The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
28. 07.2021 issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. Before completion of his tenure of 5 years as Director of RIMS, Dr. Ahanthem Santa Singh was repatriated prematurely from the post of Director, RIMS to his parent WP(C) No. 867 of 2022 Page 2 cadre, i.e., North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health & Medical Sciences, Shillong with effect from 12.10.2022, vide order dated 18.07.2022 issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. After repatriation of the said Dr. Ahanthem Santa Singh and pending the process for appointment of Director of RIMS on regular basis, the authorities of RIMS issued the impugned order dated 12.10.2022 entrusting the additional charge for the post of Director, RIMS to the respondent No. 5 for a period of 6 months or till regular appointment of Director, RIMS or till further orders whichever is the earliest. According to the petitioner, as per the applicable rules, if such additional charge is to be given, the same should be given to the senior most Officer in the next lower grade and since the petitioner is the senior most officer in the next lower grade, she is entitled to get such additional charge and that entrusting such additional charge of Director, RIMS to the respondent No. 5, who is junior to the petitioner, is ultra-vires the applica…
13. 10.2022. Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI, further submitted that as the final approval for entrusting of additional charge of Director, RIMS to respondent No. 5 vests with the Appointment Committee of Cabinet (ACC), the Ministry has forwarded an Office Memorandum dated
27. 10.2022 to the ACC seeking for ex-post facto approval and decision thereof is still awaited. The learned DSGI lastly submitted that the present writ petition is without any merit and the same deserves to be dismissed outright. [7] Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing for respondent No. 5, submitted that the inter-se-seniority list of Professors of RIMS produced by the petitioner and enclosed as Annexure - A/1 to the present writ petition has not been approved by the Executive Committee of RIMS and therefore, the said seniority list is an unauthenticated seniority list on the basis whereof no claim can be made by the writ petitioner. The learned senior counsel also vehemently contested the claim of the petitioner that she is senior to WP(C) No. 867 of 2022 Page 5 the respondent No. 5 in the grade of Professor. In this regard, it has been submitted that both the petitioner and the respondent No. 5 were appointed as Professors in RIMS on the same date, i.e., on 01.02.2009 by issuing different orders and without indicating inter-se merit. It has also been submitted that in such a situation and in terms of the seniority rules and guidelines and the law applicable for determination of interse-seniority of incumbents who have been appointed or promoted on the same date without indicating merit, the respondent No. 5 would be senior to the writ petitioner, inasmuch as, the r…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (C) No. 867 of 2022
Dr. Hemam Priyosakhi Devi, aged about 63 years, W/o Dr.
Sinam Rajendra Singh, resident of Chingmeirong East,
P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Lamphel, District Imphal East, Manipur
- 785010
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1. The Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of
Health & Family Welfare, Government of India, Nirman
Bhawan, New Delhi – 110001.
2. The Under Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi
– 110001.
3. The Regional Institute of Medical Sciences (RIMS),
Imphal, through its Director (RIMS), P.O. Imphal, P.S.
Lamphel, District Imphal West, Manipur – 795004.
4. The Deputy Director (Admn.), Regional Institute of
Medical Sciences (rims), Imphal, P.O. Imphal, P.S.
Lamphel, District Imphal West, Manipur – 795004.
……Official Respondents
5. Dr. L. Ranjit Singh, Prof., Obst & Gynae, RIMS, Imphal,
Manipur, through the Deputy Director, Regional Institute of
Medical Sciences, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Lamphel, District Imphal
West, Manipur – 795004.
........Private Respondent/s
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 1
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. BP Sahu, Sr. Adv.
For the respondents
:
Mr. HS. Paonam, Sr. Adv.
& Kh. Samarjit, DSGI.
Date of Hearing
:
01.12.2022
Date of Judgment
:
19.12.2022
Judgment
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioner, Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing for respondent
Nos. 1 to 4 and Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing for
respondent No. 5.
[2]
The present writ petition had been filed assailing the order
dated 12.10.2022 issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, entrusting additional charge
for the post of Director, RIMS to the respondent No. 5 for a period of 6
months, i.e., upto 11.04.2023 or till regular appointment of Director,
RIMS or till further orders whichever is the earliest, coupled with a
prayer for directing the official respondents to allow the petitioner to
hold the post of Director, RIMS, Imphal, pending regular appointment.
[3]
The facts of the present case in a nutshell is that just prior
to issuance of the impugned order dated 12.10.2022, one Dr.
