Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025
Dr. Ibetombi Kshetrimayum, aged about 50 years, D/o (Late)
Ksh. Shyamkanhai Singh, Senior Resident, Radiodiagnosis
Department, Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences
(JNIMS), Porompat, a resident of Sagolband Tera Yambem
Leirak, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner-cumSecretary (Health & FW), Government of Manipur, New
Secretariat Building, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
2. The Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences, JNIMS,
P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur-795005,
through its Director.
3. The Dean Academic, JNIMS, P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur-795005.
4. Dr. Mutum Anilkumar Singh, now working as Casualty Medical
Officer, Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences (JNIMS),
Porompat, P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur795005.
…… Respondent/s
With
WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Dr. Mutum Anilkumar Singh, aged about 37 years now working
as Casualty Medical Officer, Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of
Medical Sciences (JNIMS), Porompat, P.O. & P.S. Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus -
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 1
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner-cumSecretary (Health & FW), Government of Manipur, New
Secretariat Building, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
2. The Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences, JNIMS,
P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur-795005,
through its Director.
3. The Dean Academic, JNIMS, P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur-795005.
…… Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner/s
::
For the respondent/s
::
Date of reserving for order
Date of Judgment & Order
::
::
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Ms. Y. Jinita, Adv.
Mr. Lenin Hijam, AG along with Mr. Kh.
Athouba, G.A. assisted by Ms. Thanyomi
Keishing, Adv. [R1-R3];
Mrs. G. Pushpa, Adv. along with Ms. Th.
Ranjeeta, Adv. [R4]
Sharmila, Adv.
05.06.2025
11.06.2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms.
Y. Jinita, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate
General along with Mr. Kh. Athouba, learned Govt. Advocate assisted by Ms.
Thanyomi Keishing, learned Jr. G.A. on behalf of State respondent Nos. 1 to
3 and Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel along with Ms. Th. Ranjeeta, learned
counsel for respondent No. 4.
[2]
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 has been filed by Dr. Ibetombi
Kshetrimayum and WP(C) No. 295 of 2025 by Dr. Mutum Anilkumar Singh.
These writ petitions are considered together in terms of the direction of the
Hon’ble Chief Justice on administrative side and the position of the parties are
referred to as in WP(C) No. 218 of 2025. Accordingly, Dr. Ibetombi
Kshetrimayum will be referred as petitioner, State Respondents as respondent
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 2
Nos.1-3, and Dr. Mutum Anilkumar Singh will be referred as respondent No.
4 in this judgment.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025:
[3]
By the present writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the
Notice dated 11.03.2025 issued by the Director, Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of
Medical Sciences (in short, JNIMS), Imphal inviting applications from inservice candidates of all State without any regard to domicile for participation
in the Special Stray Vacancy Round State Level PG counselling 2024 and
also for quashing the Notifications dated 04.02.2025 and 10.02.2025 by Dean
(Academic), JNIMS inter-alia granting provisional selection of the respondent
No. 4 and admission granted to the respondent No. 4 in the third round
counselling of State Quota Seats for undergoing post-graduate course in the
subject of Radiodiagnosis in JNIMS under JNIMS sponsored category. There
is another prayer for directing the official respondents to conduct a special
stray round counselling of vacant seat for undergoing PG course in
Radiodiagnosis in JNIMS sponsored category after cancelling the admission
of the respondent No.4.
[4]
The prayer in the writ petition, WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 is
reproduced as:
“(i)
to admit this petition;
(ii)
to issue Rule Nisi.
(iii)
to issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari for quashing the
Notice dated 11.03.2025 issued by the respondent No. 2
inviting applications from the in-service candidates of all
States without any regard domicile for participation in the
Special Stray Vacancy Round Staff Level, PG
Counselling, 2024 thereby superseding the Notification of
even number dated 05.03.2025 issued by the respondent
No. 2.
(iv)
to issue a writ of Certiorari for quashing the Notification
dated 04.02.2025 issued by the respondent No. 3 thereby
provisionally selected the respondent No. 4 for undergoing
Post-Graduate Course in the subject of Radiodiagnosis.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 3
(v)
to issue a writ of Certiorari for quashing the Notification
dated 10.02.2025 issued by the respondent No. 3 thereby
admitting the respondent No. 4 after completion of third
round counselling of State Quota Seats for undergoing
Post Graduate Course in the subject of Radiodiagnosis.
(vi)
to issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 for fixing a date for holding a
Special Stray Vacancy Round Staff Level, PG Counselling
2024 for filling up the vacant seat for undergoing Post
Graduate Course at JNIMS in the subject of
Radiodiagnosis in the JNIMS sponsored seat.
AND
(vi)
[5]
to pass any such further order(s) or direction(s) which this
Hon’ble Court deem fit and proper to secure the ends of
justice.”
It is the case of the petitioner (Dr. Ibetombi Kshetrimayum) that
she was appointed as Senior Resident in the Department of Radiodiagnosis,
Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences (in short JNIMS) vide order
dated 25.02.2012 issued by the respondent No. 2 i.e. Director, JNIMS.
Likewise, the respondent No. 4 (Dr. Anilkumar Singh) was also appointed as
Casual Medical Officer vide order dated 18.05.2013 issued by the respondent
No. 2 i.e. Director, JNIMS and now upgraded to Senior Casualty Medical
Officer vide order dated 06.03.2021. Both the appointments were made on the
recommendation of the duly constituted selection board.
[6]
The petitioner appeared in NEET-PG, 2024 conducted by the
National Board of Examinations in Medical Science, an autonomous body
under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India under
Roll No. 24661186914. The result of the said examination was declared on
23.08.2024 and the petitioner scored 6.8387371 percentile. Likewise, the
respondent No. 4 also appeared in the NEET-PG, 2024 conducted by National
Board of Examinations in Medical Science and he scored 26.5809089
percentile.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 4
[7]
Vide notice dated 23.08.2024 issued by the National Board of
Examinations
in
Medical
Sciences,
New
Delhi,
the
minimum
qualifying/eligibility criteria for admission in MC/MS/DNB/Diploma Courses as
mentioned in the Information bulletin for NEET-PG 2024, the cut-off percentile
for various categories are as follows:
Category
Minimum
Qualifying/Eligibility Criteria
[8]
General/EWS
50th Percentile
General-PwBD
45th Percentile
SC/ST/OBC (Including PwBD
of SC/ST/OBC
40th Percentile
Vide another notice dated 04.01.2025 issued by the Directorate
General of Health Services Medical Counselling Committee, the percentile for
NEET-PG Counselling 2024 has been lowered and the eligibility criteria as
General/EWS is 15 percentile and above and SC/ST/OBC/PwD category is
10 percentile and above. Vide another notice dated 25.02.2025 issued by the
National Board of Examination in Medical Sciences, the revised minimum
qualification criteria for NEET-PG, 2024 for all category is at 5th percentile.
[9]
Vide notice dated 31.10.2024 issued by the Dean Academic,
JNIMS, applications were invited for intending NEET-PG 2024 qualified
Medical Graduate for undergoing PG Course in JNIMS in 20 (twenty)
Departments. The distribution of PG seats in JNIMS, Imphal is 90 and fixing
All India Quota (AIQ) as 46 and State Quota as 44.
[10]
Vide notice dated 21.11.2024 issued by the Member Secretary,
State Level PG Counselling Committee, the date for Combined State Level
PG counselling for filling up of vacant seats for undergoing Post-Graduate
(MD/MS/Diploma) courses at JNIMS and the RIMS, Imphal for the academic
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 5
Session 2024-2025 has given as 1st Round State Level PG counselling on
26.11.2024, 2nd Round on 19.12.2024 and 3rd Round on 09.01.2025.
[11]
Vide another notice dated 25.11.2024 issued by the Director,
JNIMS for First Round state Level PG counselling, JNIMS, 24 seats for State
Quota is distributed as (a) Sponsored Category – 21; (b) Open Category – 17;
(c) JNIMS Product – 2; and (d) JNIMS Sponsored – 4. Out of the 4 seats for
JNIMS sponsored category, the seats are distributed as Medicine – 1, OBG
– 1, Pathology – 1 and Radiodiagnosis – 1 for the year 2024.
[12]
Vide notice dated 06.01.2025 issued by the Director, JNIMS,
applications were called from newly NEET 2024 eligible candidates for 3rd
round State PG counselling and vide another notice dated 01.02.2025 issued
by the Director, JNIMS, the seats available for the 3rd round NEET-PG
Counselling 2024 was issued and in the JNIMS sponsored, 4 seats i.e.
Medicine – 1, OBG – 1, Pathology – 1 and Radiodiagnosis – 1 were still
available.
C. JNIMS Sponsored:
Sl.No. Subject
[13]
Course
Category
Vacant
Seats
1.
Medicine
MD
-
1 (One) no.
2.
OBG
MD
-
1 (One) no.
Pathology
MD
-
1 (One) no.
4.
Radiodiagnosis
MS
-
1 (One) no.
