Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ROOPESH CHANDRA VARSHNEY
ON THE 04th DAY OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 1277 OF 2016
BETWEEN:KAMLESH
KUSHWAH
S/O
SHRI
HARGOVIND KUSHWAH, AGED 24 YEARS,
OCCUPATION MACHINE OPERATOR, R/O
VILLAGE VILASPUR, DISTRICT DATIA, AT
PRESENT KISHORI KUSHWAH KA MAKAN,
VILLAGE GUTHINA, P.S.MAHARAJPUR,
DISTRICT GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI P.C.CHANDIL - ADVOCATE )
AND
1 MANGAL SINGH KUSHWAH S/O SHRI
SIYASHARAN KUSHWAH, R/O VILLAGE
GORA-BARTHARA,
P.S.
DABOH,
DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH).
(DRIVER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
2.
KASHIPRASAD
KUSHWAH
S/O
MANOHAR KUSHWAH, R/O VILLAGE
PARECHHA TEHSIL LAHAR, DISTRICT
BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH).
(OWNER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
3. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
LIMITED, REGIONAL NO. 2, OFFICE
JAYENDRAGANJ, LASHKAR, GWALIOR
THROUGH
REGIONAL
MANAGER
(MADHYA PRADESH).
.....RESPONDENTS
(RESPONDENT NO. 3 BY SHRI K.S.ROCHLANI - ADVOCATE)
AND
MISC. APPEAL No. 1279 OF 2016
BETWEEN:HARGOVIND KUSHWAH S/O LATE
SHRI KALLURAM KUSHWAH, AGED
47 YEARS, OCCUPATION SERVICE,
R/O VILLAGE VILASPUR, DISTRICT
DATIA,
AT
PRESENT
KISHORI
KUSHWAH KA MAKAN, VILLAGE
GUTHINA,
P.S.
MAHARAJPURA,
DISTRICT
GWALIOR
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI P.C.CHANDI - ADVOCATE )
AND
1 MANGAL SINGH KUSHWAH S/O
SHRI SIYASHARAN KUSHWAH, R/O
VILLAGE
GORA-BARTHARA,
P.S.
DABOH, DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA
PRADESH).
(DRIVER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
2. KASHIPRASAD KUSHWAH S/O
MANOHAR KUSHWAH, R/O VILLAGE
PARECHHA
TEHSIL
LAHAR,
DISTRICT
BHIND
(MADHYA
PRADESH).
(OWNER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
3. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
LIMITED, REGIONAL NO. 2, OFFICE
JAYENDRAGANJ,
LASHKAR,
GWALIOR THROUGH REGIONAL
MANAGER (MADHYA PRADESH).
.....RESPONDENTS
(RESPONDENT NO. 3 BY SHRI K.S.ROCHLANI - ADVOCATE)
AND
MISC. APPEAL No. 39 OF 2017
BETWEEN:NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
HAVING DIVISIONAL OFFICE NO. 2 AT
INDARGANJ, LASHKAR, GWALIOR
THROUGH ITS SENIOR DIVISIONAL
MANAGER (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI S.N.GAJENDRAGADKAR - ADVOCATE )
AND
1 KAMLESH KUSHWAH S/O SHRI
HARGOVIND KUSHWAH, AGED 24
YEARS,
OCCUPATION
MACHINE
OPERATOR, R/O VILLAGE VILASPUR,
DISTRICT DATIA, AT PRESENT
KISHORI KUSHWAH KA MAKAN,
VILLAGE
GUTHINA,
P.S.MAHARAJPUR,
DISTRICT
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.MANGAL SINGH KUSHWAH S/O
SHRI SIYASHARAN KUSHWAH, R/O
VILLAGE
GORA-BARTHARA,
P.S.
DABOH, DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA
PRADESH).
(DRIVER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
3. KASHIPRASAD KUSHWAH S/O
MANOHAR KUSHWAH, R/O VILLAGE
PARECHHA
TEHSIL
LAHAR,
DISTRICT
BHIND
(MADHYA
PRADESH).
