Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Rai Chattopadhyay
C.O. 4228 of 2025
Sri Gouranga Talukder
Vs.
Sri Tarak Nath Mondal and Anr.
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Gautam Das
For the opposite parties
: Mr. Taraknath Halder
Heard on
: 28.08.2026
Judgment on
: 28.08.2026
Uploaded on
: 31.08.2026
Rai Chattopadhyay, J. :1.
An order of the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Additional
Court of Sealdah, dated September 11, 2025 in Title Suit No. 530
of 2018 is under challenge in the instant revision.
2.
The revisionist/petitioner is the legal heir of the bharatiya of the
original thika tenant, in respect of a thika tenanted property, who
has filed the said title suit as plaintiff before the learned trial
Court. The plaintiff/petitioner’s challenge in the instant revision
is as regards the Court’s order, allowing the counter claim of the
defendant in the suit, who happens to be the original thika tenant
of the concerned landed property.
3.
Learned advocate appearing for the petitioner has submitted with
reference to sub-Section 3 of Section 8 and Section 21 of the West
Bengal Thika Tenancy (Acquisition and Regulation) Act, 2001, that
a counterclaim, which is an independent claim brought by a
defendant against a plaintiff within an existing suit, shall not be
maintainable in the instant case, at the instance of the thika
tenant.
4.
He has submitted that the defendant/opposite party is admittedly
a thika tenant in respect of a thika tenanted property. In such
circumstances by operation of sub-Section 3 of Section 8 of the
2001 Act any dispute regarding eviction of a bharatiya under the
thika tenant, shall be maintainable only before the Thika
Controller, the specified authority under the statute.
5.
Therefore, the order impugned of the learned trial Court dated
September 11, 2025 is challenged on the ground that the trial
Court has exceeded its jurisdiction and acted illegally in allowing
the counter claim of the opposite party in connection with the said
Title Suit No. 530 of 2018. To buttress his argument the learned
advocate for the petitioner has relied on the order dated
19.11.2018 passed by this Court in CO No.3381 of 2018
(Messers. Acme Estate Private Limited vs. Ramsakal Yadav &
Ors.) and the judgment passed in the case of Saghira Bano vs.
Mahmood Alam (CO 1973 of 2018) reported in 2019 SCC
OnLine Cal 9303.
6.
Learned advocate for the opposite party has raised strong
objection as to the contentions and prayer of the petitioner in the
instant revision.
According to him, the counter claim by the
opposite party/defendant is not for eviction of a bharatiya under
the thika tenant but for eviction of a trespasser over the thika
tenanted property.
With reference to the plaint as well as the
counter claim filed by the respective parties before the Court, the
learned advocate for the opposite party has developed his
argument that the plaintiff/revisionist, being the son and legal
heir of the original bharatiya of the defendant/thika tenant, since
deceased, was to be considered as a tenant under the opposite
party/defendant for a period of five years after death of his
predecessor, as per the statute. That the said prescribed period of
five years having been elapsed after the death of the said original
thika tenant i.e. the father of the plaintiff/petitioner, the status of
the plaintiff/petitioner with respect to the said thika tenanted
property is only that of a trespasser, in terms of Section 2(g) of the
West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997.
He further indicates
that in the matters relating to payment of rent by bharatiya and
their eviction by the thika tenant, the provisions of West Bengal
Premises Tenancy Act, 1997 are applicable in terms of Section 8(1)
of the Act of 2001.
Since the period of five years has already
elapsed from the date of death of the original tenant/bharatiya,
who has expired on 27th July, 2013, his legal heir should be
considered as a trespasser over the thika tenanted property, on
and from 27th July, 2018, in terms of Section 2(g) of the West
Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997.
7.
Learned advocate for the opposite party has specifically referred to
the averments made in the counter claim to show that in the
counter claim the opposite party/defendant’s the prayer is for
eviction of trespasser/plaintiff, from the suit property. To buttress
his argument the learned advocate for the defendant has relied on
a judgment in the case of Md. Jamil Akhter vs. Abdul Majid
reported in (2011) 1 CLJ CAL 308 and the order dated 13th May,
2026 passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in SAT 83 of
2026 (Husna Bano & Ors. vs. Mohammad Amiruzzaman and
Anr.).
