The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. As an uphold of these discussions, this Court finds that the appellant is entitled to succeed. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed and the appellant is granted enhanced compensation as follows:a) The income of the appellant is fixed at Rs.58,062/-. b) The loss of earning is fixed at Rs.3,86,768/(Rs.58,062/- x 8 – Rs.77,728/-). c) compensation towards permanent disability: Rs.13,53,285/- (Rs.58,062/- x 12 x 11 x 20 / 100 – Rs.1,79,552/-. d) An addiditional compensation towards Pain and Suffering is fixed at Rs.15,000/-. e) An addiditional compensation towards Loss of amenities is fixed at Rs.15,000/-. Thus, the appellants are entitled for a total amount of Rs. 17,70,053 /- (Rupees Seventeen Lakhs Seventy Thousand Fifty Three only) as an enhanced compensation with interest at 8% 2025:KER:25905 MACA NO. 425 OF 2021 from 19.09.2018 till realisation and proportionate cost. The Insurance Company shall deposit the amount within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment, directly to the bank account of the appellant. The appellant shall furnish his bank account details to the insurance company for enabling the insurance company to transfer the amount. The appeal is ordered accordingly. Sd/EASWARAN S. mea 2025:KER:25905 MACA NO. 425 OF 2021 Annexure II SERVICE CERTIFICATE DATED.17.02.2021 ISSUED BY DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF, IDUKKI
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 /28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED IN OPMV NO.586 OF 2017 OF
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT & MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,
THODUPUZHA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
HUSSAIN RAWTHER
AGED 57 YEARS
S/O. THAJUDEEN, PUTHUMANAKAL HOUSE, KEETTILA KARA,
KANJAR P.O, PIN 685 590 ARAKKULAM VILLAGE,
THODUPUZHA TALUK.
BY ADV N.M.MOHAMMED AYUB
SRI.P.V.SHAMSUDDIN
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
JAISON @ ANISH
AGED 34 YEARS
S/O. HENRY, THADATHIMACKAL HOUSE, MECHAL KARA,
VALAKOM BHAGOM, MOONNILAVU VILLAGE, MEENACHIL TALUK,
KOTTAYAM DISTRICT (OWNER CUM DRIVER OF THE MOTOR
CYCLE BEARING REG NO. KL-01-AL-7947)
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, PUTHETTU ARCADE,
KOTTARAMATTOM, PALA, PIN 686 578
BY ADV SRI.RAJAN P.KALIYATH
THIS
MOTOR
ACCIDENT
CLAIMS
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD ON 19.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 19th day of March, 2025
The appeal is filed by the claimant in O.P. (M.V.) No.
586 of 2017 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
Thodupuzha.
2.
The appellant, a driver in the grade of Sub-
Inspector of Police in the Police Department at AR Camp
Nandavanam, met with an accident on 02.12.2016 at about
5.45 PM, while he was walking through Muttom-Thodupuzha
public road and when he reached near Muttom Co-operative
Bank, the offending motor cycle bearing Registration No.KL-01AL-7947 came from Erattupetta Bhagam in a rash and
negligent manner, hit against the appellant. As a result of the
said accident, the appellant sustained severe injuries and was
taken to Chazhikkattu Hospital, Thodupuzha where he was
treated as an in-patient for 15 days under three different
occasions. The appellant contended that he was drawing a
monthly salary of Rs.63,166/-, working as a driver in the SubInspector grade in the City Police Office, Thycadu. In support of
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
his contentions Ext.A12 salary certificate was produced. Further
the appellant also contended that he suffered permanent
disability on account of the injury sustained by him in the
accident. In support of his case, the appellant produced
Ext.A10 disability certificate which shows that the appellant has
sustained a disability of 20%. The Tribunal on appreciation of
the facts and evidence produced before it with a conclusion
that
the
appellant
is
entitled
to
reckon
his
salary
as
Rs.38,864/- alone and deducted the 50% of the same and fixed
the
income
at
Rs.19,432/-.
As
regards
the
permanent
disability, the Tribunal reduced the percentage of disability
from 20% to 7% and granted the following compensation.
Sl. Head of claim
No.
Amount
claimed (₹.)s
symbol is
₹.₹₹
Amount
determined
(₹.)s
Particulars
Loss of earning
7,00,000/-
77,728/-
Partial loss of earning
3,50,000/-
Not allowed
Transport to hospital
10,000/-
3,000/-
Reasonable
assessment
Extra nourishment
1,00,000/-
5,000/-
Reasonable
assessment
Damage to clothing and 5,000/articles
1,000/-
Reasonable
assessment
Expenses for treatment
87,540/-
Ext.A11
medical
2,00,000/-
(₹38,864 x 2 months)
series
of
bills
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
₹87,531/- rounded
as ₹87,540/7
Salary of bystander
4,200/-
(14 days x 300 =
₹4200/-)
Loss of enjoyment and 2,00,000/amenities of life
20,000/-
Reasonable
assessment
Compensation for pain 2,00,000/and sufferings
50,000/-
Reasonable
assessment
10 Compensation
for 8,00,000/continuing permanent
disability
1,79,552/-
₹19,432 x 11 x 7 x
12/100
=
₹1,79,551.68/rounded
as
₹1,79,552/-
11 Compensation for loss 4,00,000/of earning power
Not allowed
Total
3.
30,000/-
Limited
to 4,28,020/₹20,00,000/-
Heard Sri. N.M. Mohamed Ayub, the learned
Counsel appearing for the appellant and Sri. Rajan P. Kaliyath,
the learned Counsel appearing for the Insurance Company.
4.
