Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:25451
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 27.11.2013 IN AS NO.370 OF 2009
OF
III
ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT
COURT,
KOLLAM
ARISING
OUT
OF
THE
JUDGMENT DATED 18.09.2009 IN OS NO.80 OF 1996 OF SUB COURT,
KOTTARAKKARA
APPELLANT/APPELLANT NO.2/PLAINTIFF NO.2:
GOURI AMMA (DIED)
X
LEELA,
D/O.GOURI AMMA,AGED 54 YEARS, LEELA BHAVAN,ELAMADU
MURI, ELAMADU VILLAGE, KOLLAM DISTRICT.
BY ADV KALEESWARAM RAJ
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
ALEYAMMA THOMAS,
W/O.THOMAS,AGED 52 YEARS, RESIDING AT KALLARA,MALICKAL
VEEDU, ANGADI MURI,RANNI VILLAGE,RANNI TALUK,KOLLAM
DISTRICT,REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER,
RAJU,S/O.NARAYANAN,ANEESH BHAVAN,PLACHERRY
MURI,VALAKODE VILLAGE-691 331.
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
BENNY K JOHNSON,
S/O JOHNSON,
AGED 49 YEARS,
RESIDING AT KADAPPARACHIL HOUSE,PLACHERY MURI,
VALACODE VILLAGE,REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY
HOLDER, JOHNSON ABRAHAM – 691 331
GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR(DIED)LRS IMPLEADED
AGED 65 YEARS
S/O PARAMU NAIR,RESIDING AT THADATHIL VIA HOUSE
ALANCHERRY MURI,EROOR VILLAGE-691 306
LEELA (REMOVED AND TRANSPOSED AS 2ND PLAINTIFF/
REMOVED AND TRANSPOSED AS 2ND PLAINTIFF/2ND APPELLANT
HEREIN.
RAJEEV,
AGED 56 YEARS,
S/O.NANOO,RESIDING AT PANAYIL VEEDU,ALANCHERY,
ALAYAMON VILLAGE-691 306.
ADDL.ROHINI GOPAL,
D/O.GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR,THIRVONAM, SHANTI
NAGAR,CHADAYAMANGALAM-691 534.
ADDL.REVATHI GOPAL,
D/O.GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR,LEELA BHAVAN,ELAMADU
MURI,ELAMADU VILLAGE,KOLLAM-691 533. (LEGAL HEIRS OF
DECEASED THIRD RESPONDENT ARE IMPLEADED AS
ADDL.RESPONDENTS 6 AND 7 AS PER ORDER DATED 28.02.2023
IN IA.2205/2017)
BY ADVS.
ASWIN.P.JOHN
MERCIAMMA MATHEW
THOMAS ABRAHAM
K.SASIKUMAR
S.ARAVIND
- R1 & R2
- R5
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
VARUN C.VIJAY
- R6
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
25.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
JUDGMENT
1.
The appellant is the second plaintiff in the suit.
She was
originally the 4th defendant in the suit. The suit was filed by one
Gouri Amma, who was the mother of the appellant. On her death,
her daughter/ 4th defendant
was transposed as the second
plaintiff. The suit was filed for declaration of title over plaint A and
B schedule property and to recover the same from the
defendants.
2.
The facts in substance are O.S. No. 126/1989 was filed by the
defendants 1 and 2 in the present suit on 17.07.1989 against the
3rd defendant in the present suit who is the husband of the
second plaintiff. They obtained an attachment over the plaint
schedule property. Thereafter, the 3 rd defendant in the present
suit executed in Ext.A1 sale deed in favour of the original plaintiff,
who was his mother-in-law. Later the suit was decreed and in
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
execution of the decree, the 5 th defendant purchased the plaint
schedule property.
He purchased the property as per Ext.B2
Sales Certificate. He obtained delivery as per Ext.B1 Delivery
Kaichit dated 05.07.1994. The present suit is filed on 28.03.1996,
claiming that the earlier suit was a collusive suit by the
defendants and there is fraud played on the plaintiff, the plaintiff
is entitled to get declaration of her title over the plaint schedule
property on the basis of Ext.A1 document.
3.
During the pendency of the suit, the original plaintiff died, and the
4th defendant who was transposed as the second plaintiff
prosecuted the suit.
4.
The Trial Court dismissed the suit finding that there was no fraud
committed by the defendants by filing the earlier suit, obtaining
the decree, executing the decree and obtaining delivery of the
plaint schedule property. The Trial Court specifically entered a
finding that fraud is played by the original plaintiff, the 3 rd
defendant and the additional plaintiff/4th defendant.
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
5.
The 2nd plaintiff filed appeal before the First Appellate Court and
the same was dismissed confirming the judgment and decree of
the Trial Court.
6. The present appeal is filed challenging the judgment and decree
passed by the Trial Court which is confirmed by the First
Appellate Court.
7.
