Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010306252019
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(The High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh)
PRINCIPAL SEAT
MAC Appeal Nos.285/2020 & 332/2021
I.
MAC App. No.285/2020
Shri Gunajit Nath,
S/o Late Jogendra Nath,
Resident of Galiahati, Srikarmar Path,
Metuakuchi, Berpeta,
PS & Dist.-Barpeta, Assam.
……Appellant.
-Versus1.
Shri Hitesh Das,
S/o Late Harmohan Das,
Resident of Vill-Manaspur, Ward No.10,
Barpeta Road, PO & PS-Barpeta Road,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781315.
2.
Shri Biplab Pratim Das,
S/o Hitesh Das,
Resident of Vill-Manaspur, Ward No.10,
Barpeta Road, PO & PS-Barpeta Road,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781315.
3.
Miss Dristirekha Das,
D/o Hitesh Das,
Resident of Vill-Manaspur, Ward No.10,
Barpeta Road, PO & PS-Barpeta Road,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781315.
4.
Smt. Kanan Bala Ojah,
W/o Late Kanak Ch. Ojah,
Resident of Vill-Manaspur, Ward No.10,
Barpeta Road, PO & PS-Barpeta Road,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781315.
signed by
Deepjyo Digitally
Deepjyoti Sarkar
Date: 2026.01.09
ti Sarkar 16:40:21 +05'30'
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
5.
Abdul Rejjak,
S/o Late Atowar Rahman,
Resident of Vill-Jogirpam, PO-Dabaliapara,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781316.
[Driver of the Dumber 10 wheeler bearing Chasis
No.MAT479182J3N37607, Engine No.81L63749284]
6.
The Branch Manager,
HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Mayur Garden, Ground Floor, Opposite Rajib Bhawan,
ABC, G.S. Road, Guwahati-781005.
[Insurer of the Dumber 10 wheeler bearing Chasis
No.MAT479182J3N37607, Engine No.81L63749284]
……Respondents.
For the Appellant
:
Mr. S. Islam.
……Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. M.H. Ahmed,
Mr. R. Ali,
Mr. R. Goswami.
……Advocates.
II.
MAC App. No.332/2021
HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Having its Registered Office & Head Office at
Ramon House, H.T. Parekh Marg,
169, Backbay Reclamation, Mumbai-400020 and its
Guwahati Branch Office at Adityam Building,
6th Floor, Lachit Nagar, G.S. Road, Guwahati,
Assam, Pin-781007.
……Appellant.
-Versus1.
Shri Hitesh Das,
S/o Late Harmohan Das.
2.
Shri Biplab Pratim Das,
S/o Hitesh Das.
3.
Miss Dristirekha Das,
D/o Hitesh Das.
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
4.
Smt. Kanan Bala Ojah,
W/o Late Kanan Ch. Ojah.
All are residents of Vill-Manaspur, Ward No.10,
Barpeta Road, PO & PS-Barpeta Road,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781315.(CLAIMANTS)
5.
Shri Gunajit Nath,
S/o Late Jogendra Nath,
Resident of Vill-Galiahati, Srikarmar Path,
Metuakuchi, Barpeta, PS-Barpeta,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781314.
[Owner of Dumber bearing Chasis No.MAT479182J3N37607,
Engine No.81L63749284]
6.
Abdul Rejjak
S/o Late Atowar Rahman,
Resident of Vill-Jogirpam, PS-Barpeta,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781316.
[Driver of the Dumber bearing Chasis No.MAT479182J3N37607,
Engine No.81L63749284]
……Respondents.
For the Appellant
:
Mr. R. Goswami.
……Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. M.H. Ahmed,
Mr. R. Ali.
……Advocates.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Date of Hearing
:-
25.11.2025
Date on which judgment is reserved
:-
25.11.2025
Date of pronouncement of judgment :-
09.01.2026
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment?
:-
N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
:-
Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. S. Islam, learned counsel for the appellant in MAC
Appeal No.285/2020 and Mr. M.H. Ahmed, learned counsel for the
respondent No. 1- 4 and Mr. R. Goswami, learned counsel for the
respondent No. 6. None appears for the respondent No.5.
2.
Also heard Mr. R. Goswami, learned counsel for the appellant in
MAC Appeal No.332/2021, Mr. M.H. Ahmed, learned counsel for
the respondent No. 1- 4 and Mr. S. Islam for the respondent No. 5.
None appears for the respondent No. 6.
3. In these appeals, being MAC Appeal No.285/2020, and MAC
Appeal No.332/2021, the judgment and award, dated 23.09.2019,
passed in MAC Case No.46/2019, by the learned Member, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), Barpeta, is being challenged.
4.
It is to be noted here that vide impugned judgment and award
dated 23.09.2019, passed in MAC Case No.46/2019, the learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), Barpeta (Tribunal
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
hereinafter) had allowed the claim petition filed under Section 166
of the M.V. Act, 1988 by one Hitesh Das and three others, and
directed the O.P. No.3- HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd. to
pay an amount of Rs. 26,80,667/- (Rupees Twenty Six Lakhs Eighty
Thousand Six Hundred Sixty Seven) being the just compensation to
the claimants along with interest @ 9% per annum with effect from
the date of filing of the claim petition until its realization subject to
the condition that the O.P. No.3- HDFC ERGO GIC Ltd. shall be at
liberty to recover the entire amount paid to the claimants from the
O.P. No.1 namely, Sri Gunajit Nath.
5.
