Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
LPA No.136/2025
Reserved on:
16.07.2026 26.02.2026
Pronounced on: 18.08.2026
Uploaded on:
18.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced-Full
.....Appellant/petitioner(s)
J&K Grameen Bank & Ors.
Through :- Mr. R.K.Jain, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Paramveer Singh, Advocate.
v/s
.....Respondent(s)
Rachhpal Singh
Through :- Mr. Abhimanyu Sharma, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
(Sekhri-J)
01.
This intra-court appeal seeks to assail judgment dated 15.05.2025, passed
by learned Single Judge of this Court in WP(C) No. 930/2023 whereby penalty
imposed by the competent authority and reduced by appellate authority of the
appellant -Bank upon the respondent came to be quashed.
CASE BEFORE THE WRIT COURT
02.
Case set out by the respondent before the writ Court was that he joined
the appellant-Bank in the year 1982 as Cashier-cum-Clerk and came to be
promoted as Scale-I Officer. He came to be transferred and posted at Simbal
Morh Branch of the Bank which was running in losses and had deposits of Rs.
23 crores against advances of Rs. 5.47 crores. According to the respondent, on
taking over the said Branch, he started aggressive lending, but within the norms
and guidelines of the Bank and brought the Branch to a profitable stage of more
than Rs. 50 lakhs as on 31.03.2020.
2.1
On 16.04.2021, he came to be served with a charge-sheet by the Bank
alleging, inter-alia, that while working as Senior Manager of the Branch, he had
extended undue favour and sanctioned loans to selected borrowers by misusing
his official position and in violation of the operational guidelines and norms of
the Bank. It was alleged that he had exceeded the powers delegated to him by
the Bank, thereby exposing the Bank’s funds to risk.
2.2.
He submitted a detailed reply to the charge-sheet on 08.06.2021, by
contending that by the time he left the aforesaid Branch, the advances which
stood at Rs. 5.47 crores was increased to Rs. 19.92 crores, business of the
Branch increased from Rs. 28.90 crores to Rs. 54 crores and NPA was reduced
from 12.37% to 3.51%. According to the respondent, the Branch which was
running in loss of Rs. 10.47 crores, was brought to a profit of Rs. 34.40 lakhs. It
was also submitted by the respondent that most of the regularities, on account of
routine mistakes and heavy workload had already been rectified.
2.3.
The appellant-Bank, however being dissatisfied with the reply of the
respondent appointed an Inquiry Officer to inquire into the charges. The Inquiry
Officer submitted his report dated 03.02.2022, whereby he came to conclude
that except for the charge under Article 3, which was partially proved, rest of
the charges were proved against the respondent.
2.4.
Consequent upon the conclusion of the inquiry, respondent came to be
served with a notice dated 28.02.2022 by the disciplinary/competent authority
whereby he was called upon to show cause as to why he should not be reduced
LPA No. 136/2025
to the lowest stage in the pay scale of Officer Scale-II and why his
superannuation benefits be not released on the reduced pay. The show-cause
notice came to be responded by the respondent on 30.03.2022, whereby he
sought personal hearing by stating that neither he committed malfeasance nor he
intentionally caused any pecuniary loss to the Bank. The competent authority,
however, accepted the findings recorded by the Inquiry Officer and vide order
dated 23.05.2022 imposed penalty of reducing the respondent to the lowest
stage in the pay scale of Officer Scale-II and also directed that all his
superannuation benefits be released on the reduced pay.
2.5.
Aggrieved of the aforesaid order of the disciplinary/competent authority,
respondent preferred an appeal before respondent no. 2-the appellate
authority/Board of Directors of the Bank, on 30.06.2022. The said appeal came
to be disposed of vide order dated 02.11.2022, whereby order passed by the
competent authority came to be modified in the following terms:"2. That the Basic pay of CSO is reduced to lowest stage (1st stage of
pay ie. Rs 48,170/-) in the Pay Scale of Officer Scale I and all his
superannuation benefits shall be released on the reduced pay;
however, in accordance to punishment order no. JKGB/H.O./ DISP/
ORDER/ 16-300 dated 16.04.2016, the superannuation benefits shall
be released only after the smooth recovery/ adjustment of all the loan
accounts mentioned in Charge sheet dated 15.04.2015. The withheld
amount under reference be kept in the shape of FDR under lien to the
Chairman, Head Office, Jammu, of the bank;
3. That CSO shall extend all his best cooperation to the bank in
effecting smooth recovery/adjustment of all the loan accounts
mentioned in the charge sheet dated 16.04.2021 and proved &
established against him and in case the bank suffers any pecuniary/
financial loss in respect of these loan accounts the same shall be
recovered from monthly pension/family pension of the CSO."
