NAGAR, GADAG.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. G.N. NARASAMMANAVAR, ADVOCATE)
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MOTOR
VEHICLE ACT PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS HEAR THE
PARTIES AND SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD PASSED
IN MVC NO.368/2006 DATED:21-07-2012 PASSED BY THE
COURT OF DISTRICT JUDGE AND MACT, GADAG. BY ALLOWING
THIS APPEAL WITH COST IN THE ENDS OF JUSTICE AND
EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This is the appeal filed under Section 173(1) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘the M.V. Act’)
questioning the judgment and award dated 21.07.2001
passed in M.V.C.No.368/2006 on the file of the learned
District Judge and M.A.C.T. Gadag, (in short, the ‘Tribunal’).
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before the Tribunal for sake of convenience and
clarity.
3.
The claimant/brother-Ajay Rohidas Anvekar of
deceased known as Anil Rohidas Anvekar has filed claim
petition
under
Section
of
M.V.
Act
claiming
compensation in respect of death of his brother involving
Bajaj Motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-26/J-2499 and
tractor and trailer bearing registration Nos.KA-37/T-3370
and KA-37/T-3371.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
4.
It
is
the
contention
of
claimant
that
on
15.08.2006 at 08.30 a.m. on Talakal-Bannikoppa road i.e.,
NH-63 road, when brother of deceased was going in his
motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-26/J-2499, the driver
of tractor and trailer came from opposite side and dashed
against the rider and caused the accident and due to said
accident, Anil Rahidas Anvekar died at the spot. After
hearing the news, the wife of deceased committed suicide
on the same day. Claimant is the only dependent on the
deceased. Due to sudden death of deceased, claimant was
thrown to street. Hence, prayed for compensation under
different heads.
5.
After service of notice, respondent being the
owner of tractor and trailer filed his written statement,
wherein he denied the petition averments in toto regarding
the age, income and occupation of deceased and also the
dependency of claimant and other averments made in the
petition. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the petition.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
6.
On behalf of claimant, claimant was examined as
PW.1. Apart from marking Exs.P1 to 13 and closed his side
before the Tribunal. On behalf of respondent, respondent
was examined as RW.1 and closed his side before the
Tribunal.
7.
After recording evidence of both sides and
hearing arguments of both sides, the Tribunal held that the
claimant is only the brother of deceased and hence,
considering the principles noted in the judgment of Hon’ble
Apex Court i.e., Sarla Verma (Smt.) and others vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation and another1, the Tribunal
has awarded compensation of ₹2,04,000/- under the head
loss of estate to the claimant.
8.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and award, the
appellant/respondent i.e., owner of the tractor and trailer is
before this Court.
9.
Heard arguments of both sides.
AIR 2009 SC 3104
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
10.
Learned counsel for appellant, Sri G.N. Raichur
would submit that appellant is the owner of tractor and
trailer and there was no insurance to it. Claimant is younger
brother of deceased and was doing family business of
goldsmith
at
Gadag,
whereas
deceased
was
Hostel
Superintendent of Government Hostel working at Koppal.
Thus, claimant cannot be the dependent of deceased. In
this regard, learned counsel for appellant relied upon the
judgment
of
division
Bench
of
this
Court
in
MFA
No.103546/2019 and two other judgments of Hon'ble Apex
Court
i.e.,
Manjuri
Bera
vs.
Oriental
Insurance
Company Ltd. and another2. The New India Assurance
Company Limited Vs. Anand Pal and others3 and hence,
prayed for allowing the appeal.
11.
Learned counsel for respondent/claimant Sri G.
N. Narasammanavar would submit that claimant was the
younger brother of deceased aged only about 19 years and
2 AIR 2007 SC 1474
SLA No. 7805/2022 dated 04.12.2023
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
only after deceased got Government job, claimant was
looking after the family business and claimant was entirely
depending upon the deceased in all respects. Hence,
considering the principles noted in Sarla Verma's case
cited supra, the Tribunal has rightly awarded compensation
only under the head ‘loss towards estate’ and not under the
head of loss of dependency. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
the appeal.
12.
Having heard arguments of both sides and
verifying the appeal papers along with Trial Court records,
the only point that arises for consideration is
Whether
any
compensation
could
be
awarded to the claimant/younger brother of
deceased, when both were not residing under
single roof?
13.
The finding of this Court on the above point is in
‘affirmative’ for the following reasons:On 15.08.2006 at 08.30 a.m., on Talakal-Bannikoppa
road i.e., NH-63 road, the accident happened involving a
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
motorcycle
bearing
registration
No.KA-26/J-2499
and
tractor and trailer bearing registration Nos.KA-37/T-3370
and KA-37/T-3371 and the deceased died at the spot are
not in dispute.
14.
The claimant was aged about 19 years at the
time of the accident. The cross-examination of claimant
reveals that the deceased has got Government job during
2004 and deceased died in the year 2006 i.e., within 2
years of he getting the Government job. The crossexamination of PW.1 further reveals that his father died
during 1996, after death of his father, his mother was
taking care of business and his mother also died in the year
2001 and after death of his mother, it is the brother of
claimant i.e., deceased was taking care of business and only
because he got job in the year 2004, this claimant started
looking after the family business and claimant was bachelor.
15.
