Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27409
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
TUESDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 8 OF 2020
AGAINST THE DECREE AND JUDGMENT DATED IN OS NO.23 OF 2017 OF
SUB COURT, SULTHANBATHERY
----APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
HAMAZA HAJI,
AGED 52 YEARS,
S/O.ANTHRU HAJI, KIZHAKKAYIL HOUSE, KAMBALAKKAD POST,
KANIYAMBETTA AMSOM DESOM, VYTHIRI TALUK,
WAYANAD - 673 122.
BY ADVS.
G.P.SHINOD
GOVIND PADMANAABHAN
SHRI.AJIT G ANJARLEKAR
RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
THYKKANDIYIL IBRAHIM,
AGED 64 YEARS,
S/O.AMMED HAJI, THYKKANDIYIL HOUSE, KAMBALAKKAD POST,
KANIYAMBETTA AMSOM DESOM, VYTHIRI TALUK,
WAYANAD - 673 122.
THAZHE RAYAROTHKANDIYIL KUNHAMMED,
AGED 51 YEARS
S/O.KUNHABDULLA HAJI, THAZHERAYAROTHKANDIYIL HOUSE,
ORKATTERI POST, KARTHIKAPPALLY AMSOM, MUYIMPRA DESOM,
VADAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 501.
2025:KER:27409
RFA NO. 8 OF 2020
-2-
THAZHE RAYAROTHKANDIYIL RAFEEQUE,
AGED 47 YEARS,
S/O.KUNHABDULLA HAJI, THAZHERAYAROTHKANDIYIL HOUSE,
ORKATTERI POST, KARTHIKAPPALLY AMSOM, MUYIMPRA DESOM,
VADAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT - 673 501.
BY ADVS.
SRI.S.VINOD BHAT
KUM.ANAGHA LAKSHMY RAMAN
SMT.MINI V.MENON
THIS
REGULAR
FIRST
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
01.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:27409
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 1st day of April, 2025
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
The suit for return of advance sale consideration
paid under an agreement for sale, was decreed in part.
Challenging
that
part
of
the
decree
which
declined
relief, the plaintiff is in appeal.
2. Ext.A1 agreement dated 09.12.2013 was entered
into between the plaintiff and the defendant, where
under,
the
plaint
'A'
schedule
property
was
to
be
purchased by the plaintiff from the defendant for a
total consideration of ₹ 1,79,50,000/-. The discharge of
the consideration was to be by conveyance of the plaint
'B' schedule property having a value of ₹ 50 lakhs in
favour
₹
of
the
1,29,50,000/-
defendant
to
be
and
the
balance
amount
of
paid.
The
period
fixed
for
performance was up to 30.09.2014. As evidenced by Ext.B1
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 2 :-
memorandum
dated
07.06.2015,
the
period
fixed
for
performance was extended up to 20.08.2015. Under the
agreement the plaintiff paid a total amount of ₹ 85
lakhs towards advance sale consideration. Alleging that
the defendant failed to convince the plaintiff of the
extent and title, the suit was instituted for return of
the advance sale consideration.
3. The execution of Ext.A1 agreement and Ext.B1
mediation memorandum, are not in dispute. The receipt of
₹ 85 lakhs towards advance sale consideration is also
admitted. It is the contention of the defendant that the
plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform the
agreement. It was claimed that consequent to the default
on the part of the plaintiff to perform the agreement,
the defendant sustained damages. He sought appropriation
of
the
advance
amount
of
₹
lakhs,
towards
the
damages.
4. The trial court held that the plaintiff had
committed breach of the agreement. It is also found that
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 3 :-
the defendant has failed to prove the damages suffered
by him consequent on the breach. However, the court
opined that, upon the breach of the agreement, the
defendant must have sustained damages and fixed the sum
of ₹ 10 lakhs. The plaintiff was granted a decree for
recovery of the balance ₹ 75 lakhs.
5.
We
have
heard
Sri.G.P.Shinod,
the
learned
counsel for the appellant-plaintiff and Sri.Vinod Bhat,
the learned counsel for the respondent-defendant.
The points that arise for determination are:(i) In the absence of any proof of damages, was the trial court
right in having not granted a decree allowing the plaintiff to recover the
entire advance sale consideration paid?
(ii) Is the plaintiff entitled for interest on the advance sale
consideration and if so at what rate?
6. Law is well settled that even if the plaintiffpurchaser is in breach of the agreement for sale, he is
entitled for return of the advance sale consideration
paid unless, the defendant-vendor proves that he has
sustained
any
damages
consequent
to
the
breach
(See:
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 4 :Ahammedkutty Bran v. Sukumaran [2024 (3) KHC 494] ).
7. It is the case of the defendant that consequent
on
the
non-performance
of
the
agreement
by
the
plaintiff, he has suffered damages. The manner in which
the
defendant
claims
to
have
suffered
damages
is
narrated in paragraph 23 of the written statement. The
same reads thus :“23. There was a coffee hulling mill with one 10 HP motor, one 2 HP motor, and
one 8 HP motor, with all accessories such as a coffee huller, elevator, vibrator
motor shed, husk shed, 3 phase electric connection and buildings in the A
schedule property. The defendant No.1 was eking livelihood by running the mill
in the A schedule property. The functioning of T.V.R. Mill in the A schedule
property, was stopped by the defendants, with the sole intention and expectation
that, the plaintiff would perform his part of the agreement well within time.