03.
Both the aforesaid orders i.e., order dated 23.05.2022 passed by the
competent authority and order dated 02.11.2022 passed by the appellate
authority, were assailed by the respondent before the writ Court primarily on the
ground that penalty imposed upon him was contrary to Regulation 39 of the
Jammu and Kashmir Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulation, 2010
(hereinafter referred to as “Regulation of 2010”).
LPA No. 136/2025
APPELLANT’S STAND
04.
The Appellant-Bank opposed the writ petition primarily on the ground
that during the inquiry proceedings, the respondent not only admitted his
misconduct while discharging duties as Branch Head of the Bank, but it was
also brought to the notice of the Inquiry Officer that respondent had already
been charge-sheeted and punished twice during his service career for various
acts of omission and commission.
4.1
It was contended by the appellant before the writ court that respondent
had sanctioned loans/advances to the selected borrowers in utter disregard to the
guidelines contained in Circular (03) dated 02.04.2019 and Circular (08) dated
03.04.2020, governing the functioning of the officers of the Bank and
prescribing their powers for sanctioning loans and advances. It was further
contended that, by his repeated acts of omission and commission, the
respondent jeopardized financial interest of the Bank, which necessitated
initiation of disciplinary proceedings against him. It was submitted that the
appellate authority, by taking a lenient view of the matter, had already reduced
the penalty awarded by the competent authority and imposed appropriate
punishment.
THE WRIT COURT VERDICT
05.
The writ petition came to be allowed and both the orders passed by the
competent authority and appellate authority came to be quashed by learned
Single Judge in terms of the impugned judgment by holding that appellant Bank
did not suffer any financial loss on account of alleged acts of omission and
commission of the respondent; that respondent did not derive any pecuniary
gain therefrom; and most of the alleged irregularities had already been rectified
by him. Learned Single Judge is thus of the view that punishment imposed upon
LPA No. 136/2025
the respondent was not only harsh but disproportionate to the misconduct
attributed to him.
GROUNDS OF CHLLANGE
06.
Appellant-Bank is aggrieved of the impugned judgment primarily on the
ground that learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate the scope of judicial
review in such matters and ignored the material aspect that during the inquiry
proceedings, the respondent himself admitted his misconduct of overstepping
the delegated powers while performing his duties as Branch Head of the Bank.
6.1.
It is contention of the appellant that it is not permissible for the writ court
to re-appreciate the evidence considered by the competent authority and assume
the role of the appellate authority. According to the appellant, since the
competent authority and the appellate authority considered the allegations
against the respondent consistent with the rules and principles of natural justice,
the question as to what punishment would meet the ends of justice is a matter
within the exclusive domain of the disciplinary authority and writ court lacks
jurisdiction to interfere with the said findings.
RIVAL CONTENTIONS & ANALYSIS
07.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties, we have gone through the
record.
08.
Mr. Jain, learned senior counsel for the appellant-Bank, at the foremost
has taken exception to the observation of learned Single Judge that since
appellant-Bank did not suffer any financial loss and acts of the respondent were
not tainted with any mala fide intention, punishment imposed upon him was
disproportionate to the misconduct attributed to him.
8.1.
Mr. Jain has relied upon Disciplinary Authority-Cum-Regional
Manager vs. Nikunja Bihari Patnaik; 1996(3) Supreme 710, to submit that
LPA No. 136/2025
acts of omission and commission on the part of a Bank employee cannot be
condoned on the specious ground that it was not actuated by ulterior motives or
extraneous considerations. Mr. Jain has vehemently argued that the very act on
the part of the respondent acting beyond his authority by itself amounts to
misconduct.