The
deceased
was
working
as
Hostel
Superintendent in Government Hostel and thus, he has to
stay in the hostel for the whole day and he would not be
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
having holidays also and he has to look after the hostel day
and night. Hence, the contention of claimant that even
though deceased was working as Hostel Superintendent,
deceased was also assisting the claimant in family business
cannot be accepted as correct. Thus, apparently deceased
ought to be in the place where he was working. However
that does not mean that deceased was not contributing
anything to the family from his salary.
16.
It is not in dispute that deceased married in year
2005 and after deceased died in the accident, immediately
on the same day, his wife also committed suicide by hearing
the news of death of her husband. Both parents of
claimants are no more and he was having only two married
sisters and they were residing in their respective husband's
houses.
17.
In first of the aforesaid citations relied by the
learned counsel for appellant i.e., MFA No.103546/2019,
the Co-Ordinate Bench of this Court held that, Tribunal has
awarded a sum of ₹.50,000/- under the ‘head loss of estate’
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
and it is contrary to the ruling of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi
and others4; and further held that, the Tribunal has not
awarded
any
compensation
under
the
head
‘loss
of
consortium’ and thus, the claimant was entitled for said
amount under the head loss of consortium and thus, there
was no interference on said judgment.
18.
In second of the aforesaid citations relied by the
learned counsel for appellant Manjuri Bera’s case (supra),
it is held at paragraph Nos.12, 17 and 18 as follows:
“12.
Judged
representative
in
that
who
background
is
not
where
dependant
a
legal
files
an
application for compensation, the quantum cannot be
less than the liability referable to Section 140 of the
Act. Therefore, even if there is no loss of dependency
the claimant if he or she is a legal representative will
be entitled to compensation, the quantum of which
shall be not less than the liability flowing from Section
140 of the Act. The appeal is allowed to the aforesaid
extent. There will be no order as to costs. We record
4 (2017) 16 SCC 680
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
our appreciation for the able assistance rendered by
Shri Jayant Bhushan, the learned Amicus Curiae.
17. In my opinion, "No Fault Liability", envisaged in
Section 140 of the said Act, is distinguishable from the
rule
of
"Strict
Liability".
In
the
former,
the
compensation amount is fixed. It is Rs.50,000/- in
cases of death [Section 140(2)]. It is a statutory
liability. It is an amount which can be deducted from
the final amount awarded by the Tribunal. Since, the
amount is a fixed amount/crystallized amount, the
same has to be considered as part of the estate of the
deceased. In the present case, the deceased was an
earning member. The statutory compensation could
constitute part of his estate. His legal representative,
namely, his daughter has inherited his estate. She was
entitled to inherit his estate. In the circumstances, she
was entitled to receive compensation under "No fault
Liability" in terms of Section 140 of the said Act. My
opinion is confined only to the "No Fault Liability" under
Section 140 of the said Act. That section is a Code by
itself within the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
18. For the above separate reasons, I agree with the
conclusion, namely, the appeal be allowed with no
order as to costs.”
19.
Thus, in the aforesaid citation, it is held that
under Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the claimant is
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
entitled for compensation which shall not be less than the
liability flowing from Section 140 of the M.V. Act and thus,
the appeal was allowed holding that even a married
daughter could maintain a claim petition.
20.
Under the same footing even the major younger
brother is also entitled to file a claim petition.
21.
The third judgment relied upon by the learned
counsel for appellant is that The New India Insurance
Company Ltd. (supra) wherein the deceased left behind
only his elder brothers who were married having their
respective children and residing separately and under those
circumstances, it was held that they are not entitled for
compensation and appeal was allowed.
22.
In the instant case, as discussed above, the
claimant is none other than the younger brother of
deceased and was just 19 years at the time of the accident.
Even though the claimant was running a family business,
the deceased was having definite income that is salary
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
because he was working as Hostel Superintendent at
Government Hostel.
23.
In the aforesaid cases, the Sarla Verma's case,
was not overruled. Under those circumstances, even though
the claimant was only the younger brother of deceased,
who was working at Koppal, it cannot be said that there was
no assistance from the deceased to the claimant. Definitely
claimant is entitled for compensation towards loss of estate.
Relying upon this Sarla Verma's case only, the Tribunal
has awarded the compensation. The salary certificate of
deceased reveal that he was drawing gross salary of
₹.7,680/- per month and after deductions it was ₹.6,672.
Considering all these facts, the Tribunal has taken the
savings of deceased that might be given to his brother
would be ₹.1,000/- per month and by making calculation
that the age of deceased is 30 years and applied the
appropriate multiplier 17.
24.
Court,
In the absence of any other material before the
respectfully
following
the
judgment
of
Sarla
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
Verma's case, the compensation of ₹.2,04,000/- awarded
by the Tribunal is in accordance with law and thus it needs
no interference. If at all, the claimant was elder to the
deceased and was having stable business and was having
his own family, then the argument of learned counsel for
appellant would be acceptable. In the absence of these
things,
when
deceased, the
the
claimant
was
said
argument
is
younger
not
brother
acceptable
of
one.
Considering these facts, the point under consideration is
answered in ‘negative’ and thus this Court proceed to pass
the following:
ORDER
i)
Appeal filed under Section 173(1) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is dismissed by
confirming
the
judgment
and
award
passed in M.V.C.No.368/2006 on the file of
the learned District Judge and Member,
MACT, Gadag.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:891
MFA No. 20628 of 2013
HC-KAR
ii) No order as to costs.
iii) Amount in deposit if any be transmitted to
the Tribunal.
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SSP: Para 1 to 15
HMB: Para 16 to end
CT-MCK
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review