Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
Reserved on:
29.05.2026 26.02.2026
Pronounced on: 17.07.2026
Uploaded on:
17.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced-Full
.....Appellant/petitioner(s)
Hari Chand & Ors.
Through :- Mr. N.K Attri, Advocate.
v/s
.....Respondent(s)
UT of J&K & Ors.
Through :- Mr. P.D Singh, Dy. AG R-1 & 2.
Mr. Susheel Kr. Sharma, Advocate for R-3.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Petitioners have invoked inherent jurisdiction of this Court for the
quashment of FIR No. 379/2022, registered with Police Station Nagrota,
primarily on the ground of ‘double jeopardy’.
02.
Before a closer look at the grounds urged in the memo of petition, some
admitted facts regarding two complaints preferred by respondent no. 3
(hereinafter referred to as “the complainant”) are required to be noticed.
FIRST COMPLAINT
03.
As factual matrix would unfurl, on 24.05.2024 complainant preferred a
written complaint in the Court of learned CJM, Jammu, in terms of Section
156(3) CrPC, against petitioner no 2, namely, Yash Pal for offence under
Section 420 RPC, stating inter alia that his father late Sobha Singh had
appointed petitioner no. 1 as Pujari of Shiv Mandir, existing on his land and
allowed him to use the land subject to certain terms and conditions for a decent
livelihood only and an affidavit in this respect was also executed. The decision
was taken in the presence of respectable members of the community and
residents of Sidhra Bye-pass area. His father passed away on 14.02.2002,
whereafter petitioner no. 2 taking advantage of the situation, started indulging in
activities contrary to the duties assigned to him and began hobnobbing with
certain strangers with a view to grab the landed properties.
04.
It was alleged by the complainant that petitioner no. 2 with an intention to
deceive the family of his late father and residents of the locality, prepared and
signed an application in his handwriting, in the name of one Yash Pal Singh S/O
Kabla Singh, a resident of Sidhra Bye-pass, impersonated as Yash Pal Singh
before Police Station, Nagrota to obtain death certificate of his late father and
the police authorities acting in good faith issued death certificate to him and
obtained his signatures. It was also alleged by the complainant that petitioner
no. 2 had procured the death certificate of his late father without authorization
of his family and by forging the signatures for the preparation of some fake
documents concerning the landed property.
05.
According to the complainant, since the allegation made in the complaint
disclosed the commission of a non-cognizable offence, the police authorities
expressed their inability to register FIR and advised him to approach the
competent court. Accordingly, on the directions of learned CJM, FIR No.
87/2004, for offence under Section 420 RPC, came to be registered and
investigation culminated in the presentation of charge-sheet against petitioner
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
no. 2, for offence under Section 420 RPC, in the Court of learned Municipal
Magistrate, Jammu.
SECOND COMPLAINT.
06.
After the presentation of aforesaid charge-sheet against petitioner no. 2 on
30.06.2004, the complainant/respondent no. 3 filed another complaint titled
“Mukhtiyar Singh vs. Hari Chand and & Ors.” on 21.07.2004 against the
petitioners, including petitioner no. 2, whereby he alleged forgery of will dated
12.12.2001, purportedly executed by his late father Sobha Singh in favor of
petitioner no. 1, namely Hari Chand, father of petitioner no. 2.
07.
The complaint preferred the subsequent complaint on the same set of
facts that his late father had appointed petitioner no. 2 as Pujari of Shiv Mandir
existing on the land belonging to him and had merely permitted him to use the
said land, comprised of Khasra Numbers 203, 204 and 205 measuring 11 kanals
03 marlas for the limited purpose and subject to the terms and conditions settled
before respectables of the locality. That petitioner no. 2 prepared and signed an
application in the name of one Yash Paul Singh S/O Kabla Singh, a resident of
Sidhra Bye-Pass, forged the signatures of said Yash Paul Singh, posed himself
as Yash Paul Singh before the Police Station, obtained death certificate of his
late father and the Police acting in good faith issued the certificate to petitioner
no. 2 against a proper receipt signed by him.
08.