8.2.
Mr. Abhimanyu Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent on the other
hand has vehemently argued that record bears testimony to the fact that by the
time respondent left the Simble Morh Branch of the appellant-Bank, the
business of the Branch had increased from Rs. 28.90 crores to 54 crores and
NPA was reduced from Rs. 12.37% to 3.51%. Mr. Sharma, submits that since
the said branch, which was running in loss of 10.47 crores, was brought to a
profit of Rs. 34.40 lakhs, and most of the irregularities allegedly committed by
the respondent on account of routine mistakes and heavy workload had already
been rectified, impugned judgment of learned Single Judge, taking a lenient
view of the matter, does not call for interference. He has relied upon a verdict of
Karnataka High Court reported in 2018(3) SLJ 131.
09.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Nikunja Bihari Patnaik (supra), has clearly
ruled that an act of a Bank official acting beyond his authority, even if it yields
profit and causes no loss to the Bank by itself amounts to misconduct and such
an act of indiscipline cannot be condoned on the premise that it was not actuated
by ulterior motives or extraneous considerations.
9.1.
Relevant excerpt of the judgment captured in para 4, for the ease of
reference is extracted below:“07.It may be mentioned that in the memorandum of charges, the
aforesaid two regulations are said to have been violated by the
respondent. Regulation 3 requires every officer/employee of the
bank to take all possible steps to protect the interests of the bank
and to discharge his duties with utmost integrity, honesty,
LPA No. 136/2025
devotion and diligence and to do nothing which is unbecoming of
a bank officer. It requires the officer/employee to maintain good
conduct and discipline and to act to the best of his judgment in
performance of his official duties or in exercise of the powers
conferred upon him. Breach of Regulation 3 is 'misconduct'
within the meaning of Regulation 24; 'The findings of the Inquiry
Officer which have been accepted by the disciplinary authority,
and which have not been disturbed by the High court, clearly
show that in a number of instances the respondent allowed
overdrafts or passed cheques involving substantial amounts
beyond his authority. True, it is that in some cases, no loss has
resulted from such acts. It is also true that in some other
instances such acts have yielded profit to the Bank but it is
equally true that in some other instances, the funds of the Bank
have been placed in jeopardy; the advances have become sticky
and irrecoverable. It is not a single act; it is a course of action
spreading over a sufficiently long period and involving a large
number of transactions. In the case of a bank - for that matter, in
the case of any other organisation - every officer/employee is
supposed to act within the limits of his authority. If each
officer/employee is allowed to act beyond his authority, the
discipline of the organisation/bank will disappear; the functioning
of the bank would become chaotic and unmanageable. Each
officer of the bank cannot be allowed to carve out his own little
empire
wherein
he
dispenses
favours
and
largesse
No
organisation, more particularly, a bank can function properly and
effectively if its officers and employees do not observe the
prescribed norms and discipline. Such indiscipline cannot be
condoned on the specious ground that it was not actuated by
ulterior motives or by extraneous considerations. The very act of
acting beyond authority - that too a course of conduct spread
over a sufficiently long period and involving innumerable
instances - is by itself a misconduct. Such acts, if permitted, may
bring in profit in some cases but they may also lead to huge
losses. Such adventures are not given to the employees of banks
which deal with public funds. It What we hear about the reasons
for the collapse of Barings Bank is true, it is attributable to the
acts of one of its employees, Nick Leeson, a minor officer
stationed at Singapore, who was allowed by his superiors to act
far beyond his authority. As mentioned hereinbefore, the very
discipline of an organisation and more particularly, a bank is
dependent upon each of its employees and officers acting and
operating within their allotted sphere. Acting beyond one's
authority is by itself a breach of discipline and a breach of
LPA No. 136/2025
Regulation 3. It constitutes misconduct within the meaning of
Regulation 24. No further proof of loss is really necessary though
as a matter of fact, in this case there are findings that several
advances and overdrawals allowed by the respondent beyond his
authority have become sticky and irrecoverable. Just because,
similar acts have fetched some profit - huge profit, as the High
court characterises. it - they are no less blameworthy. It is wrong
to characterise them as errors of judgment..........”