After completion of the 3rd round PG counselling, vide notice
dated 04.02.2025 [Annexure- A/18] issued by the Dean (Academic), JNIMS,
provisional select list was published for admission in PG Courses (MD/MS)
and in the said notification, the name of the respondent No. 4 i.e. Dr. Mutum
Anilkumar Singh was recommended in JNIMS sponsored seat in the subject
for MD in Radiodiagnosis. Vide another notification dated 10.02.2025
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 6
[Annexure- A/19] issued by the Dean (Academic), JNIMS, published the list of
admitted candidates for academic session 2024-2025 in various PG (MD/MS)
courses in JNIMS after completion of 3rd round counselling and the respondent
No. 4 was admitted in JNIMS sponsored seat for PG (MD) in Radiodiagnosis
by paying necessary fees and submission of other documents including bond.
[14]
Vide notice dated 20.02.2025 issued by the Director, JNIMS,
applications were called for filling up vacancies under Stray Vacancy Round
State Level PG Counselling 2024 (4th round) and vide another notice dated
23.02.2025, the date of Stray Vacancy Round was fixed on 26.02.2025.
[15]
Subsequently, there was a reduction of the minimum qualifying
mark for admission for NEET-PG 2024 Counselling to 5th percentile vide notice
dated 25.02.2025 issued by the National Board of Examinations in Medical
Sciences, New Delhi. The petitioner who scored 6.8387371 percentile in the
NEET-PG qualifying examination, submitted an application dated 26.02.2024
to the Dean, JNIMS for allowing her to participate in NEET-PG counselling
2024, as she was eligible by then, after the minimum eligibility criteria was
reduced to 5th percentile.
[16]
The petitioner also submitted a detailed and common
representation dated 27.02.2025 to the Commissioner (Health & Family
Welfare), Government of Manipur and Director, JNIMS for allotting the PG
seat in Radiodiagnosis, JNIMS to her for the academic session 2024, as she
is eligible for admission in terms of the Notifications dated 16.02.2025
[Annexure- A/33] and dated 21.10.2024 [Annexure- A/34] both issued by
JNIMS prescribing rules for reservation of 4 seats in the admission in PG
course for JNIMS sponsored candidates, such as, Senior Residents/Tutor/
Demonstrator/ Lady Medical Officer/Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty
Medical Officer.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 7
[17]
The Director, JNIMS issued another notice dated 05.03.2025 for
Special Stray Vacancy 5th round. The petitioner submitted an application for
appearing in the Special Stray Vacancy Round State Level NEET-PG
Counselling 2024 (5th round) with no objection certificate from the authority.
Vide letter dated 10.03.2025, the petitioner also submitted an application to
the Director, JNIMS for allotment of PG seat in the Department of
Radiodiagnosis, JNIMS as per norms and rules of JNIMS in terms of
Annexure- A/33 and Annexure- A/34. The petitioner also submitted another
application dated 11.03.2025 to the Chairman, State Level PG Counselling
Committee, 2024 and to the Member Secretary, State Level PG Counselling
Committee, 2024 for proceeding with Special Stray Round State Level PG
Counselling 2024.
[18]
In supersession of the earlier notice dated 05.03.2025, the
Director, JNIMS issued a notification dated 11.03.2025 calling for fresh
application from intending newly eligible candidates after lowering of minimum
NEET-PG 2024 qualifying percentile to participate for Special Stray Vacancy
Round State Level PG Counselling 2024. However, it is stated that in terms of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order dated 29.01.2025 in Civil Appeal No. 9289
of 2019: Dr. Tanvi Behl v. Shrey Goel & Ors: 2025 INSC 125, the vacancy
will be opened to in-service of all State without any regard to domicile. The
petitioner is aggrieved by this notification dated 11.03.2025 of merging of
vacant seats to All India Quota as well the provisional selection and admission
of respondent No. 4 in PG (MD) course in the subject of Radiodiagnosis in
JNIMS.
[19]
It is the case of the petitioner that vide notification dated
16.02.2022 [Annexure- A/33], the JNIMS framed a rule known as Time Scale
Promotion (Regularly appointed Senior Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady
Medical Officer possessing Post Graduate Degree) (1st Amendment) Rules,
2022. The rule proposes amendment of Rule 7(d) in the Time Scale Promotion
(Regularly appointed Senior Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 8
Officer possessing Post Graduate Degree) Rules, 2018 and Rule 7(d) was
amended by stipulating that 14% of the State open quota seat for PG course
of JNIMS will be reserved for teachers in each session and in order to be
eligible for PG seats reservation, the teacher must qualify NEET-PG exam
and the reservation will be in force for 5 years i.e. till 2025 and detail of
reservation given in Schedule-I. 4 seats are reserved for teachers in JNIMS
for each year on roster basis amongst 11 subjects over the five years and
Radiodiagnosis gets only one seat in 2024 over the period of five years.
[20]
The
notification
dated
16.02.2022
[Annexure-
A/33]
is
reproduced as:
“NOTIFICATION
Imphal, the 16th of February, 2022
No. 01/1/Estt/JIMS/10(v):- The President, Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of
Medical Sciences Society, Imphal, Manipur with the previous sanction
of the State Government, is pleased to make the following rules further
to amend the Time Scale Promotion (Regularly appointed Senior
Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer possessing Post
Graduate Degree) Rules, 2018, namely:1. SHORT TITLE AND COMMENCEMENT:
(1) These rules may be called the Time Scale Promotion (Regularly
appointed Senior Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical
Officer possessing Post Graduate Degree) (1st Amendment)
Rules, 2022.
(2) These rules shall come into force with effect from the current
academic session i.e. 2021-2022.
2. Amendment of Rule 7(d) of Time Scale Promotion (Regularly
appointed Senior Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical
Officer possessing Post Graduate Degree) Rules, 2018:
The existing Rule 7(d) shall be substituted by the following:
For those regularly appointed Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator
(Teachers) who do not possess Post Graduate Degree, there will be a
provision for reservation of Post Graduate Degree seats in the Institute
as follows:
(I)
(II)
14% of the State Open Quota seats in Post Graduate Degree
courses of the Institute shall be reserved for teachers in each
session.
In order to be eligible for PG seats reservation, they must
qualify NEET-PG exam.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 9
(III)
Reservation of PG seats shall be done in the same
department in which they are already working.
(IV) In case of more than one member qualifying NEET-PG Exam
in the same department in same session, preference will be
given to the one who is older in age irrespective of the score.
(V)
If any Teachers quota seat is not filled up due to unavailability
of eligible Teachers, then the vacant seat shall be filled up by
candidates from the State Merit List.
(VI) The seat allotment matrix will be adjusted from time to time
according to availability of eligible Teachers with preference
given to the subsequent year roster.
(VII) The reservation shall be in force for 5 years i.e. till 2025.
(VIII) The detail reservation roster is given at Schedule-I.
3. This issues as per approval conveyed vide letter No. JNIM1101/6/2021-HS-HEALTH dated 14th February, 2022 issued by
Secretariat Health, Dept., GoM and State Cabinet approval in
meeting held on 04.01.2022 and with the “No Objection” of the
Election Commission of India conveyed vide letter No. 437/MRLA/2022-NES-II dated 1st February, 2022 which is subject to
condition that no undue publicity is to be made.
4. This rule shall be subject to outcome of WP(C) No. 88 of 2022.
(Prof. L. Deben Singh)
Director, J.M. Institute of Medical Sciences”
“SCHEDULE-I
PG DEGREE SEAT RESERVATION ROSTER FOR REGULAR
NON-PG TEACHERS (SR/TUTOR/DEMONSTRATOR) OF JNIMS,
IMPHAL.
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Course
Year
Total
Anaesthesiology
2021 2022 2023 2024
Forensic Medicine
Medicine
OBG
Orthopaedics
Pharmacology
Radiodiagnosis
Total
Respiratory
Medicine
Surgery
Paediatrics
Pathology
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 10
[21]
Since the Senior Casualty Medical Officer and Casualty Medical
Officer were not included in the 1st Amendment Rules, 2022, JNIMS issued
another notification dated 21.10.2022 [Annexure- A/34] known as Scheme for
Reservation of Post Graduate Medical Seats in JNIMS for Senior Casualty
Medical Officers and Casualty Medical Officers, JNIMS. Under the new
Scheme, the Senior Casualty Medical Officers and Casualty Medical Officers
are also eligible for allotment of PG seats in the JNIMS sponsored quota under
Para (i) of the notification dated 16.02.2025. However, as per Para (iii) of the
notification, if eligible candidates are available from Regularly appointed
Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in the concerned
subject after lowering of the NEET-PG cut off percentile in the subsequent
round, the Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer who has
been allotted a PG seat, must surrender the seat.