Ahanthem Santa Singh was appointed to the post of Director, Regional
Institute of Medical Sciences (RIMS), Imphal on deputation basis for a
period of 5 years with effect from 09.11.2018, vide order dated
28.07.2021 issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of India,
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. Before completion of his tenure of
5 years as Director of RIMS, Dr. Ahanthem Santa Singh was
repatriated prematurely from the post of Director, RIMS to his parent
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 2
cadre, i.e., North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health &
Medical Sciences, Shillong with effect from 12.10.2022, vide order
dated 18.07.2022 issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. After repatriation of the said
Dr. Ahanthem Santa Singh and pending the process for appointment of
Director of RIMS on regular basis, the authorities of RIMS issued the
impugned order dated 12.10.2022 entrusting the additional charge for
the post of Director, RIMS to the respondent No. 5 for a period of 6
months or till regular appointment of Director, RIMS or till further orders
whichever is the earliest.
According to the petitioner, as per the applicable rules, if
such additional charge is to be given, the same should be given to the
senior most Officer in the next lower grade and since the petitioner is
the senior most officer in the next lower grade, she is entitled to get
such additional charge and that entrusting such additional charge of
Director, RIMS to the respondent No. 5, who is junior to the petitioner,
is ultra-vires the applicable rules and not sustainable in the eyes of law.
Hence, the present case.
[4]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner, submitted that the post of Director, RIMS become vacant
with effect from 13.10.2022 due to the sudden and premature
repatriation of Dr. Ahanthem Santa Singh to his parent cadre before
completion of his tenure of 5 years as Director of RIMS. According to
the learned senior counsel if such unanticipated vacancy is to be filled
up by in-charge arrangement pending regular appointment, such incharge arrangement should be done in terms of the provisions under
Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules and Regulations of RIMS, Imphal, wherein it
is provided that in respect of unanticipated vacancies the Administrative
Ministry may, with the approval of the Minister in charge, order
additional charge arrangement subject to maximum period of 6 months
with effect from the date of occurrence of the vacancy and also subject
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 3
to the condition that the officer to whom the additional charge is
assigned is the senior most officer in the next lower grade and is clear
from vigilance angle.
[5]
Mr. BP. Sahu, learned senior counsel, submitted that the
petitioner obtained the inter-se-seniority list of Professors of RIMS from
the concerned authorities of RIMS through RTI application and in the
said inter-se-seniority list of Professors, the name of the petitioner is at
Serial No. 3 while the name of respondent No. 5 is at Serial No. 5. It is
also submitted by the learned senior counsel that since the Professors
at Serial No. 1 & 2 of the said inter-se-seniority list have already retired
from service on attaining the age of superannuation, the petitioner is
presently the senior most Professor in RIMS and the respondent No. 5
is junior to her. The learned senior counsel vehemently submitted that
at the time of entrusting the additional charge of Director, RIMS to the
respondent No. 5, the authorities did not consider the case of the
petitioner and other Professors who are senior to the respondent No. 5
and that the authorities have allowed the respondent No. 5 to hold the
charge of Director, RIMS in an arbitrary and in a pick and choose
manner and in complete violation of the provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii) of
the Rules and Regulations of RIMS, Imphal. According to the learned
senior counsel such arbitrary and illegal action of the authorities are
liable to be interfered with by this Court by quashing and setting aside
the impugned order dated 12.10.2022 and by directing the authorities to
allow the petitioner to hold the additional charge of Director, RIMS
pending regular appointment.
[6]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing for respondents
No. 1 to 4, submitted that the inter-se-seniority seniority list of
Professors of RIMS relied on by the petitioner is not yet approved by
the Executive Council of RIMS and that the inter-se-seniority of
Professor of RIMS is yet to be finalized and accordingly, the claim of
the petitioner that she is the senior most Professor in RIMS is
unfounded and without any basis.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 4
It has been submitted by the learned DSGI that as the
process for filling up the post of Director, RIMS on regular basis is
going to take some time and as the said post of Director cannot be kept
vacant, the Honb’le Minister of Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of India,
by resorting to the provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules and
Regulations of RIMS entrusted the additional charge for the post of
Director, RIMS to the private respondent No. 5 as a stop gap
arrangement for a period of 6 months or till such time a regular Director
is appointed, whichever is the earliest, taking into consideration the
larger interest of the public and importance attached to such an
important medical institute which not only catered to the needs of the
State of Manipur but also to the entire North Eastern Region. It has
been strenuously submitted that such action of the authorities cannot
be faulted with specially when the respondent No. 5 have already
assumed additional charge as Director of RIMS with effect from
13.10.2022. Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI, further submitted that as
the final approval for entrusting of additional charge of Director, RIMS
to respondent No. 5 vests with the Appointment Committee of Cabinet
(ACC), the Ministry has forwarded an Office Memorandum dated
27.10.2022 to the ACC seeking for ex-post facto approval and decision
thereof is still awaited. The learned DSGI lastly submitted that the
present writ petition is without any merit and the same deserves to be
dismissed outright.