8.
The issue therefore is as to whether the counter claim of the
opposite party, who admittedly is the thika tenant under the State,
with respect to a thika tenanted suit property, should be
considered maintainable before the learned Trial Court in the Title
Suit filed by the legal heir of the deceased bharatiya under the
said thika tenant.
9.
On careful reading of the provisions of law as discussed by the
respective learned advocates for the parties as mentioned above
and the judgments as mentioned above, this Court is of the
considered opinion that after expiry of five years period from date
of death of his father, that is the original bharatiya under the
defendant/thika tenant, the plaintiff/petitioner ceases to have any
right under the statute, as his legal heir, to continue with his
possession over the said thika tenanted property, over which his
deceased father has been possessing as a bharatiya. Thus, the
opposite party/defendant has tried to emphasize and justifiably
so, that after five years of date of death of the predecessor-ininterest who has been a bharatiya under the Act, the status of the
successor in respect with the said property comes to be that of a
trespasser. A trespasser has no legal relationship with either the
State or the Thika tenant. They do not qualify as a bharatiya or a
tenant under the statutory definitions of the Act.
10.
Section 8 of the West Bengal Thika Tenancy (Acquisition and
Regulation) Act, 2001 establishes the legal framework and
incidents of tenancies of bharatias. It regulates the relationship
between thika tenants (the structure owners) and bharatias (the
actual occupants/sub-tenants) and delineates the exclusive power
of the Thika Controller to manage their disputes. A Division Bench
of this Court in Seema Begum and Another versus Marrium
Bibi and Others (vide judgment dated February 14, 2011 in
CO.LRT No. 02 of 2010) has held the legal position to be that the
Controller is the exclusive authority to hear and dispose of any
cases concerning the eviction of a bharatiya.
11.
Md. Jamil Akhter versus Abdul Majir reported in 2010 SCC
OnLine Cal 1941 is an earlier foundational judgment of this
Court, establishing that a suit against an outsider/trespasser falls
squarely under ordinary civil law jurisdiction. In Asit Chatterjee
vs. Kanai Lal Das (S.A. No. 5 of 2022 dated March 21, 2022)
the Division Bench has explicitly laid down that a suit for the
eviction of a trespasser cannot be said to be barred under Section
8(3) or Section 21 of the 2001 Act. In Sri Manik Das versus
Promila Das & Ors reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Cal 8150 this
Court has reiterated that a suit for the eviction of a trespasser,
even if it involves a thika tenanted property, remains fully
maintainable before a Civil Court.
12.
It has already been discussed above, that in accordance with the
law, the petitioner, after five years of date of death of his father,
who has been the original bharatia under the thika tenant, no
longer remains to be a bharatiya, as a legal hair of his deceased
father. On the other hand, the counter claim filed by the opposite
party/defendant before the learned trial Court appears to be for
eviction of a trespasser and not a bharatiya under the thika
tenant. There is no embargo under the 2001 Act, for filing an
action in the civil Court for eviction of a trespasser, over a thika
tenanted property. In this regard the civil Court’s jurisdiction has
not been ousted by operation of the law. The restrictions under
Section 8(3) and Section 21 of 2001 Act strictly confine themselves
to regulating the disputes between a thika tenant and a bharatia,
or determining thika status. Because a trespasser lacks any status
under the Act, the Thika Controller does not possess the inherent
machinery or statutory power to try an action for pure tortious
trespass or pass a decree for recovery of possession against them.
13.
Hence, this Court does not find any jurisdictional error, illegality
or manifest irregularity in the impugned order of the trial Court
dated September 11, 2025 in Title Suit No. 530 of 2018. Therefore,
there is no reason for interference into the same, as prayed for by
the petitioner.
14.
Considering all as above, the present revision is found meritless
and the same is dismissed.
15.
Learned trial Court shall proceed with the suit as well as the
counter claim as expeditiously as possible, however, without being
influenced by any of the observations of this Court as made in this
order and the same has been done for the purpose of adjudication
of the issues involved in the present revision only.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review