9.2.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chairman & Managing Director, United
Commercial Bank & Ors. vs. P.C. Kakkar; 2003 AIR (SC) 1571,
made it clear that a bank employee who is guilty of financial irregularities
with public money does not deserve any leniency.
9.3.
Again, Supreme Court in Divisional Controller, KSRTC (NWKRTC)
vs. A.T. Mane; 2004 AIR(SC) 4761, commenting upon the quantum of
punishment in such cases observed that it is not the amount of money
misappropriated which is a factor for awarding punishment, but it is the
loss of confidence which is the prime factor to be taken into
consideration.
9.4.
Relevant observation contained in para 12 reads as below:“12. Coming to the question of quantum of punishment, one
should bear in mind the fact that it is not the amount of money
misappropriated that becomes a primary factor for awarding
punishment, on the contrary, it is the loss of confidence which is
the primary factor to the taken into consideration. In our opinion,
when a person is found guilty of misappropriating corporation's
fund, there is nothing wrong in the corporation losing confidence
or faith in such a person and awarding a punishment of
dismissal.”
SCOPE OF JUDICIAL REVIEW
10.
The scope of judicial review in the matter of quantum of punishment
imposed upon a bank employee has vexed the Courts more often than not and
LPA No. 136/2025
has been subject matter of consideration in various decisions of Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
10.1. In Damoh Panna Sagar Rural Regional Bank vs. Munna Lal Jain;
2005 AIR (SC) 584, in which the delinquent Bank officer subsequently
informed the Head office about his misconduct and deposited back the amount
unauthorisedly withdrawn by him for his own use, it was held that Court cannot
interfere with the quantum of punishment imposed upon a bank employee
unless it is found to be shockingly disproportionate and to hold that punishment
shocks the conscience of the Court, sufficient reasons are required to be
recorded by a speaking order. Carrying the enunciation further, pertinently,
Supreme Court ruled that the mere fact that a bank officer later informed the
Head Office and deposited back the amount unauthorisedly withdrawn by him
for his own use and benefit does not absolve him.
10.2. Relevant abstract of the judgment contained in para 17, reads as below:“17.A Bank officer is required to exercise higher standards of
honesty and integrity. He deals with money of the depositors and
the customers. Every officer/employee of the Bank is required to
take all possible steps to protect the interests of the Bank and to
discharge his duties with utmost integrity, honesty, devotion and
diligence and to do nothing which is unbecoming of a Bank
officer. Good conduct and discipline are inseparable from the
functioning of every officer/employee of the Bank. As was
observed by this Court in Disciplinary Authority-cum-Regional
Manager v. Nikunja Bihari Patnaik, 1996(2) SCT 760 (SC): (1996
(9) SCC 69), it is no defence available to say that there was no
loss or profit resulted in case, when the officer/employee acted
without authority. The very discipline of an organisation more
particularly a Bank is dependent upon each of its officers and
officers acting and operating within their allotted sphere. Acting
beyond one's authority is by itself a breach of discipline and is a
misconduct. The charges against the employee were not casual
in nature and were serious. These aspects do not appear to have
been kept in view by the High Court.”
LPA No. 136/2025
10.3. Again, Supreme Court in State Bank of India & Ors. vs. Ramesh
Dinkar Punde; 2006(7) SCC 212, held that it is not permissible for the High
Court to re-appreciate the evidence which has been considered by the Inquiry
Officer, the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority. It was held that
if there was an inquiry consistent with the rules and principles of natural justice,
what punishment would meet the ends of justice is a matter within the exclusive
domain of the competent authority.
10.4. Relevant observation in Para 06 of the judgment reads as below:“6. Before we proceed further, we may observe at this stage that
it is unfortunate that the High Court has acted as an appellate
authority despite the consistent view taken by this Court that the
High Court and the Tribunal while exercising the judicial review
do not act as an appellate authority. Its jurisdiction is
circumscribed and confined to correct errors of law or procedural
error, if any, resulting in manifest miscarriage of justice or
violation of principles of natural justice. Judicial review is not
akin to adjudication on merit by re-appreciating the evidence as
an Appellate Authority. (See Govt. of A.P. and Ors. (appellant) v.
