Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 09
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Pronounced on : 02.03.2026
Uploaded on : 03.03.2026
Arb P. No. 31/2025
J and Sons Construction Pvt. Ltd.
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rohit Verma, Advocate
Vs
J&K Economic Reconstruction Agency & Ors.
.….Respondents
Through: Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
01.
Through the medium of the present petition, the
petitioner has invoked jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 seeking appointment of an Arbitrator.
02.
As per case of the petitioner, it is a registered Company
under the Companies Act, 2013 and it deals primarily in
the construction and allied works.
03.
According to the petitioner pursuant to acceptance of its
offer dated 21.05.2021 for execution of work, namely,
Supply, Installation, Testing and Commissioning of
Arb P No. 31/2025
Electrical Items and construction of oxygen Plant Room
for 15 sites in Jammu Division, acceptance letter bearing
No. JTFRP/PMU/2021/OXY/2858-65 dated 25.05.2021
came to be issued by the respondents in favour of the
petitioner.
Thereafter,
a
Contract
Agreement
was
executed between the petitioner and the respondents on
04.06.2021.
04.
As per the terms of the Contract Agreement, rates and
other specifications which were mutually agreed by both
the parties for supply and service of 300LPM and 500LPM
Oxygen Generation Plant Rooms were to be adopted
keeping in view the commercial viability of the Project. It
has been submitted that contrary to the contractual
obligations, the respondents unilaterally reduced the
price of the items without adhering to the terms and
conditions of the contract thereby violating Clause 8.2 of
the contract. It has been alleged that when the petitioner
protested
against
such
reduction
in
prices,
the
respondents assured to pay him compensation in this
regard. On the basis of this assurance, the petitioner
went ahead with the execution of the allotted work under
protest
which
was
duly
communicated
to
the
respondents.
Arb P No. 31/2025
05.
It has been further submitted that in the Electrical BOQ
(Bill of Quality) for 300 LPM and 500 LPM of the Oxygen
Generation Plant, the petitioner supplied low tension
cables as per ordered quantity and the same was
inspected by the respondents and its representatives.
Certification in this regard was also attested. Vide letter
dated 13.02.2023, the petitioner is stated to have
apprised the respondents about it and requested them to
provide address so that the material can be shifted in the
warehouse of the respondents but the respondents failed
to respond to the same. It has been submitted that final
variation was verified and recommended by respondent
No. 2 on 20.03.2024 which was duly uploaded on e-Office
vide file No. 198616, but the same has not been
approved.
06.
According to the petitioner, despite the aforesaid hurdles
created by the respondents and the losses having been
suffered
by
the
petitioner,
the
allotted
work
was
completed by the petitioner on 10.02.2024 whereafter it
handed over all the sites to the respondents. It has been
submitted that the petitioner made numerous requests to
the respondents to clear pending claims but no response
was received from the respondents which resulted in
Arb P No. 31/2025
huge loss to the petitioner due to escalation of costs. It
has been further submitted that requests of the petitioner
for amicable settlement of the disputes have fallen on
deaf ears of the respondents and, as such, the said
disputes are now required to be resolved through the
process of arbitration.
07.
According to the petitioner, Clause 6.1 of the contract
provides for settlement of disputes through arbitration in
accordance with Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
The petitioner is stated to have invoked the arbitration
clause
by
nominating
Mr.
R.
C.
Sharma,
Retd.
Superintending Engineer, JPDCL as its arbitrator and
sought nomination of Arbitrator by the respondents in
terms of the arbitration clause by issuing letter of
invocation dated 25.01.2025 but the respondents have
failed to take any action in the matter. Hence the present
petition.
08.
The respondents have contested the petition by filing
their reply. In their reply, it has been submitted that the
Contract Agreement contained express conditions for
Shipping, Contract Price, Terms of Payment, Taxes and
Duties, Specifications and Standards, Transportation,
Arb P No. 31/2025
Inspection and Tests etc. It has been submitted that
payments were made to the petitioner as per the agreed
terms of the contract/approved BOQ in the mutual
agreement and any additional items which were required
as per the site conditions were made through approved
variation which was Rs. 1.205 Cr. above the original cost
of the project. It has been submitted that increase in the
approved BOQ and other non-BOQ items has been
granted and paid to the petitioner after the approval of
the variation.