[22]
The
notification
dated
21.10.2022
[Annexure-A/34]
is
reproduced as:
“NOTIFICATION
Imphal, the 21st October, 2022
“No. 01/931/Non-PG CMO/22-JNIMS:The
President,
Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences Society, Imphal,
Manipur with the previous sanction of the State Government is
pleased to make the following Scheme for reservation of Post
Graduate Medical Seats in JNIMS for Senior Casualty Medical
Officers and Casualty Medical Officers, JNIMS as follows:(i)
The reservation of PG seats for regularly appointed
Senior Casualty Medical Officers and Casualty
Medical Officers will be considered only if any of the
regularly
appointed
Sr.
Residents/Tutor/
Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officers’ quota seats
provided by the Rule 7(d) of the Time Scale
Promotion
(Regularly
appointed
Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/lady Medical Officer
possessing
Post
Graduate
Degree)
(1st
Amendment) Rules, 2022, are not filled up due to
unavailability of eligible regularly appointed Sr.
Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady
Medical
Officer of the concerned department of JNIMS in
that academic year.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 11
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
In order to be eligible for PG seats reservation, the
Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical
officers must qualify NEET-PG Examination.
Since Sr. Casualty Medical Officers/Casualty
Medical Officers are open to any of the allocated
PG seats/subject, Senior Casualty Medical Officers
and Casualty Medical Officers shall be eligible to
join 1st round of PG Counselling; but allotment of
PG seats will be considered from 2nd round
counselling onwards. If eligible candidates are
available from the regular Senior Resident/Tutor/
Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in the
concerned subject after lowering the NEET-PG cut
off percentile in the subsequent round, the Sr.
Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officers
who has been allotted PG Seat must surrender the
seat.
In case of having more than one NEET-PG
qualifying candidates in the same Department,
preference will be given on the basis of seniority in
service, academic age of the candidate and NEETPG Score.
This scheme shall be applicable to Casualty
Medical Officers who have rendered regular service
of not less than 5 (five) years.
This reservation Scheme shall be in force for 5 (five)
years i.e. till 2026 and in the line with Time Scale
Promotion
(Regularly
appointed
Senior
Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady
Medical
Officer possessing Post Graduate Degree) 1st
Amendment) Rules, 2022.
If any Teachers’ quota seat is not filled up due to
unavailability of both eligible Teachers and Senior
Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officers,
then the vacant seat shall be filled up by candidates
from the State Merit List.
2.
This is issued as per approval conveyed by Secretariat:
Health Department, Government of Manipur vide letter No.
JNIM-1101/6/2021-HS-HEALTH,
dated
20.10.2022
in
accordance with State Cabinet Decision taken in its meeting held
on 13.10.2022.
3.
This scheme shall be subject to outcome of all analogous
Writ Petitions/SLPs relating to reservation of PG seats in JNIMS
for JNIMS’s Doctors.
(Prof. L. Deben Singh)
Director, J.N. Institute of Medical Sciences.”
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 12
[23]
It is the case of the petitioner that by the notification dated
16.02.2022, only Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officers
are eligible for consideration for admission in PG course under the JNIMS
sponsored quota against 4 (four) seats reserved for each academic year. In
the notification dated 16.02.2022, Senior Casualty Medical Officers/ Casualty
Medical Officers are not included. Subsequently, the notification dated
16.02.2022 (the rule framed under Article 309 of the Constitution), was
amended by issuing another notification dated 21.10.2022 where Senior
Casualty Medical Officer and Casualty Medical Officer in JNIMS are also
eligible for consideration against 4 (four) seats reserved under JNIMS
sponsored category in terms Para (i) of the said notification, where the
teachers are not found eligible.
[24]
However, as per Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022,
such Senior Casualty Medical Officers/Casualty Medical Officers who have
been allotted PG seats in JNIMS sponsored category, have to surrender the
seats, if regular Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in
the concerned subject are found eligible in subsequent round after lowering
NEET-PG cut off percentile.
[25]
The petitioner is claiming for her right to admission in terms of
the notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS
whereby Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer has to
surrender the seat allotted to him or her when persons like the petitioner are
eligible at subsequent stage on lowering of the minimum eligibility criteria for
NEET-PG cut off percentile.
[26]
In the present case, the respondent No. 4, a Senior Casualty
Medical Officer in JNIMS, was admitted in PG (MD) course in Radiodiagnosis
in the 3rd round, as the persons mentioned in Para (i) of the notification dated
21.10.2022 i.e. Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 13
were not eligible at that stage. The score of respondent No. 4 was 26.5809089
and NEET-PG percentile at 3rd round was 15th percentile. Later on, when the
NEET-PG percentile was reduced to 5th percentile vide notification dated
25.02.2025, the petitioner, having a NEET-PG Score of 6.8387371 percentile,
requested for her admission. The petitioner, a Senior Resident in
Radiodiagnosis department in JNIMS, claimed her right for admission in
PG(MD) course in Radiodiagnosis in place of respondent No. 4, as he ought
to surrender the seat in terms of Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022.
[27]
It is the case of the petitioner that in previous year, the JNIMS
authority issued orders to cancel the admission of Senior Casualty Medical
Officer/Casualty Medical Officer, when Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/
Lady Medical Officer were subsequently found to be eligible on reduction of
NEET-PG qualifying percentile. However, in the present case, JNIMS
authority has refused to issue such order cancelling the admission granted to
respondent No. 4 and on the contrary, it has issued the impugned notification
dated 11.03.2025 stating that any vacant seat was merged with the All India
Quota. It is stated that the same was done in compliance of the judgment
dated 29.01.2025 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.
9289 of 2019 in the case of Dr. Tanvi Behl v. Shrey Goel & Ors. reported as
2025 INSC 125.
[28]
It may be stated that the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in para 33
of the above mentioned judgment that residence-based reservation is
impermissible in PG Medical courses and the State quota seats, apart from a
reasonable number of institution-based reservations, have to be filled strictly
on the basis of merit in the All India examination and the Hon’ble Court struck
down reservation in PG seat on the basis of residence base. Para 33 of the
said judgment is reproduced as:
“33.
Having made the above determination that residencebased reservation is impermissible in PG Medical
courses, the State quota seats, apart from a reasonable
number of institution-based reservations, have to be filled
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 14
strictly on the basis of merit in the All India examination.
Thus, out of 64 seats which were to be filled by the State
in its quota 32 could have been filled on the basis of
institutional preference, and these are valid. But the other
32 seats earmarked as U.T. Chandigarh pool were
wrongly filled on the basis of residence, and we uphold the
findings of the High Court on this crucial aspect.”
[29]
In the above judgment, institution-based reservation is held to be
permissible, but what has been barred is the reservation strictly based on
residence.
[30]
The main ground raised in the writ petition, i.e., WP(C) No. 218
of 2025, is that in terms of the notifications dated 16.02.2022 [Annexure- A/33]
and 21.10.2022 [Annexure- A/34] issued by JNIMS regulating the reservation
of PG seat for JNIMS sponsored candidates, i.e., 14% open quota equivalent
to 4 seats, the respondent No. 4 who has been admitted in the JNIMS
sponsored seat, has to vacate the seat and the petitioner, who is eligible after
reduction in the percentile, has to be admitted against the seat allotted to the
respondent No. 4.
[31]
It is the case of the petitioner that the notifications dated
16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 which stipulate the rule for reservation and
admission in PG seats for JNIMS sponsored candidates, have not been set
aside or stayed by any competent Court having jurisdiction nor repealed by
the competent authority. The judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Dr. Tanvi Behl (supra) does not prohibit institution-based reservation
in PG courses in Medicine and as such, the notification dated 11.03.2025
issuing merger of all vacant seats including JNIMS sponsored seat in All India
pool is arbitrary, illegal and without any basis and it is not in terms of the
direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. It is prayed that the official
respondents be directed to cancel the admission granted to the respondent
No. 4 in PG course in Radiodiagnosis and the same be given to the petitioner.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 15
[32]
The respondent No. 1 has filed counter affidavit wherein it is
stated that the Time Scale Promotion (Regularly appointed Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady
Medical
Officer
Possessing
Post-
Graduate Degree) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2022 was framed for those
employees of JNIMS who are teachers and not for the product of JNIMS
institute. It further states that the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order dated
29.01.2025 in Civil Appeal No. 9289 of 2019 held that resident-based
reservation is not permissible in PG medical course and accordingly, the State
respondent, vide its notice dated 11.03.2025, decided to conduct counselling
of PG in vacant seats in accordance with the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order
in Dr. Tanvi Behl (supra) and therefore, all vacant seats are open to inservice all India candidates on merit without any regard to domicile.
[33]
The respondent Nos. 2 & 3, (JNIMS authority) have also filed
common counter affidavit stating that the impugned notification dated
11.03.2025 was issued in compliance of the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order
dated 29.01.2025 in Civil Appeal No. 9289 of 2019 (Dr. Tanvi Behl vs. Shrey
Goel & Ors). It is specially stated that as per the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s
order, Time Scale Promotion (regularly appointed Senior Residents/Tutor/
Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer possessing Post Graduate Degree) (1st
Amendment) Rules 2022 and Scheme for Reservation of Post Graduate
Medical seats in JNIMS for Senior casualty Medical Officer and Casualty
Medical Officers, JNIMS, 2022 stand superseded and Special Stray Vacancy
Round in PG counselling was fixed on 18.03.2025 and the same was duly
completed.
