Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
SECOND APPEAL No. 535 of 2008
BETWEEN:1. HARIMOHAN
SAXENA
S/O
RAMCHARAN
SAXENA (DECEASED) THROUGH LEGAL HEIRS:(a) SMT. KUSUM SAXENA W/O DINESH SAXENA, R/O
– HOUSE NO.3, SHASTRI COLONY, UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
(b) ANAND SAXENA S/O LATE SHRI HARIMOHAN
SAXENA, R/O – CHHOTI JIN DOR, HOUSE NO.1011, AGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
(c) NARENDRA
SAXENA
S/O
LATE
SHRI
HARIMOHAN SAXENA, R/O – CHHOTI JIN DOR,
HOUSE NO.10-11, AGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. KAMLA BAI W/O HARIMOHAN SAXENA, AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION
–
AGRICULTURIST, R/O – JHINGAKHO, AGAR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI BRAJESH PANDYA - ADVOCATE)
AND
RAVI KUMAR S/O BRIJKISHORDAS SAXENA
1. (DECEASED) THROUGH LEGAL HEIRS:SMT. JYOTIKA W/O LATE RAVIKUMAR SAXENA,
AGED – ADULT, OCCUPATION – NIL, R/O –
(i) DESHBANDHU, C.H.H. 4TH FLOOR, FLAT NO.23,
SHREENGAR ESTATE ROAD NO.17, M.G. ROAD,
GOREGAON WEST, MUMBAI-4 (MAHARASHTRA)
(ii) GIRIRAJ SAXENA S/O LATE RAVIKUMAR
SAXENA, AGED ABOUT 12 YEARS, MINOR
THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN MOTHER
SMT. JYOTIKA W/O LATE RAVIKUMAR SAXENA,
R/O – DESHBANDHU, C.H.H. 4TH FLOOR, FLAT
NO.23, SHREENGAR ESTATE ROAD NO.17, M.G.
ROAD,
GOREGAON
WEST,
MUMBAI-4
(MAHARASHTRA)
RASHMI SAXENA D/O BRIJKISHORE DAS
SAXENA, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS, R/O BHAGWATI
APARTMENT,
MALAD
WEST,
MUMBAI (MAHARASHTRA) THROUGH POWER
2.
OF ATTORNEY – RAGHUNATH PRASAD SAXENA
S/O RADHAKRISHNA DAS SAXEENA, R/O BAKHTAWARRAM NAGAR, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
3. STATE OF M.P. THROUGH
SHAJAPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
COLLECTOR,
...RESPONDENTS
(SHRI NILESH AGRAWAL – ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.2)
(SHRI SHALABH SHARMA – GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR
RESPONDENT NO.3/STATE)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
09/01/2024
Pronounced on
:
02/02/2024
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This appeal having been heard and reserved for orders, coming on
for pronouncement this day, the court pronounced the following:
JUDGMENT
1.
This second appeal has been preferred by the appellant/defendants
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short
“CPC”) being aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 16.5.2008
passed by the Addl. Judge to Addl. District Judge, Agar in Civil Appeal
No.19-A/2007, thereby affirming the judgment and decree dated
12.2.2007 passed by the 2 nd Civil Judge Class-II, Agar in Civil Suit
No.313-A/2004 filed by the respondent No.1/plaintiff for declaration of
title, permanent injunction and compensation, which has been decreed
by the trial Court.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that Purushottam Das was earlier the
owner of the suit land bearing Survey No.2439 having area 0.993
hectare and Survey No.2443/2 having area 0.178 hectare situated at
Agar and after his death Brijkishore Saxena (father of the plaintiffs)
became owner of the suit land and the plaintiffs are his legal heirs.
Chaturbhuj Das, Purushottam Das and Sankarn Das were also the senior
member of plaintiff’s family. Deceased defendant was just a caretaker
of the said property. In 1996 Brij Kishor Das has died and after his
death, plaintiff No.1 Ravi Kumar used to visit Agar and he was
managing the income derived from the suit land. In the month of
September 2003, when the plaintiff Ravi came to Agar for the purpose
of selling the suit land, at that time he came to know that allegedly
through two different registered sale deeds dated 17.11.1980 suit land
was sold out to the defendant No.1, but on the same day Brij Kishore
Das was performing his official duty in the college situated at Mumbai
and these sale deeds are forged documents, which were never executed
by Brij Kishore Saxena and no consideration was ever paid to him by
the defendant No.1. Apparently defendant No.1 has forged and
fabricated those sale deeds. Therefore, the respondents No.1 &
2/plaintiffs have preferred a civil suit before the trial Court seeking
decree for permanent injunction, declaration of title and compensation.