[7]
Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing for
respondent No. 5, submitted that the inter-se-seniority list of Professors
of RIMS produced by the petitioner and enclosed as Annexure - A/1 to
the present writ petition has not been approved by the Executive
Committee of RIMS and therefore, the said seniority list is an
unauthenticated seniority list on the basis whereof no claim can be
made by the writ petitioner. The learned senior counsel also
vehemently contested the claim of the petitioner that she is senior to
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 5
the respondent No. 5 in the grade of Professor. In this regard, it has
been submitted that both the petitioner and the respondent No. 5 were
appointed as Professors in RIMS on the same date, i.e., on 01.02.2009
by issuing different orders and without indicating inter-se merit. It has
also been submitted that in such a situation and in terms of the seniority
rules and guidelines and the law applicable for determination of interse-seniority of incumbents who have been appointed or promoted on
the same date without indicating merit, the respondent No. 5 would be
senior to the writ petitioner, inasmuch as, the respondent No. 5 is
senior in age to the petitioner. In support of his contention, the learned
senior counsel relied on the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of “D.P. Das vs. Union of India & Ors.” reported in
(2011) 8 SCC 115 wherein it has been held as under:“25. In the premises aforesaid the seniority of the
officers who were recommended on the same date
must be decided by their respective age. The
contrary view taken by the High Court of fixing
seniority on the basis of the date of interview, being
wholly fortuitous, cannot be accepted.”
“27. For the reasons aforesaid this Court holds that
for determination of seniority of the officers who
were recommended on the same date, age is the
only valid and fair basis; as such, their seniority
should be decided on the basis of age of the
candidates who have been recommended.”
[8]
Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel, lastly submitted
that as the inter-se-seniority between the petitioner and respondent No.
5 is yet to be finalized and as the respondent No. 5 has better claim of
seniority over the petitioner in terms of the judgment rendered by the
apex court in the case of “D.P. Das” (Supra) and since the Minister in
charge of the Administrative Department of the Central Government
has the power and authority for ordering/assigning additional charge
arrangement in respect of the post of Director of RIMS under Rule
12(1)(iii) of the Rules and Regulations of RIMS, no irregularity or
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 6
illegality had been committed by the authorities in issuing the impugned
order thereby entrusting the additional charge of Director of RIMS to the
respondent No. 5 and accordingly, there is no merit in the present writ
petition and the same deserves to be dismissed outright as being
devoid of merit.
[9]
Before considering the merits and demerits of the rival
submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the
parties, this Court is of the considered view that it will be appropriate to
examine the relevant provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules and
Regulations of RIMS, Imphal, which provides for making in-charge
arrangement in respect of unanticipated vacancy in the post of Director
of RIMS, Imphal. The said provisions are reproduced hereunder for
ready reference:“12. Director of the Institute
12(1)
(iii)
Notwithstanding
anything
contained hereinabove, the President,
RIMS may appoint a person to officiate
as director either during temporary
absence of the regular incumbent or
where the office of Director falls vacant
for any reason for a period not
exceeding six months at a time within
the concurrence of the Central
Government. However, in respect of
unanticipated vacancies (the regular
appointments to which require ACC
approval) the administrative ministry
may, with the approval of the Minister
in charge, order additional charge
arrangements subject to maximum
period of six months, with effect from
the date of occurrence of the vacancy
and also subject to the condition that
the officer to whom the additional
charge is assigned is the senior most
officer in the next lower grade and is
clear from vigilance angle.”
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 7
[10]
On careful examination of the provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii)
quoted hereinabove, it is crystal clear that in respect of unanticipated
vacancies in the post of Director, RIMS, the administrative ministry
may, with the approval of the Minister in charge, order additional charge
arrangements subject to maximum period of 6 months, with effect from
the date of occurrence of the vacancy and also subject to the condition
that the officer to whom the additional charge is assigned is senior most
officer in the next lower grade and is clear from the vigilance angle.