I
heard
the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
Adv.Sri.Kaleeswaram Raj and the learned counsel for the 5 th
respondent Sri.K.Sasikumar and Sri.S.Aravind.
8.
The learned counsel for the appellant contended that there is
irregularity in affecting the attachment. The Trial Court specifically
found that there is irregularity in the attachment. In such a case,
the sale conducted pursuant to the attachment is also invalid. On
the strength of Ext. A1 document, the plaintiff got exclusive title
over the plaint schedule property. The learned counsel further
contended that the attachment will not create any charge over
the plaint schedule property. In order to substantiate the said
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
point learned counsel cited the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in S.Noordeen v. V.S. Thiru Venkita Reddiar [1996 (3)
SCC 289] that attachment before judgment does not create any
new right, title, or interest, but it disables the judgment-debtor to
create any encumbrances on the property. The learned counsel
also cited the decision of this Court in Jayan Kuttichakku v.
Common Man Chitties & Loans (P) Ltd [2006 SCC Online Ker
612] in which it is held that attachments, by themselves do not
amount
to
creation
of
charges
and
are
therefore
not
encumbrances. On the strength of these two decisions, the
learned counsel submitted that as on the date of Ext. A1 sale
deed there is no charge on the plaint schedule property and
hence Ext.A1 sale deed is not to be accepted as legal and valid
ignoring the attachment. The learned counsel specifically invited
my attention to the specific contentions raised by the plaintiff
which are extracted in Para No. 5 of the Trial Court judgment as
to how the attachment is invalid.
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
9.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the contesting
respondent contended that the earlier suit was not a collusive
affair, the present suit is a collusive affair. The learned counsel
pointed out that the fraud is alleged by the original plaintiff
against the defendants, which includes her daughter 4 th
defendant. On the death of the original plaintiff it is the very
same 4th defendant, who was transposed as the additional
plaintiff and conducted the suit. The evidence is clear that Ext.A1
document was executed subsequent to the attachment.
The
plaint schedule property is situated within the limits of Anchal Sub
Registry Office. In order to avoid attachment, Ext.A1 document
was executed at Sub Registry Office, Chadayamangalam. The
3rd defendant, who was the sole defendant in the earlier suit was
represented by his wife 4th defendant herein and hence the
plaintiff and the original 4 th defendant could not contend that they
are not aware of the attachment etc. Even otherwise, the 3 rd
defendant is the son-in-law of the original plaintiff, and from the
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
facts, it is very clear that they want to defeat the claim of the
defendants 1 and 2, who were the plaintiff in the original in O.S.
No.126/1989 and hence executed Ext.A1.
10.I have considered the rival contentions.
11. Admittedly,
Ext.A1 document was executed on 17.07.1989
subsequent to the attachment effected in O.S. No.126/1989.
Even though the learned counsel for the appellant contended
that there are several irregularities in the attachment, the learned
counsel could not point out that, any evidence to substantiate
those irregularities. The fact remains that the attachment is
properly communicated with the S.R.O. In O.S. No. 126/1989,
the third defendant herein, represented by his power of attorney
holder 4th defendant was the party. The suit was compromised.
In execution of the decree, the 5th defendant purchased the plaint
schedule property as per Ext.B2 Sale Certificate and obtained
Delivery as per Ext.B1 Delivery Kaichit.
No obstruction was
made by anybody in the delivery proceedings. Now the present
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
suit is filed seeking declaration of the title with respect to the
property which was obtained delivery as per Ext.B1. In such a
case, the present suit is not maintainable in view of the bar under
Order 21 Rule 101 Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). If the original
plaintiff had any objection against the delivery, she should have
made obstruction while effecting the delivery and should have
prayed for adjudicating her claim. After effecting delivery, a fresh
suit for challenging the delivery is not maintainable. That apart,
as rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the contesting
respondent, the original plaintiff filed the suit alleging fraud
against the defendants including the 4 th defendant. Thereafter, it
is the very same 4th defendant, the person who prosecuted the
suit. The evidence would clearly indicate that the present suit is
a fraudulent one, as rightly found by the Trial Court.
12. The second plaintiff was
a party to the earlier suit as the power
of attorney of the 3rd defendant who was the sole defendant in
the earlier suit. It is she, who compromised the earlier suit. The
2025:KER:25451
RSA NO. 861 OF 2014
facts would clearly disclose that the 3rd defendant transferred the
property to his mother in law, who is the mother of the second
plaintiff after the attachment only to defeat the defendants 1 and
2 who were the plaintiffs the earlier suit. Any sale made by the
defendant subsequent to attachment is subject to the attachment.
When the property is sold pursuant to the attachment, sale made
subsequent to the attachment has no legal validity.
13.The legal prepositions laid down by the aforesaid decisions are
correct, but the same is not applicable in the facts and
circumstances of the present case as the claim is not a charge
on the basis of attachment.
14.Accordingly, I do not find any ground or reason to interfere; no
substantial question of law arises in the matter. The Regular
Second Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
mus
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review