The parties involved in both these petitions are same. And the
engaged counsel are also the same. The questions involved and the
subject matter of challenge are also the same. Therefore, as agreed
by the learned counsel for both the parties, it is being proposed to
dispose of both the appeals, by this common judgment and order.
The Background Facts:6.
The back grounds facts, leading to filing of the present
appeals, are briefly stated as under:“On 30.01.2019, in the morning, at about 11:00 Α.Μ, Smti.
Gitanjali Das, since deceased, was proceeding towards
Barpeta, from Barpeta Road, along with one Jitendra
Barman in his Maruti car, bearing registration No. AS-15B8686, and when the said car reached Kadamguri one
Dumper (10 wheeler) moving in from the opposite
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
direction (from the side of Barpeta), which was driven in a
rash and negligent manner dashed against the Maruti car
in which the deceased was travelling. Consequently,
Gitanjali Das and the driver cum owner of the Maruti car
sustained serious injuries on their person and they
succumbed to such injuries on the spot.
Thereafter, Shri Hitesh Das and three others had filed
one claim petition under Section 166 of the M.V. Act, 1988
against the owner, driver and insurer of the offending
Tipper/Dumper (10 wheeler) by arraying them as opposite
party Nos. 1, 2 and 3 respectively, seeking compensation
to the tune of Rs. 50,00,000/- (Rupees Fifty Lakhs) along
with interest thereon.
All the opposite parties have entered appearances and
contested the case by filing their respective written
statements.
O.P. Nos.1 & 2 {owner and driver of the offending
Tipper/Dumper (10
wheeler)} in their
joint written
statement, had denied their fault in the alleged accident
and also denied any kind of liability for payment of
compensation to the claimants stating that at the material
point of time the offending Tipper/Dumper (10 wheeler)
apart from having all valid documents had been duly
covered by a valid insurance policy, issued by the O.P.
No.3- HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd. vide
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
insurance
policy
No.
2315202652724500000,
having
validity up to the mid-night of 28.01.2020 and that the
driver (O.P. No.2) of the same also possessed a valid
driving licence, being D/L No. AS1519920008084, issued by
the DTO, Barpeta having validity up to 04.05.2020,
covering the date of accident i.e. 30.01.2019.
The O.P. No. 3 i.e. HDFC ERGO General Insurance
Co. Ltd. in its written statement has also denied any kind
of liability of payment of compensation to the claimants by
taking all the pleas of defence. The O.P. No.3 although
stated that its liability would be governed by the provisions
of Sections 147 and 149 (2) of the M.V. Act, and that the
policy issued by it did not cover the offending vehicle on
the day of accident and thereby contested the case with all
the defence available to it u/s 169 (2) of the M.V. Act,
1988.
Upon pleadings of the parties, the learned Tribunal
had framed following issues:(i)
Whether the alleged motor vehicular
accident had taken place on 30-01-2019
at about 10.50 a.m.at Kadamguri under
Howly P.S. in the district of Barpeta,
Assam due to rash and negligent manner
of driving on the part of the driver of
the motor vehicle bearing Chassis No.
MAT479182 J3N 37607, Engine No.81L
63749284(Dumper 10 wheeler) and in
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
consequence of that Geetanjali Das had
died ?
(ii) Whether the motor vehicle bearing Chassis
No. MAT479182 J3N 37607, Engine No.81L
63749284 (Dumper 10 wheeler) was duly
insured with the O.P. No.3 i.e. HDFC, ERGO
General Insurance Company Ltd. under valid
insurance policy at the relevant time of
accident?
(iii)Whether the claimant is entitled to get
compensation, if so, to what extent and by
whom payable?
(iv) To what other relief/reliefs the claimant
is entitled to in law and equity?
Thereafter, hearing the arguments advanced by the
engaged counsels for both the sides and also considering
the materials available on record, the learned Tribunal had
decided all the issues in affirmative in favour of the
claimants and directed the O.P. No.3- HDFC ERGO General
Insurance Co. Ltd. to pay an amount of Rs. 26,80,667/(Rupees Twenty Six Lakhs Eighty Thousand Six Hundred
Sixty Seven) being the just compensation to the claimants
along with interest @ 9% per annum with effect from the
date of filing of the claim petition until its realization
subject to the condition that the O.P. No.3- HDFC ERGO
GIC Ltd. shall be at liberty to recover the entire amount
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
paid to the claimants from the O.P. No.1 namely, Sri
Gunajit Nath.”
7.
Then being aggrieved, Shri Gunajit Nath, the owner of the
Dumper, has preferred the MAC Appeal No.285/2020, challenging
the impugned judgment and award on the following grounds:(i) The learned Tribunal had discussed about the insurance
policy that the vehicle has the valid insurance policy,
but the learned Tribunal had misinterpreted that the
vehicle does not have the road permit, therefore the
impugned Judgment dated 23/09/2019, passed by the
learned Tribunal thereby directing the insurance
company to make payment to the claimants and
liberty shall be granted to the insurance company to
recover the money from the appellant/owner of the
dumper is bad in law.
(ii)
The learned Tribunal did not consider the fact that the
vehicle was newly purchased vehicle which was
purchased on 29/01/2019 and on the very next day
while the vehicle was proceeded towards the Garage
for fitting the accessories at that time the incident was
happened, moreover the vehicle was empty vehicle.
The learned Tribunal did not appreciate the fact that
after applying for the permit, the authority concerned
issued permit to the new vehicle and it takes time.
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
(iii)
The learned Tribunal misconstrued the fact that the
vehicle in question only have insurance policy and the
vehicle did not possess the permit. For ascertaining
the liability insurance policy is the main document, but
without considering the same, the learned Member
has passed impugned Judgment dated 23/09/2019.
