Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.415 of 2024
Irrity Spices, represented by its Manager, Shri Kripesh Debnath, S/o Late
Narendra Debnath, having office at Suryamaninagar, Agartala-Udaipur Road,
P.O. Tripura University, West Tripura
………Petitioner(s);
Versus
1. Tripura Rehabilitation & Plantation Corporation Limited (A Government of
Tripura undertaking) represented by its Managing Director, having office at 1 st
floor of Humkhry Nubyung Complex, Pundit Nehru Complex, Pin-799006,
Agartala, West Tripura
2. Assistant Manager (Marketing), Tripura Rehabilitation & Plantation
Corporation Limited having office at 1 st floor of Humkhry Nubyung Complex,
Pundit Nehru Complex, Pin-799006, Agartala, West Tripura
3. State of Tripura represented by Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Forest Department, having its office at Civil Secretariat, Agartala, P.O
Kunjaban, District-West Tripura
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate,
Mr. Tapas Halam, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Order
18/09/2024
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
and Mr. D. Sharma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
respondents-State.
2.
This is the second round of writ petition at the behest of the writ
petitioner with a prayer to command the respondents No.1 & 2 to reissue
delivery challan for lifting remaining quantity of rubber sheets of various
grades pursuant to sale order dated 22.12.2023 relying upon the order dated
13.03.2024 passed in WP(C) No.10 of 2024 and the interim order dated
10.01.2024 passed therein.
3.
Petitioner, in this writ petition, has alleged violation of interim
order dated 10.01.2024 and deliberate suppression of fact relating to refund of
Rs.86,39,100/- said to have been made on 05.01.2024 before passing of the
interim order on 10.01.2024 whereby the respondents were restrained from
issuing delivery orders in respect of the remaining quantum of the specified
category of graded rubber sheets as per the sale order dated 22.12.2023. Writ
petitioner has filed copy of the bank transaction for the month of January, 2024
to show that the remittance of the amount of Rs.86,39,100/- actually took place
on 11.01.2024.
4.
Respondents No.1 & 2 have filed a Counter Affidavit in order to
traverse the allegations made. The relevant stand of the respondents is at
paragraphs 9, 11, 12 & 14 which are being extracted hereunder:
“9. That, in regards to the statement made in paragraph 7 of the writ Petition it is
stated that averments are denied and disputed by the answering respondents. A
Copy of sale order cancellation dated 28-12-2023 was received by the petitioner
on 05-01-2024. And a copy of the same was also sent through registered post on
06-01-2024, token no.EE437621088IN IVR:6969437621088 to the petitioner.
A Copy of the cancellation letter dated 28-12-2023 and postal receipt dated 0601-2024 is annexed and marked as Annexure R/1.
11. That, in regard to the statements made in paragraph 12 of the writ petition, it
is stated that averments are denied and disputed. For remaining lots of rubber retendered on 29-12-23, which was opened on 06-01-2024 and sale order for which
was issued on 08-01-2024. This happened before Hon'ble high court passed
interim stay of delivery of remaining quantity and it was required to be disposed
immediately to safeguard corporation's financial loss considering the perishable
nature of rubber sheet.
It was already proposed and approved on 30-12-2023 to refund the balance
amount of Rs.86,39,100/- vide file no. F.No.8(6)/RPC and MU/TRPC-22/Part-B,
page no. 9 and note no. 11.
Accordingly, Assistant Manager (Marketing), TRPC Ltd. issued a letter to
Deputy Manager (HQ), TRPC Ltd. on 05.01.2024 to refund the balance amount
of Rs.86,39,100/- and on 10.01.2024 Deputy Manager (HQ) send the application
form for fund transfer (including a Cheque bearing No.001471 dt. 10.01.2024) to
Bandhan Bank, Agartala and Bandhan Bank transferred amounting to Rs.
86,39,100/- to M/s. Irity Spices on 11.01.2024.
Therefore, there is neither any intention to frustrate effect of interim order nor did
Corporation took the shelter of falsehood.
A Copy of the sale order dated 08-01-2024 is annexed and marked as Annexure
R/2.
A Copy of the letter dated 05-01-2024 is annexed and marked as Annexure R/3.
A Copy of the approval dated 30-12-2023 is annexed and marked as Annexure
R/4.
A Copy of the RTGS Form and Cheque dated 10-01-2024 is annexed and marked
as Annexure R/5.
12. That, in regard to the statements made in paragraph 13, 14 & 17 of the writ
petition, it is stated that it was already proposed and approved on 30-12-2023 to
refund the balance amount Rs.86,39,100/- vide file no. F.No.8(6)/RPC and
MU/TRPC-22/Part-B, page no. 9 and note no.11.
