The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. 11.2018 within three days. Thereafter, the petitioner approached the District Magistrate & Collector asking for the same relief as granted by the order dated 15.11.2018, but no order was passed on the said application filed before the District Magistrate & Collector. Mr. D Sharma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the respondents have stated that the respondents No.10-15 are squatting over the government land for about 50 years. However, having received the complaint, SDM, Sonamura did a field inquiry through the competent surveyors led by the Tahshildar. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sonamura in his affidavit has admitted that the structures on the Public Works Department’s land are still there but “a reasonable time will be required to dispose of the matter, so that no law and order problem arises in that area”. From that statement it appears that SDM is actively considering the proper action as regards the complaint filed by the petitioner. That apart, with the reply filed by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Sonamura, a copy of the inquiry report dated 19.09.2019 (Annexure A to the reply) has been placed before this court. From such reply, it appears that the petitioner purchased his land from one Shahjahan Miah in the year 2016 and he got that land mutated in his favour. Before purchasing the said piece of land, the respondents No.10-15 were occupying the said land and were doin…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 647 of 2021
Ismail Miah
…………Petitioner
Vs.
The State of Tripura & 14 Ors.
………..Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
: Ms. S Deb (Gupta), Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D Sharma, Addl. GA.
Mr. S Bhattacharjee, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
06.04.2022
Heard Ms. S Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner as well as Mr. D Sharma, learned Addl. GA
appearing for the respondents No.1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8 & 9 and Mr. S
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
No.10-15.
The petitioner has a residential plot of land pertaining to
Khatian No.1474, Plot No.1629/7135 measuring 0.08 acre
within Mouja – NC Nagar, Sub Division-Sonamura. The said land
is situated along the Sonamura - Baxonagar road. After his land,
there is a drain and thereafter, the land of the Public Works
Department
constructed.
on
which
indisputably
the
road
has
been
The grievance of the petitioner is that the respondents No.
10-15 have illegally put up structure on the government land
and the jote land of the petitioner. That apart, they have
dumped the waste materials into the drain causing emission of
foul smell from the said waste. The petitioner had approached
Sonamura Nagar Panchayet for restraining the respondent
No.10 in particular from constructing his shop with the RCC
pillar over the government land.
Ms.
Deb
Gupta,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner has taken this court to the order dated 15.11.2018
passed by the SDM, Sonamura in Misc./2018 under reference
No.4(3)/SDM/SNM/REV./2017/1295 (Annexure-9 to the writ
petition). For purpose of reference, the relevant part of the said
order is extracted hereunder:
“First party claimed that in addition to the
shops located in the PWD land there are some
shops located in his Jote land and also corners
of the shops are depositing waste materials into
the drain and creating foul smell making life
unbearable.
Second party submitted that they are
occupying the PWD land for the last 50 years
without creating any trouble to the nearby
residents. And also submitted if PWD requires
the land they will remove their shops from the
said land.
It is hereby ordered that the second
shall remove any type constructing temporary or
permanent located in the Jote land of the first
party within three days of this order and also
the second shall restrained from dumping waste
into the drain and if there is ny permanent
construction such RCC Pillar located in the PWD
land shall be removed by the second party
within three days of this order. DCM Sonamura
is hereby ordered to verify the execution of the
order after three days and during the
verification if anything seen objectionable to the
order shall be removed. The cost of removal
shall be borne, in that condition, that
circumstances by the second parties.”
Ms. Deb Gupta, learned counsel has further submitted that
despite the said order the respondents No.10-15 did not stop
dumping the noxious materials in to the drain and even they did
not remove the RCC Pillar erected on the land of PWD. The
private respondents were supposed to act on the order dated
15.11.2018
within
three
days.
Thereafter,
the
petitioner
approached the District Magistrate & Collector asking for the
same relief as granted by the order dated 15.11.2018, but no
order was passed on the said application filed before the District
Magistrate & Collector.
Mr. D Sharma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the
respondents have stated that the respondents No.10-15 are
squatting over the government land for about 50 years.
However, having received the complaint, SDM, Sonamura did a
field inquiry through the competent surveyors led by the
Tahshildar. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sonamura in his
affidavit has admitted that the structures on the Public Works
Department’s land are still there but “a reasonable time will be
required to dispose of the matter, so that no law and order
problem arises in that area”.