(iv) The learned Tribunal, by misinterpreting the provisions
of law has passed the impugned Judgment and award
dated 23/09/2019, thereby directing the insurance
company to pay awarded amount and recover it from
the appellant/owner of the vehicle.
(v)
In the impugned Judgment dated 23/09/2019, the
learned Tribunal has not considered the fact that the
appellant has valid insurance policy, but without
considering the same has passed impugned judgment
dated 23/09/2019, therefore the same is liable to be
modified to the extent that the awarded amount shall
be paid by insurance company and it should not be
recovered from the appellant.
(vi) The impugned Judgment is not based on the evidence
on record and the findings given by the learned
Tribunal
are
perverse. As such,
the
impugned
judgment is absolutely illegal and without jurisdiction.
Hence, the same is liable to be modified to the extent
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
that the appellant is not liable to pay the awarded
amount.
(viii) The learned Tribunal has misconceived, misunderstood
and misconstrued the relevant provisions of law while
giving direction to pay the awarded amount.
8.
And being aggrieved by the impugned judgment the opposite
party No. 3, i.e. HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd. has
preferred MAC Appeal No.332/2021 on the following grounds:(i)
The learned Tribunal ought to have appreciated the
fact that in the absence of any reliable evidence to
prove the income of the deceased, who was
admittedly a housewife, the income ought not to have
been presumed to be Rs. 16,638.89/- per month.
(iii) The learned Tribunal ought to have given due
weightage to the deposition made by CW1 as per
which the deceased was a housewife and as such she
can be considered as a non earning person. As such
presumption of the income of the deceased as
Rs.16,638.89/- per month who was a house wife is
extremely on higher side and without any basis.
(iv) The learned Tribunal ought to have appreciated the
fact that claimants had failed to prove the income of
the deceased in its proper perspective. The claimants
did not adduce any convincing evidence to prove the
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
income of the deceased. In absence of any reliable
document, to prove the income of the deceased, the
learned Tribunal ought not to have considered the
income of the deceased as Rs. 16,638.89/- per month
on the basis that it happens to be one third of the
income of the husband,
(v) The learned Tribunal ought to have considered the fact
that award of Rs.30,000/- under the head of filial
consortium to the children has no basis after the
recent Apex Court Judgment in National Insurance Co.
Ltd vs. Pranay Sethi.
(vi) The learned Tribunal ought to have considered the fact
that the award of interest at the rate of 9% is also on
higher side as compared to the prevailing trend.
Submissions:9. Mr. Islam, learned counsel for the appellant, in MAC Appeal No.
285 of 2020, submits that the ground for challenge of the impugned
judgment and award is allowing the Insurance Company to recover
the awarded amount from the appellant after payment being made
by it. Mr. Islam submits that the vehicle was a new vehicle
purchased on the day before the accident and that it is fact that on
that day the vehicle had no road permit, but it was taken to the
workshop on that day for fitting of some accessories. In support of
such contention, Mr. Islam has also produced one certificate, dated
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
15.02.2019, issued by the In-Charge of Abdul Awal Motors Garage.
He also submits that absence of permit is a minor and
inconsequential breach not direct cause of accident and therefore, it
would not constitute sufficient ground to deny the benefit of
coverage of insurance to the appellant as on the relevant date the
vehicle has valid insurance policy.
9.1. In support of his submission, Mr. Islam has referred to a
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, reported in (2004) 3
SCC 297.
10. Mr. Goswami, the learned counsel for the appellant in MAC
Appeal No. 332 of 2021, submits that the grounds for challenge of
impugned judgment and award dated 23/09/2019 are:(i)
The rate of interest so awarded by the learned Tribunal is
in higher side;
(ii)
The learned Tribunal has failed to consider that no salary
certificate of the deceased was exhibited and proved;
(iii)
The pay and recovery principle is not applicable as the
offending vehicle concerned was driven without permit;
(iv)
The liability is clearly upon the owner of the vehicle.
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
10.1.
Under the aforesaid fact and circumstances, Mr. Goswami
has contended to allow the appeal by interfering the impugned
judgment and award.
10.2.
In support of his submission, Mr. Goswami has referred
following decisions:
(i)
Amrit Paul Singh vs. TATA AIG General Insurance
Co. Ltd., reported in (2018) 7 SCC 558;
(ii) National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Challa Upendra
Rao, reported in (2004) 8 SCC 517
11.
Per Contra, Mr. M.H. Ahmed, learned counsel for the
respondent No. 1-4, has supported the impugned judgment and
award. According to him the impugned judgment and award suffers
from no infirmity or illegality and as such it requires no interference
of this Court. Therefore, Mr. Ahmed has contended to uphold the
same.
11.1.
Mr. Ahmed also submits that the respondent No. 1-4 have
filed an affidavit bringing on record the salary drawal statement of
the respondent No.1 from 01.03.2018 to 28.02.2019 and also a
copy of Form 16 as Annexure-1 and 2. And Mr. Ahmed also submits
that in the month of January, 2019 the gross salary of the
respondent No.1 was Rs.52,466/ and net salary was 50,058/ and as
per Annexure 2 he paid a sum of Rs. 10,281/ as income tax and
showing his total salary for the financial year 2018-19 at Rs.
6,19,077/. Mr. Ahmed also submits that as such, the learned
Tribunal had not committed any mistake while assessing the
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
monthly income of the deceased at Rs. 16,638.89 per month, which
is 1/3rd of Rs.51,000/, the monthly income of the respondent No.1.