(OWNER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
.....RESPONDENTS
AND
MISC. APPEAL No.40 OF 2017
BETWEEN:NATIONAL
INSURANCE
CO.
LTD.
HAVING DIVISIONAL OFFICE NO. 2 AT
INDARGANJ, LASHKAR, GWALIOR
THROUGH ITS SENIOR DIVISIONAL
MANAGER (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI S.N.GAJENDRAGADKAR - ADVOCATE )
AND
1 HARGOVIND KUSHWAH S/O LATE
SHRI KALLURAM KUSHWAH, AGED
45 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE VILASPUR,
DISTRICT DATIA, AT PRESENT
KISHORI KUSHWAH KA MAKAN,
VILLAGE
GUTHINA,
P.S.
MAHARAJPURA, DISTRICT GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.MANGAL SINGH KUSHWAH S/O
SHRI SIYASHARAN KUSHWAH, R/O
VILLAGE
GORA-BARTHARA,
P.S.
DABOH, DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA
PRADESH).
(DRIVER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
3. KASHIPRASAD KUSHWAH S/O
MANOHAR KUSHWAH, R/O VILLAGE
PARECHHA
TEHSIL
LAHAR,
DISTRICT
BHIND
(MADHYA
PRADESH).
(OWNER
:
MOTORCYCLE
NO.
MP30MG9256)
.....RESPONDENTS
(RESPONDENT NO. 1 BY SHRI P.C.CHANDIL - ADVOCATE)
These appeals coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
This common order shall govern disposal of M.A.No. 1277/2016,
1279/2016, 39/2017 and 40/2017 as all these appeals are filed by against
the common award dated 14/10/2016 passed by First Additional Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Gwalior in Claim Case No. 69/2015 and
72/2015 respectively, whereby, the Claims Tribunal has awarded a sum of
Rs. 68,118/- and 32,200/- to complainant/injured Kamlesh Kushwah and
Hargovind Kushwah respectively, who sustained grievous injuries in road
accident dated 24/5/2014 and liability for payment of compensation
amount was fastened over Driver-cum-Owner and Insurance Company
jointly and severally.
2. M.A.Nos. 1277/2016 and 1279/2016 are filed on behalf of
claimants/injured for enhancement of the impugned award amount;
whereas, M.A.Nos. 39/2017 and 40/2017 have been filed on behalf of
Insurance Company assailing liability part of the impugned award.
3.The
brief facts giving rise are to the effect that on 24/5/2014 at about 8.00 pm,
when claimant Kamlesh Kushwah alongwith his father /another claimant
Hargoind Kushwah were going on a motorcycle from Indargarh to their
village Vilaspur, when they reached Indargarh Lanch Road Petrol Pump,
the driver of motorcycle No. MP30MG9256 by driver its motorcycle in
rash and negligent manner dashed motorcycle of claimants headon due to
which injured suffered grievous hurts. Thereafter, claimants filed separate
claim applications before the Claims Tribunal vide Claim Case No.
69/2015 (Kamlesh Kushwah Vs. Mangal Singh Kushwah & Ors.) and
Claim Case No. 72/2015 (Hargovind Kushwah Vs. Mangal Singh
Kushwah & Ors.) which stood partly allowed by impugned award and the
Claims Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs. 68,188/- and 32,200/- respectively
as compensation for the injuries sustained by them and has fixed the
liability of payment of compensation amount over driver and owner and
insurance company jointly and severally.