Mohd. Nasrullah Khan (respondent) (2006) 2 SCC 373 at page
SCC 379.”
10.5. Again, Supreme Court, in Bank of India vs. T. Jogram;2007(7) SCC
236, ruled that High Court cannot sit in appeal over the findings recorded by the
Inquiry Officer and assume the role of the Appellate Authority.
11.
The common thread running through afore-quoted decisions of the Apex
Court is that scope of judicial review in matters relating to quantum of
punishment to Bank employees is very limited. Court can interfere with the
findings of the competent authority and the appellate authority only if
punishment is shockingly disproportionate and it no longer res integra now that
in the banking sector, the very act of acting beyond one’s delegated authority by
itself constitutes a gross breach of discipline and misconduct. The absence of
LPA No. 136/2025
actual financial loss or the fact that Bank earned a profit does not absolve the
employee because Banks deal with public money and procedural discipline must
be absolute.
FINDINGS
12.
Back to the case on hand, learned Single Judge has quashed both the
orders; of the competent authority and that of Appellate Authority on the ground
that appellant-Bank has not suffered any financial loss on account of acts of
omission and commission alleged against the respondent; said acts were neither
tainted by mala fide intentions nor respondent derive any pecuniary gain
therefrom; and most of the irregularities had been rectified by him.
12.1. If the present case is approached in the light of principles of law
enunciated by the Apex Court, we have no doubt in our mind that learned Single
Judge has failed to appreciate the controversy in its correct perspective and
embarked upon judicial review of the findings recorded by the competent
authority and the appellate authority as a Court of appeal, which is not
countenanced in law.
12.2. Charge against the respondent is that while working as a Branch Head,
he extended undue favor and sanctioned loans to selected borrowers by
misusing his official position and in violation of the operational guidelines and
norms of the Bank. Though, respondent opposed the charge-sheet by contending
that during his tenure as Senior Manager of Branch Office Simble Morh,
business of the branch had increased from Rs. 28.90 crores to 54 crores and
NPA was reduced from Rs. 12.37% to 3.51% and branch, which was running in
loss of Rs. 10.47 crores, was brought to a profit of Rs. 34.40 lakhs, but during
the course of disciplinary inquiry he admitted his misconduct while discharging
his duties as Branch Head of the Bank. It also surfaced that act of omission and
LPA No. 136/2025
commission on the part of the respondent was not an exception but he had
already been charge-sheeted and punished twice during his service career for
various acts of omission and commission.
12.3. Be that as it may, a perusal of the record reveals that out of the loans
stated to have been sanctioned by the respondent, the appellant-Bank has been
made to settle 24 accounts under OTS scheme, while 10 accounts were declared
non-performing assets, recovery in the remaining 14 accounts is stuck and is
likely to be declared NPA.
13.
Mr. Abhimanyu Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent, has relied
upon Inspector Prem Chand vs. Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi & Ors.; 2007 (4)
SCC 566, to submit that, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present
case, acts of negligence or innocent mistakes on the part of the respondent
would not constitute misconduct.
13.1. In departmental disciplinary proceedings, the presence of mens rea is not
a prerequisite to prove misconduct of an employee. An unauthorised act, even if
committed with good intentions, is still a violation of the service rules. As
analysed in the afore-quoted judgments involving public sector Banks, officers
are strictly mandated to protect the interests of the Bank within the permitted
limits. Any unauthorised sanctioning of credit or crossing the financial limits
automatically triggers the liability. Supreme Court has explicitly noted that
discipline of a banking organisation depends entirely upon its employees and
officers, who are supposed to perform their official duties strictly within their
allotted sphere, because banks operate as fiduciaries, handling public deposits,
and their employees and officials are held to a higher standard of institutional
honesty, uprightness and procedural compliance than the employees of other
commercial sectors. The act of a bank employee exceeding his authority by
LPA No. 136/2025
itself would constitute serious misconduct, even if Bank suffered no financial
loss or made a profit and the employee acted without malice or ulterior motives.
