Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
****
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
&
THE HON’BL SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
C. R. P. Nos. 3774, 3778 and 3779 of 2025
Between:
IDMC Limited, Rep.by its Managing Director,
GIDC Estate, Vithal Udyog Nagar,
Anand District, Gujrat State and 2 others
.....PETITIONERS
(in all three CRPs)
AND
M/s. C-Star Engineers & Contractors (C-180)
Rep.by its Proprietor Sri S.V.Shiva Kumar,
Visakhapatnam
.....RESPONDENTS
(in all three CRPs)
DATE OF JUDGMENT RESERVED
:
03.02.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED:
22.04.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT UPLOADED
22.04.2026
:
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
&
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
Yes/No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
Yes/No
3. Whether Your Lordships wish to see the fair
Yes/No
may be allowed to see the Judgments?
marked to Law Reporters/Journals
copy of the Judgment?
_______________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
____________________________
MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM, J
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
* THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
&
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
+ C. R. P. Nos. 3774, 3778 and 3779 of 2025
% 22.04.2026
Between:
IDMC Limited, Rep.by its Managing Director,
GIDC Estate, Vithal Udyog Nagar,
Anand District, Gujrat State and 2 others
.....PETITIONERS
(in all three CRPs)
AND
M/s. C-Star Engineers & Contractors (C-180)
Rep.by its Proprietor Sri S.V.Shiva Kumar,
Visakhapatnam
.....RESPONDENTS
(in all three CRPs)
! Counsel for the Petitioners
Counsel for the Respondents
< Gist :
> Head Note:
? Cases Referred:
1. (2013) 14 SCC 1
: Sri C. V. R. Rudra Prasad,
Assisted by Sri Pavan Kumar M
: ---
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
&
THE HON’BL SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
C. R. P. Nos. 3774, 3778 and 3779 of 2025
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari)
Heard Sri C. V. R. Rudra Prasad, assisted by Sri Pavan Kumar M, learned
counsel for the petitioners in all three civil revision petitions.
2. The petitioners are the defendants and the respondent is the plaintiff
in C.O.S.No.10 of 2022, pending in the Court of the Special Judge for Trial and
Disposal of the Commercial Disputes, at Visakhapatnam (in short ‘the Special
Judge’).
3. The plaintiff/respondent originally filed O.S.No.9 of 2017 on the file of
the learned XIII Additional District Judge, Gajuwaka, Visakhapatnam, which
was later on transferred to the Court of the Special Judge and re-numbered as
COS.No.10 of 2022. The suit is for recovery of an amount with subsequent
interest and costs. In the said suit, the defendants/petitioners filed I.A.No.268
of 2025 for the purpose of receiving document and cross examination of PW 1;
I.A.No.269 of 2025 under Order XVIII Rule 17 of Code of Civil Procedure (in
short ‘CPC’) to recall PW 1 for further cross examination, and I.A.No.270 of
2025 under Order XI Rule 1 (10) CPC, as applicable to the Commercial Courts,
to receive the legal notice dated 29.06.2012 issued by the plaintiff under
Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act as documentary evidence. All
the three aforesaid I.As have been dismissed with costs by the learned Special
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
Judge, vide Orders of the same date 14.11.2025, but passed separately on each
application.
4. Challenging the said Orders dated 14.11.2025 in I.A.No.268 of 2025,
CRP No.3779 of 2025; in I.A.No.269 of 2025, CRP No.3774 of 2025 and in
I.A.No.270 of 2025, CRP No.3778 of 2025 have been filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India.
5. As the issue involved is almost common, as the prayer made in all
applications is related, we proceed to decide all the civil revision petitions by
the common judgment.
6. In I.A.No.268 of 2025 the learned Special Judge framed the following
points for consideration:
“(1) Whether the petitioners’ side evidence can be reopened for further cross
examination of PW 1?
(2) To what relief?”
7. The learned Special Judge held that the suit stands posted for filing of
written arguments and at that belated stage, the application could not be
allowed when the document sought to be produced vide I.A.No.268 of 2025
was in possession of the petitioners all along.
8. In I.A.No.269 of 2025 the learned Special Judge framed the following
points for determination:
“(1) Whether PW 1 can be recalled for further cross examination?
(2) To what relief?”
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
9. The learned Special Judge recorded the same reason that at the
belated stage when the suit was posted for filing of written arguments and the
said document was undisputedly in the possession of the petitioners all along,
the suit could not be reopened to recall PW 1 for cross examination.
10. In I.A.No.270 of 2025 the learned Special Judge framed the following
points for determination:
“(1) Whether the legal notice dated 29.06.2012 can be received as an
evidence on behalf of petitioners/defendants?
(2) To what relief?”
