Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
…
CRMC No. 395/2017
Reserved on: 29.05.2026
Pronounced on: 03.07.2026
Uploaded on: 03.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Hindustan Coco Cola Beverages Pvt
Ltd having its registered office at B91, Mayapuri Industrial Area Phase-1,
New Delhi 110064 having amongst
others a plant at Hindustan Coca Cola
Beverages Pvt. Ltd 47-50 (A&B)
Industrial Extension Area, Gangyal
Jammu & Kashmir 180010 through
Mr. K. K. Giri, Factory Manager S/o
Mrityunjoy Giri Aged 46 years
…….Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Virender Bhat, Advocate
Versus
1. Assistant Controller Legal
Metrology, Reasi
2. Inspector, Legal Metrology, Reasi
……Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Dewakar Sharma, Dy.AG
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The Criminal Complaint titled 'Inspector Legal Metrology, Reasi v.
Domino’s Pizza Katra & Anr.', preferred by the Inspector, Legal
Metrology, Reasi (respondent No. 2 herein) against the petitioner
and the co-accused for the alleged commission of offence under
CRMC No.395/2017
Section 18 of the Legal Metrology Act, 2009 ('the Act') read with
Rules 6 and 2(bc) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities)
Rules, 2011 ('the Rules'), along with the subsequent order taking
cognizance and issuing process passed thereon by the Court of
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class (Munsiff), Reasi (hereinafter
referred to as the 'learned Magistrate'), are sought to be quashed,
inter alia, on the following grounds:
a. That the bottle in question obviously bears all declarations
mandated by the Act and rules made thereunder including net
quantity and MRP and there is no allegation that any bottle was
sold above the printed MRP.
b. That even, otherwise the price of concerned beverage and other
packaged commodities manufactured by the petitioner is not
fixed or regulated by any law for the time being in force,
therefore the petitioner has complete freedom to fix the price of
the said commodities.
c. That mere act of declaring different MRPs for the same
packaged products cannot constitute contravention of any
provisions of law including the Legal Metrology Act and Rules
made thereunder.
d. That the sale of packaged beverages/bottles within select
channel environment cannot be equated to a sale simpliciter at a
standard retail outlet in the open market. The ambience
provided to customers at such select channels completely
distinguish the transaction from general trade. Consequently,
pricing or supply within these distinct commercial frameworks
cannot be subjected to a strict parity comparison for the
purposes of the Act and Rules.
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, to supplement the
grounds of challenge made in the petition, has submitted that there
was no statutory bar or prohibition under the Act or the Rules
CRMC No.395/2017
preventing a manufacturer from declaring different Maximum Retail
Prices (MRPs) for an identical commodity based on distinct
channels of trade at the relevant point of time. Dual pricing is a
widely recognized socio-economic reality. The practice of declaring
different MRPs on identical products under varying commercial
market circumstances is not only judicially protected but also
legislatively recognized. This is evident from the explicit statutory
framework of Section 4A of the Central Excise Act, 1944, which
provides for the valuation of excisable goods with reference to the
retail sale price declared on the package, and explicitly contemplates
scenarios where different retail prices are declared on different
packages of identical goods. The Act and the Rules merely mandate
the prominent declaration and printing of the MRP on the packaging.
So long as a commodity (such as a 600 ml beverage bottle carrying
an MRP of ₹60 at a select premium outlet and ₹35 elsewhere)
carries all mandatory statutory declarations and is sold at or below
its own uniquely printed MRP, no offence under Section 18 of the
Act read with Rules 6 and 18(2) of the Rules can be said to be made
out. The impugned criminal complaint is fundamentally misguided
as it is founded entirely on a mere 'price disparity' between different
retail environments. The complaint does not contain any allegation
of overcharging above the printed MRP, nor does it allege any
structural violation of labelling or packaging norms. Learned
counsel further submits that it is a settled position of law that a
manufacturer retains the absolute autonomy to determine and
declare the retail price of its goods. The Government does not
CRMC No.395/2017
scrutinize the fiscal reasonableness of an MRP unless the
commodity
is
specifically
controlled
under
the
Essential
Commodities Act, 1955, or any other price-control legislation, as
explicitly clarified by the Department of Consumer Affairs vide its
official Frequently Asked Questions (Annexure 'D' to the petition).