From that statement it appears that SDM is actively
considering the proper action as regards the complaint filed by
the petitioner. That apart, with the reply filed by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Sonamura, a copy of the inquiry report
dated 19.09.2019 (Annexure A to the reply) has been placed
before this court. From such reply, it appears that the petitioner
purchased his land from one Shahjahan Miah in the year 2016
and he got that land mutated in his favour. Before purchasing
the
said
piece
of
land,
the
respondents
No.10-15
were
occupying the said land and were doing their business. It has
been further stated that from the piece of land as donated by
Shahjahan Miah, the said drain was excavated and constructed.
The shops are built in front of the said drain and the land on
which the shops were situated are recorded in the name of
Public Works Department, Government of Tripura.
It has been significantly observed that the petitioner has
the alternative entrance from the southern side of the piece of
land where the PWD road is passing over. With this report, a
hand sketch map showing the entrance from the petitioner’s
land has been placed.
The respondents No.10-15 have filed a separate reply and
they have stated that the order dated 15.11.2018 has been
passed after giving them the opportunity of hearing. Thereafter,
SDM, Sonamura has caused an inquiry and found that the
respondents No.10-15 have never encroached any part of the
land of the petitioner. The respondents No.10-15 have got the
valid Trade Licence and they are also enjoying the electricity
provided by the Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited.
According to those respondents, the entire action taken by the
petitioner is mala fide, as those respondents are not creating
any nuisance or obstruction in utilizing the residential land of
the petitioner.
Mr. Sharma, learned Addl. GA has added that the SubDivisional Magistrate has been examining all alternatives and no
action is being taken in hurry as that may cause break-down of
law and order situation in that area.
Mr. S Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the respondents
No.10-15 has quite solemnly made an undertaking before this
court that the respondents No.10-15 will not dump any
material, noxious or otherwise, into the drain and they will abide
by the order of SDM, Sonamura dated 15.11.2018.
In the rejoinder, Ms. Deb Gupta, learned counsel has
submitted
that
the
entry
from
the
residential
house
is
obstructed for those shops and those are required to be
removed.
It appears that the order dated 15.11.2018 has been
passed under the authority of provision of Section 133 of the
Cr.PC in order to relegate the nuisance.
As Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents No.10-15 has made the undertaking that those
respondents will abide the order dated 15.11.2018, SDM,
Sonamura is directed to verify whether the undertaking that has
been given for and on behalf of the respondents No.10-15, is
being observed by them. Otherwise, the SDM may take the
appropriate action against those respondents.
While making the undertaking, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel has made a qualified statement that none of the
respondents No.10-15 has constructed any RCC Building or RCC
Pillar over the PWD land and according to them, the petitioner
has constructed an RCC Pillar over his jote land.
Having appreciated the submissions made by the counsel
for the parties, this court is of the view that if the petitioner has
any difficulty as regards the construction of any RCC Pillar over
his jote land, then this court cannot adjudicate that issue and in
that event, the petitioner will have to approach the civil court of
the competent jurisdiction for eviction of the person who is
responsible for encroachment or for construction of the RCC
Pillar.
So far the public nuisance as allegedly caused by the
respondents No.10-15 by dumping the noxious and other
materials over the drain is concerned, the competent authority,
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sonamura has passed the order
dated 15.11.2018 (Annexure 9 to the writ petition) for its
mitigation.
None of the counsel for the parties have raised any
objection against the said order. Even it has been reported from
the bar that no appeal or challenge has been carried forward by
any party against the said order and that is the reason why the
SDM, Sonamura has been asked to verify and ensure the
compliance of the order dated 15.11.2018. For that, this court is
not required to pass any fresh order inasmuch as, SDM,
Sonamura has made a statement in his reply that for eviction of
the illegal squatters over the PWD land, the appropriate action
will be taken.
Be that as it may, the petitioner cannot ask this court for
passing any order for
eviction
of the occupants of the
government land inasmuch as, the appropriate jurisdiction has
been carved out for that purpose. The petitioner, if aggrieved,
may approach the said authority for drawing up proceeding for
eviction of illegal occupants.
So far the issue of ingress and egress is concerned, this
court is persuaded to observe that from the report of SDM,
Sonamura what can be gathered is that when the petitioner had
purchased the said land, the respondents No.10-15 were over
the said land. So the petitioner was quite aware of the
difficulties that he might face for purchasing the said land but
the petitioner had taken an informed decision while purchasing
the said land.
However, this observation will not create any embargo for
the petitioner to take appropriate action that will be available to
him for any remedy.
With these observations, this writ petition stands disposed
of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
satabdi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review