In other words, the absence of actual financial loss or the fact that Bank earned a
profit would not absolve the employee of the Bank, because the absence of
malice or mens rea in departmental proceedings is irrelevant.
13.2. It is not and cannot be the case of the respondent that being a Senior
Manager or a Class-I Officer he was not aware of the limits of his authority. As
a matter of fact, during the course disciplinary inquiry, he admitted misconduct
on his part and it was brought to the notice of the Inquiry Officer that
respondent had already been charge-sheeted and penalized twice during his
service career for various acts of omission and commission. Thus, the
misconduct on the part of the respondent, we have no doubt in our mind, is
unpardonable.
14.
It may be recalled, though at the cost of brevity, that aggrieved of the
findings of the competent authority dated 23.05.2022, whereby penalty of
reducing him to the lowest stage in the pay-scale of Officer Scale-II was
imposed, he preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority/Board of
Directors-respondent no. 2. During the appeal proceedings, the respondent not
only admitted misconduct on his part while acting as Branch Head, but also
prayed for a lenient view in his favor and the findings of the competent
authority came to be modified by the appellant authority by providing that basic
pay of the respondent is reduced to the lowest stage (1st stage of pay i.e., Rs.
48,170/-) in the pay scale of Officer Scale-I instead of Officer Scale-II, as
imposed by the competent authority. In addition to the reduction of the pay scale
of Officer Scale-I, the appellate authority also directed that his superannuation
benefits on the reduced pay shall be released only after smooth
LPA No. 136/2025
recovery/adjustment of all the loan accounts mentioned in the charge-sheet, with
a further stipulation that till such time, the withheld amount under reference
shall be kept in the shape of FDR under lien to the Chairman of the Bank and
respondent was directed to extend his best cooperation to the Bank in effecting
smooth recovery/adjustment of the loan accounts and that, in case Bank suffers
any financial loss in respect of such loans, same shall be recovered from his
monthly pension and family pension.
15.
The only question for consideration of this Court in the circumstances of
the present case is whether withholding of superannuation benefits of the
respondent by the appellate authority till recovery/adjustment of the loan
accounts is justified and permissible in law.
15.1. Mr. Abhimanyu Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent, has relied
upon Jyotirmay Ray vs. The Field General Manager, Punjab National Bank
& Ors; 2023 A4 SCR 2346, T.B. Mohanan vs. Canara Bank & Ors (writ
petition no. 16934/2021 decided on 09.09.2022 and UCO Bank & Ors. vs.
Anju Mathur; 2013 SCC (Online) 5014, to submit that forfeiture of gratuity
provident fund and pensionary benefits of a bank employee in the absence of
quantification of loss and opportunity of hearing is not permissible in law.
15.2. There cannot be two opinions to the settled position of law that forfeiture
of superannuation benefits can be directed to the extent of damage or loss so
caused or destruction of property belonging to the Bank and, whenever
forfeiture of such benefits is ordered, there has to be quantification of loss and
an opportunity of hearing must be given to the employee.
15.3. Neither the competent authority nor the appellate authority in the present
case has quantified the loss caused to the Bank. Therefore, superannuation
benefits of the respondent cannot be withheld till the recovery of the loan
LPA No. 136/2025
accounts mentioned in the charge-sheet because appellant Bank has an
efficacious alternative remedy to recover the loan amounts against the
borrowers by filing recovery suits.
ORDER
16.
For what has been observed and discussed above, present appeal is
allowed and impugned order passed by learned Single Judge is set-aside.
Consequently, while order passed by the appellate authority regarding reduction
of the respondent to the lowest stage (1st stage of pay, i.e., Rs. 48,170/-) in the
pay scale of Officer Scale-I is upheld, the said order withholding superannuation
benefits of the respondent is set-aside. Appellants are directed to immediately
release superannuation benefits of the respondent, however they shall be at
liberty to recover the loan amounts by availing the appropriate remedy.
17.
Disposed of.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
(Sindhu Sharma)
Judge
JAMMU
18.08.2026.
Abinash
Whether the judgment is speaking? Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable? Yes
LPA No. 136/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review