3.
Defendants No.1 & 2/appellants denied all the allegations by
filing their written statement, in which it has been contended that
Chaturbhuj was the main Karta of the family and his decisions were
always accepted by all the family members. Being a owner of the suit
land Brij Kishore Das sold out the suit land to the defendant No.1 vide
two different registered sale deeds and accordingly name of the
defendants were duly mutated in revenue records. The suit filed by the
plaintiffs is barred by law and is not tenable and deserves to be
dismissed.
4.
Learned trial court after recording the evidence and hearing both
the parties, allowed the suit filed by the plaintiffs by the judgment and
decree dated 12.2.2007. Being aggrieved by the said judgment and
decree, the appellants/defendants No.1 & 2 have preferred first appeal
before the appellate court and by the impugned judgment and decree
dated 16.5.2008 the first appellate court has affirmed the judgment and
decree passed by the trial Court. Before the first appellate court an
alternate plea of adverse possession has been taken by the appellants,
which has been also discarded. Hence, this second appeal has been
preferred before this court by the appellants.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the judgment
and decree passed by both the courts below are contrary to the law and
facts. The trial court has erred in allowing the suit of the defendants
No.1 & 2/plaintiffs. The first appellate court has also committed grave
error in dismissing the application under Order 41 Rule 3 of CPC and
another application under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC filed by the
appellants. Both the courts below have failed to consider the oral and
documentary evidence produced by the appellants. Signature of Brij
Kishore Das was not examined by any handwriting expert and in
absence of any handwriting expert’s report, the trial court has
committed error in holding that the said sale deeds were not executed
by Brij Kishore Das Saxena. Thus, in view of the aforesaid, learned
counsel for the appellants submits that the appeal deserves to be
admitted on the substantial question of law proposed by the appellants.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents/plaintiffs opposed
the prayer by submitting that the impugned judgment and decree passed
by both the courts below are just and proper and not deserve for any
interference.
7.
This appeal has been admitted on the sole substantial question of
law:“Whether, the court below has committed error in
passing a decree for declaration that sale deed dated
17.11.1980 is forged and does not bear signature of
Brijkishore Das without appointing Handwriting Expert by
rejecting an application filed by the present appellant under
Section 45 of the Evidence Act?”
8.
I have gone through the judgment and decree passed by both the
courts below and also perused the entire record with due care.
9.
First of all learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the
lower appellate court has committed grave error in dismissing the
application under Order 41 Rule 3 of CPC and another application
under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC filed by the appellants.
10.
Both these interim applications filed before the first appellate
court i.e. IA No.2 & IA No.3 perused, but the proposed amendments do
not appears to be bonafide in nature and not necessary for proper
adjudication of the first appeal. Appellants did not show any good and
reasons for not pleading the same facts before the trial court. Therefore,
on the basis of the above, the lower appellate court has rightly rejected
both the interim applications – IA No.2 & IA No.3.
11.
Appellant’s second legal contention is that respondents/plaintiffs
have filed the suit for declaration and injunction after lapse of about 25
years, therefore, the suit is time barred. But the defendants were not the
party in the aforesaid registered sale deed. They have no knowledge
regarding the execution of the aforesaid sale deeds. When they came to
know about the execution of the sale deed, they have filed a suit within
the limitation. Therefore, both the courts below have rightly held that
the suit filed by the respondents/plaintiffs is not time barred.
12.
Plaintiff/respondent Raghunath Saxena (PW-1) categorically
stated in his statement that father of the plaintiff Brijkishore Das Saxena
was the owner of the suit land and defendant No.1 Harimohan Saxena
was only care taker of the suit land. Plaintiff No.1 Ravi Kumar used to
visit Agar for managing the suit land and in the month of September
2003 he came to know that the suit land was sold out by two different
registered sale deeds Ex.P/22 & P/23, but the same was not executed by
the Brijmohan Das Saxena. At the time of execution of the sale deed,
Brijkishore Das was doing job in a college situated at Mumbai. Ravi
Kumar Saxena (PW-2), Brijmohan Das Saxena (PW-3) and Haridas
(PW-5) also corroborated the statement of Raghunath Saxena (PW-1).
13.