It was, however, alleged by the complainant in the second complaint that
petitioners hatched a conspiracy with a view to deprive him of his ownership
over the landed property left behind by his late father, prepared a fictitious will
by forging the signatures of his late father and one Durga Dass Chowkidar of
the area as a witness to the said will, presented the same for registration before
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
the registering authority, made a false statement and got it registered on
13.05.2004.
09.
The complainant asserted that petitioner no. 1 during investigation of the
first complaint had concealed the fact that he had obtained death certificate for
preparing a fictitious will with the connivance of other petitioners. He came to
know about the same only after receiving summons from the Court of learned
Sub-Judge, Samba, where petitioner no. 1 had filed a suit for declaration of title
and obtained ad-interim injunction against him with a view to defeat his right of
inheritance and grab the landed property.
10.
According to the complainant, neither his late father during his lifetime
executed any will in favor of petitioner no. 1 nor any such will came to be
disclosed to the members of the Biradari or people residing in the neighborhood,
at the time of his death on 14.02.2002. It was alleged that petitioners had
fabricated a false will and used it as a genuine document before a Court of law
to obtain injunction against him with a view to usurp the landed property of his
late father, which was already mutated in his favor.
11.
This subsequent complaint preferred by the complainant came to be
transferred to the Court of learned City Judge Jammu [“the trial court”] on
21.07.2004, who took cognizance of the matter, postponed the issuance of
process and directed SHO Police Station Nagrota to hold an inquiry in
accordance with the mandate of Section 202 CrPC and submit a detailed report
within fifteen days. The inquiry officer submitted the report on 09.07.2007,
stating that no offence was made out against the petitioners. However, the trial
court disagreeing with the conclusions drawn by the inquiry officer directed him
to proceed further with the inquiry and get the Will examined through FSL.
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
12.
The inquiry officer on 22.10.2014 came up with an application in the trial
court stating that though the original sale deed, will deed and FSL report dated
17.07.2005 seized by the investigating officer were deposited in the Police
Station by SGCT Pravez Iqbal on 02.07.2010 but these documents could not be
traced in the Police Station. The SHO expressed his inability to locate the
original documents and FSL report. On consideration of this application, the
trial court vide order dated 22.11.2014 directed SSP Jammu to conduct an
inquiry into the matter, take appropriate action against the delinquent official,
responsible for misplacing the documents and submit the compliance report.
APPLICATION FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION IN THE FIRST
CHARGE-SHEET.
13.
Pertinently, while proceedings in the second complaint were underway
complainant preferred an application under Section 173(8) CrPC for further
investigation in the earlier Charge-sheet No. 71/2004, which had arisen from
FIR No. 87/2004, on same set of allegations those were made in the second
complaint relating to the alleged forgery of Will by the petitioners. This
application for further investigation came to be allowed by learned Municipal
Magistrate, Jammu on 08.11.2013, whereby investigating agency was directed
to investigate the allegations regarding forgery of the Will dated 12.12.2001.
Further investigation culminated in the presentation of Supplementary Chargesheet no. 127/2015 dated 01.07.2015, against petitioner no. 2 whereby the
Investigating Officer came to conclude that the Will deed in question, registered
on 13.05.2004 in the Court of Sub-Registrar, Additional Munsiff Jammu, was
genuine. The investigating agency also concluded that though petitioner No. 2
had got the death certificate issued in his name, but he never used it. The
investigating agency also revealed in the supplementary charge-sheet that
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
departmental enquiry had been initiated against Head Constable MHC Chet
Ram No. 222/J, regarding misplacement of the FSL report, the Will deed and
other documents from the Police Station.
DISMISSAL OF FIRST CHARGESHEET AND SUPPLEMENTARY
CHARGE-SHEET
14.
Learned Municipal Magistrate, Jammu, vide a detailed judgment dated
08.12.2015, dismissed the first charge-sheet as also the supplementary chargesheet arising out of first FIR No. 87/2004 and acquitted petitioner No. 2 of the
allegations concerning forgery of the Will and use of death certificate. While
acquitting petitioner no. 2, Court also directed SSP, Jammu, to register FIR
against Chet Ram, MHC No. 222/2 of Police Station Nagrota.
15.
