Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TH E H I GH COURT OF SI KKI M : GAN GTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
DA TED : 7th OCTOBER, 2016
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : H ON ’BLE M RS. JUSTI CE M EEN AKSH I M AD AN RAI , JUD GE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail A ppln.N o.08 of 2016
Petitioner
:
Shri Jacob Rai (Khaling),
A ged about 32 years,
S/ o Shri Dal Bahadur Rai,
R/ o Below H otel M ayur,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
A pplication for Bail under Section 438
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
M r. Sudesh Joshi and M s. Tengop Subba, A dvocates for the
Petitioner.
M r. Karma Thinlay N amgyal, A dditional Public Prosecutor w ith
M r. S. K. Chettri and M rs. Pollin Rai, A ssistant Public Prosecutors
for the State on advance notice.
SI Silash Tamang, Investigating Officer, in person.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORD ER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
H eard.
2.
A dverting to the allegations made out in the FIR against the
Petitioner, his Counsel in the first instance denies that the offence w as at
all committed by the Petitioner. That, assuming but not admitting that
Bail Appln. N o.08 of 2016
Jacob Rai (Khaling)
vs.
State of Sikkim
such an offence had been committed, no physical injury w as caused to
the Officers named in the FIR being Senior IA S Officers of the
Government of Sikkim w ho for their part have not lodged any joint or
individual FIR in connection w ith the incident, but has been lodged as
an afterthought by the Station H ouse Officer, Sadar Police Station, w ho
w as present at the place of occurrence, although no arrests w ere carried
out at the spot.
That, he is the General Secretary of the principal
Opposition Party in Sikkim, i.e., Sikkim Krantikari M orcha (SKM ), and
he along w ith his party members had expressed solidarity w ith former
students of the Institute of Technology and Future Trends (ITFT),
Chandigarh, w ho are agitating their demands in view of the nonrecognition of their Degrees by the University Grants Commission,
making them ineligible for higher studies, apart from w hich he has been
raising issues on corruption in Sikkim. A meeting w as held on 21-092016 in the Conference H all at M anan Kendra, Gangtok, w ith the Chief
Secretary of the Government of Sikkim and the tw o Officers named in
the FIR, on conclusion of w hich the students demanded copies of the
minutes of the meeting, w hich w ere denied to them. The students thus
started raising slogans on w hich the Police intervened and forcibly
removed them out of the Conference H all and took them to Sadar Police
Station. It is urged that the Petitioner at no time manhandled any of the
officials present, this being evident from the fact that although the Police
w ere present at the M anan Kendra, the Petitioner w as not arrested
despite the alleged offence. The acts of the Police officials are violative
Bail Appln. N o.08 of 2016
Jacob Rai (Khaling)
vs.
State of Sikkim
of the provisions of the fundamental rights enshrined in A rticles 19 and
21 of the Constitution of India.
That, presently he is admitted in the
Central Referral H ospital (CRH ), Tadong, Gangtok, and undergoing
treatment. That, he is a permanent resident of Village Chumbung, N aya
Bazar, West Sikkim, and apprehending arrest in connection w ith FIR
dated 21-09-2016 under Sections 353/ 341/ 34 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (for short “ IPC” ) lodged by PI Bijay Subba, Station H ouse Officer of
the Sadar Police Station, Gangtok, follow ing w hich Sadar Police Station
Case bearing N o.330/ 2016 dated 21-09-2016 has been registered against
him. H e undertakes to cooperate w ith the Police in the investigation
and that he is available at the H ospital for any information required
from him.
It is prayed that this Court pass an order granting
anticipatory bail. To fortify his submissions, reliance w as placed by
Learned Counsel on the follow ing decision;
(i)
Siddharam Satlingappa M hetre vs. State of M aharashtra
and O thers : (2011) 1 SCC 694
(ii)
Shobhan Singh Khanka vs. State of Jharkhand : (2012) 4
SCC 684
(iii)
Hema M ishra vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and O thers : (2014)
4 SCC 453
(iv)
Arnesh Kumar vs. State of Bihar and Another : (2014) 8 SCC
273 and
(v)
Bhadresh Bipinbhai Sheth vs. State of Gujarat and Another
: (2016) 1 SCC 152.
3.
Vehemently objecting to the submissions of Learned
Counsel for the Petitioner, it w as countered by Learned A dditional
Bail Appln. N o.08 of 2016
Jacob Rai (Khaling)
vs.
State of Sikkim
Public Prosecutor that, the Petitioner is only seeking to draw political
mileage of the entire situation as he is a member of the Opposition party
and is inclined to give any agitation a political colour w hich likely w ill
lead to a law and order situation.