Accordingly. Assistant Manager (Marketing), TRPC Ltd. issued a letter to
Deputy Manager (HQ), TRPC Ltd. on 05.01.2024 to refund the balance amount
Rs.86,39,100/- and on 10.01.2024 Deputy Manager (HQ) send the application
form for fund transfer (including a Cheque bearing No. 001471 dt. 10.01.2024) to
Bandhan Bank, Agartala and Bank transferred amounting to Rs.86,39,100/- to
M/s. Irity Spices on 11.01.2024.
14. That, in regard to the statements made in paragraph 16 of the writ petition, it
is stated that for remaining lots of rubber which were re-tendered on 29-12-23
and tender opened on 06-01-2024 and sale order for this was issued on 08-012024. This is before Hon'ble High court passed interim stay order dated 10-012024 for lifting of the remaining quantity of rubber sheet and it was required to be
disposed immediately to safeguard corporation's financial loss considering the
perishable nature of rubber.”
5.
On behalf of the petitioner, learned senior counsel Mr. Somik Deb,
while drawing our attention to the judgment dated 13.03.2024, contended that
the ultimate observations made by this Court relating to refund of the balance
amount in the name of the petitioner to the tune of Rs.86,39,100/- on
05.01.2024 and asking the respondents to allow the petitioner to lift remaining
lots of graded rubber sheets under the sale order dated 22.12.2023 upon deposit
of the requisite amount of money refunded to him were recorded on the basis of
suppression of facts to this Court which has surfaced later on. Therefore,
respondents No.1 & 2 are guilty of not only misleading this Court, but also
attempting to evade the specific directions of this Court to allow the petitioner
to lift the remaining lots of graded rubber sheets upon deposit of requisite
amount of money refunded to him.
6.
Mr. D. Sharma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
respondents, on the other hand has sought to persuade this Court that the
attendant facts, on which the final judgment was passed on 13.03.2024, were
not any attempt on the part of the respondents to mislead the Court by
suppression of fact. It is submitted that after cancellation of the sale order dated
22.12.2023 on 28.12.2023, re-tender issued on 29.12.2023 led to issuance of a
sale order on 08.01.2024 before passing of the interim order on 10.01.2024.
Though a formal communication was made on behalf of respondents No.2 to
the Deputy Manager, HQ, TRPC Ltd. on 05.01.2024, apart from information to
the petitioner, but the act of processing of the RTGS Form for such transfer was
made on 10.01.2024 by the Deputy Manager (HQ), TRPC Limited while the
remittance was made on 11.01.2024 in favour of the petitioner. Learned
counsel for the respondents submits that the interim order dated 10.01.2024 was
passed by this Court in the presence of the learned State counsel who was only
representing respondent No.3. This Court had directed the learned State counsel
to receive instructions from respondents No.1 & 2-Corporation within a short
time while directing the respondents not to issue delivery orders in respect of
the remaining quantum of the specified category of graded rubber sheets as per
sale order dated 22.12.2023. It is only thereafter that the respondents No.1 & 2
appeared before this Court and filed their Counter Affidavit. The writ petition
was thereafter disposed of vide judgment dated 13.03.2024.
7.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner Mr. Deb has, in reply,
however also drawn the attention of this Court to certain statements recorded in
the judgment dated 13.03.2024 that a re-tender was done by the Corporation
which however was again recalled. As such, issuance of re-tender on
29.12.2023 and sale order on 08.01.2024 in favour of another person was not
duly brought to the notice of the Court when the writ petition was being
disposed of.
8.
We have given anxious consideration to the submission of learned
counsel for the parties. We find from perusal of the records that when the
matter was taken up for the first time on 10.01.2024, the respondent No.1
herein-Tripura Rehabilitation & Plantation Corporation Limited was not
represented. Respondent No.3 herein i.e. The State of Tripura was only
represented by the learned Government Advocate. After recording the
submission of learned counsel for the petitioner, this Court directed the State
counsel to seek instruction from respondents No.1 & 2-Corporation within a
short time. An interim order was also passed that in the meantime, the
respondents should not issue delivery orders in respect of the remaining
quantum of specified category of graded rubber sheets as per the sale order
dated 22.12.2023 issued in favour of the petitioner. Affidavits were filed
thereafter by the Corporation; the contents of which have been referred to in the
judgment dated 13.03.2024. This Court, after consideration of rival submission
of the parties, interfered in the cancellation of the sale order as being arbitrary
and in violation of principles of natural justice. Since the affidavits on behalf of
the parties were not clear on the question whether the remaining amount of
graded rubber sheet had been lifted before passing of the interim order dated
10.01.2024 or not, a conditional order was passed in the following manner:
“It however appears that after cancellation of the sale order the balance amount
remaining in the name of the petitioner to the tune of Rs.86,39,100/- has been
refunded on 05.01.2024. We are not informed as to whether the interim stay on
the lifting of the remaining amount of graded sheet rubber had been adhered to or
not. In case, the remaining lots of graded sheet rubber under the sale order dated
22.12.2023 has not been lifted, the respondents could allow the petitioner to lift it
upon deposit of the requisite amount of money refunded to him. Otherwise,
respondents could undertake fresh calculation of the amount which requires to be
refunded to the petitioner if any, over and above the amount of Rs.86,39,100/earlier refunded on 05.01.2024.
