Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.249 of 2023
Hindustan Steelworks Construction Limited
………Petitioner(s);
Versus
The State of Tripura and others
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
………Respondent(s).
: Mr. Ajit Kumar, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. K.K. Pal, Advocate.
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General,
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Order
31/07/2023
Heard Mr. Ajit Kumar, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
assisted by Mr. K.K. Pal, learned counsel and Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate
General for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioner has approached this Court once again after passing of
the reasoned order dated 07.01.2023 [Annexure-25] by the Empowered Officer,
Tripura RRDA, pursuant to the observations made by this Court earlier in
WP(C) No.1007/2022 dated 29.11.2022. The perusal of the reasoned order
shows that there are factual issues involved in the matter. Clause 24 in the
General Conditions of Contract contains a dispute redressal system. Clause 8.0
of the tripartite agreement between the petitioner, the Union of India and the
State of Tripura contains an arbitration clause. As per the said clause, the
disputes between the parties can be referred to the Secretary, Ministry of Rural
Development, Government of India in the event of non-settlement of the
difference or dispute within 60(sixty) days by the Monitoring and Supervision
Committee.
3.
Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General for the respondents-State,
has taken objection to the maintainability of the writ petition.
4.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has, however, referred to
not only the observations of the audit report, but previous instances when the
parties have been relegated to approach the Empowered Committee or to the
competent Civil Court for adjudication of the dispute.
5.
A perusal of the reasoned order and the pleadings of the writ
petition along with the annexures reveal that the dispute raised herein involves
adjudication on disputed issues of facts and the construction of terms of the
agreement between the parties. Petitioner has also impleaded the contractors as
private respondents to whom the work was allotted by the petitioner after
entering into the tripartite agreement with the State of Tripura and Union of
India. The relevant extract of the reasoned order is also quoted here to indicate
the complex nature of the dispute between the parties.
“This fresh order is being passed in terms of and in compliance of Hon’ble High
Court’s direction containing dated 29.11.2022 first in WP(C)1007 of 2022.
1.
2.
In this connection it is stated that –
Tripura Rural Roads Development Agency had revealed from the documents
furnished by HSC Ltd. Vide letter No. HSCL/Tripura/PMGSY/F25(XXIV)/2016/895 dt. 11.11.2016 that overpayment for an amount of Rs.313.87
lakh (Rupees three hundred thirteen point eight seven lakh) only had been made to
M/s Dilip Kumar Kar, Contractor by HSC Ltd. for 4 (four) PMGSY works against
the Agreement No. GM/HSCL/Tripura/PMGSY/NIT-52/2011 dt. 28.02.2011. The
matter was informed to HSCL vide letter No. F.4(47)/TR/PMGSY/PtXIII/2004/3026-31 dt. 27.7.2017. Copy of the said letter is enclosed at Annexure-A.
On detailed enquiry, it had been observed that (i) HSCL, Project Implementing
Agency (PIU), had released excess payment of Rs.1,11,08, 295/- (Rupees one crore
eleven lakh eight thousand two hundred and ninety five) only, for the work
sanctioned under Phase- V(a)[Package No. TR-04-61] without execution of work
and Rs.25,67,068/- (Rupees twenty five lakh sixty seven thousand and sixty eight)
only, for the work sanctioned under Phase- IX [Package No. TR-04-206] to their
agencies by recording false measurement (ii) constructional defects in two RCC box
culverts at Ch: 1.370 km & Ch: 5.485 km constructed under Phase-V(a) bearing
Package No- TR-04-61; two box culvert at Ch: 0.196 km & Ch: 1.084 km
constructed under Phase-IX bearing Package No. TR-04-206 and approximately 15
meters stretch of the road (from Ch:2.237 km onwards-left side) constructed under
Package No. TR-04- 206; (iii) Shoulder of almost entire road constructed under both
packages is covered by jungle and (iv) blockage of almost entire road side drain
constructed under both packages. The matter was intimated to HSCL vide letter
No.F. 1(6)/Part-XV/TR/PMGSY/2004/5007-10 dt. 25.5.2018. Copy of the said letter
is enclosed at Annexure-B.
3.
From the financial year 2016-17, Ministry of Rural Development (MoRD), GoI had
introduced e-payment system in OMMAS (R&F module) for the work under
PMGSY for making necessary payment to the agency on the basis of bill raised by
PIU. During scrutiny of current bills amount of last payment made by PIU / official
documents, it had come to the notice of TRRDA that payment without execution /
inflater measurement of works for an amount of Rs 10.85 Crore against 10 (ten)
works was made by HSC Ltd. to their agencies which was communicated vide letter
No.F.4.(47)/TR/PMGSY/2006/5733 dt 28.6.2018. Copy of the said letter is enclosed
at Annexure-C.