Appellant/defendant Harimohan Saxena (DW-1) categorically
stated in his statement that he had purchased the suit land from
Brijkishore Das in presence of the witnesses Haridas and Mohanlal on
consideration of Rs.15,000/- through registered sale deeds, which were
duly signed by the Brijkishore Das and attesting witnesses Haridas and
Mohanlal. Then Brijkishore Das handed over the possession of the suit
land to his wife Kamla Bai. Thereafter he along with Kamla Bai
keeping continuous possession over the suit land as owner and doing
agricultural work upon it. Mohanlal (DW-2) and Banshidhar
Maheshwari (DW-3) also corroborated the statement of the defendant
Harimohan Saxena.
14.
Admittedly,
respondents/plaintiffs
did
not
examine
any
handwriting expert before the trial Court to establish that both the
registered sale deeds did not bear any signature of Brijmohan Das.
Although it is the settled position of law that as per Section 45 of the
Indian Evidence Act, handwriting expert’s opinion is not a conclusive
form of evidence and it cannot be read in absence of other corroborative
evidence. Therefore, it is quite clear that such type of evidence is a
week form of evidence. Appellants were having all rights and
opportunities to get the report of handwriting expert to strengthen their
case, but the same had not been done by them. Appellants cannot be
allowed to take advantage of his own wrong. It is also true that the
appellants have filed an application under Section 45 of the Evidence
Act before the trial Court and same has been dismissed, but the
appellants did not challenge the said order before the Hon’ble High
Court, therefore, the said order has attained finality and same cannot be
made a ground of this appeal.
15.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that it is settled law
that registered sale deeds were presumed genuine document and
without getting any handwriting expert’s evidence, such presumption
cannot be ignored and without the aid of an expert, Court cannot make
any conclusion only upon his own comparison. Counsel for the
appellants has placed reliance upon the judgment in the case of K.
Ahmed Alli Sab (deceased) and others Vs. Desai Abdul Gani Desai
[AIR 2005 Andhra Pradesh 374], The State (Delhi Administration)
Vs. Pali Ram [1979 AIR(SC) 14], Bhagwan Din Vs. Gouri Shankar
and another [AIR 1957 Allahabad 119], O. Bharathan Vs. K.
Sudhakaran and another [AIR 1996 SC 1140] and Vimal Chand
Ghevarchand Jain and others Vs. Ramakant Eknath Jajoo [2009(3)
Supreme 460].
16.
It is the settled position of law that Section 73 of the Indian
Evidence Act empowers the Court to compare signature, writing or see
with other admitted or proved documents. The Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of S. Gopal Reddy Vs. State of A.P. reported in 1996 SCC
(Cri.) 792 has held that:“28. Thus, the evidence of PW 3 is not definite and cannot be
said to be of a clinching nature to connect the appellant with the
disputed letters. The evidence of an expert is rather weak type of
evidence and the courts do not generally consider it as offering
‘conclusive’ proof and therefore safe to rely upon the same
without seeking independent and reliable corroboration. In
Magan Bihari Lal v. State of Punjab [(1977) 2 SCC 210], while
dealing with the evidence of a handwriting expert, this Court
opined: (SCC pp. 213-14, para 7)
“...... We think it would be extremely hazardous to candemn
the appellant merely on the strength of opinion evidence of a
handwriting expert. It is now well settled that expert opinion
must always be received with great caution and perhaps none so
with more caution than the opinion of a handwriting expert.
There is a profusion of precendential authority which holds that it
is unsafe to base a conviction solely on expert opinion without
substantial corroboration. This rule has been universally acted
upon and it has almost become a rule of law. It was held by this
Court in Ram Chandra v. State of U.P. [AIR 1957 SC 381] that it
is unsafe to treat expert handwriting opinion as sufficient basis
for conviction, but it may be relied upon when supported by
other items of internal and external evidence. This Court again
pointed out in Ishwari Prasad Misra v. Mohd. Isa [AIR 1963 SC
1728] that expert evidence of handwriting can never be
conclusive because it is, after all, opinion evidence, and this view
was reiterated in Shashi Kumar Banerjee v. Subodh Kumar
Banerjee [AIR 1964 SC 529] where it was pointed out by this
Court that expert's evidence as to handwriting being opinion
evidence can rarely, if ever, take the place of substantive
evidence and before acting on such evidence, it would be
desirable to consider whether it is corroborated either by clear
direct evidence or by circumstantial evidence. This Court had
again occasion to consider the evidentiary value of expert
opinion in regard to handwriting in Fakhruddin v. State of M.P.
[AIR 1967 SC 1326] and it uttered a note of caution pointing out
that it would be risky to found a conviction solely on the
evidence of a handwriting expert and before acting upon such
evidence, the court must always try to see whether it is
corroborated by other evidence, direct or circumstantial.”
