Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:32467
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. Appeal (A-SB) No. 20 of 2026
Decided on: August 5, 2026
_________________________________________________________________
Harvinder Singh
……... Appellant
State of Himachal Pradesh & others
Versus
…....Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
For the Appellant:
Mr. M.A. Safee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s):
Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar, Additional
Advocate Generals with Mr. Ravi Chauhan & Mr.
Anish Banshtu, Deputy Advocates General, for
respondent No.1-State.
Mr.J.K. Verma and Mr. Mayank Verma,
Advocates, for respondents Nos.2 to 8.
__________________________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, J. (oral)
Instant appeal filed under S.14-A of the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, lays challenge to judgment of
acquittal dated 15.2.2025 passed by learned Special Judge, Sundernagar, District
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh (hereinafter, ‘trial court’) in POA Act No. 2/2023, whereby
respondents-accused (hereinafter, ‘accused’) came to be acquitted for their having
committed offences punishable under Sections 447, 147, 149, 323, 504 IPC and
Ss.3(iv), 3(v) and 3(x) of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes
2026:HHC:32467
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, in FIR No. 44, dated 28.2.2017, registered at Police
Station Sundernagar, District Mandi, Himachal Pradesh.
2.
Facts, in brief, are that a written complaint was filed by appellant-complainant
(hereinafter, ‘complainant’), who is member of Scheduled Castes with In Charge,
Police Post Slapper on 28.2.2017, alleging therein that he had purchased land
measuring 10-4 Biswa comprised in Khasra No.174/1, from one Raghu Ram, about
six months back. Mutation was attested in the name of mother of complainant. It is
alleged that on 28.2.2017, complainant alongwith his brother Rajinder Singh and
uncle Tara Singh had visited land in question, when accused attacked them with
sticks. Allegedly, turbans worn by complainant and his uncle were removed and
castiest remarks, “tum dagi chamaron ko jameen kisne di hai, aapka yahan kuch
nhain hai, hayan se chale jaao, varna maar denge” were also made. On the basis of
such complaint, FIR No. 44, dated 28.2.2017 was lodged at Police Station
Sundernagar against the accused. Investigation was conducted by SDPO
Sundernagar, Shri Sanjeev Bhatia. Accused were medically examined. Statements
of witnesses were recorded and after completing codal formalities, Challan was filed
in the court of learned Sessions Judge, Mandi, which assigned the matter to learned
Special Judge, Sundernagar.
3.
On finding prima facie case, accused were charged for the commission of
offences punishable under Ss. 447, 147, 149, 323 and 504 IPC and S.3(1), 3(r) and
3(s) of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities)
2026:HHC:32467
Act. Prosecution examined thirteen witnesses, whereas accused in their statements
recorded under S.313 CrPC, denied the prosecution case and claimed to be
innocent. It is the defence of the accused that the land in question belongs to them
and when their female family members had gone to the land, complainant party
started quarreling with them, on which they went to the spot.
4.
The bone of contention in this case is the land denoted by Khasra No. 174/1,
which was subject matter of a civil suit No. 148-1/2016 filed in the court of learned
Senior Civil Judge, Court No.1, Sundernagar, which was filed on 17.11.2016, much
prior to lodging of present FIR. As per said suit, the accused claimed their hostile
possession over the suit land, through their predecessor-in-interest Khazana Ram
and one Daulat Ram. The dispute also reached this Court and an order was passed
in CMP No. 4592 of 2019 on 28.5.2019, wherein an order was passed and it was
observed that partition had not been effected qua the suit land and same was
ordered to be partitioned and instrument of partition was ordered to be placed on
record before this Court. However, there is no further record available as to whether
partition was effected and whether possession of suit land was given to the
purchaser or not?
5.
Coming back to the FIR, it is admitted by the complainant that possession
over suit land was of the accused persons. Though it is averred by the complainant
that possession of land was handed over to them by Raghu, but same was not
proved by leading evidence. PW-11, Nirmal Kumar, Kanungo, examined by
2026:HHC:32467
prosecution though deposed that land in Khasra No. 1014/174/1 was in the name of
Surinder Kaur, but still it is not clear whether she had possession over the suit land
or not. Learned trial Court has noticed in para-16 that possibility of complainant
party taking forcible possession over suit land cannot be ruled out. Since it is
averred on behalf of complainant that possession of suit land was handed over by
Raghu Ram to Surinder Kaur, said Surinder Kaur was an essential witness, but she
has not been examined.