12.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the
parties, this Court has carefully gone through the memo of appeals
and the grounds mentioned therein and also gone through the
decisions referred by learned counsel for both the appellants and
also gone through the scanned copy of the record.
13.
The basic facts in these appeals are not in dispute. The
Accident Information Report i.e. Form No. 54 (Ext.1), the certified
copies of F.I.R. dated 30.01.2019 (Ext.2), the Post Mortem Report
of the deceased Gitanjali Das (Ext.3) including inquest report,
extract copy of Howly P.S. GDE No. 896 dated 30.01.2019, sketch
map, charge sheet No. 51/19 dated 31.03.2019, seizure lists,
reports of M.V.I. etc. goes a long way to establish that the accident
had taken place on 30.01.2019, at about 11:00 A.M., at Kadamguri
on the Howly - Barpeta PWD Road, under Howly P.S. in the district
of Barpeta, Assam with the involvement of two motor vehicles
bearing registration No. AS-15B-8686 (Maruti car) and Dumper (10
wheeler) bearing Chasis No. MAT479182J3N37607 and Engine No.
81L63749284 wherein Gitanjali Das, claimants' wife/ mother/
daughter and the driver cum owner of the Maruti car, namely,
Jitendra Barman died on the spot. In connection with the said
accident Howly P.S., as Howly P.S. Case No. 48/19, u/s
279/304(A)/427 IPC was registered and after investigation charge
sheet has been submitted against the driver of the Dumper. The
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
accident took place due to rash and negligent driving on the part of
the driver of the Dumper.
14. The learned Tribunal, while assessing the just compensation,
had assessed the income of the deceased Gitanjali Das at
Rs.16,638.89/- being 1/3rd of income of her husband whose
monthly income was Rs.49,916.67/- as per the ratio of the aforesaid
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Arun Agarwal
–vs.- HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co.; reported in AIR
2010 SC 3426, specially in para 35. Notably, husband of the
deceased i.e. claimant No.1 is a Government Servant (Sub Engineer
in the PWD Drilling Division, Barpeta) whose monthly salary was Rs.
51,000/- at the relevant time as deposed by him. However, no proof
in that regard has been produced, but the learned Tribunal had
placed reliance upon the same.
14.1.
Thereafter, the learned Tribunal had assessed the just
compensation as under:Pecuniary damages (Special damages):Computation of multiplicand: (i)
Monthly
income
of
deceased
(notional)
=
₹16,638.89/(ii) Compensation after multiplier of 13 is applied
to the above multiplicand (16,638.89/- X 12 X
13) = ₹ 25,95,666.84/- ~ 25,95,667/-
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
Non pecuniary damages(general damages) :(iii) For loss of filial consortium for the husband
(claimant No.1) = ₹ 40,000/(iv) For loss of filial consortium (for son and
daughter)
[@15,000/- x 2]
(v) Loss of Estate
= ₹ 30,000/-
= Nil.
(vi) Funeral expenses including other incidental
expenses= ₹ 15,000/-
TOTAL
15.
= ₹ 26,80,667/-
First, let the issue of income of the deceased be decided.
From the evidence brought on record it appears that though the
claimants have asserted that the deceased worked as a tailor in
Sambhu Ladies Tailoring at Barpeta Road, wherefrom, she used to
earn an amount of 15,000/- p.m. and also earned an amount of
Rs.5,000/- (approx.) from animal husbandry, at the time of her
death, yet no proof in support of such contention was made
available. No documentary evidence could be produced before the
learned Tribunal. Rather, CW-1, during his cross-examination had
admitted that his deceased wife was a homemaker.
16.
But, it appears that the learned Tribunal, had assessed the
income of the deceased, being 1/3rd of the income of her husband.
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
Notably, the husband of the deceased, i.e. the claimant No.1 was
serving as a Government Servant (Sub Engineer in the PWD Drilling
Division, Barpeta) whose monthly salary was Rs. 51,000/- at the
relevant time.
17.
And taking note of the income of the husband of the
deceased, i.e. the claimant No.1, and also the ratio laid down in the
case of Arun Agarwal –vs.- HDFC ERGO General Insurance
Co.'(SIC), in fact it is Arun Kumar Agrawal v. National
Insurance Co. Ltd., reported in (2010) 9 SCC 218:) the
learned Tribunal had taken 1/3rd income of the husband of the
deceased as her income.
18.
Notably, in the case of Arun Kumar Agrawal (supra),
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:‚35. In our view, it is highly unfair, unjust
and inappropriate to compute the compensation
payable to the dependants of a deceased
wife/mother, who does not have a regular
income, by comparing her services with that of
a housekeeper or a servant or an employee, who
works for a fixed period. The gratuitous
services rendered by the wife/mother to the
husband and children cannot be equated with the
services of an employee and no evidence or data
can possibly be produced for estimating the
value of such services. It is virtually
impossible to measure in terms of money the
loss of personal care and attention suffered by
the husband and children on the demise of the
housewife. In its wisdom, the legislature had,
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
as early as in 1994, fixed the notional income
of a non-earning person at Rs. 15,000 per annum
and in case of a spouse, 1/3rd income of the
earning/surviving spouse for the purpose of
computing the compensation.‛
19. It is also to be noted here that in the case of Rajendra Singh
vs. National Insurance Company Ltd., reported in (2020)
7 SCC 256, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:‘9. The first deceased was a housewife aged
about 30 years. In Lata Wadhwa vs. State of
Bihar [Lata Wadhwa v. State of Bihar, (2001) 8
SCC 197], this Court had observed that
considering the multifarious services rendered
by housewives, even on a modest estimation, the
income of a housewife between the age group of
34 to 59 years who were active in life should
be assessed at Rs 36,000 p.a. A distinction was
also drawn with regard to elderly ladies in the
age group of 62 to 72 who would be more adept
in discharge of housewife duties by age and
experience, and the value of services rendered
by them has been taken at Rs 20,000 p.a.