Three phase electric connection was also dismantled on the request of the
plaintiff. The claims of workers in the Mill were also not renewed since the
agreement with plaintiff. Over and above all these, the buildings in the A
schedule property also was demolished on the request of the plaintiff. All the
machineries, allied articles were sold at a throw away price. In fact, entire
investment made in the Mill were turned meaning less causing a huge loss to the
defendants. The routine income from the mill was ceased. All the commitments
and various business projects envisaged were all sabotaged. As a result of all
these defendants suffered grave heavy, irretrievable loss and damages. For the
purpose of an average assessment of damages, the defendants limits therein
claim for damages to the tune of advance amount. The plaintiff therefore is not
entitled to claim or get any amount from the defendants.”
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 5 :-
It is the claim of the defendant that, pursuant to the
agreement for sale he stopped functioning of the mill.
The electricity connection was dismantled, the claims of
workers were settled, the licence of the mill was not
renewed, the machineries were sold and the building in
the
property
was
demolished,
claims
the
defendant.
Though the plaintiff does not dispute that there existed
a mill in the property, according to him, it was not
functioning. The subject matter of the agreement for
sale included the building. Therefore, the defendant
could not have demolished the building. Such conduct
would amount to breach of the agreement. The defendant
did not adduce any evidence to show that he had a
licence for the running of the mill and that it was
functioning at the relevant time. There is no evidence
that, if at all the mill was functioning, it was on
profit or its quantum. There is also no evidence adduced
by him to prove the settlement of workmen's dues. There
is no evidence that there were any workman employed.
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 6 :-
There is total lack of evidence on the above claims.
Ext.A2 is the notice issued by the defendant to the
plaintiff
on
21.10.2014.
Therein
there
is
no
claim
regarding any damages. In the absence of any proof
regarding damages, the defendant is not entitled to
appropriate the advance amount or any part of it. Though
the trial court also found that there is no evidence of
any damages, the court awarded damages holding thus:“..... But, when plaintiff is found to be the defaulting party in the contract, it is
injustice on the part of the court to direct the defendants to refund the entire
amount without considering their loss and sufferings. Based on the discussion
made above, it has already found that defendants have suffered some loss. In the
absence of a determined amount, this court is constrained to do a guess work
and fix a reasonable amount as compensation for the said loss.
22. Hence, based on the evaluations made above, ₹ 10,00,000/- (Rupees
Ten lakhs only) is fixed as compensation for the loss sustained.…”.
Evidently the finding of the trial court cannot be
sustained.
There
is
no
basis
upon
which
the
court
arrived at and awarded damages of ₹ 10 lakhs. It is to
be borne in mind that, the property involved is an
immovable property and by passage of time its value is
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 7 :-
on the rise. As noticed above there is no evidence that
the defendant suffered any damages consequent on the
breach. Therefore, the defendant is not entitled to
recover any amount as damages. The plaintiff is entitled
to realise the entire sale consideration of ₹ 85 lakhs.
8. Coming to the claim for interest, the learned
counsel for the respondent-defendant would argue that,
the plaintiff having committed breach of the agreement,
he cannot be permitted to take advantage of his own
fault. He is not entitled for any
interest on the
advance amount, it is argued. The learned counsel also
referred
to
the
judgment
of
the
Apex
Court
in
M/s.Tomorrowland Ltd. v. Housing and Urban Development Corporation Ltd. & another (2025
INSC 207)
of
to contend that, grant of interest is a matter
discretion
and
it
is
to
be
on
the
facts
and
circumstances of each case, applying the principles of
fairness and justice. In the said case before the Apex
Court, the Court noticed the conduct of the plaintiff
which
was
held
to
be
unscrupulous.
The
Apex
Court
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 8 :-
observed:“We have no hesitation in holding that such conduct was nothing short of a
brazen attempt at forum shopping, as the Appellant wanted to avoid the
jurisdiction of the High Court before whom they had failed to prove their bona
fides by not depositing the stipulated sum. Such demeanour not only raises grave
suspicions on the Appellant’s propriety, but also amounts to sheer abuse of the
process of law and a waste of precious judicial time”.
On the circumstances as noticed therein, the claim for
interest on the advance amount was declined. It is not
in dispute that no such allegations could be raised
against the conduct of the plaintiff in the present
case. Admittedly, as on 23.12.2014 the plaintiff had
paid a total amount of ₹ 35 lakhs. He paid a further
amount of ₹ 50 lakhs on 25.07.2015, thus making the
total amount at ₹ 85 lakhs. The defendant as DW1 has
admitted
that
he
has
invested
ventures.
The
defendant
having
the
amount
had
the
in
other
benefit
of
enjoyed/utilised the amount of ₹ 85 lakhs, is bound to
pay reasonable interest upon the same.
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 9 :-
9. Now we consider the question as to from which
date the plaintiff is entitled to interest and the rate.
The suit is filed only on 31.08.2017. Strangely, both
the plaintiff and the defendant have not attempted to
offer any explanation as to what happened in between,
for a period of two years. There has been a long time
gap in claiming the amount. Having not claimed back the
amount, it cannot be held that the defendant withheld
the amount. In the circumstances it is appropriate that
interest be granted only from the date of suit. Taking
note of the entire facts and circumstances and also the
prevailing rate of interest in banking transactions, we
are of the opinion that it would be reasonable to grant
interest at the rate of 6% per annum from date of suit
till recovery.
10. It is reported that, when execution proceedings
followed the trial court decree, an amount of ₹ 75 lakhs
was deposited by the defendant which was withdrawn by
the
plaintiff.
Needless
to
say
that
interest
would
R.F.A. No.8 of 2020
2025:KER:27409
-: 10 :-
accrue on the said amount of ₹ 75 lakhs only up to the
date of deposit.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. The decree and
judgment
of
the
trial
court
are
set
aside.
In
modification of the decree and judgment of the trial
court it is held that the plaintiff is entitled to
realise the entire advance sale consideration of ₹ 85
lakhs with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
date
of
suit
till
recovery.
The
plaintiff-appellant
shall be entitled for proportionate costs throughout.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review