[34]
The respondent No. 4 filed counter affidavit. One vacant seat for
Radiodiagnosis under JNIMS sponsored quota in 3rd round was granted to the
respondent No. 4 who was eligible for attending 3rd round PG counselling in
terms of relaxation of eligibility criteria to 15th percentile and admittedly, the
respondent No. 4 scored 26.5809089 percentile. It is the case of the
respondent No.4 that once he has been admitted in the 3rd round, the said
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 16
admission cannot be cancelled without any fault or fraud on his part. It is stated
that the petitioner was not eligible at the stage of 3rd round counselling, as her
scored was only 6.8387371. After his selection and admission, the respondent
No. 4 deposited a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- as admission fee and he started
attending classes. It is also stated that the respondent No. 4 was admitted
under the notification dated 21.10.2022 and the respondent No. 4 is also an
employee of the JNIMS. Once respondent No. 4 has been admitted in the PG
course, he cannot be forced to vacate the seat, as he will be disqualified to
appear in further NEET-PG examination as per the bulletin issued for NEETPG (MD/MS) counselling. It is stated that after 3rd round, a candidate who does
not join 3rd round seat may exit with forfeiture of security deposit and
elimination and cannot participate any further counselling conducted by NMC
and a candidate attending round three and not allocated to 3rd round seat can
participate in stray on further round. Since the respondent No.4 has been
allotted a seat in the 3rd round, he cannot attend any further counselling for
NEET-2024.
[35]
Respondent No. 4 has also submitted that he has already
submitted a bond of Rs. 1,39,73,520/- when proceeding for study leave and if
the admission to respondent No. 4 is to be cancelled as prayed for by the
petitioner, it will cause immense hardship and the difficulty to him and he will
not be eligible for appearance in the subsequent NEET entrance examination.
It is also stated that respondent No. 4 has not committed any illegal act while
taking admission and he cannot be compelled to vacate the seat and if any
seat is available, it may be offered to the petitioner.
[36]
The petitioner has filed rejoinder affidavit to the counter affidavit
filed by respondent No. 1 stating that the authority has not issued any
notification treating earlier notifications regarding PG medical course 2024 as
null and void. It is also stated that in admission to PG courses 2023 in JNIMS
under the JNIMS sponsored quota, one Dr. Mekhulshim Tontanga Maring, a
Senior Casualty Medical Officer was allotted to PG seat in Surgery on the
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 17
basis of notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022, as no eligible Senior
Resident was available at that stage. As eligible Senior Resident was
available later on, the JNIMS authority issued an order dated 18.10.2023
cancelling the admission granted to Dr. Mekhulshim Tontanga Maring and in
his place, one Dr. Pukhrambam Kiran Singh, a Senior Resident, was directed
to be admitted under the said notification.
[37]
The petitioner has also filed rejoinder affidavit to the counter
affidavit of respondent Nos. 2 & 3 stating that the Apex Court in the judgment
dated 29.01.2025 does not consider the legality of the JNIMS sponsored
quota and as such, the impugned notice dated 13.03.2025 issued by the
JNIMS authority is without any basis. It is also stated that there is no further
notification issued by the JNIMS authority cancelling the notification dated
16.02.2022 and the notification dated 21.10.2022 and hence, the plea of
respondent Nos. 2 & 3 in their counter affidavit that the notifications stand
superseded in terms of the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, is not tenable.
[38]
The petitioner has filed a short rejoinder affidavit to the counter
affidavit of respondent No. 4 stating that notifications dated 16.02.2022 and
21.10.2022 will be applicable in admission to JNIMS sponsored seats and the
respondent No. 4 who was admitted to undergo PG courses, has to vacate
the seat in favour of the petitioner. It is also stated that there is no rule which
mandate the qualifying service of 10 years after completion of PG courses.
WP(C) No. 295 of 2025:
[39]
The respondent No. 4 in WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 has also filed
another writ petition, i.e., WP(C) No. 295 of 2025 challenging the notification
dated 21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS authority [Annexure-A/34 in WP(C)
No. 218 of 2025].
[40]
Respondent No. 4 is aggrieved by Para (iii) of the notification
dated 21.10.2022 whereby JNIMS has formulated the Scheme for reservation
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 18
of PG seat in JNIMS sponsored seat for Senior Casualty Medical
Officer/Casualty Medical Officer requiring them to vacate the seat in favour of
the teachers at a later stage. This notification is in continuation of the earlier
notification dated 16.02.2022 issued by the JNIMS authority for fixing 14%
seat for JNIMS sponsored candidate which amounts to 4 seats in PG in every
year, where only Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer of
JNIMS are to be considered for admission to PG course in JNIMS against
these 4 seats over the year 2021 to 2025.
[41]
Since the original notification dated 16.02.2022 does not include
the Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer of JNIMS, by the
impugned notification dated 21.10.2022, Senior Casualty Medical Officers/
Casualty Medical Officers are also permitted for taking admission against 14%
seats i.e. 4 seats reserved for JNIMS sponsored candidates, if eligible
candidates from the teacher’s category are not available. In Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022, it is stated that the Senior Casualty Medical
Officer/Casualty Medical Officer who has taken admission against the 4 seats
for JNIMS sponsored candidates, has to surrender the seat; if after lowering
NEET-PG cut off percentile in subsequent round, the regular Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer are eligible. In such
situation, the Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer who
has been allotted a PG seat, has no option other than surrendering the seat.
The respondent No.4 submits that such a condition is very harsh, irrational
and leads to class legislation amongst the equals who have basic MBBS
degree and are employees of the same institute.
[42]
Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 is reproduced as:
“(iii)
Since Sr. Casualty Medical Officers/Casualty Medical
Officers are open to any of the allocated PG seats/subject,
Senior Casualty Medical Officers and Casualty Medical
Officers shall be eligible to join 1st round of PG
Counselling; but allotment of PG seats will be considered
from 2nd round counselling onwards. If eligible candidates
are available from the regular Senior Resident/Tutor/
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 19
Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in the concerned
subject after lowering the NEET-PG cut off percentile in
the subsequent round, the Sr. Casualty Medical
Officer/Casualty Medical Officers who has been allotted
PG Seat must surrender the seat.”
[43]
The respondent No. 4 who has been admitted in the PG course
in Radiodiagnosis in 3rd round of the NEET-PG 2024 Counselling in JNIMS is
liable to surrender the seat in terms of Para (iii) of the Notification dated
21.10.2022. This is the prayer of the petitioner i.e. Dr. Ibetombi Kshetrimayum
in WP(C) No. 218 of 2025, praying for cancelling the seat allotted to the
respondent No. 4 and to consider her case against the seat likely to be
vacated by him.
[44]
The main grounds raised in the writ petition i.e. WP(C) No. 295
of 2025 are that:
(i)
The impugned notification dated 21.10.2022, especially
Para (iii) has been issued by JNIMS authority in arbitrary
exercise of power and in malafide intention only to favour
Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer
over Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical
Officer of JNIMS.
(ii)
There is no reason to discriminate between Senior
Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer over
Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer
of JNIMS, as both categories of employees have MBBS
degree only.
(iii)
If the respondent No. 4 is to surrender the seat, the same
will not be in conformity with the notification of NEET-PG
(MD/MS/DMB) Counselling 2024, information bulletin
issued by the Medical Council of India. If a candidate does
not join 3rd round seat, he cannot participate in any further
round of counselling and also in future examination.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 20
(iv)
The impugned notification dated 21.10.2022 is not tenable
in law because of class legislation amongst the MBBS
Degree holders.
(v)
The impugned notification dated 21.10.2022 is in violation
of the scheme floated by National Board of Counselling of
NEET-PG.
[45]
WP(C) No. 295 of 2025 is listed along with WP(C) No. 218 of
2025 as directed by the Hon’ble Chief Justice on administrative side.
[46]
The State respondents have not filed counter affidavit in WP(C)
No. 295 of 2025 and the petitioner in WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 is not a party in
this writ petition.
[47]
The issues involved in the present case are:
(i)
Whether the Notifications dated 16.02.2022 [AnnexureA/33] and dated 21.10.2022 [Annexure-A/34] issued by
the JNIMS authority regulating the reservation of seats for
JNIMS sponsored candidates in PG course, have been
superseded by the judgment dated 29.01.2022 passed by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 9289 of 2019
in the case of Dr. Tanvi Behl v. Shrey Goel & Ors.
reported as 2025 INSC 125?
(ii)
Whether the respondent No. 4 i.e. Dr. Mutum Anilkumar
Singh
has
to
surrender/vacate
the
PG
seat
in
Radiodiagnosis allotted to him in terms of Para (iii) of the
Notification dated 21.10.2022 [Annexure-A/34]?
(iii)
Whether the Notification dated 21.10.2022 [AnnexureA/34] is unreasonable and ultra vires of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India as far as it makes a class legislation
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 21
amongst the equals, ie, the employees of JNIMS holding
MBBS degree?