The revision petition preferred by said Chet Ram against the aforesaid
directions came to be dismissed by 1st Additional Sessions Judge Jammu, on
17.12.2016 and thereafter, CRMC No. 249/2017 filed by Chet Ram in this Court
also came to be dismissed on 13.10.2021.
CONTINUATION
OF
PROCEEDINGS
IN
THE
‘SECOND
COMPLAINT’.
16.
It is pertinent to underline that despite dismissal of the earlier charge-
sheet and the supplementary charge-sheet and acquittal of petitioner no. 2 in the
first FIR, the complainant continued to pursue the second complaint against the
petitioners by concealing material facts from the trial court that petitioner no. 2
had already been acquitted of the charges relating to forgery of the will and use
of forged documents as genuine by a competent court of law.
17.
Right of the complainant to lead evidence in the second complaint came
to be closed on 01.08.2017, i.e, much after dismissal of the first
complaint/charge-sheet by the competent court on 08.12.2015. The matter
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
remained pending for arguments till 20.09.2018. The arguments came to be
concluded and matter was reserved for orders. However, on 24.12.2009, trial
court again sent for fresh status report from SSP Jammu, which was submitted
on 04.02.2020 and thereafter matter continued to remain pending on the files of
learned trial court.
18.
Suddenly on 26.07.2022, about seven years after the dismissal of the first
charge-sheet and the supplementary charge-sheet, complainant made an
application in the trial court for directing SSP Jammu for registration of FIR. On
the same day SSP was directed by the trial court to lodge FIR against the
petitioners and impugned FIR No. 379 of 2022 for offences under Sections 420,
467, 471 and 120-B IPC came to be registered against the petitioners on
28.10.2022.
GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE
19.
Petitioners are aggrieved of the impugned FIR, inter alia, on the grounds
that a perusal of the interim orders passed by learned trial court from time to
time, would show that complainant did not apprise the Court that first chargesheet had already been dismissed by the competent Court on 08.12.2015. The
complainant kept the criminal proceedings stretched for 18 long years despite
the fact that genesis of the dispute had already been addressed by the
investigating agency and the competent criminal Court.
20.
It is contended by the petitioners that complainant has filed a civil suit
titled “Mukhityar Singh vs. Hari Chand” for the annulment of the Will deed in
question 12.12.2001, which is pending adjudication in the Court of learned
Additional District Judge, Jammu. Petitioner No. 1, has also filed a civil suit for
declaration of ownership and possession of the land in question on the strength
of the same Will deed, which is pending on the files of learned City Judge,
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
Jammu. Both the suits came to be transferred, by District Judge Jammu and
consolidated by Additional District Judge, Jammu. Consolidated issues with
respect to the Will in question have been framed in the suit. Since the will in
question was misplaced by the Police authorities, petitioner no. 1 filed an
application seeking permission to lead secondary evidence to prove the Will and
application was allowed.
21.
It is allegation of the petitioners that the complainant/respondent no. 3
with oblique motive to prevent petitioner no. 1 from proving the Will through
secondary evidence, moved application before the trial Court for registration of
FIR which was allowed on the same day, which is an abuse of the process of
law.
22.
Heard arguments and perused the file.
RIVAL CONTENTIONS
23.
Mr. Attri, learned counsel for the petitioner, has relied upon T.P
Gopalakrishnan Vs. The State of Kerala; 2002 Live Law (SC) 1039, to
reiterate the grounds urged in the memo of the petition.
24.
Per contra, Mr. P.D Singh, learned Dy. AG appearing for the official
respondents
and
Mr.
Susheel
Sharma,
learned
counsel
for
the
complainant/respondent no. 3, have vehemently argued that though a complaint
in respect of the same transaction covered by the first FIR may not be
maintainable, it is nevertheless permissible where it relates to a distinct issue,
uncovering a larger conspiracy or fresh facts beyond the scope of the first
complaint/FIR.
25.
Mr. Sharma, learned counsel for the private respondent, has relied upon
The State of Rajasthan Vs. Surendra Singh Rathore; AIR 2025 SC 1096,
Central Bureau of Investigation vs. Aryan Singh; 2023 live law (SC) 292
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
and Parbatbhai Aahir @ Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur & Ors. vs.
