The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. Accordingly, the substantial question of law is answered in the ‘affirmative’, holding that the confirmed tenancy rights granted in favour of defendant No.1 would enure to the benefit of the joint family, and furthermore, by virtue of Ex.P1memorandum of partition, the entire property was allotted to the share of Agasar Kristappa. Thus, the alienation made by defendant No.1 in favour of defendant No.2 is illegal, unauthorized and without competency. The suit is therefore liable to be decreed by declaring that the plaintiffs are the owners of the suit schedule land. Consequently, the judgments and decrees passed by both the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court are liable to be set aside.
22. Hence, I pass the following: a) The appeal is allowed; b) The judgment and decree passed in R.A.No.99/2008 dated 22.04.2009 on the file of Principal Civil Judge (Sr.Dn) and CJM, Ballari, as well as the judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.106/2006 dated 25.06.2008 on the file of Civil Judge (Jr.Dn), Siraguppa, are set aside; - 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:194 RSA No. 5497 of 2009 HC-KAR c) The registered Sale Deed dated 30.07.2002 is declared null and void, and consequently, the plaintiffs are declared as owners of the suit schedule land; d) Defendant No.2 is directed to handover vacant possession of the suit schedule land to the plaintiffs; e) No order as to costs. Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR) PMP /CT-AN List No.: 1 Sl No.: 31
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 8TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 5497 OF 2009 (DEC)
BETWEEN:
1.
ISHWARAMMA W/O. AGASAR KRISTAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS.
2.
MINOR LAXMI D/O. AGASAR KRISTAPPA,
AGE: 17 YEARS.
3.
MINOR RAMESH S/O. AGASAR KRISTAPPA,
AGE: 09 YEARS.
4.
MALLIKARJUN
RUDRAYYA
KALMATH
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
MINOR ERAMMA D/O. AGASAR KRISTAPPA,
AGE: 06 YEARS,
ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF MUDDATANUR VILLAGE,
SIRUGUPPA TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT-583120,
(APPELLANT NOS.2 TO 4 ARE THE MINORS,
APPELLANT NO.1 IS THE MOTHER AS
NATURAL GURADIAN)
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI GODE NAGARAJA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
2.
AGASARA VENKOBAPPA S/O. ERANNA,
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS.
YELLAPPA S/O. KURUBAR KALASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
BOTH ARE AGRICULTURIST,
BOTH ARE RESIDENT OF MUDDATANUR VILLAGE,
SIRUGUPPA TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT-583120.
…RESPONDENTS
(NOTICE TO R1 SERVED; NOTICE TO R2 HELD SUFFICIENT)
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
100 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE
RECORDS AND SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED
22.04.2009 PASSED BY THE PRIL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN) AND
CJM BELLARY, IN R.A.NO.99/2008 AND THE JUDGMENT AND
DECREE DATED 25.06.2008 PASSED BY THE CIVIL JUDGE
(JR.DN) SIRUGUPPA IN O.S.NO.106/2006 AND ALLOW THE
APPEAL BY DECREEING THE SUIT FILED BY THE APPELLANTS.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER AGRUMENT,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
This Regular Second Appeal is filed by the plaintiffs
challenging the judgment and decree passed in R.A.No.99/2008
dated 22.04.2009 on the file of Principal Civil Judge (Sr.Dn) and
CJM, Bellary1, as well as the judgment and decree passed in
O.S.No.106/2006 dated 25.06.2008 on the file of Civil Judge
(Jr.Dn), Siraguppa2. By the said judgments, the suit filed by the
plaintiffs for declaration and possession was dismissed by the
Trial Court, and the same was confirmed by the First Appellate
Court.
2.
Being aggrieved by the same, the plaintiffs have
preferred the present appeal.
Hereinafter referred to as, ‘the First Appellate Court’
Hereinafter referred to as ‘the Trial Court’
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
3.