The statutory amendment prohibiting different MRPs for identical
pre-packaged commodities was not in force on the date of the
alleged offense, i.e., 25th October 2016 (having only come into
effect prospectively on 1st January 2018) and a criminal or penal
provision cannot be applied retrospectively to criminalize conduct
that was perfectly lawful at the time of its commission. He has relied
upon the judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in “Pallavi
refractories and others vs. Singaneri Collieries Co. Ltd.” 2005(2)
SCC 227.
3.
Per contra, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondents
robustly defended the impugned proceedings, submitting that the
learned Magistrate committed no error of law in taking cognizance
and issuing process upon the complaint filed by respondent No. 2. It
is contended that during inspection conducted at the co-accused‟s
premises on 25th October 2016, it was detected that the co-accused
was charging an inflated price of ₹60/- for a 600 ml Coca-Cola
bottle. He asserts that this amounted to an illegal overcharge of ₹25/when contrasted against the standard Maximum Retail Price (MRP)
of ₹35/- fixed for an identical commodity in the open market. It is
the specific case of the respondents that such arbitrary price
discrimination
and
dual-pricing
of
identical
pre-packaged
CRMC No.395/2017
commodities directly contravenes the mandate of Section 18 of the
Act, read alongside Rules 2(bc) and 6 of the Rules, thereby fully
justifying the initiation of criminal prosecution.
4.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
5.
The
petitioner-company
is
engaged
in
the
business
of
manufacturing, packaging, distribution and sale of non-alcoholic
carbonated beverages.
On 25th October 2016, respondent No.2
visited the premises of M/s Dominos Pizza, Katra, and found that the
product of the petitioner-company i.e. pet bottle of Coca-Cola (600
ml) was priced at Rs. 60/-, whereas the similar product in the open
market was available for Rs. 35/-, thus it was alleged that the
petitioner and the other accused were overcharging Rs. 25/-, thereby
violating the provisions of Section 18 of the Act and Rule 2(bc) and
6 of the Rules. Consequently, respondent No.2 filed the complaint
before the learned Magistrate, who issued notice to the petitioner to
appear before and submit the written statement.
6.
It is the contention of the petitioner that, at the material point of
time, no provision of law prevented a manufacturer from declaring
differential MRPs for the same packaged commodity; there being no
prohibition under the Act or the Rules made thereunder, such a
declaration was legally permissible, and therefore no offense is
made out against the petitioner.
7.
According to the respondents, the petitioner and the co-accused have
committed the violation of Section 18 of the Act and Rules 2(bc)
and 6 of the Rules.
CRMC No.395/2017
8.
Before this Court enters upon the determination of the controversy
involved herein, it would be appropriate to advert to the relevant
provisions alleged by the respondents to have been violated by the
petitioner and the co-accused.
9.
The respondent-Department has alleged that the petitioner-Company
violated Section 18 of the Act, which structurally regulates
mandatory statutory declarations and pricing benchmarks on prepackaged commodities. It would be thus appropriate to extract
Section 18 of the Act, hereunder:
“18. Declarations on pre-packaged commodities. —
(1) No person shall manufacture, pack, sell, import, distribute,
deliver, offer, expose or possess for sale any pre-packaged
commodity unless such package is in such standard quantities or
number and bears thereon such declarations and particulars in
such manner as may be prescribed.
(2) Any advertisement mentioning the retail sale price of a prepackaged commodity shall contain a declaration as to the net
quantity or number of the commodity contained in the package in
such form and manner as may be prescribed.”
10.