State of Gujarat & Anr.; 2017 (9) SCC 641, to buttress his contention.
DISCUSSION
26.
There can be no exception to the settled position of law that while
examining the FIR or the complaint sought to be quashed, the High Court in
exercise of its inherent jurisdiction cannot embark upon an enquiry or conduct a
mini trial to determine the genuineness or otherwise of the allegations contained
therein. It is equally well settled that mere existence of a civil dispute would not
ipso facto bar the criminal proceedings. A general impression that criminal
proceedings are barred whenever a civil dispute exists cannot be stretched to
such an extent. What the Court is required to examine is whether the allegations
made in the complaint disclose the ingredients of a cognizable offence
independent of the civil dispute. These principles have been reinforced by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Aryan Singh (supra) and Parbatbhai Aahir (supra),
the case law cited at bar by learned counsel for the complainant.
27.
Section 482 CrPC recognizes and preserves the powers of the High Court
to prevent the abuse of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends
of justice. It serves as a reminder that High Court is not merely a Court of law
but also a Court of justice, possessing inherent powers to remove injustice.
Therefore, before forming an opinion as to whether criminal proceedings, a
complaint or an FIR deserves to be quashed, Court is obliged to evaluate
whether the ends of justice would justify the exercise of such inherent powers.
28.
In the aforesaid circumstances, the question which arises for
consideration in the present case is whether second complaint, relating to the
same cause of action or transaction covered by the first FIR in the absence of
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
unknown facts and exceptional circumstances and simply by adding new
offence or naming new people shall be maintainable.
29.
Clause 2 of Article 20 expressly provides that “No person shall be
prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once”. In legal
parlance, it is termed as protection against ‘double jeopardy’, which constitutes
a fundamental right guaranteed under Part III of the Constitution of India.
30.
Section 300 CrPC, corresponding to Section 337 BNSS, also embodies
the same protection, which for the facility of reference is extracted below:Section 300 CrPC Person once convicted or acquitted not to be tried for same
offence.
A person who has once been tried by a Court of competent jurisdiction for an
offence and convicted or acquitted of such offence shall, while such conviction
or acquittal remains in force, not be liable to be tried again for the same
offence, nor on the same facts for any other offence for which a different
charge from the one made against him might have been made under
subsection (1) of section 221, or for which he might have been convicted under
sub-section (2) thereof.(2)
A person acquitted or convicted of any offence may be afterwards tried, with the
consent of the State Government, for any distinct offence for which a separate
charge might have been made against him at the former trial under sub-section (1) of
section 220.
(3) A person convicted of any offence constituted by any act causing consequences
which, together with such act, constituted a different offence from that of which he
was convicted, may be afterwards tried for such last mentioned offence, if the
consequences had not happened, or were not known to the Court to have happened,
at the time when he was convicted.
(4) A person acquitted convicted of any offence constituted by any acts may,
notwithstanding such acquittal or conviction, be subsequently charged with, and tried
for, any other offence constituted by the same acts which he may have committed if
the Court by which he was first tried was not competent to try the offence with which
he is subsequently charged.
(5) A person discharged under section 258 shall not be tried again for the same
offence except with the consent of the Court by which he was discharged or of any
other Court to which the first mentioned Court is subordinate.
(6) Nothing in this section shall affect the provisions of section 26 of the General
Clauses Act, 1897(10 of 1897) or of section 188 of this Code
Explanation.—The dismissal of a complaint, or the discharge of the accused, is not
an acquittal for the purposes of this section.
Explanation—The dismissal of a complaint, or the discharge of the accused, is not an
acquittal for the purposes of this section.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
31.
Section 300 CrPC is slightly different from Article 20 (2) of the
Constitution because it incorporates within its sweep not only the plea of
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
autrefois convict or previously convicted but also autrefois acquit or previously
acquitted, whereas Article 20(2) bars second prosecution only on the plea of
autrefois convict; i.e, when accused has been prosecuted and punished for the
same offence previously and does not bar subsequent trial if ingredient of the
offences in the previously and subsequent trial are different.
32.