For the purpose of convenience, ranking of the parties
is referred to as per their status before the Trial Court.
4.
The plaintiffs have filed a suit for declaration and
possession, declaring that they are the owners of the suit
schedule property. One Agasar Kristappa is the husband of
plaintiff No.1, father of plaintiffs No.2 to 4 and son of defendant
No.1. Defendant No.1 had filed an application in Form No.7
before
the
Land
Tribunal,
Siruguppa.
The
Land
Tribunal,
Siruguppa, granted occupancy rights as per Ex.P2 in favour of
defendant No.1.
5.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that grant of land was
enure to the benefit of the joint family consisting of Agasar
Kristappa and defendant No.1. Defendant No.1 executed a family
settlement deed/partition deed, bequeathing the entire suit
schedule property in favour of Agasar Kristappa. Consequently,
upon the death of Agasar Kristappa, the plaintiffs, by way of
inheritance, have become the owners of the suit property. When
this being the fact, defendant No.1 had no authority or
competency to sell the suit schedule land to the extent of 01 acre
out of 02 acres 20 guntas. Hence, the plaintiffs have filed the
present suit for declaration and possession.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
6.
It is the case of defendants that defendant No.2 filed
written statement supporting the case of the plaintiffs by stating
that there is no valid conveyance.
7.
Defendant No.2 has filed written statement by taking
pleadings that defendant No.1 is the absolute owner of the suit
schedule land, and has sold the suit schedule land through
registered Sale Deed dated 30.07.2002. Further, grant of land
measuring 2 acres 20 guntas is an inheritable benefit to the joint
family. Thus, it enures to the benefit of defendant No.1 and
Agasar Kristappa. As well, defendant No.1 was having half share
in the suit schedule land, therefore had executed Sale Deed in
favour of defendant No.2 to the extent of 01 acre only.
Therefore, defendant No.2 is the bonafide purchaser, hence,
prays to dismiss the suit.
8.
The Trial Court dismissed the suit on the reason that
the plaintiffs failed to prove their ownership over the suit
schedule land under the final settlement deed/partition deed
dated 08.08.1999. It is held that the Sale Deed executed by
defendant
No.1
in
favour
of
defendant
No.2
is
valid.
Consequently, the suit was dismissed. The First Appellate Court
confirmed the judgment and decree of the Trial Court, holding
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
that though Ex.P1 is described as settlement deed, but virtually it
is relinquishment deed. Since Ex.P1-relinquishment deed is
unregistered, it does not convey any right, title or interest in
favour of Agasar Kristappa. Therefore, the land granted by land
Tribunal continued to remain joint family property, in which,
defendant No.1 held half share. Accordingly, defendant No.1 was
competent to execute Sale Deed in favour of defendant No.2.
Therefore, the First Appellate Court dismissed the appeal,
thereby confirmed the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court.
9.
Upon the concurrent finding of both the Courts, the
plaintiffs have preferred the present appeal.
10.
This Court, on 12.02.2014, while admitting the appeal,
has framed the following substantial question of law:
i. Whether the trial Court as well as the First
Appellate Court have committed a serious error in
ignoring the fact that, the conferment of tenancy
right in favour of the first defendant is enure to
the benefit of joint family and therefore, judgment
of the Courts below are perverse and illegal?
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
11.
Learned counsel appearing for the plaintiffs/appellants
submitted that there was a partition in the joint family, and in
the said partition, the suit schedule land to the extent of 02 acres
20 guntas fell to the share of Agasar Kristappa, who is the
husband of plaintiff No.1 and the father of plaintiffs No.2 to 4.
Since the entire land was allotted to the share of Agasar
Kristappa, he became absolute owner of the said extent. It was
further contended that defendant No.1, despite having no any
right or ownership over the suit schedule property, executed a
Sale Deed in favour of defendant No.2.
12.
