Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 271 of 2024
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.
VERSUS
Union of India
For the appellant:
Mr. Amit Kumar Nag, Adv.
Mr. Partha Banerjee, Adv.
For the respondent/UOI
Eastern Railway):
(South
Mr. Pinaki Bhattacharyya, Adv.
Mr. Partha Chakraborty, Adv.
Last Heard on: February 06, 2026
Judgment on: May 22, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury,J:
The appellant before this Court was an applicant under Section 16 of the
Railway Claim Tribunal Act 1989 and is aggrieved by the Judgement and
Award dated 21-06-2016 passed by Learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Kolkata
Bench
in
claim
applicant/appellant.
Application
No.
OA(III)/Kol/2013/0034
filed
by
the
The case of the applicant/appellant before Learned Tribunal may be
summed up thus:
One racket of Naptha was loaded and booked EX-HDCB to I.O.C/Bahauli
from 17-07-11 to 29.10.11 vide RRs. The local booking authority charged
20/RR surcharge whimsically total amounting to Rs. 8,67,595/-. Inspite of
several letters representation and protest by IOCL authority to the Railway
authorities against the said erroneous RR Surcharge the Railway authority did
not consider IOCL against the illegal deduction of RR and regret the IOCL
justified demand. Getting no other alternative to get the refund of illegally
deducted 20/RR, Surcharge amounting to Rs. 86,7595/-, the applicant prayed
for passing an award of Rs. 8,67,595/- with cost and interest 15% per annum
from 17-07-11 till finalization of the case along with application fees Rs. 6805/and advocate fees etc.
The Respondent Union of India contested the case by filing written
statement. ISSUES were framed and evidence was adduced. Learned Tribunal
upon considering the evidence and upon hearing the Learned Advocates for the
parties by Judgment and Award dated 21-06-2016 was pleased to dismiss the
claim case.
The appellant/applicant being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award
passed by the Learned Tribunal has come up with the instant appeal.
Heard Learned Advocates for the parties. Perused the evidence adduced
and materials on record.
Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that the Railway Circular
dated 16-10-2007 applies to the case of the appellant. As per Goods Tariff No.
45, Part-I (VOL-II) which was given effect from 1st April 2007 in clause 12.0
thereof the abbreviation “OR” in Column No. 6 (Captioned as „Risk Rate‟) was
defined as „Owner Risk‟. As opposed to the same the expression „RR‟ was
defined as „Railway Risk‟. The concept was that if the consignment was booked
with the endorsement „OR‟ in the Risk Rate Column (Column No.6) the risk for
the same would be covered by the owner, whereas if the booking was with the
endorsement „RR‟ under Column No.6 the risk would be of the Railways for
which payment of 20% surcharge was levied by Railways.
Learned Advocate further submits that during the subsistence of Good
Tariff No. 45, Part-I (VOL-III) the Railway Board issued circular dated 16th
October 2007, universally replacing the endorsement „OR‟ with „RR‟. As such
from the said date there would be no option for the consigns to book a
consignment by depicting „OR‟ under the Risk Rate Column but the consignor
would be compulsorily have to book the goods as „RR‟. In the said circular the
product Petroleum Products and Gases, under which the commodity-inquestion (Naptha) falls is under the „General Tariff Lines.‟ Therefore as per the
Circular the consignment had to be booked with endorsement „RR‟ in Column-6
and would be free from levy of additional 20% surcharge. Learned Advocate
also submits that the application does not fall within the purview of Order 2
Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908. The appellant has filed two claim
case before the Railway claim Tribunal for two different consignments which
were booked on two different dates and the amount of surcharge which was
levied by the Railway was different for the two different consignments. Both the
consignments have no relation to each other except the product which is
„Naptha‟. It is submitted that both the
consignments were booked on two
different dates and the amount of surcharge deducted for two consignments
were also different. Therefore both the disputes arose from different cause of
action and are not similar.
Learned Advocate relies upon the following Judicial decisions:FMAT No. 237 of 2019.
Indian Oil Corporation VS Union of India.
High Court at Calcutta.
