The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. The history of incident noted in Ex.P.5 and in Ex.R.1 is noted in those documents in the usual course of the profession of R.W.1 and thus, the history narrated in Ex.P.5 and R.W.1 presumed to be true, unless it is rebutted. Admittedly, no rebuttable evidence is produced by the claimant. Thus, the contention of claimant in claim petition and his evidence is quite contrary to the documentary evidence produced by him and also produced by the doctor as per Ex.R.1. Under those circumstances, definitely, if the claimant himself had a fall from the tractor without any negligence on the part of the driver of tractor, then the owner and insurer of the tractor cannot be held liable to pay compensation to the injuries sustained by claimant in the said accident. Furthermore, tractor is a vehicle used for tilling and ploughing and except driver; nobody could be - 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:892 MFA No. 21131 of 2013 HC-KAR permitted to sit in the tractor. Under those circumstances also, if the claimant had a fall from tractor then, definitely the insurer cannot be held liable. Considering these aspects, rightly, the Tribunal has dismissed the claim petition. It requires no interference. Accordingly, the points under consideration are answered in ‘negative’ and this Court proceeds to pass the following: i) The appeal filed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is dismissed by confirming…
30. 01.2013 on the file of the learned M.A.C.T.-II, Bagalkot; ii) No order as to costs. Sd/(GEETHA K.B.) SH:Para 1 to 10 SSP:Para 11 to end CT-MCK LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 6
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 23RD DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 21131 OF 2013 (MV)
BETWEEN:
SRI. GYANAPPA BASAPPA KURI,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SANGAPUR VILLAGE,
TQ AND DIST: BAGALKOT.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. M.C. HUKKERI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
BHARATHI
HM
BHARATHI H M
Location:
HIGHCOURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
YELAGONDA BASAPPA BAGEWADI,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: DRIVER CUM
OWNER OF TRACTOR AND TRAILOR NO.
KA.23/T.A.733, 734, 735,
R/O. HALYAL, TQ: ATHANI,
DIST: BELGAUM.
2.
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY,
CO. LTD., MELLIGERI COMPLEX, BAGALKOT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. VITTHAL S. TELI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. N.R. KUPPELLUR, ADVOCATE FOR R2)
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MOTOR
VEHICLE ACT, 1988, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT
AND AWARD PASSED BY THE MEMBER, MACT-II, BAGALKOT IN
M.V.C.NO.336/2011
DATED:
30-01-2013
AND
AWARD
COMPENSATION AS CLAIMED BY THE APPELLANT, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This is the appeal filed under Section 173(1) of Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘M.V. Act’) challenging the
judgment
and
award
dated
30.01.2013
in
MVC
No.336/2011 on the file of MACT-II, Bagalkot (for short,
‘the Tribunal’) dismissing the claim petition filed by the
claimant.
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks as they
were before Tribunal for sake of convenience and clarity.
3.
The case of claimant before Tribunal in nutshell is
that on 08.03.2011 at about 11.30 a.m. claimant along with
his uncle and cousin were waiting in front of Kannada
School of Bevoor at about 11.30 a.m. on 08.03.2011 at
Bagalkot-Sangam PWD road side for going to Corporation
Bank and at that time, the tractor and trailer bearing
Reg.No.KA-23/T.A. 733, 734, 735 came from Bagalkor side
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
with high speed rashly and negligently and only to avoid
road humps i.e., speed breakers, the driver has taken the
tractor at rough road and lost his control and dashed
against the claimant and then the engine of the wheel ran
over the claimant and he sustained grievous injuries.
Immediately, he was shifted to Kumareshwar Hospital,
Bagalkot and then, he took treatment in Manipal Hospital
and spent huge amount for his treatment. It is further
contended that at the time of accident, claimant was 35
years and doing agriculture. After the accident, he is not
able to work as he was working earlier. Hence, claimed
compensation under different heads.
4.
After service of notice, respondent No.1/owner of
the tractor-trailer appeared through his counsel and filed his
objection statement, wherein he has taken contention that
the petition is false, fictitious and contrary to provisions of
law and there was no accident as alleged in the petition. If
claimant able to establish the accident, then the vehicle in
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
question is validly insured with respondent No.2 and hence
he is not liable to pay compensation.
5.