10.
In Arun Kumar Agrawal vs. National
Insurance
Co.
Ltd.
[Arun
Kumar
Agrawal v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2010)
9 SCC 218: (2010) 3 SCC (Civ) 664: (2010) 3 SCC
(Cri) 1313], the Tribunal assessed the notional
income of the housewife at Rs 5000 per month,
but
without
any
rationale
or
reasoning
concluded that she was a non-earning member and
reduced the same to Rs 2500, which was affirmed
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
[Arun Kumar Agrawal v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd., FAFO No. 2408 of 2003, order dated 30-42004 (All)] by the High Court. Disapproving the
same and restoring the assessed income, this
Court observed at paras 26 and 27 as follows:
(SCC pp. 237-38)
‚26. In India the courts have recognised
that the contribution made by the wife to
the house is invaluable and cannot be
computed in terms of money. The gratuitous
services rendered by the wife with true
love and affection to the children and her
husband and managing the household affairs
cannot be equated with the services
rendered by others. A wife/mother does not
work by the clock. She is in the constant
attendance of the family throughout the
day and night unless she is employed and
is required to attend the employer's work
for particular hours. She takes care of
all the requirements of the husband and
children
including
cooking
of
food,
washing of clothes, etc. She teaches small
children and provides invaluable guidance
to them for
their future life. A
housekeeper or maidservant can do the
household work, such as cooking food,
washing clothes and utensils, keeping the
house clean, etc., but she can never be a
substitute for a wife/mother who renders
selfless service to her husband and
children.
27. It is not possible to quantify any
amount in lieu of the services rendered by
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
the wife/mother to the family i.e. the
husband and children. However, for the
purpose of award of compensation to the
dependants, some pecuniary estimate has to
be
made
of
the
services
of
the
housewife/mother. In that context, the
term ‚services‛ is required to be given a
broad meaning and must be construed by
taking into account the loss of personal
care and attention given by the deceased
to her children as a mother and to her
husband as a wife. They are entitled to
adequate compensation in lieu of the loss
of gratuitous services rendered by the
deceased. The amount payable to the
dependants cannot be diminished on the
ground that some close relation like a
grandmother may volunteer to render some
of the services to the family which the
deceased was giving earlier.‛
11. The notional income of the first deceased
is therefore held to be Rs 5000 per month at
the time of death. The compensation on that
basis with a deduction of 1/4th i.e. Rs 15,000
towards personal expenses with a multiplier of
17 is assessed at Rs 7,65,000. If the deceased
had survived, in view of observations in
Lata
Wadhwa [Lata Wadhwa v. State of Bihar, (2001)
8 SCC 197], her skills as a matured and skilled
housewife in contributing to the welfare and
care of the family and in the upbringing of the
children would have only been enhanced by time
and for which reason we hold that the
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
appellants
shall
be
entitled
to
future
prospects @ 40% in addition to the loss of
consortium and future expenses already granted.
We therefore assess the total compensation
payable to the appellants in the first appeal
at Rs 11,96,000.’ (emphasis supplied)
20.
The proposition so laid down in the case of Rajendra Singh
(supra), was endorsed very recently by another Bench of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Sunita & Ors. vs. Vinod Singh
& Ors., Civil Appeal No. of 2025 [@ Special Leave
Petition
(Civil)
No. 1114
of
(2025
INSC
366),
wherein it has been held as under:‚14. We express our respectful agreement with
Rajendra Singh (supra) and, accordingly, assess
loss of future prospects at 25%, bearing in
mind the dicta in Pranay Sethi (supra). In
undertaking the exercise of computation of
compensation, we have verily reminded ourselves
that
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is a
beneficial and welfare legislation and it is
our duty to award ‘just compensation’ [refer
Ningamma v United India Insurance Company
Limited, (2009) 13 SCC 710]‛
21.
But, it has to be noted here that in order to take 1/3rd income
of the husband of the deceased, the husband, who is the claimant
No.1, had not adduced any convincing evidence, either documentary
or oral. Only during preliminary examination by the learned
Tribunal, however, he stated that his monthly income is Rs. 51,000/
and that he is working as Sub-Engineer in the PDW, Drilling Division.
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
But, under what provision the said preliminary statement was
recorded is not discernible from the record of the learned Tribunal.
21.1. However, as stated herein above, the respondent No. 1-4 in
MAC Appeal No. 332/2021, have filed an affidavit bringing on record
the salary drawal statement of the respondent No.1 from
01.03.2018 to 28.02.2019 and also a copy of Form 16 as Annexure1 and 2. Perusal of the Annexure-1 and 2 reveals that in the month
of January, 2019 the gross salary of the respondent No.1 was
Rs.52,466/ and net salary was Rs. 50,058/ and as per Annexure 2,
he paid a sum of Rs. 10,281/ as income tax and showing his total
salary for the financial year 2018-19 at Rs. 6,19,077/. Thus, it
appears that the learned Tribunal had not committed any mistake
while assessing the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.