4.
On detailed enquiry, it had been observed that (i) HSC Ltd. implementing agency
had released excess payment of 198.05 lakh (Rupees one hundred ninety eight lakh
five thousand) only to the agencies against the agreement for the work of
“Upgradation of Jalabassa to Bhandarima (Part-II) road including construction of
3(three) long span RCC Bridges (at Ch: 17.078 km, Ch: 17.909 km and Ch:19.22
km) sanctioned under Phase-V in the year 2007-08” without execution or by inflated
measurement / unspecified work in RCC piles of the proposed 3(three) long span
bridges and (ii) length/ depth of the constructed Piles of the proposed RCC bridge at
Ch. 17.078 km of the road is less than length / depth required as per sanctioned DPR
(iii) quality of concreting work of the constructed Piles of the proposed RCC bridge
at Ch. 17.078 km of the road was unspecified. It was communicated to HSCL vide
letter No.F.4(47)/TR/ CE/ PMGSY/2004/09-12 dt. 09.01.2019. Copy of the said
letter is enclosed at Annexure-D.
Vide this office letter No.F.4(47)/TR/PMGSY/2006/2470-76 dt. 03.7.2019, HSCL
was requested to deposit excess payment of Rs.464.91 lakh (Rupees four hundred
sixty four point nine one lakh) made to their agency without execution of "Manikpur
to Hazirai road". Copy of the said letter is enclosed at Annexure-E
5.
6.
Further, on detailed enquiry, it had been observed that HSCL had released excess
payment of 1,32,77,152.00 (Rupees one crore thirty two lakh seventy-seventhousand one hundred and fifty two) only to their agencies for implementation of the
“Up-gradation of road from Bairathal to Jagannathpur (Part-II) (Link No-T03) under
Kumarghat block". It was communicated to HSCL vide letter No.F.4(105)/TR/CE/
PMGSY/2018/11873-77 dt. 16.03.2020. Copy of the said letter is enclosed at
Annexure-F.
7.
In addition, there was another road "Kashirampur to Dharam Para” Package No.TR03-70 under Dasda block (L031) where excess payment to the tune of 1,44,02,293.00
(Rupees one crore forty four lakh two thousand two hundred and ninety three) only
was made to agency by HSC Ltd without executing or by inflated measurement.
No construction activities were carried out beyond Ch. 2.20 km (approx) though the
work had been declared as physically completed by HSCL during March 2013 for
full sanctioned length of 4.38 km and the same was uploaded on OMMAS.
Thereafter, the completed road had been shown as "Ongoing" during December 2017
and the completed length had been reduced on OMMAS without permission of
TRRDA.
8.
The matter of very poor performance of HSC Ltd. in implementation of PMGSY
work in Tripura had also been communicated to the Secretary, Rural Development,
Ministry of Rural Development, GoI. vide letter No.F.4(47)/TR/PMGSY/2006/996768 dt. 29.9.2018 for his kind intervention which was also endorsed to the Chairmancum- Managing Director, NBCC (India) Ltd. Vide letter No.F.4 (47)/TR/PMGSY
/2006/10230 dt. 06.10.2018. Copy of both the letter are enclosed at Annexure-G.
In above facts clearly reveals the reason and justifies the calculation of which is as
follows:
"Expenditure incurred by HSC Ltd. including Maintenance works
Excess payment made by HSC Ltd. without execution of works
Eligible expenditure for agency fees as per tripartite agreement is
Thus, agency fees will be (10% of expenditure)
TRRDA had already released agency fees to HSCL
Hence, no agency fees pending with the TRRDA"
Rs.722.60crore.
Rs. 24.75 crore
Rs.697.85 crore
Rs. 69.78 crore
Rs. 69.78 crore
However, it appears that you have conveniently withdrawn these facts in your writ
petition W.P. (C) No-1007 of 2022.
Accordingly, it is reiterated that no agency fees is pending or due to be paid to you
on any account.
In fact the above mentioned fact would reveal that you are liable to pay back a sum
of 24.75 crore (Rupees twenty four crore and seventy five lakh) only being the excess
payment made by you to your agencies without execution of work or by inflated
measurement.”
6.
Having considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and in view of the nature of the factual dispute involved herein,
including those with private contractors/agencies who have also been joined as
party and against whom the petitioner HSCL may have independent cause of
action to agitate, we are not inclined to entertain the writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, as not only clause 8.0 of the Tripartite
agreement, but Clause 24 of the General Conditions of Contract provide for
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanism.
7.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. Petitioner may have
liberty to approach the appropriate forum.
8.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(T. AMARNATH GOUD), J
Pijush
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2023.08.04 17:18:21 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review