11. The learned Special Judge held that the legal notice under Section
138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act dated 29.06.2012 was undisputedly in
possession of the petitioners all along.
The learned Special Judge did not
accept the contention of the petitioners/defendants that the said document
could be traced only recently and such reason assigned did not inspire
confidence to the learned Special Judge.
Observing that the object of the
Commercial Courts Act 2015 is expeditious disposal of the commercial disputes
and in view of the express bar in the Order 11 Rule 1 (10) CPC as amended in
its application by the Commercial Courts Act, the defendants/petitioners could
not be permitted to file a document at that stage which was all along in their
power and possession.
12. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the rejection of
the petitioners’ applications by the Orders impugned in the civil revision
petitions cannot be sustained.
He submitted that in the plaint filed by the
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
plaintiff/respondent there was specific mention of the legal notice dated
29.06.2012 issued by the plaintiff and though the plaintiff made an averment to
that effect in the plaint, but had chosen not to file the said document in the list
of documents along with plaint. Consequently, the application was filed by the
defendants seeking leave of the Special Court of the Special Judge to file the
said document as also to reopen for cross examination of PW 1 after receiving
the document. He further submitted that the said fact of non-filing of the legal
notice came to the knowledge of the petitioners only recently at the time of
preparation of arguments. So, there was no negligence on their part in not
filing the application previously, which was filed in a short span of closure of the
evidence.
13. We have considered the aforesaid submissions and perused the
material on record.
14. It has not been disputed that the document sought to be filed with
the permission of the Court i.e., the legal notice issued by the plaintiff on
29.06.2012
was
in
power,
possession
and
custody
of
the
defendants/petitioners. They have chosen not to file it along with their written
statement, which was filed on 19.02.2016 itself. With respect to the plaintiff’s
averment in the plaint about that legal notice dated 29.06.2012 vide para-III (f)
the defendants/petitioners in their written statement, in para-8 of the written
statement though generally denied the contents of para-III (f) of the plaint and
disputed their liability under the terms and conditions of the purchaser order
etc., but no specific dispute was raised with respect to the legal notice dated
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
29.06.2012. The list of documents along with the plaint clearly revealed as to
what documents were filed by the plaintiff along with the plaint which did not
contain the legal notice dated 29.06.2012. The defendants had the knowledge
that the document legal notice dated 29.06.2012 issued by the plaintiff to the
defendants was not filed by the plaintiff. The said document was in possession
of the defendants as that notice was sent to the defendants and there was no
denial of its receipt in the written statement. Even in the application, there is
no such averment.
15. Order XI Rule 1 (10) CPC specially provides that save and except for
sub-rule 7 (c) (iii), defendants shall not be allowed to rely on documents, which
were in the defendants power, possession, control or custody and not disclosed
along with the written statement or counterclaim, save and except by leave of
Court and such leave shall be granted only upon the defendant establishing
reasonable cause for non-disclosure along with the written statement or
counterclaim. Sub-rule (7) (c) (iii) of Order XI Rule 1 CPC is not attracted. It is
also not the petitioners’ case that such clause is attracted. Consequently, in
view of the mandate of law, the petitioners/defendants could not be allowed to
rely on the document i.e., the legal notice dated 29.06.2012, which was not
filed along with the written statement, which should have been filed by the
defendants, as the same was not filed by the plaintiff with the plaint which
could also not be filed by the plaintiff as it was in possession, power and control
of the defendants, along with their written statement filed way back in 2016.
Though a document can be filed afterwards also, but with the leave of the
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
Court. The mandate of law is that such leave shall be granted by the Court
only upon defendants establishing the reasonable cause for non-disclosure/nonfiling along with the written statement. So, in the absence of any reasonable
cause forthcoming, the Court shall not grant the leave. The cause stated by
the defendants in the application has not been established to be a reasonable
cause to the satisfaction of the learned Special Judge.
16. We are of the view that under the circumstances, the cause stated
has rightly not been believed by the learned Special Judge.
17. It is settled position in law that at a belated stage, an application to
recall a witness cannot ordinarily be allowed.
In the present case, the
application to recall the witness was with respect to the document i.e., the legal
notice sought to be filed and once that was not permitted, leave was not
granted by the Special Judge for the reasons recorded which are reasonable
and justifiable, the question of recalling the witness does not arise.
18. Bagai Construction v. Gupta Building Material Store1, on
which the learned Special Judge placed reliance, learned counsel for the
petitioners submitted that the said judgment is not applicable. But we find that
the submission is not correct.
