The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
09. 10.2023, disposed of the said writ petition directing the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner in accordance with law. The relevant portion of the order of this Court dated 09.10.2023 passed in WP(C) No.615 of 2023 as referred by the learned senior counsel, is quoted herein-below: “…….. [6] After perusing the records, this court is of the opinion that ex-post approval of medical bills cannot be bar for considering the case of the petitioner. As per the documentary evidence placed before this court by way of an affidavit, it is evident that the petitioner belongs to Group B employee and Group B employees and their dependent family members may avail treatment in any enlisted referral hospital inside/outside of the states with approved by the State Government without referral of the Standing Medical Board subject to condition that ex-post facto approval shall be given in case of emergency/acute illness arising while the government servant is staying outside the state with station leave permission. This court has also decided earlier in several matters that no appropriate instructions is required indicating that the medical reimbursement bills need not be necessarily referred through the penal doctors. The medical bills can be released provided the same is not disputed. [7] Without any expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, the present case is disposed of d…
21. 11.2023 issued by the respondents allowing the instant writ petition with all the reliefs as sought for. [10] Heard the submissions made before this Court. Perused the record. [11] In all fairness, the learned Advocate General, Mr. S.S. Dey has submitted that the endeavor of the State is to attend the needy citizens on priority by relaxing any such conditions that would cause hindrance in providing medical assistance and expressed his displeasure against the manner the impugned order is passed by respondents rejecting the request of the petitioner. [12] With the above discussions, this Court is of the view that the Standing Medical Board absolutely failed to consider the fact that as the daughter of the petitioner was under treatment at Bengaluru, there was no scope to bring back his daughter to Agartala for obtaining reference from the Standing Medical Board. Doctors of the institution at Bengaluru suggested immediate treatment of the daughter of the petitioner. If the daughter of the petitioner was not taken to Narayan Hrudayalaya Hospital, Bengaluru and was not given timely treatment, her life might not have been saved. [13] This Court by order dated 09.10.2023 in earlier writ petition filed by the petitioner i.e. WP(C) 615 of 2023 had already opined that ex-post approval of medical bills cannot be bar for considering the case of the petitioner. As per the documentary eviden…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 01 of 2024
Goutam Datta
……..Petitioner.
Versus
State of Tripura and others
……..Respondent.
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. SS Dey, Advocate General.
Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
ORDER
23.04.2024
This writ petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India for issuance of writ in the nature of mandamus and/or any other direction
or directions and/or order or orders of like nature directing the respondents to
reimburse MR Bill for Rs.2,93,230/- to the petitioner along with 9% interest
thereon from the date of submission till the payment is made to the petitioner.
[2]
The case of the petitioner in brief is that he along with his family
members went for LTC trip from Agartala to Bengaluru (Karnataka). During the
tour when the petitioner along with his family members were in Bengaluru, the
daughter of the Petitioner, Ms. Sneegdha Datta suddenly became seriously ill and
on urgent basis, she was taken to Narayana Hrudayala Hospital, Bengaluru and
consulted with Dr. Suresh PV (Pediatric Cardiologist). Dr. Suresh PV. Pediatric
Cardiologist, diagnosed the daughter of the Petitioner on 19.05.2023 and
advised for admission. As per advice of Dr. Suresh PV. Pediatric Cardiologist, the
daughter of the petitioner was admitted on 24.05.2023 and underwent treatment
of Secundum ASD upto 26.05.2023.
[3]
It is contended in the petition that the petitioner was not in a
position to travel back to the State for getting the reference. After availing
treatment of his daughter, the petitioner returned to Agartala. Thereafter on
27.05.2023, the petitioner submitted MR bills for an amount of Rs 2,93,230/-.
The petitioner submitted representation to the Medical Superintendent, AGMC &
GBP Hospital to accord ex-post facto approval for treatment of his daughter
outside state during LTC tour. Thereafter, the Tripura Standing Medical Board.
AGMC & GBP Hospital, rejected the prayer of the petitioner for obtaining ex-post
facto approval.
[4]
According to the petitioner, the Standing Medical Board absolutely
failed to consider, that, as the daughter of the petitioner suddenly became ill in
Bengaluru and it was a life threatening illness, there was no scope to bring back
his daughter to Agartala for obtaining reference from the Standing Medical
Board. Narayana Hrudayalaya Hospital, Bengaluru is one of the renowned
Hospitals in the Country for specialized treatment for heart ailment and doctors
of that institution suggested immediate treatment of the daughter of the
petitioner. It is contended that if the daughter of the petitioner was not taken to
that hospital at Bengaluru and was not given timely treatment, her life could not
have been saved. It is contended that Medical Board failed to consider, that, it is
a fit case for post facto reference.
[5]
Thereafter, the petitioner filed writ petition before this Court vide
W.P (C) No. 615 of 2023. In the said writ petition the petitioner prayed for
necessary direction upon the respondents to reimburse the MR Bill for Rs
2,93,230/- to the petitioner alongwith 9% interest thereon. This Court vide order
dated, 09.10.2023, disposed of W.P(C) 615 of 2023 directing the respondents to
consider the case of the petitioner in accordance with law and thereafter, the
petitioner vide representation, dated, 12.10.2023, forwarded a copy of the said
order of this Court to the Medical Superintendent, AGMC & GBP Hospital, through
proper channel. Subsequently, the Principal/Chairman, Standing Medical Board,
AGMC & GBP Hospital vide letter, dated. 21.11.2023 informed the petitioner that
his application seeking ex-post facto referral for undertaking treatment of his
daughter at Narayana Hrudayala Hospital, Bengaluru, for ASD2 secundum atrial
septal defect has been examined and after careful examination of the documents
it is evident, that, patient was Asymptomatic on presentation and ASD was
incidentally detected and ASD closure was done on follow up admission and not
on emergency basis and hence it does not qualify for ex-post facto approval.