16,638.89 per month, which is 1/3rd of Rs.51,000/, the monthly
income of the respondent No.1. Mr. Ahmed, the learned counsel for
the respondent No.1-4 in MAC Appeal No. 332/2021, had rightly
pointed this out during his argument, and the same is not
controverted by Mr. Goswami and also by Mr. Islam, learned counsel
for the appellants in both the appeals.
22.
Under the given factual scenario the submission of Mr.
Goswami, the learned counsel for the appellant in MAC Appeal No.
332 of 2021 cannot be acceded to.
23.
Accordingly, the income of the deceased at the time of
accident has to be assessed at Rs. 16,638.89, (rounded off @
Rs.16,640/ per month). Thus, having assessed her monthly income
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
at Rs. 16,640/, per month, now an endeavor will be made to
determine just compensation, which the claimants/respondents are
entitled to.
24.
As per PAN Card, the date of birth of the deceased was
01.01.1974, and on the date of accident, her age was 45 years 29
days. The multiplier to be applicable in the present case is for the
age group of 41 – 45 years which is 14 as per the decisions of
Sarla
Verma
(Smt)
and
Others
v.
Delhi
Transport
Corporation and Another, reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121
and
Shashikala
and
Others
vs.
Gangalakshmamma
and
Another, reported in (2015) 9 SCC 150.
24.1.
Notably, in the case of Shashikala (Supra), Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held as under:‚16. Insofar as appropriate multiplier, the
date of birth of the deceased as per driving
licence was 16-6-1961. On the date of accident
i.e. 14-12-2006, the deceased was aged 45 years
5 months and 28 days and the Tribunal has taken
the age as 46 years. Since the deceased has
completed only 45 years, the High Court has
rightly taken the age of the deceased as 45
years and adopted multiplier of 14 which is the
appropriate
multiplier
and
the
same
is
maintained.
Total
loss
of
dependency
is
calculated at Rs 16,82,310 (Rs 1,20,165 × 14).‛
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
24.2. So in view of the aforementioned decision, this Court is of
the view that the applicable multiplier in the instant case would be
14 instead of 13 so applied by the learned Tribunal.
24.3.
Thus, having accepted the income of the deceased at Rs.
16,640/ per month, 25% of the same has to be added as future
prospect, as at the time of accident, the deceased was between 4050 years, and in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay
Sethi, reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680. After addition of 25% to
Rs. 16,640/ per month, the amount would be Rs. 12,500/
(Rs.16,640/+Rs.4160/ =Rs.20,800/).
25. Thereafter, in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Sarla Verma (Supra),¼th of the aforesaid amount
has to be deducted as personal expenses since he left behind four
dependants at the time of accident. Though the learned Tribunal
had rejected the claim of claimant/respondent No.4 (mother of the
deceased), yet, the evidence of CW-2, namely, Brajen Ojah testified
that his mother used to live equally in the house of her siblings.
Therefore, the ground assigned by the learned Tribunal appears to
be not justified.
After deducting ¼th of the above, the amount
would be Rs.15,600/-[Rs.20,800/– Rs.5,200/)= Rs.15,600].
After application of multiplier, the amount would be Rs.26,20,800/
(Rs.15,600/ x 12 x 14 = Rs.26,20,800/).
26. Besides, under the conventional heads, a sum of Rs.
40,000/ each, with 10% increase in every three years has to be
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
awarded under
the head - consortium, and a sum of Rs.
15,000/- under head - funeral expenses, and the aforesaid
amounts should be enhanced by 10% in every 3 years, and a sum
of Rs. 15,000/- under head - loss of estate, and the aforesaid
amounts should be enhanced by 10% in every 3 years in view of the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Pranay Sethi
(supra). It is to be noted here that after the accident almost 6
years elapsed. That being so, the aforesaid amounts, have to be
enhanced twice.
27. The whole calculation, after application of the principle laid
down in the case of Sarla Verma (Supra) and also in the case of
Pranay Sethi (Supra), would be as under:-
Sl.
No.
Heads
I
Monthly income Rs. 16,640/ -
II
25% of (i) to be added as future Rs.20,800/prospect=(Rs.16,640/+Rs.4160/)
=Rs.20,800/
III
1/4th of the (ii) deducted as Rs.15,600/
personal
expenses
of
the
deceased Rs.20,800/–Rs.5,200/)=
Rs.15,600
IV
Compensation after multiplier of Rs.26,20,800
14 is applied (Rs.15,600/ x 12 x
14) = Rs.26,20,800
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
Calculation
Sl.
No.
Heads
V
Loss of Estate Rs.15,000/- which Rs.15,000/-+
has to be increased by 10% in Rs.3000/-=
every three years (15,000 x Rs.18,000/10/100) = 1500 x 2 = Rs.3,000/-
VI
Loss of Consortium =Rs.40,000/-,
which has to be increased by 10%
in each three years 40,000 x
10/100 = 4000 x 2 = 8,000.
(Rs.40,000 + 8,000 = Rs.48,000/-
VII
Calculation
Rs.40,000/-+
Rs.8,000/-=
Rs.48,000/x4
=Rs.192,000-
Funeral
expenses
Rs.15,000/-, Rs.15,000/-+
which has to be increased by 10% Rs.3,000/-=
in each three years 15,000 x Rs.18,000/10/100 = 1500 x 2 =Rs.3000/-
Total compensation awarded
= Rs.28,48,800/
28. Now, moving forward to the last point, i.e. who will pay the
aforesaid amount of compensation, it appears from the record that
at the relevant time, the vehicle was insured with the appellant
Insurance Company in MAC Appeal No. 332/2021, i.e. HDFC ERGO
General Insurance Co. Ltd. vide policy No. 2315202652724500000
(Ext.-A) having validity w.e.f. 18.31 hrs., of 29.01.2019 up to the
mid-night of 28.01.2020. And as such, it is the responsibility of the
appellant Insurance Company in MAC Appeal No. 332/2021, i.e.