4. M.A.No. 1277/2016 and 1279/2016 have been filed by claimants
assailing the impugned award on the ground of quantum of compensation
amount as accordingly to them looking to the injuries sustained by them,
the amount of compensation as awarded by the Claims Tribunal is on the
lower side; whereas, according to learned counsel for the Insurance
Company, who filed M.A.Nos. 39/2017 and 40/2017 assailing impugned
award on the ground of liability part, submits that on the date of incident,
the offending vehicle was being run in breach of insurance policy as the
driver of the vehicle was not holding driving licence and in this respect he
also produced evidence. Further in seizure memo (Ex. P/2) there is no
mention of seizure of any driving licence. In the Mechanical report of
vehicle Ex. P/6 also, there is no
reference of any licence. Insurance
Company also issued notices to produce the licence but even thereafter, no
licence has been produced. Evidence produced by Insurance Company
remained unrebuttable before the Claims Tribunal, even thereafter, liability
was fixed over insurance company, and therefore, same is bad in law.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6. As regards M.A.No. 1277/2016 and 1279/2016 filed on behalf of
claimants/injured, after having heard learned counsel appearing for the
parties and on perusal of the pleadings and the evidence so adduced, in
the opinion of this Court, the amount of compensation as awarded by the
claims Tribunal is on the lower side considering the nature of injuries,
treatment papers and its period, the mental pain and suffering and also the
other heads, the compensation as awarded by the Claims Tribunal is
liable to be enhanced by Rs. 25,000/- each in lump sum thereby making
the total compensation Rs.93,118/- and 57,200/- respectively which shall
be payable along with the interest from the date of filing of the claim
petition.
7. As regards M.A.Nos. 39/2017 and 40/2017 moved on behalf of
Insurance Company, on the basis of evidence adduced by the insurance
company as referred above by learned counsel for the Insurance Company,
which remained unrebutted, in the opinion of this Court learned claims
tribunal has wrongly fixed the liability of payment of compensation
amount over the Insurance Company as the vehicle was being driven
without licence. Therefore, Insurance Company is hereby exonerated from
the liability of payment of compensation amount and instead driver and
owner of the offending vehicle are held liable for payment of
compensation amount; however, in light of decisions of the Supreme
Court in the cases of Shivaraj Vs. Rajendra; [(2018) 10 SCC 432],
Manuara Khatun Vs. Rajesh Kumar Singh; [2017 ACJ 1031] &
Shamanna and another Vs. Divisional Manager Vs. the Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. and others, [(2018) 9 SCC 650]; wherein, it has
observed that in the case of breach of policy, directions against the
Insurance Company to pay the awarded sum to the claimants and then to
recover the said sum from the insured be given by applying the principle of
"pay and recover". Therefore, it is directed that insurance company shall
pay the compensation to the claimants with the right to recover the same
from driver and owner of the offending vehicle.
8.
In view of the forgoing discussions, the appeals (M.A.No.
1277/2016 and 1279/2016) filed by claimants succeeds and are hereby
allowed in part and the claimants Kaimlesh Kushwah and Hargovind
Kushwah are held entitled to receive the enhanced amount of Rs. 25,000/each in addition to the amount of compensation already awarded by the
Claims Tribunal with interest as per impugned award from the date of
claim petition and as regards M.A.No. 39/2017 and 40/2017, moved on
behalf of Insurance Company, they are also allowed in part and while
exonerating the Insurance Company from liability of payment of
compensation amount, driver and owner of the offending vehicle are held
liable for payment of compensation amount; however, in light of decisions
of Apex Court as referred above it is directed that insurance company shall
pay the compensation to the claimants first with the right to recover the
same from
driver and owner of the offending vehicle. Rest of the
conditions as imposed by the Claims Tribunal shall remain intact. In the
facts of the case, parties are directed to bear their own costs.
(ROOPESH CHANDRA VARSHNEY)
JUDGE
jps/JAI
PRAKASH
SOLANKI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
BENCH GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=287738d30aabaeda9b10cecdf179cec865
c7633f4cfb9e38ce14fcbb05b9522a,
postalCode=474001, st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=8D6BC1C9FCE36623D0BD6B8072A
2D8C01433EBD48AE4F609F108CA8F8DE6B522,
cn=JAI PRAKASH SOLANKI
Date: 2024.01.08 11:17:55 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review