The
learned
Counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant submitted that the Tribunal was not justified in taking
the net salary drawn by the appellant. Ext.A12 is the certificate
of salary which shows a total amount of Rs.63,166/-. The
deduction except towards income tax and professional tax are
not liable to be taken for the purpose of calculating the salary.
Still further it is pointed out that the Tribunal could not have
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
applied the split multiplier and reduced the compensation. Still
further it is pointed out that the appellant was on leave for
eight months from the date of accident which is supported by
Ext.A13 and the Tribunal ought not have discarded the same.
5.
On the otherhand Sri. Rajan P. Kaliyath, the
learned Counsel for the Insurance Company opposed the plea
of the appellant on the ground that, no evidence has been
produced before the Tribunal to show that the leave taken by
the appellant on loss of pay was on account of the injury
sustained by him in the accident. It is also pointed out that the
Tribunal has rightly taken this split multiplier since there is no
loss caused to the appellant.
6.
I have considered the rival submissions raised
across the Bar.
7.
The first question to be considered is what
should be the income of the appellant. This Court in Reliance
General Insurance Co.Ltd v. Bindu [2025 KHC 228] has
held that except the deduction towards income tax and
professional tax, no other deduction can be taken into
consideration for the purpose of calculating the income of the
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
claimant in a motor accidents claim. In the present case
Ext.A12 salary certificate shows that an amount of Rs.63,166/is the amount drawn by the appellant. Deducting an amount of
Rs.5,000/- and the amount towards the professional tax, the
total deduction should come only to Rs.5,104/-. Thus, the
appellant was entitled to have an amount of Rs.58,062/reckoned as the amount drawn by him as salary.
8.
The next question to be considered is as to
whether the appellant has suffered any loss of earning due to
the accident. This Court in Akhilesh Chandran v. Sabu
Varghese [2024 KHC OnLine 7008]
following a Division
Bench judgment of this Court in Robin Babu v. Kunjappan &
Others [2015 (4) KHC 91] held that even if a Government
employee has not sustained any loss of income on account of
the accident, compensation is being awarded towards the
injury suffered by him in the road traffic accident. Therefore,
this Court is of the considered view that the appellant is
certainly entitled to have the compensation towards permanent
disability reckoned with the monthly income of Rs.58,062/-.
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
9.
In N. Jayasree v. Cholamandalam M/S
General Insurance Company Ltd.[(2022) 14 SCC 712]and
following the decision of Kamala v. Bajaj Alliance General
Insurance Company Limited [2024 KHC 791] this Court
held that, adopting split multiplier is impermissible under law.
While calculating compensation payable under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Therefore, on this point also the
appellants appeal is entitled to succeed.
10.
As regards the fixing of the percentage of
disability at 7%, this Court cannot subscribe through the
findings rendered by the Tribunal. In Manikandan.G
v.
Janardanan Nair [2021 (5) KHC 305] a Single Bench of this
Court has held that, the Tribunal cannot reduce the percentage
of disability without refering the claimant to the medical board.
In the present case, the disability certificate Ext.A10 produced
by the appellant before the Tribunal, shows that he was
examined by the District Hospital, Thodupuzha. In the said
certificate the disability noticed is 20%. Therefore, this Court is
of the view that unless a reassessment is ordered by the
Tribunal, the Tribunal could not have reduced the percentage of
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
disability to 7%, and therefore the appellant is entitled to have
the disability reckoned as 20%.
11.
Lastly, it is contended before this Court that
the appellant was granted only compensation for loss of
earning for two months. In George v. Krishnavenu [2020(4)
KLT 239] the Single Bench of this Court has held that a
Government employee who suffers loss of earning on account
of taking earned leave due to the injury sustained by him in the
road traffic accident is entitled to be compensated for the
same. Though the learned Counsel for the Insurance Company
vehemently contended that the contends of Ext.A12 cannot be
accepted unless there is a further proof regarding the fact that
the leave was on account of the injury sustained by the
claimant in the road traffic accident, this Court is of the view
that on perusal of Ext.A13, it is evidently clear that the
claimant was granted leave without allowance from 02.12.2016
till 31.07.2017, and the terms of provisions contained in Part-I
Rule 88 of Kerala Service Rules. This prima facie shows that
the leave was availed by the appellant on account of the injury
sustained by him in the road traffic accident.
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
12.
As an uphold of these discussions, this Court
finds that the appellant is entitled to succeed. Accordingly, the
appeal is allowed and the appellant is granted enhanced
compensation as follows:a)
The
income
of
the
appellant
is
fixed
at
Rs.58,062/-.
b) The loss of earning is fixed at Rs.3,86,768/(Rs.58,062/- x 8 – Rs.77,728/-).
c)
compensation
towards
permanent
disability:
Rs.13,53,285/- (Rs.58,062/- x 12 x 11 x 20 / 100 –
Rs.1,79,552/-.
d) An addiditional compensation towards Pain and
Suffering is fixed at Rs.15,000/-.
e) An addiditional compensation towards Loss of
amenities is fixed at Rs.15,000/-.
Thus, the appellants are entitled for a total amount of Rs.
17,70,053 /- (Rupees Seventeen Lakhs Seventy Thousand Fifty
Three only) as an enhanced compensation with interest at 8%
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
from 19.09.2018 till realisation and proportionate cost. The
Insurance Company shall deposit the amount within a period of
two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment, directly to the bank account of the appellant. The
appellant shall furnish his bank account details to the
insurance company for enabling the insurance company to
transfer the amount. The appeal is ordered accordingly.
Sd/EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
mea
2025:KER:25905
MACA NO. 425 OF 2021
APPENDIX OF MACA 425/2021
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure II
SERVICE CERTIFICATE DATED.17.02.2021
ISSUED BY DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF, IDUKKI
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review