09.
It has been further submitted that the petitioner had to
supply articles as per the requirement of the site after
ascertaining the same and if the petitioner has made any
excess purchase, the same cannot be attributed to the
respondents. It has been submitted that the petitioner
cannot raise unjustified and baseless claims.
10.
The respondents have not disputed the existence of
arbitration clause nor have they disputed the invocation
of the said clause by the petitioner.
11.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record of the case.
Arb P No. 31/2025
12.
As already stated, the existence of Arbitration Agreement
in terms of Clause 6.1 of the agreement is not in dispute.
As per this clause, all disputes between the parties
relating to any matter arising out of or connected with
the agreement is to be resolved in accordance with the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. It further provides
that Arbitral Tribunal shall comprise of three Arbitrators
one each to be nominated by the Purchaser and Supplier
with mutual consent. The third Arbitrator has to be
chosen by the two arbitrators so appointed by the parties
who shall act as presiding arbitrator and in case failure
of the two arbitrators appointed by the parties to reach
consensus
within
a
period
of
days
from
the
appointment of the arbitrator appointed subsequent, the
Presiding Arbitrator shall be appointed by the Chairman
Institution of Engineers, J&K State Centre Srinagar.
13.
The invocation of arbitration clause by the petitioner is
not in dispute. The petitioner, in terms of its invocation
letter dated 25.01.2025, nominated Mr. R.C. Sharma,
Retd. Superintending Engineer, JPDCL as the arbitrator
but the respondents did not make any nomination of
arbitrator on its behalf nor did they respond to the
invocation letter issued by the petitioner.
Arb P No. 31/2025
14.
The contention of the respondents is that, whatever was
required to be paid to the petitioner under the terms and
conditions of the contract has already been paid which
includes the amount on account of price variation and
therefore, no dispute arises between the parties. This
position is being disputed by the petitioner and it has
been submitted that the respondents have unilaterally
reduced the prices of items without adhering to the terms
and the conditions of the contract.
15.
The question whether the respondents have reduced the
prices of the items contrary to the terms and conditions
of the contract or whether the respondents have paid
whole of the amount due to the petitioner in accordance
with the terms and conditions of the contract constitutes
a dispute arising out of the terms of the contract. The
same is required to be resolved through appointment of
an Arbitrator in view of the existence of arbitration clause
in the agreement.
16.
Though, petitioner has nominated its Arbitrator, yet the
respondents have failed to nominate their arbitrator.
Thus, the mechanism provided for appointment of an
Arbitrator in Clause 6.1 for settlement of disputes cannot
Arb P No. 31/2025
work out. In this view of the matter, it would be
appropriate to refer the disputes that have arisen
between the parties to a sole Arbitrator.
17.
Accordingly, the petition is allowed and Hon’ble Mr.
Justice Puneet Gupta, former Judge of this Court is
appointed as sole Arbitrator to adjudicate upon the
disputes and differences between the parties arising out
of and in connection with the agreement referred to
above.
18.
A copy of this order shall be communicated to the learned
Sole Arbitrator by the Registry of this Court within a
period of ten (10) days from today and the learned
Arbitrator
is
requested
to
forward
the
‘Statutory
Statement of Disclosures’ under Section 11(8) read with
Section 12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, to the parties within a period of two weeks from
the date of receipt of this order.
19.
The
parties
shall
appear
before
the
learned
Sole
Arbitrator on the date and place, to be fixed by the
learned Sole Arbitrator. It is further directed that all the
arbitration costs and fees of the Arbitral Tribunal shall be
borne by the parties equally and shall be subject to the
Arb P No. 31/2025
final award that may be passed by the learned Arbitrator
in relation to the costs.
20.
Disposed of.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
02.03.2026
SUNIL
Whether the order is speaking ?
Whether the order is reportable ?
:
:
Yes
No
Arb P No. 31/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review