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd. to pay the same. And the
learned Tribunal had rightly fastened the liability upon it.
28.1.
However, Mr. Goswami, the learned counsel for the
appellant Insurance Company, has pointed out that the vehicle had
no valid permit on the day of accident and since the vehicle was
driven without permit, Mr. Goswami submits that the Insurance
Company is not liable to indemnify the owner of the vehicle. Under
such background Mr. Goswami has contended to allow the appeal
filed by the Insurance Company.
28.2.
But, Mr. Islam, the learned counsel for the appellant in MAC
Appeal No. 285/2020, submits that the vehicle being a new one,
was being taken to garage for fitting of accessories and the same is
permissible. But, the submission of Mr. Islam left this Court
unimpressed in as much as much as in the case of Challa Upendra
Rao (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:‚12. The High Court was of the view that
since there was no permit, the question of
violation of any condition thereof does not
arise. The view is clearly fallacious. A
person without permit to ply a vehicle cannot
be placed on a better pedestal vis a-vis one
who has a permit, but has violated any
condition thereof. Plying of a vehicle
without a permit is an infraction. Therefore,
in terms of Section 149(2) defence is
available to the insurer on that aspect. The
acceptability of the stand is a matter of
adjudication. The question of policy being
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
operative had no relevance for the issue
regarding liability of the insurer. The High
Court was, therefore, not justified in
holding the insurer liable.‛
28.3.
Again in the case of Amrit Paul Singh (supra), Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held as under:‚24. In the case at hand, it is clearly
demonstrable from the materials brought on
record that the vehicle at the time of the
accident did not have a permit. The appellants
had taken the stand that the vehicle was not
involved in the accident. That apart, they had
not stated whether the vehicle had temporary
permit or any other kind of permit. The
exceptions that have been carved out under
Section 66 of the Act, needless to emphasise,
are to be pleaded and proved. The exceptions
cannot be taken aid of in the course of an
argument to seek absolution from liability. Use
of a vehicle in a public place without a permit
is a fundamental statutory infraction. We are
disposed to think so in view of the series of
exceptions carved out in Section 66. The said
situations cannot be equated with absence of
licence or a fake licence or a licence for
different kind of vehicle, or, for that matter,
violation of a condition of carrying more
number of passengers. Therefore, the principles
laid down in Swaran Singh [National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, (2004) 3 SCC 297 :
2004 SCC (Cri) 733] and Lakhmi Chand [Lakhmi
Chand v. Reliance General Insurance, (2016) 3
SCC 100 : (2016) 2 SCC (Civ) 45] in that regard
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
would not be applicable to the case at hand.
That apart, the insurer had taken the plea that
the vehicle in question had no permit. It does
not require the wisdom of the ‚Tripitaka‛, that
the existence of a permit of any nature is a
matter of documentary evidence. Nothing has
been brought on record by the insured to prove
that he had a permit of the vehicle. In such a
situation, the onus cannot be cast on the
insurer. Therefore, the Tribunal as well as the
High Court had directed that the insurer was
required to pay the compensation amount to the
claimants with interest with the stipulation
that the insurer shall be entitled to recover
the same from the owner and the driver. The
said directions are in consonance with the
principles stated in Swaran Singh [National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, (2004) 3
SCC 297 : 2004 SCC (Cri) 733] and other cases
pertaining to pay and recover principle.‛
28.4.
Further in the case of Swaran Singh (supra), Hon’ble
Supreme Court has recorded the summary of finding as under:‚110. The
summary
of
our
findings
to
the
various
issues as raised in these petitions is as follows:
(i)
Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
providing compulsory insurance of vehicles
against third-party risks is a social welfare
legislation to extend relief by compensation
to victims of accidents caused by use of motor
vehicles.
The
provisions
of
compulsory
insurance coverage of all vehicles are with
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
this paramount object and the provisions of
the Act have to be so interpreted as to
effectuate the said object.
(ii)
An insurer is entitled to raise a defence in a
claim petition filed under Section 163-A or
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
inter alia, in terms of Section 149(2)(a)(ii)
of the said Act.
(iii)
The
breach
of
policy
condition
e.g.
disqualification of the driver or invalid
driving licence of the driver, as contained in
sub-section (2)(a)(ii) of Section 149, has to
be proved to have been committed by the
insured for avoiding liability by the insurer.
Mere absence, fake or invalid driving licence
or disqualification of the driver for driving
at the relevant time, are not in themselves
defences available to the insurer against
either the insured or the third parties. To
avoid its liability towards the insured, the
insurer has to prove that the insured was
guilty of negligence and failed to exercise
reasonable care in the matter of fulfilling
the condition of the policy regarding use of
vehicles by a duly licensed driver or one who
was not disqualified to drive at the relevant
time.
(iv)
Insurance companies, however, with a view to
avoid their liability must not only establish
the available defence(s) raised in the said
proceedings but must also establish ‚breach‛
on the part of the owner of the vehicle; the
burden of proof where for would be on them.
(v)
The court cannot lay down any criteria as to
how the said burden would be discharged,
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
inasmuch as the same would depend upon the
facts and circumstances of each case.