6.
PW-1 Harvinder Singh deposed that on the given date, when he alongwith
his brother Rajinder Singh and uncle Tara Singh had gone to land in question to do
some work, Rama Devi, Kanta Devi and Savitri Devi (accused) were working in
their fields adjoining to suit land and when they were talking to these persons, Rup
Lal and Balak Ram (deceased) came over there and started beating them with
sticks. In the meantime, Pawan Kumar and Kashmir Singh also came on the spot
and gave beatings to them, with fists and blows. This witness stated that turbans
worn by him and his uncle were removed and castiest remarks were made.
However, in the complaint, PW-1 stated that all the accused persons had come on
the spot together and attacked them. There is another inconsistency in the
deposition of this witness regarding presence of Rup Lal and Pawan Kumar
alongwith Rama Devi, Kanta Devi and Savitri Devi on the spot.
7.
Similarly, PW-3 Rajinder Singh, who deposed that when they reached the
spot, Rama Devi, Kanta Devi, Savitri Devi and Geeta Devi were present on the spot
2026:HHC:32467
and working on their adjacent field. In the same breath, he also deposed that
Kashmir Singh and Pawan Kumar were also present on the spot. As per this
witness, Rup Lal and Balak Ram came on the spot with sticks and started abusing
them. Balak Ram and Rup Lal gave beating them with sticks and Pawan Kumar and
Kashmir Singh also gave them beatings with fists and blows. In the same breath,
this witness stated that Kashmir Singh and Pawan Kumar were already present on
the spot. This deposition is contrary to the deposition of the complainant. This
witness nowhere stated that the accused ladies also gave them beatings, whereas,
as per version of complainant, accused ladies also gave them beatings.
8.
PW-2 Manoj Kumar is an independent witness in the case, who deposed that
he alongwith Sher Singh had stopped for tea at Satluj Dhaba near Slapper and at
about 12.30 on 28.2.2017, some quarrel was taking place on nearby fields. They
reached the spot and found that accused persons were beating complainant party,
3-4 accused were carrying sticks in their hands. As per this witness, they rescued
complainant party from the accused. Accused persons uttered caste related
remarks against complainant party. However, in his cross-examination, PW-2 stated
that he does not know about ownership and possession of land in question. He did
not see the accused or the complainant party on the suit land. Surprisingly, he
stated that no caste based remarks were made by accused in his presence. As per
this witness, 3-4 persons were carrying sticks in their hands, whereas, as per
complainant, only two persons were carrying sticks. There is serious contradiction in
2026:HHC:32467
the version of this witness in examination-in-chief and in cross-examination vis-à-vis
prosecution story regarding use of caste based remarks. There is another important
aspect of the matter, complainant did not name these so called independent
witnesses namely Manoj Kumar and Sher Singh in his complaint.
2.
So far medical evidence is concerned, though
there are MLCs of
complainant party on record, but so far accused persons are concerned, Pawan
Kumar, accused No.2, also made a report to the police regarding beatings given to
them by the complainant party and had requested the investigating officer to get him
medically examined for his injuries, but it was not done, as such, it points to the
possibility that scuffle took place between the accused and complainant party, when
complainant party went to spot to take forcible possession of land. Therefore,
possibility of altercation having taken place on account of complainant party trying
to take forcible possession of disputed land, cannot be ruled out.
9.
Clause (r) of Section 3(1) criminalizes a person, not being a member of a
Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe, who intentionally insults or intimidates with
intent to humiliate a member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe in any
place within public view whereas clause (s) criminalizes a person who abuses any
member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe by caste name in any place
within public view.
10.
In this case, such offence has not been proved against the accused, for the
reason that independent witness Manoj Kumar had admitted in his cross-
2026:HHC:32467
examination that accused did not use any caste based remarks, whereas, evidence
of other witnesses being interested witnesses, when sifted for reliability, does not
inspire confidence on account of material contradictions in their statements, coupled
with the fact that there is already a civil dispute between the parties.
11.
So far allegation of using caste based remarks by the accused persons is
concerned,
except the one sided version of complainant party, there is no
independent corroboration to the same. The only independent witness in the case
has denied that any caste based remarks as contained in the complaint and FIR,
were uttered by accused in his presence, therefore it cannot be conclusively held
that any criminal action coming under the purview of Section 3(1)(r) and (s) was
committed by the accused. Otherwise also, very root of the altercation is the
disputed land, possession whereof seems to be with the accused party, as such,
possibility of false implication of the accused cannot be ruled out.