Both the Courts have erroneously held that the said
document to be the relinquishment deed. But upon perusing the
recitals involved in the case, it is a partition deed but not a
relinquishment deed. By virtue of the partition, Agasar Kristappa
has become owner of the entire extent of 02 acres 20 guntas of
suit schedule land. Consequently, the Sale Deed made by
defendant No.1 in favour of defendant No.2 is without authority
or competency and does not convey any valid title. Therefore,
the plaintiffs have title over the suit schedule land. Hence, the
learned counsel for the appellants/plaintiffs prays to decree the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
suit by declaring that the plaintiffs are the owners of suit
schedule land.
13.
Notice was issued to the respondents; however they
remained absent. Accordingly, there is no representation on
behalf of respondents.
14.
Ex.P2 is the order passed by the land Tribunal,
Siruguppa, dated 25.09.1980, under which occupancy rights
were granted in favour of defendant No.1. Thus, defendant No.1
became owner of the suit schedule land. This fact is not disputed
by defendant No.2. It is also not in dispute that the husband of
plaintiff No.1 and father of plaintiffs No.2 to 4, namely Agasar
Kristappa, is the son of defendant No.1. In view of these
admitted facts, the question that arises for consideration is
whether defendant No.1 had exclusive right to alienate the suit
schedule land.
15.
Defendant No.2 has contended in the pleadings and
evidence that Agasar Kristappa, the husband of plaintiff No.1 and
father of plaintiffs No.2 to 4, had left the village and house long
ago and that his whereabouts are not known. On that basis, it is
contended that the plaintiffs have failed to establish whether
Agasar Kristappa is alive or residing elsewhere. Defendant No.2
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
claims to be a bonafide purchaser of the suit schedule land to the
extent of 01 acre from defendant No.1, after verifying that
defendant No.1 was the absolute owner of the property. It is also
contended that defendant No.2 has developed the land by
spending a considerable amount.
16.
However, the fact to be considered is that once
defendant No.1 and his son became joint owners of the suit
schedule land, and the land would enure to the benefit of the
joint family, the competency of defendant No.1 alone to alienate
the property becomes questionable. The plaintiffs rely on Ex.P1,
documents. It is the case of plaintiffs that on 08.08.1999
partition took place in the family, and the land bearing
Sy.No.422A to the extent of 02 acres 20 guntas was allotted to
Agasar Kristappa, thereby making him exclusive owner of the
said land. If Agasar Kristappa became exclusive owner of the
property on 08.08.1999, then the alienation made by defendant
No.1 in favour of defendant No.2 is questionable. Both the Courts
have
held that Ex.P1
is a
relinquishment
deed requiring
compulsory registration and that since it is unregistered, there
was no valid conveyance in favour of Agasar Kristappa. Hence, it
was held that the property continued to be jointly owned by
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
defendant No.1 and Agasar Kristappa, and that defendant No.1
had half share out of 02 acres 20 guntas, which entitled him to
sell 01 acre of land in favour of defendant No.2.
17.
With these observations, both the trial Court and the
First Appellate Court interpreted Ex.P1 as relinquishment deed.
Undoubtedly,
a
relinquishment
deed
requires
compulsory
registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, 1908.
However,
the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellants/plaintiffs contended that Ex.P1 is not a relinquishment
deed, but a memorandum of partition.
18.