(iv)
Whether the plea of the respondent No.4 challenging Para
(iii) of the Notification dated 21.10.2022 [Annexure-A/34]
after obtaining benefit under Para (i) of the same
Notification, is hit by the principle of approbate and
reprobate?
(v)
What is the power of High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution, in exceptional circumstances, for moulding
relief to do complete justice to the parties in the litigation?
Petitioner’s Contentions:
[48]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, draws
the attention of this Court to the notification dated 16.02.2022 issued by the
JNIMS known as Time Scale Promotion (Regularly appointed Senior
Residents/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady
Medical
Officer
possessing
Post
Graduate Degree) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2022. By this rule, an amendment
was incorporated in Rule 7(d) whereby 14% of the State Open Quota in PG
course
in
JNIMS
will
be
reserved
for
teachers
i.e.
Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in each session and in
order to be eligible for PG seats reservation under this rule, the teacher must
qualify NEET-PG examination. The teachers can only be considered for the
seats concerning their departments.
[49]
The reservation of seat will be done in the same department in
which seat the teachers are working. If any teacher’s quota is not filled up due
to non-availability of teachers, the vacant seat will be filled up from the State
merit list and this reservation will be valid for 5 years i.e. from 2021-20225 and
14% of the State Open Quota comes to be 4 seats. These 4 seats are
distributed over 11 departments from the year 2021-2025 with 4 seats every
year and for the year 2024, one seat each has been reserved for Medicine,
OBG, Pathology and Radiodiagnosis.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 22
[50]
of
The petitioner is working as Senior Resident in the department
Radiodiagnosis
in
JNIMS.
Since
the
Senior
Casualty
Medical
Officers/Casualty Medical Officers are not included in the notification dated
16.02.2022, vide another notification dated 21.10.2022 JNIMS framed a
Scheme for reservation of PG seats in JNIMS for Senior Casualty Medical
Officer/Casualty Medical Officer, JNIMS. Such Officers are eligible to compete
in 14% seats i.e. 4 seats reserved for JNIMS sponsored candidates, in view
of Para (i) of the notification due to non-availability of eligible teachers.
However, Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 requires Senior
Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer, who has taken admission
in 4 reserved seats for teachers in JNIMS, has to surrender/vacate the seat
in favor of the regularly appointed Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady
Medical Officer when they are eligible in subsequent round on reduction of
NEET-PG cut off percentile.
[51]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, further
submits that respondent No. 4, a Senior Casualty Medical Officer in JNIMS,
was admitted in 3rd round with percentile score of 26.5809089 when the
NEET-PG percentile was fixed at 15% by the Central Authority. He was
provisionally selected and admitted vide notifications dated 04.02.2025 and
10.02.2025 issued by the JNIMS and was admitted in PG course in
Radiodiagnosis against one of the 4 seats reserved for JNIMS sponsored
teachers/candidates. However, after reduction of NEET-PG minimum
eligibility criteria vide notification dated 25.02.2025 to 5th percentile by the
National Board of Examination, the petitioner became eligible for appearing in
counselling and admission for PG course in Radiodiagnosis. Subsequently,
vide letter dated 26.02.2025 and by subsequent representation, the petitioner
requested to the authority that she be called for counselling and the
respondent No. 4 be directed to vacate the seat in terms of Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 23
[52]
The petitioner, being a Senior Resident in JNIMS, is
subsequently eligible for the same seat. However, vide impugned notification
dated 11.03.2025, JNIMS authority has issued a fresh notification cancelling
earlier notification for Special Stray Vacancy Round State Level PG
Counselling by merging all vacant seats to all India Merit List in terms of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court judgment dated 29.01.2025 in Civil appeal No. 9289
of 2019. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner, submits that the stand of
the State respondent as well as JNIMS authority to the effect that the
notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS for
reserving 4 seats for JNIMS sponsored candidates have been superseded by
the judgment dated 29.01.2019 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, is without any
basis. In fact, these two notifications were never considered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. The issue before the Hon’ble Supreme Court was the
permissibility of the resident-based reservation in PG course in medicine. In
para 33 of the judgment, it was observed that for any PG course in Medicine,
the resident-based reservation was held to be impermissible while upholding
institution-based reservation.
[53]
It is submitted that 4 seats reserved for JNIMS Teachers are
under the notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 and these seats are
nothing but institution-based reservation. The stand of the State respondent
and JNIMS that the judgment dated 29.01.2025 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Dr. Tanvi Behl (supra) has superseded these two notifications,
is not tenable and without any basis. It is stated that the notifications dated
16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 are still valid and subsisting.
[54]
It is also pointed out that the respondent No. 4 has been admitted
in PG course in terms of the notification dated 21.10.2022, as none of the
Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer of JNIMS were
eligible in the 3rd round of the counselling. However, as per Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022, the petitioner who is a Senior Resident in
JNIMS in Radiodiagnosis, is now eligible on reduction of the NEET-PG
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 24
eligibility criteria to 5th percentile. Admittedly, the petitioner scored 6.8387371
percentile. It is also stated that as per Schedule-I of the notification dated
16.02.2022, Radiodiagnosis has one seat reserved in the year 2024 only for
the period of five years from 2021 to 2025. If the petitioner is not adjusted
against the only seat reserved for the subject Radiodiagnosis throughout the
period of 5 years i.e. 2021-2025, she may not get the benefit of the scheme
at all although the same has been formulated for employees like her.
[55]
Further, Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, draws the attention of this Court that the notifications dated
16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 have neither been revoked nor cancelled by any
competent authority and have not been set aside by any court of competent
jurisdiction. The respondent No. 4, having taken advantage of the benefit
under Para (i) of the notification dated 21.10.2022, now cannot challenge
legality of Para (iii) the notification and the same is hit by the principle of
approbate and reprobate.
[56]
During the course of hearing, Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner, produced a letter dated 21.05.2025 submitted by
one Dr. Md. Mosmir, who took admission in PG in General Medicine in JNIMS
as per NEET-PG examination 2024, submitted his resignation from PG course
due to personal reason. In the alternate, Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner, submits that instead of cancellation of admission of
the respondent No. 4, he may be shifted to the subsequent vacant seat in PG
course in Medicine and the petitioner may be considered against the seat to
be vacated by respondent No. 4 in terms of Para (iii) of the notification dated
21.10.2022. It is emphasised that the reservation of 4 seats for JNIMS
sponsored candidates in terms of notifications dated 16.02.2022 and
21.10.2022 cannot be termed as a resident-based reservation so to attract the
bar imposed in the judgment dated 29.01.2025 passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Dr. Tanvi Behl case (supra).
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 25
[57]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, draws
the attention of this Court to an order dated 28.02.2025 passed by this Court
in MC(WP(C) No. 136 of 2024 [Ref: WP(C) No. 740 of 2023] where in an
exactly similarly situation, one Dr. Mekhulshim Tontanga Maring, a Senior
Casualty Medical Officer who was admitted under the same notification dated
21.10.2022 was shifted to another vacant seat in Surgery Department and one
Dr. Pukhrambam Kiran Singh, a Senior Resident in Surgery Department was
admitted in PG course in his place in terms of Para (iii) of the notification.
[58]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner refers to the following
case law in support of his submission:
(i)
(2013)10 SCC 237 [Nikhil Himthani v. State of
Uttarkhand]: Institutional based reservation in post
graduate course in medicine is permissible, if the same is
not resident-based criteria.
(ii)
(1984) 4 SCC 654 [Pradeep Jain v. Union of India]:
Domicile and residence are different concept.
(iii)
(2003) 7 SCC 83 [State of MP v. Gopal D. Tirthani]: 20%
reservation for in-service candidates in PG medical course
was upheld.
(iv)
(2014) 11 SCC 456 [Vishal Goyal v. State of
Karnataka]:
Impermissibility of the resident-based
reservation disguised as institutional-based reservation.
(v)
AIR 2013 SC 1241: (2013) 5 SCC 470 [Rajasthan State
Industrial Development and Investment Corporation &
Anr. Vs. Diamond and Gem Development Corporation
Ltd. & Anr.]: A party cannot be permitted to “blow hotblow cold”, “fast and loose” or “approbate and reprobate”
where one accepts the benefits of a contract or
conveyance or an order, he is estopped from denying the
validity of or binding effect of such contract, or
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 26
conveyance, or order upon himself. This rule is applied to
ensure equity.
Official Respondents’ Contentions:
[59]
Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General, submits that para
33 of Dr. Tanvi Behl case (supra) held that resident-based reservation is
impermissible in PG medical course. However, reservation can be made for
institution-based seat. Learned A.G. further submits that it is stand of the State
and official respondents that the notifications dated 16.02.2022 and
21.10.2022 of reserving 4 seats for JNIMS sponsored candidates in PG
course in JNIMS, have been superseded by the judgment in Dr. Tanvi Behl
case (supra). However, learned AG fairly concedes that on plain reading of
para 33 of the judgment, it is ample clear that what has been barred is only
resident-based admission in PG in Medicine. However, the same para 33
permits institution-based admission in PG course in Medicine.