19. In Bagai Construction (supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court has held
that the power under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC is to be sparingly exercised and not
as a general rule in a routine way merely for the asking otherwise it will defeat
(2013) 14 SCC 1
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
the very purpose of expeditious trial. Paragraphs 9 to 12 of Bagal
Construction (supra) read as under:
“9. In Vadiraj
Naggappa
Vernekar v. Sharadchandra
Prabhakar
Gogate [Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar v. Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate,
(2009) 4 SCC 410 : (2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 198] this Court had an occasion to
consider similar claim, particularly, application filed under Order 18 Rule 17
and held as under: (SCC pp. 414-15, paras 25, 28-29 & 31)
“25. In our view, though the provisions of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC have been
interpreted to include applications to be filed by the parties for recall of
witnesses, the main purpose of the said Rule is to enable the court, while trying
a suit, to clarify any doubts which it may have with regard to the evidence led
by the parties. The said provisions are not intended to be used to fill up
omissions in the evidence of a witness who has already been examined.
***
28. The power under the provisions of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC is to be
sparingly exercised and in appropriate cases and not as a general rule merely on
the ground that his recall and re-examination would not cause any prejudice to
the parties. That is not the scheme or intention of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC.
29. It is now well settled that the power to recall any witness under Order 18
Rule 17 CPC can be exercised by the court either on its own motion or on an
application filed by any of the parties to the suit, but as indicated hereinabove,
such power is to be invoked not to fill up the lacunae in the evidence of the
witness which has already been recorded but to clear any ambiguity that may
have arisen during the course of his examination.
***
31. Some of the principles akin to Order 47 CPC may be applied when a
party makes an application under the provisions of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC, but
it is ultimately within the court's discretion, if it deems fit, to allow such an
application. In the present appeal, no such case has been made out.”
10. If we apply the principles enunciated in the above case and the
limitation as explained with regard to the application under Order 18 Rule 17,
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
the applications filed by the plaintiff have to be rejected. However, the learned
counsel for the respondent by placing heavy reliance on a subsequent decision,
namely, K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy [K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy,
(2011) 11 SCC 275 : (2011) 3 SCC (Civ) 665] , submitted that with the aid of
Section 151 CPC, the plaintiff may be given an opportunity to put additional
evidence and to recall PW 1 to prove those documents and if need arises other
side may be compensated. According to him, since the High Court has adopted
the said course, there is no need to interfere with the same.
11. In Velusamy [K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy, (2011) 11 SCC 275 :
(2011) 3 SCC (Civ) 665] even after considering the principles laid down
in Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar [Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar v. Sharadchandra
Prabhakar Gogate, (2009) 4 SCC 410 : (2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 198] and taking
note of Section 151 CPC, this Court concluded that: (K.K. Velusamy case [K.K.
Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy, (2011) 11 SCC 275 : (2011) 3 SCC (Civ) 665] ,
SCC p. 286, para 22)
“22. … in the interests of justice and to prevent abuse of the process of the
court, the trial court [is free to consider] whether it was necessary to reopen the
evidence and if so, in what manner and to what extent….”
12. Further, it observed that the evidence should be permitted in exercise of
its power under Section 151 of the Code. The following principles laid down in
that case are relevant: (K.K. Velusamy case [K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy,
(2011) 11 SCC 275 : (2011) 3 SCC (Civ) 665] , SCC p. 285, para 19)
“19. We may add a word of caution. The power under Section 151 or Order
18 Rule 17 of the Code is not intended to be used routinely, merely for the
asking. If so used, it will defeat the very purpose of various amendments to the
Code to expedite trials. But where the application is found to be bona fide and
where the additional evidence, oral or documentary, will assist the court to
clarify the evidence on the issues and will assist in rendering justice, and the
court is satisfied that non-production earlier was for valid and sufficient
reasons, the court may exercise its discretion to recall the witnesses or permit
the fresh evidence. But if it does so, it should ensure that the process does not
become a protracting tactic. The court should firstly award appropriate costs to
RNT, J & MRK, J
CRP Nos.3774, 3778 & 3779 of 2025
the other party to compensate for the delay. Secondly, the court should take up
and complete the case within a fixed time schedule so that the delay is avoided.
Thirdly, if the application is found to be mischievous, or frivolous, or to cover
up negligence or lacunae, it should be rejected with heavy costs.”
20. Consequently, we are of the view that the applications could not be
allowed and have rightly been disallowed at the belated stage of filing of the
written arguments, considering the object of Commercial Courts Act which is for
expeditious disposal of the disputes of commercial nature.
21. No case for interference is made out with the Orders impugned as
we do not find any such ground for interference under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India in the exercise of supervisory jurisdiction which is not to
be so invoked in a routine way.
22. All the aforesaid Civil Revision Petitions are dismissed.
23. No order as to costs.
Pending
miscellaneous
petitions,
if
any,
shall
stand
closed
in
consequence.
_______________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
Date: 22.04.2026
Dsr
Note:
LR copy to be marked
B/o
Dsr
______________________________
MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review