That, the Petitioner had indeed
committed the offence alleged in the FIR and custodial interrogation of
the Petitioner is required as otherw ise it is likely that he w ould tamper
w ith w itnesses. A part from that, the I.O. has to delve into questions of
(i) w hether the demand of the minutes of the meeting w as made by the
students or by the Petitioner (ii) w hether the Petitioner w as present at
the meeting w ith the consent of the students or of his ow n accord and,
(iii) ultimately the larger interest of the public has to be taken into
consideration as a law and order situation could arise. That, presently
there is a Criminal Case pending against the Petitioner in the Sessions
Court, South District at N amchi, thereby indicative of the fact that he
is a habitual offender. H e relies on Bhagirath vs. State of M adhya
Pradesh : 1981 (Supp) SCC 70 and K. K. Jerath vs. Union Territory,
Chandigarh and O thers : (1998) 4 SCC 80
and prays that this
A pplication be rejected and dismissed. A copy each of the Section 161
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “ Cr.P.C.” ), statements
of the Officers alleged to have been the victims have also been
submitted before this Court.
4.
I have heard the rival contentions of Learned Counsel and
given due and anxious consideration to the same. I have also carefully
Bail Appln. N o.08 of 2016
Jacob Rai (Khaling)
vs.
State of Sikkim
perused the documents relied on by the parties and the citations made
at the Bar.
5.
I have given careful consideration to the Law relating to
anticipatory bail as has been developed through the years by judicial
interpretative process for w hich purpose I have meticulously perused
the Judgements in Shri Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia and O thers vs. State of
Punjab : (1980) 2 SCC 565, Siddharam Satlingappa M hetre (supra) and
Bhadresh Bipinbhai Sheth (supra).
I have also perused the indepth
discussions made under Section 41 of the Cr.P.C. in Arnesh Kumar
(supra).
6.
Consequently, w hile considering a Petition under Section
438 of the Cr.P.C. w hat must, inter alia, w eigh w ith the Court is the
gravity of the offence, the severity of the penalty it entails and the
requirement for custodial interrogation.
This, of course, has to be
balanced w ith the possibility of the Petitioner seeking to impede
investigation on w hich count the Courts ought to be circumspect. In the
instant matter, of the offences under w hich the Petitioner is booked,
only one is a non-bailable offence w hich entails imprisonment for tw o
years or fine or both.
7.
It is not disputed that he has roots in society here, neither is
there any apprehension on the part of the Prosecution that he w ill
abscond so the question of his presence not being ensured during
Bail Appln. N o.08 of 2016
Jacob Rai (Khaling)
vs.
State of Sikkim
investigation or trial does not arise. It w ould be relevant to notice that
the FIR w as lodged on 21-09-2016 w ith no arrest made till date, w hich
thereby allays the apprehension of absconsion. H e is not guilty of an
offence punishable w ith death or imprisonment for life as the offence
under Section 353 of the Cr.P.C. entails a tw o year imprisonment or fine
or both as already discussed, in addition to w hich he undertakes to
cooperate w ith the investigation in the matter.
The question of
tampering w ith w itness appears to be a little far-fetched as it is evident
from the FIR that the students purportedly the w itnesses in the case and
the Petitioner do not appear to be at cross purposes, both having
attended the meeting on a common agenda, i.e., on the point of nonrecognition of the college degree as discussed supra. The allegation that
he has criminal antecedents also boils dow n to a criminal case that is
pending against him, the trial of w hich is still underw ay.
In the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the discussions
8.
herein, it is hereby Ordered that in the event of arrest of the Petitioner
for the offences mentioned in the FIR, supra, he shall be released on bail
on furnishing PB& SB of Rs.20,000/ - (Rupees tw enty thousand) only,
each, subject to the follow ing conditions;
(i)
H e shall make himself available for interrogation by the I.O.
as and w hen required.
(ii)
H e shall not directly or indirectly make any inducement,
threat or promise to any person acquainted w ith the facts of
Bail Appln. N o.08 of 2016
Jacob Rai (Khaling)
vs.
State of Sikkim
the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to
the Court or to any Police Officer.
(iii)
H e shall not leave the State of Sikkim w ithout the prior
permission of the Learned Sessions Judge, East Sikkim at
Gangtok, on grant of w hich, due notice shall be given to the
I.O. by the Learned Court.
(iv)
H e shall not commit the offence alleged to have been
committed by him in the FIR or any other offence.
9.
The observations hereinabove are only for the purposes of
disposing of this A pplication and are not to be construed as telling on
the merits of the case.
10.
The A pplication is allow ed and stands disposed of
accordingly.
11.
Certified copies be made available to the parties as per
Rules.
Sd/ ( M eenakshi M adan Rai )
Judge
07-10-2016
A pproved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review