(vi)
Even where the insurer is able to prove breach
on the part of the insured concerning the
policy condition regarding holding of a valid
licence by the driver or his qualification to
drive during the relevant period, the insurer
would not be allowed to avoid its liability
towards the insured unless the said breach or
breaches on the condition of driving licence
is/are so fundamental as are found to have
contributed to the cause of the accident. The
Tribunals
in
interpreting
the
policy
conditions would apply ‚the rule of main
purpose‛ and the concept of ‚fundamental
breach‛ to allow defences available to the
insurer under Section 149(2) of the Act.
(vii) The question, as to whether the owner has
taken reasonable care to find out as to
whether the driving licence produced by the
driver (a fake one or otherwise), does not
fulfil the requirements of law or not will
have to be determined in each case.
(viii) If a vehicle at the time of accident was
driven by a person having a learner's licence,
the insurance companies would be liable to
satisfy the decree.
(ix) The Claims Tribunal constituted under Section
165 read with Section 168 is empowered to
adjudicate all claims in respect of the
accidents involving death or of bodily injury
or damage to property of third party arising
in use of motor vehicle. The said power of the
Tribunal is not restricted to decide the
claims inter se between claimant or claimants
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
on one side and insured, insurer and driver on
the other. In the course of adjudicating the
claim for compensation and to decide the
availability of defence or defences to the
insurer, the Tribunal has necessarily the
power and jurisdiction to decide disputes
inter se between the insurer and the insured.
The decision rendered on the claims and
disputes inter se between the insurer and
insured in the course of adjudication of claim
for compensation by the claimants and the
award
made
thereon
is
enforceable
and
executable in the same manner as provided in
Section 174 of the Act for enforcement and
execution of the award in favour of the
claimants.
(x)
Where on adjudication of the claim under the
Act the Tribunal arrives at a conclusion that
the insurer has satisfactorily proved its
defence in accordance with the provisions of
Section 149(2) read with sub-section (7), as
interpreted by this Court above, the Tribunal
can direct that the insurer is liable to be
reimbursed by the insured for the compensation
and other amounts which it has been compelled
to pay to the third party under the award of
the Tribunal. Such determination of claim by
the Tribunal will be enforceable and the money
found due to the insurer from the insured will
be recoverable on a certificate issued by the
Tribunal to the Collector in the same manner
under Section 174 of the Act as arrears of
land revenue. The certificate will be issued
for the recovery as arrears of land revenue
only if, as required by sub-section (3) of
Section 168 of the Act the insured fails to
deposit the amount awarded in favour of the
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
insurer within thirty days from the date of
announcement of the award by the Tribunal.
(xi) The provisions contained in sub-section (4)
with the proviso there under and sub-section
(5) which are intended to cover specified
contingencies mentioned therein to enable the
insurer to recover the amount paid under the
contract of insurance on behalf of the insured
can be taken recourse to by the Tribunal and
be extended to claims and defences of the
insurer against the insured by relegating them
to the remedy before regular court in cases
where on given facts and circumstances
adjudication of their claims inter se might
delay the adjudication of the claims of the
victims.
28.5.
Thus, in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Amrit Paul Singh (supra) and of Swaran Singh
(supra), this Court is of the view that the learned Tribunal had not
committed any illegality in directing the Insurance Company to pay
the amount first, and thereafter, to recover the same from the
owner of the vehicle. This Court has considered the submission of
Mr. Islam, learned counsel for the appellant in MAC Appeal No.
285/2020, but in view of aforesaid discussion and finding, the
same fails to mandate an acceptance of this Court.
29.
It also appears that the learned Tribunal has directed to pay
interest @ 9%, from the date of filing of the claim petition till
payment of the amount. Though Mr. Goswami, learned counsel for
the Insurance Company has submitted that the rate of interest so
awarded is in higher side yet such submission left this Court
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
unimpressed in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of
Municipal
Corporation
of
Delhi
Vs.
Upahar
Tragedy Victims Association and Ors, reported in (2011)
14 SCC 481 and also in Kalpanaraj vs. Tamil Nadu State
Transport Corporation; reported in (2014) Acci.C.R.693
(S.C.),where it is provided that the amount shall carry interest @
9%, till realization of the amount. Hence, this Court is inclined to
award interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing the claim
petition i.e. 02.04.2019.
30. In the result, this Court finds no merit in these appeals and
accordingly, the same stands dismissed. However, the quantum of
compensation, which, the claimant is entitled to, is modified to the
extent as indicated above. The appellant is directed to pay a sum of
Rs. 28,48,800/- (Rupees twenty eight lakhs forty eight
thousand eight hundred only) to the respondent No.1-4 in MAC
Appeal No. 332/2021, within 30 days from today, adjusting the
amount, if any, already paid.
31. It also appears that the learned Tribunal had further directed
that out of the total amount of compensation, an amount of
Rs.6,00,000/- (Rupees Six Lakhs) each shall remain invested in the
fixed deposits in favour of the claimants i.e. claimant Nos. 1, 2 & 3
(husband, son and daughter of the deceased). The said fixed
deposits shall be made initially for a period of 5 years and then
reinvested for another term in favour of the claimants in a
Nationalized Bank. It is further provided that the accrued interest on
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
fixed deposits shall be paid to claimant Nos. 1, 2 & 3 in their
respective savings account maintained in the Bank. In given factual
scenario, this Court finds no ground to interfere with the same.
32.
Send down the record of the learned Tribunal with a copy of
this judgment and order forthwith. The parties have to bear their
own cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
MAC App. 285/2020, 332/2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review