Respondent No.2-Insurer of the vehicle filed its
objection statement, wherein respondent No.2 also has
taken similar contention taken by respondent No.1 denying
the date, place and time of accident and all other averments
of the claim petition except admitting that the vehicle in
question is validly insured with respondent No.2. Hence,
prayed for dismissal of petition.
6.
P.W.1,
On behalf of claimant, claimant was examined as
examined
the
complainant,
who
accompanied
claimant as P.W.2 and examined the doctor of Manipal
Hospital who treated the claimant as P.W.3, got marked
Exs.P.1 to P.11 and closed his side before the Tribunal. On
behalf of respondents, the doctor, who has issued wound
certificate as per Ex.P.5 was examined as R.W.1, got
marked the case sheet of claimant as Ex.R.1 and closed
their side.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
7.
After recording evidence of both sides and
hearing arguments of both sides, the Tribunal came to the
conclusion that the claimant had a fall from the tractor and
sustained injuries and has not proved the involvement of
tractor as alleged in the claim petition and thus dismissed
the claim petition.
8.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and award, the
appellant/claimant is before this Court.
9.
Heard arguments of both sides.
10.
Learned counsel for appellant Sri M.C. Hukkeri
would submit that the charge sheet is filed against the
driver of tractor and complaint is also lodged against the
tractor that when claimant along with his uncle and his
cousin were standing by the side of tar road, only to avoid
speed breakers, the driver of tractor has taken the tractor
to the extreme left side of the road and lost his control over
the tractor and dashed against the claimant which caused
the accident. Immediately on the same day of accident, the
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
complaint is lodged and criminal law was set into motion.
Ultimately, the charge-sheet is filed against driver of the
tractor. Hence, only by relying upon a sentence in wound
certificate that fall from tractor, the Tribunal has dismissed
the
claim
petition,
which
is
erroneous.
Furthermore,
claimant along with the complainant who was present at the
time of accident was examined on behalf of claimant. They
have categorically denied the suggestion that claimant had
a fall from tractor and because of that fall, he sustained
injuries in the accident. Hence, the Tribunal ought not to
have dismissed the claim petition. He would further submit
that, at least the claim petition could have been allowed
against the owner of the vehicle and the direction to insurer
to pay and recover could have been awarded. Hence,
prayed for allowing the appeal and to remand the matter to
the Tribunal to decide the quantum of compensation.
11.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1, Sri Vitthal
S. Teli would submit that respondent No.1 has specifically
denied the accident and rash and negligent driving of driver
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
of the tractor. In the wound certificate and also in the casesheet, it is clearly mentioned that the claimant had a fall
from the tractor and sustained injuries. Hence, rashness
and negligence on the part of driver of the tractor is not
established.
Considering
it
rightly,
the
Tribunal
has
dismissed the claim petition. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
the claim petition.
12.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2/Insurer
Sri.N. R. Kuppellur also submits the above points and
further submits that respondent No.2 has examined the
doctor who has issued wound certificate as per R.W.1 and
he has also submitted the case sheet as per Ex.R.1. In the
case sheet and also in the wound certificate, there is
specific averment about fall from the tractor and this
evidence was given by R.W.1, which is not disputed by the
claimant by cross-examining R.W.1. Considering these
aspects, rightly the Tribunal has dismissed the claim
petition and it requires no interference.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
13.
Having heard the arguments of both sides and
verifying the appeal papers along with Trial Court records,
the points that arise for consideration are as follows:
i)
Whether claimant establishes that he was
pedestrian at the time of accident and
sustained
injury
because
of
rash
and
negligent driving of driver of the tractor
and trailer bearing No.KA-23/TA-733, 734,
735?
ii)
Whether
the
judgment
and
award
of
Tribunal requires interference? and
iii)
14.
What orders?
Findings of this court of the above points are in
‘NEGATIVE’ for the following:
The case of claimant is that on 08.03.2011 at about
11.30 a.m. when he along with his uncle and cousin was
waiting on the side of road in front of Kannada School of
Bevoor Village at Bagalkot-Sangam PWD Road, the tractor
and trailer bearing No.KA-23/TA-733, 734, 735 came with
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
high speed rashly and negligently and only to avoid speed
breakers, the driver of tractor has taken the tractor on
rough road and lost his control over the vehicle and dashed
against the petitioner and because of that, wheel of the
engine of tractor, ran over body of the claimant and caused
the accident.