However, the cancellation of the sale order cannot be upheld in the eye of law for
the aforesaid reasons. It is accordingly set aside.”
Petitioner later on approached this Court in contempt jurisdiction
which was however disposed of by order dated 15.05.2024 with an observation
that the interim order dated 10.01.2024 had merged in the final judgment and if
the remaining amount of Rs.86,39,100/- had already been refunded to the
petitioner on 05.01.2024, a fact which was also not brought to the notice of this
Court when the interim order was passed, proceedings for contempt would not
lie for deliberate violations of the order of this Court. Thereafter, the present
writ petition has been filed.
9.
From the narration of facts recorded above and scrutiny of the
records, two things emerge:
(i) On 10.01.2024, the respondents No.1 & 2 had on their part
processed the RTGS Form relating to remittance of the amount, of
Rs.86,39,100/- in favour of the petitioner with the Bandhan Bank consequent
upon the cancellation of the sale order dated 22.12.2023 on 28.12.2023. The
respondents No.1 & 2 were not before this Court on the date of interim order
i.e. 10.01.2024. Therefore, the remission of that amount on their part on
11.01.2024 by the Bank, could not be treated as an act of deliberate violation of
the interim order.
(ii) The second aspect thereafter which needs scrutiny is whether
the remaining lots of graded rubber sheets under sale order dated 22.12.2023
had been lifted or not before passing of the interim order dated 10.01.2024?
Since it could not be clear at the time of passing of the judgment dated
13.03.2024 whether the remaining sheets of graded rubber had been disbursed
in favour of another person, this court passed a conditional order that if the
same had not been lifted, petitioners would be allowed to lift it upon deposit of
the requisite amount of money refunded to him. This Court also observed that
otherwise respondents could undertake fresh calculation of the amount which
was required to be refunded to the petitioner if any, over and above the amount
of Rs.86,39,100/- earlier refunded.
10.
Though it seems that the actual date of remittance of refund
amount do not tally with the date i.e. 05.01.2024 as recorded in the judgment
dated 13.03.2024, but it appears now that such act of remittance had been made
on the part of the respondents on 10.01.2024 through RTGS to the Bandhan
Bank when the interim order was being passed in their absence. The question,
therefore, falls for consideration is whether the difference of date i.e.
05.01.2024, which is a communication for refund of the amount by the
respondent No.2 to the Deputy Manager (HQ) TRPC Ltd. and also to the
petitioner and the actual act of remittance through RTGS on the part of the
respondents on 10.01.2024 could make any difference so far as the operative
part of the judgment dated 13.03.2024 in WP(C)10 of 2024.
11.
We are of the view that since the interim order had been passed in
the absence of the respondents-Corporation on 10.01.2024 and that act of
remittance on the part of the Corporation of the refund amount of
Rs.86,39,100/- had been made on 10.01.2024 by filling up of the RTGS Form
with the Bandhan Bank and that on 08.01.2024 itself sale order had been issued
for lifting of the remaining amount of graded rubber sheet in favour of another
party pursuant to the re-tender undertaken on 29.12.2023, this Court is unable
to come to a conclusion that there was a deliberate suppression of fact on behalf
of the respondents-Corporation regarding refund of the amount in favour of the
petitioner or lifting of the remaining lots of graded rubber sheets in favour of
another party while the judgment was passed on 13.03.2024 in WP(C)10 of
2024 by this Court. It is also seen that the communication dated 05.01.2024
[Annexure-R/3] though was also sent to the petitioner relating to the refund of
the balance amount of Rs.86,39,100/-, but the same was not brought to the
notice of this Court when the interim order was passed on 10.01.2024. In such
circumstances, after due scrutiny of the attendant facts and circumstances, we
do not find a case made out on behalf of the petitioner for directing the
respondent Corporation to issue delivery challan of remaining quantity of
rubber sheets of various grades pursuant to the sale order dated 22.12.2024 by
holding that the respondent had misled the Court deliberately and disobeyed the
order of this Court.
12.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s),
if any, shall stand disposed of.
(ARINDAM LODH), J
Pijush/
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2024.09.21 15:15:26 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review