[60]
Learned AG has pointed out that on minute scrutiny of the two
notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS reserving
4 seats in PG course for JNIMS teachers, the same are not based on
residence criterion, rather these two notifications provide strictly institutionbased reservation for JNIMS employees in PG course and hence, the stand
of the official respondents in their pleadings may not strictly be in conformity
with the decision of Dr. Tanvi Behl case (supra).
[61]
Learned AG refers to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reported as (1992) 4 SCC 683 para 10: R N Gosain v. Yashpal Dhir that law
does not permit a person both to approbate and reprobate in the same
transaction. However, learned AG submits that once the respondent No. 4 has
taken admission in PG course in Radiodiagnosis in terms of the benefit under
Para (i) of the notification dated 21.10.2022, now he cannot challenge Para
(iii) of the same notification as contrary to law and in violation of Article 14 of
the Constitution. Further, learned AG submits that with the subsequent
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 27
development of existence of one vacant seat in PG course in the subject
General Medicine in JNIMS, this Court may pass appropriate order
considering the peculiar facts of the case and without strictly going into the
merit of the case.
Respondent No.4’s Contentions:
[62]
Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel for respondent No. 4, submits
that respondent No. 4 was admitted in the 3rd round counselling based on
merit and on the date of 3rd round counselling, i.e., on 03.02.2025, the
petitioner was not eligible for appearing in the counselling for 3 rd round. The
petitioner was eligible only in 5th round, i.e., Special Stay Round where the
minimum eligibility criteria for NEET-PG was reduced to 5th percentile. Both
the petitioner and the respondent No.4 are employees of JNIMS and there is
no rational behind discriminating against the Senior Casualty Medical Officer/
Casualty Medical Officer like the respondent No.4, in favour of the Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in JNIMS like the petitioner
herein. After his successful selection and admission in the PG course in
Radiodiagnosis in JNIMS on the basis of the 3rd round counselling, the
respondent No.4 has deposited a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- as admission fee and
also executed a bond of Rs. 1,39,73,520/- for study leave w.e.f. 10.02.2025
for completing PG course.
[63]
It is submitted that if the admission of the respondent No. 4 is
cancelled as prayed for by the petitioner, it will cause immense hardship and
inconvenience to the respondent No.4, as he will not be eligible for appearing
any further NEET-PG examination and amount deposited as admission fee
and bond for study leave would be forfeited. If this Court is to consider
subsequent vacant seat of General Medicine PG in JNIMS as vacated by one
Dr. Md. Mosmir, the same may be allotted to the petitioner. At this stage,
having already attended classes in Radiodiagnosis for 3 or 4 months, it will be
improper and unjust to the respondent No. 4 to shift him to another subject in
the mid-course.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 28
[64]
It is also stated that the respondent No. 4 has filed another writ
petition being WP(C) No. 295 of 2025 challenging the validity and arbitrariness
of the notification dated 21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS, framing a scheme
for admission to PG course for reserving seat for PG course for Senior
Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer. It is stated that Para (iii) of
the notification dated 21.10.2022 is arbitrary, without any basis and
discriminatory against similarly situated persons in favour of the Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer in JNIMS against the
Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer in JNIMS. It is
pointed out that both the categories are employees of JNIMS and have the
same degree, i.e., MBBS.
[65]
It is also stated that the respondent No. 4 has a legitimate
expectation of continuing the PG course and the principle of estoppel will
apply against the JNIMS authority. Once the respondent No. 4 has been
admitted in the PG course in terms of rules and on his own merit, it is urged
that he cannot be asked to vacate the seat at the later stage, in absence of
any mala fide or fraudulent act alleged against him.
[66]
Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel for the respondent No. 4, also
submits that in the subsequent order, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
protected the previous admission granted prior to the judgment of Dr. Tanvi
Behl case and as such, admission of the respondent No. 4 is also protected
by the said order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
[67]
Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel for respondent No. 4, relies on
the decisions in the following case law in support of her submission:
(i)
(1948) 1 KB 223 [Associated Provincial Picture
Houses, Limited v. Wednesbury Corporation]: In this
case the rule of Wednesbury was established where Court
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 29
can interfere with the administrative action or decision if
the same is unreasonable and without any basis.
(ii)
(2001) 2 SCC 386 [Om Kumar v. Union of India]: Article
14 of the Constitution provides that administrative action
can be struck down on the ground of unreasonableness,
discriminatory, arbitrary applying the Wednesbury Rule.
(iii)
(1994) Legal Eagle (SC) 1021: (1995) 1 CC 478 [M/s
New Horizons Limited & Anr. vs. Union of India &
Ors.]: Judicial review is applicable even in the field of
contractual power by the Government bodies on the basis
of Wednesbury Principle of reasonableness.
(iv)
Indian Kanoon-http:/indiankanoon.org/doc/27422/ [V.
Ramana vs. A.P.S.R.T.C & Ors.]: While examining
administrative action, the Court is to examine whether the
order is rational or reasonable and the test of Wednesbury
will be applicable.
(v)
(1994) AIR SCW 3344 [Tata Cellular v. Union of India]:
Although there may be a judicial restraint, the Court can
exercise judicial review if the power of the government in
contractual matter is arbitrary, by applying the principle of
Wednesbury rule.
(vi)
1978 Legal Eagle (SC) 388: (1979) 2 SCC 409 [Motilal
Padampat Sugar Mills Company Limited vs. State of
U.P. & Ors.]: Where the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
the doctrine of promissory estoppel is applicable against
the State authority.
(viii)
(2021) 10 SCC 116 [Somesh Thapiyal v. HNB Garhwal
University]: Hon’ble Supreme Court has taken judicial
note of unequal bargaining power between the employer
and the employee who is to accept the terms of
appointment/contract without any protest.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 30
[68]
In the present case, the respondent No. 4 has no bargaining
power while accepting the admission for PG course in terms of the notification
dated 21.10.2022 and this aspect has to be considered by this Court.
Analysis & Reasoning of the Court:
[69]
This Court has considered the materials on record, especially the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Tanvi Behl (supra);
the notifications dated 16.02.20222 [Annexure-A/33] and dated 21.10.2022
[Annexure-A/34] issued by the JNIMS reserving 4 seats for JNIMS sponsored
candidates, especially for the teachers and Casualty Medical Officer; the
scheme of counselling for NEET-PG 2024 issued by National Board of
Medical Examination; other related documents; and the relevant case law. On
careful examination of para 33 of Dr. Tanvi Behl case (supra), it is ample
clear that the Hon’ble Supreme Court held the resident-based reservation in
PG course in Medicine as impermissible, while upholding the institutionalbased reservation.
[70]
In the present case, the notifications dated 16.02.2022 and dated
21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS provide for reservation in favour of JNIMS
employees. In fact, it is an institution-based reservation made by the above
notifications, where 4 seats are reserved for teachers in JNIMS in 11
subjects/courses during the year 2021-2025 and the Senior Casualty Medical
Officer/Casualty Medical Officer in JNIMS can also be considered under the
said scheme of reserving 4 seats for JNIMS employees. However, in terms of
Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022, they have to vacate/surrender
the seat once the Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer
are found eligible in subsequent round after reduction of eligibility criteria of
NEET-PG percentile by the authority. This Court is of the considered view that
these two notifications cannot be termed as resident-based reservation, rather
they are institution-based reservation. Hence, the decision in Dr. Tanvi Behl
case (supra) of non-permissibility of admission in PG course in Medicine on
the basis of residence, will not be attracted to the schemes as alleged by the
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 31
JNIMS. This fact has rightly been admitted by the learned AG in the course of
his submission, even if the same is contrary to the pleadings of the official
respondents.
[71]
dated
This Court is conscious of fact that Para (iii) of the notification
21.10.2022
is
heavily
loaded
in
favour
of
the
Senior
Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer and seems to be
discriminatory against the Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical
Officer in JNIMS to the extent that latter have to surrender their seats, if the
teachers (like the petitioner) are eligible in subsequent round of NEET-PG
counselling on reduction of eligibility criteria. However, this harsh condition
has not been revoked and withdrawn by any competent authority, nor set
aside by any competent court till date. In spite of this discriminatory nature,
the respondent No. 4 has consciously taken admission in PG course in
Radiodiagnosis in JNIMS sponsored quota under Para (i) of the notification
dated 21.10.2022. Subsequently, when the NEET-PG eligibility criteria is
reduced to 5th percentile, the petitioner becomes eligible for admission in PG
course against the seat of Radiodiagnosis allotted to the respondent No.4 and
the same is liable to be vacated by him in terms of Para (iii) of the notification
dated 21.10.2022.
[72]
If strict interpretation of rules is adopted, the respondent No. 4
has to vacate the seat in terms of Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022.
In the previous year, the JNIMS issued orders cancelling the admission of
persons like the respondent No. 4 herein on the basis of Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022, when teachers such as Senior Resident/Tutor/
Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer are eligible in subsequent round of
counselling upon reduction of NEET-PG eligibility criteria.