Section 18 of the Act provides that no person shall, among other
things, pack or sell any prepackaged commodity unless such
package is in such standard quantity or number and bears on it such
declarations and particulars in such manner as may be prescribed
and that any advertisement mentioning the retail sale price of a prepackaged commodity shall contain a declaration about the net
quantity or number of the commodity contained in the package.
11.
Rule 2(bc) (Unamended) of the Rules defines “Institutional
Consumer‟ and the same is extracted as under:
“Institutional Consumer" means the institution who hires or
avails of the facilities or services in connection with transport,
hotel, hospital or other organization which buy packaged
commodities directly from the manufacturer or from an importer
or from wholesale dealer for use by that institution, and the
package shall have declaration „not for retail sale‟.
CRMC No.395/2017
12.
It must be adumbrated that although Rule 2(bc) was substantially
amended in the year 2017, the incident dates back to 2016. The
present controversy must, therefore, be resolved strictly in
accordance with the unamended provision in force at the material
time. The respondents have been unable to satisfy this Court as to
how a prosecution can lie against the petitioner for an alleged
violation of Rule 2(bc), given that the provision is purely a
definitional clause for 'Institutional Consumer‟.
13.
Pursuant to Rule 6 of the Rules, a pre-packaged commodity intended
for sale must carry distinct and conspicuous information detailing,
inter alia, the manufacturer, packer, date of manufacture or prepacking, and the relevant expiry or 'best before' metrics. It is
additionally mandated under the same provision that every package
shall bear its declared retail sale price. It is the admitted case of the
parties that the product in question bore a retail price of Rs. 60.
14.
Rule 18 of the Rules governs the sale, distribution, delivery, display,
and storage for sale of packaged commodities by both wholesale and
retail dealers. The rule explicitly mandates that no retail dealer,
manufacturer, packer, importer, or wholesale dealer shall sell any
packaged commodity at a price exceeding its declared retail sale
price. Furthermore, it prohibits any such dealer or person from
obliterating, smudging, or altering the retail sale price indicated by
the manufacturer, packer, or importer.
15.
The contention of the petitioner is that there was no law at the
relevant point of time that prohibited the manufacturer from
declaring differential MRPs for the same packaged product and once
CRMC No.395/2017
there is no prohibition under any law including the Act and Rules
framed thereunder, declaration of differential MRPs for the same
product was permissible, as such, no offence is made out against the
petitioner.
16.
Initially, Rule 18 of the Rules contained no prohibition against
declaring differential MRPs for the same product; however,
following an amendment in 2017, sub-rule (2A) was inserted into
Rule 18 to introduce such a restriction, which provides that “Unless
otherwise
specifically provided
under any other law,
no
manufacturer or packer or importer shall declare different
maximum retail prices on an identical pre-packaged commodity
by adopting restrictive trade practices or unfair trade practices
as defined under 2[clause (nnn) and clause (r), respectively] of
sub-section (1) of section 2 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986
(68 of 1986)”.
17.
It is, therefore, manifest that on the date of the alleged inspection,
there existed no bar preventing a manufacturer from declaring
differential MRPs for an identical product. This restriction was
brought into force for the first time only w.e.f. 01.01.2018 through
G.S.R. 629(E), dated 23rd June, 2017. Consequently, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the uncontroverted facts fail to disclose
the commission of any offense by the petitioner-company.
18.
In view of the detailed discussion and the settled legal position
delineated hereinabove, this Court is of the considered view that the
continuation of the impugned criminal proceedings would amount to
nothing short of an abuse of the process of law. Consequently, the
CRMC No.395/2017
criminal complaint titled 'Inspector Legal Metrology, Reasi v.
Domino's Pizza, Katra & Anr.', pending before the Court of learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class (Munsiff), Reasi, for the alleged
commission of offenses under Section 18 of the Act read with Rules
2(bc) and 6 of the Rules, along with the order taking cognizance and
all consequential process issued thereunder, are hereby quashed.
19.
Copy of this order be sent to learned Magistrate for information.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
03.07.2026
Ajaz Ahmad, Secy
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
KARAM CHAND
2026.07.03 13:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRMC No.395/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review