12.
By now it is well settled that in a criminal trial evidence of eye-witness
requires careful assessment and needs to be evaluated for its creditability. Hon’ble
Apex Court has repeatedly held that since fundamental aspect of criminal
jurisprudence rests upon well established principle that “no man is guilty until
proved so”, utmost caution is required to be exercised in dealing with the situation
where there are multiple testimonies and equally large number of witnesses
testifying before the Court. Most importantly, Hon’ble Apex Court has held that there
must be a string that should join the evidence of all the witnesses thereby satisfying
2026:HHC:32467
the test of consistency in evidence amongst all the witnesses. In nutshell, it can be
said that evidence in criminal cases needs to be evaluated on the touchstone of
consistency. In this regard, reliance is placed upon the judgment passed by
Hon’ble Apex Court in C. Magesh and others v. State of Karnataka (2010) 5
Supreme Court Cases 645, wherein it has been held as under:“45. It may be mentioned herein that in criminal jurisprudence,
evidence has to be evaluated on the touchstone of consistency.
Needless to emphasis, consistency is the keyword for upholding the
conviction of an accused. In this regard it is to be noted that this Court
in the case titled Surja Singh v. State of U.P. (2008)16 SCC 686:
2008(11) SCR 286 has held:-( SCC p.704, para 14)
“14. The evidence must be tested for its inherent consistency and the
inherent probability of the story; consistency with the account of other
witness is held to be creditworthy; ..the probative value of such
evidence becomes eligible to be put into the scales for a cumulative
evaluation.”
13.
In this case, leaving aside the independent witness, even the testimony of
material prosecution witnesses, including the complainant himself is full of
inconsistencies and contradictions on material aspects of the matter, thereby
rendering the prosecution story doubtful.
14.
There is another important aspect of the matter. The accused have alleged
that it is the complainant party which was aggressor. Learned counsel for the
accused has placed reliance on the judgment passed by Hon’ble Apex Court
reported in State of UP v. Ghambhir Singh & others, AIR 2005 (92) SC 2439,
wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that if on the same evidence, two views
2026:HHC:32467
are reasonably possible, the one in favour of the accused must be preferred. The
relevant paragraph is reproduced as under:“6. So far as Hori Lal, PW-1 is concerned, he had been sent to fetch a basket
from the village and it was only a matter of coincidence that while he was
returning he witnessed the entire incident. The High Court did not consider it
safe to rely on his testimony because he evidence clearly shows that he had
an animus against the appellants.
Moreover, his evidence was not
corroborated by objective circumstances. Though it was his categorical case
that all of them fired, no injury caused by rifle was found, and, only two
wounds were found on the person of the deceased. Apart from this PW-3 did
not mention the presence of either PW-1 or PW-2 at the time of occurrence.
All these circumstances do create doubt about the truthfulness of the
prosecution case. The presence of these three witnesses becomes doubtful
if their evidence is critically scrutinized. May be it is also possible to take a
view in favour of the prosecution, but since the High Court, on an
appreciation of the evidence on record, has recorded a finding in favour of
the accused, we do not feel persuaded to interfere with the order of the High
Court in an appeal against acquittal. It is well settled that if on the same
evidence two views are reasonably possible, the one in favour of the
accused must be preferred.”
15.
In this case, the root of the altercation is the disputed land and complainant
party has failed to prove that they were in possession of the land and it is the
accused, who attacked them. Further the independent witness has not corroborated
the version of complainant party regarding uttering of caste based remarks. The
only evidence in this case is the testimony of the complainant party, which is an
2026:HHC:32467
interested party and therefore, its version is required to be dealt cautiously and
cannot be made sole ground to convict the accused. Therefore, the learned court
below has rightly acquitted the accused.
16.
In view of the detailed discussion made herein above and law taken into
consideration, there is no merit in the appeal, which is accordingly dismissed.
Judgment dated 15.2.2025 passed by learned Special Judge, Sundernagar, District
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh (hereinafter, ‘trial court’) in POA Act No. 2/2023 is upheld.
Record, if received, be sent back forthwith.
August 5, 2026
(Shankar)
(Sandeep Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review