[6]
According to the petitioner, the Standing Medical Board without any
application of mind most casually in cavalier manner and unreasonably declined
to grant post facto referral in connection with the treatment of the daughter of
the petitioner at outside the State i.e. Narayana Hrudayala Hospital, Bengaluru.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has preferred this present writ petition seeking
following reliefs:
“(iii)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in
the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or direction/ directions of
like nature shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
reimburse MR Bill for Rs 2,93,230/- to the Petitioner alongwith 9% interest
thereon from the date of submission till the payment is made to the Petitioner.
(iv)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or direction/ directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby quashing the letter, dated, 21.11.2023, issued by the
Principal / Chairman, Standing Medical Board, AGMC & GBP Hospital.
[7]
(v)
Make the rules absolute.
(vi)
Call for records………”
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K.
Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. K. De, learned
Addl. G.A. for the State respondents. On request, Mr. SS Dey, learned Advocate
General after perusal of the records has assisted this Court.
[8]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner on earlier occasion filed writ petition before this Court
vide W.P (C) No. 615 of 2023 for similar relief. This Court vide order dated,
09.10.2023, disposed of the said writ petition directing the respondents to
consider the case of the petitioner in accordance with law. The relevant portion
of the order of this Court dated 09.10.2023 passed in WP(C) No.615 of 2023 as
referred by the learned senior counsel, is quoted herein-below:
“…….. [6]
After perusing the records, this court is of the opinion that
ex-post approval of medical bills cannot be bar for considering the case of
the petitioner. As per the documentary evidence placed before this court by
way of an affidavit, it is evident that the petitioner belongs to Group B
employee and Group B employees and their dependent family members
may avail treatment in any enlisted referral hospital inside/outside of the
states with approved by the State Government without referral of the
Standing Medical Board subject to condition that ex-post facto approval
shall be given in case of emergency/acute illness arising while the
government servant is staying outside the state with station leave
permission. This court has also decided earlier in several matters that no
appropriate
instructions
is
required
indicating
that
the
medical
reimbursement bills need not be necessarily referred through the penal
doctors. The medical bills can be released provided the same is not
disputed.
[7]
Without any expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, the
present case is disposed of directing the respondents to consider the case
of the petitioner in accordance with law within a period of two months from
the date of the receipt of the copy of this order……”
[9]
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel further contends that, the
Standing Medical Board without any application of mind by its communication
dated 21.11.2023, declined to grant post facto referral in connection with the
treatment of the daughter of the petitioner at outside the State. They failed to
consider, that, as the daughter of the petitioner suddenly became ill in Bengaluru
and it was a life threatening illness, there was no scope to bring back his
daughter to Agartala for obtaining reference from the Standing Medical Board.
He, therefore, urges this Court to set aside the impugned letter dated
21.11.2023 issued by the respondents allowing the instant writ petition with all
the reliefs as sought for.
[10]
Heard the submissions made before this Court. Perused the record.
[11]
In all fairness, the learned Advocate General, Mr. S.S. Dey has
submitted that the endeavor of the State is to attend the needy citizens on
priority by relaxing any such conditions that would cause hindrance in providing
medical assistance and expressed his displeasure against the manner the
impugned order is passed by respondents rejecting the request of the petitioner.
[12]
With the above discussions, this Court is of the view that the
Standing Medical Board absolutely failed to consider the fact that as the
daughter of the petitioner was under treatment at Bengaluru, there was no scope
to bring back his daughter to Agartala for obtaining reference from the Standing
Medical Board. Doctors of the institution at Bengaluru suggested immediate
treatment of the daughter of the petitioner. If the daughter of the petitioner was
not taken to Narayan Hrudayalaya Hospital, Bengaluru and was not given timely
treatment, her life might not have been saved.
[13]
This Court by order dated 09.10.2023 in earlier writ petition filed by
the petitioner i.e. WP(C) 615 of 2023 had already opined that ex-post approval
of medical bills cannot be bar for considering the case of the petitioner. As per
the documentary evidence placed before this Court by way of an affidavit in that
writ petition, it was evident that the petitioner belongs to Group B employee and
Group B employees and their dependent family members may avail treatment in
any enlisted referral hospital inside/outside of the State approved by the State
Government without referral of the Standing Medical Board subject to condition
that ex-post facto approval shall be given in case of emergency/acute illness
arising while the government servant is staying outside the State with station
leave permission. But, the respondents have rejected the claim of the petitioner
for medical reimbursement by its letter dated 21.11.2023 with the following
observation(s):
“….In reference to your application seeking ex-post facto referral for
undertaking treatment of your daughter, Miss Sneegdha Datta at Narayana
Hrudayalaya Hospital, Bengaluru for ASD2 secundum atrial septal defect &
After careful examination of the documents, it is evident that the patient
was Asymptomatic on presentation and that ASD was incidentally detected,
ASD closure was done on follow up admission & not on emergency basis.
Hence it does not quality for ex-post facto approval (memo-F.2(10-43A)DHS/ESTT/MR/2022, clause no.-b & d).
Therefore, your application for ex-post facto referral is regretted by
the Standing Medical Board, AGMC…..”
Hence, an adverse inference is drawn against the State respondents
due to non-compliance of the order of this Court dated 09.10.2023 passed in
W.P.(C) 615 of 2023.
[14]
In view of the above, this instant petition filed by the petitioner is
allowed with all the reliefs as sought for and the impugned letter dated
21.11.2023 is set aside. Respondents are directed to reimburse the medical bills
of the petitioner within a period of one month from the date of receipt of the
copy of this order.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall
stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi. G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2024.04.26 13:06:35
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review