[73]
In the present case, the JNIMS authority has not exercised such
power on the assumption that the judgment dated 29.01.2025 of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Dr. Tanvi Behl case (supra) has abrogated the
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 32
notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 issued by the JNIMS reserving
4 seats for JNIMS employees in PG medical course.
Principle of Approbate And Reprobate:
[74]
In the case of Workmen v. Food Corpn. of India: (2023) 8 SCC
116, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a person cannot accept and reject the
same thing in the same transaction. Para 16 is reproduced below:
“16. In Union of India v. N. Murugesan: (2022) 2 SCC 25, this Court
pointed out that the phrases “approbate” and “reprobate” mean that
no party can be allowed to accept and reject the same thing, as the
principle behind the doctrine of election is in-built in the concept of
approbate and reprobate, that is, a person cannot be allowed to
have the benefit of an instrument while questioning the same. It was
noted that an element of fair play is in-built in this principle and it is
a species of estoppel dealing with the conduct of a party.”
[75]
The decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Tajvir
Singh Sodhi & Ors. v. State of Jammu & Kashmir & ors (2023 SCC Online
SC344) has clearly explained on the concept of the approbate and reprobate
and the relevant portions are reproduced as follows:“29. It was averred that persons who participated in the
selection process and interview cannot challenge the same
upon being unsuccessful since they do not have a cause to
challenge the same and a writ petition filed by them is not
maintainable, vide Madan Lal; Anupal Singh v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, (2020) 2 SCC 173; Sadananda Halo and Mohd.
Mustafa. Reliance was also placed on D. Sarojakumari v. R.
Helen Thilakom, (2017) 9 SCC 478. That in the present case,
none of the writ petitioners was selected on merit and they were
not even on the waiting list, therefore, the writ petitions filed by
them were not maintainable on the ground of the same being
devoid of any locus.
“67. Thus, Courts while exercising the power of judicial
review cannot step into the shoes of the Selection
Committee or assume an appellate role to examine
whether the marks awarded by the Selection Committee
in the viva-voce are excessive and not corresponding to
their performance in such test. The assessment and
evaluation of the performance of candidates appearing
before the Selection Committee/Interview Board should
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 33
be best left to the members of the committee. In light of
the position that a Court cannot sit in appeal against the
decision taken pursuant to a reasonably sound selection
process, the following grounds raised by the writ
petitioners, which are based on an attack of subjective
criteria employed by the selection board/interview panel
in assessing the sustainability of candidates, namely,
(i)that the candidates who had done their post-graduation
had been awarded 10 marks and in the viva-voce, such
PG candidates had been granted either 18 marks or 20
marks out of 20. (ii) that although the writ petitioners had
performed exceptionally well in the interview, the
authorities had acted in an arbitrary manner while
carrying out the selection process, would not hold any
water.
“69. It is therefore trite that candidates, having taken
part in the selection process without any demur or
protest, cannot challenge the same after having been
declared unsuccessful. The candidates cannot
approbate and reprobate at the same time. In other
words, simply because the result of the selection
process is not palatable to a candidate, he cannot
allege that the process of interview was unfair or that
there was some lacuna in the process. Therefore, we
find that the writ petitioners in these cases, could not
have questioned before a Court of law, the rationale
behind recasting the selection criteria, as they
willingly took part in the selection process even after
the criteria had been so recast. Their candidature
was not withdrawn in light of the amended criteria. A
challenge was thrown against the same only after
they had been declared unsuccessful in the selection
process, at which stage, the challenge ought not to
have been entertained in light of the principle of
waiver and acquiescence.
[76]
In the case of Bhagwat Sharan v. Purushottam: (2020) 6 SCC
387, Hon’ble Supreme Court considered the concept of approbate and
reprobate and held that a person who has taken benefit of a portion of a will
cannot challenge the remaining portion of the will. This is based on the
principles of equity, election, acquiesces and estoppel. Relevant para are
reproduced below for ready reference:
“26. It is also not disputed that the plaintiff and Defendants 1 to 3
herein filed suit for eviction of an occupant in which he claimed that
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 34
the property had been bequeathed to him by Hari Ram. According
to the defendants, the plaintiff having accepted the will of Hariram
and having taken benefit of the same, cannot turn around and urge
that the will is not valid and that the entire property is a joint family
property. The plaintiff and Defendants 1 to 3 by accepting the
bequest under the will elected to accept the will. It is trite law that a
party cannot be permitted to approbate and reprobate at the same
time. This principle is based on the principle of doctrine of election.
In respect of wills, this doctrine has been held to mean that a person
who takes benefit of a portion of the will cannot challenge the
remaining portion of the will. In Rajasthan State Industrial
Development & Investment Corpn. v. Diamond & Gem
Development Corpn. Ltd.11, this Court made an observation that a
party cannot be permitted to “blow hot and cold”, “fast and loose” or
“approbate and reprobate”. Where one party knowingly accepts the
benefits of a contract or conveyance or an order, it is estopped to
deny the validity or binding effect on him of such contract or
conveyance or order.
27. The doctrine of election is a facet of law of estoppel. A party
cannot blow hot and blow cold at the same time. Any party which
takes advantage of any instrument must accept all that is mentioned
in the said document. It would be apposite to refer to the treatise
Equity—A Course of Lectures by F.W. Maitland, Cambridge
University, 1947, wherein the learned author succinctly described
principle of election in the following terms:
“The doctrine of election may be thus stated : that he who
accepts a benefit under a deed or will or other instrument must
adopt the whole contents of that instrument, must conform to
all its provisions and renounce all rights that are inconsistent
with it….”
This view has been accepted to be the correct view in Karam
Kapahi v. Lal Chand Public Charitable Trust12. The plaintiff
having elected to accept the will of Hari Ram, by filing a suit
for eviction of the tenant by claiming that the property had been
bequeathed to him by Hari Ram, cannot now turn around and
say that the averments made by Hari Ram that the property
was his personal property, is incorrect.”
(2013) 5 SCC 470 : (2013) 3 SCC (Civ) 153 : AIR 2013 SC 1241
(2010) 4 SCC 753 : (2010) 2 SCC (Civ) 262
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 35
[77]
This Court is of the opinion that the respondent No. 4 will have
an independent right of challenging Para (iii) of the notification dated
21.10.2022 on the ground that the same is discriminatory against the Senior
Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical Officer like him. In the peculiar
facts of the case, once he has taken admission in PG course against the seat
reserved for Senior Resident/Tutor/Demonstrator/Lady Medical Officer under
Para (i) of the notification dated 21.10.2022, it may not be proper for him to
challenge Para (iii) of the same notification on the ground that the condition
for surrendering the seat by Senior Casualty Medical Officer/Casualty Medical
Officer is arbitrary, discriminatory, harsh and without any basis. The same will
be barred by the principle of approbate and reprobate.
[78]
Accordingly, this Court is not considering WP(C) No. 295 of 2024
in the present form and the same is left to be considered later on confined to
the general ground of arbitrariness and irrationality in violation of the principle
of equality as enshrined in the Article 14 of the Constitution of India and not to
the particular ground that the condition requiring the respondent No. 4 to
vacate the seat allotted to him is arbitrary. The petitioner herein who is a
Senior Resident, claims her right of admission in the PG course in
Radiodiagnosis as per Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 against
the seat adjusted in favour of respondent No. 4 in terms of Para (i) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022. The petitioner has also a legitimate right of
expectation for admission as per the prevailing rules. Her right has also to be
considered vis-à-vis the interest of the respondent No.4.
[79]
As observed above, the reservation under the notifications dated
16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022 providing 4 seats for JNIMS teachers has not
been set aside by any competent Court nor repealed by the authority and such
institutional-based reservation has been upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Para 33 of Dr. Tanvi Behl Case (supra). By strict and literal
interpretation of the statutory rules, the respondent No. 4 is likely to lose his
seat in PG course in Radiodiagnosis course in JNIMS in which he has been
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 36
admitted in terms of Para (i) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 in the 3rd
round of counselling. By Para (iii) of the same notification, the petitioner is to
be considered against the seat to be vacated by respondent No. 4.
[80]
If the writ petition is allowed, it will cause immense hardship,
inconvenience and loss of academic year to the respondent No. 4. If the writ
petition is dismissed, it will also cause injustice to the petitioner as she has a
right to be considered for admission in PG course in Radiodiagnosis in terms
of the notification dated 16.02.2022, especially in view of Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022. In the present case, this Court is dealing with
the conflicting rights of two persons claiming under the same rules. While
deciding this case, the Court has to find a mid-way where both parties can
have something. Deciding the issues involved herein on merit may not be a
good option, where there is a likelihood of the contesting parties becoming a
victim in the process of adjudication.
[81]
It may be apposite to refer a decision in the case of Vikram
Dhillon v. State of Haryana: (2007) 9 SCC 408, where Hon’ble Supreme
Court was reluctant to cancel the admission given to a less meritorious
candidate in BDS course at a later stage.