Learned Advocate for the respondent Union of India submits that the
appellant/applicant M/S. Indian Oil Corporation Limited (MD) Kolkata filed a
suit being No. OA. (III)/34/2013 on 19-03-2013 before the Learned Tribunal
claiming refund of a sum of Rs. 8,67,595/- along with cost, interest,
application fees and advocate fees. Learned Advocate further submits that
subsequently the appellant M/S. Indian Oil Corporation Limited (M.D.) Kolkata
filed another suit on the same day that is on 19.03.2013 for refund of 12 RR.
Charge amounting to Rs. 1,14,05,071 on the same grounds as pleaded in the
first suit and this second suit was numbered as OA (III)/35/13.
Learned Advocate also submits that suppression of material facts and
documents are rampant in the pleading of both the suits, namely notice dated
23-08-2011 stipulate an amount of Rs. 8,67,595/- whereas the II (Index) is
amount mentioned against the first suit amounting to Rs. 8,67,595/-. In the
light of the facts and circumstances second suit being No. OA (III)/35/13 filed
on 19-03-2013 is barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC.
It is submitted by the Learned Advocate that the provisions of Order-2
Rule 2 are offshoots of principle of law that there should be an end of litigation.
No one ought to be vexed twice for the same cause. In the instant case both the
suits were filed on 19-03-2013 and the allegation contained in the second suit
would have been incorporated in the first suit itself. It is further submitted that
two split suits based on same cause of action cannot be maintainable in law
and the relief claimed in the second suit ought to have been included in the
first suit. It is also submitted that proper court fees is not paid by the applicant
on the amount claimed.
Before proceeding to decide the material in issue it is necessary to
consider as to whether the Railway Authority wrongly charged 20/RR.
Surcharge whimsically total amounting to Rs. 8,67,595/-.
It is the case of the appellant/applicant that total freight paid was Rs.
52,92,341/- out of which Rs. 8,67,595/- is charged, on the ground Rs.
8,67,595.32 which is RR charge is not applicable on petroleum products. The
claim of the appellant/applicant is based on the circular dated 16-10-2007
being No. TCR/1078/2007/2 which is annexed to the application filed along
with this Appeal.
The circular dated 16-10-2007 provides as follows:
„Sanction of the Central Government is hereby accorded to replace „OR‟
with „RR‟ of the commodities mentioned below in Column 6 of the IRCA Goods
Tariff No. 45 Pt. I (VOL-II).
a) General Tariff lines.
b) All commodities under the main commodity heads 1. Acids and
Alcohols 2. Alloys and Metals; 3. Caustic Potash and Soda. 4. Cement;
5. Chemical Manures; 6. Clay and sand. 7. Foodgrain Flowers and
Pulses, 8. Hydrogenated and other Edible Oils; 9. Iron or steel, 10.
Mineral and Ores, 11. Metal scrap and Pig Iron 12. Oil Cakes and
Seeds, 13. Petroleum products, 14 Soap, 15. Sugar, 16, Miscellaneous
and,
c) Low Rated Tariff Lines.
22. Division „A‟- All Commodities under head Electrical appliances
and fittings, Empty drums Jerrycomes and Barrels, Jagre Jute,
Organic Manures, Vegetable oil pitches and Water.
24. Division C-Boiler Components and Paper.
25. Division D-Bamboos Brooms Coffee and Tea, Coir, Cotton and
other Textiles; and IV and Insecticide fluid.
There will be no change in the class given in column 8. To illustrate after
this change, Acids and Alcohols will be booked at „RR‟ and charged at class 210
without levy of additional 20% surcharge.‟
Thus from the bare reading of the circular dated 16-10-2007. „RR‟. has to
be replaced with „OR‟ and 20% surcharge cannot be imposed on petroleum
product. Naptha was transported by Railway being an inflammable oil comes
under General Tariff lines and is Covered by the circular dated 16-10-2007.
Thus imposing of additional surcharge is bad in law. Although the circular was
not before the Learned Tribunal for consideration but the Respondent Railway
Authority having knowledge of the said circular ought to have brought to the
notice of the Learned Tribunal for decision. Moreover respondent Railway
Authority being State under Article 12 of the Constitution has the duty to see
that lawful claims of any individual or institution are honoured without the
said persons being put to hardship. In the instant case also the Respondent
Railway Authority could have considered the representation of the Appellant for
refund on the basis of circular dated 16-10-2007 if necessary upon giving the
appellant an opportunity of being heard instead of relegating the appellant to
Tribunal.