evident
Therefore, upon considering the recitals in Ex.P1, it is
that
the
document
clearly
records
a
partition
of
properties between defendant No.1 and Agasar Kristappa, or in
other words, it is a family settlement deed. The words used in
the said Ex.P1 document is “D¹ÛAiÀÄ ¥Á®Ä «¨sÁUÀ ¥ÀvæÀªÉãÉAzÀgÉ F ¢ªÀ¸À
£À£ÀUÀÆ £ÀªÀÄä ªÀÄUÀ£ÁzÀ PÀȵÀÖ¥Àà¤UÀÆ PÀÆrPÉÆAqÀÄ EgÀ®Ä ¸Àj ¨ÁgÀzÀ PÁgÀt £À£ßÀ ¸ÀéAvÀ
¸ÀA¥ÁzÀ£É¬ÄAzÀ ¸ÀA¥Á¢¹zÀ F PɼÀPÀAqÀ µÉqÀÆå¯Á¹ÛAiÀÄ£ÀÄß FvÀ¤UÉ ¸ÀéAvÀ ºÀPÄÀ Ì PÉÆlÄÖ
¨ÉÃgÉ fêÀ£À ªÀiÁrPÉÆArgÀ®Ä ©lÄÖPÉÆnÖgÀÄvÉÛãÉ.” In the first paragraph and
also in the second paragraph at last line, the wordings used are
“JgÀqÀÄ JPÀgÉ E¥ÀàvÀÄÛ ¸ÉAmïì ¨sÀÆ«ÄUÉ F ¢£À¢AzÀ zÁ£À «PÀæAiÀiÁ¢ ¸ÀªÄÀ ¸ÀÛ ºÀPÄÀ ÌUÀ½UÉ
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
¤Ã£ÀÄ ¤£Àß ªÁgÀ¸ÀQèÁzsÀågÀÄ. »UÉAzÀÄ £À£Àß ¸ÀéAvÀ ªÀÄ£À¹ì¤AzÀ §gɬĹPÉÆlÖ D¹ÛAiÀÄ
¥Á®Ä «¨sÁUÀ zÀ¸ÁÛªÉÃdÄ ¸À».”
19.
Thus, Ex.P1 is a record or memorandum evidencing a
completed partition and does not itself effect transfer of rights.
Both the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court have failed to
correctly appreciate the true matter of Ex.P1 document. By virtue
of this partition, the granted land fell to the exclusive share of
Agasar Kristappa, who is the husband of plaintiff No.1 and father
of plaintiffs No.2 to 4.
20.
Once defendant No.1 lost his authority and ownership
over the suit schedule land by virtue of Ex.P1, he had no
competency to execute registered Sale Deed in favour of
defendant No.2. Therefore, the Sale Deed executed by defendant
No.1 in favour of defendant No.2 is invalid, as it was executed
without authority or title. Consequently, there is no valid
conveyance of 01 acre of land in favour of defendant No.2. In
this view of the matter, both the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court have committed error. Hence, defendant No.2
cannot be stated to be a bonafide purchaser.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
21.
Accordingly,
the
substantial
question
of
law
is
answered in the ‘affirmative’, holding that the confirmed tenancy
rights granted in favour of defendant No.1 would enure to the
benefit of the joint family, and furthermore, by virtue of Ex.P1memorandum of partition, the entire property was allotted to the
share of Agasar Kristappa. Thus, the alienation made by
defendant
No.1
in
favour
of
defendant
No.2
is
illegal,
unauthorized and without competency. The suit is therefore liable
to be decreed by declaring that the plaintiffs are the owners of
the suit schedule land. Consequently, the judgments and decrees
passed by both the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court are
liable to be set aside.
22.
Hence, I pass the following:
ORDER
a) The appeal is allowed;
b) The
judgment
and
decree
passed
in
R.A.No.99/2008 dated 22.04.2009 on the file of
Principal Civil Judge (Sr.Dn) and CJM, Ballari, as
well as the judgment and decree passed in
O.S.No.106/2006 dated 25.06.2008 on the file of
Civil Judge (Jr.Dn), Siraguppa, are set aside;
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:194
RSA No. 5497 of 2009
HC-KAR
c) The registered Sale Deed dated 30.07.2002 is
declared null and void, and consequently, the
plaintiffs are declared as owners of the suit
schedule land;
d) Defendant No.2 is directed to handover vacant
possession of the suit schedule land to the
plaintiffs;
e) No order as to costs.
Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE
PMP /CT-AN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review