[82]
It may be noted that the scheme of reservation under original
notification dated 16.02.2022 [Annexure-A/33] is valid for only 5 years i.e. from
2021-2025 and 4 seats are distributed amongst 11 seats under Schedule-I of
the notification dated 16.02.2022. The subject of Radiodiagnosis has got only
one seat in the year 2024 during the period of five years (i.e., 2021-2025),
where other subjects like Medicine got 4 seats over the period of 5 years. If
the petitioner is not considered this year, she will not get any chance to be
considered under the scheme in the next year also. The Senior Residents are
assigned to different departments and the petitioner is in the department of
Radiodiagnosis since the date of her initial appointment. As per the rules, she
can only to be considered for PG in Radiodiagnosis course as stipulated by
Para 2(III) of the notification dated 16.02.2022 [Annexure-P/33]. On the other
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 37
hand, the respondent No. 4, a Senior Casualty Medical Officer who has not
been assigned to any particular department except the Casualty, can be
adjusted in any subject.
[83]
Learned AG has admitted the existence of one subsequent
vacant seat in PG course in General Medicine in JNIMS as surrendered by
one Dr. Md. Mosmir in the 2024 session.
Moulding of Relief:
[84]
In a recent judgment of J. Ganapatha and Ors. vs. N.
Selvarajalou Chetty Trust and Ors.: MANU/SC/0387/2025: 2025 INSC 395,
Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the concept of moulding of relief as an
exception in a proceeding based on the facts and circumstances of the case,
even if the relief granted was not actually prayed for. While applying the rule,
utmost care ought to be taken so as not to cause injustice and prejudice to
any party. Relevant para is reproduced below:
“20. The concept of moulding of relief refers to the ability of a court to
modify or shape a relief sought by a party in a legal proceeding based
on the circumstances of the case and the facts established after a fullfledged trial. The principle enables the court to grant appropriate
remedies even if the relief requested in the pleading is not exact or
could not be considered by the court or changed circumstances have
rendered the relief obsolete. The court aims that justice is served while
taking into account the evolving nature of a case. The above road map
is pursued by a court based on the notion of flexibility in relief,
equitable jurisdiction, and is tempered by judicial discretion. When
moulding the relief, the court considers the issues and circumstances
established during the full-fledged trial, looks at shortening the
litigation, and then in its perspective, renders complete justice to the
issue at hand. The converse of the above is that the moulded relief
should not take the aggrieved party by surprise or cause prejudice.
The relief is moulded as an exception and not as a matter of course.”
[85]
In the case of Shivanna and Ors. v. B.S. Puttamadaiah (Dead)
through L.Rs.: MANU/SC/1462/2023, Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated the
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 38
principles of moulding of relief as an exception to do complete justice to the
parties. Relevant para are quoted below for easy understanding:
“11. The submission made by Mr. Sharanagowda Patil, learned
Counsel appearing for the Appellants and Mr. Ashwin v. Kotemath,
learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents are considered. What
is important to note here is that the First Appellate Court declared title
in favour of the Defendant although the Defendant never put forth any
such claim in the Civil Suit. The suit was filed by the Plaintiff seeking
declaration and injunction and the Appellate Court after dismissing the
suit could not have then issued the declaration of title and possession,
in favour of the Defendant, particularly when the Defendant never
claimed any such relief from the Civil Court. It is well-settled in law that
the principle of moulding of reliefs could at best be applied as an
exception. This Court in Om Prakash Gupta v. Ranbir B.
Goyal, MANU/SC/0035/2002 : 2002 INSC 35 : (2002) 2 SCC 256 laid
down the following conditions where the relief could be moulded:
11. The ordinary Rule of civil law is that the rights of the parties
stand crystallised on the date of the institution of the suit and,
therefore, the decree in a suit should accord with the rights of the
parties as they stood at the commencement of the lis. However,
the Court has power to take note of subsequent events and
mould the relief accordingly subject to the following conditions
being satisfied:
(i) that the relief, as claimed originally has, by reason of
subsequent events, become inappropriate or cannot be granted;
(ii) that taking note of such subsequent event or changed
circumstances would shorten litigation and enable complete
justice being done to the parties; and
(iii) that such subsequent event is brought to the notice of the
court promptly and in accordance with the Rules of procedural
law so that the opposite party is not taken by surprise.”
[86]
Keeping in mind the principle of moulding of relief as an
exceptional measure so as to do complete justice to the contesting rights of
both parties and without going to the merit of the case, this Court is of the
considered view that it will suffice, just and proper if respondent No. 4 is
adjusted against the PG seat in Medicine vacated by one Dr. Md. Mosmir in
terms of the letter dated 21.05.2025 in PG in Medicine in JNIMS and in the
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 39
seat of PG in Radiodiagnosis to be vacated by the respondent No. 4, the
petitioner and similarly situated candidates, i.e., the Senior Residents and
other teachers in JNIMS in Radiodiagnosis department are to be considered.
It may be noted that the petitioner has also filed an affidavit dated 05.05.2025
affirming on oath that she is the only Senior Resident working in the
Radiodiagnosis department of JNIMS, indirectly implying that she is the only
eligible candidate under the notifications dated 16.02.2022 and 21.10.2022.
This fact may be ascertained by the authority.
[87]
This Court has been apprised by Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner of an order dated 28.02.2025 passed by this Court
in MC(WP(C) No. 136 of 2024 [Ref: WP(C) No. 740 of 2023] where one Dr.
Mekhulshim Tontanga Maring, a Senior Casualty Medical Officer of JNIMS
admitted under Para (i) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 [Annexure-A/34]
and a person similarly situated as the respondent No.4 herein, was adjusted
against the subsequent vacant seat and a Senior Resident (like the petitioner
herein) was directed to be admitted in the seat vacated by the Senior Casualty
Medical Officer as per Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022. The
above referred order was also passed to adjust both parties in the peculiar
facts of the case.
[88]
This Court is conscious of the fact that respondent No. 4 may
face some difficulties in shifting to another course in Medicine from the
Radiodiagnosis in mid-way. However, this will be a consolation and a lesser
evil against the possibility of cancellation of his seat looming over his head as
Damocles’ sword, if the matter is to be considered on merit.
[89]
With these observations and directions, the official respondents
are directed to adjust the admission of the respondent No. 4 in PG course in
Radiodiagnosis subject against the subsequent vacant PG seat in Medicine
in JNIMS as surrendered by one Dr. Md. Mosmir on personal ground and the
petitioner and other eligible candidates, if any, as per Para (iii) of the
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 40
notification dated 21.10.2022, be considered for admission in PG seat in
Radiodiagnosis. It is made clear that the respondent No.4 is not required to
pay any fee for fresh admission and all payments made by him for admission
in PG for Radiodiagnosis will be adjusted against the new seat. The bond
submitted by him will be valid for the new subject. The respondent No.4 is
liable to pay future fee and charges only.
[90]
It is clarified that this is one-off exercise undertaken by this Court
in exercise of its extraordinary power under Article 226 of the Constitution for
doing complete justice by keeping in mind the interest of both the petitioner
and respondent No. 4. While taking this decision as an exception, this Court
considers the fact that the petitioner is having only one opportunity in the year
2024 over the period of 5 years for admission in Radiodiagnosis course and
also the difficulty to be faced by the respondent No.4, if his admission to be
cancelled. This exceptional endeavour is not to be treated as a precedent and
this exercise is resorted to for doing complete justice to both parties in the
peculiar facts of the present case.
[91]
Since the scheme is valid for up to 2025, the JNIMS authority
has the liberty to re-consider the problematic portion of Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022 [Annexure-A/34] which requires the Senior
Casualty Medical Officer/ Casualty Medical Officer to surrender the seat at a
later stage in favour of the teachers. This Court is not passing any direction in
this regard.
[92]
With the above observations and directions, WP(C) No. 218 of
2025 is disposed of. The direction for adjustment of the seat for the respondent
No.4 to Medicine and the consideration of the petitioner’s request for
admission in PG seat in Radiodiagnosis be completed as expeditiously as
possible keeping in mind the stage of the present semester.
[93]
Send a copy of this order to the Director, JNIMS for necessary
information and compliance.
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 41
[94]
It is made clear that this Court does not express any opinion on
the merit of the case about the legality or otherwise of Para (iii) of the
notification dated 21.10.2022.
[95]
List WP(C) No. 295 of 2025 on 09.07.2025 for consideration of
the legality of Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 as raised by the
respondent No.4 herein on the general ground of arbitrariness and violation of
the principle of equality as enshrined in the Article 14 of the Constitution.
Respondents may file counter affidavit on or before the next date.
[96]
It is also made clear that the pendency of WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
shall not be an impediment to the JNIMS authority, if it so desires, to modify
Para (iii) of the notification dated 21.10.2022 to make it more balance.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Kh. Joshua Maring
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
Digitally signed
by KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2025.06.11
16:55:11 +05'30'
WP(C) No. 218 of 2025 with WP(C) No. 295 of 2025
Page 42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review