[11]
In the present case on careful examination and perusal of
the O.M. dated 27.10.2022 of the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare,
Government of India, containing the proposal for seeking ex-post facto
approval of the ACC for entrustment of additional charge of Director,
RIMS to respondent No. 5, which is enclosed as Annexure – C/4 to the
additional affidavit dated 24.11.2022 filed by respondents No. 1 to 4,
and the letter dated 28.11.2022 of the Under Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, addressed to
the Director, RIMS, Imphal, enclosing therein the tentative inter-seseniority list of Professor of RIMS as on 01.07.2022, which was placed
before this Court in terms of the direction given by this Court, it is found
that the respondent No. 5, whose name is at Serial No. 4 of the said
tentative inter-se-seniority list of Professor, RIMS, had been entrusted
with the additional charge of the Director, RIMS, Imphal in terms of the
provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules and Regulations of RIMS and
the DoPT O.M. dated 05.01.2015 of the Central Government. This
Court also found that in the said tentative inter-se-seniority list of
Professors relied on by the authorities, the name of the petitioner is at
Serial No. 2, thereby showing that the petitioner is senior to respondent
No. 5 in the grade of Professor. The said Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules
and Regulations of RIMS and points (ii) of the aforesaid DoPT’s O.M.
dated 05.01.2015, inter-alia, provides for making interim in-charge
arrangement in respect of unanticipated vacancies subject to the
condition that the officer to whom the additional charge is assigned is
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 8
the senior most officer in the next lower grade and is clear from
vigilance angle.
[12]
In the present case, the respondents have not been able
to show before this Court any material whatsoever to indicate that at
the time of assigning additional charge of Director of RIMS to the
respondent No. 5, the authorities have also considered the case of the
petitioner and other senior Professors who are placed above the
respondent No. 5 in the said tentative inter-se-seniority list of
Professors, RIMS relied on by the authorities. Faced with such
undisputed facts, this Court is constrained to hold that the authorities
have entrusted additional charge of Director of RIMS, Imphal to the
respondent No. 5 arbitrarily and in a pick and choose manner and in
complete violation of the provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules and
Regulations of RIMS, Imphal. Accordingly, this Court has no hesitation
to hold that the official respondents have acted arbitrarily and illegally in
issuing the impugned order dated 12.10.2022.
[13]
It will be pertinent to mention here that in the case of
“Government of A.P. & Anr. Vs. A.V. Venugopala Rao” reported in
(1995) 1 SCC 179, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that interim incharge arrangement given to senior most employee in the tentative
seniority list of the promotional post pending finalization of seniority list
to avoid administrative hardship or heartburning among rival candidates
had a rational and reasonable basis.
In the present case, as the inter-se-seniority
of the
Professors of RIMS are yet to be finalized, the authorities have relied
on the tentative inter-se-seniority list of Professors of RIMS for
assigning additional charge of Director, RIMS as an
interim
arrangement and this Court did not find any fault with it. The only
unacceptable thing is about assigning such additional charge of
Director, RIMS to the respondent No. 5, without considering the cases
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 9
of the senior Professor, including the present petitioner, who are placed
above the respondent No. 5 in the said tentative seniority list.
[14]
In so far as the contention advanced by the learned senior
counsel appearing for respondent No. 5 is concerned, it has to be
pointed out that as the validity and correctness of the said tentative
inter-se-seniority list of Professor, RIMS has not been questioned or
challenged by anybody and as such issue is not before this Court in the
present proceeding, this Court is of the considered view that it will not
be just and proper to entertain and decide the points and contentions
raised by the learned senior counsel appearing for respondent No. 5 in
the present proceedings. Accordingly, this Court declined to do so.
For the findings and reasons given hereinabove, the
present writ petition is hereby allowed by quashing and setting aside
the impugned order dated 12.10.2022. Quashing of the impugned order
will not preclude the official respondents from making fresh interim incharge arrangement in respect of the vacant post of Director, RIMS,
Imphal strictly in terms of the provisions of Rule 12(1)(iii) of the Rules
and Regulations of RIMS.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is
disposed of without any order as to cost.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
joshua
signed by KH.
KH. JOSHUA Digitally
JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2022.12.19
MARING
13:08:02 +05'30'
WP(C) No. 867 of 2022
Page 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review