17.
In the case of Sunil Chowdhury vs. Arup Kumar Ghos
reported in AIR 2006 Calcutta 109, a Division Bench of the Calcutta
High Court also held that:“24. Section 73 of the Evidence Act on the other hand authorises
the Court in order to ascertain whether a signature, writing etc. by
the person by whom it purports to have been written or made, to
compare the same with any signature, writing etc. admitted or
proved to the satisfaction of the Court to have been written or
made by that person although that signature, writing etc. has not
been produced or proved for any other purpose.
25. The aforesaid Section 73 further authorises the Court to
direct any person present in Court to write any words or figures
for the purpose of enabling the Court to compare the words or
figures so written with any words or figures alleged to have been
written by such person.”
18.
Same principle has been laid down by the Division Bench of the
Delhi High Court in the case of Rajinder Bajaj Vs. Indian Tanning
Industries and others reported in AIR 2008 Delhi 62, wherein it has
been held that:“6. Applying the principles laid down in the above noted
judicial pronouncements, it would be seen that in the instant
case no expert evidence, was available and the trial Court
examined the signatures on the purported appointment letter
and compared the same with the admitted signatures of Mr.
Juneja in the written statement and the affidavit. The trial court
was perfectly justified in doing so. The trial Court found
glaring discrepancies which could be discerned by naked eye.
It was, therefore, of the view that the purported appointment
letter was a fabricated one. The expert evidence had not been
led. In these circumstances, where the conclusion reached by
the trial Court was a definite and categorical one not admitted
to any doubt, non examination of the handwriting expert could
not be said to be fatal.”
19.
It is trite law that there is no legal bar to prevent the Court from
comparing signature or handwriting by using its own eye to compare
the disputed writing with the admitted writing and applying its own
observation to prove the said handwritings to be the same or different,
as the case may be. Signature of Brijmohan Das on the admitted letter
(Ex.P/26 to P/29), which has been written by Brijmohan Das, has been
duly proved, which was not challenged during the cross-examination of
the Ravi Kumar (PW-2). Therefore, these documents are unrebutted
documents. Glaring discrepancies discernible with naked eye.
Therefore, non examination of the handwriting expert is not fatal for the
respondents/plaintiffs and the conclusion reached by both the courts
below that the registered sale deeds (Ex.D/1 & D/2) are the fabricated
one, deserves credence. Both the courts below were duly justified in
examining and comparing the registered sale deeds with the admitted
signature of Brijmohan Das. Therefore, contention made by the
appellants cannot be accepted.
20.
It is also noteworthy that during the cross-examination of the
Raghunath Saxena (PW-1) and Ravi Kumar Saxena (PW-2) appellants/
defendants did not give any suggestion that consideration amount was
paid by the defendant or in lieu of the consideration, sale deeds were
executed. Appellant did not produce any relevant evidence that the
amount of consideration paid by them was deposited in the account of
the deceased Brijmohan Das. Therefore, the appellants have failed to
prove that they have purchased the suit land after payment of proper
consideration.
21.
Mohanlal (DW-2) who happens to be witness of the alleged sale
deeds, categorically stated in his statement that Haridas Saxena and
Brijkishore Das had signed the alleged sale deed and he is not aware
with rest of the facts. Therefore, on the basis of the statement of
Mohanlal (DW-2) the execution of the alleged sale deed by Brijkishore
Das appears to be doubtful. Banshidhar Maheshwari (DW-3) who
happens to be an advocate and allegedly drafted the sale deeds (Ex.D/1
& D/2), but he has turned hostile and not supported the case of the
defendant. He stated that he has just typed the alleged sale deeds and
nothing more. Even he is not acquainted with the Brijkishore Das and
further admits that he has typed the sale deeds on the instruction of the
defendant. Appellants did not examine concerned Registrar of Registry
Department before the trial Court. Therefore, the execution of the sale
deeds also became more suspicious.
22.
On the basis of the foregoing analysis and the law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court and different High Courts, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the judgment and decree passed by both the
courts below are based upon the proper appreciation of evidence.
Therefore, this Court does not find any infirmity in the judgment and
decree passed by both the courts below who have taken a plausible and
reasonable view on the evidence on record. Hence, this second appeal is
dismissed being devoid of merit. No order as to costs.
(ANIL VERMA)
JUDGE
Trilok/-
SAVNER
Date: 2024.02.02 18:14:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review