It is manifest from a plain reading of Section 300 CrPC that it not only
bars the trial of a person for the same offence but also for any other offence
founded on same facts. Sub-section (1) of Section 300 CrPC. embodies the
general rule of double jeopardy by affirming the pleas of autrefois acquit
(previously acquitted) and autrefois convict (previously convicted). In other
words, so long as an order of acquittal or conviction rendered by a competent
Court of law remains in operation and is not called into question by the
complainant or the prosecution, the person cannot be tried again for the same
offence or on same set of facts for any other offence for which he was tried
earlier except in the cases provided under sub-sections 2 to 5.
33.
The principles underlying sub-sections 2 to 5 of Section 300 CrPC came
to be discussed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vijayalakshmi vs. Vasudevan
(1994) 4 SCC 656, whereby it was held that in order to bar the trial of a person
already tried, it must be shown that in the first trial, he was tried by a court of
competent jurisdiction for the same offence or one for which he might have
been charged or convicted at a trial on the same facts and he has been
convicted or acquitted in the said trial and such conviction or acquittal is in
operation and never called into question.
34.
A similar observation has been made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in T.P.
Gopalakrishnan (supra).
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
35.
Mr. Susheel Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the complainant has
predominantly relied upon Surendra Singh Rathore (supra) to vehemently
argue that though subsequent complaint when relates to the same offence or
transaction covered by the first FIR is not maintainable, however, it is
permissible when it pertains to a distinct issue uncovering a larger conspiracy or
there are new facts beyond the scope of first FIR.
36.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Surendra Singh Rathore following the
conspectus of various pronouncements rendered by it from time to time laid
down the following principles regarding permissibility of the registration of
second FIR:
“9.1 When the second FIR is counter-complaint or presents a rival version of a set of
facts, in reference to which an earlier FIR already stands registered.
9.2 When the ambit of the two FIRs is different even though they may arise from the
same set of circumstances.
9.3 When investigation and/or other avenues reveal the earlier FIR or set of facts to be
part of a larger conspiracy.
9.4 When investigation and/or persons related to the incident bring to the light hitherto
unknown facts or circumstances.
9.5 Where the incident is separate; offences are similar or different.”
37.
If the present case is approached with the aforesaid principles of law
enunciated by the Apex Court, it is manifestly clear that subsequent complaint
preferred by the complainant in the case on hand is not covered by the
parameters laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court, regarding permissibility of
the registration of subsequent complaint/FIR.
38.
As stated in detail, during the currency of second complaint preferred by
the complainant on 21.07.2004, he simultaneously filed an application for
further investigation under Section 173(8) CrPC in the first charge-sheet on the
same set of allegations with respect to the forgery of the will and use of forged
documents as genuine by the petitioners. The application was allowed and
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
further investigation culminated in the presentation of supplementary chargesheet against petitioner no. 2, whereby pertinently the investigating officer
concluded that neither will deed was forged nor petitioner no. 2 had used the
death certificate as genuine. Consequently, petitioner no. 2 was acquitted by the
competent Court of the allegations concerning forgery of the will and use of
death certificate. However, the complainant concealed these material facts from
the trial court and continued to pursue the second complaint.
39.
Pertinently, the findings of the investigating agency in the supplementary
charge-sheet, to the effect that will deed, which was duly executed and
registered before the competent registering authority, was not forged and that
petitioner no. 2 had not used the death certificate as genuine, and judgment of
the competent court whereby petitioner no. 2 came to be acquitted of the
allegations relating to the forgery of the will purportedly executed by late father
of the complainant having not been called into question by the complainant had
attained finality.
40.