15.
In
support
of
his
contention,
claimant
has
produced 11 documents. Amongst them, the copy of FIR,
complaint and wound certificate i.e., Exs.P1, P2 and P5 are
important and material documents to decide whether there
was rashness and negligence on the part of driver of the
tractor in causing the accident or whether the claimant was
negligent, and because of his negligence, he had a fall from
the tractor and sustained injuries.
16.
On perusal of Exs.P1 & P2, they reveal that the
complaint was lodged on the date of accident itself at 04.45
p.m. in the hospital i.e., the statement of P.W.2 was
recorded by the I.O. in the hospital and then, he had been
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
to the police station and registered the case at 05.00 p.m.,
and thus, he sets criminal law into motion.
17.
Ex.P.5 is the certified copy of wound certificate
collected by the I.O. from Kumareshwara Hospital, where
the claimant has taken treatment initially and it was
produced
along
with
charge-sheet.
According
to
this
document, the doctor had first seen the claimant-Gyanappa
at 12.55 p.m., on 08.03.2011 for injuries alleged to have
been caused by fall from running tractor at about 11 a.m.,
on 08.03.2011, near Bevoor on the way to Kudalasangama
and he was accompanied by Subhash Mallappa Kuri,
(brother) i.e., P.W.2. The injuries that have been sustained
by claimant are mentioned in Ex.P.5.
18.
The
injuries
sustained
by
claimant
are
not
seriously disputed by respondents. However, their dispute is
that only because of negligence of claimant, he had a fall
from the tractor and sustained injuries and it is not because
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
of the rashness and negligence on the part of the driver of
the tractor.
19.
In this regard, suggestions were put to both
P.W.1 and P.W.2 that P.W.1 had a fall from tractor and he
sustained injuries and said suggestion is denied by both
P.W.1 and P.W.2 in their cross-examination. In this regard,
respondent No.2 has summoned the doctor who issued
wound certificate as per Ex.P.5 and examined him as R.W.1.
In that evidence, R.W.1 has deposed before Court that on
08.03.2011 at 12.55 noon, he examined the claimant at
Kumareshwara Hospital and at that time, claimant had told
that near Bevoor while going in the tractor, he had a fall
and sustained injuries and in this regard, he has issued the
wound certificate as per Ex.P.5 and he has also produced
the case sheet of claimant as per Ex.R.1. In Ex.R.1 at page
No.3, it is clearly mentioned that the patient came to the
hospital with the history of fall from tractor on that day at
11.00 a.m., and he was having history of pain and swelling
over his left side of hip. Thus, the history stated by claimant
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
before doctor at the time of examining the patient and at
the time of admitting the patient to the hospital is that he
has a fall from tractor and not that tractor hit him on the
road.
20.
The history of incident noted in Ex.P.5 and in
Ex.R.1 is noted in those documents in the usual course of
the profession of R.W.1 and thus, the history narrated in
Ex.P.5 and R.W.1 presumed to be true, unless it is rebutted.
Admittedly, no rebuttable evidence is produced by the
claimant. Thus, the contention of claimant in claim petition
and his evidence is quite contrary to the documentary
evidence produced by him and also produced by the doctor
as per Ex.R.1. Under those circumstances, definitely, if the
claimant himself had a fall from the tractor without any
negligence on the part of the driver of tractor, then the
owner and insurer of the tractor cannot be held liable to pay
compensation to the injuries sustained by claimant in the
said accident. Furthermore, tractor is a vehicle used for
tilling and ploughing and except driver; nobody could be
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:892
MFA No. 21131 of 2013
HC-KAR
permitted to sit in the tractor. Under those circumstances
also, if the claimant had a fall from tractor then, definitely
the insurer cannot be held liable. Considering these aspects,
rightly, the Tribunal has dismissed the claim petition. It
requires no interference. Accordingly, the points under
consideration are answered in ‘negative’ and this Court
proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER
i)
The appeal filed under Section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is dismissed
by confirming the judgment and award
passed
in
M.V.C.
No.336/2011
dated
30.01.2013 on the file of the learned
M.A.C.T.-II, Bagalkot;
ii) No order as to costs.
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SH:Para 1 to 10
SSP:Para 11 to end
CT-MCK
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review