In the case of Indian Oil Corporation VS Union of India (supra) Hon‟ble
Division Bench of this Court observed as follows:
„6. In order to decide the short issue involved, as to the legality of the levy
of 20% surcharge, the relevant Circulars as well as GT Nos.45 and 46 of the
IRCA are required to be examined.
7. Circular No.TCR/1078/2007/2 dated October 16, 2007 replaced “OR”
with “RR” in Column No.6.
8. To appreciate such change, GT No.45, Part-I (Vol.-II), which was given
effect from April 1, 2007, is to be looked into. As per Clause 12.0 thereof, the
abbreviation “OR” in Column No.6 (captioned as “Risk Rate”) was defined as
“Owner’s Risk”. As opposed to the same, the expression “RR” was defined as
“Railway Risk”. The concept was that if the consignment was booked with the
endorsement “OR” in the Risk Rate Column (Column No.6), the risk for the same
would be covered by the owner, whereas if the booking was with the
endorsement “RR” under Column No.6, the risk would be of the Railways, for
which payment of 20% surcharge was levied by the Railways.
9. During subsistence of GT No.45, Part-I (Vol.-II), the Railway Board
issued Circular No.TCR/1078/2007/2 dated October 16, 2007, universally
replacing the endorsement “OR” with “RR”. As such, from the said date, there
would be no option for the consignor to book a consignment by depicting“OR”
under the Risk Rate Column but the consignor would compulsorily have to book
the goods as “RR”.
10. Simultaneously, the Circular dated October 16, 2007 also remitted the
additional 20% surcharge in case of “RR” consignments.
11. In the self-same Circular, the product “Petroleum Products and Gases”,
under which the commodity-in-question (Naptha) falls, was shown under the
head “General Tariff Lines”.
12. Thus, on and from October 16, 2007, the consignments had to be
booked mandatorily with the endorsement “RR” in Column No.6 and would be
free from levy of additional 20% surcharge.’
Now the issue for consideration is whether claim is barred under Order 2
Rule 2 CPC.
Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides as follows:
„Rule-2 Suit to include the whole claim:1) Every suit shall include the whole of the claim which the plaintiff is
entitled to make in respect of the cause of action but a plaintiff may
relinquish any portion of his claim in order to bring the suit within the
jurisdiction of any Court.
2) Relinquishment of part of claim-Where a plaintiff omits to sue in respect
of or intentionally relinquishes any portion of his claim, he shall not
afterwards sue in respect of the portion so omitted or relinquished.
3) Omission to sue for one of several reliefs-A person entitled to more than
one relief in respect of the same cause of action may sue for all or any
of such reliefs but if he omits except with the leave of the Court to sue
for all such reliefs he shall not afterwards sue for any relief so omitted.
Explanation- For the purpose of this rule an obligation and a collateral
security for its performance and successive claims arising under the same
obligation shall be deemed respectively to constitute but one cause of action.’
Now upon plain reading of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
it will appear that the intention of the said provision is to bring as far as
possible all matters in dispute between the parties relating to same transaction
to be disposed of in the same suit. Thus it intends to prevent multiplicity of
suits in respect of same cause of action. The effect of Order II Rule 2 of CPC is
to bar a plaintiff who had earlier claimed certain remedies in regard to a cause
of action from filing a second suit in regard to other reliefs based on the same
cause of action. Second suit based on a different and distinct cause of action is
not barred under Order II Rule 2 CPC.
In the instant case the appellant filed two claim cases with regard to two
consignments. As each consignment agreement dispute gives rise to a
particular cause of action it cannot be said that dispute with regard to both the
consignment agreement is to be raised in one suit.
Moreover Railway Tribunals are not bound by provisions of CPC but by
the principles of Natural Justice thus rigid view in this regard may not be
taken.
In the facts and circumstances this Appeal FMA 271 of 2024 stands
allowed. Judgment and Award dated 21-06-2016 passed by Learned Railway
Claim Tribunal Kolkata Bench Kolkata in Claim Application No. OA
(III)/Kol/2013/0034 is set aside. The Respondent Railway Authority is directed
to refund additional 20% surcharge an freight to the appellant amounting to
Rs. 8,67,595/- along with interest @6% from date of filing of claim application
till today.
Such payments shall be made within 8 weeks from the date of
communication of this order.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review