Be that as it may, learned trial court on mere asking of the complainant
has directed registration of the impugned FIR against the petitioners in the
absence of any fresh material/status report with respect to the inquiry regarding
misplacement of the documents. Learned trial court has failed to appreciate that
the investigating officer, SHO Police Station Nagrota after repeated inquiries
regarding the will in question and getting it examined through the forensic
laboratory had already submitted a report on 22.10.2014 that original sale deed,
will deed and FSL report dated 17.07.2002, seized by the investigating officer,
though deposited in the Police Station by SGCT Pervaiz Iqbal on 02.07.2010
could not be traced. The SHO expressed his inability to locate the original
documents and the FSL report. On consideration of the status report of the
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
inquiry officer, learned trial court vide order dated 22.11.2014 had directed SSP
Jammu to conduct an enquiry into the matter, take appropriate action against the
delinquent officials/officer responsible for misplacing the documents and submit
the compliance report. Significantly no compliance report in this respect is
found to have been made by the inquiry officer. Learned Municipal Magistrate,
Jammu, vide judgment dated 08.12.2015, while acquitting petitioner no. 2 of the
allegations concerning forgery of the will and use of documents also directed
SSP Jammu to register FIR against MHC Chet Ram No. 222/2 of Police Station,
Nagrota. The Revision preferred by said Chet Ram was dismissed by 1st
Additional Sessions Judge, Jammu and CRMC filed by said Chet Ram in this
Court had also met the same fate.
41.
Chapter XV of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) deals with
‘Complaints to Magistrates’. The Chapter provides a compressive procedure
with respect to the entertainment of a complaint and taking cognizance under
Section 200, the procedure to be adopted by a Magistrate who is not competent
to take cognizance of the offence under Section 201, postponement of the
issuance of process for the purpose of deciding whether or not there is sufficient
ground for proceeding under Section 202 and dismissal of the complaint after
considering the statements of the complainant and his witnesses and the result of
the enquiry under Section 203. Chapter XVI lays down the procedure for the
commencement of proceedings before the Magistrate. Therefore, if a Magistrate
duly applies the mind to the material before him and proceeds to commence the
proceedings and issue process under Chapter XVI, second complaint on same
set of facts is manifestly barred. The necessary corollary of this proposition is
that dismissal of a complaint by the Magistrate under section 203 CrPC does not
bar the entertainment of second complaint on the same set of facts if the order in
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
the first complaint was passed on an incomplete record, or on misunderstanding
the nature of complaint, or where it was manifestly absurd, or where new facts
could not be brought on record by the complainant despite due diligence.
42.
This issue has been considered in detail by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Parmatha Nath Talukdar vs. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar; 1961 SCC online SC
155.
43.
Relying upon this verdict, Supreme Court in Vindeshwari Prasad Singh
Vs. Kali Singh; (1977) 1 SCC 57 has reiterated that a second complaint can lie
only on fresh facts or even on the previous facts only if a special case is made
out.
44.
An identical observation was made by Supreme Court in Shivshankar
Singh Vs. State of Bihar: (2012) 1 SCC 130. Relevant observation contained
in para 18 of the said judgment, for the facility of reference, is extracted below:“18. Thus, it is evident that the law does not prohibit filing or entertaining of
the second complaint even on the same facts provided the earlier complaint
has been decided on the basis of insufficient material or the order has been
passed without understanding the nature of the complaint or the complete
facts could not be placed before the court or where the complainant came to
know certain facts after disposal of the first complaint which could have tilted
the balance in his favour. However, the second complaint would not be
maintainable wherein the earlier complaint has been disposed of on full
consideration of the case of the complainant on merit.”
45.
A similar observation has been made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Jatinder Singh vs. Ranjit Kour; (2001) 2 SCC 570. Relevant extract reads as
below:"9. There is no provision in the Code or in any other statute which debars a
complainant from preferring a second complaint on the same allegations if the
first complaint did not result in a conviction or acquittal or even discharge.
Section 300 of the Code, which debars a second trial, has taken care to
explain that "the dismissal of a complaint, or the discharge of the accused, is
not an acquittal for the purposes of this section". However, when a Magistrate
conducts an inquiry under. Section 202 of the Code and dismisses the
complaint on merits, a second complaint on the same facts cannot be made
unless there are very exceptional circumstances. Even so, a second
complaint is permissible depending upon how the complaint happened to be
dismissed at the first instance."
46.
It is manifest from the conspectus of consistent judicial approach
discussed above that though after the acceptance of the final report under
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
Section 173 CrPC, it is open to the Magistrate to take cognizance of second
complaint but subject to the caveat that there is discovery of new facts which,
despite due diligence could not be brought on record by the complainant in the
first complaint, or where there is a manifest error or miscarriage of justice.
Thus, though there is no absolute bar to taking cognizance of a second
complaint, the same is permissible only in exceptional circumstances and not in
a mechanical or routine fashion.
47.
Mr. P.D Singh, learned Dy. AG. representing the official respondents, has
vehemently contended that first complaint, which culminated in charge-sheet
no. 71/2004, was against petitioner no. 2 alone and for the alleged commission
of an offence under Section 420 RPC only, whereas the impugned FIR has been
ordered by learned trial court to be lodged against five accused persons,
petitioners herein, for offences under Sections 420, 467, 471 and 120-B IPC.,
Learned Dy. AG. is of the view that impugned FIR would be maintainable to
unearth larger conspiracy on the basis of factual foundation laid in the second
complaint by respondent no. 3.
48.
In the backdrop of the settled canons of criminal jurisprudence discussed
hereinabove, Court is required to examine the facts and circumstances giving
rise to the preference of two complaints by the same complainant, by applying
the ‘test of sameness’ to ascertain whether both the FIRs relate to the same
incident, the same occurrence, or whether they constitute different parts of the
same transaction. If the answer is in the affirmative, the impugned FIR is liable
to be quashed and on the contrary, if it is found that version contained in the
impugned FIR relates to a different incident or discloses a distinct crime, it
would be legally permissible.
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
49.
The only ground urged by the complainant to maintain the subsequent
complaint is that petitioners hatched a conspiracy to prepare a fictitious will,
appended the signatures of his late father, appeared before the registering
authority, made false statements on oath and got the will registered by forging
the signatures of his late father and one of the witnesses. According to the
complainant, he came to know about the conspiracy only after receiving
summons from the Court of Sub-Judge, Samba where petitioner no. 1 had filed
a civil suit and obtained an injunction against him with a view to defeat his right
of inheritance and grab the landed estate. As already discussed in detail, the
complainant not only filed the second complaint but simultaneously preferred an
application for further investigation in the earlier charge-sheet on the same set
of facts and allegations. Further investigation concluded in the presentation of
supplementary charge-sheet against petitioner no. 2 whereby it was established
that neither the will deed in question was found forged nor any document was
used by petitioner no. 2 as genuine. Despite this, conclusive satisfaction of the
investigating agency and acquittal of petitioner no. 2 in the first charge-sheet,
complainant continued with the subsequent complaint against the petitioners by
suppressing these material facts from the trial court.
50.
No doubt, reopening a closed dispute can be permitted but under strict
conditions; such as first complaint was dismissed on a technical default rather
than on merits, or substantial evidence had surfaced that could not be discovered
earlier with reasonable diligence or if second complaint adds new accused
persons who play a distinct and provable role in a larger conspiracy or a
criminal transaction. It is evident from the conspectus of the facts and
allegations of the second complaint and application filed by the complainant for
further investigation in the first charge-sheet that it clears the ‘test of sameness’,
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
because the ambit of both is same, incident is same and offences are also same.
The investigation and/or persons related to the incident do not bring to the light
unknown facts or circumstances. Therefore, complainant could not be allowed
to continue with the second complaint for the same cause of action simply by
adding new offence or naming new people or tweaking his original statement. If
subsequent complaint merely drags a different set of individuals into the exact
same
grievance
that
was
already
investigated
and
ruled upon, it cannot sustain in the eyes of law. Multiple complaints cannot be
permitted by the same complainant in respect of the same incident which leads
to the accused persons being entangled in mult
51.
iple criminal proceedings.
CONCLUSION
52.
Having regard to what has been observed and discussed above, I am of
the considered view that impugned FIR has been lodged by the complainant
with an ulterior motive to wreak vengeance by dragging a different set of
persons, petitioners herein, into the very same grievance which already stands
ruled upon and rejected by the competent court. It is an attempt on the part of
the complainant to entangle the petitioners in multiple criminal proceedings,
which is not permissible in law. Therefore, impugned FIR, being an abuse of the
process of law, is liable to be set-aside.
53.
Hence, present petition is allowed and impugned FIR is quashed.
54.
Disposed of.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
JAMMU
17.07.2026.
Abinash
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
Whether the judgment is speaking?
Whether the judgment is reportable?
.
CRM(M) No. 1038/2022
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review